DOCSLIB.ORG

Winnipeg Taxicab Services Review FINAL REPORT December 20, 2016

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Winnipeg Taxicab Services Review FINAL REPORT December 20, 2016 Winnipeg Taxicab Services Review FINAL REPORT December 20, 2016 Prepared for: Taxicab Board, Manitoba Indigenous and Municipal Relations Prepared by Table of Contents 1.0 Executive Summary ................................................................................................................. 1 Industry Overview ................................................................................................................ 1 Findings ............................................................................................................................... 2 Recommendations ............................................................................................................... 6 Implementation ................................................................................................................... 9 Part I – Background and Approach ........................................................................................... 10 2.0 Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 10 Project Scope and Objectives ............................................................................................ 10 3.0 Methodology ......................................................................................................................... 11 Document Review .............................................................................................................. 11 Interviews .......................................................................................................................... 12 Stakeholder Consultation .................................................................................................. 12 Other Jurisdictional Research ............................................................................................ 15 Part II – Vehicle for Hire Industry Profile .................................................................................. 16 4.0 Canadian Vehicle for Hire Industry ......................................................................................... 16 5.0 Trends and Issues in the Vehicle For Hire Industry ................................................................. 18 Growth .............................................................................................................................. 18 Technology ........................................................................................................................ 19 Environmental ................................................................................................................... 19 Accessibility ....................................................................................................................... 19 Regulating Supply .............................................................................................................. 20 Transportation Networks – Driving Regulatory Change ..................................................... 23 6.0 The Taxicab Industry in Winnipeg .......................................................................................... 28 History ............................................................................................................................... 28 Regulatory Framework ...................................................................................................... 29 Taxicab Industry Participants ............................................................................................. 36 Winnipeg Market Information ............................................................................................ 45 Taxicab Trips in Winnipeg .................................................................................................. 49 Financial Performance ....................................................................................................... 53 Part III – Findings and Recommendations ............................................................................... 60 7.0 Regulatory Structure ............................................................................................................. 60 Effectiveness and Efficiency ............................................................................................... 60 Provincial Regulation of Taxicab Industry .......................................................................... 62 2016 Winnipeg Taxicab Services Review | Table of Contents Prepared by 8.0 Supply and Demand .............................................................................................................. 64 Demand for Vehicles for Hire in Winnipeg ......................................................................... 64 Supply in Winnipeg ............................................................................................................ 65 Is Supply Meeting Demand? .............................................................................................. 68 Insights from Other Jurisdictions ....................................................................................... 