INTEGRATED RISK MANAGEMENT ACTION PLAN 2012-2013

CONSULTATION PAPER

INTRODUCTION

West Fire and Rescue Authority faces some difficult challenges in meeting its objectives and at the same time delivering significant efficiencies over the next few years.

The following report presents seven important proposals for more efficient and effective ways of working.

On 9 September 2011, the fire authority agreed that the recommendations from its chief fire officer be published for a 12-week period of public consultation. A further report will then be considered by the authority in December 2011.

If the proposals are approved they will be implemented between 2012 and 2017.

2

WYFRA FULL AUTHORITY 9 Sept 2011 ITEM NO

REPORT OF: DIRECTOR OF OPERATIONS

PURPOSE OF REPORT: To present a range of proposals as part of the Integrated Risk Management Planning (IRMP) process for inclusion in the 2012/13 Action Plan.

RECOMMENDATIONS: 1. Approval is given to undertake full consultation in relation to:

 The introduction of a Fire Response Unit and Resilience Pump at Moortown to replace the 2nd fire 3 appliance and the removal of up to 12 fulltime posts by way of planned retirements.

 Remove the 2nd fire appliance at and transfer it to as a Resilience Pump and the removal of 5 Retained Duty System posts from the establishment at Silsden.

 The construction of a new fire station to replace fire station with the removal of 11 fulltime posts from the establishment by way of planned retirements and the closure of Hemsworth fire station with the removal of 12 Retained Duty System posts.

 The construction of a new fire station to replace Rawdon fire station with the removal of 11 fulltime posts from the establishment by way of planned retirements and the closure of fire station with the removal of 12 Retained Duty System posts.

 The construction of a new fire station to replace and fire stations and removal of 24 fulltime posts from the establishment by way of planned retirements.

 The construction of a new fire station to replace and fire stations and removal of 24 fulltime posts from the establishment by way of planned retirements.

 The construction of a new fire station to replace Gipton and Stanks fire stations and removal of 24 fulltime posts from the establishment by way of planned retirements.

2. The outcomes of the full consultation are reported back to Fire and Rescue Authority in December 2011 for approval of the proposals subject 4 to the feedback received.

LOCAL GOVERNMENT (ACCESS TO INFORMATION) ACT DETAILS

EXEMPTION CATEGORY: NONE

ACCESS CONTACT OFFICER: DCFO Beckley and AM Rhodes

BACKGROUND PAPERS: Service Plan 2011-15 Community Risk Management Strategy 2011-15 IRMP Community and Engagement Strategy

OPEN TO INSPECTION: www.wyfrs.co.uk

SUMMARY

WYFRA faces some difficult challenges in meeting its objectives and at the same time delivering significant efficiencies over the next few years. There have been some major successes over recent years in reducing risk, activity and demand, with the number of fires, deaths and injuries at an all-time low, providing opportunity to consider more efficient and effective ways of working.

This paper presents seven proposals, each of which is supported by a business case. 5 Approval of WYFRA is sought to commence full consultation with all stakeholders and interested parties over a 12 week period in relation to a range of proposals that will enable significant efficiencies to be made.

A further report will be submitted in December 2011 to WYFRA, which will include the outcomes of the consultation. Approval will be sought for the proposals, subject to any changes arising from the process of consultation.

If the proposals are approved they will be included in the Action Plan for 2012/13 for implementation between 2012 and 2016.

1 BACKGROUND

1.1 Integrated Risk Management Planning was introduced by Government in April 2004, replacing the 1985 Standards of Fire Cover. Since the introduction of Integrated Risk Management Plans, WYFRS has not only complied with statutory requirements but has also been proactive in developing initiatives that have enabled the delivery of an excellent Fire and Rescue Service for the community of West Yorkshire. West Yorkshire is one of the best performing fire services in the country; the Integrated Risk Management Planning process it uses will enable it to remain a first class service whilst still delivering value for money.

1.2 In 2009 WYFRS reviewed its Integrated Risk Management Planning process in order to prepare fully for the challenges that Fire and Rescue Services across the country were likely to face due to budgetary reductions. In late 2009 firefighter recruitment was suspended in anticipation that funding would reduce.

1.3 This critical decision places WYFRS in a strong position to be able to respond to reductions in funding. The high level strategy is based on the alignment of changes to the profile of 6 firefighters retiring. This enables the number of firefighters employed by WYFRA to reduce gradually, in order to avoid wholetime firefighter redundancies.

