Regina Romero Confidential Research Summary

1 TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. “WHAT’S WRONG WITH TUCSON

(pages 3 – 9)

II. SHIRLEY SCOTT (1995 – PRESENT)

(pages 10 – 22)

III. REGINA ROMERO (2007 – PRESENT)

(pages 23 – 35)

IV. PAUL CUNNINGHAM (2010 – PRESENT)

(pages 36 - 44)

2 WHAT’S WRONG WITH TUCSON?

For decades, Tucson has languished under incompetent government and has been stagnant in some areas, while declining in others. When compared with the growth and success of Phoenix, people are wondering why their city comes up short in comparison with the bigger city in Arizona, and why growth isn’t happening in Tucson compared to other areas of Arizona. This document shows trends in various categories, such as population growth, crime, taxes, and others.

POPULATION GROWTH

 Tucson had 526,116 in population as of July 1, 2013 (Estimate from the US Census Bureau, http://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml? src=bkmk) Tucson had a population of 488,108 in 2000 (http://censusviewer.com/city/AZ/Tucson), a growth of 7.8% in 13 years. o During this same time, Phoenix has grown by 14.6%, almost double the rate of Tucson. (http://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.x html?src=bkmk, 2000 population of 1,321,045; http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/04/0455000.html, 2013 population of 1,513, 367)

3 GROWTH IN NUMBER OF PEOPLE ON DISABILITY AND WELFARE

 While Tucson has only grown by 7.8% in 13 years, the growth of people ages 18- 64 on disability has grown from 8,859 in December 2000 (http://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/statcomps/ssi_sc/2000/az.pdf) to 12,363 in December 2013 (http://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/statcomps/ssi_sc/2013/az.html), a 40% increase, more than 5 TIMES the growth of population.  The proportion of people on SNAP benefits (food stamps, WIC, etc.) in Pima County has grown by 198% from 2000 to 2013. (http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/map_of_the_week/2013/04 /food_stamp_recipients_by_county_an_interactive_tool_showing_local_snap _data.html)

LAGGING ECONOMIC INDICATORS

According to Forbes magazine, Tucson is the WORST place to look for a job among major metro areas for Summer 2015. (http://www.forbes.com/pictures/gklg45fj/no-1-tucson-arizona/) The poverty rate nationwide in 2013, the latest the Census Bureau has data, is 14.5% (http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/poverty/about/overview/) In Tucson, the poverty rate is 25.2%, 74% higher than the national average. This is in comparison to the Phoenix area, which has a 17.6% poverty rate, 30.2% lower than Tucson. (http://www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/phoenix/2014/09/19/phoenix- among-highest-poverty-rates-for-metro-areas-in-us/15851529/, 9/19/2014) The median household income nationwide is $53,046.00 for 2013 (http://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml? pid=ACS_13_5YR_DP03&src=pt). The median household income in Tucson for 2013 is $37,032.00, 30% lower than the national average.

4 Fitch Ratings, a nationally known company that assigns ratings for bonds issued by corporations and governments, assigned a NEGATIVE outlook for the City of Tucson’s bonds and downgraded a series of ratings for bonds issued by the City of Tucson due to economic conditions and increased government spending (http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20150520006286/en/Fitch- Downgrades-Tucson-AZ-GOs-COPs-Outlook#.VWDEUflViko, 5/20/2015) : o $20 million general obligation (GO) bonds, series 2012-C (2015) 'AA o $36.6 million general obligation refunding bonds, series 2015 'AA-' o $20.7 million certificates of participation (COPs), refunding series 2015 'A+'. In addition, Fitch downgrades the following ratings: o $214.8 million GO bonds outstanding (pre-refunding) to 'AA-' from 'AA' o $259.2 million COPs outstanding (pre-refunding) to 'A+' from 'AA-' o $11 million Rio Nuevo Multipurpose Facilities District (MFD) COPs (City of Tucson Convention Center Expansion Project), series 2009 to 'A' from 'A+' o This ratings downgrade is at the same time that the rating for the State of Arizona government has INCREASED during the same month. (http://tucson.com/business/local/arizona-gets-credit- upgrade/article_4a1206f8-8027-5084-afa9-fa2a23733010.html, 5/5/2015) Jobs in construction has gone down in Tucson from 28,800 in October 2006 to only 15,000 in March 2015, a 47.9% drop. (http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/SMU04460602000000001?data_tool=XGtable) Jobs in manufacturing has gone down in Tucson from 28,500 in July 2006 to 22,700 in March 2015, a 16.8% drop. (http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/SMU04460603000000001?data_tool=XGtable) Jobs in the information sector, such as computer programmers and similar positions, has declined in Tucson from 7,600 in February 2006 to 4,200 in March 2015, a 44.7% drop. (http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/SMU04460605000000001?data_tool=XGtable) While the other side may talk about the unemployment dropping to 4.9% in March 2015 from a high of 10.1% in January 2010, the number of the people in the labor force in Tucson has declined from 489,213 in August 2009 to 469,004 in March 2015, a 20,209 drop. (http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LAUMT044606000000006? data_tool=XGtable) If the same number of people were in the workforce as in August 2009, the unemployment rate would be 9.2% right now. It is likely that many of the people no longer in the workforce are on disability due to discouragement in being able to find a decent job.

5 Earnings in Tucson as of May 2014 is 10% below the national average; with the average person in Tucson making $20.45/hour, compared to the national average of $22.71/hour. (http://www.bls.gov/regions/west/news- release/occupationalemploymentandwages_tucson.htm) The social network WalletHub did a survery of the 150 largest metro areas nationwide, and they found Tucson the 8th worst place to look for a job in 2015. (http://www.wildcat.arizona.edu/article/2015/01/lack-of-jobs-hurts- tucsons-reputation) CBS News finds Tucson to be the 5th poorest city in the nation. Tucson is even poorer than Baltimore. (http://www.cbsnews.com/media/americas-11- poorest-cities/8/, 2/18/2015; http://www.ywcatucson.org/site/c.elLYJiOZKqLcG/b.9257737/k.5D1D/Women _Out_Of_Poverty_Initiative.htm) 34.8% of people have an income under $25,000.00/year According to a Harvard University study, Pima County is worse than 95% of counties in the United States when it comes to poor children being able to rise up out of poverty. (http://www.insidetucsonbusiness.com/business_chatter/harvard-university- poor-children-pay-big-price-for-sluggish-pima/article_e62fc700-f8c5-11e4- 8784-6fb6c4a18fd4.html, 5/15/2015)

6 WASTEFUL SPENDING

1. While pensions in Tucson are only being funded at 40% of what is needed to have them fully funded (http://psprswrongs.com/2015/03/06/tucson-leaders-worry- about-ballooning-public-safety-pension-costs/, 3/6/2015), the City has proposed a Fiscal Year 2016 budget that is 8.1% higher than FY 2015, a $103 million increase. (http://www.tucsonnewsnow.com/story/28986284/city-council-holds- public-hearing-on-2016-budget, 5/20/2015) 2. This same proposed budget is proposing on increasing city property taxes by 9.3% (http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/budget/16Book-Op_1.pdf, page 13) 3. The City of Tucson spends a. Vacation time for Cesar Chavez Day (Page 14 of FY 2016 proposed budget) b. An increase of $97,520.00 for the Mayor and city council people (http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/budget/16Book-Op_1.pdf, page 76) c. An increase of $768,840.00 for the city convention center (Page 76 of proposed 2016 budget) Total amount coming from General Revenue to fund the convention center is $4.2 million (Page 250 of proposed 2016 budget) d. $7.6 million for golf courses (Page 76 of proposed 2016 budget) e. $2.5 million for a 43 person department for just the Mayor and City Councilpeople (Page 78 of proposed 2016 budget) f. $510,800.00 on state and federal lobbyists (Page 123 of proposed 2016 budget) g. 6 full time employees are designated for “medical leave management”. (http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/budget/16Book-Op_1.pdf, Page 170) h. $1.9 million and 16 employees for a division called “Integrated Planning”. This amount has grown from just over $1 million, by almost 90%, since FY 2014. (Page 186 of proposed 2016 budget)

7 i. $1.36 million in general revenue funding for the Reid Park Zoo. (Page 201 of Proposed 2016 budget) j. $5.7 million/year for a streetcar program, Sun Link, for a 4 mile stretch of rail. (Page 234 of Proposed 2016 budget) k. An $880,000.00 increase in graffitti abatement, more than doubling the amount from FY 2015. (Page 229 of Proposed 2016 budget) l. $19.5 million for “non-departmental services” (Page 294 of Proposed 2016 budget) m. An increase of $100,000.00 for the Tucson Gem Show (Page 295 of Proposed 2016 budget) n. $350,000 for the Tucson-Pima County Arts Council (Page 297 of Proposed 2016 budget)

CRIME IN TUCSON

1. The crime rate, while dropping in some areas like homicide and robbery, has grown in other areas, such as: a. Sexual assault (rate has gone up from 29 per 100,000 people in 2010 to 41 in 2013, a 41.4% increase (http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/police/allgraphs_13rate.pdf, page 2) b. Larceny (rate has gone up from 3,347 per 100,000 people in 2009 to 5,230 in 2013, a 56.3% increase, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/police/allgraphs_13rate.pdf, page 6) c. Property crimes (burglary, larceny, etc) (rate has gone from 4,976 per 100,000 people in 2009 to 6,621 in 2013, a 33.1% increase; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/police/allgraphs_13rate.pdf, page 15) 2. Tucson last year ranked 10th highest in the nation for property crimes. (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/tucson-in-top-for-property- crimes-nationally/article_d5edb12b-0071-57d0-801d-3012a899b7b5.html, 11/15/2014) 3. Tucson as of June 2015 has the highest rate of violent crime in Arizona. (http://tucson.com/r/news/local/crime/arizona-s-most-dangerous- cities/collection_094a5688-1473-11e5-9041-6b67567e22b1.html?id=201408, 6/17/2015)

8 TERRIBLE ROADS

1. Tucson has the 21st most congested traffic in the nation, with the average commuter spending 55 extra hours in gridlock each year. (http://www.azfamily.com/story/28669387/tucson-traffic-among-worst-in-us- according-to-new-study, 4/14/2015) 2. Tucson has the 5th worst roads in the nation. (https://arizonadailyindependent.com/2015/03/03/tucson-roads-ranked-5th- worst-in-country-2/) It will cost an estimated $850 million just to repair existing roads.