73 Recommendations ............................................................................................................. 76 9.0 Licensing Structure ................................................................................................................ 81 Taxicab Business Licence ................................................................................................... 84 Seasonal Taxicab Business Licences .................................................................................. 88 Dispatch............................................................................................................................. 90 Taxicab Driver’s Licence ..................................................................................................... 92 Insights from Other Jurisdictions ....................................................................................... 94 Fees ................................................................................................................................... 96 Recommendations ............................................................................................................. 97 10.0 Fares .................................................................................................................................... 102 Insights from Other Jurisdictions ..................................................................................... 105 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 109 11.0 Safety and Security.............................................................................................................. 112 Driver Safety .................................................................................................................... 112 Passenger Safety ............................................................................................................. 114 Vehicle Safety ................................................................................................................... 117 Consumer Protection ....................................................................................................... 118 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 119 12.0 Customer Service ................................................................................................................ 121 Quality of Service ............................................................................................................. 123 Priorities for Change and Problem Resolution ................................................................. 126 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 130 13.0 Compliance and Enforcement .............................................................................................. 131 Compliance Inspections .................................................................................................... 131 Complaint Submission Process ........................................................................................ 140 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 145 14.0 Summary of Recommendations .......................................................................................... 148 Section 7 – Regulatory Structure ................................................................................................. 148 Section 8 – Supply and Demand .................................................................................................. 149 Section 9 – Licensing Structure ................................................................................................... 154 Section 10 – Fares ....................................................................................................................... 158 Section 11 – Safety and Security .................................................................................................. 161 Section 12 – Customer Service .................................................................................................... 162 2016 Winnipeg Taxicab Services Review | Table of Contents Prepared by Section
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Vehicles for Hire Bylaws
    Chapter 280, VEHICLES FOR HIRE [HISTORY: Adopted by the Board of Selectmen of the Town of Falmouth 11-1-1990; amended in its entirety 2-13-2006. Subsequent amendments noted where applicable.] GENERAL REFERENCES Authority of Selectmen to enact taxicab regulations—See Ch. 65, Art. VI. Licenses and permits—See Ch. 140. ARTICLE I, General Provisions § 280-1. Definitions. The following words as used in these regulations, unless the context otherwise requires, shall have the following meanings: BASE -- The place of business licensed by the Town of Falmouth from which vehicles for hire shall be dispatched. CLEARED -- A taximeter is cleared when it is inoperative with respect to all fare indication, when no indication of fare or extras is shown and when all parts are in those positions in which they are designed to be when the vehicle on which the taximeter is installed is not engaged by a passenger. COLD TIRE PRESSURE -- The pressure of a tire when the tire is at ambient temperature. EXAMINER -- The Chief of Police of the Town of Falmouth or any person or persons so designated by the Chief of Police. EXTRAS -- Charges to be paid by a passenger in addition to the fare, including any charge at a flat rate for the transportation of passengers in excess of a stated number and any charge for the transportation of baggage. FACE -- That side of a taximeter upon which passenger charges are indicated. FARE -- That portion of the charge for the fare of a vehicle that is automatically calculated by a taximeter through the operation of the mileage or time mechanism.
