THE AUSTRALIAN MONDAY SEPTEMBER 22 2008 36 MEDIA www.theaustralian.com.au Start-up Eleven wants to fill retail space No worries as Lara Sinclair THREE senior staffers from retail agency Ideaworks set up shop on their own last week, forming a new full-service retail business called Eleven Communications. NRMA sports The trio — former executive creative director Jonathan McCauley, former operations director John McLachlan and former head of art Ryan Fallow- field — aim to fill a gap in the market between high-end brand new tagline agencies and small, tactical mar- keting agencies. Simon Canning that after two so it’s important that the brand is ‘‘We reckon there’s a pretty Branding years, if people warm and approachable. ‘‘Our big gap between the big brand had not made a brief was to pull away from the agencies that can come up with a IAG’S insurance brand, NRMA claim on their pack and defy category conven- great brand idea (and agencies Insurance, has embarked on a insurance they tion. It is very un-NRMA.’’ that can) implement day-to-day massive repositioning, dropping developed a level Brand consultancy Brand brand promotional work,’’ Mr its familiar ‘HELP’ advertising of resentment in Council began work on the McCauley said. tagline after more than 20 years. paying pre- NRMA brand two years ago, ‘‘It gets funnelled off into a The brand has been running a Argent miums, feeling while STW-owned ad agency factory (staffed) by juniors. series of teaser telling people that they had not Human has created the ads for ‘‘Building brands for retailers to ‘‘uncomplicate’’ their lives got their money’s worth. the campaign. is what we specialise in because before it unveiled the new ‘Un- The new position is a bid to Human managing director that’s what we did at Ideaworks, worry’ tagline last night. invest value in paying insurance Kate Walker admitted devising a but we reckon we can do it NRMA Insurance group mar- by portraying the freedom from new campaign to replace ‘HELP’ smarter.’’ keting manager Lynette Argent worry that comes with being was a challenge. The last high-profile former told Media the move was an insured. ‘‘‘HELP’ has been such a Ideaworks staffer to leave the attempt to escape the increasing ‘‘We wanted a statement that strong idea for them and it was commoditisation of the insurance agency, co-founder Stephen Kul- reminded consumers what they going to take something big to mar, attacked listed global adver- market. get, not what it costs,’’ she said. top that,’’ Ms Walker said. IAG is understood to have tising group WPP’s approach to Ms Argent said the decision to ‘‘But we think ‘Unworry’ is a business in an aggressive parting been working on the rebranding step away from the two-decade very worthy successor — it will for almost two years. attack, saying it forced agencies old ‘HELP’ positioning — which have the legs to take the brand to put profits ahead of relation- ‘‘For some time now, the had originally come from the where it needs to go.’’ category has been stuck in a rut ships. NRMA’s road service unit — had Media agency Carat has nego- and we realised that we needed to Mr McCauley said the Eleven not been taken lightly. tiated a massive media buy for trio did not share the same views. change the conversation, to stop Breaking free: Eleven Communications’ Jonathan McCauley, left, Ryan Fallowfield and John McLachlan Picture: Bob Finlayson talking about what insurance However, she said that ‘HELP’ the brand extending from TV to ‘‘We wish Ideaworks well and had become part of the DNA of outdoor, print and radio. we think there’s plenty of space costs and start talking about what showing the agency will ‘‘go one lot of experience in creating retail said. Mr McCauley said the retail retail overseas and we’re starting the brand and would be forever The campaign will also feature for both of us to exist,’’ Mr it buys every day,’’ Ms Argent ’’ ’’ ’’ associated with it even though it on takeaway coffee cups. McCauley said. louder than 10 . environments. sector had shifted from a Wal- to see a bit of it here. said. Mr McCauley said there were A point of difference from Mart style focus on discounting Mr Fallowfield said Eleven ‘‘At the end of the day, what was no longer a part of the Ms Argent said NRMA Insur- ‘‘There are a lot of medium- marketing. ance had made a long-term sized businesses that big agencies no official clients, but the agency other start-ups will be Mr to