DOCSLIB.ORG

The Rhetoric of Poetry Contests and Competition

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Rhetoric of Poetry Contests and Competition Georgia State University ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University English Dissertations Department of English 8-7-2007 Winning, Losing, and Changing the Rules: The Rhetoric of Poetry Contests and Competition Marc Pietrzykowski Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/english_diss Part of the English Language and Literature Commons Recommended Citation Pietrzykowski, Marc, "Winning, Losing, and Changing the Rules: The Rhetoric of Poetry Contests and Competition." Dissertation, Georgia State University, 2007. https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/english_diss/21 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of English at ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. It has been accepted for inclusion in English Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 1 Winning, Losing, and Changing the Rules: The Rhetoric of Poetry Contest and Competition by Marc Pietrzykowski Under the Direction of Dr. George Pullman ABSTRACT This dissertation attempts to trace the shifting relationship between the fields of Rhetoric and Poetry in Western culture by focusing on poetry contests and competitions during several different historical eras. In order to examine how the distinction between the two fields is contingent on a variety of local factors, this study makes use of research in contemporary cognitive neuroscience, particularly work in categorization and cognitive linguistics, to emphasize the provisional nature of conceptual thought; that is, on the type of mental activity that gives rise to conceptualizations such as “Rhetoric” and “Poetry.” The final portions of the research attempt to use some modeling techniques derived from cognitive linguistics as invention strategies for producing stylistically idiosyncratic academic knowledge, and for examining the relationship between the stylistic markers we associate with each of the two aforementioned fields. INDEX WORDS: Dissertation, Rhetoric, Composition, Poetry, Poetics, Contest, Debate, Competition, Stylistics, Cognitive Linguistics, Conceptual Blending, Cognitive Science, Categorization, History. 1 Winning, Losing, and Changing the Rules: The Rhetoric of Poetry Contest and Competition by Marc Pietrzykowski A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy In the College of Arts and Sciences Georgia State University 2007 1 Copyright by Marc Pietrzykowski 2007 2 Winning, Losing, and Changing the Rules: The Rhetoric of Poetry Contest and Competition by Marc Pietrzykowski Major Professor: Dr. George Pullman Committee: Dr. Marti Singer Dr. Lyneé Gaillet Electronic Version Approved: Office of Graduate Studies College of Arts and Sciences Georgia State University August 2007 iv3 This dissertation is dedicated to my wife. v4 TABLE OF CONTENTS TITLE PAGE.......................................................................................................................... i COPYRIGHT PAGE ............................................................................................................. ii APPROVAL PAGE.............................................................................................................. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS...................................................................................................... iv LIST OF FIGURES ................................................................................................................v CHAPTERS 1. Preface.........................................................................................................................1 2. Introduction...............................................................................................................12 3. Poetic Contest and Competition in Ancient Greece .................................................37 4. Poetic Contest in the Second Sophistic.....................................................................68 5. Poetic Contest and the Augustan Age.....................................................................100 6. The Romantic Movement in English Poetry, or, Is There Any Good Way to Argue Against Self-Love? .................................................................................................130 7. Jackals Snarling Over a Dried-up Well, or, Contemporary Poetry in the U.S. ......151 8. The Narrow Road to Nowhere, or, My Journey Across A Kitchen Table Full of Rhetoric and Composition..................................................................................189 9. Postscript...................................................................................................................217 WORKS CITED .................................................................................................................222 vi 5 LIST OF FIGURES Fig. 1: The Wine-Dark Sea ......................................................................................................37 Fig 2.: Rhapsodic Victory........................................................................................................41 Fig 3.: Man is the Dream of a Shadow ....................................................................................50 Fig. 4: The Showpiece Orator..................................................................................................71 Fig. 5: A Neural Circuit ...........................................................................................................91 Fig. 6: Accentual-Syllabic Meter...........................................................................................103 