International Market Potential for Certified Timber of Five Locally Prized Woods Commonly Found in South-East Tanzania
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Mpingo Conservation & Development Initiative International market potential for certified timber of five locally prized woods commonly found in south-east Tanzania Abridged Report – March 2014 Markets for five timber species found in community forests in Tanzania CONTENTS Executive Summary ...................................................................................................................................... 3 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................................... 4 2. Methodology ............................................................................................................................................. 4 3. Physical & Woodworking Properties ........................................................................................................ 4 4. International Trade in Tropical Hardwoods .............................................................................................. 7 5. Existing Markets ....................................................................................................................................... 9 6. Key Market Sectors ................................................................................................................................. 11 7. Market Interest ........................................................................................................................................ 14 8. Discussion ............................................................................................................................................... 15 Appendix 1: Market sector definitions ........................................................................................................ 17 Appendix 2: Secondary data sources for research ...................................................................................... 17 Appendix 3: Definitions of physical and woodworking properties ............................................................ 18 This report was produced by Abigail Wills based on a longer report written for MCDI by Kilimanyika Ltd. Citation: MCDI (2014) International market potential for certified timber of five locally prized woods commonly found in south- east Tanzania. Mpingo Conservation & Development Initiative, Tanzania. Cover photo: MCDI supervisors and the logging team in Kilwa, with African lignum vitae logs (Photographer: Neil Bridgland) Acronyms & Abbreviations used in this report CITES Convention on International Trade in Kgf Kilograms of force Endangered Species MCDI Mpingo Conservation & Development EUR Euro Initiative FSC Forest Stewardship Council PFM Participatory Forest Management GBP Great British Pound USD United States Dollar ITTO International Tropical Timber VLFR Village Land Forest Reserve Organisation p. 2 Markets for five timber species found in community forests in Tanzania EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This report describes the market potential of five Locally Prized Woods (LPW): Millettia stuhlmannii (proposed trade name: panga panga), Pterocarpus angolenis (East African padauk), Acacia nigrescens (African lignum vitae), Afzelia quanzensis (pod mahogany), and Julbernardia globiflora (mtondoro) that are commonly found in south-east Tanzania. The findings will be used to design effective marketing strategies for the species, thereby increasing the viability of livelihoods based on sustainable timber harvesting in community forests of Kilwa, Tanzania. The aims of the study were to: (1) determine the physical and woodworking properties of each LPW; (2) identify similar, widely traded, species for which they could be used as substitutes; and (3) investigate the requirements of key timber market sectors into which each species can be suitably positioned. The study comprised two stages. Firstly, secondary data was compiled to identify the appropriate sectors in which to establish the five LPW in the marketplace. Secondly, samples were distributed to gather feedback from potential buyers. There is definitely potential for the LPW to be sold into Western markets, where ethical concerns are comparatively high. Sample recipients showed immediate interest in panga panga, East African padauk, and pod mahogany, which have significant prospects in the flooring, musical instrument, decking, construction, household and consumer good, luxury furniture, and high quality window and door sectors. African lignum vitae shows strong potential for introduction into the decking and flooring industries. For all of the LPW, it will be critical to ensure that consistently high quality timber is harvested, prepared and exported to manufacturers