DOCSLIB.ORG

CEDAW & Malaysia. Malaysian

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
CEDAW & Malaysia. Malaysian Women’s Aid Organisation (WAO) PO Box 493, Jalan Sultan 46760 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Malaysia Tel: +603 7957 0636 / 7957 5636 Fax: +603 7956 3237 Email: [email protected] Website: www.wao.org.my Facebook: www.facebook.com/womens.aid.org Copyright © 2012 Women’s Aid Organisation (WAO) ISBN: 978-983-40325-5-5 All rights reserVed. No part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced or utilised in any form or by any means without permission in writing from the publisher. CoVer, Layout and Design: Michael Voon <[email protected]> Printer: TM Graphic Sdn. Bhd. Printing of this report is supported by the High Commission of Canada, Kuala Lumpur. CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 1 CONTRIBUTING ORGANISATIONS 5 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 9 LIST OF CRITICAL ISSUES 15 STATUS REPORT ON THE MALAYSIAN GOVERNMENT’S OBLIGATIONS 25 DECLARED IN THE INTERNATIONAL ARENA Status report on the implementation of the CEDAW Committee’s recommendations 25 from 2006 Statements of intent made during the Malaysian government’s appearance 44 before the CEDAW Committee in 2006 Statements of intent made during the Malaysian government’s examination at the 47 Universal Periodic Review in 2009 relating to women ARTICLES 1 – 4: 55 DEFINITION OF DISCRIMINATION, LAW, POLICY AND MEASURES TO IMPLEMENT THE CONVENTION Article 1: Definition of discrimination lacking in legislation 58 Article 2: Limited progress in eliminating discrimination in law 58 Article 3: Measures to promote equality 64 Article 4: Temporary special measures in Malaysia 66 Recommendations to the Malaysian Government regarding Articles 1 – 4 of CEDAW 68 ARTICLE 5: SEX ROLES AND STEREOTYPING 73 Removal of reservation to Article 5(a) 74 Government rhetoric reinforces women’s stereotypical roles 75 Women in government policy plans 78 Sexist remarks by politicians 78 Government attempts to control women’s movement 79 Gender segregation in public transport 80 Media portrayals of women 80 ‘Obedient Wives Club’ blames women for domestic violence 81 Section 498 of the Penal Code 81 Polygamy 81 National fatwas discriminatory to women 81 Moral policing 83 Discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity 85 Government control of images of women on International Women’s Day 89 Recommendations to the Malaysian Government regarding Article 5 of CEDAW 90 ARTICLE 6: TRAFFICKING AND EXPLOITATION OF PROSTITUTION OF WOMEN 93 Malaysia acceded to UN trafficking in persons protocol 93 Anti-Trafficking in Persons Act 2007 93 Statistics on trafficking 95 Malaysia’s low ranking in the US Department of State Trafficking in Persons Reports 95 Poor treatment of trafficking victims 96 Treatment of victims is a disincentive to report trafficking 96 Degrading and humiliating treatment of women prostitutes 97 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding Article 6 of CEDAW 98 ARTICLES 7 AND 8: PARTICIPATION IN POLITICAL AND PUBLIC LIFE 101 RemoVal of reserVation to Article 7(b) of CEDAW 102 Appointment of female Syariah Court judges 102 Women’s low representation in politics 102 Ambassadors and High Commissioners 104 Women at the decision-making leVel in the public sector 104 Women’s participation in the public sphere 105 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding Articles 7 and 8 of CEDAW 106 ARTICLE 9: CITIZENSHIP 109 Non-citizen spouses 109 Employment for non-citizen spouses permitted with restrictions 109 Different constitutional provisions for citizenship for men and women 110 Discriminatory constitutional provisions regarding the citizenship of children 110 born oVerseas Entry visas and permanent residency for non-citizen spouses 111 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding Article 9 of CEDAW 114 ARTICLE 10: EDUCATION 117 Continued gender gaps in technical courses and higher degrees 118 Gender stereotypes reinforced in schools 118 Sex education in schools 119 Pregnant girls drop out of school 119 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding Article 10 of CEDAW 120 ARTICLE 11: EMPLOYMENT 123 Participation of women in the workforce 124 Parental leaVe 125 “Housework” main reason women don’t enter workforce 126 Childcare centres 126 Sexual harassment 126 Retirement age different for women in some industries 127 Non-citizen women