DOCSLIB.ORG

State Effectiveness and Political Will: the Case of Malaria Control in Uganda and Rwanda by Hussein Kasim a Thesis Submitted To

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
State Effectiveness and Political Will: the Case of Malaria Control in Uganda and Rwanda by Hussein Kasim a Thesis Submitted To State Effectiveness and Political Will: The Case of Malaria Control in Uganda and Rwanda By Hussein Kasim A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy In Public Policy Carleton University Ottawa, Canada @Hussein Kasim, 2018 Abstract Employing a comparative case study and using state effectiveness as a conceptual framework, this research explores malaria and its control in Uganda and Rwanda. These two neighbouring countries, which share a significant number of socio-economic characteristics, have been implementing the malaria control policies widely recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO). Despite their similarities, and the implementation of comparable malaria control policies, the two countries have experienced divergent outcomes: a reduction in malaria-related hospital admission and death rates in Rwanda, and an overall increase in malaria-related hospitalizations and deaths in Uganda during the same 2000-2015 period. During fieldwork in both countries over the span of several months, data was collected using key informant interviews; observation at four sites; and examination of government documents. The key findings suggest that the variation in malaria policy outcomes is due largely to political factors including the role of political leaders and institutions (i.e. the Presidency, the ruling party and parliament), and not to technical factors, as most of the literature suggests. The politicization of malaria and its control in Rwanda (i.e. putting responsibility for malaria control in the hands of political leaders), and the de- politicization of malaria control in Uganda explains the divergence in malaria control outcomes. ii Acknowledgements I am grateful to a number of individuals who have made the completion of this dissertation possible. I would like to thank the study participants in both Uganda and Rwanda, who have not only shared key insights about the two countries, but also connected me to key informants and provided me with access to documents. Some of these participants took personal risks to contribute to this research. I have been privileged to have Professor Lisa Mills as my stalwart dissertation supervisor. Without Dr. Lisa Mills’ unwavering support and guidance, this project would not have been completed. Dr. Mills is undoubtedly the best thesis supervisor any doctoral student could wish for. Similarly, I have enormously benefitted from the support and inputs of my dissertation committee members Valerie Percival, Christopher Stoney, and Anil Varughese. Professor Saul Swartz, the director of the PhD program, also kept believing in me. He provided advice and a much needed push to complete this project. I have been blessed and humbled by the steadfast support of my loving wife, Sahra Abdikadir. Her devotion to the success of this project and dedication to care for our lovely three kids, when I have been swamped with PhD life is towering. My kids, Aisha, Layla and Hashi, have been truly patient with me. I am grateful for your understanding and support for all those years. I am also grateful for other members of the family who have always been there for me including my mom, Aisha Yusuf, my brothers Ismail Kasim, Mohamed Kasim, and Abdirisak Kasim. My cousins Fowsia Abdulkadir, Sahra Abdulkadir, Nafisa M. Dahri and Abdullahi M. Hussein, Kamil Hussein, Idil Abdulkadir and Awo (Adar) Abdulkadir provided support and encouragement through the process. I would like to thank a number of people whose support was instrumental in completing this project. They include my friends Salah Jama and Dr. Hodan Shafie Mohamed who have read and critiqued my work. Other friends including Amin Mahdi, Mustafe iii Muhumed (Cagjar), Abdiwasa Mahdi, Gamal Hassan, Naima Elmi, Dr Hamdi Mohamed, Prof. Afyare Elmi, Professor Abdi I Samatar, Ikram Jama, Farrah Hussein, Daud Abdi, and Dr Abdiwasa Bade made the process of writing and rewriting the dissertation more pleasant. I wou like to thank Mulugeta Gebru, everyone’s favorite Carleton University librarian for his continues support arguably at Carleton’s main corrdior of knowledge - the MacOdrum library. I would like to thank my colleagues at work including Marieke Denissen, Abdullahi Gabho, Karen Mahy, Mathew Bryden, Abdihakim Yusuf, Mukhtar Omar, and Suleiman Mohamed who made sure I got the space and time I needed to finalize the dissertation. Lastly, many thanks to my incredible editor, Lyndal Neelin. iv Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................ ii Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................ iii Table of Contents ................................................................................................................ v List of Tables .................................................................................................................... viii List of Figures ..................................................................................................................... ix List of Abbreviations ........................................................................................................... x CHAPTER I .........................................................................................................................1 INTRODUCTION ..............................................................................................................1 Similar policies, different outcomes: Malaria control in Uganda and Rwanda .......................... 