Fig. 7: Romanticism as a Blend .............................................................................................134 Fig. 8: An Academic Haibun .................................................................................................200 1 Preface In reviewing some other recent dissertations published in the field of Rhetoric and Composition (Boozer, Ferstle, Kemp, Marquez, Stahlnecker, Vie, et. al.), I found that most of them began with a story of some kind. These stories were sometimes personal (Boozer, Ferstle, Marquez, Stahlnecker), sometimes cited from other sources (Kemp) and still others were journalistic (Vie), but all appeared to serve the same function: to set the “scene” for the reader, much as playwright might describe the setting of a scene before the characters are introduced, except that the “characters” in a dissertation are ideas. And as is the case with a play, if the scene is not well- established before the action begins, the audience will struggle to understand why the characters are speaking and behaving the way they are. So, my own story begins this way: I am a student in the PhD program at Georgia State University in Atlanta, GA, I have written a dissertation, and I would like to introduce the audience to its main characters. Rhetoric and Poetics My first goal in writing a dissertation is to prove a mastery of the sort of scholarly tools a successful PhD candidate will use: research, writing, analysis and interpretation, and knowledge of the discipline. The discipline I am part of, Rhetoric and Composition, is a comparatively new one, having only existed formally since the first meeting of the Conference of College 2 Composition and Communication in 1949 1, but which also has established itself as part of the significantly longer tradition of the discipline of Rhetoric. Part of the ongoing process of disciplinary definition thus involves doing historical research, and my dissertation is, for the most part, a historical study of the field. I have chosen to study a particular aspect of this history that is, I believe, largely under-examined at this point: the shifting role played by Poetics, which was considered one of the sub-disciplines of Rhetoric until fairly recently. Part of the process of disciplinary definition that Rhetoric and Composition has undergone within English Departments has included avoiding subject matter that other English scholars address, such as Literature and, to a lesser extent, Creative Writing 2. Given departmental politics and the general need to get along with co-workers, keeping to one’s scholarly “turf” makes a great deal of sense, but it also can lead to scholarship that is specialized to the point of solipsism; also, in as much as Rhetoric and Composition is concerned with writing, disallowing research into a significant aspect of written production—that is, the production of poetic effect in writing—does a disservice to the subject, to the discipline, and, as I hope to argue, to English Studies in general. Each of the different disciplinary areas within English studies brings different ways of constructing knowledge to the field, and I believe that increased collaboration between all three is necessary if English studies is to thrive and not be reduced to a service department for other disciplines. In my dissertation, then, I hope to explore some of the ways that the relationship between Rhetoric and Poetics has been conceptualized in the Western tradition, and I also hope to illustrate how different stylistic and organizational strategies in academic research can affect the way knowledge is constructed by using some of these strategies in my research. For example, the 1 Formal authorization occurred during the National Council of Teachers of English conference that year. 2 See Bishop, Bizzarro, Ingham, Mayers et. al. Also, Maureen Goggin has written a useful
Load more

Recommended publications
  • What Is Rhetoric?
    What is Rhetoric? Rhetoric – the art of persuading someone through your speech and writing. It is a discourse (form of communication) that aims to improve the capability of writers or speakers to inform, persuade, or motivate a particular audience in certain situations. Origin – ancient Greece became the birthplace of rhetoric (effective speech/writing) in the fifth century B.C. Even Plato, Socrates, and Aristotle were arms deep in theories on the most effective means of persuasion. Examples Martin Luther King, Jr. – “I Have a Dream” Abraham Lincoln – “Gettysburg Address” There are many more famous speakers who use rhetoric. Can you think of other examples? Why is rhetoric in writing so important? Writing more effectively saves time. Things to Consider Audience – Who are you writing to? Purpose – Why are you writing this? What’s the point? Adjust your voice, tone, and persona to accommodate your communication situation. For every writing project, you can best determine what you want to say and how you want to say it by analyzing your rhetorical situation (which is sometimes called your communication situation). Learning to think rhetorically is one of the most important benefits of education! Successful leaders and decision makers are capable of making good decisions because they have learned to examine problems from a rhetorical perspective. Successful writers have learned they can write a more effective document in less time by thinking rhetorically. By simply thinking rhetorically, someone can utilize many mental activities – such as focusing on identifying the needs of a particular audience or situation. Ask yourself: Who’s going to read this? In what way can I persuade my audience? .
