Introduction to Quantum Hall Effects
MarkMark OliverOliver GoerbigGoerbig
EMFL Summer School “Science in High Magnetic Fields”, Arles, 29/09/2018 Reminder: ClassicalClassical Hall effect (1879)
(Quantum) Hall system: 2D electrons in a (perp.) Magnetic field B
Hall resistance: obtained from stationary equation of motion (Drude model)
Resistivity and conductivity
From Drude model: Cyclotron frequency :
Drude conductivity :
Resistivity and conductivity
From Drude model: Cyclotron frequency :
Drude conductivity :
Ohm’s law: current density:
→ resistivity/conductivity tensor:
Resistivity and conductivity
From Drude model: Cyclotron frequency :
Drude conductivity :
Ohm’s law: current density:
→ resistivity/conductivity tensor:
Link with mobility :
Hall resistivity: Shubnikov–de-Haas effect (1930) see A. Pourret’s class
Oscillations in longitudinallongitudinal resistance when
→ Einstein relation:
→ Landau quantization (into levels ): Quantum Hall effect (1980)
Signature of QHE:
→ plateau in
→ vanishing
quantized in terms of universal constant
→ use for metrology (resistance standard) Quantum Hall effect (1980)
Signature of QHE:
→ plateau in
→ vanishing
v. Klitzing (1985) Integral quantum Hall effect (IQHE, 1980)
Fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE, 1982) Laughlin; Störmer, Tsui (1998) Ways to understand the QHE
Ways to understand the QHE
SpoilerSpoiler AlertAlert
© The Big Bang Theory
Ways to understand the QHE
● LandauLandau quantizationquantization → energy of charged particles in a magnetic field is quantized into highly degenerate LandauLandau levelslevels
Ways to understand the QHE
● LandauLandau quantizationquantization → energy of charged particles in a magnetic field is quantized into highly degenerate LandauLandau levelslevels ● FromFrom energyenergy quantizationquantization toto conductanceconductance quantizationquantization → every filled Landau level contributes to the conductance
Ways to understand the QHE
● LandauLandau quantizationquantization → energy of charged particles in a magnetic field is quantized into highly degenerate LandauLandau levelslevels ● FromFrom energyenergy quantizationquantization toto conductanceconductance quantizationquantization → every filled Landau level contributes to the conductance → sample edges are conductanceconductance channelschannels → additional electrons in partially filled Landau levels get localizedlocalized byby impuritiesimpurities and do not contribute to the electronic transport References and further reading
● M. O. Goerbig, QuantumQuantum HallHall EffectsEffects, Les Houches Summer School (2009), chapterschapters 1-31-3 http://arxiv.org/abs/0909.1998 ● S. M. Girvin, TheThe QuantumQuantum HallHall Effect:Effect: NovelNovel ExcitationsExcitations andand BrokenBroken SymmetriesSymmetries, Les Houches Summer School (1998) http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9907002
● G. Murthy and R. Shankar, Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 1101 (2003) http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0205326 ● D. Yoshioka, TheThe QuantumQuantum HallHall EffectEffect, Springer, Berlin (2002)
Ways to understand the QHE
● LandauLandau quantizationquantization → energy of charged particles in a magnetic field is quantized into highly degenerate LandauLandau levelslevels ● FromFrom energyenergy quantizationquantization toto conductanceconductance quantizationquantization → every filled Landau level contributes to the conductance → sample edges are conductanceconductance channelschannels → additional electrons in partially filled Landau levels get localizedlocalized byby impuritiesimpurities and do not contribute to the electronic transport Landau quantization (“quick and dirty” approach)
Circular trajectories of electrons in a magnetic Field (cyclotron motion)
→ Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization (see D. Basko’s class)
(single-valuedness of wave function)
Landau quantization (“quick and dirty” approach)
Circular trajectories of electrons in a magnetic Field (cyclotron motion)
→ Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization (see D. Basko’s class)
(single-valuedness of wave function)
→ Quantization of cyclotron radius:
weird stuff integer integer (related to Berry phase)
magnetic length Landau quantization (“quick and dirty” approach)
Circular trajectories of electrons in a magnetic Field (cyclotron motion)
→ Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization (see D. Basko’s class)
(single-valuedness of wave function)
→ Quantization of cyclotron radius:
→ Quantization of energy: weird stuff (related to Berry phase)
here: Landau level quantization (canonical)
1.) Hamiltonian of electrons in a lattice:
latticelattice momentummomentum
Landau level quantization (canonical)