1 Research problem and question .................................................................................................. 2 Argument ..................................................................................................................................... 8 Approaches to understanding malaria and its control ............................................................... 10 The biomedical science approach to malaria and its control. ................................................................... 11 The socio-economic approach to malaria and its control. ........................................................................ 13 The behavioural/cultural approach to malaria and its control. ................................................................ 16 The need for a political approach to malaria and its control. ................................................................... 18 Analytical framework: Assessing state effectiveness .................................................................. 21 Research design and methodology ............................................................................................ 23 Primary research question. ............................................................................................................................. 23 Methodology: Comparative case study. ........................................................................................................ 24 Why a small N case study and why Uganda and Rwanda?........................................................................ 25 Data collection and analysis. .......................................................................................................................... 27 Contributions of the research .................................................................................................... 32 Structure of the thesis ................................................................................................................ 34 CHAPTER II .................................................................................................................... 38 ANALYTICAL FRAMEWORK ........................................................................................ 38 The State defined ....................................................................................................................... 39 The role of the state in development and health ....................................................................... 39 Unpacking state effectiveness ................................................................................................... 45 State autonomy and health. ............................................................................................................................ 46 State capacity and health. ................................................................................................................................ 56 Political will and health. .................................................................................................................................. 63 The interconnectedness of political will, state autonomy and capacity. .................................................. 68 Conclusions ............................................................................................................................... 69 CHAPTER III .................................................................................................................... 71 COMBATTING MALARIA: THE EVOLUTION OF THE INTERNATIONAL POLICY RESPONSE AND ITS POLICY IMPLICATIONS FOR UGANDA AND RWANDA ........................................................................................................................... 71 Malaria: An ancient killer disease in Uganda, Rwanda, and the world ....................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Rhode Island M Edical J Ournal
    RHODE ISLAND M EDICAL J OURNAL SPECIAL SECTION GLOBAL HEALTH GUEST EDITORS: ADAM C. LEVINE, MD, MPH; ALISON S. HAYWARD, MD, MPH SEPTEMBER 2019 VOLUME 102 • NUMBER 7 ISSN 2327-2228 RHODE ISLAND M EDICAL J OURNAL 16 Little Rhody Goes Global ADAM C. LEVINE, MD, MPH; ALISON S. HAYWARD, MD, MPH GUEST EDITORS 17 Addressing Global Human Rights Violations in Rhode Island: The Brown Human Rights Asylum Clinic ODETTE ZERO, BA, MD-ScM ‘22; MARGA KEMPNER, BA, MD ‘22; SARAH HSU, BA, MD-ScM ‘22; HEBA HALEEM, BA, MD ‘22; ELIZABETH TOLL, MD; ELIZABETH TOBIN-TYLER, JD, MA A. Levine, MD, MPH A. Hayward, MD, MPH 21 Obstetric Fistula Repair in Sub-Saharan Africa: Partnering to Create Sustainable Impact for Patients and Trainees AMITA KULKARNI, MD; ANNETTA MADSEN, MD; SARAH ANDIMAN, MD; ARLENE NISHIMWE, MD; B. STAR HAMPTON, MD 25 A Collaborative Family Planning Program in Rural Uganda Utilizing Community Health Workers ALISON S. HAYWARD, MD, MPH; KELSEY BROWN, MD’22 28 Tele-ECHO for Point-of-Care Ultrasound in Rural Kenya: A Feasibility Study LINDSAY DREIZLER, MD’21; GRACE W. WANJIKU, MD, MPH 32 Building and Sustaining Partnerships in Health Workforce and Research Capacity in Rwanda STEPHANIE C. GARBERN, MD, MPH; KYLE D. MARTIN, MD; CATALINA GONZALEZ- MARQUES, MD; OLIVIER FÉLIX UMUHIRE, MD; DORIS LORETTE UWAMAHORO, MD; ADAM R. ALUISIO, MD, MSc; ADAM C. LEVINE, MD, MPH 36 Developing a Novel Mobile Health (mHealth) Tool to Improve Dehydration Assessment and Management Rwandan emergency medicine residents and inter- in Patients with Acute Diarrhea in Resource-Limited Settings national faculty outside of the ambulance entrance MONIQUE GAINEY, MS, MPH; MEAGAN BARRY, MD, PhD; at the Kigali University Teaching Hospital.