    [Show full text]
  • University Interscholastic League Literary Criticism Contest • Invitational a • 2021
    University Interscholastic League Literary Criticism Contest • Invitational A • 2021 Part 1: Knowledge of Literary Terms and of Literary History 30 items (1 point each) 1. A line of verse consisting of five feet that char- 6. The repetition of initial consonant sounds or any acterizes serious English language verse since vowel sounds in successive or closely associated Chaucer's time is known as syllables is recognized as A) hexameter. A) alliteration. B) pentameter. B) assonance. C) pentastich. C) consonance. D) tetralogy. D) resonance. E) tetrameter. E) sigmatism. 2. The trope, one of Kenneth Burke's four master 7. In Greek mythology, not among the nine daugh- tropes, in which a part signifies the whole or the ters of Mnemosyne and Zeus, known collectively whole signifies the part is called as the Muses, is A) chiasmus. A) Calliope. B) hyperbole. B) Erato. C) litotes. C) Polyhymnia. D) synecdoche. D) Urania. E) zeugma. E) Zoe. 3. Considered by some to be the most important Irish 8. A chronicle, usually autobiographical, presenting poet since William Butler Yeats, the poet and cele- the life story of a rascal of low degree engaged brated translator of the Old English folk epic Beo- in menial tasks and making his living more wulf who was awarded the 1995 Nobel Prize for through his wit than his industry, and tending to Literature is be episodic and structureless, is known as a (n) A) Samuel Beckett. A) epistolary novel. B) Seamus Heaney. B) novel of character. C) C. S. Lewis. C) novel of manners. D) Spike Milligan. D) novel of the soil.
    [Show full text]
  • Ockham's Razor and Chemistry
    Ockham’s Razor and Chemistry * Roald Hoffmann, Vladimir I. Minkin, Barry K. Carpenter Abstract: We begin by presenting William of Ockham’s various formulations of his principle of parsimony, Ockham’s Razor. We then define a reaction mechanism and tell a personal story of how Ockham’s Razor entered the study of one such mechanism. A small history of methodologies related to Ock- ham’s Razor, least action and least motion, follows. This is all done in the context of the chemical (and scientific) community’s almost unthinking accep- tance of the principle as heuristically valuable. Which is not matched, to put it mildly, by current philosophical attitudes toward Ockham’s Razor. What ensues is a dialogue, pro and con. We first present a context for questioning, within chemistry, the fundamental assumption that underlies Ockham’s Ra- zor, namely that the world is simple. Then we argue that in more than one pragmatic way the Razor proves useful, without at all assuming a simple world. Ockham’s Razor is an instruction in an operating manual, not a world view. Continuing the argument, we look at the multiplicity and continuity of con- certed reaction mechanisms, and at principal component and Bayesian analysis (two ways in which Ockham’s Razor is embedded into modern statistics). The dangers to the chemical imagination from a rigid adherence to an Ockham’s Razor perspective, and the benefits of the use of this venerable and practical principle are given, we hope, their due. Keywords: Ockham’s Razor , reaction mechanism , principle of least action , prin- ciple of least motion , principal component analysis , Bayesian analysis .
