• Abstract and Figures
• Public Full-text

Instantons in QCD T. Sch¨afer Institute for Nuclear Theory, Department of Physics, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA E.V. Shuryak Department of Physics, State University of New York at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, New York 11794, USA We review the theory and phenomenology of instantons in QCD. After a general overview, we provide a pedagogical introduction to semi-classical methods in quantum mechanics and field theory. The main part of the review summarizes our understanding of the instanton liquid in QCD and the role of instantons in generating the spectrum of light hadrons. We also discuss properties of instantons at finite temperature and how instantons can provide a mechanism for the chiral phase transition. We give an overview over the role of instantons in some other models, in particular low dimensional sigma models, electroweak theory and supersymmetric QCD. arXiv:hep-ph/9610451v3 16 Mar 1998 1 CONTENTS I. Introduction 4 A. Motivation 4 B. Physics outlook 5 1. Hadronic structure 5 2. Scales of non-perturbative QCD 5 3. Structure of the QCD vacuum 6 4. QCD at finite temperature 9 C. The history of instantons 9 1. Discovery and early applications 10 2. Phenomenology leads to a qualitative picture 10 3. Technical development during the 80’s 11 4. Recent progress 11 D. Topics that are not discussed in detail 12 II. Semi-classical theory of tunneling 13 A. Tunneling in quantum mechanics 13 1. Quantum mechanics in Euclidean space 13 2. Tunneling in the double well potential 15 3. Tunneling amplitude at one loop order 16 4. The tunneling amplitude at two-loop order 19 5. Instanton-anti-instanton interaction and the ground state energy 20 B. Fermions coupled to the double well potential 23 C. Tunneling in Yang-Mills theory 26 1. Topology and classical vacua 26 2. Tunneling and the BPST instanton 27 3. The theta vacua 28 4. The tunneling amplitude 30 D. Instantons and light quarks 31 1. Tunneling and the U(1)A anomaly 31 2. Tunneling amplitude in the presence of light fermions 33 III. Phenomenology of instantons 35 A. How often does the tunneling occur in the QCD vacuum? 35 B. The typical instanton size and the instanton liquid model 36 C. Instantons on the lattice 38 1. The topological charge and susceptibility 38 2. The instanton liquid on the lattice 40 3. The fate of large-size instantons and the beta function 42 D. Instantons and confinement 45 IV. Towards a theory of the instanton ensemble 47 A. The instanton interaction 47 1. The gauge interaction 47 2. The fermionic interaction 50 B. Instanton ensembles 51 C. The mean field approximation 52 D. The quark condensate in the mean field approximation 54 E. Dirac eigenvalues and chiral symmetry breaking 56 F. Effective interaction between quarks and the mean field approximation 58 1. The gap equation for Nf =1 58 2. The effective interaction for two or more flavors 59 G. Bosonization and the spectrum of pseudo-scalar mesons 60 H. Spin dependent interactions induced by instantons 61 V. The interacting instanton liquid 63 A. Numerical simulations 63 B. The free energy of the instanton ensemble 64 C. The instanton ensemble 65 D. Dirac Spectra 66 E. Screening of the topological charge 67 VI. Hadronic correlation functions 70 A. Definitions and Generalities 70 B. The quark propagator in the instanton liquid 72 1. The propagator in the field of a single instanton 73 2. The propagator in the instanton ensemble 74 2 3. The propagator in the mean field approximation 75 C. Mesonic correlators 76 1. General results and the OPE 76 2. The single-instanton approximation 78 3. The random phase approximation 80 4. The interacting instanton liquid 81 5. Other mesonic correlation functions 83 D. Baryonic correlation functions 84 1. Nucleon correlation functions 84 2. Delta correlation functions 86 E. Correlation functions on the lattice 87 F. Gluonic correlation functions 88 G. Hadronic structure and n-point correlators 90 VII. Instantons at finite temperature 92 A. Introduction 92 1. Finite temperature field theory and the caloron solution 92 2. Instantons at high temperature 94 3. Instantons at low temperature 96 4. Instanton interaction at finite temperature 97 B. Chiral symmetry restoration 99 1. Introduction to QCD phase transitions 99 2. The instanton liquid at finite temperature and IA molecules 103 3. Mean field description at finite temperature 104 4. Phase transitions in the interacting instanton model 107 C. Hadronic correlation functions at finite temperature 110 1. Introduction 110 2. Temporal correlation functions 111 3. U(1)A breaking 112 4. Screening masses 114 D. Instantons at finite temperature: lattice studies 115 VIII. Instantons in related theories 117 A. Two-dimensional theories 117 1. The O(2) sigma model 117 2. The O(3) sigma model 119 B. Instantons in electroweak theory 120 C. Supersymmetric QCD 122 1. The instanton measure and the perturbative beta