    [Show full text]
  • Report on the Health Care Sector and Business Opportunities in Rwanda
    Report on the Health Care Sector and Business Opportunities in Rwanda Kristina Leuchowius for SWECARE FOUNDATION September 2014 Table of Contents Abbreviations ..................................................................................................................................................................................... I Preface .............................................................................................................................................................................................. II 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................................................................................ 1 1.1 General .......................................................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1.1 Why Rwanda? ........................................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1.2 Health is a prioritized sector ..................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1.3 Health sector bottlenecks and needs ....................................................................................................................... 1 1.1.4 Perception of Swedish technology and health sector .............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Strengthening Health Systems
    Strengthening health systems Evidence-informed approaches and lessons learned from Rwanda ‘Institutional Support to Ministry of Health – Phase IV’ (Minisanté IV) Program Capitalization and Knowledge Management: generating lessons from program implementation and translating them into concrete actions at managerial and technical levels for increased ownership, evidence-based policy development and sharing of good practices This booklet is a product of the Ministry of Health in Rwanda in collaboration with the ‘Institutional Support to Ministry of Health – Phase IV’ (Minisanté IV) Program through support from the Belgian Development Agency. The book capitalizes on the work done within the BTC- Rwanda partnership and reflects on different components such as health system strengthening, Strengtheningmaternal health, mental health, urban health, health health technologies and ecologicalsystems interventions, decentralization and aid modalities reflections. It is also a reflection on the value of results achieved and the progress made through the whole institutional support process while providing an appreciation of the relevance, efficiency, effectiveness, sustainability and impact of planned Evidence-informedinterventions. In addition, this book is seen approaches as an intensive sharing and and learning lessons opportunity in order to draw useful lessons for other similar interventions, new policies and strategies in other learnedcountries and future from partnerships Rwanda in Rwanda. Strengthening health systems Evidence-informed approaches
    [Show full text]
  • Causes of Death and Predictors of Childhood Mortality in Rwanda: a Matched Case-Control Study Using Verbal Social Autopsy Neil Gupta1,3,4* , Lisa R
    Gupta et al. BMC Public Health (2018) 18:1378 https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-018-6282-z RESEARCHARTICLE Open Access Causes of death and predictors of childhood mortality in Rwanda: a matched case-control study using verbal social autopsy Neil Gupta1,3,4* , Lisa R. Hirschhorn2, Felix C. Rwabukwisi3, Peter Drobac1,3,4, Felix Sayinzoga5, Cathy Mugeni5, Fulgence Nkikabahizi5, Tatien Bucyana5, Hema Magge1,3, Daniel M. Kagabo3, Evrard Nahimana3, Dominique Rouleau3, Amelia VanderZanden6, Megan Murray1,4 and Cheryl Amoroso3 Abstract Background: Rwanda has dramatically reduced child mortality, but the causes and sociodemographic drivers for mortality are poorly understood. Methods: We conducted a matched case-control study of all children who died before 5 years of age in eastern Rwanda between 1st March 2013 and 28th February 2014 to identify causes and risk factors for death. We identified deaths at the facility level and via a community health worker reporting system. We used verbal social autopsy to interview caregivers of deceased children and controls matched by area and age. We used InterVA4 to determine probable causes of death and cause-specific mortality fractions, and utilized conditional logistic regression to identify clinical, family, and household risk factors for death. Results: We identified 618 deaths including 174 (28.2%) in neonates and 444 (71.8%) in non-neonates. The most commonly identified causes of death were pneumonia, birth asphyxia, and meningitis among neonates and malaria, acute respiratory infections, and HIV/AIDS-related death among non-neonates. Among neonates, 54 (31.0%) deaths occurred at home and for non-neonates 242 (54.5%) deaths occurred at home.
