The “Im Tirtzu” Attack on Prof. Naomi Chazan – an Ominous Hour for Israeli Democracy

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Meretz USA: The “Im Tirtzu” attack on Prof. Naomi Chazan – an ominous hour for Israeli democracy On February 2, Meretz USA President Lawrence Lerner and Chair Theodore Bikel issued the following statement to the press: This is an ominous hour for Israeli democracy. The recent attack on the New Israel Fund and its President, Prof. Naomi Chazan, by the Im Tirtzu organization – base and reprehensible as it is – is just the most recent in a frighteningly consistent series of events in Israel that evokes the McCarthy period in America, and worse. The thuggish Im Tirtzu ad campaign, depicting Prof. Chazan, a three-term Meretz MK and Deputy Speaker of the Knesset, as a treasonous “informant”, should serve as a chilling reminder of how quickly a society can degenerate when the right to criticize one’s own government policy is delegitimized. Im Tirtzu is just the latest manifestation of this worrying trend. But after the Jewish-terrorist bomb attack against peace activist, Prof. Ze’ev Sternhell, in 2008; the attempt to ban Arab parties from running in the 2009 Knesset elections; the branding of Peace Now as a “virus” by Vice Premier Moshe Ya’alon; and the defamatory remarks made about the “Breaking the Silence” organization by Prime Minister Netanyahu – not to mention Avigdor Lieberman’s proposal of a “loyalty test” for citizenship – the Im Tirtzu campaign, in truth, should not come as a complete surprise. The attack on Prof. Chazan is also further proof – if we needed it – of the corrosive effects of the Occupation. Although the Occupation might legally stop at the Green Line border, its fundamentally anti-democratic character continues to seep into Israeli society, poisoning its values, weakening its foundations and creating the environment in which groups like Im Tirtzu can thrive. Meretz USA calls on all those who care about Israeli democracy to stand up in solidarity with Prof. Chazan, the New Israel Fund and the many important organizations it supports, which are working to promote pluralism, equality and justice in Israel. And we call upon the Israeli government to publicly condemn the Im Tirtzu campaign, so that Israeli citizens will know that their elected officials can be counted upon to defend their basic rights and freedoms..

Copy Link

Recommended publications

2 Israeli Attacks on Human Rights Organizations and Activists Palestinian Centre for Human Rights 2019 3
2 Israeli Attacks on Human Rights Organizations and Activists Palestinian Centre for Human Rights 2019 3 Contents Introduction 8 Part I 11 Isolation of the Victim :Shrinking Space for NGOs in the oPt by the Israeli occupation 1. The belligerent occupation attempts to criminalize the victim: Smear 13 campaigns against human rights defenders 2 .Sanctions and the Restrictions on Freedom of Movement 29 3 .Attempts to Defund Human Rights Organizations 33 4 .Threatening human rights defenders 35 Part II 38 International Standards for Human Rights Defenders 1. International Conventions 39 2 .States ’Obligations towards Human Rights Defenders 44 Conclusion and Recommendations 46 4 Israeli Attacks on Human Rights Organizations and Activists Palestinian Centre for Human Rights 2019 5 Preface From the moment we took it upon ourselves to defend human rights and civilians in times of war, we were conscious to both the dignity in our mission and the dangers it bears on our lives and security as human rights defenders. Nonetheless, human dignity and advocating for the rights of victims were at the heart of our mission, our life goal and purpose. We were armed with the international law’s rules and mechanisms, which is the fruit of many peoples’ experiences and struggles to identify justice from injustice, in our mission to protect humans and their rights to live a dignified life. Decades passed and we fought via every legal route we had available tirelessly, without a single moment of hesitation in the face of the Israeli occupation’s restrictions and threats. As the occu- pation continued without rest to put hurdles in our path, and enjoyed the illusion of depriving us from the means and mechanisms to defend the defeated and oppressed, our will never waned and we were never persuaded to drift from the path we chose to tread, because it is our deep belief that we have no choice but to stand tall and defend, as Palestinian people, our existence, dignity and right to self-determination.