function 122 2. N = 1 supersymmetric QCD 123 3. N = 2 supersymmetric gauge theory 125 IX. Summary and discussion 127 A. General remarks 127 B. Vacuum and hadronic structure 127 C. Finite temperature and chiral restoration 128 D. The big picture 129 X. Acknowledgments 132 XI. Notes added in proof 132 Appendix A: Basic instanton formulas 134 1. Instanton gauge potential 134 2. Fermion zero modes and overlap integrals 134 3. Properties of η symbols 135 4. Group integration 136 References 137 3 I. INTRODUCTION A. Motivation QCD, the field theory describing the strong interaction, is now more than 20 years old, and naturally it has reached a certain level of maturity. Perturbative QCD has been developed in great detail, with most hard processes calculated beyond leading order, compared to data and compiled in reviews and textbooks. However, the world around us can not be understood on the basis of perturbative QCD, and the development of non-perturbative QCD has proven to be a much more difficult task. This is hardly surprising. While perturbative QCD could build on the methods developed in the context of QED, strategies for dealing with the non-perturbative aspects of field theories first had to be developed. The gap between hadronic phenomenology on the one side and exactly solvable model field theories is still huge. While some fascinating discoveries (instantons among them) have been made, and important insights emerged from lattice simulations and hadronic phenomenology, a lot of work remains to be done in order to unite these approaches and truly understand the phenomena involved. Among the problems the field is faced with is a difficulty in communication between researchers working on different aspects of non-perturbative field theory, and a shortage of good introductory material for people interested in entering the field. In this review, we try to provide an overview over the role of instantons in field theory, with a particular emphasis on QCD. Such a review is certainly long overdue. Many readers certainly remember learning about instantons from some of the excellent papers (Callan, Dashen & Gross 1978a) or introductory reviews (Coleman 1977, Vainshtein, Zakharov, Novikov & Shifman 1982) that appeared in the late 70’s or early 80’s, but since then there have been very few publications addressed at a more general audience1. The only exceptions are the book by (Rajaraman 1982), which provides a general discussion of topological objects, but without particular emphasis on applications and a few chapters in the book by (Shuryak 1988c), which deal with the role of instantons in hadronic physics. All of these publications are at least a decade old. Writing this review we had several specific goals in mind, which are represented by different layers of presentation. In the remainder of the introduction, we provide a very general introduction into instanton physics, aimed at a very broad readership. We will try to give qualitative answers to questions like: What are instantons? What are their effects? Why are instantons important? What is the main progress achieved during the last decade? This discussion is continued in Sec. III, in which we review the current information concerning the phenomenology of instantons in QCD. Section II is also pedagogical, but the style is completely different. The main focus is a systematic development of the semi-classical approximation. As an illustration, we provide a detailed discussion of a classic example, the quantum mechanics of the double-well potential. However, in addition to the well known derivation of the leading order WKB result, we also deal with several modern developments, like two-loop corrections, instantons and perturbation theory at large orders, as well as supersymmetric quantum mechanics. In addition to that, we give an introduction to the semi-classical theory of instantons in gauge theory. Sections IV-VII make up the core of the review. They provide an in-depth discussion of the role of instantons in QCD. Specifically, we try to emphasize the connection between the structure of the vacuum, hadronic correlation functions, and hadronic structure, both at zero and finite temperature. The style is mostly that of a review of the modern literature, but we have tried to make this part as self-contained as possible. The last two sections, VIII,IX, deal with many fascinating applications of instantons in other theories, and with possible lessons for QCD. The presentation is rather cursory and our main motivation is to acquaint the reader with the main problems and to provide a guide to the available literature. 1A reprint volume that contains most of the early work and a number of important technical papers was recently published by (Shifman 1994). 4 B. Physics outlook 1. Hadronic structure In this section, we would like to provide a brief outline of the theory and phenomenology of hadronic structure and the QCD vacuum.

Load more

  143

Copy Link