9 SHIRLEY C. SCOTT

CONFIDENTIAL RESEARCH DOCUMENT

10 QUICK BIO Age: 73

Residence: Grew up in Toronto, Canada, now lives at 7542 East Lurlene Drive in Tucson, AZ. Property is assessed at $146,304.00 (http://www.asr.pima.gov/links/frm_Parcel.aspx?parcel=13622075A&taxyear=2016)

Other Property: The couple also owns two industrial zoned properties on 3214 and 3220 East 46th Street. The 3214 property is valued at $182,250.00 (http://www.asr.pima.gov/links/frm_Parcel.aspx?parcel=132060770&taxyear=2016) and the 3220 property is valued at $17,726.00. (http://www.asr.pima.gov/links/frm_Parcel.aspx?parcel=132060780&taxyear=2016)

Family: Married to Joe, 4 adult children

Education: Drew University, New Jersey (1965)

Employment: Pennsylvania State University (German Instructor) Columbia University (German Instructor) Scott Supply Service, Inc. (Family Business - Director of Finance/VP, 1974-2000) City of Tucson (Councilwoman, 1995-present)

Associations: Pima County Council on Aging (Board of Directors) Pima Prevention Partnership Tucson Clean and Beautiful (Advisory Committee) National League of Cities (Economic Development Committee Chair) National League of Cities (Board of Directors, 2005)

Awards: Pan-Asian Community Alliance Woman of the Year Korean American Cultural Foundation Appreciation Certificate Parks & Rec Outstanding Public Official Award American Planning Association Distinguished Elected Official League of United Latin American Voters Silver Award Alliance of Construction Trades AZ Human Rights Fund Southern AZ Home Builders Association Public Official of the Year (2002, 2007) Pima Trails Association Friends of the Trails

11 Websites: Official - http://www.tucsonaz.gov/ward-4

Social Media:Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/shirley.scott.9085 Twitter - https://twitter.com/shirleyscott11 LinkedIn- https://www.linkedin.com/pub/shirley-scott/1a/224/b3a? trk=pub-pbmap

Religiosity: None publically listed

OFFICIAL BIO ( http://www.tucsonaz.gov/ward-4/shirley-scotts-bio ) The Honorable Shirley C. Scott is serving her fourth term as the Ward IV Council Member for the City of Tucson. In December of 2005, Council Member Scott was one of 40 elected officials in the United States to be elected to a 2-year term to the Board of Directors of the National League of Cities (NLC). She had previously completed a one- year term as the Chair of the NLC’s Community and Economic Development Committee, after having served two one-year terms as its Vice Chair. She has also served in the international, national, state and local arenas dealing with issues of the environment and community sustainability. She was previously a member Governor’s Advisory Task Force, improving outcomes for incarcerated women and their children. As the former owner of a small business in the city, Mrs. Scott is also keenly aware of the issues that face small business owners.

Mrs. Scott’s passions are the quality of life for children, families, seniors, the environment and public safety. She is a frequent speaker and lecturer for public, private and civic events. Mrs. Scott hosts an annual event for school children, The Ward IV Back to School Bash, where breakfast, school supplies and raffle prizes are given free of charge to participants. She has been instrumental in the expansion of the Clement’s Regional Recreational Center, which is a first-ever project that brought together resources and expertise from not only the city, but from Pima County and Pima Community College, as well.

She has served as board member, officer or liaison to: Tucson Clean and Beautiful, Pima Council on Aging, the Tucson International Airport Authority, Bond Advisory Committee, Sister Cities, the United Way of Greater Tucson City Service Area Committee, and the Susan G. Komen Foundation. She is currently on the Board of Directors for Pima Prevention Partnership and the board for Visit Tucson.

12 Among Mrs. Scott’s awards and achievements are; the Pan-Asian Community Alliance had named her the Woman of the Year, The Korean American Cultural Foundation awarded her a Certificate of Appreciation, Arizona Parks & Recreation Association recognized her as the Outstanding Public Official Award for 2009, and the American Planning Association-Arizona Chapter recognized her in 2009 as the Distinguished Elected Official of the Year. The League of United Latin American Citizens honored her with their Silver Award. She has also been honored by the Alliance of Construction Trades and the Arizona Human Rights Fund. The Southern Arizona Home Builders Association (SAHBA) named her 2002 and 2007 Public Official of the Year. She was awarded the annual “Friends of the Trails” honor from the Pima Trails Association.

PERSONAL LEGAL HISTORY 1. No traffic tickets 2. Paid property taxes over 5 months late on their residence for 2011, paying their 1st payment for 2011 that was due on 10/31/2011 on 4/16/2012, paying $12.91 in interest. In fact, they still owe $19.28 on this amount to make it current as of 5/20/2015. Saved screenshot in separate document. 1. Paid property taxes over 5 months late on their industrial property at 3214 West 46th, paying their 1st payment that was due on 10/31/2014 on 4/13/2015, paying $34.05 in interest. Saved screenshot on separate document.

ABORTION 1. Voted to authorize a grant application for the Gila River Indian Community in support of the activities of Planned Parenthood Arizona (Consent Item G, page 14, 8/6/2008; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2008/MN_08- 06-08.pdf) 2. Voted to give $800.00 in taxpayer money to Planned Parenthood. (Consent Item W, pages 19-20, 9/6/2006; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2006/MN_09-06-06.pdf)

BUSINESS ISSUES 1. Voted to impose a Transaction Privilege Tax on the business of health spas and other fitness related businesses, an over $16 million/year tax increase (Ordinance #10685, page 7, 6/16/2009, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2009/MN_06-16-09.pdf; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/agdocs/20090616/jun16-09-334.pdf)

13 2. Voted for legislation supporting the federal Employee Free Choice Act, which would have taken away the right to secret ballot in voting whether or not workers wanted to have a union (Consent Item R, page 14, 9/9/2009, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2009/MN_09-09-09.pdf; http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB124165379013293871, 5/7/2009, Article written by former Democratic presidential candidate George McGovern opposing this legislation) 3. Voted to impose a new fee on pawn shop transactions (Consent Item F, pages 9- 10, 5/18/2010, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2010/MN_05-18- 10.pdf)

CRIME 1. Voted to remove the question of an applicant’s criminal history from the City of Tucson job application (Resolution 22373, 3/17/2015, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/sirepub/mtgviewer.aspx? meetid=1401&doctype=AGENDA)

GOOD GOVERNMENT 1. Voted against setting an $8 citywide minimum wage in 1999 (AP State and local wire, 9/14/1999) 2. Opposed easing regulations on the rehab of old or dilapidated buildings (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue2/2002/10/29/39779-council-oks-new-code- to-ease-rehab-of-buildings/, 10/29/2002) 3. Voted to oppose the Federal Patriot Act (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue2/2003/04/29/214014-city-votes-to-oppose- federal-patriot-act/; Resolution # 19583, pages 17-18, 5/5/2003, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2003/MN05-05-03.pdf) 4. Opposed putting light rail project on the ballot (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue2/2002/06/12/32494-light-rail-backers-need- many-to-sign/) 5. Voted against balanced budget that cut funding to multiple civic projects in 2004 (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue2/2004/06/22/51548-council-oks-budget- cuts-aid-for-37-civic-events/, 6/22/2004) 6. Supported a $14/month additional fee for trash service for residents of Tucson (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue/2007/10/12/65652-spahr-thinks-trash-fee- may-help-unseat-scott/, 10/12/2007) 7. Opposed a bioscience park at UA because it included a golf course that would temporarily use drinking water for greens (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue/2006/07/25/20188-bioscience-park-woes- on-council-agenda/, 7/25/2006)