    [Show full text]
  • WORDSWORTH's GOTHIC POETICS by ROBERT J. LANG a Thesis
    WORDSWORTH’S GOTHIC POETICS BY ROBERT J. LANG A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of WAKE FOREST UNIVERSITY GRADUATE SCHOOL OF ARTS AND SCIENCES in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS English December 2012 Winston-Salem, North Carolina Approved By: Eric Wilson, Ph.D., Advisor Philip Kuberski, Ph.D., Chair Omaar Hena, Ph.D. TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT ....................................................................................................................... iii CHAPTER 1 ........................................................................................................................1 CHAPTER 2 ........................................................................................................................8 CHAPTER 3 ......................................................................................................................27 CHAPTER 4 ......................................................................................................................45 CONCLUSION ..................................................................................................................65 WORKS CITED ................................................................................................................70 VITA ..................................................................................................................................75 ii ABSTRACT Wordsworth’s poetry is typically seen by critics as healthy-minded, rich in themes of transcendence, synthesis,
    [Show full text]
  • Poetry Vocabulary
    Poetry Vocabulary Alliteration: Definition: •The repetition of consonant sounds in words that are close together. •Example: •Peter Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers. How many pickled peppers did Peter Piper pick? Assonance: Definition: •The repetition of vowel sounds in words that are close together. •Example: •And so, all the night-tide, I lie down by the side Of my darling, my darling, my life and my bride. -Edgar Allen Poe, from “Annabel Lee” Ballad: Definition: •A song or songlike poem that tells a story. •Examples: •“The Dying Cowboy” • “The Cremation of Sam McGee” Cinquain: Definition: • A five-line poem in which each line follows a rule. 1. A word for the subject of the poem. 2. Two words that describe it. 3. Three words that show action. 4. Four words that show feeling. 5. The subject word again-or another word for it. End rhyme: Definition: • Rhymes at the ends of lines. • Example: – “I have to speak-I must-I should -I ought… I’d tell you how I love you if I thought The world would end tomorrow afternoon. But short of that…well, it might be too soon.” The end rhymes are ought, thought and afternoon, soon. Epic: Definition: • A long narrative poem that is written in heightened language and tells stories of the deeds of a heroic character who embodies that values of a society. • Example: – “Casey at the Bat” – “Beowulf” Figurative language: Definition: • An expressive use of language. • Example: – Simile – Metaphor Form: Definition: • The structure and organization of a poem. Free verse: Definition: • Poetry without a regular meter or rhyme scheme.
    [Show full text]
  • Henryson's Fables: "The Subtell Dyte of Poetry" Gregory Kratzmann
    Studies in Scottish Literature Volume 20 | Issue 1 Article 6 1985 Henryson's Fables: "the subtell dyte of poetry" Gregory Kratzmann Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.sc.edu/ssl Part of the English Language and Literature Commons Recommended Citation Kratzmann, Gregory (1985) "Henryson's Fables: "the subtell dyte of poetry"," Studies in Scottish Literature: Vol. 20: Iss. 1. Available at: https://scholarcommons.sc.edu/ssl/vol20/iss1/6 This Article is brought to you by the Scottish Literature Collections at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Studies in Scottish Literature by an authorized editor of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Gregory Kratzmann Henryson's Fables: "the subtell dyte of poetry" Henryson's Fables were once discussed almost exclusively as documents of social realism, or as humorous poems which at their best might be designated "Chaucerian." In an important article in 1962, Denton Fox urged "that it might be helpful to look at the Fables from a more severely literary viewpoint, and to examine them as poems"; further, he pleaded the necessity to examine the poems "as wholes," that is, as fables consisting of two carefully related parts, story and moralization.1 Although there has been some stimulating criticism of the Fables during the past twenty years, commentary has been neither as prolific nor as wide-ranging as that directed at The Testament of Cresseid, and there is room for more discussion of those two closely-related critical issues raised in Fox's article. This essay has two concerns.
    [Show full text]
  • Westmoreland Arts & Heritage Festival 2021 Poetry & Short Story Contest
    47th Westmoreland Arts & Heritage Festival 2021 Poetry & Short Story Contest July 1, 2, 3, & 4 Postmark Deadline: April 16, 2021 Eligibility Rules Only previously unpublished works will be considered. All work Please send two (2) copies of each entry. All entries must be typed on must be original, not having been entered in any previous Poetry 8 1/2” x 11” paper. & Short Story Contest sponsored by the Westmoreland Arts & Short Stories - Stories are to be double spaced and typed on one side Heritage Festival. Poems and short stories must be 4,000 words or of the paper only. Do not staple or connect pages. Include page less. Each author may enter one story; each poet may enter two number and title of story in the top right corner of each page. Include poems. All genres will be accepted. a cover sheet that shows your full name, address, title of story, and number of words. Entry Fee Poems - Do not put your name on the poem(s). Include page number Poetry entry fee is $10 for up to two (2) poems. Short Story entry and title of poem in the top right corner of each page. Include a cover fee is $10 for one (1) short story. Submit an entry in both sheet that shows your full name, address, title of poem, and number categories for a $20 entry fee. International entries must use of words. PayPal. All other entries may pay by check, made payable to WAHF No short story or poem will be returned. Winning entries may be or by credit card (Visa, MasterCard, or Discover).