married to Malaysian men must haVe written permission 128 from husbands to work Discrimination based on diVerse sexual orientations and gender identities in employment 129 Refugee women 130 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding Article 11 of CEDAW 130 ARTICLE 12: HEALTH 133 Lack of gender disaggregated data 134 Access to healthcare services 134 ContraceptiVe preValence 134 Maternal mortality rate 135 Abortion 135 Sex education 137 GoVernment banned children’s sex education book 137 Violations of women’s rights in goVernment hospitals 137 One Stop Crisis Centres 138 HIV/AIDS 138 Mandatory HIV testing for Muslim couples 139 Health promotion for sex workers hindered by police 139 Female circumcision compulsory for Muslim women 140 Differing leVels of access to health care for vulnerable women 140 Health insurance 142 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding Article 12 of CEDAW 143 ARTICLE 13: SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC RIGHTS 147 Benefits 147 Banking for non-citizen spouses 147 Women’s participation in sport 148 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding Article 13 of CEDAW 148 ARTICLE 14: RURAL WOMEN 151 Low representation of women in village committees 152 Abuse of Penan women and girls in Sarawak 152 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding Article 14 of CEDAW 154 ARTICLE 15: EQUALITY IN THE LAW 157 Judicial interpretation of the Federal Constitution 157 Women viewed as the property of their husbands in laws against “enticing a 159 married woman” Employment laws do not protect migrant domestic workers’ rights 160 Non-recognition of the rights of women of diVerse sexual orientations and gender 162 identities in law Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding Article 15 of CEDAW 164 ARTICLE 16: EQUALITY IN MARRIAGE AND FAMILY 167 RemoVal of reserVation to Article 16(2) 168 A brief oVerview of family law in Malaysia 168 Discrimination faced by women under civil and Islamic family law 169 Discrimination faced by women under civil law 174 Discrimination faced by women under Islamic family law 175 ConVersion of religion during marriage 182 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding Article 16 of CEDAW 186 CEDAW COMMITTEE GENERAL RECOMMENDATION NO. 19: VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN 193 PreValence of violence 195 Violence against women perpetrated by the State 196 Legal reform – domestic violence, rape, sexual harassment 197 Violence against migrant women 201 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding the CEDAW Committee’s 206 General Recommendation No. 19 CEDAW COMMITTEE GENERAL RECOMMENDATION NO. 26: WOMEN MIGRANT 211 WORKERS Migrant domestic workers in Malaysia 212 Lack of protection from the State 213 Vulnerability of domestic workers to abuse 215 Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding the CEDAW Committee’s 220 General Recommendation No. 26 CEDAW COMMITTEE GENERAL RECOMMENDATION NO. 28: 225 STATE OBLIGATION TO ELIMINATE ALL FORMS OF DISCRIMINATION AGAINST ALL WOMEN Gender stereotypes reinforced in education sector 227 Discrimination in employment 229 Access to healthcare 231 Violence based on perceiVed sexual orientation or gender identity 231 Harassment of women on the basis of sexual orientation 233 Malaysian transwoman granted refugee status in Australia 234 Yogyakarta Principles 235 Fatwas against non-heteronormatiVe identities 235 Contrary court decisions on gender and name change for transpeople 238 Laws that discriminate on the basis of sexuality and gender identity 237 Laws that discriminate on the basis of women’s sexual orientation 241 Response of SUHAKAM to discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and 241 gender identity Media portrayals of sexual diVersity 242 Film censorship guidelines 242 Banning of Seksualiti Merdeka (sexuality independence) in 2011 243 CEDAW Committee’s response to other countries regarding discrimination on the 245 basis of sexual orientation and gender identity Recommendations to the Malaysian GoVernment regarding the CEDAW 246 Committee’s General Recommendation No. 28 PICTURES 249 GLOSSARY 258 INTRODUCTION 1 The Malaysian goVernment’s combined initial and second report to the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women was reViewed by the Committee at its 35th session in 2006.1 Malaysian non-goVernment organisations (NGOs) prepared a Shadow Report for the 2006 reView