14 8. Opposed trash to power incinerator at Air Force base in Tucson (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue/2006/09/19/26677-incinerator-proposal- given-chilly-reception/9/19/2006) 9. Supported project and annexation of 573 Acres on the south side of town for development into golf course, resort, shopping (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue/2006/11/22/33467-city-pays-more-for- graffiti-removal-but-happy-with-effort/) She said this was the most important economic development project for Tucson in decades. 10. Approved red light cameras and photo radar enforcement in Tucson (http://www.tucsonnewsnow.com/story/5980810/tucson-city-council-approves- photo-radar-enforcement, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2007/MN_01-23-07.pdf, Page 19, 1/23/1007) 11. Voted against tight 2009 Tucson budget that included cuts http://btucson.com/Tucson/News/Daily/Jun%2004%202008//153322 12. Voted to increase bus fees (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/city- tentatively-oks-bus-fare-hikes/article_8e80d355-5a64-5761-83db- 0a6eca6c5e6d.html; Ordinance # 10672, page 22, 6/2/2009, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2009/MN_06-02-09.pdf) a. Regular bus fares from $1.00 to $1.25, a 25% increase b. Day pass increase from $2.00 to $3.00, a 50% increase c. Monthly passes from $28.00 to $35.00, a 25% increase 13. Wanted police and fire union representation on the city’s tax advisory commission http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/council-oks-tax- panel-creation/article_7e5058ba-850b-53b4-85b1-6e933f5af7f2.html 14. Voted to urge the US Government to give up nuclear weapons (Consent Item DD, 8/6/2007; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2007/MN_08-06- 07.pdf, page 17) 15. Voted to adopt the 2012 International Building Code (Ordinance 11042, pages 11- 12, 12/18/2012, (http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2012/MN_12- 18-12.pdf) There are many that feel this is implementing Agenda 21, which many feel is a potential future land grab by the United Nations. (http://agenda21news.com/2014/09/uns-international-building-codes- necessary-tool-agenda-21-implementation/)

15 16. Voted to endorse the US Mayors’ Environmental Protection Agreement, which urges cities to lessen greenhouse gas emissions by adhering to the Kyoto Protocol. (Consent Item Q, pages 17-18, 9/6/2006, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2006/MN_09-06-06.pdf; http://www.usmayors.org/climateprotection/agreement.htm) It was estimated in 1998 that if Kyoto was implemented in the United States, it would cause the unemployment rate in Arizona to almost double. (http://accf.org/wp- content/uploads/1997/01/warming2.pdf)

IMMIGRATION 1. Voted to spend $700.00 on the group Derechos Humanos for an event they were hosting, an organization that complains about the “militarization” of the US Border, and works for much more lenient immigration policies. (Consent Item A, page 6, 10/14/2008; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2008/MN_10-14-08.pdf; http://www.derechoshumanosaz.net/about/) 2. Voted to make Tucson an “immigrant welcoming city”. (Resolution #21944, page 15, 8/7/2012, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2012/MN_08-07- 12.pdf) 3. Voted for a resolution expressing support for the 2003 Immigrant Workers Freedom Ride, which one of their goals was to legalize millions of undocumented workers. (Resolution #19693, page 7, 10/6/2003; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2003/MN10-06-03.pdf; http://articles.latimes.com/2003/sep/23/business/fi-ride23) 4. In stating her opposition to Proposition 200 in 2004, a measure that would require Photo ID to vote in Arizona elections and that applicants for benefits would need to have their identity verified before they could receive benefits (http://www.azleg.gov/jlbc/prop200fn.pdf), she said anybody that would support this was “anti-American” and that anybody who disagreed with her was not an American citizen (Page 12, 10/11/2004, Tucson City Council Minutes, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2004/MN_10-11-04.pdf) 5. Supported creating a city holiday honoring Caesar Chavez, which could cost taxpayers as much as $500k (http://www.tucsonsentinel.com/local/report/030314_chavez_holiday/city- council-approves-cesar-chavez-holiday/, 3/3/2014; Ordinance # 11146, page 13, 3/4/2014) 6. Voted to spend $6,400.00 for the 2006 Cesar Chavez Annual Celebration (Resolution 20309, page 4, 3/28/2006, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2006/MN_03-28-06.pdf)

16 SOCIAL ISSUES 1. Voted to “enhance” the city’s support of civil unions and domestic partnerships (Ordinance #11088, page 9, 6/18/2013, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2013/MN_06-18-13.pdf) 2. Voted to approve Famous Sams as an off track betting site for the Tucson Greyhound Race Track (Resolution # 19767, page 29, 1/26/2004, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2004/MN_01-26-04.pdf) Also approved the Maverick King of Clubs as an off track betting site. (Same cite as above, page 30) Approved Arizona Ale House as an off track betting site. (Resolution 20083, pages 15-16, 6/7/2005, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2005/MN_06-07-05.pdf) 3. Voted to spend $200 of taxpayer money for fencing required for the “Cesar Chavez March for Peace” (Resolution 20618, 3/27/2007; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2007/MN_03-27-07.pdf, pages 8-9) 4. Voted to urge President Obama to repeal “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell”, which now allows gays and lesbians to be open about their orientation (Consent Item DD, 8/6/2007; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2007/MN_08-06- 07.pdf, page 17) 5. Voted to re-affirm the city’s policy to provide health and medical benefits for gay and lesbian partners (Consent Item G, page 9, 10/10/2006, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2006/MN_10-10-06.pdf)

TAXES AND FEE INCREASES 1. Voted to send a measure to the voters to increase the maximum amount Tucson could impose for city sales taxes from 2% to 2.5%, a 25% increase (Ordinance # 10820, page 17, 7/7/2010, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2010/MN_07-07-10.pdf) 2. Voted to approve a Notice of Intent to increase water rates (Resolutions 20355 & 20356, pages 14-15, 6/6/2006, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2006/MN_06-06-06.pdf) 3. Voted to increase water usage fees (Ordinance 10987, Pages 18-19, 5/22/2012, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2012/MN_05-22-12.pdf)

17 4. Voted to again increase water usage fees (Consent Item C, page 6, 3/5/2013, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2013/MN_03-05-13.pdf)

WASTE 1. Voted to authorize the sale of $80 million in bonds for the Rio Nuevo development project; this project has been called “the biggest failure in Tucson history”, with some estimates the project has wasted $230 million (http://www.tucsonnewsnow.com/story/21008933/rio-nuevo-rises-from-the- ashes, 2/6/2013; Consent Item H, page 7, 12/9/2008; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2008/MN_12-09-08.pdf) 2. Voted to continue the relationship with the Rio Nuevo District (Resolution 21707, page 16, 3/22/2011, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2011/MN_03-22-11.pdf) 3. Office budget increased by $117,711 (46.1%) from 2000-2004 (https://www.nexis.com/results/docview/docview.do? docLinkInd=true&risb=21_T22023178530&format=GNBFI&sort=DATE,A,H&st artDocNo=326&resultsUrlKey=29_T22023178513&cisb=22_T22023206572&tre eMax=true&treeWidth=0&csi=312035&docNo=343) 4. Voted for $1.9M tax funded drug institute (http://tucson.com/business/city-oks- m-for-drug-institute/article_bc3ef473-ce0e-5a63-b803-557e3311b03f.html) 5. Opposed combining cities Trash, Water entities despite the merger saving money (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue2/2004/12/14/194824-council-oks- combining-water-trash-operations/) 6. Voted to annex 27 square miles of largely vacant land in the southern side of town from the State (http://tucson.com/news/local/east/annexation-some-want-it- some-don-t/image_7f2decb8-0d5f-53fe-8ff0-5089aa8f693c.html) 7. Voted to spend $1.5 million of Tucson city money for subsidizing the zoo in Tucson (Substitute motion of Councilman Leal, pages 14-15, 6/21/2005, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2005/MN_06-21-05.pdf) 8. Supported a $12.5 million expansion of the zoo to keep elephants in Tucson, with the city picking up $6.25 million of the tab (http://tucson.com/news/local/tucson-s-elephants-to-get-new- quarters/article_118640d5-6e2d-5abb-82b8-db83e196ec75.html, 4/12/2006) 9. Spent $6,600 in taxpayer dollars to attend National League of Cities events – and other waste (http://tucson.com/news/local/your-taxes-paid-for- it/article_0b3f5b1c-ba40-50ab-9ba2-484a45240c3f.html) 10. Supported 14% hike in city budget for 2007 (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt- and-politics/city-budget-hike-pegged-at/article_84849c18-4dbd-5aa8-8b2d- 65b2aa040abb.html)

18 11. Continued pushing Westcor development in her district despite water use concerns and cost (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/westcor-to- put-m-in-se-planning/article_ba7b48f7-60c6-5c1f-9135-3be49b2b63c8.html… this project fell through due to the financial collapse and other factors) 12. An aide has accrued more than 1,000 hours of sick leave from the city (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/city-workers-accrue-huge- level-of-sick-vacation-pay/article_5f5834ae-3234-50a9-a9d5- 52ee37612206.html) 13. Voted to spend $500.00 of taxpayer money for a student to attend a debate camp. (Consent item J, 5/22/2007; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2007/MN_05-22-07.pdf, pages 7-8)

POLITICAL STANCES 1. Said to vote with the Republicans on the board “More often than not” (Arizona Daily Star, 9/12/2001) 2. Voted to allow city staffers to participate in political campaigning activities (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue2/2002/06/04/5902-city-staff-wins-ok-to- work-on-campaigns/,6/4/2002) 3. Voted to allow the AFSCME union to collectively represent Tucson city employees (Resolution 19915 & Ordinances 10019 & 10020, pages 43-45, 8/2/2004, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2004/MN_08-02-04.pdf; Consent agenda item H, 6/26/2007; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2007/MN_06-26-07.pdf, pages 10-11) 4. Voted to give the City of Tucson the option to have an all-mail election, which would have the effect of allowing the city to circumvent Arizona’s Voter ID laws (Consent Item A, page 8, 4/18/2006, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2006/MN_04-18-06.pdf)