    [Show full text]
  • Dear AP Literature Students
    Dear AP Literature Students: Welcome! I’m excited to meet you in the fall and to revel in the amazing reading! Before you return to school in August, please complete the following work to get our conversation started: 1. Carefully read and annotate All the Pretty Horses by Cormac McCarthy and Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro. When you read McCarthy, I would recommend bookmarking this page as it provides translations of the Spanish: http://cormacmccarthy.cookingwithmarty.com/wp- content/uploads/ATPHTrans.pdf. 2. Next, watch the animated film Persepolis (based on the graphic novel by Marjane Satrapi) and think about how it connects to our summer reading and why. You can rent it on Netflix or Amazon or possibly check it out at your local library. Yes, it is in French with subtitles J 3. Lastly, actively study the vocabulary lists "Literary Allusions" and "Literary Terms" (both in this packet). I would recommend not passively memorizing flashcards or a Quizlet, but instead using the words in your everyday conversations and in your writing to secure them in your memory and into your own personal lexicon! On the first day of AP week, you will be tested on the summer work. The test on the works of fiction will be primarily objective rather than interpretive, and it will include quotation identification, plot and setting points, and character descriptions. The test on the vocabulary will be matching. The point of the test is to ensure that you have read actively and studied the vocabulary so that you can use the works and words immediately.
    [Show full text]
  • Concrete Poetry Workbook
    SUMMER LEARNING CHALLENGE: READ WEEK 2: SHAPE ADVENTURE CONCRETE POETRY WORKBOOK To earn this week's READ Badge, use words to create shapes by crafting your own concrete poems. This fun activity guide will help you get started! WWW.SSF.NET/KIDS Concrete Poetry A concrete poem is also called a shape poem, because the words of the poem take the shape of the poem's subject. Concrete poems do not have to rhyme or follow any other poetic word pattern. The most important thing is that the words create a matching picture. Examples There are two ways to create concrete poetry. The first is called outline form. In this form, the words of the poem are used to outline or to fill in the shape of that object. Here are two examples: The second is to write in drawing form. In this form, the poet uses the words of the poem to create a scene. Here are two examples: Drawing Activity Experiment with these words, writing them in a way that portrays their meanings: Roller Coaster Explode Wavy Crowded Shrinking Poetry Worksheet Let's use an ice cream cone for inspiration. Take a look at this outline: Think of words that represent this image to you, and write them in the box below. You can describe feelings, objects, or activities. Circle your favorite words (the words you want to use in your poem). Write a Poem Using the words you just brainstormed, write your poem here. Don't try to make it into a shape yet; just focus on writing the words! _________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________
    [Show full text]
  • Enhancing the Students' Rhetoric Attainments in Teaching of College
    Sino-US English Teaching, July 2019, Vol. 16, No. 7, 300-305 doi:10.17265/1539-8072/2019.07.003 D DAVID PUBLISHING Enhancing the Students’ Rhetoric Attainments in Teaching of College English Intensive Reading ZHANG Rong-gen Shanghai Publishing and Printing College, Shanghai, China Beginning with various definitions of rhetoric, the paper gives a survey of some common English rhetoric figures found in College English intensive reading, such as metaphor, simile, transferred epithet, allusion, hyperbole, personification, metonymy, antithesis, onomatopoeia, double negative, inversion, rhetoric question, parady, transferred negation, and the like. By elaborating the functions of those rhetoric figures, the paper attempts to enhance the students’ rhetoric attainments and arouse their interest in learning English. Keywords: rhetoric attainments, rhetoric figures, College English teaching Introduction Some students often complain that the teaching of College English intensive reading course is so monotonous. It is really the case. How can a tasteless person feel his delicious food? And a certain rhetoric attainment is the prerequisite for the student to enjoy this “delicious food” of College English intensive reading course. The category of rhetoric is quite broad, one of which definitions is given by Aristotle as the art of public speaking by means of persuasion (Aristotle, 1954, pp. 2-12); and Hartwell extends the definition of rhetoric as the art of using words in speaking or writing (Hartwell & Bentley, 1982, pp. 1-15). That is to say, rhetoric contains both the art of public speaking and the method of composition. According to Chen Wangdao, a modern Chinese rhetorician, rhetoric includes both active rhetoric and passive rhetoric.
