JWC Dissertation

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

JWC Dissertation Mormon Polygamy and the Construction of American Citizenship, 1852-1910 by Jenette Wood Crowley Department of History Duke University Date: ___________________________ Approved: ___________________________ Sarah Deutsch, Supervisor ___________________________ Laura Edwards ___________________________ John Thompson ___________________________ Grant Wacker Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of History in the Graduate School of Duke University 2011 i v ABSTRACT Mormon Polygamy and the Construction of American Citizenship, 1852-1910 by Jenette Wood Crowley Department of History Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Sarah Deutsch, Supervisor ___________________________ Laura Edwards ___________________________ John Thompson ___________________________ Grant Wacker An abstract of a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of History in the Graduate School of Duke University 2011 Copyright by Jenette Wood Crowley 2011 Abstract From 1852 to 1910 Congress labored to find the right instruments to eliminate polygamy among the Mormons and the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints struggled to retain its claim as the most American of institutions. What these struggles reveal about the shifting role of religion in the developing definition of American citizenship is at the heart of this dissertation. Looking at developing ideas about citizenship in this particular frame exposes the social and political history of exclusion and inclusion comes and the role religion played in determining who could lay claim to citizenship and who could not, who tried and failed, who succeeded, and why. In the end, the coercive measures of the state and their own desire to join the body politic drove the Saints to abandon unquestionably the practice of polygamy, a central tenet of their faith, so that they could be accepted as American citizens. The battle over polygamy and the rights of polygamists was not limited to the floor of the U.S. Congress or the Supreme Court, although those sources are carefully examined here. Debates over polygamy and Mormons’ right to be Americans also took place in sermons, novels, newspapers, and popular periodicals. Official actions of the state and popular discourses simultaneously defined citizenship and influenced how Mormons understood their own citizenship. This dissertation is a history of the discourse generated by Mormons and their antagonists, laws passed by Congress, and court cases fought to defend or deny the civil, political and social rights of Latter-day Saints. iv To Matt, Tommy and Charlie. I love you. v Contents Abstract.............................................................................................................................. iv Introduction......................................................................................................................... 1 Chapter 1: A People Apart................................................................................................ 25 Theocracy and National Standing............................................................................... 28 1852 ............................................................................................................................ 38 Polygamy Enters National Politics ............................................................................. 45 Reformation ................................................................................................................ 51 More Trouble with Judges .......................................................................................... 55 Mountain Meadows .................................................................................................... 60 The Utah War.............................................................................................................. 62 Denouement ................................................................................................................ 74 Chapter 2: The Threat of Polygamy ................................................................................. 77 Mormonism Threatens Western Civilization.............................................................. 80 Polygamy Destroys the American Family and Home ................................................ 85 Domestic Fiction and its Influence on Anti-Mormon Literature................................ 90 True American Women, Consent, and Slavery .......................................................... 92 Orientalism of Mormons and the Creation of a New Race....................................... 106 Politics of the Written Word..................................................................................... 112 Chapter 3: Rapidly Diverging Understandings of Religion and Citizenship.................. 115 Legislators Make the Case that Mormonism is Not a Religion................................ 120 The Cullom Bill ........................................................................................................ 128 The Poland Act ......................................................................................................... 135 vi The United States vs. George Reynolds and the Centrality of Monogamy to American Citizenship ................................................................................................................ 143 A Change in Course.................................................................................................. 