Controversial contributions to Scott’s campaign

19 1. $390.00 from Jim Click on 4/27/2007 (Controversial now that he’s now funding the effort to get rid of her) 2. $100.00 from Pam Sutherland, Executive Director for pro-abortion group Arizona List, on 6/26/2007 3. $25.00 from Patricia Caldwell, a social worker for Planned Parenthood, on 9/4/2007 4. $500.00 on 3/22/2011 and $500.00 on 5/15/2011 from Arizona List (These contributions were returned on 10/3/2011) 5. $400.00 from former Democratic US Senator Dennis DeConcini, of the Keating Five fame, on 7/10/2011 6. $20.00 from Victoria Hadd-Wissler, program manager of Planned Parenthood of Arizona, on 6/5/2011 7. $430.00 from the Pascua Yaqui Tribe on 7/29/2011 8. $430.00 from the Las Adelitas Arizona PAC on 8/16/2011, a group that “mobilizes Latinas participate in the political process and to support progressive causes”. This was originally formed to support US Rep. Raul Grijalva (http://www.lasadelitasarizona.org/Las_Adelitas/Las_Adelitas_Home.html) 9. $430.00 from Planned Parenthood of Phoenix on 9/22/2011

Attorney contributions 1. 43 total contributions from attorneys from 2007-2011 totaling $6,296.00 2. $390.00 from Arthur Chapa on 3/21/2007 3. $150.00 from Leighton Rockafellow on 3/16/2007 4. $100.00 from Mary Beth Savel on 3/21/2007 5. $370.00 from Robert Gugino on 4/5/2007 6. $50.00 from Barbara Lawall on 5/14/2007 7. $50.00 from Jeannine Mortimer Anjakos on 6/29/2007 8. $50.00 from Michael Piccareta on 3/14/2007 9. $25.00 from Marjore Cunningham on 6/26/2007, and $20.00 on 5/1/2011 10. $25.00 from Mark O’Hara on 8/20/2007 11. $200.00 from Leighton Rockafellow on 6/22/2007 12. $390.00 from Frank Bangs, Jr. on 9/12/2007 13. $100.00 on 3/28/2011, $20.00 on 5/1/2011 and $300.00 on 9/10/2011 from Marjorie Cunningham 14. $430.00 from Robert Gugino on 5/27/2011 15. $200.00 from Larry Hecker on 4/18/2011 16. $10.00 from Vince Rabago on 3/14/2011 17. $250.00 from Leighton Rockafellow on 5/25/2011, and $250.00 on 6/29/2011 18. $430.00 from Pamela Sutherland on 3/22/2011 19. $96.00 from former AZ Attorney General Terry Goddard on 4/16/2011 20.$240.00 from Larry Hecker on 5/25/2011

20 21. $100.00 from Jeff Rogers on 5/1/2011, and $330.00 on 8/3/2011 22.$20.00 from Demitri Downing on 5/28/2011 23.$25.00 from James Fullin on 6/28/2011 24.$100.00 from Pat Griffin on 7/14/2011 25. $25.00 from Barry Kirschner on 7/14/2011 26.$20.00 from Robert Colbert on 7/14/2011 27. $75.00 from Marc Simon on 7/14/2011 and $75.00 on 9/7/2011 28.$100.00 from Lowell Rothschild on 6/27/2011 29.$250.00 from Frank Bangs, Jr. on 7/20/2011, and $100.00 on 10/16/2011 30.$50.00 from Jonathan Rothschild on 7/14/2011, and $200.00 on 9/27/2011 31. $100.00 from Keri Silvyn on 7/14/2011 32.$50.00 from Karen Christiansen on 9/19/2011 33.$100.00 from Barbara LaWall on 9/9/2011 34.$100.00 from Jeannine Mortimer on 9/8/2011 35. $50.00 from Clauge Van Slyke on 9/9/2011 36.$100.00 from Bruce Burke on 10/4/2011 37. $100.00 from Matt Muehlback on 10/10/2011

Union contributions 1. $500.00 from the Communications Workers of America on 8/1/2007 2. $20.00 from Mike Coiro, Executive Director of AFSCME in Tucson, on 3/15/2011 3. $2,170.00 from AFSCME in Washington, DC on 8/11/2011 (This check was returned on 10/26/2011)

MISCONDUCT 1. An employee of Sun Tran lost his job after he started raising concerns about Scott’s husband’s company, Scott Supply, having a contract with SunTran to supply nuts, bolts and other supplies, an obvious conflict of interest. (http://www.tucsonweekly.com/tw/11-06-97/feat.htm) 2. Aide forced to resign in 2000 for making racist, sexist, and anti-gay remarks (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue2/2000/07/25/28469-macko-report-likely- to-remain-private/ 7/25/2000) His comments: “John Macko, who worked for Councilwoman Shirley Scott, allegedly referred to Councilmen Steve Leal and Ibarra, City Manager Luis Gutierrez and County Supervisor Raul Grijalva as "the Mexican Mafia"; called developer Don Diamond and his associates "inbred Jews"; and said members of the Pima County-Tucson Women's Commission were "dykes."

3. In 2002 another aide was fired and arrested (facing up to 10 years) for a 53 count federal indictment for defrauding a disabled veteran

21 (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue2/2002/04/04/117287-council-aide-fired- after-fraud-indictment/) 4. Is Canadian by birth, did not become US Citizen until she was 21 (http://tucson.com/news/local/scott-is-a-canadian-transplant-via-n- j/article_bc221c57-33e7-5a4c-ab3d-b430a807e479.html) 5. Violated AZ open meetings requirements with series of private council meetings (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue2/2009/05/15/130867-council-s-talks-likely- violated-arizona-open-meetings-law/, 5/15/2009)

Questionable spending With taxpayer dollars from the City of Tucson, Scott spent: 1. $61.91 in purchases on iTunes over the years 2. $762.83 in “golf invoices” in 2007 and 2008 3. $12,610.08 in “non-local travel” to places such as Washington, DC, Charlotte, NC; Denver, CO; Taos, NM; and Indianapolis, IN 1. On her campaign account, she had a returned check fee for $12.00 on 10/25/2011

22 REGINA ROMERO

CONFIDENTIAL RESEARCH SUMMARY

23 QUICK BIO

Age: 40 (Born in September 1974)

Residence: Lives at 1510 North Mojean Court in Tucson, AZ. That house is currently assessed at $233,904.00 (http://www.asr.pima.gov/links/frm_Parcel.aspx? parcel=116062950&taxyear=2016) Regina and her husband also own property at 2860 West Desert Crest Drive in Tucson assessed at $130,991.00. (http://www.asr.pima.gov/links/frm_Parcel.aspx? parcel=118030740&taxyear=2016)

Family: Married on 10/11/2003 to Ruben Reyes (who works for Democrat Congressman Raúl Grijalva), 2 children: Emiliano and Luciana

Education: B.A., University of Arizona, Communication (1996-2000) Certificate, Harvard University, State & Local Government (2013)

Employment: Pima County (Youth Internship Coordinator, 1996-2000) Pima County (Neighborhood Reinvestment Coordinator, 2000- 2005) City of Tucson (Council Aide to Karin Ulich, 2005-2007) City of Tucson (Councilmember, 2007-present) Tucson Vice Mayor (2013)

Awards: LULAC/F.B.I. Community Service Award from the League of United Latin American Citizens / Federal Bureau of Investigation. Woman of Influence Award from Wings for Women (2014) Given the 40 under 40 Award by the Arizona Daily Star for recognition as a young leader making an impact in the community with her professional and charitable work (2013) Job Path Leadership Award from Job Path (2011) Recognized as a Champion for Women and Children by Child and Family Resources (2010) Recognized at Midvale Park Neighborhood Festival on October 22nd, 2011 for her service and dedication for the betterment of the Midvale Park Community Councilor Romero was given the award by Midvale Park Neighborhood Association President Joe Miller. Public Servant of the Year from the Tucson Mountains Association (2010)

24 Associations: Las Adelitas (Co-Founder) This group pushes progressive values to Latino voters Southern Arizona Center Against Sexual Assault (Board Member) Cesar Chavez Holiday Coalition (Co-Founder)

Websites: Official - http://www.tucsonaz.gov/ward-1 Campaign: http://www.votereginaromero.com/about_rr.html

Social Media:Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/tucson.romero Twitter - https://twitter.com/tucsonromero LinkedIn- https://www.linkedin.com/pub/regina-romero/b/682/89b

Religion: Grew up Catholic (http://translate.google.com/translate? hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.beliefnet.com/Espanol/Regina-Romero-Tucson-Council- Woman.aspx&prev=search)

Official Bio

Since 2007, Regina Romero has proudly served Tucson residents on the City Council. She brings more than fifteen years’ experience in progressive public policy, job training and neighborhood reinvestment to the Council.

Romero has championed successful efforts to bring new jobs and economic development to Tucson, while working to improve the climate for existing small businesses. She led the City to bring back its economic development office and create a small business forum. She improved the Small Business Enterprise program, a plan that enhances opportunities for local vendors to do business with the City of Tucson. She pushed for changes to the land use code to promote green building and smart growth, and updated certificate of occupancy rules to make it easier to re-use older buildings.