    [Show full text]
  • Occam's Razor in Science: a Case Study from Biogeography
    Biology and Philosophy (2007) 22:193–215 Ó Springer 2006 DOI 10.1007/s10539-006-9027-9 Occam’s Razor in science: a case study from biogeography A. BAKER Department of Philosophy, Swarthmore College, 500 College Avenue, Swarthmore, 19081, USA (e-mail: [email protected]) Received 22 June 2004; accepted 16 March 2006 Introduction There is a widespread philosophical presumption – deep-rooted and often unarticulated – that a theory whose ontology exceeds that of its competitors is at a prima facie disadvantage. This presumption that ontologically more parsi- monious theories are preferable appears in many guises. Often it remains im- plicit. Sometimes it is invoked as a primitive, self-evident proposition that cannot be further justified or elaborated upon (for example at the beginning of Good- man and Quine’s 1947 paper,1 and in Quine’s remarks about his taste for ‘‘clear skies’’ and ‘‘desert landscapes’’). Other times it is elevated to the status of a ‘‘Principle’’ and labeled as such (for example, the ‘‘Principle of Parsimony’’). However, perhaps it is best known by the name ‘‘Occam’s (or Ockham’s) Razor.’’ The question I wish to address in this paper is whether Occam’s Razor is a methodological principle of science. In addition to being a significant issue in its own right, I am also interested in potential connections between attitudes towards parsimony in science and in philosophy. Metaphysicians might once have aimed to justify the use of Occam’s Razor in science by appeal to aprioriphilosophical principles. The rise of scientific naturalism in the second half of the 20th Century has undercut this style of approach.
    [Show full text]
  • A Pragmatic Study of Litotes in Trump's Political Speeches
    International Journal of Innovation, Creativity and Change. www.ijicc.net Volume 11, Issue 3, 2020 A Pragmatic Study of Litotes in Trump's Political Speeches Wafaa Mokhlosa, Ali Abdulkareem Mukheefb*, a,bUniversity of Babylon, Iraq, Email: b*[email protected] Litotes is defined as a figure of speech by which the affirmative is expressed by denying its contrary. The current study is concerned with identifying and analysing litotes in Donald Trump's political speeches on pragmatic level. The study aims at identifying the illocutionary force of litotes, the functions of litotes, which maxim of Grice is mainly breached in the production of litotes to produce implicature, and which type of litotes is heavily used by Trump. The analysis is curried out on data consists of four texts from Trump's speeches during being president from 2016 to 2019. The study concludes that the illocutionary force of litotes in most of the times is asserting. Litotes is used mainly to fulfil the function of emphasis, but it can be used to perform the functions of encouraging and inciting. Trump uses contrary litotes in most of his speeches. Key words: Pragmatics, Litotes, Illocutionary force, Implicature, Functions. Introduction Politicians use different strategies and devices to convince their audience or gain their support. Figurative language is one of these strategies that are mainly based on the use of certain figures of speech such as irony, euphemism, metaphor, litotes etc. according to Griffiths (2006:81). Understanding figurative language requires a great interaction between semantics and pragmatics. Therefore, to understand the meaning of certain figure of speech a total knowledge of the context is required.
    [Show full text]