session.2 The report you are now reading is the second Malaysian NGO report on the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women. It has been produced by Malaysian NGOs as an AlternatiVe Report, in the absence of the Malaysian goVernment’s combined third and fourth periodic report. Malaysia’s third report to the CEDAW Committee was due in August 2004 and the fourth periodic report was due in August 2008. Upon the delay of the third report, the CEDAW Committee requested that a combined third and fourth report be submitted by the Malaysian goVernment in August 2008. At the time of writing, in April 2012, the Malaysian goVernment has not yet submitted its combined third and fourth report to the CEDAW Committee. Unfortunately, many of the concerns raised in the first Malaysian NGO CEDAW Shadow Report of 2005, submitted for reView by the CEDAW Committee in 2006, are still releVant. This second NGO report does not attempt to replicate the
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Indicators and Rationales for Health Care Reform in Malaysia
    “1 Care for 1 Malaysia”?: Indicators and Rationales for Health Care Reform in Malaysia Dr. Por Heong Hong Contributor [email protected] 1. Introduction Since the attainment of independence in 1957, Malaysia’s health care service has been characterized by a mix of dominant public provision and significant presence of private services. Despite considerable changes over the past three decades, the dual system has made significant achievement with a total national expenditure less than the WHO recommended 5% GDP on health care each year. This is indicated in the country’s decreasing infant death rate, from 75.5 per 1,000 live births in 1957 to 6.8 per 1,000 live births in 2010, and improvement in life expectancy of male and female, from 55.8 years and 58.2 years in 1957 to 71.9 years and 77 years in 2010 respectively (see Table 1), REFSA which is above the world average of 68.5 years for males and 73.5 years for females over the period 2010–2013. Paper Focus Table 1: Infant death rate and life expectancy by sex in Malaysia, from 1957 to 2010. Infant death rate (per Life Expectancy (in years) Year 1,000 live births) Male Female 1957* 75.5 55.8 58.2 1980 19.7 66.7 71.6 2000 8.1 70.2 75.0 2010 6.8 71.9 77.0 1 Source: Vital Statistics Time Series: Peninsular Malaysia 1911-1985 by Department of Statistics, and Health Facts (various years) by Ministry of Health. Note: * Figure not inclusive of Sabah and Sarawak.
    [Show full text]
  • US Congress, Stand with Malaysians, Not Our Corrupt Government
    November 28, 2016 US Congress, Stand with Malaysians, Not Our Corrupt Government By Nurul Izzah Anwar Earlier this month, tens of thousands of Malaysians took to the streets to demand free and fair elections and the end of status quo's endemic corruption. While our demands are not new, our protest demonstrated the remarkable fortitude of the Malaysian people in the face of mounting oppression by Prime Minister Najib Razak. In an attempt to prevent the rally, Najib took a page out of the dictator’s playbook and ordered the preemptive arrest of 11 opposition organizers. One of those detained is well known Malaysian activist, Maria Chin Abdullah, the 60-year-old chairwoman of the Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections (Bersih). She remains in solitary confinement under the draconian Security Offences Act — catering to hardcore terrorists, which vaguely criminalizes activities “contrary to parliamentary democracy.” Amnesty International has already designated those arrested as prisoners of conscience who must be released immediately and unconditionally. Abdullah joins my father, former Deputy Prime Minister and opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim, as one of many political prisoners in Malaysia. Currently imprisoned on politically-motivated charges, Anwar posed a threat to the ruling regime when he championed a multi-ethnic and multi-religious opposition movement that garnered 52 percent of the votes in the 2013 parliamentary election — a victory that was ultimately rendered hollow by the government’s gerrymandering. The United Nations has denounced my father imprisonment as arbitrary and in violation of international law. Dozens more have been targeted, harassed, or imprisoned under the false pretenses of national security simply because they dare to speak out against Najib’s authoritarian tendencies and corrupt practices.
