European Online Journal of Natural and Social Sciences 2013; www.european-science.com vol.2, No. 3(s), pp. 430-433 ISSN 1805-3602 Manipulation of price and its consequences

Bahram Moazeni1, Faride Asadollahi2 1Allameh Tabataba’I University, Tehran, Iran; 2University of Economic Science, Iran

Abstract Public confidence increase the integrity of mar- ket, liquidity strength and its performance increases With expansion of financial markets and capi- and this has a significant importance in capital mar- tal market and also existence of so many buyers and ket, especially stock markets. sellers who are looking to gain from their trades, ma- The most important prerequisite for the develop- nipulation has taken a new display. Forgers are able ment and deepening of capital markets in each financial to manipulate the trading activity of the system as the engine Economic mobile , is the public and offer a false display and mislead the and confidence to the integrity and rightness a basis for de- encourage them to buy their shares. Manipulation termining the fair price of a capital asset and thereby in can cause investors to be uncertain optimize allocation of funds to different areas of the to the capital market and it is an obstacle to market economy .In general, raised issue is that if investors gain depth. Certain controls and special regulations needed the insightthat prices do not reflect true value of stock to deal with this phenomenon in order to avoid distort- ,this will destroy their confidence to the capital market . ing the minds of investors and confronting false prices. In a manipulated market or a market which is threatened by manipulation ,it is not expected that prices reflect a Keywords: Price manipulation, , Data true view of current which affect demand and supply. manipulation In fact, stock can take full advan- tage and of the economicresources to deal with serious Introduction threat.

The most controversial issues goes back to the Manipulation definition and its types first formation of the capital market in its modern Manipulation is any interference in the market form (Amsterdam, Netherlands), is discussion of fi- mechanism that prevents determination of a fair price, nancial market manipulation. Studies in other coun- as well as any factor that may affect the stock price tries about the manipulation of prices say that ma- artificially. Superficial transactions, Chinese order in nipulation refers to activities which in any way may a specific volume, increase in company›s stock price interfere the free function of supply and demand, to by rumors and stock collection at low prices in order create artificial prices and false view of market activi- to gain profit are the best examples for manipulation. ties, and finally lead to misleading market. United States Securities Exchange Commission has Discussion about manipulation in both devel- defined manipulation as follow: intentional and pre- oped and emerging markets is important issue to be planned behavior in order to control or to influence addressed. Although in developed markets through artificially to market of special byinvestors . appropriate legislation and effective oversight mech- Market manipulation generally refers to activities anisms, many aspects of manipulation is limited. that may somehow interfere with the functioning of In contrast, emerging markets do not have ef- the free market supply and demand and activists mock ficient and effective regulatory system to prevent demonstration and create a false prices for stock mar- market manipulation, so market manipulation and ket, and finally lead to mislead market participants. price are impressed by people who have the power You can find manipulation as an important is- to widely order. sue in both developed and emerging markets. Prices

Corresponding author: Bahram Moazeni, Allameh Tabataba’I University, Tehran, Iran. Email: [email protected]

Copyright © Bahram Moazeni, Faride Asadollahi, 2013 European Online Journal of Natural and Social Sciences; vol.2, No. 3(s), pp 430-433