1.4 As firefighters retire, obviously the numbers that remain to crew WYFRS fire appliances also reduces. It is therefore necessary to change the number and locations of fire appliances to maximise the capacity of the workforce by implementing a major change programme to reorganise and restructure the Service.

1.5 At the heart of WYFRS’s strategy to meet the challenges and continue to make West Yorkshire safer is the integration of prevention, protection, response and resilience services. An explanation of how these key pillars operate together is contained within the Community Risk Management Strategy 2011-2015, which explains how WYFRS determines a proportional approach to the management of risk in order to deliver an equitable service to the whole of West Yorkshire.

1.6 The risk management methodology adopted and set out in the Community Risk Management Strategy has been externally validated to ensure that the Authority is provided with the highest quality of robust information practicable. This document can be found on the home page of the WYFRS internet site.

1.7 Incidence of fire is comparatively rare; WYFRS has achieved great success in reducing the total number of all incidents in West Yorkshire by 22% between 2004/5 and 2009/10, with the number of more serious fires reducing by 42%. It is entirely appropriate that the general reduction of risk and demand is taken account of when determining the level of resources required.

1.8 The principles outlined in the Community Risk Management Strategy 2011-15 enabled a range of changes to be presented to WYFRA in June 2011. Approval was given at that meeting to carry out internal consultation and negotiation with employees and their representatives as the changes have an insignificant impact on fire cover. This report now presents further proposals requiring full consultation.

2 INFORMATION

2.1 A comprehensive Emergency Cover Review has recently been concluded. This review enables WYFRS to ensure that its emergency response resources are in the right place at the right time and that they are being provided in an efficient and effective way. The Emergency Cover Review provides the basis for determining proposals for future change. Such changes will alter the way in which WYFRS delivers its emergency response and drive the optimum use of resources, 7 delivering better value for money.

2.2 Many fire stations are located in certain areas for historical reasons and due to the changes in risk and demography, are no longer in the optimum location. The Emergency Cover Review has provided strong evidence for major change.

2.3 The Emergency Cover Review has utilised a number of scientific evaluation tools alongside local knowledge and professional judgment to identify the changes which would have the least impact on service delivery. The risk process has been developed, and externally validated by Risk Management specialists. The Review is also underpinned by a very detailed Resource Optimisation Study jointly undertaken with experts in this field. The outcome of this extensive and thorough collaborative work is a robust evidence base on which proposals can be constructed.

2.4 The alignment of the retirement profile and the anticipated financial plan has enabled significant changes to be identified that have a limited effect on fire cover. The Community Risk Management Strategy approved by WYFRA in September 2010, presented a range of potential types of change which could be introduced, these have been summarised below:

 Restructuring of Response resources based on Risk:

o Station Mergers and redistribution of appliances.

o Closure of some Retained Stations.

o Removal of 2nd appliances or change or supplement the types of appliances with, for example, Fire Response Units.

 Dual Crewing Specialist appliances.

 Introducing Combined Aerial Rescue Pumps.

 Day Crewing (Close Call) Stations.

 Peak Activity Crewing.

 Resilience Pumps. 8 2.5 The Emergency Cover Review has enabled the impact of these and other options for change to be considered; those options which have the least impact have led to evidence based business cases being produced.

2.6 Five of the proposals in this report will require the purchase of land and the building of new fire stations. It has been necessary to include these proposals at this early stage to allow the lengthy process of land purchase, planning permission and construction to be undertaken. If approved, the implementation of the five new builds will take place between 2013 and 2017; this is dependent on the availability of suitable land for purchase.

2.7 Further proposals will be presented to WYFRA in future years, however it is not anticipated that these will involve any further new builds prior to 2016.

3 FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS

3.1 The table below summarises the financial implications of the proposals included within this report. It can be seen that overall, once fully implemented, they will generate ongoing revenue (staff) savings of £4.134m per year and will require capital investment of £14.45m over the next four years. Detailed implications on each of the individual schemes are shown within this report with a summary of the overall financial picture provided below.