    [Show full text]
  • MARIA CHIN ABDULLAH GE14 CAMPAIGN MANIFESTO Maria Chin Abdullah Endorses the PAKATAN HARAPAN MANIFESTO Maria Chin Abdullah Endorses the PAKATAN HARAPAN MANIFESTO
    Dignity. For All. MARIA CHIN ABDULLAH GE14 CAMPAIGN MANIFESTO Maria Chin Abdullah endorses the PAKATAN HARAPAN MANIFESTO Maria Chin Abdullah endorses the PAKATAN HARAPAN MANIFESTO DIGNITY IS BEING ABLE: TO PUT FOOD ON TO GIVE OUR THE TABLE FOR OUR CHILDREN AN FAMILY EDUCATION FOR A BRIGHTER FUTURE TO WALK ON THE STREETS SAFELY TO BREATHE CLEAN TO TREAT EACH AIR AND TO PROTECT OTHER AS EQUALS AND CONSERVE OUR AND WITH RESPECT ENVIRONMENT TO EXPRESS OUR OPINIONS WITHOUT FEAR “I, like you, have been fortunate to grow up in a Malaysia that is peaceful and inclusive. Sadly, times have changed so much. Every day, most of us have to fight hard to keep our dignity.” • GST means everything costs so much more. • Violence against women and children is on the rise, like other crimes. • Scholarships are less available, denying our children quality education. • Our country is now one of the most corrupt in Asia. • Our forests and native lands are being destroyed by corrupt developers. • Oppressive laws restrict our freedom of expression. Things are much worse than before. What can be done? Change for the better is possible. HOW WILL MARIA ACHIEVE HER GOALS? MY AIM WHAT I BELIEVE HOW I WILL DO IT A clean and fair I will work to put in place: government is the Legal reform foundation of a prosperous, • A Royal Commission of 1 healthy nation. Our leaders Inquiry (RCI) to review the must be freely, fairly and electoral system and CLEAN legitimately elected, at all processes AND FAIR levels of government, from • RCI on Local Council Federal to local.
    [Show full text]
  • Dewan Negara
    Bil. 11 Rabu 21 Julai 2010 MALAYSIA PENYATA RASMI PARLIMEN DEWAN NEGARA PARLIMEN KEDUA BELAS PENGGAL KETIGA MESYUARAT KEDUA K A N D U N G A N JAWAPAN-JAWAPAN LISAN BAGI PERTANYAAN-PERTANYAAN (Halaman 1) USUL: Rancangan Malaysia Kesepuluh (2011 - 2015) (Halaman 18) Diterbitkan Oleh: CAWANGAN PENYATA RASMI PARLIMEN MALAYSIA 2010 DN.21.7.2010 i AHLI-AHLI DEWAN NEGARA 1. Yang Berhormat Tuan Yang di-Pertua, Tan Sri Abu Zahar bin Dato’ Nika Ujang 2. Yang Berhormat Timbalan Yang di-Pertua, Datuk Armani binti Haji Mahiruddin (Sabah) 3. “ Dato’ Haji Abdul Rahim bin Haji Abdul Rahman (Dilantik) 4. “ Datuk Abdul Rahman bin Bakar (Dilantik) 5. “ Dato’ Haji Abdul Rashid bin Ngah (Dilantik) 6. “ Tuan Haji Ahamat @ Ahamad bin Yusop (Johor) 7. “ Tuan Ahmad bin Hussin (Perlis) 8. “ Tuan Haji Ahmad Rusli bin Haji Iberahim (Kelantan) 9. “ Datuk Akbar bin Ali (Melaka) 10. “ Tuan A. Kohilan Pillay a/l G. Appu (Dilantik) – Senator – Timbalan Menteri Luar Negeri I 11. “ Tan Sri Datuk Amirsham bin A. Aziz (Dilantik) 12. “ Datuk Dr. Awang Adek Hussein (Dilantik) – Senator – Timbalan Menteri Kewangan II 13. “ Dato’ Azian bin Osman (Perak) 14. “ Datuk Hajah Azizah binti Abd. Samad (Dilantik) 15. “ Datuk Chandrasekar Suppiah (Dilantik) 16. “ Dato’ Daljit Singh Dalliwal (Dilantik) 17. “ Puan Hajah Dayang Madinah binti Tun Abang Haji Openg (Sarawak) 18. “ Puan Doris Sophia ak Brodi (Dilantik) 19. “ Puan Hajah Fatimah binti Hamat (Terengganu) 20. “ Dato’ Dr. Firdaus bin Haji Abdullah (Dilantik) 21. “ Tuan Gan Ping Shou @ Gan Ping Sieu (Dilantik) 22. “ Puan Heng Seai Kie (Perak) – Senator – Timbalan Menteri Wanita, Keluarga dan Masyarakat 23.