154 Chapter 4: The Political and Legal Reconstruction of Utah........................................... 157 The Cullom Bill and Radical Reconstruction ........................................................... 159 Anti-Mormon Hysteria ............................................................................................. 165 Edmunds Act of 1882 ............................................................................................... 169 Political Reconstruction of Utah............................................................................... 187 Legal Reconstruction of Marriage ............................................................................ 200 Chapter 5: Building a White, Monogamous, Protestant Nation ..................................... 215 Edmunds-Tucker Act................................................................................................ 217 Sexuality ................................................................................................................... 221 Immigration .............................................................................................................. 226 Civil Rights ............................................................................................................... 234 Property and Faith..................................................................................................... 251 Dreams of Statehood................................................................................................. 258 Chapter 6: Becoming American ..................................................................................... 262 Public Acquiescence and Private Continuance......................................................... 267 The Saints Join the Union......................................................................................... 277 The Price of American Citizenship........................................................................... 287 Continued Cohabitation ............................................................................................ 296 New Plural Marriages ............................................................................................... 300 Continuing Revelation and Loyalty to the Nation .................................................... 304 vii Acceptance................................................................................................................ 312 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 319 Bibliography ................................................................................................................... 327 Biography........................................................................................................................ 365 viii Introduction In June 2008, authorities within the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints called on California Mormons to donate their time and money to the campaign for Proposition 8, a measure that if passed would overturn a state Supreme Court ruling permitting gay marriage. In response to the Church’s calling, Latter-day Saints gave more than $20 million to the effort to pass the measure, helping the initiative win narrow passage on election day. The Church’s role in Proposition 8’s success made the Mormons a political target of those who opposed the measure. Protestors gathered outside Mormon temples across the country; for every donation made to a fund to overturn Proposition 8, a postcard was sent to the President of the Church; supporters of Gay marriage proposed a boycott of Utah businesses; and someone burned a Book of Mormon outside a temple near Denver. Many called for the Church’s tax-exempt status to end because it had so involved itself in political matters. 1 In response to the political backlash, the First
Recommended publications
  • Utah History Encyclopedia
    POLYGAMY Polygamist prisoners, State Penitentiary, 1888 When establishing the LDS Church, Joseph Smith recorded numerous revelations he claimed to receive, often in answer to questions about the Bible, which are now included in the Doctrine and Covenants, part of the LDS canon. In answer to his question as to why many of the Old Testament leaders had more than one wife, Smith received what is now known as Section 132. Although the revelation was not recorded until 1843, Smith may have received it in the 1830s and married his first plural wife, Fanny Alger, in 1835. Polygamy was not openly practiced in the Mormon Church until 1852 when Orson Pratt, an apostle, made a public speech defending it as a tenet of the church. From 1852 until 1890, Mormon Church leaders preached and encouraged members, especially those in leadership positions, to marry additional wives. A majority of the Latter-day Saints never lived the principle. The number of families involved varied by community; for example, 30 percent in St. George in 1870 and 40 percent in 1880 practiced polygamy, while only 5 percent in South Weber practiced the principle in 1880. Rather than the harems often suggested in non-Mormon sources, most Mormon husbands married only two wives. The wives usually lived in separate homes and had direct responsibility for their children. Where the wives lived near each other, the husbands usually visited each wife on a daily or weekly basis. While there were the expected troubles between wives and families, polygamy was usually not the only cause, although it certainly could cause greater tension.