    [Show full text]
  • St. Louis Metropolitan Taxicab Commission
    11/5/08 Rev. 8.3 METROPOLITAN TAXICAB COMMISSION St. Louis, Missouri VEHICLE FOR HIRE CODE Version 8.3 adopted by the MTC 2/28/10 effective 3/15/10 Revised – 12/07/2015 INDEX Chapter 1 Definitions 101 Definitions ................................................................................................................... Page 12 Chapter 2 Certificate of Convenience and Necessity 201 Certificate of Convenience and Necessity - Required – Application .......................... Page 24 202 Certificate of Convenience and Necessity - Hearing ................................................... Page 26 203 Certificate of Convenience and Necessity - Issuance - Factors .................................. Page 26 204 Certificate of Convenience and Necessity - Not Transferable ................................... Page 27 205 Discontinuing Service ................................................................................................. Page 27 206 Permits Assigned to Certificates of Convenience and Necessity ................................ Page 27 207 Suspension - Revocation - Hearing ............................................................................ Page 28 208 Garage Extra Vehicles ................................................................................................. Page 28 209 Insurance Required ...................................................................................................... Page 29 210 Addresses and Directories ..........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • COMMERCIAL GROUND TRANSPORTATION 10.1 Purpose These Rules and Regulations
    Omaha Airport Authority Section 10 SECTION 10 - COMMERCIAL GROUND TRANSPORTATION 10.1 Purpose These rules and regulations are promulgated to promote customer service and ensure safe, efficient and consistent movement for both the traveling public and commercial Passenger Carriers and Drivers transporting passengers to or from Eppley Airfield (note: terms in Section 10 of the OAA’s Rules and Regulations are defined herein, or have the meaning defined elsewhere in the OAA’s Rules and Regulations, or the State of Nebraska Public Service Commission’s Motor Carrier Rules and Regulations) . 10.2 Applicability The provision of ground transportation services at Eppley Airfield shall be governed by all applicable laws and ordinances (federal, state and local) in addition to these Rules and Regulations. Any person who engages in the provision of commercial ground transportation services at Eppley Airfield in a manner that is in violation of these Commercial Ground Transportation Rules and Regulations (CGTRR) shall be subject to the enforcement section of these CGTRR. Prior to operating at Eppley Airfield all ground transportation Passenger Carriers that desire to pick up or drop off passengers and conduct any business that generates revenue directly or indirectly from Eppley Airfield involving the movement of passengers in surface vehicles shall have in place, to the extent applicable as determined by the sole discretion of the OAA: (1) a valid classification permit issued by the State of Nebraska Public Services Commission (PSC) (for those entities
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 25 Vehicles for Hire
    CHAPTER 25 VEHICLES FOR HIRE1 Art. I. In General, §§ 25-1. -- 25-15. Art. II. Taxicabs, § 25-16 -- 25-53. Div. 1. Generally, §§ 25-16. -- 25-30. Div. 2. Business License, §§ 25-31. -- 25-45. Div. 3. Driver’s License, §§ 25-46. -- 25-53. ARTICLE I. IN GENERAL Secs. 25-1. -- 25-15. Reserved. ARTICLE II. TAXICABS DIVISION 1. GENERALLY Sec. 25-16. Definitions. The following words and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the meanings respectively ascribed to them: Motor Vehicle for Hire. The term “motor vehicle for hire” shall mean a motor vehicle not equipped with a taximeter designed to carry seven (7) or less persons for public hire at an hourly rate. Taxicab. The word “taxicab” shall mean a motor vehicle for transportation of seven (7) or less persons for hire upon a trip or mileage basis. (Code 1957, § 7.131) Cross reference - Definitions and rules of construction generally, §§ 1-2. Sec. 25-17. Lost Articles. Every taxicab driver, immediately after the termination of any hiring or employment, shall carefully search such taxicab for any property lost or left therein, and any such property unless sooner claimed or delivered to the owner shall be taken to the headquarters of the Police Department and deposited with the officer in charge within twenty-four (24) hours after the finding of such article. (Code 1957, § 7.147) 1 Cross reference – Traffic and motor vehicles, Ch. 22. 25-1 Detroit_906167_1 Sec. 25-18. Passengers. Every taxicab driver shall have the right to demand payment of the legal fare in advance, and may refuse employment until so prepaid, but no taxicab driver shall otherwise refuse or neglect to convey any orderly person upon request anywhere in the City unless previously engaged or unable to do so.