Moortown Silsden South Elmsall Rawdon Brighouse Dewsbury Gipton Total Hemsworth Otley Elland Batley Stanks

Wholetime fire fighters -£288,000 -£434,000 -£434,000 -£932,000 -£932,000 -£932,000 -£3,952,000 Retained fire fighters -£60,000 -£255,000 -£300,000 -£615,000 £0 Running costs -£220,000 -£220,000 -£220,000 -£660,000 £0 Allowances £129,000 £129,000 £258,000 Capital financing charges £12,000 £170,000 £170,000 £170,000 £180,000 £180,000 £882,000

Total revenue implications -£276,000 -£60,000 -£390,000 -£435,000 -£982,000 -£972,000 -£972,000 -£4,087,000

Total capital cost £50,000 £2,800,000 £2,800,000 £2,800,000 £3,000,000 £3,000,000 £14,450,000 9 Revenue Implications

3.2 Together with the rest of Local Government the Fire Service is experiencing significant cuts in funding during the period of the current spending review. Overall fire funding will be cut by 25% over this period; however this will not be shared equally throughout the sector. In the first two years whilst overall funding has been cut by 6.5% this Authority along with the other metropolitan brigades will suffer a grant cut of over 10.5%.

3.3 In total the Authority will lose almost £6m of grant in the first two years and if the cuts are shared out on a similar basis in the final two years could lose a further £12m, if not more.

3.4 The Authority therefore will have to deliver significant savings over the next 3 years in order to maintain a balanced budget. As explained earlier in the report the Authority will take advantage of firefighter retirements as a major element of its budget strategy and it is anticipated that this will deliver a significant proportion of the savings.

3.5 This report identifies the proposed changes in the establishment to deal with the impact of non-recruitment. An indication of the net savings in staffing costs in a full year once the changes have been fully implemented is included within each section of the report

3.6 The overall proposals will deliver ongoing revenue savings of approximately £4m per annum which, when added to the proposals presented in June 2011, will bring annual savings of over £6m once fully implemented. These savings will be delivered through non recruitment and have already been factored into the medium term financial forecast.

3.7 It should be noted that even after the implementation of these proposals there will still be a significant budget gap and the CFO/CE is developing further plans for WYFRA to consider.

Capital Implications

3.8 As can be seen from the table in paragraph 3.1 the estimated capital cost of delivering these changes will be £14.45m over the next 4 years which is on top of the normal capital requirement to replace fire appliances, purchase operational equipment and maintain and refurbish the current building stock. Fire and Rescue Authorities no longer receive any financial support towards the cost of borrowing from Central Government which means these costs estimated to be £0.83m per annum will have to be met from the precept/efficiencies.

3.9 In the current year the Authority has received a capital grant of £2.5m as its share of a £70m 10 pot to fund fire capital schemes which will be used to reduce borrowing.

3.10 Whilst a similar pot is available for 2012/2013, this will be allocated on the basis of a competitive bidding process and consequently there is no guarantee this Authority will be successful. However it is hoped that the ongoing revenue savings that can be delivered through capital investment should provide a compelling ‘invest to save’ business case.

3.11 The proposals include the removal/replacement of 10 fire stations which will be available for sale once the individual schemes are completed. The value of this land will vary dependent upon size and location; it is anticipated that some of the land may provide significant capital receipts. However in the current economic climate it would not be prudent to assume any significant level of capital receipts. For this reason the detailed financial implications exclude any potential income from capital receipts. Any receipts that are generated will be used to either fund other schemes later in the programme or reduce borrowing.

4 PROPOSAL 1 - MOORTOWN FIRE STATION

4.1 This proposal involves the removal of the 2nd fire appliance at Moortown, replacing it with a Fire Response Unit that is crewed during periods of high activity and provision of a Resilience Pump. If approved this proposal will be introduced during 2012/13. (See appendix 1 for the business case)

4.2 In the period between 2004/5 and 2009/10 the number of incidents in this area has reduced by 35% (there has been a reduction of 47% of serious fires). The reduction in risk has been achieved by working with partners and local communities, making Moortown a safer place to live and work.

4.3 The provision of two 24/7 fire appliances is now disproportionate to the level of risk: On a cost per risk basis Moortown is the second most expensive multi-pump fire station in West Yorkshire (Dewsbury being the most expensive).

4.4 WYFRS intend to drive the level of risk down further by setting and achieving a number of challenging risk reduction targets. The current location of the fire station continues to provide an effective base for WYFRS resources, but as it was constructed over 50 years ago, investment will be required to improve the standard of accommodation for firefighters and visiting members of the 11 community.

4.5 WYFRS’ commitment to providing an excellent and efficient service has informed the proposal to introduce an innovative way of providing an emergency response service within the area of Moortown and District. Instead of continuing to provide two front line fire appliances WYFRS will replace one of them with a Fire Response Unit which will be capable of providing a faster response to smaller incidents across Leeds District. This will maximise the availability of front line fire appliances for life and property incidents.