    [Show full text]
  • Wayward Saints: the Godbeites and Brigham Young Ronald W. Walker
    BYU Studies Quarterly Volume 39 Issue 1 Article 10 1-1-2000 Wayward Saints: The Godbeites and Brigham Young Ronald W. Walker Dean L. May Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq Part of the Mormon Studies Commons, and the Religious Education Commons Recommended Citation May, Dean L. (2000) "Wayward Saints: The Godbeites and Brigham Young Ronald W. Walker," BYU Studies Quarterly: Vol. 39 : Iss. 1 , Article 10. Available at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol39/iss1/10 This Book Review is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in BYU Studies Quarterly by an authorized editor of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected]. May: <em>Wayward Saints: The Godbeites and Brigham Young</em> Ronald W book reviews RONALD W WALKER foreword by jan shipps wayward saints the Godgodbeitesbeites and brigham young urbana university of illinois press 1998 399 appp illustrations bibliography notes index hardback 4995499549.95 paper- back 2500250025.00 reviewed by dean L may the Godgodbeitesbeites were a group of mormon dissenters mostly of british birth who in the 1870si8yos took strong exception to the communal economic policies of brigham young and other leaders of the church so outspoken was their criticism that most were eventually excommunicated several after becoming attached to spiritualism this belief apparently served as a surrogate for the excitement and zeal that they had experienced as new
    [Show full text]
  • The Secret Mormon Meetings of 1922
    University of Nevada, Reno THE SECRET MORMON MEETINGS OF 1922 A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in History By Shannon Caldwell Montez C. Elizabeth Raymond, Ph.D. / Thesis Advisor December 2019 Copyright by Shannon Caldwell Montez 2019 All Rights Reserved UNIVERSITY OF NEVADA RENO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL We recommend that the thesis prepared under our supervision by SHANNON CALDWELL MONTEZ entitled The Secret Mormon Meetings of 1922 be accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS C. Elizabeth Raymond, Ph.D., Advisor Cameron B. Strang, Ph.D., Committee Member Greta E. de Jong, Ph.D., Committee Member Erin E. Stiles, Ph.D., Graduate School Representative David W. Zeh, Ph.D., Dean, Graduate School December 2019 i Abstract B. H. Roberts presented information to the leadership of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in January of 1922 that fundamentally challenged the entire premise of their religious beliefs. New research shows that in addition to church leadership, this information was also presented during the neXt few months to a select group of highly educated Mormon men and women outside of church hierarchy. This group represented many aspects of Mormon belief, different areas of eXpertise, and varying approaches to dealing with challenging information. Their stories create a beautiful tapestry of Mormon life in the transition years from polygamy, frontier life, and resistance to statehood, assimilation, and respectability. A study of the people involved illuminates an important, overlooked, underappreciated, and eXciting period of Mormon history.
    [Show full text]
  • “They Are of Ancient Date”: Jaredite Traditions and the Politics of Gadianton's Dissent
    Brigham Young University BYU ScholarsArchive Faculty Publications 2020-8 “They Are of Ancient Date”: Jaredite Traditions and the Politics of Gadianton’s Dissent Dan Belnap Brigham Young University, [email protected] Daniel L. Belnap Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/facpub Part of the Mormon Studies Commons BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Belnap, Dan and Belnap, Daniel L., "“They Are of Ancient Date”: Jaredite Traditions and the Politics of Gadianton’s Dissent" (2020). Faculty Publications. 4479. https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/facpub/4479 This Book Chapter is brought to you for free and open access by BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. ILLUMINATING THE RECORDS Edited by Daniel L. Belnap Published by the Religious Studies Center, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah, in cooper- ation with Deseret Book Company, Salt Lake City. Visit us at rsc.byu.edu. © 2020 by Brigham Young University. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America by Sheridan Books, Inc. DESERET BOOK is a registered trademark of Deseret Book Company. Visit us at DeseretBook.com. Any uses of this material beyond those allowed by the exemptions in US copyright law, such as section 107, “Fair Use,” and section 108, “Library Copying,” require the written permission of the publisher, Religious Studies Center, 185 HGB, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah 84602. The views expressed herein are the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent the position of Brigham Young University or the Religious Studies Center.