430 Social science section should be determined by the market without any ing or selling their companies in many countries,this interference .Prices should reflect the value of the type of manipulation has rarely occurs. stock by the accounting information and all infor- mation which is revealed about company, without Transaction-based on transaction manipulation any judgment on behalf of investors. In this type of manipulation,doing transactions One of the most important distortions in stock among themselves (with the purchase and sale of secu- prices can be done by manipulation and if investors rities) creates a vision of an active market and by arti- come to believe that the stock price does not reflect ficial increase in prices and trading volume will attract the true value of ��������������������������������������the������������������������������������� ����������������������������������stock��������������������������������� ����������������������������they��������������������������� �����������������������will���������������������� ������������������lose����������������� �������������their������������ �������confi������- other investors to buy shares. One of the factors that dence to the market. Consequences of manipulation affect investors’ decision is the volume of transactions, which can have loss to investors is as follows: the lack liquidity which can be considered the most important of public confidence in the integrity and rightness of feature.It is evident that if the liquidity power increases market, justice in capital asset pricing, reduction in it can add to attractiveness of a share to investors. liquidity of stock, deduction in investment and not In such circumstances, forgers can manipulate optimized resource allocation and finally decrease in the trading activity of the stock market by offering a economic growth. Iran›s capital market as an emerg- false display and mislead investors and encourage ing market is not exempt from this issue and efforts encourage them to buy their shares and they will sell to attract investors into this market and obtaining their shares at higher prices. -term public confidence in order toincrease in- vestment growth requires creating mechanisms to Background of manipulating stock prices prevent behavior that can lead to the manipulation Issue of market manipulation is almost as old as of the .So attracting public trust for the first securities market. Historically artificial influ- investing in this market and preventing from intense ence in stock prices has been an important issue .So and sectional volatilities by right determination of that after the Amsterdam Stock Exchange began in prices will lead to resource allocation in areas with early 17th century, traders in the stock found that they high performance and make economical growth . can manipulate prices by several ways and thereby What can be found on manipulation of securi- achieve profits.So they used the stock in hand in a ties in all studies, there are three types������������� ������������of �������������������manipula- concentrated period, sold their shares by creating a tion. Each of researchers have examined one aspect weak perspective for share. Investors who feared of of manipulation. this situation also began to sell their shares .So traders could buy again after stock prices fell enough .At lower Manipulation based on information prices, sold shares are redeemed. This Strategy was This strategy is the manipulations of stock prices called“bear raid”. Due to the success of this strategy, by spreading false rumors and misleading informa- brokers found that using this strategy along with pub- tion .People who invest in securities are sensitive to lishing false information and misleading rumors about market risk. Investors impression by information the future of the company can also have better results. and rumors is shown in price volatilities and trades By formation of united security markets in oth- volumes. So,there would be incentive for forgers to er countries and lack of obstacle laws, this kind of publish misleading information and guide public manipulation in stock prices appear with intense opinion toward their illegitimate interests. and weakness points and got a new display. In some Examples of this kind of transaction is manipu- markets,a combination of different strategies is used lating coalition, that investors creating a coalition buy to accelerate profits of price manipulation at the securities ,then release rumors about company so they same time. By the way price manipulation is being can sell their shares with higher prices and gain profit. continued and a large amount of profit was obtained by some at Wall Street in 19th century . Manipulation based on practice After the 1929 crisis, there was a general con- Activities instead of transactions which affect cern thatdecline in stock prices is because of massive real or realized value of trading assets and change it. influx for selling and manipulation is derived In this kind of manipulation managers are known as from the this matter. manipulators and their function impress prices,like SenateBanking and Currency Committee’s con- shutting down a factory to influence the price. But cerns about the operation of the securities market fol- since managers have limited gaining a ����� ����buy- lowed an investigation .Although studies show fewer

Openly accessible at http://www.european-science.com 431 Social science section samples from manipulating stock prices through the reduce market depth and can have an extreme effect massive influx of for short sale but other examples of on market efficiency (Hoang, 2007). manipulating stock prices revealed. When this kind of Wu and Aggrwal (2004) offered theories about price manipulation become epidemic, it become il- some empirical evidence of the manipulation of stock legal in some countries (Allen &Gale, 1992). prices in the United States .They have developed Allen Huebner argues that the manipulation of stock and Gale model and they found that people with inside prices is one of the most extensive discussions in information about the company’s securities are likely 1934,and after the Great Depression of 1929, the to be known as the manipulators,Securities that have largest public issue that has caused a drop in stock low liquidity,are more likely to be vulnerable to price prices was massive influx of short-sale securities manipulation and They will increase the of with the objective of price manipulation. price manipulation, They also found that the prices However it is very hard to display cases that lead will increase during manipulation and after period of to unbalanced market, by appropriate legislation, will manipulation it will reduce. When the trimmer starts lead to a reasonable advanced balance of the securi- selling, price and liquidity of the share is more than ties markets. But it should not be assumed that mar- when he has bought it. So they offered a model in this ket manipulation is solved in the market and this kind case and concluded that manipulation could have an of manipulation is quite complex and very difficult influence on market performance. (Walter & Howie, to hide it.But in emerging market manipulation, in 2003) studied the Chinese market manipulation and all kinds and extensively, is done by those who have found that the manipulation is one of the obstacles that enough power.The �������������������������������������������������������������������������first investigations about price ma- hinder the development of China’s stock market. nipulation, is Hart studies in 1977, that have studied price manipulation using econometric models in asset Conclusions markets. Huert has discussed conditions under which profitable may occur in a non-probabilistic Issue of market manipulation is almost as old as the and when demand function is nonlinear,speculators first securities market.Any intervention that prevents will be able to make profitable trades (Jarrow,1992). market supply and demand to be released refers to a form of manipulation.As regards that market manipulation Impact of stock price manipulation cause the lack of confidence to the stock market Manipulation in market refers to kind of a business and There will be preventing the development and deep- leading to distorted prices and enable manipulators to ening of the capital market as an economic engine. gain profits at the expense of other market participants According to studies conducted in the field of losses (Kaming, 2010). When a group of traders, at stock market manipulation and stock price based on the expense of other investors, earn extremely high investors’ insufficient information and asymmetry returns,this difference in performance is enough to information in the market are the main cause of ma- cause concern to investors from entering the market. nipulation. As well as the consequences of manipu- In a manipulated market or exposure ,we should lating stock prices, include preventing the spread of not expect that prices have a true reflection of cur- market, not entering of investors in the market, lack rent economic realities affected to supply and de- of market confidence , increase the frequency as well mand. Indeed, manipulating the stock market can tired shareholders, the Exchange requires listed com- threaten all benefit and exchange economic re- panies to disclose timely information as one of the sources. Studies about impact of price to the quality main areas to prevent manipulation. Disclosure of of stock market in Taiwan show that stock prices are executive instructions listed companies on the Stock higher during the period of manipulation of prices. Exchange in connection with this matter has been So that the cumulative abnormal stock returns are approved by the board of exchange. ���������������������������������������Also, informed peo- manipulated by more than 70% which is much higher ple are recognized to be the possibility of manipulation than in developed markets returns.Thereby stock ma- in securities. Securities that have low liquidity. Accord- nipulated shows increase in trading volume, as well as ing to this information, in order to prevent market ma- increased volatility, resulting in an increase in liquid- nipulation by inside information. Article 46 of the Se- ity during manipulation period. In addition, market curities Market Act Islamic republic of Iran mentioned manipulation, will worsen market depth that shows people with inside information in companies and has stock manipulation can cause an inefficient market established punishments to prevent abuse of this people that makes high increase in volume and volatility but as individuals’ aware of company’s inside information.