PERSONAL LEGAL HISTORY 1. 5 traffic tickets since 1995 https://apps.supremecourt.az.gov/publicaccess/caselookup.aspx 2. Nothing major here; speeding tickets and parking tickets. 3. Regina and her husband were sued for a car accident in a case that was ultimately dismissed, most likely due to the couple and the plaintiff settling out of court. (Oscar Martinez vs. Regina Romero & Ruben Reyes, Jr. (Case # 20122681, Pima County Superior Court, filed 4/26/2012) 4. No tax liens or late payment of taxes.

25 ABORTION 1. Voted to authorize a grant application for the Gila River Indian Community in support of the activities of Planned Parenthood Arizona (Consent Item G, page 14, 8/6/2008; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2008/MN_08- 06-08.pdf)

BUSINESS ISSUES 4. Voted to impose a Transaction Privilege Tax on the business of health spas and other fitness related businesses (Ordinance #10685, page 7, 6/16/2009, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2009/MN_06-16-09.pdf) 5. Voted for legislation supporting the federal Employee Free Choice Act, which would have taken away the right to secret ballot in voting whether or not workers wanted to have a union (Consent Item R, page 14, 9/9/2009, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2009/MN_09-09-09.pdf; http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB124165379013293871, 5/7/2009, Article written by former Democratic presidential candidate George McGovern opposing this legislation) 6. Voted to impose a new fee on pawn shop transactions (Consent Item F, pages 9- 10, 5/18/2010, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2010/MN_05-18- 10.pdf)

GOOD GOVERNMENT 3. Opposed bringing in new university to Tucson, turning away potentially over 1,000 jobs with it (https://arizonadailyindependent.com/2013/05/28/tucson-to- turn-away-grand-canyon-university/5/28/2013)…despite originally supporting the College and bringing the idea to the table in the first place (http://www.tucsonweekly.com/TheRange/archives/2013/05/28/regina- romero-to-pull-support-of-the-el-riogrand-canyon-university-proposal; 5/28/2013) 4. As a councilperson, she has incurred these notable expenditures using taxpayer dollars: a. $413.00 to American Airlines, with a $363.00 purchase on 1/28/2014 b. $724.30 to the Conrad Hotel in Chicago on 3/10/2014 c. $163.04 to the Holiday Inn Hemosillo, Mexico on 12/8/2014 d. $289.95 in purchases over the years to Mariscos Chihuahua, a Mexican seafood restaurant in Tucson (https://www.facebook.com/MariscosChihuahuaGrant) e. $226.78 in purchases over the years to Taco Giro Mexican Grill (http://www.tacogirotucson.com/)

26 5. Supported bill requiring companies working city contracts hire locals from Tucson to complete the work, even over the objections of businessmen. (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/city-considers-local-hire- law/article_26d1f0f0-3e34-5c9a-899c-0f608ab57f28.html, 11/27/2011) 6. Voted to adopt the 2012 International Building Code (Ordinance 11042, pages 11- 12, 12/18/2012, (http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2012/MN_12- 18-12.pdf) There are many that feel this is implementing Agenda 21, which many feel is a potential future land grab by the United Nations. (http://agenda21news.com/2014/09/uns-international-building-codes- necessary-tool-agenda-21-implementation/) 7. Urged the EPA/Obama Admin to strengthen carbon pollution regulations in Tucson after Az. Gov. Jan Brewer pulled state out of the Western Climate Initiative (http://www.biologicaldiversity.org/news/press_releases/2011/clean- air-cities-12-21-2011.html) Adoption of the Waxman-Markey climate change bill, which Brewer opposed, would cost Arizona 24,472 jobs over the course of time from 2012-2035. (http://s3.amazonaws.com/thf_media/2009/pdf/wm2504_table1.pdf) 8. Wanted to suspend fees and curfews on Occupy Tucson (http://tucson.com/news/opinion/editorial/court-best-suited-to-decide-rights- of-occupy-tucson/article_a206a59b-e025-52b9-97e4-6e318a33c2f1.html) 9. Voted to increase bus fees (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/city- tentatively-oks-bus-fare-hikes/article_8e80d355-5a64-5761-83db- 0a6eca6c5e6d.html; Ordinance # 10672, page 22, 6/2/2009, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2009/MN_06-02-09.pdf) a. Regular bus fares from $1.00 to $1.25, a 25% increase b. Day pass increase from $2.00 to $3.00, a 50% increase c. Monthly passes from $28.00 to $35.00, a 25% increase 10. Wanted to see city dip deeper into rainy day fund to cover shortfalls rather than tax hikes or spending cuts (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/city- budget-options-revisit-rental-tax/article_cd44c388-de12-5b0b-9aec- c43cfb86f8da.html) 11. Supported putting land use rules for developers on hold for 5 years (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/tucson-might-let-developers- put-land-use-rules-on-hold/article_666a3bbd-2116-5758-ae39- fcd8fafeb0ed.html) 12. When police union was upset with city over poor pay, Councilwoman Romero said that they were already receiving good pay (http://www.transformingnetworkinfrastructure.com/news/2008/04/26/34103 10.htm)

GUNS

27 1. Voted to urge the Arizona Legislature to repeal its law banning cities from enacting gun legislation; presumably for Tucson city council people to enact stricter gun laws than the State of Arizona (City Manager Communication #18, page 18, 1/8/2013, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2013/MN_01-08-13.pdf)

IMMIGRATION 1. Voted to make Tucson an “immigrant welcoming city”. (Resolution #21944, page 15, 8/7/2012, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2012/MN_08-07- 12.pdf)

TAXES AND FEE INCREASES 5. Voted to send a measure to the voters to increase the maximum amount Tucson could impose for city sales taxes from 2% to 2.5%, a 25% increase (Ordinance # 10820, page 17, 7/7/2010, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2010/MN_07-07-10.pdf) 6. Voted to increase by $12 the annual business license fee (Substitute motion, page 10, 11/16/2010, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2010/MN_11-16- 10.pdf) 7. Voted to increase water usage fees (Ordinance 10987, Pages 18-19, 5/22/2012, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2012/MN_05-22-12.pdf) 8. Voted to again increase water usage fees (Consent Item C, page 6, 3/5/2013, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2013/MN_03-05-13.pdf)

WASTE 1. Introduced a measure, and supported, creating a city holiday honoring Caesar Chavez, which could cost taxpayers as much as $500k (http://www.tucsonsentinel.com/local/report/030314_chavez_holiday/city- council-approves-cesar-chavez-holiday/, 3/3/2014; Ordinance # 11146, page 13, 3/4/2014) 2. Voted to authorize the sale of $80 million in bonds for the Rio Nuevo development project; this project has been called “the biggest failure in Tucson history”, with some estimates the project has wasted $230 million (http://www.tucsonnewsnow.com/story/21008933/rio-nuevo-rises-from-the- ashes, 2/6/2013; Consent Item H, page 7, 12/9/2008; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2008/MN_12-09-08.pdf) 3. Voted to continue the relationship with the Rio Nuevo District (Resolution 21707, page 16, 3/22/2011, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2011/MN_03-22-11.pdf)

28 4. Wanted the city to piggyback on Pima County bond vote to fund construction projects for meeting ADA compliance (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and- politics/city-needs-up-to-m-to-comply-with-ada/article_2090bd29-01ff-5bc1- 824e-7909e0bd4a9a.html) 5. Developer cheats city out of tens of thousands of dollars, Romero pushes to reward them with further contracts and payouts (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/josh-brodesky-city-continues- to-reward-failing-developer/article_3e5bec99-abc7-5880-8fba- eec237681be5.html) 6. Gave $8,000 of her office’s account towards teaching kids graffiti (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/city-pays-for- graffiti/article_423805f8-ccd3-5e24-8165-8d6bbf705049.html) 7. Wanted city to spend $65k on study of potential arts district (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/city-may-ok-k-for-arts- district-study/article_8ae7a056-3f9c-57bf-9f0a-0f1e5a547ecc.html) 8. Supported allowing 15 teens to determine how to invest $25k of city funds in the city youth program (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue/2008/07/25/91897- youths-get-green-light-to-divvy-up-city-funds/) 9. Helped use city funds to fund teenager’s documentary of city neighborhoods (https://www.nexis.com/results/docview/docview.do? docLinkInd=true&risb=21_T22017059907&format=GNBFI&sort=BOOLEAN&st artDocNo=751&resultsUrlKey=29_T22017059911&cisb=22_T22017059910&tree Max=true&treeWidth=0&csi=255270&docNo=756)

SOCIAL ISSUES 1. Endorses freedom of marriage movement (http://whymarriagemattersarizona.org/arizonans-for-freedom-tucson-city- councilor-regina-romero/) 2. Vocal opponent of gender wage gap (http://www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/tempe/2015/04/14/arizona-cities- follow-phoenix-wage-gap-fight/25786751/) 3. Fought for paid holiday honoring Caesar Chavez (http://tucson.com/news/opinion/column/honor-chavez-today-with-service- free-park-day/article_ffafde36-b501-53aa-a2d2-69eb173697be.html) 4. Voted to fire City Manager in 2009 over performance issues (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/council-votes---to-fire-city- manager/article_85568180-5419-5636-a3be-1b48f96c34c7.html) …local business leaders were very critical of the firing as there was no game plan on replacement or the future of the city in consideration with the decision (http://tucson.com/business/business-leaders-critical-of-hein-s- firing/article_0f7a00e6-b7ab-5143-b2c6-a3329dd17c94.html)