    [Show full text]
  • Mormon Classification Schedules
    Mormon Classification Schedules Harold B. Lee Library Provo, Utah Revised 2019 Devised by Naoma Rich and Chad Flake From the work of Robert Divett Enlarged and edited by the Committee on Mormon Classification of the Utah Library Association, 1959 Modified for use with the Library of Congress Classification Schedules at Brigham Young University, 1977 Revised, reformatted, and with a new index by Dale Swensen, 1997 Updated by Dale Swensen, 2009 Updated by Kayla Willey, 2013 Updated by Kayla Willey, 2019 First published 1959 Second edition 1962 Revised and reformatted with new index 1997 Updated 2009 Updated 2013 Updated 2019 CONTENTS Preface ............................................................................................................................................. v Synopsis ........................................................................................................................................ vii Outline ........................................................................................................................................... ix BX8600 (Mormon Church) ..............................................................................................................1 Index to BX8600+ ..........................................................................................................................31 Index to Mormon Sects ..................................................................................................................38 Appendix 1: BYU Policy on classification of biography,
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix 1 Andrew Jenson, Mormon Encyclopedist Davis Bitton and Leonard J
    Appendix 1 Andrew Jenson, Mormon Encyclopedist Davis Bitton and Leonard J. Arrington In November 1876, shortly after the appearance of Edward Tullidge’s zealous collector of historical records, faithful diarist, and author of Life of Brigham Young; Or, Utah and Her Founders, a twenty-six-year- more than five thousand published biographical sketches. Jenson may old Danish settler in Pleasant Grove, Utah, wrote to Daniel H. Wells, have contributed more to preserving the factual details of Latter-day a close adviser to Brigham Young. Hopeful that he would not have to Saint history than any other person; at least for sheer quantity, his spend the rest of his life as a manual laborer, the young man asked if projects will likely remain unsurpassed. Jenson’s industry, persistence, he might have permission to prepare and publish a history of Joseph and dogged determination in the face of rebuffs and disappointments Smith in the Danish language. Wells replied that he had “no hesi- have caused every subsequent Mormon historian to be indebted to him. tancy” in approving the proposal but doubted that the project, although Andreas Jensen was born in 1850 in the country village of Damgren, worthwhile, would be financially remunerative. The young immigrant in Torslev Parish, Hjørring County, Jutland, Denmark, the second son arranged his affairs at home, began the work of translating and writing, of Danish peasants.1 When Andreas was four, his parents were visited and canvassed for subscribers. by Mormon missionaries in Denmark and converted. Andreas and his Thus began the historical labors of Andrew Jenson, who for the older brother, Jens, who were subjected to harassment at school because next sixty-five years worked prodigiously in the cause of Mormon his- 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Vol. 20 Num. 2 the FARMS Review
    Review of Books on the Book of Mormon 1989–2011 Volume 20 Number 2 Article 17 2008 Vol. 20 Num. 2 The FARMS Review FARMS Review Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/msr BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Review, FARMS (2008) "Vol. 20 Num. 2 The FARMS Review," Review of Books on the Book of Mormon 1989–2011: Vol. 20 : No. 2 , Article 17. Available at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/msr/vol20/iss2/17 This Full Issue is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Review of Books on the Book of Mormon 1989–2011 by an authorized editor of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. The FARMS Review The FARMS Review Editor Daniel C. Peterson Associate Editors Louis C. Midgley George L. Mitton Production Editors Don L. Brugger Larry E. Morris Cover Design Andrew D. Livingston Layout Alison Coutts Jacob D. Rawlins The Neal A. Maxwell Institute for Religious Scholarship Executive Director M. Gerald Bradford Director, FARMS Paul Y. Hoskisson Director, METI Daniel C. Peterson Director, CPART Kristian Heal Director, Publications Alison Coutts The FARMS Review Volume 20 • Number 2 • 2008 ! The Neal A. Maxwell Institute for Religious Scholarship Brigham Young University © 2008 Neal A. Maxwell Institute for Religious Scholarship Brigham Young University All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America ISSN 1550-3194 To Our Readers The Neal A. Maxwell Institute for Religious Scholar ship encour- ages and supports re search on the Book of Mormon, the Book of Abraham, the Bible, other ancient scripture, and related subjects.
