Part Xi – Laws of Attempted Crime
Criminal Law and Procedure 11 – Attempted Crime PART XI – LAWS OF ATTEMPTED CRIME I Introduction A Inchoate Crimes Inchoate crimes encompass doctrines of attempt, incitement and conspiracy, which share the common characteristic of making it criminal to participate in the commission of incomplete offences. Here, we are specifically concerned with attempt. Laws of attempt extend criminal liability beyond acts of a defendant to include what they try but fail to do. The general common law doctrine of attempt states that an attempt to commit a crime is itself a crime. However, most states and territories have introduced legislation codifying the doctrine into statutory form (see, in Victoria, Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) ss 321M-S). The difficulty arises in attempting to articulate the legal boundaries to this doctrine. For example, if I try to kill a person but am unable to achieve that result (eg, because of police intervention or my own incompetence or mistake), how close to committing the full crime must I be in order to be found guilty of attempted murder? B Relationship between Inchoate Crimes and Other Offences Laws of attempt may be distinguished from specific crimes that set a penalty for some lesser offence (eg, attempted murder in New South Wales and South Australia – but not Victoria, in which attempted murder is covered by the general law of attempt). Attempted crimes are also different from crimes whose actus reus consists of a lesser (often summary) offence with an intention to commit a further crime (see, eg, Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) ss 31, 40). The commission of these offences is a complete, and not inchoate, crime.
[Show full text]