Openly accessible at http://www.european-science.com 432 Social science section

References stock market. Working paper. Kmyjany, A. & Saadat Far, J. (2006). Application of Allen, ��������������������������������������������F.,������������������������������������������� & Gale, ��������������������������������D. �����������������������������(1992). ���������������������Stock�������������������� ���������������pricemanipula��������������- neural network models in predicting the finan- tion. Review of Financial Studies: 503-529. cial solvency of stock market companies. Jour- David Diaz., Babis Theodoulidis, Pedro. nal of Economic Research. Cumming, D, Johan., S & Li, D. (2010). Exchange Kumar, P., & Seppi, D.J. (1992). Futures manipu- Trading Rules and Stock . Jour- lation with cash settlement. Journal of Finance nal of Financial Economics. 47, 1485-1502. Demuth, H., &Beale, M. (2004). Matlab Neu- Küçükkocaoğlu, G. (2011). Intra-Day Stock Re- ral Network Toolbox Manual, Digital Edition, turns and Close-End Price Manipulation in the Math Work Inc: 33-68. Istanbul Stock Exchange, Frontiers in Finance Fallah, S.M. (2008). Reviews of affecting factors of and Economics, 5, 46 – 84. price manipulation in . Mahoney Paul, G. (1999). The stock pools and the Research of Economic Science. securities Exchange Act. Journal of Financial Fallah, S. M. & Teimouri, S.A. (2005). Designing a Economics, 51, 343-369. model to predict of price manipulation in Teh- Palshikar ,G.K. & Apte, M.M.(2008). Collusion set ran stock exchange, Imam Sadegh Quarterly Re- detection using graph clustering. Data mining and search, 27. knowledge Discovery. Felixon, K., & Pelli, A. (1999). Day end returns- Rajesh, K. & Aggarwal, G.W. (2006). Stock Mar-Mar- stock manipulation. Journal of Multinational Fi- ket Manipulation. Chicago Journal, 1915-1953. nancial Management, 9, 95-127. Rostami Tabar, B. & Amin N.M. (2007). Intermit- Gerard, B., & Handa, V. (1993). Trading and ma- tent Demand Prediction with using Neural Net- nipulation around seasoned equity offerings, works. Master's thesis. Faculty of Engineering, Journal of Finance, 48, 213-245. Tarbiat Modarres University. Iran. Jarrow, R.A. (1992). Market Manipulation, Bubble, Sampaio, A. (2011). Analysis of stock market Corner ,and Short Squeezes. Journal of Finan- manipulations using knowledge discovery cial and Quantitative Analysis, 27, 311-336. techniques applied to intraday trade price. Khwaja, A.I.&Main, A.(2003). Trading in phantom Expert Systems with Applications, 38, 12757– market : Price manipulation in an emerging 12771.

Openly accessible at http://www.european-science.com 433