    [Show full text]
  • Concession Contract Between Metropolitan
    CONCESSION CONTRACT BETWEEN METROPOLITAN WASHINGTON AIRPORTS AUTHORITY AND TAXICAB COMPANY, INC. TO OPERATE A TAXICAB CONCESSION AT WASHINGTON DULLES INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT CONTRACT NO. 6-12-C002 INDEX Article Page I. Contract Term ............................................................................................................................1 II. Scope of Services .......................................................................................................................2 III. Premises and Facilities ...............................................................................................................3 IV. Operational Requirements .........................................................................................................4 V. Financial Consideration ...........................................................................................................13 VI. Performance Guarantee ............................................................................................................19 VII. Indemnification and Insurance .................................................................................................19 VIII. Quality of Performance and Liquidated Damages ...................................................................22 IX. Incorporation of Contractor’s Proposal and Confidentiality ...................................................23 X. Trademarks, Service Marks, or Logos .....................................................................................24 XI. Default
    [Show full text]
  • Page. CLAIMS of the PRINCIPLE of RPTATION of TURBINE ONE
    Page. CLAIMS OF THE PRINCIPLE OF RPTATION OF TURBINE ONE. What to claim is: 1. Rotation is obtained of the cross axial and axial bearing mounted turbine rotors, by shielding the returnblades partially or completely and uncovering the pushblades partially or completely. 2. Rotation of horizontal and vertical mounted rotor operable in bearings comprising at least three rotor blades radial and axially projecting its form expending from the hub. Cross-axial rotation of turbine rotors by means of shielding vane, or wind screen shielding the return blades partially or completely and uncovering the pushblades partially or completely for fluid to be channelled cross axially trough the intakes and impact coaxial and horizontally on the transverse projecting turbine rotor blades causing rotation of the prime mover, drivetrain by the converting kinetic energy into mechanical energy and into electric energy by means of a constant transmission turbine gearbox and lubricant system mechanical coupled in rotational mode with the electric generator rotor, comprising a cylindrical permanent or electromagnet coupled electrically to the exciter electrically connected with the disk magnet and axially opposing stator coils or disk or plates or massive electric conductive material disk or cylinder. 3. Rotation of the horizontal and vertical turbine rotor is obtained in clockwise direction and in counterclockwiswise direction. Generating AC current or dc current. Defines the rotor by at least two axial halves exposed axially for cross-axial flow axial flow and/or for perpendicularly flow turbine rotors. A left and right axial halve, or upper and lower axial halve which form the returnblades section and the pushblades intake and exhaust sections.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 25.1 of the County Code
    ARLINGTON COUNTY CODE Chapter 25.1 TAXICABS § 25.1-1. Purpose and Persons Covered. § 25.1-2. Definitions. § 25.1-3. Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity. § 25.1-4. Determination of Number of Taxicabs; Issuance of Certificates. § 25.1-5. Annual Certificate Fees and Application Fees. § 25.1-6. Certificate Form and Term. § 25.1-7. Insurance Requirements. § 25.1-8. Suspension or Revocation of Certificates. § 25.1-9. Public Vehicle Driver’s Licenses. § 25.1-10. Appeal from Suspension, Revocation or Denial of a Certificate or Public Vehicle Driver’s License. § 25.1-11. Records and Reports. § 25.1-12. Rate Schedule, Tolls, Payment. § 25.1-13. Rate Display Cards. § 25.1-14. Duty of Driver and Certificate-Holder to Charge Authorized Fare or Charge. § 25.1-15. Duty of Passenger to Pay Fare or Charge. § 25.1-16. Adjustments in Rates of Fare. § 25.1-17. Operation of Taxicabs. § 25.1-18. Taximeters, Maintenance and Inspection Thereof. § 25.1-19. Vehicles and Contents. § 25.1-20. Age of Vehicles. § 25.1-21. Inspection of Taxicabs; Inspection Fee; Procedure When Taxicab is Found in Unsafe, Unfit or Unclean Condition. § 25.1-22. Obstruction and Hindering of Official Duties; False Statements. § 25.1-23. Transfer of Certificates. § 25.1-24. Notification in Taxicabs of Proposed Amendments to this Chapter. § 25.1-25. Rules and Regulations. § 25.1-26. Compliance with this Chapter and Reciprocity Agreements. § 25.1-27. Enforcement. § 25.1-28. Penalties. § 25.1-29. Effect of Enactment of this Chapter. § 25.1-1. Purpose and Persons Covered.