4.6 A comprehensive trial of the Fire Response Unit at Moortown has been undertaken over the last 6 months; the pilot indicates that the Fire Response Unit is very effective. It attends a large number of incidents across the Leeds District enabling other fire appliances to remain available to respond to more serious incidents involving risk to life and property.

4.7 The staffing arrangements for the Fire Response Unit will improve efficiency and provide better value for money. The existing 1st fire appliance at Moortown will continue to be crewed as it is currently, providing an adequate and appropriate response for the area. The Fire Response Unit will only be crewed during busier periods of activity.

4.8 An additional fire appliance will be strategically located at Moortown fire station as part of WYFRS’ resilience arrangements. This Resilience Pump will not be continuously crewed but will be activated during periods of anticipated or unplanned/unexpected high levels of operational activity and in response to significant events which could affect emergency response. Examples of such events include wide area flooding, the bonfire period, periods of bad weather, or for attending very large protracted incidents.

4.9 Financial Implications

Replacing the second fire appliance at Moortown with a Fire Response Unit and a Resilience Pump will result in the removal of between 8 and 12 firefighters (dependent on the shift pattern and staffing level agreed during the consultation and negotiation process). The purchase/lease cost of the Fire Response Unit will be £50,000. The table below summaries the financial implications of these changes based on the deletion of 8 posts.

Salary Number Full year Cost\Saving Reduction in staffing Firefighters £36,000 -8 -£288,000 12 Net staffing savings -£288,000 Capital expenditure £50,000 Capital financing charges £12,000 Net saving -£276,000

NOTE: Salary includes on costs

If 12 posts removed the annual savings will rise to £420,000.

5 PROPOSAL 2 – SILSDEN FIRE STATION

5.1 This proposal involves the relocation of the second fire appliance at Silsden to provide a Resilience Pump at Keighley. If approved this proposal will be implemented during 2012/13. (see appendix 2 for the business case).

5.2 This proposal for Silsden fire station reflects the very low demand placed upon the fire appliances stationed there. Silsden is one of the safest places to live in West Yorkshire, and is categorised to be a Very Low Risk Area. During 2009/10 there were just 36 incidents (not including false alarms) within the station area (many of these were small rubbish fires).

5.3 This is a low level of activity even when compared to the other Very Low Risk station areas in West Yorkshire, (all of which are provided with one fire engine, not two as is the case for Silsden). There has been a 43% reduction in all incidents between 2004/5 and 2009/10 (there has been a reduction of 63% of serious fires).

5.4 The fire station currently houses two front line fire appliances which are crewed by 13 retained duty system (part-time) firefighters who either live or work within close proximity to the fire station and respond to emergencies from these locations. The provision of two fire appliances at Silsden is greatly disproportionate to the risk. Silsden is the only Retained Duty System station that has two fire appliances. This proposal will provide the community of Silsden with the same level of service currently delivered to other West Yorkshire Very Low Risk station areas.

5.5 Since 2010 WYFRS has provided operational and administrative support to retained stations by the employment of whole-time Local Retained Support Officers, this provision will be continued. The introduction of a Local Retained Support Officer on retained stations has been highly successful in helping drive down risk, improving standards and increasing the amount of time the fire appliances are fully staffed.

5.6 The fire appliance that is removed from Silsden will be strategically located at Keighley fire station as part of WYFRS’s resilience arrangements as previously described (paragraph 4.8).

5.7 Financial Implications

The removal of the second fire appliance at Silsden will result in the removal of 5 part-time firefighter posts from the establishment. The table below summarises the financial implications of these changes.

Salary Number Full year Cost\Saving Reduction in staffing Retained Firefighters £12,000 -5 -£60,000

Net staffing savings -£60,000

NOTE: Salary includes on costs

14

6 PROPOSAL 3 – SOUTH ELMSALL AND HEMSWORTH FIRE STATIONS

6.1 This proposal involves the construction of a new fire station to replace South Elmsall fire station in an optimum location with the provision of one fire appliance and the transfer of the fire appliance from Hemsworth to provide a District based Resilience Pump. Hemsworth fire station will be surplus to requirements and will be closed. If approved this proposal will be introduced between 2013 and 2017. (See Appendix 3 for the business case).

6.2 The District of West Yorkshire is currently served by fire appliances at South Elmsall, Hemsworth, / and , with additional appliances at Wakefield, Normanton and . At the south eastern extremity there are two fire stations close together, one is based at a whole time staffed fire station at South Elmsall and the other is a retained duty system (part time) fire station at Hemsworth.