    [Show full text]
  • Research the Health-Related Millennium Development Goals (Mdgs)
    Open Access Research The health-related Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) 2015: Rwanda performance and contributing factors Médard Nyandekwe1, Jean Baptiste Kakoma1, Manassé Nzayirambaho1,& 1University of Rwanda, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, School of Public Health, Kigali, Rwanda &Corresponding author: Manassé Nzayirambaho, University of Rwanda, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, School of Public Health, Kigali, Rwanda Key words: Rwanda, Millennium Development Goals, Health-related targets Received: 23/10/2016 - Accepted: 06/08/2018 - Published: 26/09/2018 Abstract Introduction: The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) 2015 are the eight international development goals adopted by the Millennium Summit of the United Nations in 2000 to which Rwanda is signatory. In 1990, Rwanda was at least one of the Sub-Saharan Africa countries with poor performance on health-related MDGs indicators. To date, despite the setbacks caused by the 1994 genocide, impressive performance is registered. The objective of the study is to document Rwanda gradual progress to achieving the health-related MDGs 2015 targets from 1990 to 2014/2015. Methods: The study is retrospective and comparative documenting the period of 1990 to 2014/15. Results: The performance of Rwanda on health-related MDGs 2015 targets is impressive despite the negative effects of the 1990-1994 civil wars and the 1994 genocide against Tutsi on 1990's levels. In effect, out of 17 health-related MDGs indicators, eleven (11) registered "remarkable" performances, i.e. reached global levels or fastened Vision 2020 targets attainment, two (2) registered "good performances", i.e. reached basic or revised own targets exhibiting overall impressive performance, while four (4) "weaknesses" are observed, i.e.
    [Show full text]
  • Evaluation of PEPFAR's Contribution (2012-2017) to Rwanda's Human Resources for Health Program (2020)
    THE NATIONAL ACADEMIES PRESS This PDF is available at http://nap.edu/25687 SHARE Evaluation of PEPFAR's Contribution (2012-2017) to Rwanda's Human Resources for Health Program (2020) DETAILS 270 pages | 6 x 9 | PAPERBACK ISBN 978-0-309-67205-4 | DOI 10.17226/25687 CONTRIBUTORS GET THIS BOOK Committee on the Evaluation of Strengthening Human Resources for Health Capacity in the Republic of Rwanda Under the President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR); Board on Global Health; Health and Medicine Division; National FIND RELATED TITLES Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine SUGGESTED CITATION National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2020. Evaluation of PEPFAR's Contribution (2012-2017) to Rwanda's Human Resources for Health Program. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/25687. Visit the National Academies Press at NAP.edu and login or register to get: – Access to free PDF downloads of thousands of scientific reports – 10% off the price of print titles – Email or social media notifications of new titles related to your interests – Special offers and discounts Distribution, posting, or copying of this PDF is strictly prohibited without written permission of the National Academies Press. (Request Permission) Unless otherwise indicated, all materials in this PDF are copyrighted by the National Academy of Sciences. Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved. Evaluation of PEPFAR's Contribution (2012-2017) to Rwanda's Human Resources for Health Program Evaluation of PEPFAR’s Contribution (2012–2017) to Rwanda’s Human Resources for Health Program Committee on the Evaluation of Strengthening Human Resources for Health Capacity in the Republic of Rwanda Under the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR) Board on Global Health Health and Medicine Division A Consensus Study Report of PREPUBLICATION COPY: UNCORRECTED PROOFS Copyright National Academy of Sciences.