[Show full text]
The Rise and Fall of Israel's Bilateral Aid Budget 1958-2008
A mere ten years after Israel gained its independence from British mandatory rule in 1948, it launched an official development cooperation program. At a time when Israel was itself still a developing country, it began a training and technical assistance program that expanded within a few short years to include the dispatch of hundreds of Israeli technical assistants to other developing countries and the training of thousands of Africans, Asians and Latin Americans annually. Driven by both political necessity and the moral vision of Israel’s leaders, the program rapidly grew in size and scope. At its height, in the late 1960s and early 1970s, MASHAV, the government body responsible for managing the aid program, was the largest department in Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and Israel had, per capita, one of the most extensive technical assistance programs in the western world. Unfortunately, this vision of cooperation, at least as far as Africa was concerned, proved to be short-lived. Within 15 years of the establishment The Rise and of Israel’s official aid program, the "golden age" of Israel's development cooperation came to an abrupt end, as all but four African countries Fall severed relations with Israel in the wake of the October 1973 Arab-Israeli War. Africa’s rejection of Israel dealt a deep blow to Israeli public and of Israel's political support for its aid program, marking a turning point from which Bilateral Aid Israel technical assistance has never recovered. The rupture of relations led to an immediate 50% drop in MASHAV’s operational budget and further Budget substantial budgetary cuts over the past 35 years.
[Show full text]
S New Mccarthyism
Israel’s New McCarthyism Peter Dreier published the following article in The American Prospect. Dreier teaches politics and chairs the Urban & Environmental Policy Department at Occidental College. His latest book is The 100 Greatest Americans of the 20th Century: A Social Justice Hall of Fame (Nation Books, 2012). The article examines the growing attacks on Israel’s progressive civil rights and human rights movement (such as Breaking the Silence) and on the New Israel Fund by the Netanyahu’s government and extremist groups like Im Tirtzu: Israel’s New McCarthyism Inside the well-organized campaign against Israel’s progressive community. As international discontent with Israel’s occupation policy continues to rise, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government and Israel’s ultra-right-wing movement have escalated their attacks on the country’s progressive community, which opposes the 49-year-old Israeli occupation of the West Bank and the ever-expanding government-subsidized settlements. This week, the Knesset is expected to take up a bill backed by Netanyahu and his allies that will require Israeli nongovernmental organizations that expose and challenge the government’s human rights abuses against Palestinians to register, in effect, as foreign agents. Some Israeli activists call the legislation their country’s version of McCarthyism. Others liken what’s happening in Israel as similar to the current attack on Planned Parenthood by Republicans and their more successful campaign several years ago to dismantle the community organizing group ACORN. The attack includes the recent publication of a report and the release of a video, both sponsored by the ultra-nationalist group Im Tirtzu (literally, “if you will it”).
[Show full text]
The Lieberman We Need to Worry About
The Lieberman We Need To Worry About Israeli Minister of Minority Affairs Avishai Braverman (Labor) thinks Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman should be fired from his ministry for saying that an end to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict “…is not achievable in the next year or in the next generation.” One understands Braverman’s point. Lieberman was, after all, not just offering an analysis. He himself is one of the main reasons that the pessimism he expresses exists. Lieberman is not merely a bystander offering a judgment, but an actor working against the sorts of resolutions that have, for more than 15 years, made up the foundation of a two-state solution. But Braverman’s solution wouldn’t really change much. Lieberman’s “role” as Foreign Minister has been thoroughly curtailed. Indeed, every now and then, Lieberman, who is well aware of his marginalization in the Netanyahu government, bristles and has a public spat with his boss, Benjamin Netanyahu. Bibi might toss Lieberman some kind of bone, but he has made it clear that Lieberman is not part of the inner circle. His opinion, in and of itself, carries no weight, and Bibi’s only concern (and it is a serious one) is what Lieberman can do domestically to rally people against the Likud leader. This was evidenced once again at the Washington launch of direct talks between Israel and the Palestinians last week. Surely, any country’s foreign minister should be present at such a momentous event. But Lieberman couldn’t make it as he had a very important job in bringing his diplomatic powers to bear on the sensitive and crucial relationship between Israel and … Cyprus.