29 5. Voted to allow extension in developers’ contracts during the slow economy (http://tucson.com/news/opinion/editorial/county-should-give-builders- deadline-relief/article_a414ea60-895a-513f-9bd4-033f4b6f9204.html) 6. Initially supported 2% tax on rented property (http://www.norenttax.com/news/view.cfm?id=1241390660) 7. Pushed for legislation expanding staff benefits to same sex couples (note that these extensions were applied to heterosexual couples not married as well (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/expanding-city-staff-s- benefits-supported/article_fdd8eb0a-b354-55d3-9e23-6f4eac80b069.html)

STUPIDITY AND RIDICULOUSNESS 1. Voted to urge the Hershey candy company to stop selling and marketing “Ice Breakers Pacs” due to them looking like meth. (Consent Item J, 1/15/2008; http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2008/MN_01-15-08.pdf, page 14; https://aftermathnews.wordpress.com/2008/01/25/hershey-pulls-candy- that-resembles-bags-of-heroin-and-cocaine/) 2. Violated AZ open meetings requirements with series of private council meetings (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue2/2009/05/15/130867-council-s-talks-likely- violated-arizona-open-meetings-law/, 5/15/2009)

POLITICAL STANCES 14. Said that Republicans’ attempts to make Tucson voting more democratic was “going around the will of the people” (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and- politics/republican-group-sues-to-change-city-council- elections/article_cdc9c706-8dbe-5080-8452-8bcc30a68e87.html) 15. Deep disagreement / distrust between Romero and Mayor Rothschild over streetcar development (http://tucson.com/news/blogs/pueblo-politics/political- notebook-romero-and-rothschild-spar-over-streetcar/article_d3d41140-1e70- 589f-9409-83f37a65eba3.html) 16. Supported all-mail voting in Tucson with goal being to increase voter turnout (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/tucson-oks-all-mail-elections- beginning-with-votes-this-year/article_f8f32e92-9c88-5340-b1fe- fe19e29ed87b.html) 17. Endorsed Obama in 2008 (http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue/2008/01/31/75609-old-west-shootout-for- latinos-votes/)

30 Controversial contributions 1. $100.00 from Congressman Raul Grijava (D) on 4/29/2007 2. $100.00 from Pamela Sutherland, Executive Director of the pro-abortion Arizona List, on 5/11/2007 3. $5.00 from Zach Trainer, finance assistant for Arizona List, on 5/11/2007 4. $1,000.00 from Arizona List on 11/1/2007. They made another $1,000.00 contribution on 4/1/2015 5. $10.00 from James Jordan, a paid activist for the Alliance for Global Justice. This group recognizes “the concentration of wealth and power is the root cause of oppression” and seeks socialistic solutions to right these perceived wrongs (https://afgj.org/about/our-mission), such as “US Militarism” and for “real” democracy. 6. $100.00 from Deyanira Nevarez, project director of Save Ethnic Studies, which seeks to overturn the ban on Mexican American studies in Arizona (https://www.facebook.com/saveethnicstudies/info?tab=page_info) 7. $500.00 on 4/13/2011 and $500.00 on 5/24/2011 from Arizona List 8. $430.00 from the Political Committee of Planned Parenthood of Tucson on 10/10/2011 9. $25.00 from Edna Meza-Aguirre on 5/17/2015 10. $10.00 from Laura Roth-Hogan, political director of Arizona List, on 4/19/2015 11. $50.00 from Pam Simon, outreach coordinator for Every Town for Gun Safety, a group that wants to limit our 2nd amendment gun rights (http://everytown.org/who-we-are/) This group is co-chaired by Michael Bloomberg, a known anti-gun crusader. (http://www.capitalnewyork.com/article/media/2015/05/8567578/bloombergs- gun-safety-sets-editorial-operation) 12. $500.00 from the Livable Communities PAC, a group that advocates for “smart growth”, code for imposing restrictions on development. (http://www.livpac.com/who-we-are/)

Unions 1. $50.00 from UFCW Local 99 union rep Paul Rubin on 5/22/2007 2. $20.00 from Raquel Teran, organizer for the SEIU union, on 3/30/2007 3. $50.00 from Paul Rubin, a union rep for UFCW Local 99 on 4/27/2011 4. $25.00 from Linda Hatfield, President of CWA Local 700, on 5/28/2011 5. $20.00 from Laura Hogan, Field Director for the AZ AFL-CIO on 5/23/2011 6. $50.00 from Paul Rubin, union rep for UFCW Local 99, on 4/25/2015 7. $430.00 from Ironworkers Local Union #75 on 5/30/2011 8. $2,080.00 from UFCW Local 99 PAC on 3/3/2011 9. $2,170.00 from AFSCME/AFL-CIO in Washington, DC on 6/17/2011 10. $430.00 from Local Union 469 PAC on 7/7/2011

31 11. $50.00 from Roman Ulman, Executive Director of the AFSCME People Conference on 8/26/2011 12. $60.00 from Fred Yamashita, union rep for UFCW Local 99, on 3/12/2015

Attorneys 1. $25.00 from Marla Borbon on 3/25/2007 2. $10.00 to Bruce Burke on 3/26/2007 3. $50.00 from Margo Cowan on 3/25/2007 4. $10.00 from John Crow on 4/18/2007 5. $10.00 from Bunny Davis on 3/23/2007 6. $20.00 from Paul Durham on 4/10/2007 7. $100.00 from Brendan Griffin on 4/19/2007 8. $20.00 from Rachel Kondor on 4/6/2007 9. $250.00 from Michael McNulty on 4/13/2007 10. $10.00 from Vincent Rabago on 3/17/2007 11. $200.00 from Jonathan Rothschild on 3/25/2007 12. $50.00 from Andrew Schorr on 4/23/2007 13. $250.00 from Frank Bangs, Jr. on 4/28/2007 14. $50.00 from Lisa Bibbens on 4/18/2007 15. $100.00 from Arthur Chapa on 5/11/2007 16. $20.00 from Mich Coker on 4/22/2007 17. $50.00 from John Crow on 5/11/2007 18. $50.00 from Anne Graham-Bergin on 3/21/2007 19. $25.00 from Linda Henderson on 4/28/2007 20.$50.00 from Barbara LaWall on 5/11/2007 21. $390.00 from Doug Levy on 4/24/2007 22.$140.00 from Grace Mcilvain; $40.00 on 4/2/2007, $50.00 on 5/11/2007, and $50.00 on 5/24/2007 23.$100.00 from Leslie Nixon on 5/2/2007 24.$50.00 from Nancy O’Neill on 5/11/2007 25. $100.00 from William Risner on 3/25/2007 26.$200.00 from Mary Beth Savel on 4/19/2007 27. $50.00 from SL Sohorr on 5/1/2007 28.$50.00 from Keri Silvyn on 4/19/2007 29.$100.00 from Maurice Destouet on 7/11/2007 30.$10.00 from James Fullen on 7/4/2007 31. $100.00 from Francisco Aguilar on 6/11/2007 32.$50.00 from Jeannine Mortimer Anjakos on 5/11/2007 33.$150.00 from Paul Eckerstrom on 5/9/2007 34.$390.00 from Robert Gugino on 6/11/2007 35. $390.00 from Moses Mercado on 7/1/2007

32 36.$25.0 from Mark O’Hare on 6/7/2007 37. $10.00 from Amelia Craig Cramer on 10/2/2007 38.$200.00 from Mich Coker on 4/19/2011 39.$100.00 from Marjorie Cunningham on 4/11/2011 40.$20.00 from Paul Durham on 4/1/2011 41. $50.00 from Stanley Feldman on 4/11/2011 42.$40.00 from James Fullin on 3/28/2011 43.$50.00 from Rodney Glassman on 2/24/2011 44.$50.00 from Sasha Glassman on 2/24/2011 45. $100.00 from Philip Hall on 5/30/2011 46.$250.00 from Lawrence Hecker on 5/16/2011 47. $50.00 from Jeffrey Imig on 5/24/2011 48.$20.00 from Penelope Jacks on 4/27/2011 49.$50.00 from Russell Jones on 5/16/2011 50.$50.00 from Barry Kirschner on 4/11/2011 51. $100.00 from Dana Pitt on 5/24/2011 52. $50.00 from Vince Rabago on 4/4/2011 53. $75.00 from Jonathan Rothschild on 2/26/2011 54. $410.00 from Pamela Sutherland on 1/20/2011 55. $100.00 from Kathleen Williamson on 4/27/2011 56. $100.00 from Kendrick Wilson on 4/3/2011 57. $100.00 from Paul Eckerstrom on 4/8/2011 58.$50.00 from Rodney Glassman on 5/16/2011 59. $20.00 from former AZ Attorney General Terry Goddard on 3/28/2011 60.$50.00 from Patrick Griffin on 4/8/2011 61. $250.00 on 5/24/2011 and $180.00 on 5/28/2011 from Robert Gugino 62.$50.00 from Barry Kirschner on 5/16/2011 63.$100.00 from Barbara Lawall on 5/16/2011 64.$300.00 from Richard Martinez on 5/11/2011 65. $30.00 from Bill Risner on 4/8/2011 66.$200.00 on 2/24/2011 and $230.00 on 4/8/2011 from Jeffrey Rogers 67. $120.00 from Jonathan Rothschild on 5/25/2011 68.$100.00 from Keri Silvyn on 4/11/2011 69.$100.00 from Donna Snyder on 5/11/2011 70.$20.00 from Scott Clark on 6/6/2011 71. $180.00 from Lawrence Hecker on 6/15/2011 72. $100.00 from Kathleen Williamson on 6/6/2011 73. $20.00 from Charles Hyde on 8/19/2011 74. $50.00 from Richard Jones on 8/11/2011 75. $250.00 from Eric Ollason on 8/19/2011 76. $30.00 from Barbara Burstein on 4/23/2015

