198 6Apj. . .300. .37 9T the Astrophysical Journal, 300
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
9T .37 The Astrophysical Journal, 300:379-395,1986 January 1 © 1986. The American Astronomical Society. All rights reserved. Printed in U.S.A. .300. 6ApJ. 198 SPECTROSCOPIC STUDIES OF WOLF-RAYET STARS. III. THE WC SUBCLASS Ana V. Torres and Peter S. Conti1,2 Joint Institute for Laboratory Astrophysics, University of Colorado and National Bureau of Standards AND Philip Massey2 Kitt Peak National Observatory, National Optical Astronomy Observatories Received 1985 AprilS; accepted 1985 June 28 ABSTRACT We present spectrophotometric data for the major optical emission lines of 64 Galactic and 18 Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) WC stars. Using line ratios of O v A5590, C m 25696, and C iv 25806 we quantify the subtype classification. A few Galactic stars are reclassified, and nearly all the LMC WC stars are found to be of type WC4. Thus there is even a greater discrepancy in the distribution of WC subtypes between the LMC and the Galaxy than previously assumed, since WC4 types in the Galaxy are rare. New measures of the line widths of C in 24650 are found to correlate nicely with the (revised) WC subtypes, although a few stars have lines too wide for their line ratios. Two of the most discrepant stars, WR 125 and WR 140, also show nonthermal radio emission and are strong X-ray sources. Terminal wind velocities are estimated from an excitation—line width relation. The terminal velocities range from 1000 km s_1 for the latest subtypes to 5000 km s "1 for the earliest types. Subject headings: galaxies: Magellanic Clouds — stars: stellar statistics— stars: winds — stars: Wolf-Rayet I. INTRODUCTION Willis 1983). Torres and Conti (1984) have analyzed the optical Wolf-Rayet (W-R) stars are the descendants of massive spectra of 12 WC9 stars and found them to be very similar to (M > 30 Mq) O-type stars. They are all (mostly?) in a He core one another in line strengths. In this paper we attempt to give a burning phase, and their spectra are characterized by strong complete overview of the most important spectroscopic fea- emission lines superposed on a hot continuous spectrum. Most tures of WC stars in the optical region. show P Cygni profiles in some lines, indicating the presence of The WC sublcasses are defined mainly by the relative strong stellar winds. W-R stars are subdivided into three strengths of C n, C m, C iv, and O v. For the majority of the groups depending on their spectral appearance. When the pro- WC stars these ratios also correlate well with the line widths, ducts of CNO burning are seen in their spectrum allowing a secondary classification criterion (full width half (predominantly helium and nitrogen), the stars belong to the maximum [FWHM] of 4650 Â). Subtypes range from WC4 to nitrogen class (WN), and when the products of the He core WC10, corresponding both to higher and lower ionization burning phase are evident in their spectrum (strong helium, stages and to larger and smaller Doppler velocities in their carbon, and oxygen lines), they belong to the carbon class winds. (WC). Recently, the oxygen class (WO) has been introduced in Table 1 is taken from the Catalog, and it shows the classi- order to distinguish W-R stars whose spectra show the same fication criteria for WC subtypes. Since the publication of the products as the WC but with the oxygen lines enhanced Catalog, a few stars have been reclassified by other authors, (Barlow and Hummer 1982). and the classification has been extended to WC10 to include Each of these three W-R classes is further subdivided into an one star of an even lower ionization state (Massey and Conti ionization/excitation sequence. This classification system has 1983a). This classification had been applied to the central stars been based on the work done by Smith (1968) and adapted by of planetary nebulae (e.g., Cowley and Hiltner 1969) but not to van der Hucht et al (1981, hereafter the Catalog) to classify all Population I W-R stars. For reasons of consistency with spec- the known Galactic W-R stars. WN subclasses range from tral type classification (i.e., a temperature sequence), subtypes WN2 (higher ionizations) to WN9 (lower ionizations). A com- WC7 to WC10 are called “late WC stars” (WCL), and all plete analysis of the optical line strengths of the WN stars is others are “early WC stars” (WCE); however, it is uncertain given by Conti, Leep, and Perry (1983, hereafter Paper I). No whether this wind ionization sequence correlates with stellar such analysis exists for the WC sublcass; only a few individual effective