[Show full text]
Lfein Forward Template
February 19th, 2010 Im Tirtzu in Goldstone's Footsteps By Leonard Fein By and large, I resist conspiratorial explanation of events. Most often, coincidence governs; things that seem related have arrived together from different sources, and their togetherness is curious rather than significant. Now, however, I admit to alarm. We are witness to an escalating series of events that begin to feel cumulative, moving faster and faster to subvert Israel’s democracy and transform its political and social life into a kind of Absurdistan. As so often happens, the first steps in this new and perilous direction were barely noticed. A nip at freedom of expression here, a tuck at dissent there, another permit refused, another home demolished, another protest quashed. No big deal, except to those directly involved. The police put down a demonstration the courts have permitted, and still more people show up the following week. An opaque organization called NGO Monitor whines tediously on about the lack of transparency in Israeli NGOs, and the earth still spins safely in its orbit. But suddenly in recent days, the dots have begun to seem connected. The precipitating event was the publication, in Israel, of a document of 69 pages (plus 43 pages of appendices) alleging that save for the support of organizations funded (in part) by the New Israel Fund, there’d have been no Goldstone Report. This utterly preposterous allegation is quite explicit. It appears, among other places, in a full-page ad by the document’s publisher, an organization called Im Tirtzu (“if you will it …”): “Fact,” the ad asserts in large letters: “Without the New Israel Fund, there could be no Goldstone Report, and Israel would not be facing international accusations of war crimes.” 1 The Im Tirtzu report was immediately picked up by the Israeli press — most provocatively by Ben Caspit in Maariv, and insult was added to insult when Im Tirtzu took a full- page ad in The Jerusalem Post that featured a crude caricature of the NIF’s president, Naomi Chazan.
[Show full text]
State Infringement on Basic Civil and Political Rights in Israel (From Mossawa)
State infringement on basic civil and political rights in Israel (from Mossawa) This past year has seen a series of arrest of prominent political and civil society leaders, especially during peaceful demonstrations, which are indicative of the effect of the current government’s policies and actions on the exercise of basic civil and political rights, such as the freedom of speech and the right to demonstrate. Moreover, a government-backed bill threatening the independence and the work of Human Rights NGOs in Israel is currently being discussed at the Knesset. In 2009, over 70 people were arrested during a weekly peaceful demonstration in Sheikh Jarrah.1 In addition, seven hundred protesters were arrested during demonstrations to protest the war on Gaza.2 When considering these arrests, one must also take into account the recent government backed law granting amnesty to all 400 settlers who violently demonstrated against the Gaza disengagement.3 Again, in March 2010, the Israeli law enforcement authorities responded to protests in Jerusalem against the stagnation of the peace process by locking the city, which proceeded to massive arrests of demonstrators and the use of grenades and rubber-bullets on unarmed people.4 Proposed legislation to restrict foreign funding to Human Rights NGOs Following the release of the “Breaking the Silence” Testimony Report - a compilation of soldier’s testimonies which contradicted the official government version of what took place during operation Cast Lead in December and January 2009 in Gaza - the Israeli government publicly announced its intention to wage an ‘aggressive battle against NGOs it deems biased against Israel’.5 In essence, such a discussion threatens almost all Human Rights groups in Israel that advocate for the rights of Palestinians, as well as groups that actively oppose the inhumanity of the occupation, the illegality of the Wall, the construction of settlements, and war crimes committed in the West Bank and Gaza.
[Show full text]
Camp David's Shadow
Camp David’s Shadow: The United States, Israel, and the Palestinian Question, 1977-1993 Seth Anziska Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY 2015 © 2015 Seth Anziska All rights reserved ABSTRACT Camp David’s Shadow: The United States, Israel, and the Palestinian Question, 1977-1993 Seth Anziska This dissertation examines the emergence of the 1978 Camp David Accords and the consequences for Israel, the Palestinians, and the wider Middle East. Utilizing archival sources and oral history interviews from across Israel, Palestine, Lebanon, the United States, and the United Kingdom, Camp David’s Shadow recasts the early history of the peace process. It explains how a comprehensive settlement to the Arab-Israeli conflict with provisions for a resolution of the Palestinian question gave way to the facilitation of bilateral peace between Egypt and Israel. As recently declassified sources reveal, the completion of the Camp David Accords—via intensive American efforts— actually enabled Israeli expansion across the Green Line, undermining the possibility of Palestinian sovereignty in the occupied territories. By examining how both the concept and diplomatic practice of autonomy were utilized to address the Palestinian question, and the implications of the subsequent Israeli and U.S. military intervention in Lebanon, the dissertation explains how and why the Camp David process and its aftermath adversely shaped the prospects of a negotiated settlement between Israelis and Palestinians in the 1990s. In linking the developments of the late 1970s and 1980s with the Madrid Conference and Oslo Accords in the decade that followed, the dissertation charts the role played by American, Middle Eastern, international, and domestic actors in curtailing the possibility of Palestinian self-determination.