    [Show full text]
  • Health Sector Performance Report FY 2019-2020
    Rwanda Health Sector Performance Report 2019-2020 TABLE OF CONTENT FOREWORD ....................................................................................................................................................... i TABLE OF CONTENT ......................................................................................................................................... ii LIST OF TABLES................................................................................................................................................ vii LIST OF FIGURES ............................................................................................................................................. viii LIST OF ACRONYMS .......................................................................................................................................... 1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................................ 3 1. HEALTHCARE SERVICE DELIVERY .............................................................................................................. 3 1.1. Outpatient department (OPD) visits in health facilities ..................................................................... 3 1.2. Hospitalization .................................................................................................................................. 5 1.3. Access to clinical laboratory services ...............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 2014‑2018 Rwanda
    WHO COUNTRY COOPERATION STRATEGY 2014-2018 RWANDA WHO Country Cooperation Strategy 2014-2018 1 Contents Abbreviation............................................................................................................. 4 Preface...................................................................................................................... 7 Executive summary....................................................................................................8 1. Introduction.........................................................................................................11 2. Health and development challenges and national response ................................13 2.1. Macroeconomic, political and social context .....................................................13 2.2. Major determinants of health.............................................................................14 2.3. Health status of the population..........................................................................18 2.4. National responses to health challenges............................................................21 2.5. Health systems and services..............................................................................21 2.6. Contributions of Rwanda to the global health agenda.......................................24 2.7. Summary............................................................................................................26 3. Development cooperation and partnerships........................................................28
    [Show full text]
  • Uganda's Economic Development
    CHECK REALITY UGANDA’S ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT THE CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES OF CLIMATE CHANGE Emmanuel Kasimbazi This project is funded by Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung e.V. Uganda Plot 51 A, Prince Charles Drive, Kololo, P.O. Box 647 Kampala, Uganda Tel: +256 - (0)312 - 262011/2 www.kas.de/Uganda Uganda’s Economic Development REALITY CHECK UGANDA’S ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT THE CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES OF CLIMATE CHANGE Emmanuel Kasimbazi The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung but rather those of the author. i REALITY CHECK UGANDA’S ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT THE CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES OF CLIMATE CHANGE Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung, Uganda Programme 51A, Prince Charles Drive, Kololo P.O. Box 647, Kampala Tel: +256 - (0)312 - 262011/2 www.kas.de/uganda ISBN: 978 9970 477 00 5 Author: Dr. Emmanuel Kasimbazi Design and Production Media PH Limited Plot 4 Pilkington Road Tel: +256 (0) 312 371217 Email: [email protected] © Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung e.V. 2013 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, without written permission of the Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ..................................................................... v FOREWORD .................................................................................. vi LIST OF FIGURES AND PHOTOS .................................................. viii LIST OF TABLES .........................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Aid in Uganda
    and Policies by Ralph Giark I 5S Uti Overseas Development Institute Aid in Uganda The Overseas Development Institute has started a series of studies which look at the problems of aid as seen by recipient countries. The first country chosen for such a study was Uganda. Aid in Uganda is a three-part study of the impact of aid in that country and of the problems of an aid recipient as seen by Uganda itself. The first two parts of the Study, Part I Aid in Uganda—Programmes and Policies and Part II Aid in Uganda—Education have now both been completed. Part III in the series, Aid in Uganda—Agriculture by Hal Mettrick, will follow later in the year. Part I Aid in Uganda—Programmes and Policies by Ralph Clark (15/-) This first general study examines the background, development planning in the colonial period, the first Uganda Five Year Plan, and aid and the influence of political factors. After this general survey the author looks in particular at British aid, American aid and problems of technical assistance. In his conclusions, the author demonstrates the distorting effects of tied aid upon the economy of a developing country, and pleads that since politically tied aid is likely to continue anyway it should be at least applied whenever possible to projects. He also argues that the British High Com­ mission should be given more technical staff to deal with matters of aid and links tViis with the need for greater consultation among donors res­ ponsible for aid programmes in Uganda. Part II Aid in Uganda—Education by Peter Williams (20/-) This study examines the impact of external educational aid to Uganda.
