A Journey to Baseball's Alternate Universe

A Journey to Baseball’s Alternate Universe - New York Times 4/2/08 7:05 AM

HOME PAGE MY TIMES TODAY'S PAPER VIDEO MOST POPULAR TIMES TOPICS My Account Welcome, gloftus Log Out Help

Opinion Opinion All NYT

WORLD U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION ARTS STYLE TRAVEL JOBS REAL ESTATE AUTOS

EDITORIALS COLUMNISTS CONTRIBUTORS LETTERS THE PUBLIC EDITOR

OP-ED CONTRIBUTORS More Articles in Opinion » A Journey to Baseball’s Alternate Universe

By SAMUEL ARBESMAN and STEVEN STROGATZ Published: March 30, 2008 E-MAIL

Ithaca, N.Y. PRINT

SAVE WITH the baseball season under way Multimedia and the memory of scandal in the SHARE sport so fresh, many fans yearn for an earlier era, a time when mythology mingled with baseball. The sport’s most mythic achievement is Joe DiMaggio’s 56-game hitting streak, a feat that has never

Graphic come even close to being matched. Fans and scientists Length of Record Hitting Streaks alike, including Edward M. Purcell, a Nobel laureate in physics, and Stephen Jay Gould, the evolutionary biologist, have described the streak as well-nigh impossible.

In a fit of scientific skepticism, we decided to calculate how unlikely Joltin’ Joe’s achievement really was. Using a comprehensive collection of baseball statistics from 1871 Graphic to 2005, we simulated the entire history of baseball How Often the Record Hitting 10,000 times in a computer. In essence, we programmed Streak Occurred in a Particular Season the computer to construct an enormous set of parallel baseball universes, all with the same players but subject to the vagaries of chance in each one.

Related Here’s how it works. Think of baseball players’ Times Topics: Baseball performances at bat as being like coin tosses. Hitting streaks are like runs of many heads in a row. Suppose a hypothetical player named Joe Coin had a 50-50 chance of getting at least one hit per game, and suppose that he played 154 games during the 1941 season. We could learn something about Coin’s chances of having a 56-game hitting streak in 1941 by flipping a real coin 154 times, recording the series of heads and tails, and observing what his longest streak of heads happened to be.

Our simulations did something very much like this, except instead of a coin, we used random numbers generated by a computer. Also, instead of assuming that a player has a 50 percent chance of hitting successfully in each game, we used baseball statistics to calculate each player’s odds, as determined by his actual batting performance in a given year.

For example, in 1941 Joe DiMaggio had an 81 percent chance of getting at least one hit MOST POPULAR in each game (this statistic can be calculated using his total number of hits in the season, E-MAILED BLOGGED SEARCHED the number of games he played and his number of plate appearances). We simulated a mock version of his 1941 season, using the computer equivalent of a trick coin that 1. New Therapies Fight Phantom Noises of Tinnitus comes up heads 81 percent of the time. 2. David Brooks: Pitching With Purpose http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/30/opinion/30strogatz.html?scp=1&sq=hitting+streaks&st=nyt Page 1 of 3 A Journey to Baseball’s Alternate Universe - New York Times 4/2/08 7:05 AM

comes up heads 81 percent of the time. 2. David Brooks: Pitching With Purpose 3. Elite Colleges Reporting Record Lows in Admission But the right question is not how likely it was for DiMaggio to have a 56-game hitting 4. Essay: It’s Not You, It’s Your Books streak in 1941. The question is: How likely was it that anyone in the history of baseball 5. Op-Ed Contributors: Tighten Your Belt, Strengthen Your Mind would have achieved a streak that long or longer? 6. Basics: Blind to Change, Even as It Stares Us in the Face To answer this, our simulation repeated the coin-flipping experiments for every player in 7. Maureen Dowd: The Hillary Waltz the history of the game, for every season in which he played. This is what we mean by a 8. Inside the Black Budget simulation of the entire history of baseball. 9. Insurers Faulted as Overloading Social Security To tease out the meaningful lessons from random effects (fluky streaks that happen by 10. Contributing Columnist: Fresh Ideas for a Tired Crusade luck), we redid the whole thing 10,000 times. In each of these simulated histories, somebody holds the record for the longest hitting streak. We tabulated who that player Go to Complete List » was, when he did it, and how long his streak was.

And suddenly the unlikely becomes likely: we get a very long streak each time we run baseball history. These results are shown in Figure 1. The streaks ranged from 39 games nytimes.com/health at the shortest, to a freakish baseball universe where the record was a remarkable (and remarkably rare) 109 games.

More than half the time, or in 5,295 baseball universes, the record for the longest hitting streak exceeded 53 games. Two-thirds of the time, the best streak was between 50 and 64 games. Zen and the art of coping with Alzheimer's In other words, streaks of 56 games or longer are not at all an unusual occurrence. Also in Health: Forty-two percent of the simulated baseball histories have a streak of DiMaggio’s length An in-depth report on Alzheimer's Finding Alzheimer's before a mind fails or longer. You shouldn’t be too surprised that someone, at some time in the history of What are the symptoms of Alzheimer's%3F the game, accomplished what DiMaggio did.

The real surprise is when the record was set. Our analysis reveals that 1941 was one of the least likely seasons for such an epic streak to occur. ADVERTISEMENTS

Figure 2 shows the number of times, out of 10,000 simulations, that the longest streak occurred in a particular year. The likeliest time for the longest streak to have occurred was in the 19th century, back in the misty beginnings of baseball. Or maybe in the 1920s or ’30s.

But not in 1941, or afterward. That season was the miracle year in only 19 of our alternate major-league histories. By comparison, in 1,290 of our baseball universes, or more than a tenth, the record was set in a single year: 1894.

And Joe DiMaggio is nowhere near the likeliest player to hold the record for longest hitting streak in baseball history. He is No. 56 on the list. (Fifty-six? Cue “The Twilight Zone” music.) Two old-timers, Hugh Duffy and Willie Keeler, are the most probable record holders. Between them, they set the record in more than a thousand of the parallel baseball universes. Ty Cobb did it nearly 300 times.

DiMaggio held the record 28 times. Plus once more, when it counted.

Samuel Arbesman is a graduate student at Cornell. Steven Strogatz is a professor of applied mathematics there.