[Show full text]
Naomi Chazan Curriculum Vitae Personal
NAOMI CHAZAN CURRICULUM VITAE PERSONAL Address: Cottage #1 San Martin Jerusalem 93341 Israel Telephone: 972-2-6791975 Mobile: 972-505-217614 Email: [email protected] Born: 18 November 1946, Jerusalem EDUCATION 1975 Ph.D., Departments of Political Science and African Studies, Hebrew University of Jerusalem. 1968 M.A., Political Science, Columbia University, New York. 1967 B.A. (with honors), Barnard College, Columbia University, New York. PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE 2019 Patenkin Visiting Professor of Israel Studies, Department of Political Science, University of Chicago. 2017- Senior Research Fellow, The Van Leer Jerusalem Institute. 2009-2018 Co-Director, The Center for the Advancement of Women in the Public Sphere, The Van Leer Jerusalem Institute, 2009-present. 2005-2017 Dean, School of Government and Society, The Academic College of Tel-Aviv-Yaffo 1 2004-2005 Robert Wilhelm Fellow, Center for International Studies, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) 1992-2003 Member of the Knesset (Meretz Party) 1996-1998; 1999-2003 Deputy Speaker of the Knesset 1998-1999 Chairperson, Committee to Combat Drug Abuse Parliamentary Committees: Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee (Chair: Sub-Committee on Human Resources, 2000-2003) Economics Committee Committee for the Advancement of the Status of Women (Chair: Sub-Committee on the Personal Status of Women, 1992-1996) Education Committee Immigration and Absorption Committee The Knesset (House) Committee Legislation: One of Israel’s top ten legislators during her tenure in the fields of human rights, women’s rights, consumer affairs, and civil liberties. 1992-2000 Professor, Departments of Political Science and African Studies, Hebrew University of Jerusalem (since 2000--Professor emerita). 1990-1992 Chairperson, The Harry S Truman Research Institute for the Advancement of Peace, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
[Show full text]
Ronen Shoval / HERZL's VISION
Ronen Shoval / HERZL’S VISION 2.0 HERZL’S VISION 2.0 IM TIRTZU A Manifesto for Renewed Zionism Ronen Shoval Rubin Mass Publishers, Jerusalem Herzl’s Vision 2.0 Im Tirtzu Ronen Shoval ISBN 978-965-09-0318-6 English edition: Edited by Ilana Brown © All rights reserved, 2013 Rubin Mass Ltd, Publishers and Booksellers P.O.B. 990, Jerusalem 91009, Israel Tel. +972-2-6277863 Fax. +972-2-6277864 [email protected] www.rubinmass.com www.en.imti.org.il Printed in Israel Ronen Shoval is the founder and chairman of the Im Tirtzu movement, which works towards renewal in Zionist thinking, culture and ideology in Israel. He is a graduate of the Young Leadership Forum of the Institute for Zionist Strategy and was an instructor and lecturer at the Ein Prat Social Leadership Academy. Born in Ramat Hasharon in 1980, Ronen Shoval holds a B.A. in International Relations, an M.A. in Jewish Philosophy from the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. He is currently completing his doctorate in Jewish Political Thought at the Sorbonne - University of Paris, Nanterre. In 2013, Ronen was chosen by the Algemeiner as one of the top 100 people positively influencing Jewish life. Ronen is married and the father of three. To the members of Im Tirtzu Renewing our belief in the justice of our path, And not allowing our nation to withdraw from its lifeline “A star shall step forth from Jacob, and a scepter shall rise out of Israel” Numbers, 24:17 “…When they saw that the goal was remote and difficult and that the means were close at hand and simple, they substituted the remote and difficult for the close at hand and simple.” S.Y.