    [Show full text]
  • Joseph F. Smith: the Father of Modern Mormonism a Thesis
    Joseph F. Smith: The Father of Modern Mormonism A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Humanities By Alexander Reid Harrison B.S., Brigham Young University Idaho, 2010 2014 Wright State University WRIGHT STATE UNIVERSITY GRADUATE SCHOOL Dec 13, 2013 I HEREBY RECOMMEND THAT THE THESIS PREPARED UNDER MY SUPERVISION BY Alexander Reid Harrison ENTITLED Joseph F Smith: The Father of Modern Mormonism BE ACCEPTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF Master of Humanities ____________________ Ava Chamberlain, Ph.D. Thesis Director Committee on ____________________ Final Examination Valerie L. Stoker, Ph.D. Director, Master of Humanities Program ____________________ Ava Chamberlain, Ph.D. ____________________ Jacob Dorn, Ph.D. ____________________ Nancy G. Garner, Ph.D. _____________________ Robert E. W. Fyffe, Ph.D. Vice President for Research and Dean of the Graduate School iii ABSTRACT Harrison, Alexander Reid. M.H. Department of Humanities, Wright State University, 2014. Joseph F. Smith: The Father of Modern Mormonism Joseph F. Smith (1838-1918) was the father of modern Mormonism. Nephew of the founding Prophet, President Joseph Smith Jr. (1805-1844), Joseph F. Smith was the sixth president of the Mormon Church. During his presidency (1901-1918), he redefined Mormonism. He helped change the perception of what a Mormon was, both inside and outside the faith. He did so by organizing the structure of the faith theologically, historically, ideologically, and institutionally. In doing this, he set the tone for what Mormonism would become, and set a standard paradigm for the world of what a Mormon is. Joseph F.
    [Show full text]
  • Brigham Young and the Massacre at Mountain Meadows
    Book Reviews 149 Book Reviews WILL BAGLEY. Blood of the Prophets: Brigham Young and the Massacre at Mountain Meadows. (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2002. xxiv + 493 pp. Illustrations, maps, appendix, notes, bibliography, index. $39.95 hardback.) Reviewed by W. Paul Reeve, assistant professor of history, Southern Virginia University, and Ardis E. Parshall, independent researcher, Orem, Utah. Explaining the violent slaughter of 120 men, women, and children at the hands of God-fearing Christian men—priesthood holders, no less, of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints—is no easy task. Biases per- meate the sources and fill the historical record with contradictions and polemics. Untangling the twisted web of self-serving testimony, journals, memoirs, government reports, and the like requires skill, forthrightness, integrity, and the utmost devotion to established standards of historical scholarship. Will Bagley, a journalist and independent historian with sever- al books on Latter-day Saint history to his credit, has recently tried his hand at unraveling the tale. Even though Bagley claims to be aware of “the basic rules of the craft of history” (xvi), he consistently violates them in Blood of the Prophets. As a result, Juanita Brooks’ The Mountain Meadows Massacre remains the most definitive and balanced account to date. Certainly there is no justification for the Mountain Meadows Massacre. Mormon men along with Paiute allies acted beyond the bounds of reason to murder the Fancher party, a group of California-bound emigrants from Arkansas passing through Utah in 1857. It is a horrific crime, one that Bagley correctly identifies as “the most violent incident in the history of America’s overland trails” (xiii), and it belongs to Utah and the Mormons.