33 77. $500.00 from George Cunningham on 3/21/2015 78. $250.00 from Marjorie Cunningham on 4/14/2015 79. $100.00 from Philip Hall on 4/8/2015 80.$500.00 from Lawrence Hecker on 5/9/2015 81. $150.00 from Peter Hormel on 5/21/2015 82.$25.00 from Penelope Jacks on 4/27/2015 83.$20.00 from Barry Kirschner on 3/28/2015 84.$100.00 on 4/23/2015, and $10.00 on 5/7/2015 from Leslie Nixon 85.$15.00 from Kasey Nye on 2/14/2015 86.$100.00 from Norma Kristine Rabago on 5/21/2015 87. $100.00 from Vince Rabago on 5/21/2015 88.$25.00 from Jonathan Rothschild on 3/3/2015 89.$50.00 from Sherry Teachnor on 4/29/2015 90.$10.00 from Sue Ann Welch on 4/23/2015 91. $50.00 from Kathleen Williamson on 4/9/2015 92.$250.00 from Frank Bangs on 4/27/2015 93.$100.00 from Robert Gugino on 5/4/2015 94.$200.00 from Barbara LaWall on 5/7/2015 95. $50.00 from Robert Schwartz on 3/12/2015 96.$500.00 from Keri Silvyn on 3/10/2015 97. $50.00 from Kendrick Wilson on 4/21/2015

Questionable campaign expenditures 1. $200.00 for tickets for the Arizona List Luncheon, a pro-abortion group, on 5/3/2007

IMMIGRATION 1. Supports issuing IDs to undocumented workers in Tucson (http://www.tucsonweekly.com/TheRange/archives/2015/03/11/immigration- rights-activists-have-upcoming-plans-to-work-with-city-to-issue-ids-for- undocumented-people, 3/11/2015) 2. Opposed “show-me-your-papers” policing rules, happy to see them lifted (http://tucson.com/news/tucson-police-revise-immigration- policy/article_b59466dc-cb05-5c51-94bc-c036478d2eb8.html, 2/24/2015) 3. Wanted Obama to stop deporting “non-criminal” illegal immigrants. (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/city-may-ask-obama-to-curb- deportations/article_ce7ffcca-c27f-56fb-8039-388baaa87e48.html, 7/3/2014) 4. Supported Tucson becoming “immigrant welcoming city” (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/tucson-becomes-an- immigrant-welcoming-city/article_c63f3f19-db26-5940-a1b1- 8dc38428248d.html, 8/8/2012)

34 5. Called for the Tucson City Attorney to bring a lawsuit against the State of Arizona over the constitutionality of the state’s immigration crack down (http://www.cnn.com/2010/POLITICS/05/06/arizona.immigration.boycott/, 5/6/2010)

35 PAUL ARTHUR CUNNINGHAM CONFIDENTIAL RESEARCH DOCUMENT

36 Key Points

Age: 41 (Born in April 1974) Residence: Resides at 2713 North Neruda Lane in Tucson; house is assessed at $159,967.00 (http://www.asr.pima.gov/links/frm_Parcel.aspx? parcel=110152550&taxyear=2016#taxpayer) Tucson, AZ (native) Also owns property at 1205 North Santa Rosa Avenue assessed at $101,677.00. (http://www.asr.co.pima.az.us/links/frm_Parcel.aspx? parcel=121114310&taxyear=2016) Family: Married to Erica Hansen on 11/2/2006, remarried to Alisa Anne Alonzo on 1/27/2015, 2 sons Education: Rincon High School 1992 B.A., History, University of Arizona M.A., Social Work, Arizona State University Employment: US Army (E-5, 1992-2001) A Company 5th Battalion 10th Infantry A Company 232 Medical Battalion HQ Co. 9th Battalion 40th Armor E Troop 1st Battalion 98th Aviation HQ Co. 1st Squadron 285th Aviation TEAM TUCSON (Chairman, 2005-2006) Sunnyside United School District (Coach, 2001-2007) Pima County (Juvenile Probation Officer, 1998-2010) City of Tucson (Councilman, 2010-present) Vice Mayor of Tucson (2014) Websites: Official - http://www.tucsonaz.gov/ward-2/paul-cunninghams-bio Social Media:Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/paul.cunningham.7121 Campaign FB- https://www.facebook.com/TucsonWard2 Twitter - https://twitter.com/paultucson LinkedIn- https://www.linkedin.com/pub/paul- cunningham/59/6a4/661

Religiosity: Judaism

OFFICIAL BIO

37 Paul Cunningham is a native Tucsonan and longtime community activist with 19 years of professional and volunteer public service. His is the son of former State Senator George Cunningham and lifelong Tucson advocate Margie Cunningham.

Cunningham started his career at the Ott Family YMCA located in Ward 2. He is a 12 year veteran of the Pima County Juvenile Probation Department, and served in the Army Reserve and National Guard from 1993-2001.

A 1992 graduate of Rincon High School, Paul has a B.A. in History from the University of Arizona and a Master's Degree from ASU. Councilmember Cunningham served on the Arizona Juvenile Justice Commission, the Correction Officer Retirement Local Board, has been active in volunteering with Youth on their Own, Our Family, the Pima County Probation Officers Association, National Youth Sports, the YMCA, Friends of the Library, and the Community Prevention Coalition. He and several youth founded “TEAM Tucson” (teen empowerment and advocacy movement) in 2005. He also authored a youth empowerment program, known as the “Hoop Dreams: Control Your Destiny” curriculum. He is the former president of the EL GHEKO neighborhood association.

Since being sworn into office in, Councilmember Cunningham championed preseason professional soccer as an economic development engine for Tucson. In the past two years, ties with Major League Soccer have grown and the league considers Tucson its “Western Hub.”

Councilmember Cunningham is committed to safeguarding Tucson’s greatest asset – our water supply. He championed our current water service area policy and advocated for rainwater harvesting rebates. He firmly believes that policies like these are the only way to ensure the long term viability of both our community and the precious desert we live in.

Paul was sworn in as a councilmember by his Grandmother, retired Superior Court Judge Lillian Fisher, on May 11, 2010. He was elected to a full term in November of 2011. On April 8, 2014, Paul was selected by his colleagues to be Vice Mayor. He served in that position until December of 2014. He has two sons.

PERSONAL LEGAL HISTORY

38 1. 15 traffic offenses since 1994 (https://apps.supremecourt.az.gov/publicaccess/caselookup.aspx) Some of the notable tickets he has gotten are for: a. No current registration (Case # M-1041-TR-8093665, 12/18/2008; Case # M-1041-TR-1476021, 7/22/2014) b. Red light camera violations (Case # M-10410TR-8084265, 7/17/2008; Case # M-1041-TR-8093665, 1/7/2009; Case # M-1041-TR-8141887, 6/15/2009; Case # M-1041-TR-9137532, 2/17/2010) c. No proof of insurance (Case # M-1041-CR-94087346, 9/17/1994; Case # M-1041-TR-12069735, 8/5/2013) d. Liquor to Minor by Licensee (Case # M-1041-CR-94087346, 9/17/1994) 2. No bankruptcies, federal lawsuits, late payments on property taxes, or tax liens

BUSINESS ISSUES 7. Voted to impose a new fee on pawn shop transactions (Consent Item F, pages 9- 10, 5/18/2010, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2010/MN_05-18- 10.pdf)

CRIME 2. Voted to remove the question of an applicant’s criminal history from the City of Tucson job application (Resolution 22373, 3/17/2015, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/sirepub/mtgviewer.aspx? meetid=1401&doctype=AGENDA)

GOVERNING 1. Said that Tucson is “ground zero for climate change” (http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/nov/3/tucson-eyes-expanding- rainwater-harvesting-rebates/) 2. Notable expenditures of taxpayer dollars he’s spent (spending records from the City of Tucson, spreadsheet in a separate document): a. $43.48 in purchases on iTunes over the years b. $515.56 in purchases at Daglio’s Cheesesteaks in 2011 (It appears that this establishment has since closed: http://www.yelp.com/biz/daglios- cheesesteaks-hoagies-tucson) c. $210.96 to Grandma Tony’s Pizza in purchases since 2014 (http://grandmatonyspizza.com/) d. $369.70 to Soccer and Tennis LTD, a soccer shop, on 6/30/2013

3. Worked with Mayor Rothschild to build a 130 foot student tower in a residential neighborhood that promised neighbors a maximum height of 90 feet

39 (http://www.tucsonweekly.com/tucson/overlay-overdose/Content? oid=3880860) 4. Voted to approve combined $11M pay raises for Tucson employees – up from what was supposed to be only a $5.3M raise (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/city-pay-raises-balloon-to- m/article_053998e3-8389-51ec-9453-bfe947f560e1.html) 5. Voted to adopt the 2012 International Building Code (Ordinance 11042, pages 11- 12, 12/18/2012, (http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2012/MN_12- 18-12.pdf) There are many that feel this is implementing Agenda 21, which many feel is a potential future land grab by the United Nations. (http://agenda21news.com/2014/09/uns-international-building-codes- necessary-tool-agenda-21-implementation/)