6.3 Changes in the demographic profile of this area, combined with a series of sustained risk reduction initiatives have resulted in a 36% reduction in the combined number of incidents for 15 South Elmsall and Hemsworth between 2004/5 and 2009/10 (there has been a reduction of 43% of serious fires). The road network has also undergone recent significant upgrade as part of the social and economic strategy to regenerate the area. These improvements and reduced appliance availability levels at Hemsworth are significant contributory factors for this proposal. This area is one of the safer places to live in respect of fire-related emergencies in West Yorkshire, and is considered by WYFRS to be a Very Low Risk Area.

6.4 The proposal is to introduce a more efficient and effective service by consolidating resources in the area by building a new fire station with one front line fire appliance replacing the existing two at South Elmsall and Hemsworth. This fire appliance will be crewed by whole time firefighters providing a swift emergency response service and improved prevention and protection services for the surrounding communities. This resource is proportionate to the low level of risk and activity.

6.5 A more efficient duty system (Day Crewed Close Call) which utilises a smaller pool of firefighters but delivers a comparable speed of operational response to that currently being provided by resources based at South Elmsall and faster than that at Hemsworth, will be introduced.

6.6 Over the past 15 years a number of detailed reviews and studies have concluded that the traditional approach to crewing emergency appliances needs to change and be replaced with arrangements that are appropriate to the levels of risk and demand. Following extensive research, WYFRS has successfully introduced a variation of the traditional Day-Crewing duty system at Normanton fire station (and temporarily at Knottingley) called Day Crewing Close Call which provides a comparable response service to that of the four shift duty system with fewer firefighters working more flexibly. This duty system was approved by the WYFRA Personnel Committee on 8 April 2011, following collective agreement with the Fire Brigades Union.

6.7 The shift arrangements will be amended to improve efficiency and provide better value for money. This will be done in such a way that ensures the fire appliance will be crewed to respond to emergencies in less than two minutes from being mobilised (the same as traditional wholetime shift fire stations). This is appropriate due to the very low number of incidents at night time. Off-duty accommodation will be provided close to the fire station which will enable firefighters to rest during the night but still be able to respond to calls as quickly as they were when they were at work in the fire station. This can be achieved by reducing staffing by 11 fulltime personnel. 16

6.8 The closure of Hemsworth Fire Station will result in the Retained Duty System firefighters working there being removed from the establishment and the fire appliance will be strategically located at the new station as part of WYFRS’ resilience arrangements as previously described (Para 4.8).

6.9 Financial Implications

The current duty system at South Elmsall comprises of four Watch Managers, four Crew Managers and 16 firefighters; a total establishment of 24, costing £916,000 per annum. Implementation of Day Crewing Close Call at the new fire station will reduce the establishment to a total of 13, with two Watch Managers, one Crew Manager and 10 firefighters. In order to bring about these changes it will be necessary to invest £2.8m in capital to construct the new fire station and suitable accommodation. The closure of Hemsworth station will provide efficiencies of £0.255m (inclusive of staffing and maintenance costs). There will be a reduction of 12 Retained Duty Systems posts from the establishment. The table below summarises the financial implications of these changes.

South Kirby

Salary Number Full year Cost\Saving Reduction in staffing South Elmsall Firefighters £36,000 -6 -£216,000 Crew managers £40,000 -3 -£120,000 Watch managers £49,000 -2 -£98,000

Add additional allowances Firefighters £9,500 10 £95,000 Crew managers £10,000 1 £10,000 Watch managers £12,000 2 £24,000

-£305,000

Closure of Hemsworth Retained -£255,000

Net staffing savings -£560,000 Capital expenditure £2,500,000 Capital financing charges £150,000 Net saving -£410,000

NOTE: Salary includes on costs

17

7 PROPOSAL 4 – RAWDON AND OTLEY FIRE STATIONS

7.1 This proposal involves the construction of a new fire station to replace Rawdon fire station in an optimum location with the provision of one fire appliance and the transfer of the fire appliance from Otley to the new station to provide a Resilience Pump. Otley fire station will be surplus to requirements and will be closed. This proposal results in significant efficiencies. If approved this proposal will be introduced between 2013 and 2017. (See Appendix 4 for the business case)

7.2 The North West Area of Leeds District is currently served by fire appliances at Otley, Rawdon and Cookridge, there are also appliances locally based at Shipley, Idle and . Historically this area has experienced very few incidents with a 19% reduction in incidents between 2004/5 and 2009/10 (there has been a reduction of 43% of serious fires). WYFRS’ proposal reflects this low level of activity. This area is one of the safer places to live in respect of fire-related emergencies in West Yorkshire. Both station areas are categorised as Very Low Risk areas.