    [Show full text]
  • Labour Migration from Indonesia
    LABOUR MIGRATION FROM INDONESIA IOM is committed to the principle that humane and orderly migration benets migrants and society. As an intergovernmental body, IOM acts with its partners in the international community to assist in meeting the operational challenges of migration; advance understanding of migration issues; encourage social and economic development through migration; and uphold the human dignity and wellbeing of migrants. This publication is produced with the generous nancial support of the Bureau of Population, Refugees and Migration (United States Government). Opinions expressed in this report are those of the contributors and do not necessarily reect the views of IOM. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher: International Organization for Migration Mission in Indonesia LABOUR MIGRATION FROM INDONESIA Sampoerna Strategic Square, North Tower Floor 12A Jl. Jend. Sudirman Kav. 45-46 An Overview of Indonesian Migration to Selected Destinations in Asia and the Middle East Jakarta 12930 Indonesia © 2010 International Organization for Migration (IOM) IOM International Organization for Migration IOM International Organization for Migration Labour Migration from Indonesia TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS vii PREFACE ix EXECUTIVE SUMMARY xi ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS 1 INTRODUCTION 3 Purpose 3 Terminology 3 Methodology
    [Show full text]
  • Malaysia's Health 2004
    Ministry of Health Malaysia MALAYSIA’S HEALTH 2004 Malaysia’s Health provides a glimpse of health developments in Malaysia, covering a wide array of topics on healthcare services, population health, health system management as well as research and development in the health sector in Malaysia. This technical report series was started in 1992 and provide the most comprehensive record of health developments in the country, including the private sector. Malaysia has a mix public-private healthcare system with the Ministry of Health as a major healthcare provider in the public sector. Being the lead agency for health, it provides leadership on matters relating to health, and sets the direction for health development in the country through standards and policy settings; promoting research and development in health; formulating health legislations and their enforcement to protect the health of its population; as well as providing high quality, accessible and affordable primary, secondary and tertiary care services to those who cannot afford private healthcare. Selected topics in this report provide an account of various initiatives undertaken by the Ministry of Health to improve health of its people, as well as healthcare services in its facilities and the coutry. These include quality improvements in healthcare provision and patient safety; affordable medicine; disease prevention and control; food quality control and safety; as well as health planning and management. The report on National Health Account gives an interesting insight into the pattern of health expenditures in the country while under the section on Research and Development, Malaysia’s role in establishing the Global Hub for Integrated Medicine and Herbal R&D is explained.
    [Show full text]
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
    86 AMMB Holdings Berhad • Annual Report 2007 Corporate Social Responsibility Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) today is part and parcel of the organisational way of succeeding in business, and is, in essence, a set of transparent and ethical actions to ‘give back’, nurture and aid in the progress of the various environments in which the corporation operates. This is to contribute to the very partners, customers and sources without which the organisation would not be able to succeed and prosper. The AmBank Group takes prides in giving and interacting with its various communities and the AmBank Group continues to be a highly active citizen in the socially responsible corporate world. Responsibility to the Marketplace The AmBank Group’s business transactions, deals and Tan Sri Dato’ Azman Hashim, Chairman, AmBank Group (right), receiving the Corporate Governance Award certifying AmBank Group’s status as relationships with all its groups of customers, suppliers top five among 100 listed companies on Bursa Malaysia in the Corporate and partners are executed with the highest concern Governance Survey 2004 (Announced August 2006) from Encik Abdul for transparency and ethical conduct, guided by high Wahab Jaafar Sidek, CEO of Minority Shareholder Watchdog Group corporate governance standards. Providing opportunity for market access to Syariah- compliant products also came about with exciting “firsts”: The Group was named in the top five among 100 listed companies on Bursa Malaysia in the Corporate • the launch of the Al-`Aqar KPJ REIT – the world’s first Governance Survey Report 2004 (announced August Islamic healthcare REIT (July 2006); and 2006), spearheaded by the Minority Shareholder Watchdog Group.