    [Show full text]
  • Journal of Mormon History Vol. 22, No. 1, 1996
    Journal of Mormon History Volume 22 Issue 1 Article 1 1996 Journal of Mormon History Vol. 22, No. 1, 1996 Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/mormonhistory Part of the Religion Commons Recommended Citation (1996) "Journal of Mormon History Vol. 22, No. 1, 1996," Journal of Mormon History: Vol. 22 : Iss. 1 , Article 1. Available at: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/mormonhistory/vol22/iss1/1 This Full Issue is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at DigitalCommons@USU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Mormon History by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@USU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Journal of Mormon History Vol. 22, No. 1, 1996 Table of Contents CONTENTS ARTICLES PRESIDENTIAL ADDRESS • --The Emergence of Mormon Power since 1945 Mario S. De Pillis, 1 TANNER LECTURE • --The Mormon Nation and the American Empire D. W. Meinig, 33 • --Labor and the Construction of the Logan Temple, 1877-84 Noel A. Carmack, 52 • --From Men to Boys: LDS Aaronic Priesthood Offices, 1829-1996 William G. Hartley, 80 • --Ernest L. Wilkinson and the Office of Church Commissioner of Education Gary James Bergera, 137 • --Fanny Alger Smith Custer: Mormonism's First Plural Wife? Todd Compton, 174 REVIEWS --James B. Allen, Jessie L. Embry, Kahlile B. Mehr. Hearts Turned to the Fathers: A History of the Genealogical Society of Utah, 1894-1994 Raymonds. Wright, 208 --S. Kent Brown, Donald Q. Cannon, Richard H.Jackson, eds. Historical Atlas of Mormonism Lowell C. "Ben"Bennion, 212 --Spencer J. Palmer and Shirley H.
    [Show full text]
  • Lds Apologetics and the Battle for Mormon History
    CHRISTIAN RESEARCH INSTITUTE P.O. Box 8500, Charlotte, NC 28271 Feature Article: JAM502 LDS APOLOGETICS AND THE BATTLE FOR MORMON HISTORY by Bill McKeever and Eric Johnson This article first appeared in the Christian Research Journal, volume 28, number 1 (2005). For further information or to subscribe to the Christian Research Journal go to: http://www.equip.org SYNOPSIS Apologetics, historically, has not been a high priority for the leaders of the Mormon Church, but it has become more so in recent years. Thanks especially to the Internet, several Latter-day Saint (LDS, Mormon) apologetics groups have made it their business to actively defend the historicity of the Book of Mormon and the Book of Abraham as well as uphold the integrity of early Mormon leaders. The most prominent of these organizations is the Foundation for Ancient Research and Mormon Studies (FARMS), which became an entity of the Mormon Church during the past decade. Among the many authors whose works have been criticized by FARMS researchers are fellow Mormons Grant Palmer and D. Michael Quinn, both of whom hold views on LDS scripture and history that are contrary to the position of the LDS establishment. The issue, then, centers on whether or not the history as propagated by LDS Church leaders is accurate. If it is not, then the average Mormon who wishes to keep his or her faith must spiritualize significant parts of Mormon history, from the notion that LDS founder Joseph Smith, Jr., had the ability to translate ancient texts to the very idea that there were ever Nephites and Lamanites on the American continent.
    [Show full text]
  • A Third Jaredite Record: the Sealed Portion of the Gold Plates
    Journal of Book of Mormon Studies Volume 11 Number 1 Article 10 7-31-2002 A Third Jaredite Record: The Sealed Portion of the Gold Plates Valentin Arts Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/jbms BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Arts, Valentin (2002) "A Third Jaredite Record: The Sealed Portion of the Gold Plates," Journal of Book of Mormon Studies: Vol. 11 : No. 1 , Article 10. Available at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/jbms/vol11/iss1/10 This Feature Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Book of Mormon Studies by an authorized editor of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. Title A Third Jaredite Record: The Sealed Portion of the Gold Plates Author(s) Valentin Arts Reference Journal of Book of Mormon Studies 11/1 (2002): 50–59, 110–11. ISSN 1065-9366 (print), 2168-3158 (online) Abstract In the Book of Mormon, two records (a large engraved stone and twenty-four gold plates) contain the story of an ancient civilization known as the Jaredites. There appears to be evidence of an unpublished third record that provides more information on this people and on the history of the world. When the brother of Jared received a vision of Jesus Christ, he was taught many things but was instructed not to share them with the world until the time of his death. The author proposes that the brother of Jared did, in fact, write those things down shortly before his death and then buried them, along with the interpreting stones, to be revealed to the world according to the timing of the Lord.
    [Show full text]