Arxiv:2012.05924V2 [Cond-Mat.Mes-Hall] 4 May 2021
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Exact analytical treatment of multiqubit noisy dynamics in exchange-coupled semiconductor spin qubits Donovan Buterakos and Sankar Das Sarma Condensed Matter Theory Center and Joint Quantum Institute, Department of Physics, University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland 20742-4111 USA (Dated: May 5, 2021) Charge noise remains the primary obstacle to the development of quantum information technolo- gies with semiconductor spin qubits. We use an exact analytical calculation to determine the effects of quasistatic charge noise on a ring of three equally spaced exchange-coupled quantum dots. We calculate the disorder-averaged return probability from a specific initial state, and use it to deter- ∗ mine the coherence time T2 and show that it depends only on the disorder strength and not the mean interaction strength. We also use a perturbative approach to investigate other arrangements of three or four qubits, finding that the return probability contains multiple oscillation frequencies. These oscillations decay in a Gaussian manner, determined by differences in energy levels of the Hamiltonian. We give quantitative values for gate times resulting in several target fidelities. We find that the decoherence time decreases with increasing number of qubits. Our work provides useful analytical insight into the charge noise dynamics of coupled spin qubits. I. INTRODUCTION However, the fidelities of these two-qubit gates must still be increased substantially (> 99%) in order to meet the Electron spin qubits in semiconductor (particularly, minimum threshold values needed to implement quan- Si) quantum dots is considered to be a promising plat- tum error correcting codes. The two-qubit gate fidelities form for developing quantum information technologies are predominantly limited by charge noise, which can due to its long coherence times and fast gate speed, arise from local charge impurities in the solid or in the as well as the potential scalability and ability to use controlling circuits which create the quantum dot poten- resources from the semiconductor industry which are tial wells [14, 15]. These impurities can affect the elec- currently available. Semiconductor spin qubits remain tron wave functions, and in turn affect the strength of among the most-studied quantum computing platforms the exchange interaction used to perform the two-qubit in the world with laboratories in USA, Australia, Eu- gates, since the exchange interaction depends very pre- rope, Japan, Canada, and China actively pursuing cou- cisely on the wavefunction overlap [14]. Methods have pled semiconductor quantum dot systems for eventual been proposed to reduce the effect of charge noise, such quantum computing applications. There has been much as using quadrupolar exchange-only qubits, which uses experimental progress including the implementation of four electrons in three quantum dots to access a \sweet two qubit gates between singlet-triplet qubits [1], the spot" where qubit operation is robust to first order charge fabrication of linear arrays of nine quantum dots [2], noise [16]. Additionally, there are proposals for dynam- the shuttling of spins across linear arrays [3], and the ical decoupling schemes, which perform rotations using implementation of basic quantum algorithms on a pro- complex pulse shapes which cancel errors to some degree grammable two-qubit processor [4]. A plaquette of four [17, 18]; however, dynamical decoupling requires a pre- quantum dots has also been used to perform simulations cise understanding of the source and form of the noise to of the Hubbard model and observe Nagaoka ferromag- be canceled. None of the proposed techniques for mitiga- netism [5{7]. A four-qubit quantum processor has been tion has been generically successful in eliminating charge constructed with hole qubits in Geranium quantum dots noise, and understanding and eliminating charge noise [8, 9]. Very recent unpublished work from Delft reports remains the main obstacle in the development of semi- the fabrication of a 6-spin qubit Si system, where our conductor spin qubits. work should be relevant [10]. These are just a few exam- The effects of noise have been studied theoretically in ples from the many recent exciting developments in the coupled double quantum dot systems [19{23]. Beginning field. In spite of much impressive progress, the subject with a Hamiltonian for two exchange coupled dots in arXiv:2012.05924v2 [cond-mat.mes-hall] 4 May 2021 faces a rather difficult challenge in mitigating errors aris- the presence of an external magnetic field, the proba- ing from charge noise, which is invariably present in all bility P (t) was calculated that the system initialized in electronic materials, devices, and circuits. In particular, a