7.3 The proposal is to introduce a more efficient and effective service by consolidating resources in 18 the Menston/ area by building a new fire station with one front line fire appliance and a Resilience Pump replacing Rawdon and Otley appliances. The front line fire appliance will be staffed by whole time firefighters providing a swift emergency response service and improved prevention and protection services for the surrounding communities. This resource is proportionate to the low level of risk and activity.

7.4 A more efficient duty system (Day Crewing Close Call) that utilises a smaller pool of firefighters but delivers a comparable speed of operational response to that currently being provided by our resources based at Rawdon and faster than those at Otley will be introduced.

7.5 This is the same Duty system being proposed for Proposal 3, South Elmsall/Hemsworth.

7.6 The closure of Otley Fire Station will result in the Retained Duty System firefighters working there being removed from the establishment.

7.7 The other fire engine will be strategically located at the new fire station as part of WYFRS’ resilience arrangements as previously described (paragraph 4.8).

7.8 Financial Implications

The current duty system at Rawdon comprises of four Watch Managers, four Crew Managers

and 16 firefighters; a total establishment of 24, costing £916,000 per annum. Implementation of Day Crewing Close Call at the new fire station will reduce the establishment to a total of 13, with two Watch Managers, one Crew Manager and 10 firefighters. In order to bring about these changes it will be necessary to invest £2.8m in capital to construct the new fire station and suitable accommodation. The closure of Otley station will provide efficiencies of £0.30m (inclusive of staffing and maintenance costs). There will be a reduction of 12 Retained Duty Systems posts from the establishment. The table below summarises the financial implications of these changes.

Rawdon Otley

Salary Number Full year Cost\Saving Reduction in staffing Firefighters £36,000 -6 -£216,000 Crew managers £40,000 -3 -£120,000 Watch managers £49,000 -2 -£98,000

Add additional allowances Firefighters £9,500 10 £95,000 Crew managers £10,000 1 £10,000 19 Watch managers £12,000 2 £24,000

-£305,000

Closure of Otley Retained -£300,000

Net staffing savings -£605,000 Capital expenditure £2,800,000 Capital financing charges £170,000 Net saving -£435,000

NOTE: Salary includes on costs

8 PROPOSAL 5 – BRIGHOUSE AND ELLAND FIRE STATIONS

8.1 This proposal involves the construction of a new fire station to replace the fire stations at Brighouse and Elland. The new station will be sited in an optimum location with the provision of one fire appliance and one Resilience Pump. If approved this proposal will be introduced between 2013 and 2017. (See Appendix 5 for the business case)

8.2 The South and East area of West Yorkshire is currently served by fire appliances at Brighouse and Elland, with surrounding stations at Halifax, Odsal, and .

8.3 The communities in the locality of Brighouse and Elland have historically been areas which have experienced very few serious fires and associated rescues. The number of incidents has reduced by 4% between 2004/5 and 2009/10 (there has been a reduction of 27% of serious fires). A co-ordinated approach to risk reduction with partner organisations and communities has led to the risk within these areas being maintained at a relatively low level. 20 The proximity of Brighouse and Elland fire stations to the M62 motorway results in WYFRS resources based within these areas responding to a higher than average number of road traffic collisions.

8.4 Elland is Low Risk, and Brighouse is Very Low Risk, compared to other areas of West Yorkshire. The Elland/Brighouse area of Calderdale is one of the safer places to live in respect to fire-related emergencies.

8.5 Both fire stations at Brighouse and Elland have one front line fire appliance and given the low risk and low operational activity levels in these areas WYFRS can provide a more efficient and effective service by consolidating these resources at a new fire station located within the Rastrick locality. The new fire station will also improve the fire appliance arrival times into the higher risk areas of Huddersfield.

8.6 Brighouse also provides a combined Swift Water Rescue and Flood Response capability for the surrounding area and supports a response to water incidents across West Yorkshire.

8.7 The new station will house one front line fire appliance instead of the two appliances currently based at the existing locations. The fire appliance at Rastrick will be able to respond quickly

into Elland and Brighouse whilst still being able to access the motorway network. The Swift Water Rescue and Flood Response capability will also be provided at the new Rastrick Station. The new fire station will be built to a high specification and will provide modern accommodation and training facilities for firefighters. The surrounding communities will receive continuous fire and rescue cover, provided by the whole time staffing of one front line fire engine.