[Show full text]
Sunday, July 19Th Welcome, Introductions and Orientation
Naomi Chazan/New Gen Activism Fellowship Trip to Israel New Israel Fund July 19th – 27th, 2015 Sunday, July 19th Welcome, Introductions and Orientation Arrival and check-in at the hotel in Jerusalem 4:00 PM Depart Hotel 4:30 – 5:00 PM Welcome and Introductions Location: NIF Offices 5:00 – 6:00 PM Meeting with Rachel Liel, Executive Director of NIF in Israel and Ronit Heyd, Director of Shatil 6:00 – 7:15 PM Meeting with Naomi Chazan, Former NIF President and current NIF Board Member 7:15 – 8:15 PM Introduction to the Program and Expectations 8:30 PM Welcome Dinner Location: HaSadna, 28 Hebron Rd, Jerusalem Overnight at Prima Royale, 3 Mendele St., Jerusalem Monday, July 20th Human Rights and Democracy: Strengthening Democratic Infrastructure 8:00 AM Setting up the day 8:15 AM Depart Hotel 9:00 – 10:00 AM Tour of the Knesset 10:15 – 11:00 AM Conversation with Giyora Wahle, Policy Expert at Shatil Location: Meretz Party Room 11:00 – 11:45 AM Meeting with MK Hilik Bar Location: Meretz Party Room 12:00 – 1:30 PM Lunch 2:00 – 3:00 PM Guided Tour of the Supreme Court 3:00 – 4:00 PM Conversation with Avigail Kormes, NIF's Democracy, Civil and Human Rights Grants Officer 4:00 – 4:45 PM Processing Session 5:00 – 7:00 PM Culinary Tour of Mahane Yehuda Market with Iris Saraf-Reinharts of Amechaye Fun Evening Overnight at Prima Royale, 3 Mendele St., Jerusalem Tuesday, July 21st Religious Freedom and Pluralism: Building Momentum for Change Breakfast at Hotel 8:15 AM Setting up the day 8:45 AM Depart Hotel 9:00 – 10:00 AM Meeting with Anat Hoffman,
[Show full text]
Im Tirtzu Activities & Achievements
Academic Year תשע"ח 2017-18 Im Tirtzu Activities & Achievements Annual Summary Highlights “Im Tirtzu is, in my opinion, the most influential movement in Israel in recent years.” Carmi Gillon, former Director of the Shabak (Israel Security Agency). August 26, 2018 Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked at Im Tirtzu's Annual Conference 2 Over 2 laws inspired by Im 15,000,000 Tirtzu were passed in the Knesset views and 40,000,000 Prime Minister reach on videos posted by Netanyahu IMTI on social media networks adopted our language regarding campus/ the New Israel Fund 13 pre-army academy tours to Hebron IMTI-inspired Academic 4 tours and 3 lectures Code of Ethics to visiting Chinese students was adopted by the Council for Higher Education Over 1,500 mentions in a variety of media outlets. Increased campus presence from IMTI’s Zionist Hasbara to campuses 15 20 Center enlisted the support of 1,500 Israeli Friends of Council IMTI together with over for Higher of financial Education $125,000 support. instructed universities to balance biased legal Jerusalem Now & Forever clinics following an IMTI report 4 photo exhibit displays Commission of inquiry Over students 6,500 established following IMTI exposure attended over 50 IMTI lectures of imprisoned terrorists harassing female prison guards 3 Combating BDS from Within continued to expose and combat the radical NGOs funded by the New Israel IMTI Fund and foreign governments that work to harm Israel and IDF soldiers. “Ridding Israel of the New Israel Fund” IMTI released a video game depicting how A new IMTI campaign against the New Israel NIF-backed radical NGOs harass IDF soldiers.
[Show full text]
NIF's Naomi Chazan Speaks: "We Can't Be Silent"
NIF's Naomi Chazan Speaks: "We Can't be Silent" DAN VERBIN problems there was one obligation I had funds Arab civil society in Is- and that is to fix them. I’ve been fixing all rael (along with human rights, On Sunday, May 9, Toronto Reconstruc- my life.” women’s rights, Ethiopian tionist synagogue Darchei Noam hosted the The dilemma Chazan believes Israel cur- rights and other civil society president of the New Israel Fund, Naomi rently faces? Sixty-two years after Israel’s causes). Chazan, as part of a lecture series dealing creation, one of its most important achieve- “Behind all of this is the key with Israel, its domestic challenges and its ments is its “capacity to maintain its boister- target and that is the justice relations with its neighbours and with the ous democracy.” She quoted a remarkable system of the state of Israel,” Diaspora. figure – of the over 150 countries created she said, explaining that the Born In Jerusalem in 1946, Chazan, who after WWII, Israel and India are only two that court system, the last resort described herself as the “mother of civil society have survived as democracies. A “tremendous of Israeli citizens, is “being in Israel,” ironically addressed the packed achievement,” she remarked. attacked as being too leftists audience in flawless English on Mother’s Day; However: “Democracies are like gardens. because it is protecting the hu- a fact that she lamented by mentioning with If you don’t water them, they whither. They man and civil rights of Israeli Naomi Chazan a tinge of sadness that in Israel Mother’s Day begin to flounder.
[Show full text]