in a timely manner. p. 3 Markets for five timber species found in community forests in Tanzania 1. INTRODUCTION This report details the potential international markets for five Locally Prized Woods (LPW; Table 1) that are commonly found in south-east Tanzania. They are thus significant potential revenue earners for forest managers there who can meet international standards, especially on the ethical dimension. Table 1: The Locally Prized Woods (LPW) included in the study. Scientific name Swahili name Proposed trade name* Known trade alternatives Millettia stuhlmannii Mpangapanga Panga panga Wenge (Millettia laurentii) African padauk (Pterocarpus Pterocarpus angolensis Mninga East African padauk soyauxii) Acacia nigrescens Msenjele African lignum vitae None Afzelia and Doussie (Afzelia Afzelia quanzensis Mkongo Pod mahogany spp. from West Africa) Julbernardia globiflora Mtondoro Mtondoro None * Hereafter, the LPW species are referred to by their proposed trade names. 2. METHODOLOGY The five LPW were analysed in respect to: structural characteristics, woodworking qualities, and current uses and markets (for the species themselves, along with their trade alternatives; Table 1). They were compared with similar internationally-traded tropical and temperate hardwoods to identify opportunities for positioning them in ten market sectors (see Appendix 1 for definitions of these): Musical instruments Flooring Boats and yachts Window frames and doors Furniture Marine and freshwater applications Household and consumer goods Sawn wood Construction Veneers A variety of sources (including timber trade and wood research online databases and search facilities, industry organisations, and internet searches using Google; Appendix 2) were used to investigate the known commercial uses, trade prices, and volumes of the LPW and/or alternatives, as well as to compile a database of potential distributors. 3. PHYSICAL & WOODWORKING PROPERTIES All of the LPW have high density, moderate hardness (except African lignum vitae, one of the top ten hardest species worldwide) and high bending strength (the value for this is unknown for African lignum vitae; Table 2). In addition, with mostly straight or interlocked grain and medium-coarse texture, they are all at least moderately durable and therefore suited to hard-wearing, long-lasting functions. p. 4 Markets for five timber species found in community forests in Tanzania Table 2: Physical and woodworking properties of the Locally Prized Woods (LPW). East African African lignum Property* Panga panga Pod mahogany Mtondoro padauk vitae Density (Kg/m3) 881 624 1,100 817 881 Hardness (Kgf) 739 671 1,945 916 1,120 Bending Strength 2 1,033 1,144 Unknown 1,001 1,248 (Kg/cm ) Durability Medium Very Very Very Medium Stability High Medium Medium High Medium Machining Medium Good Difficult Difficult Medium Workability Medium Good Difficult Medium Medium Straight/ Straight/ Grain Straight Often irregular Interlocked interlocked interlocked Coarse/ Medium/ Coarse/ Medium/ Texture Medium medium coarse medium coarse Red/ Red/ Colour Dark brown Dark brown Golden brown light brown orange brown * See Appendix 3 for definitions. 3.1 Similar Traditionally Internationally Traded Hardwood Species The LPW were compared with Traditionally Internationally Traded Hardwood Species (TITHS) which are: (a) heavily traded and/or well known; (b) used to manufacture specialist products; and, (c) similar in characteristics to the LPW. These were grouped into three categories: light (density: 500-700 kg/m3), medium (700-900 kg/m3) and heavy (900+ kg/m3) hardwoods. 3.1.1 Light hardwoods East African padauk is similar to sapele and iroko in terms of density and hardness (Figure 1). Nonetheless, African padauk is commonly used as an alternative in industry, despite being significantly harder and denser (Figure 2). p. 5 Markets for five timber species found in community forests in Tanzania Figure 1: Comparison of light hardwood (500-700 kg/m3) species (a) density and hardness, and (b) durability, machining and stability. 3.1.2 Medium hardwoods Panga panga is similar to wenge, bubinga and Macassar ebony in terms of density, hardness and stability (Figure 2). Pod mahogany shares the most properties with merbau, doussie and bubinga, which are similar in density and hardness. Mtondoro is most alike wenge, bubinga and Macassar ebony in these respects. Figure 2: Comparison of medium hardwood (700-900 kg/m3) species (a) density and hardness, and (b) durability, machining and stability. p. 6 Markets for five timber species found in community forests in Tanzania 3.1.3 Heavy Hardwoods African lignum vitae is most similar to ipȇ, greenheart, lignum vitae, and cumaru (Figure 3). Figure 3: Comparison of medium hardwood (900+ kg/m3) species (a) density and hardness, and (b) durability, machining and stability.