more of a focus on creativity wanted to take an ‘‘innovative’’ our customers buy is the freedom was already working on a number McLachlan’s experience running from the medium-sized chains. approach to retail creativity. to get on with living their lives ‘‘NRMA will always have commitment to the new brand can’t tackle properly. A key part of collaborative projects with the operational side of retail ‘‘If you look at it on a global ‘‘ without having to worry about ‘HELP’ as part of its DNA,’’ she positioning. of it is staying small. Most creative people in this other agencies. the what-ifs.’’ said. ‘‘We are looking at ‘Unworry’ ‘‘We want to cut out a lot of accounts, which typically require level, five years ago, the big push country don’t understand retail Ms Argent said the insurance ‘‘If we tried to rub it out of the to be our brand position for years the (layering) big agencies do day The trio has worked on big a high volume of fast-turnaround was to engineer costs out of the and don’t really want to,’’ Mr category had ‘‘lost its lustre’’. DNA we couldn’t. ‘HELP’ is to come,’’ she said. in and day out. retail brands including Westfield, print, catalogue and point-of-sale business,’’ Mr McCauley said. Fallowfield said. ‘‘We have become very undif- driven from the motoring and The ads will use lines such as ‘‘We want to employ creative BigW, Mitre 10, Supercheap Auto work. ‘‘People are expecting more ‘‘But when you look around ferentiated and so we have been service perspective and is reac- ‘Unworry’, ‘Unbamboozle’ and people who can deal directly with and its boating, camping and ‘‘It’s always been the holy grail than just low cost. They want the world, people like Ikea, Tar- on quite a journey,’’ she said. tive. So lets focus on what they ‘Undo what you did’. clients and solve problems fishing spin-off BCF. for retail — high-end creative smart value. They don’t want to get and Selfridges are producing ‘‘Our market has become very (customers) get everyday. What The initial ad campaign is directly.’’ ‘‘We’ve had a lot of experience thinking combined with a ruth- feel like they’re shopping at a some of the most innovative work commodified and it is very ‘doom we will be is more human and slated to run for the next month The name Eleven Communica- of designing brand identities,’’ lessly efficient delivery mecha- discounter any more. in the business. That’s the kind of and gloom’.’’ less corporate. We know people before more elements and prod- tions is a reference to movie spoof Mr McCauley said. nism. And that’s what we’ve ‘‘I think there has been a work we are interested in doing in She said research had shown can be cynical about big business uct ads are introduced. This Is Spinal Tap aimed at ‘‘The other thing we have is a constructed,’’ Mr McLachlan creative renaissance going on in this market.’’ Reclusive media moguls are the nation’s quiet achievers From Page 33 seller and a web design and maybe one or two of them will Colourful tycoons a law unto themselves marketing division. It also oper- want to take over.’’ His reach extends into Queens- ates a commercial printing opera- land through stations in Too- From Page 33 Queensland. Bill owned a stack year. ‘‘We must have dinner tion. GEOFF HANDBURY is happy to woomba and Gympie. of radio stations and was Harold!’’ The McPhersons have been take a back seat at his ACE Radio Caralis uses the once fabled I commented that I’d always influential in Channel Ten in ‘‘Sure Bruce, Tre Scalini (in part of the Goulburn Valley in Broadcasters network of Victor- 2SM in Sydney, which he bought wanted to use it to build a home. Queensland. Sydney), an early dinner, I’ll Victoria since 1888, but in the ian stations these days. His farmer in 2000 for $8.2 million, to ‘‘No problem,’’ said Alan I flew from Melbourne to come from Melbourne.’’ 1960s sold 25 per cent of their son-in-law, Rowly Patterson, is generate programming for his Scott, ‘‘I own the quarry.’’ Longreach in the big plane, only ‘‘Good, I’ll travel up from company to to fund new the group’s chairman and a ‘‘super network’’ stations, ignor- The next issue was how to get to find two smaller aircraft Wollongong,’’ said Bruce. presses. After Fairfax took over grand-daughter sits on the board ing the lucrative Sydney radio the stone from Mt Gambier to waiting to take us to the property At 7.30pm still no Bruce and The Age, its interest grew to 47 as a non-executive director. He is market. It is this kind of counter- Melbourne. ‘‘No problem,’’ he — one for people, one for bags! no phone call. I’d been stood up. per cent. satisfied a family succession is on intuitive decision-making action In 1998, the brothers saw an said, ‘‘I own the trucking But the real top banana has Only a private family can do the cards. that draws fire from many critics. opportunity to reclaim their heri- ’’ that! Handbury acquired the 50 per Caralis shrugs it off. company. got to be Bruce Gordon, now tage, and took 100 per cent Gotcha!: Bill Caralis, black coat, in a 1981 rugby league photograph My visit to Sir William Allen approaching 80 and in fine Harold Mitchell is executive cent of ACE that he didn’t own in ‘‘That’s just Bill,’’ an associate ownership. Ross, 57, is executive 1995 when it operated four sta- who would not be named says. was at his home outside health. We have regular meals chairman of the Mitchell chairman, Chris, 54, is CEO and Longreach in central together, or used to until late last Communications Group tions in Western Victoria. Now it ‘‘He has a very private nature; Paul, 59, runs the Melbourne has 13 stations, mostly AM-FM Rare glimpse of silent there’s nothing sinister about it commercial printing operation. combos, in Horsham, Hamilton, . . . it’s just his way. He doesn’t Dugald, 37, work. Grant looks ‘‘I should have taken a holi- says: ‘‘I was really cross at the The group is valued at around $80 Colac, Warrnambool, Swan Hill, seek publicity, but he’s a very after the Sydney operations while day,’’ Cameron tells Media. ‘‘It way analysts were never happy million. Gippsland and Albury in southern king of the airwaves shrewd operator and a tough Dugald tends the Melbourne end was during television aggregation with good, organic growth. They ‘‘We’ve had lots of offers and NSW. As well, the company ’’ Mark Day He established a fruit and businessman. and Allison, an accountant, is and the future was uncertain. I always wanted you to be buying opportunities to consider float- publishes the Weekly Advertiser ing,’’ Ross says. Radio vegetable store in Sydney’s Queen He is said to believe his net- chief financial officer. was heavily involved in industry something; they wanted to write it newspaper in Horsham and Ara- work is worth about $200 million, ‘‘But we love the business and Victoria Building, where Bill affairs and had lost the plot in up in a sexy way. I saw it as a rat. It is valued at more than $50 although others say this is too Grant Broadcasting, whose as- the challenges of building multi- SCOOP! Hold the presses! worked long hours with his father, running the business. There was caution about life in a public million. high. But in a sense, it is immate- sets today are estimated to be media platforms. We believe we This is a photograph of Bill driving a horse and cart along ’ rial: the word from the Caralis worth about $125 million, has too much politics, so when I got a company. It s too sophisticated have a good feel for what country Handbury is the brother-in-law Caralis, the Super Network radio George Street selling produce to camp is that he has no interest in always been a family affair. Ja- good offer, I took it. I immediately for me. I’m a plain-vanilla kind of people want, and being private we of Rupert Murdoch, chairman of owner who refuses to talk to the help support the family. either selling or listing his net- net’s father, Walter T. Grant, regretted it.’’ person. can set our own goals and operate The Australian’s owner, News media, or allow his picture to be After his father died when Bill work. bought 2DU Dubbo in 1942 and, It was not long before she was ‘‘To me, radio ownership is all at a scale that suits us and our Corporation. He was married to taken for publication. was 16, he worked at the Masonic Club to learn the liquor trade. with a background as an electri- rebuilding the business, buying about providing the best product region.’’ Rupert’s sister, Helen, who died All right, it might be 27 years cian, immediately sought to in- the Muswellbrook station in the and what you’re doing in your in 2004. Their daughter, Judy, is old, but it’s Bill in his days as It was the only time he worked JANET CAMERON has to stop The last time the brothers for a boss. and count when she’s asked how crease its power. It took 10 years Upper Hunter, before adding sta- communities. For us, floating is considered selling into a float was married to Patterson, who over- president of the now-defunct of battling bureaucracy before he tions (in no particular order) in not on the agenda — we’re sees a 3000ha farm near Lake Newtown Jets Rugby Leagues He established the Marrickville many stations her company, when Fairfax paid $155 million for Cellars drive-in liquor story, and Grant Broadcasters, owns. It’s won. Bega, Wollongong, Ballarat, comfortable with our size and I’m the Albury Border Mail. Bolac in central Victoria. club. He posed with the Jets before ‘‘It’s still a bit like that,’’ Janet Bendigo, Geelong, Mildura, Dar- not sure we could grow it and still ‘‘I spend a couple of days a they narrowly lost the 1981 grand dabbled in real estate develop- kind of complicated when you ‘‘We thought that was an ment. Later he owned the huge have to sort out the fully owned says. ‘‘It can be a real battle to get win and Murray Bridge. Earlier keep in touch with the people in insane price, but we decided we week on the radio business,’’ says final to Parramatta. change.’’ this year, in the wake of forced Patterson. ‘‘It’s a great way to Camperdown Cellars and pursued and part owned. each of our stations.’’ were having too much fun,’’ Ross He is flanked by legendary his great love of league through Finally: ‘‘I think it’s 32 — Walter Grant died in 1961 and divestments by the Macquarie says. ‘‘If we walked away with a keep in touch with the commun- players Tommy Raudonikis (left) his presidency of the Jets. that’s 27 of ours, and five in a his wife Christina took over the Media Group, she picked up nine ROSS McPHERSON and his bucket of money we would simply ities around Victoria.’’ and Phil Gould (right.) In 1982, he retired to the Gold 50-50 partnership with Kevin business. In 1972 Janet became Tasmanian stations and one brothers Chris and Paul are the become investment managers. Asked to describe the attrac- It’s a pity that Caralis won’t Coast. But the lure of the deal led Blyton, including 6IX in Perth.’’ managing director and has re- (from ) in Ipswich. definition of mini multi-media What sort of life is that?’’ tions of being privately held, he talk, because he has a fascinating him to his first radio purchase — And then there’s the Radio Sales mained in the position since. Janet Cameron has had experi- moguls. Their McPherson Media Ross McPherson says he and says: ‘‘We can run our own race tale to tell. His father George 2RG Griffith — in the early 80s, Network, a sales organisation that By 1986, GB owned four sta- ence with listed companies. She Group company, publisher of the his brothers have eight children at our own pace. We don’t need came from Sparta in Greece in followed by stations in Parkes, sells air time on the 68 stations tions in Parkes, Dubbo, Mudgee was a foundation director of the Shepparton News and a dozen between them, and most have shareholders, and we have a 1910 and worked in the Sydney Dubbo and Mudgee in 1985. Since she and Bill Caralis collectively and Nowra. Then, in what she Gold Coast-based Sea FM, which other small regional newspapers, worked in the company at some quality approach to our struc- markets. In 1930, he returned to then it has been a non-stop own. described as ‘‘the worst decision I she describes as: ‘‘Not a happy has a finger in all the major new stage. tures, our values, our staff and the Greece, but after the end of the growth curve. He and wife Pam That’s where her three chil- ever made’’, she sold three sta- experience.’’ She is no longer media growth areas — an internet ‘‘They’ll need to make their impact we have on the commun- war in 1954 migrated with his wife remain the sole owners of 36 dren, Grant, 45, Allison, 42, and tions, keeping only Nowra. connected with those stations, but service provider, a telephony re- way on merit,’’ he says, ‘‘but ities we service.’’ and family to Sydney. stations of 35 translators.

THE TOP 25 TV PROGRAMS MEDIA MONITOR RANK/PROGRAM STN NETW SYD MEL BRI ADE PER RANK/PROGRAM STN NETW SYD MEL BRI ADE PER Most mentioned items: press, radio, TV and internet, September 13-19 THE NUMBERS 1 Packed to the Rafters Seven 1,895,000 615,000 589,000 328,000 153,000 210,000 14 Bones Seven 1,298,000 333,000 404,000 228,000 155,000 178,000 AUDIENCE SHARE 2 City Homicide Seven 1,857,000 511,000 617,000 314,000 202,000 213,000 15 Crash Investigation Unit Seven 1,287,000 393,000 331,000 270,000 134,000 159,000 22,386 Malcolm Turnbull All TV, city metro (6am – midnight) Week 38: September 14 – 20 3 Find my Family Seven 1,815,000 482,000 558,000 401,000 156,000 218,000 16 Battlefronts Nine 1,286,000 385,000 372,000 265,000 148,000 117,000 40 4 Border Security Seven 1,814,000 546,000 507,000 356,000 176,000 229,000 17 Seven News – Saturday Seven 1,284,000 329,000 376,000 283,000 135,000 161,000 18,650 AFL Finals 22.6% 5 Rspca Animal Rescue Seven 1,813,000 501,000 522,000 389,000 168,000 233,000 18 NCIS Ten 1,280,000 346,000 367,000 229,000 165,000 173,000