8.8 The shift arrangements will remain unchanged. The reduction from two to one continually staffed fire appliance improves efficiencies and provides better value for money. This can be achieved by removing 24 fulltime posts from the establishment by way of planned retirements.

8.9 Another front line fire appliance will be strategically located at the new fire station as part of WYFRS’ resilience arrangements as previously described (paragraph 4.8).

8.10 Financial Implications

The merging of Brighouse and Elland will provide efficiency savings of four Watch Managers, four Crew Managers and 16 firefighters. In order to bring about these changes it will be necessary to invest £2.8m in capital to construct the new fire station. The table below summarises the financial implications of these changes. 21 Brighouse Elland

Salary Number Full year Cost\Saving Reduction in staffing Firefighters £36,000 -16 -£576,000 Crew managers £40,000 -4 -£160,000 Watch managers £49,000 -4 -£196,000

-£932,000

Saving in running expenses -£220,000

Net staffing savings -£1,152,000 Capital expenditure £2,800,000 Capital financing charges £170,000 Net saving -£982,000

NOTE: Salary includes on costs

9 PROPOSAL 6 – DEWSBURY AND BATLEY FIRE STATIONS

9.1 This proposal involves the construction of a new fire station to replace the fire stations at Dewsbury and Batley. The new station will be sited in an optimum location with the provision of two fire appliances and one Resilience Pump. If approved this proposal will be introduced between 2013 and 2017. (See Appendix 6 for the business case).

9.2 The East area of is currently served by two fire appliances at Dewsbury, with Batley, , Ossett, Cleckheaton and Morley each housing one fire appliance each. Dewsbury is a High Risk station area and Batley is Medium Risk. The risk in both these station areas is reducing and the provision of two fire appliances in this area is proportionate to the risk and is comparable to other similar station areas.

9.3 Despite successful risk reduction activities and a 17% reduction in the number of incidents between 2004/5 and 2009/10 (there has been a reduction of 34% of serious fires); WYFRS recognise that the level of risk in this area warrants a swift fire and rescue response. The 22 provision of a new station will replace the ageing fire station at Dewsbury. Dewsbury and Mirfield are less than two miles apart (Mirfield is a retained fire station), the close proximity of these two stations means that the three fire appliances cover the same areas. Relocating Dewsbury to a location between Batley and Dewsbury will make better use of the fire appliance at Mirfield.

9.4 The proposal is to build a new fire station in the area between Dewsbury and Batley with two fire appliances plus one Resilience Pump.

9.5 The new station will be built to a high specification and will provide modern accommodation and training facilities for firefighters. It will also continue to provide a base for community safety activity which will work proactively within the community to reduce the incidence of fire related events.

9.6 The shift arrangements will remain unchanged; the reduction from three to two continually staffed fire appliances improves efficiency and provides better value for money. This can be achieved by removing 24 fulltime posts from the establishment.

9.7 Another front line fire appliance will be strategically located at the new fire station as part of

WYFRS’ resilience arrangements as previously described (Para 4.8).

9.8 Financial Implications

The merging of Dewsbury and Batley will provide efficiency savings of four Watch Managers, four Crew Managers and 16 firefighters. In order to bring about these changes it will be necessary to invest £3.0m in capital to construct the new fire station. The table below summarises the financial implications of these changes.

Dewsbury Batley

Salary Number Full year Cost\Saving Reduction in staffing Firefighters £36,000 -16 -£576,000 Crew managers £40,000 -4 -£160,000 Watch managers £49,000 -4 -£196,000

-£932,000

Saving in running expenses -£220,000 23

Net staffing savings -£1,152,000 Capital expenditure £3,000,000 Capital financing charges £180,000 Net saving -£972,000

NOTE: Salary includes on costs

10 PROPOSAL 7 – GIPTON AND STANKS FIRE STATIONS

10.1 This proposal involves the construction of a new fire station to replace the fire stations at Gipton and Stanks. The new station will be sited in an optimum location with the provision of two fire appliances and one Resilience Pump. If approved, this proposal will be introduced between 2013 and 2017. (See Appendix 7 for the business case).

10.2 The North East Area of West Yorkshire currently has two fire appliances at stations at Gipton, Leeds and Moortown. , Stanks, and Rothwell stations each house one fire appliance. North East Leeds (in particular Gipton) has historically been an area that has experienced higher numbers of fires and rescues. The coordinated risk reduction work undertaken with partner organisations, local communities and the highly successful Arson Task Force has, resulted in a 28% reduction in incidents at Gipton and Stanks between 2004/5 and 2009/10 (there has been a reduction of 61% of serious fires) .