    [Show full text]
  • What Lies Ahead for Malaysian Healthcare? Lee Poh Onn ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute E-Mail: [email protected]
    No. 2015-4 What Lies Ahead for Malaysian Healthcare? Lee Poh Onn ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute E-mail: [email protected] ISEAS Economics Working Paper December 2015 Abstract Healthcare in Malaysia has been characterised by a strong public sector presence where government hospitals and clinics acted as a primary source of care. The healthcare system has also been lauded as a model for other developing countries to follow as it has succeeded in improving the health status of Malaysians over time. With the rising costs of healthcare over the last three decades, the government is now facing increasing pressures to restructure its healthcare system. Social healthcare insurance, corporatisation, and privatisation have been increasingly seen as possible measures to supplement the current healthcare system dominated by the public sector. In Malaysia, the involvement of government-linked companies in the private healthcare sector has, however, raised conflict-of-interest issues. Political economy factors will continue to play out; the private sector will continue to play an increasingly important role in the provision of healthcare while a long-awaited social healthcare insurance plan takes shape. Ultimately, clear rules of governance, regulations, and transparency have to be put in place to ensure that standards are maintained, conflict-of-interest issues are checked, and that healthcare continues to remain accessible. Keywords: Social Protection; Public Healthcare; Private Healthcare; Malaysia 30 Heng Mui Keng Terrace, Singapore 119614 6778
    [Show full text]
  • CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Healthcare in Malaysia Most Countries Undergoing Structural Change from Low to High Value Added Ac
    CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Healthcare in Malaysia Most countries undergoing structural change from low to high value added activities of healthcare have been characterised by the private providers. The process of privatisation and contracting out services to the private businesses has led to an increasing shift in healthcare from being delivered as an essential public utility to a profit seeking target by private providers. Privatisation has also been used frequently by governments as a policy instrument to reduce the financial burden of the public sector. Malaysia is one of the countries that have experienced fundamental changes in the healthcare sector since independence in 1957. The colonial healthcare system in Malaya had originally been developed primarily for the purpose of serving the needs of the civil servants and other government employees and also the plantation sector (Harper, 1999), but expanded gradually to meet the needs of the general public. In addition, healthcare facilities were concentrated in urban areas with a focus on curative healthcare during the colonial period. After the Second World War, there were greater efforts to provide services to the rural areas both as part of overall development policies and as a strategic measure to counter Communist insurgency (Chee, 1990). The newly independent government of Malaya was committed to expanding state healthcare, especially services in rural areas has hitherto been neglected. At independence in 1957, the Federal Government assumed control of all government healthcare services, which had previously been, to a large extent, the responsibility of individual states of the Federation of Malaya (Barraclough, 1999). Government healthcare activities encompass curative, rehabilitative, promotive and regulatory concerns.
    [Show full text]
  • Title Protecting and Assisting Refugees and Asylum-Seekers in Malaysia
    Title Protecting and assisting refugees and asylum-seekers in Malaysia : the role of the UNHCR, informal mechanisms, and the 'Humanitarian exception' Sub Title Author Lego, Jera Beah H. Publisher Global Center of Excellence Center of Governance for Civil Society, Keio University Publication year 2012 Jtitle Journal of political science and sociology No.17 (2012. 10) ,p.75- 99 Abstract This paper problematizes Malaysia's apparently contradictory policies – harsh immigration rules applied to refugees and asylum seekers on the one hand, and the continued presence and functioning of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) on the other hand. It asks how it has been possible to protect and assist refugees and asylum seekers in light of such policies and how such protection and assistance is implemented, justified, and maintained. Giorgio Agamben's concept of the state of exception is employed in analyzing the possibility of refugee protection and assistance amidst an otherwise hostile immigration regime and in understanding the nature of juridical indeterminacy in which refugees and asylum seekers in Malaysia inhabit. I also argue that the exception for refugees in Malaysia is a particular kind of exception, that is, a 'humanitarian exception.' Insofar as the state of exception is decided on by the sovereign, in Carl Schmitt's famous formulation, I argue that it is precisely in the application of 'humanitarian exception' for refugees and asylum seekers that the Malaysian state is asserting its sovereignty. As for the protection and assistance to refugees and asylum seekers, it remains an exception to the rule. In other words, it is temporary, partial, and all together insufficient for the preservation of the dignity of refugees and asylum seekers.