1.) Hamiltonian of electrons in a lattice:
latticelattice momentummomentum → Example 1: electrons in the vicinity of a band minimum (e.g. GaAs)
band mass
Landau level quantization (canonical)
1.) Hamiltonian of electrons in a lattice:
latticelattice momentummomentum → Example 1: electrons in the vicinity of a band minimum (e.g. GaAs)
band mass
→ Example 2: electrons in graphene/2D boron nitride or transition-metal dichalcogenides (“gapped graphene”)
E k y EF
kx Landau level quantization (canonical)
1.) Hamiltonian of electrons in a lattice:
latticelattice momentummomentum
2.) Presence of a magnetic field (→ Peierls substitution)
with
gauge-invariant not gauge-invariant
Landau level quantization (canonical)
1.) Hamiltonian of electrons in a lattice:
latticelattice momentummomentum
2.) Presence of a magnetic field (→ Peierls substitution)
with
3.) Quantum mechanics:
yields non-commuting components of
Landau level quantization (canonical)
Quantum mechanics of electrons in a magnetic field:
and
Landau level quantization (canonical)
Quantum mechanics of electrons in a magnetic field:
and
Remarks:
● Result is gauge-invariant (i.e. depends only on not on )
● and are conjugate q.m. variables
→ introduction of “harmonic-oscillator” ladder operators
with
Example 1: Landau levels
Parabolic band:
Equidistant energy (Landau) levels:
“weird” offset 2 arises naturally from commutator
Example 2: Landau levels (graphene)
Landau levels of graphene:
~
band index 2
Example 2: Landau levels (graphene)
Landau levels of graphene:
“weird offset” 2
Example 2: Landau levels (gapped graphene)
Landau levels of gapped graphene:
Example 2: Landau levels (gapped graphene)
Landau levels of gapped graphene:
“Dirac mass” weird offset !!! Example 2: Landau levels (gapped graphene)
Landau levels of gapped graphene:
“parity anomaly”:
does not disperse with magnetic field ! Unveiling Landau levels: magneto- optical spectroscopy (→graphene)
see D. Basko’s class
Landau-level degeneracy
Origin:
- translation invariance
→ energy does not depend on center of cyclotron motion
Landau-level degeneracy
Origin:
- translation invariance
→ energy does not depend on center of cyclotron motion decomposition of position:
: cyclotron coordinate (dynamics)
Landau-level degeneracy
Quantum mechanics:
BUT: → Heisenberg uncertainty: Landau-level degeneracy
→ Heisenberg uncertainty:
Consequences:
● Each quantum state occupies minimal surface
● Number of states per Landau level:
total surface → number of flux quanta threading system
Landau-level degeneracy
→ Heisenberg uncertainty:
Consequences:
● Each quantum state occupies minimal surface
● Number of states per Landau level:
● Filling factor:
Landau-level degeneracy
→ Heisenberg uncertainty:
Consequences:
● Each quantum state occupies minimal surface
● Number of states per Landau level:
● Filling factor:
● Quantum states characterized by two orbital quantum numbers
internal degrees of freedom (spin, valley,...) Landau-level quantum number guiding center (Landau site)
Ways to understand the QHE
● LandauLandau quantizationquantization → energy of charged particles in a magnetic field is quantized into highly degenerate LandauLandau levelslevels ● FromFrom energyenergy quantizationquantization toto conductanceconductance quantizationquantization → every filled Landau level contributes to the conductance → sample edges are conductanceconductance channelschannels → additional electrons in partially filled Landau levels get localizedlocalized byby impuritiesimpurities and do not contribute to the electronic transport Quantum Hall electrons in electrostatic potential
sample edges charged impurities
→ potential lifts Landau-level degeneracy
→ good approximation for
Quantum Hall electrons in electrostatic potential
sample edges charged impurities
→ potential lifts Landau-level degeneracy
Heisenberg equations of motion:
Quantum Hall electrons in electrostatic potential
sample edges charged impurities
→ potential lifts Landau-level degeneracy
Heisenberg equations of motion:
→ guiding centers follow equipotential lines (semiclassics) Quantum Hall electrons in electrostatic potential
sample edges
→→ extendedextended statesstates ~~ conductionconduction channelschannels
charged impurities
→ guiding centers follow equipotential lines (semiclassics) Quantum Hall electrons in electrostatic potential
sample edges
→→ extendedextended statesstates ~~ conductionconduction channelschannels
charged impurities →→ localizedlocalized statesstates ~~ electronselectrons trappedtrapped onon closedclosed equipotentialequipotential lineslines aroundaround potentialpotential valleys/hillsvalleys/hills
→ guiding centers follow equipotential lines (semiclassics) Edge states
Four-terminal resistance measurement
constance of chemical potential :
no electron leakage through the bulk !