given state would be measured in the same state after charge noise has prevented semiconductor quantum dot evolution for some time t. Quasistatic noise was mod- platforms from developing multiqubit system operations eled by choosing the magnetic field and exchange interac- with the current limit being 2-4 coupled qubits at most. tion strengths from random Gaussian distributions, and Benchmarking of quantum dot devices has obtained the return probability was analytically averaged over all single qubit gates with fidelities over 99.9% [11], but choices for each parameter. This disorder-averaged re- two-qubit gates have fidelities ranging from 90% to 95%, turn probability showed oscillations within a Gaussian- ∗ with a few specific gates reaching up to 98% [12, 13]. shaped envelope, and the value of T2 for the system was 2 obtained from the decay rate of the envelope [19]. Nu- equilateral triangle. Specifically, we consider the case merical simulations have also been performed for larger where the mean interaction strength between each pair of systems in the same manner, including a system of two dots is identical. This case has a high degree of symmetry, capacitively coupled singlet triplet qubits [20, 21] and ion which allows the dynamics in the presence of noise to be trap spin chains (which have a similar Hamiltonian and calculated exactly analytically. We begin by defining the dynamics)[22]. This method has also been used to deter- model and Hamiltonian; we then show the calculation of mine the fidelity of spin transport across spin chains via the disorder averaged return probability from an initial SWAP gates [23]. These works are all, however, purely state; finally, we discuss the results. numerical, and although useful in their own right, these numerical calculations fail to provide analytical insight into the noise dynamics. A. Model and Hamiltonian In this current work, we analytically calculate the ef- fects of charge noise on various systems of three and four We consider a single half-filled band in a plaquette con- quantum dots. For a ring of three quantum dots, we sisting of a ring of three quantum dot, and thus three perform an exact analytical calculation and obtain ex- electrons are present. We neglect the effect of higher pressions for the disorder averaged return probability, as unoccupied energy orbitals as the energy difference be- well as the spin expectation values and entanglement en- tween bands tends to be much larger than the interaction tropy for each qubit. We find that the shape of the os- strength between dots, which is the relevant energy scale cillation envelope is completely independent of the mean for the dynamics of the system. Similarly, we also as- exchange interaction strength and depends only on the sume a large onsite interaction energy, and thus we ignore disorder strength, and we obtain the exact coherence states where a single dot contains more than one electron ∗ time T2 as a function of disorder strength. For other (these are all experimentally valid and theoretically used systems, we develop a pertubative approach to calculat- approximations for semiconductor quantum dot qubits). ing the noise-induced decoherence effects. We show that Then each dot will contain exactly one electron, and the multiple frequencies appear in the resulting expressions, exchange interaction between dots will give rise to the and that these frequencies depend on the differences be- following Heisenberg Hamiltonian: tween energy levels of the noiseless Hamiltonian. These frequencies each decay in a Gaussian-like manner with ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ their own decay rate, and the decay rates are given by H = J12S1 · S2 + J23S2 · S3 + J13S1 · S3 (1) the first order noise-induced corrections to the energy levels which produce the frequencies. For each system, Let the values of the exchange interaction between two ∗ dots Jij have a Gaussian distribution because of the noise we calculate T2 and find the times tc at which the system drops below various fidelity benchmarks. Our analytical with mean J0 and standard deviation σJ . Here, σJ is a theory provides detailed insight into the noise dynamics measure of the charge noise induced disorder, leading to which are hidden (and therefore difficult to discern) in random Gaussian fluctuations in the exchange coupling. the existing numerical calculations. It is in fact quite In order for this distribution to be sensible, J0 must be an unanticipated finding that the multiqubit dynamics several times larger than σJ , so that the proportion of under charge noise can be obtained analytically. the distribution with a negative value of J is negligible, This paper is organized as follows: in Sec. II, we ex- and we will assume this is the case. It is convenient to amine a ring of three equally spaced quantum dots, and define and