temperatures. stars have been carefully studied (e.g., Underhill 1959; Smith Hydrogen and helium absorption lines are present in several and Aller 1971 ; Vreux, Dennefeld, and Andrillat 1983), or a few stars. A few of these have been studied for radial velocity varia- lines in various stars have been measured (e.g., Smith and tions, and their binary orbital parameters are well known (see, for example, Hidayat, Admiranto, and van der Hucht 1984, and references therein). The rest of them are just classified as 1 Visiting Astronomer, Kitt Peak National Observatory, NOAO, which is WC + abs to indicate the presence of the absorption lines, operated by AURA, Inc., under contract with the National Science Founda- which may be from a distant companion (Conti et al 1984) or a tion. 2 Visiting Astronomer, Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory, NOAO, nearby companion (Lamontagne, Moffat, and Seggewiss 1984) which is operated by AURA, Inc., under contract with the National Science or may be intrinsic to the star (Fitzpatrick 1982; see also Foundation. Massey, Conti, and Niemela 1981). Throughout this paper, we © American Astronomical Society • Provided by the NASA Astrophysics Data System 9T .37 380 TORRES, CONTI, AND MASSEY .300. TABLE 1 Catalog Classification of W-R Spectra Based on the Smith (1968) System 6ApJ. Carbon Ions Carbon, Oxygen Ions WC Type ¿5696 C m/¿5805 C iv ¿5696 C iii/¿5592 O v Other Criteria 198 WC9 C in > C iv O v weak or absent C n present WC8.5 C in > C iv O v weak or absent C n not present WC8 C in » C iv O v weak or absent WC7 C ni < C iv C ni > O v WC6 C in C iv C in > O v WC5 C in « C iv C in < O v WC4 C iv strong, C m weak or absent O v moderate do not differentiate between the known binaries and the bration, and all plates were developed for 5 minutes in D-19. “ + abs ” stars ; we call all of them “ + abs.” Spectra of the brightest Catalog stars and blue spectra of the Breysacher (1981) has compiled a catalog of all known W-R faintest and most heavily reddened stars could not be obtained. stars in the EMC. Of the 100 W-R stars in Breysacher’s All the northern hemisphere stars were also observed by one catalog, only 18 are classified as WC, of which nearly all are of us (P. M.) at Kitt Peak National Observatory with the called WC5. As we show in § III, these need to be reclassified to intensified Reticon scanner (1RS) on the No. 1 0.9 m telescope. even earlier subtypes for consistency with the line ratios of The 1RS is an analog spectrophotometer. Details of these Galactic WC stars. The W-R population in the Galaxy is very observations are given by Massey (1984), and a complete different from that in the EMC. The Catalog has a total of 159 description of the instrument is given by Barnes (1982). Total stars, and the WN/WC ratio is ~ 1.0; in the EMC, this ratio is spectral coverage, from several observations, was typically 4.5, according to the data of Breysacher. It had been suggested from 3200 to 7300 Â with a three-pixel resolution of ~ 4.5-6 Â. that the difference between the Galactic and the EMC stars The southern hemisphere W-R stars were observed by two of could be due to differences in metallicities in the two galaxies us (P. M. and P. S. C.) with the SIT Vidicon detector on the (Smith 1973; Vanbeveren and Conti 1980), but Massey and Cassegrain spectrograph of the CTIO 1.5 m telescope on runs Conti’s (1983h) data on M33 and the study by Armandroff and from 1981 November to 1985 February. The slit was usually Massey (1985) of several other galaxies with various metal- opened to 6"-10" to allow absolute fluxes to be measured; with licities do not support this conclusion. Rather, the difference the gratings used, this resulted in resolution of typically 10 Â. may be due to differences in the initial mass function, or to a Owing to the limited dynamic range of the SIT Vidicon detec- combination (Massey 1985). tor, each observation of a star consisted of two exposures : one As explained in the Catalog, the assignment of WC subtypes to get good continuum fluxes (with the strongest lines usually has been based on visual inspections of photographic plates. saturated), and another one to get unsaturated lines. Total One of the aims of this study is to quantify these visual esti- wavelength coverage was 3400-7300 Â, with the data obtained mates. In § III we present the measured ratios of equivalent with different gratings. widths and the FWHM of the 4650 Â line for Galactic and The photographic spectrograms and spot sensitometer EMC stars, and on this basis we propose the reclassification of exposures were traced either on a Boiler and Chivens micro- some stars.