Four-terminal resistance measurement
constance of chemical potential :
no electron leakage through the bulk !
non-zero, but why quantized ?
Conductance of a (single) Landau level
→ current of n-th LL from mesoscopic physics:
Conductance of a (single) Landau level
→ current of n-th LL from mesoscopic physics:
Put under the rug: → Landau gauge
→ good quantum number → determines position (guiding center): Conductance of a (single) Landau level
→ current of n-th LL from mesoscopic physics:
→ periodic boundary conditions:
Put under the rug: → Landau gauge
→ good quantum number → determines position (guiding center): Conductance of a (single) Landau level
→ current of n-th LL from mesoscopic physics:
→ periodic boundary conditions:
Conductance of a (single) Landau level
→ current from mesoscopic physics:
→ equilibration at edge:
: voltage drop between upper and lower edge Contribution of one Landau level to (Hall) conductance
Hall resistance of n Landau levels: IQHE – one-particle localization
IQHE – one-particle localization
IQHE – one-particle localization
Localization and percolation picture tested in experiment
Quantum Hall effect in graphene Zhang et al., Nature (2005)
Ramifications of IQHE
Topological insulators (1980→2007)
Science,766, 318 (2007), Würzburg group
TopologicalTopological insulatorinsulator == BulkBulk insulatorinsulator ++ ConductingConducting edgesedges (surfaces)(surfaces)
Quantum Hall effect Quantum spin Hall effect
all states move in the same spin up and spin down states direction move in opposite directions (chiral edge states) (helical edge states) Quantized transport in QSHE
CdTe/HgTe quantum wells [Roth et al., Science 2009]
Quantized transport in QSHE
CdTe/HgTe quantum wells [Roth et al., Science 2009]
Towards the fractional quantum Hall effect
fractional filling factor
→→ electronicelectronic correlationscorrelations atat originorigin ofof thethe effecteffect Correlations in Landau levels
Possible excitations in Possible excitations in completely filled LLs partially filled LLs
weak correlations (perturbation) strong correlations (~ flat bands) → collective (plasmon-type) excitations → quantum Hall ferromagnets → fractional quantum Hall effects Multi-component quantum Hall systems
Quantum Hall ferromagnetism
SkyrmionsSkyrmions
● collective effect ● no Zeeman effect required topological charge here: generally: Conclusions
● LandauLandau quantizationquantization → energy of charged particles in a magnetic field is quantized into highly degenerate LandauLandau levelslevels ● FromFrom energyenergy quantizationquantization toto conductanceconductance quantizationquantization → every filled Landau level contributes to the conductance → sample edges are conductanceconductance channelschannels → additional electrons in partially filled Landau levels get localizedlocalized byby impuritiesimpurities and do not contribute to the electronic transport ● IQHE = prototype of topologicaltopological insulatorinsulator ● Correlations in Landau levels (~flat bands): FQHE,FQHE, QHQH ferromagnetismferromagnetism (in multicomponent QH systems) Additional slides
Light-matter coupling
Magneto-optical selection rules in 2D TMDC
Reminder: Schrödinger vs. Dirac
Landau levels MOG, Montambaux, Piéchon, EPL (2014)
Landau levels
A measure of DiracnessDiracness MOG, Montambaux, Piéchon, EPL (2014)