    [Show full text]
  • Dewan Rakyat
    Bil. 18 Selasa 13 April 2010 MALAYSIA PENYATA RASMI PARLIMEN DEWAN RAKYAT PARLIMEN KEDUA BELAS PENGGAL KETIGA MESYUARAT PERTAMA K A N D U N G A N JAWAPAN-JAWAPAN LISAN BAGI PERTANYAAN-PERTANYAAN (Halaman 1) RANG UNDANG-UNDANG: Rang Undang-undang Perbekalan Tambahan (2009) 2010 Jawatankuasa:- Jadual:- Maksud B.60 (Halaman 22) Maksud B.62 (Halaman 38) Rang Undang-undang Perbekalan Tambahan (2010) 2010 (Halaman 66) USUL-USUL: Waktu Mesyuarat dan Urusan Dibebaskan Daripada Peraturan Mesyuarat (Halaman 20) Anggaran Pembangunan Tambahan (Bil.2) 2009 Jawatankuasa:- Maksud P.62 (Halaman 38) Anggaran Pembangunan Tambahan (Bil.1) 2010 (Halaman 72) Diterbitkan oleh: CAWANGAN PENYATA RASMI PARLIMEN MALAYSIA 2010 DR.13.4.2010 i AHLI-AHLI DEWAN RAKYAT 1. Yang Berhormat Tuan Yang di-Pertua, Tan Sri Datuk Seri Utama Pandikar Amin Haji Mulia, S.U.M.W., P.G.D.K., P.S.M., J.S.M., J.P. 2. Yang Berhormat Timbalan Yang di-Pertua, Datuk Dr. Haji Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar, P.J.N., P.B.S. J.B.S., J.S.M. (Santubong) – PBB 3. “ Timbalan Yang di-Pertua, Datuk Ronald Kiandee, A.S.D.K., P.G.D.K. (Beluran) – UMNO MENTERI 1. Yang Amat Berhormat Perdana Menteri dan Menteri Kewangan, Dato’ Sri Mohd. Najib bin Tun Haji Abdul Razak, D.U.P.N., S.S.A.P, S.I.M.P., D.P.M.S., D.S.A.P., P.N.B.S., D.U.B.C.(T). (Pekan) – UMNO 2. “ Timbalan Perdana Menteri dan Menteri Pelajaran, Tan Sri Dato’ Haji Muhyiddin bin Haji Mohd. Yassin, S.P.M.P., S.P.M.J., P.S.M., S.M.J., P.I.S., B.S.I.
    [Show full text]
  • Thesis Final
    STATE POWER AND THE REGULATION OF NON-CITIZENS: IMMIGRATION LAWS, POLICIES, AND PRACTICES IN PENINSULAR MALAYSIA ALICE MARIA NAH HAN YUONG NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE 2011 STATE POWER AND THE REGULATION OF NON-CITIZENS: IMMIGRATION LAWS, POLICIES, AND PRACTICES IN PENINSULAR MALAYSIA ALICE MARIA NAH HAN YUONG B.A. (Hons), University of Leeds M.Soc.Sci., National University of Singapore A THESIS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIOLOGY NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE 2011 DECLARATION I hereby declare that this thesis is my original work and it has been written by me in its entirety. I have duly acknowledged all the sources of information that have been used in this thesis. This thesis has not been submitted for any degree in any university previously. Alice M. Nah 14 July 2012 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am greatly indebted to my supervisor, A/P Roxana Waterson, for her moral and intellectual support during the completion of this research. I am particularly thankful for her constant encouragement and her sensitivity in understanding how personal life sometimes ‘takes over’ during research projects. I would not have completed this work if not for her. I am grateful to the Asia Research Institute for the Research Scholarship that made this dissertation possible. At the Department of Sociology, I enjoyed learning from Professor Bryan Turner, A/P Tong Chee Kiong, and A/P Maribeth Erb, as well as tutoring for A/P Syed Farid Alatas and A/P Vineeta Sinha. I am also thankful to Dr. Nirmala PuruShotam who started me on the path of sociological research exactly a decade ago.
    [Show full text]