10.3 Notwithstanding this success in reducing risk it is also recognised that the level of risk within this area of the county is still Very High and warrants the provision of a swift fire and rescue response. The provision of a new station will replace the ageing fire station at Gipton and will resolve the 24 access and egress restrictions caused by traffic calming measures at Stanks fire station.

10.4 The proposal is to build a new fire station in the Killingbeck/Seacroft area that houses two front line fire appliances replacing the existing fire stations at Gipton and Stanks. The existing three front line fire appliances will be reduced to two located at the new station, plus one Resilience Pump.

10.5 The new station will be built to a high specification and will provide modern accommodation and training facilities for firefighters. It will also continue to provide a base for the Arson Task Force team who work proactively within the community to reduce the incidence of fire setting. WYFRS’ continued commitment to work closely with local communities will be reflected by the provision of improved facilities available for use by local partners and community groups. WYFRS will also continue to work with local schools to support younger members of the community by delivering the Young Firefighters Scheme at this fire station.

10.6 The shift arrangements will remain unchanged; the reduction from three to two continually staffed fire appliances improves efficiency and provides better value for money. This can be achieved by removing 24 fulltime posts from the establishment by way of planned retirements.

10.7 Another front line fire appliance will be strategically located at the new fire station as part of WYFRS’ resilience arrangements as previously described (Para 4.8).

10.8 Financial Implications

The merging of Gipton and Stanks will provide efficiency savings of four Watch Managers, four Crew Managers and 16 firefighters. In order to bring about these changes it will be necessary to invest £3.0m in capital to construct the new fire station and suitable accommodation. The table below summarises the financial implications of these changes.

Gipton stanks

Salary Number Full year Cost\Saving Reduction in staffing Firefighters £36,000 -16 -£576,000 Crew managers £40,000 -4 -£160,000 Watch managers £49,000 -4 -£196,000

-£932,000

Saving in running expenses -£220,000 25

Net staffing savings -£1,152,000 Capital expenditure £3,000,000 Capital financing charges £180,000 Net saving -£972,000

NOTE: Salary includes on costs

11 EQUALITY AND DIVERSITY IMPLICATIONS

11.1 The Fire and Rescue Service is delivered to the whole community of West Yorkshire. The challenge is that service provision needs to be proportionate to the risks from fire and related incidents within individual communities. The level of risk is not the same across the county; some communities are safer than others.

11.2 This requires a greater level of prevention, protection and response services being provided where the risk is greatest and where communities are more vulnerable to fire related incidents.

11.3 The obvious consequence of this strategy is that fewer resources are deployed in areas where the communities are at less risk from fire.

11.4 Targeted community safety (prevention) activities are undertaken to identify individuals and families who are particularly vulnerable with regard to fire related incidents due to lifestyle factors, irrespective of where they live.

26 11.5 The objective behind the Public Sector Equality Duty is to ensure that WYFRS considers equality issues as part of its decision making and routine day to day operational service delivery.

11.6 The way in which WYFRS ensures that equality issues are embedded at a strategic planning level is via the Service Plan and Service Delivery Framework, both of which are supported by the Corporate Driving Diversity Board. This enables strategic decisions to be fully informed by equality analysis.

11.7 At a local level WYFRS endeavours to deliver its services in a manner which is tailored to the needs of individuals and communities, this is supported by the completion of Equality Impact Assessments (EIA). An EIA has been completed for each proposal and is included within each business case.

12 CONCLUSIONS

12.1 The proposals in this paper represent a significant reduction in firefighter posts, yet maintain appropriate levels of emergency response; this strategy avoids the need for wholetime compulsory redundancies by aligning the introduction of the changes to the retirement profile.

12.2 Due to the timescales involved in the identification and procurement of land, obtaining planning consent and construction of new fire stations, it would not be possible to deliver the same efficiencies by the adoption of compulsory redundancies without impacting on public and firefighter safety.

12.3 The proposals have been supported by comprehensive business cases and are proportionate to risk.

12.4 The proposals put forward are those that have the least impact on service delivery, yet contribute significantly to addressing the budget gap.

12.5 The Service Delivery Framework and range of community safety initiatives that are being undertaken have been designed to reduce the impact of such changes. 27

28

INTEGRATED RISK MANAGEMENT ACTION PLAN 2012-2013