IMMIGRATION 2. Voted to make Tucson an “immigrant welcoming city”. (Resolution #21944, page 15, 8/7/2012, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2012/MN_08-07- 12.pdf)

WASTE 1. Involved in a sexual harassment scandal during trip that cost taxpayers $58,000.00 (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/snell-k-san-diego- trip-was-profitable/article_4f36ab36-9e45-5ec9-a0a9-317274361176.html, 6/9/2012) 2. Voted to continue the relationship with the Rio Nuevo District (Resolution 21707, page 16, 3/22/2011, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2011/MN_03-22-11.pdf) This project has been called “the biggest failure in Tucson history”, with some estimates the project has wasted $230 million (http://www.tucsonnewsnow.com/story/21008933/rio-nuevo-rises-from-the- ashes, 2/6/2013) 3. Supported creating a city holiday honoring Caesar Chavez, which could cost taxpayers as much as $500k (http://www.tucsonsentinel.com/local/report/030314_chavez_holiday/city- council-approves-cesar-chavez-holiday/, 3/3/2014; Ordinance # 11146, page 13, 3/4/2014)

SOCIAL ISSUES

40 1. Pushed to allow home delivery for medical marijuana (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/new-medical-pot-rules-longer- hours-home-delivery/article_2e42c959-13eb-503f-b540-b270cc1f8f92.html) 2. Heavily advocates expansion of Tucson’s marijuana industry (http://tucson.com/news/local/column/steller-tucson-risks-losing-a-longtime- industry-marijuana/article_5f11765a-b5f3-5277-ab21-2cc7b4cb47ee.html) 3. Backing a measure to make cops not ticket or arrest for possession of small amounts of marijuana (http://www.tucsonweekly.com/tucson/dreams-of- legalization/Content?oid=3941515) 4. Planned to visit Occupy Wall Street camp (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt- and-politics/occupiers-ask-city-council-to-end-curfew/article_b1df149e-1ed7- 56a8-88a1-01df9b74e40c.html) 5. Voted to “enhance” the city’s support of civil unions and domestic partnerships (Ordinance #11088, page 9, 6/18/2013, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2013/MN_06-18-13.pdf)

TAX AND FEE INCREASES 1. Voted to increase water usage fees (Ordinance 10987, Pages 18-19, 5/22/2012, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2012/MN_05-22-12.pdf) 2. Voted to again increase water usage fees (Consent Item C, page 6, 3/5/2013, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2013/MN_03-05-13.pdf)

GUNS 1. Supports increasingly restrictive gun laws – mandatory intoxication testing for negligent discharging of a weapon (later overturned by the state’s Attorney General) (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/tucson-city-council- oks-two-gun-laws-to-give-police/article_3329b12d-47be-5337-ad04- 70e0e6e85cf0.html) 2. Voted for background checks on those purchasing guns at gun show… show skips town (http://www.tucsonweekly.com/TheRange/archives/2013/02/06/tucson- city-council-advances-plan-for-background-checks-but-gun-show-will-probably- go-on-elsewhere) 3. Voted to urge the Arizona Legislature to repeal its law banning cities from enacting gun legislation; presumably for Tucson city council people to enact stricter gun laws than the State of Arizona (City Manager Communication #18, page 18, 1/8/2013, http://www.tucsonaz.gov/files/clerks/minutes/2013/MN_01-08-13.pdf)

POLITICAL ISSUES

41 1. Didn’t even win the vote within his district during last election but was elected due to city’s citywide election laws (http://tucson.com/news/local/columnists/steller/steller-tucson-s- undemocratic-election-system-stays-intact-again/article_5a719445-10c4-5c05- a568-fb5b2dfc1d54.html)

Controversial Contributions 1. $10.00 contribution from Jennifer Allen, the Executive Director of Border Action Network on 3/4/2011. This organization is rabidly anti-Border Patrol, and pro- open borders (http://americanpatrol.com/REFERENCE/Border-Action- Network.html) 2. $50.00 from CWA Local 7000 union leader Linda Hatfield 3. $2,170.00 from UCFW Local 99 union on 7/27/2011 4. $500.00 from the AFSCME union from Washington, DC on 8/11/2011 5. $50.00 from Laura Horton-Charles, a union rep from UFCW Local 99, on 1/11/2015 6. $10.00 from Rick Johnson, accountant for Jim Click Auto, on 1/25/2015. Controversial in the fact that Jim Click is funding the effort to oust Cunningham 7. $10.00 from Fred Yamashita, union rep for UFCW Local 99, on 1/7/2015 8. $10.00 from David Ceballos, union rep for UFLW 99 (I think this is meant to be spelled UFCW), on 1/7/2015 9. $10.00 from Linda Hatfield, president of the CWA Local 7000, on 1/21/2015 10. $20.00 from Jay Haubert, business agent for UFCW 99, on 1/7/2015

Contributions from attorneys 1. $10.00 from Cynnamon Arizpuru on 1/25/2011 2. $10.00 from Mich Coker on 3/4/2011 3. $10.00 from Annette Everlove on 1/23/2011 4. $50.00 from Rodney Glassman on 1/24/2011 5. $50.00 from Sasha Glassman on 1/24/2011 6. $100.00 from Lawrence Hecker on 1/25/2011, and $100.00 on 6/16/2011 7. $20.00 from Peter Hormel on 1/17/2011 8. $10.00 from Leslie Nixon on 3/2/2011 9. $10.00 from Nancy O’Neil on 1/27/2011 10. $10.00 from Leighton Rockafellow on 2/10/2011 11. $10.00 from Dwight Whitley on 1/30/2011 12. $200.00 from Shelly Abel on 3/3/2011 13. $100.00 from Eric Cahah on 3/8/2011 14. $20.00 from Scott Clark on 5/23/2011 15. $200.00 from former Attorney General Terry Goddard on 3/6/2011 16. $410.00 from Peter Hormel on 4/1/2011

42 17. $10.00 from Shari Lightstone on 2/6/2011 18. $10.00 from Tim Medcoff on 2/22/2011 19. $5.00 on 2/13/2011 and $50.00 on 4/28/2011 from Vince Rabago 20.$50.00 on 1/15/2011 and $150.00 on 4/28/2011 from Jeff Rogers 21. $100.00 from James Walsh on 4/6/2011 22.$200.00 from Greg Foster on 6/16/2011 23.$250.00 on 6/15/2011 and $100.00 on 6/30/2011 from Robert Gugino 24.$100.00 from Deborah Oseran on 7/21/2011 25. $230.00 from Jeff Rogers on 7/6/2011 26.$75.00 from Jonathan Rothschild on 6/20/2011 27. $430.00 from Annette Everlove on 9/28/2011 28.$500.00 from George Cunningham on 1/4/2015 29.$500.00 from Margie Cunningham on 1/4/2015 30.$10.00 from Barry Kirschner on 1/21/2015 31. $100.00 from Patrick Moran on 3/23/2015 32.$10.00 from Nancy O’Neill on 1/7/2015 33.$10.00 from Jeffrey Rogers on 3/23/2015, $200.00 on 4/12/2015 34.$20.00 from Jonathan Rothschild on 1/10/2015 35. $10.00 from Stacy Scheff on 1/8/2015 36.$500.00 from Keri Silvyn on 5/4/2015 37. $50.00 from Pam Sutherland on 1/10/2015 38.$10.00 from Dwight Whitley on 3/25/2015 39.$200.00 from Greg Foster on 4/5/2015

Other 1. Well known leftist blogger joins Cunningham’s staff (http://www.tucsonweekly.com/TheRange/archives/2013/01/11/rum- romanism-and-resurrection-lefty-blog-returns) 2. Gets red light camera tickets regularly – opposes red light cameras vehemently (http://www.tucsonweekly.com/tucson/image-problems/Content?oid=3910566)

MISCONDUCT

43 1. Despite his own legal troubles – his chief of staff Katie Bolger was also arrested for drunken behavior (http://tucson.com/news/local/tim-steller-cunningham- aide-katie-bolger-might-not-deserve-another/article_eedaeea5-2be4-5aa1-8f07- 37f9d3857acb.html, 4/10/2013) 2. More on Chief of Staff Katie Bolger’s arrest: (http://www.scrippsmedia.com/kgun9/news/200988751.html, 4/1/2013) Excerpt from her little rampage: “F**** you, you mother f****, you almost hit me." 3. While intoxicated, Cunningham sexually harassed 3 female city employees on trip (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/paul-cunningham-found-to- have-harassed-city-workers/article_cbd07898-6561-522b-ba7f- 65184e8afa56.html) …to which he later admitted (http://www.1041kqth.com/news/161251165.html)…and underwent treatment for drinking problem (http://tucson.com/news/local/govt-and- politics/cunningham-admits-drinking-problem/article_c6cc7f2a-e6a7-51e0- 8407-a40f9fffe65c.html) 4. Participates in “too Jewish” podcast to talk about Jewish heritage and overcoming addiction in his life (http://toojewishradio.podbean.com/e/too- jewish-32215-councilman-paul-cunningham/)