    [Show full text]
  • Uganda. Industrial Development Review Series
    OCCASION This publication has been made available to the public on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the United Nations Industrial Development Organisation. DISCLAIMER This document has been produced without formal United Nations editing. The designations employed and the presentation of the material in this document do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the Secretariat of the United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO) concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries, or its economic system or degree of development. Designations such as “developed”, “industrialized” and “developing” are intended for statistical convenience and do not necessarily express a judgment about the stage reached by a particular country or area in the development process. Mention of firm names or commercial products does not constitute an endorsement by UNIDO. FAIR USE POLICY Any part of this publication may be quoted and referenced for educational and research purposes without additional permission from UNIDO. However, those who make use of quoting and referencing this publication are requested to follow the Fair Use Policy of giving due credit to UNIDO. CONTACT Please contact [email protected] for further information concerning UNIDO publications. For more information about UNIDO, please visit us at www.unido.org UNITED NATIONS INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATION Vienna International Centre, P.O. Box 300, 1400 Vienna, Austria Tel: (+43-1) 26026-0 · www.unido.org · [email protected] ! \ . I. I •• 2 I t?l/.6 Distr. LIMITED RPD.5 4 September 1997 Original: ENGLISH UNITED NATIONS INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATION SERIES Sustained stabilization ancJ I·,~-~.1 ,mi.~ ......
    [Show full text]
  • Achieving Uganda's Development Ambition
    ACHIEVING UGANDA’S DEVELOPMENT AMBITION The Economic Impact of Green Growth: An Agenda for Action A Report by the Government of Uganda and the New Climate Economy Partnership November 2016 THE REPUBLIC OF UGANDA THE REPUBLIC OF UGANDA About this paper This paper was jointly prepared by the Government of Uganda through the Ministry of Finance, Planning and Economic Development (MFPED), the Ugandan Economic Policy Research Centre (EPRC) Uganda, the Global Green Growth Institute (GGGI), the New Climate Economy (NCE), and the Coalition for Urban Transitions (an NCE Special Initiative). Ministry of Finance, Planning and Economic Development Plot 2/12 Apollo Kaggwa Road P.O.Box 8147 Kampala, Uganda +256-414-707000 COALITION FOR URBAN TRANSITIONS A New Climate Economy Special Initiative Foreword As Uganda embarks on accelerating its economic development, the Government is taking conscious steps to ensure that growth is socially inclusive and that the protection of the environment is upheld. The Second National Development Plan and the Vision 2040 strategy set out Uganda’s development priorities. The forthcoming Green Growth Strategy, which the fndings of this report will support, will comprehensively address challenges and opportunities to ensure Uganda’s development trajectory is sustainable, in accordance with the Sustainable Development Goals and the ambitious climate change commitments this Government pledged a year ago at the 21st Conference of Parties in Paris. Uganda’s economic transformation and the related growing demand for energy, water and other natural resources as well as unprecedented levels of urbanisation pose immense challenges to the Government of Uganda’s commitment to sustainable development. Against this background, research and analysis of green growth related issues will support the integrated long-term planning by the Government.
    [Show full text]