Pay 6 The Force Seven 1,733,000 520,000 499,000 313,000 169,000 232,000 19 Criminal Minds Seven 1,258,000 321,000 377,000 250,000 160,000 150,000 18,022 NFL Finals 30 TV 20.8% 7 60 Minutes Nine 1,686,000 495,000 483,000 320,000 188,000 199,000 20 Spicks & Specks ABC1 1,252,000 413,000 354,000 228,000 109,000 148,000 20.0% 20 8 National – Sunday Nine 1,637,000 576,000 422,000 336,000 177,000 126,000 21 Home and Away Seven 1,247,000 367,000 352,000 250,000 124,000 154,000 12,166 Lehman Bothers 16.5% 9 Seven News – Sunday Seven 1,490,000 359,000 462,000 283,000 161,000 225,000 22 Midsomer Murders ABC1 1,233,000 394,000 324,000 209,000 140,000 166,000 0 4000 8000 12,000 16,000 20,000 Seven News – Monday-Friday Seven 1,485,000 388,000 391,000 314,000 171,000 222,000 Better Homes and Gardens Seven 1,232,000 345,000 431,000 253,000 96,000 106,000 10 14.6% 10 23 After calling a snap leadership vote at the 11 Medical Emergency Seven 1,426,000 409,000 349,000 338,000 142,000 189,000 24 Australian Idol Ten 1,224,000 380,000 348,000 246,000 139,000 111,000 beginning of the week it was Brendan 3.1% 0 12 Two and a Half Men – Wed Nine 1,376,000 394,000 432,000 271,000 132,000 147,000 25 All Saints Seven 1,212,000 431,000 356,000 164,000 129,000 132,000 Nelson who ended up with a nasty surprise when Malcolm Turnbull defeated Weeks 1–38 Source: OzTAM 13 Today Tonight Seven 1,325,000 341,000 353,000 261,000 167,000 204,000 him narrowly to become the new federal Opposition Leader. The AFL Finals and NRL Finals coverage NETWORK SHARE THE TOP 10 MOVIES Scene from THE TOP 10 PHOTOGRAPHY WEBSITES was neck and neck this week at second and METROPOLITAN ABC SEVEN NINE TEN SBS Box-office takings last weekend (Thur-Mon) In Bruges Week ending September 13, 2008 third on the Media Monitors Index, with four SYDNEY 20.10% 27.30% 28.10% 18.90% 5.60% TITLE WEEKS IN $$$ SCREENS $$$ RANK NAME DOMAIN MARKET SHARE Victorian teams to battle it out for the AFL MELBOURNE 16.60% 29.20% 26.70% 22.70% 4.80% RELEASE TO DATE flag for the first time in more than a decade. 1 Photobucket www.photobucket.com 23.00% The New Zealand Warriors were the surprise BRISBANE 17.50% 28.40% 30.70% 18.30% 5.10% 1 The Mummy 1 3,509,055 362 3,524,115 2 Flickr www.flickr.com 20.09% packet of the NRL finals. ADELAIDE 17.60% 28.90% 25.70% 22.40% 5.40% 2 Tropic Thunder 4 757,330 261 8,823,045 3 ImageShack www.imageshack.us 4.65% One of America and the world's largest PERTH 21.00% 31.50% 21.90% 20.50% 5.20% 3 In Bruges 2 472,679 113 1,483,161 merchant banks went to the wall this week 4 Picasa Web Albums picasaweb.google.com 4.52% after the US Government refused to bail out 4 Make it Happen 2 463,740 166 1,345,147 REGIONAL ABC PRIME/7QLD WIN/NBN TEN/S.CROSS SBS 5 Digital Photography Review www.dpreview.com 1.94% the ailing financial giant, while Merrill Lynch Total* 18.20% 28.10% 28.30% 19.20% 6.20% 5 Hellboy II 3 459,611 224 4,069,338 was sold to Bank of America. 6 ImageVenue.com www.imagevenue.com 1.94% The launch of the long awaited and much Queensland 18.80% 30.80% 25.70% 18.70% 6.00% 6 The Dark Knight 9 424,725 213 44,619,506 7 Canon Australia www.canon.com.au 1.75% anticipated Costello Memoirs was largely Northern NSW 15.50% 24.80% 32.70% 20.30% 6.80% 7 Taken 5 406,156 182 6,333,120 8 Slide.com www.slide.com 1.54% overshadowed by the Liberal leadership Southern NSW 21.10% 25.90% 29.10% 17.50% 6.40% 8 Mamma Mia! 10 370,099 246 30,069,047 vote, although there was extensive discus- 9 PBASE www.pbase.com 1.44% Victoria 17.90% 31.20% 24.90% 20.30% 5.70% 9 Harold & Kumar 2 363,376 131 1,165,381 sion about Costello's comments in the 10 Panoramio www.panoramio.com 1.30% book about Janette Howard's influence. Tasmania 32.10% – 23.00% 37.5% 7.40% 10 Baby Mama 4 173,108 161 2,368,505 * Free-to-air TV Source: OzTAM, Regional TAM Source: Motion Picture Distributors Association of Australia Source: Hitwise Data and analysis provided by Media Monitors Australia