    [Show full text]
  • Taxi Industry Regulation, Deregulation, and Reregulation: the Paradox of Market Failure
    Taxi Industry Regulation, Deregulation & Reregulation: the Paradox of Market Failure Paul Stephen Dempsey* TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Introduction ............................................... 74 II. Historical Antecedents of Modern Taxicab Regulation .... 76 III. Contemporary Statutory & Regulatory Criteria Governing the Taxi Industry .......................................... 77 A . N ew York ............................................. 78 B . Los A ngeles ........................................... 78 C . H ouston .............................................. 79 Copyright © 1996 by the author * Paul Stephen Dempsey is Professor of Law and Director of the Transportation Law Program at the University of Denver. He formerly served as an attorney with the Civil Aero- nautics Board and the Interstate Commerce Commission in Washington, D.C.. Professor Dempsey has written more than forty law review articles and six books: AVIATION LAW & REGULATION (two volumes, Butterworth 1993); AIRLINE DEREGULATION & LAISSEZ FAIRE MYTHOLOGY (Quorum Books, 1992); FLYING BLIND: THE FAILURE OF AIRLINE DEREG- ULATION (Economic Policy Institute, 1990); THE SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC CONSEOUENCES OF DEREGULATION (Quorum Books, 1989); LAW & FOREIGN POLICY IN INTERNATIONAL AVIATION (Transnational Publishers, 1987); and LAW & ECONOMIC REGULATION IN TRANSPORTATION (Quorum Books, 1986). Dr. Dempsey holds the following degrees: A.B.J., J.D., University of Georgia; LL.M., George Washington University; D.C.L., McGill University. He is admitted to practice law in Colorado, Georgia
    [Show full text]
  • 1. Taxicabs 2. U-Drive Motor Vehicles 3. Tour Services (4
    Chapter 12 REGULATIONS OF COMMON CARRIERS AND THEIR FEES Articles: 1. Taxicabs 2. U-Drive Motor Vehicles 3. Tour Services (4. General Provisions. Repealed by Ord. 16-38.) 4. Reserved 5. Pedicab 6. Private Transportation Companies, Vehicles, and Drivers Article 1. Taxicabs Sections: 12-1.1 Purpose—Scope—Definitions. 12-1.2 Establishment of road taxi stands—Fees. 12-1.3 Director of customer services—Authority. 12-1.4 Prohibited acts. 12-1.5 Fraudulent call and nonpayment. 12-1.6 Bulky items. 12-1.7 Disorderly persons. 12-1.8 Taximeters. (12-1.9 Taxicab driver's certificate. Repealed by Ord. 16-25.) (12-1.9 Taxicab driver's certificate. Automatically repealed on 3-16-17 per Ord. 16-38.) 12-1.9 Reserved. 12-1.10 Director to establish rate of fare and baggage charge—Exceptions—Conditions—Receipt required upon request. 12-1.11 Special operations. (12-1.11A Special operations for an interim period for Hanauma Bay Nature Park. Automatically repealed on 12-31-94 per Ord. 93-80.) 12-1.12 Trip records. 12-1.13 Soiling of taxicab. 12-1.14 Condition of taxicabs. (12-1.15 Taxicab license—Issuance—Fees. Repealed by Ord. 16-38.) 12-1.15 Reserved. 12-1.16 Taxi sign. 12-1.17 Violation—Penalty. (12-1.18 Appeals. Repealed by Ord. 16-25.) 12-1.18 Reserved. 12-1.19 Severability. 12-1.20 Taxicab certification numbers. 12-1.21 Trip route. (12-1.22 Annual reports. Repealed by Ord. 14-24.) 12-1.22 Reserved. 12-1.23 Evidence of financial responsibility.
    [Show full text]
  • Taxicab Regulations
    TAXICAB REGULATIONS ISSUED BY THE TOWN OF BROOKLINE TRANSPORTATION BOARD In cooperation with the BROOKLINE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS BROOKLINE POLICE DEPARTMENT BROOKLINE HEALTH DEPARTMENT Effective July 1, 2015 Transportation Board Brookline Department of Public Works Joshua Safer, Chairman Andrew M. Pappastergion, Commissioner Pamela Zelnick, Vice Chairman Peter M. Ditto, Director – DPW Engineering/Transportation Christopher Dempsey Kevin Johnson, Director – DPW Highways & Sanitation Guustaaf C.M. Driessen, PE Todd M. Kirrane, Transportation Administrator Scott Englnader Ali Tali, PE Brookline Health Department Ray Cunningham, Division of Weights & Measures Brookline Police Department Chief Daniel C. O’Leary Deputy Superintendent Myles Murphy Sergeant Michael Murphy 1 I. AUTHORITY AND PURPOSE A. Authority These Taxicab Regulations are promulgated under the authority vested in the Brookline Transportation Board by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts in Chapter 317 of the Acts of 1974. B. Purpose of Regulations 1. It is the purpose of these regulations to provide for the safe, fair, and efficient operation of taxicabs in the Town of Brookline, and to promote competition among taxicab companies for the benefit of the public. As “common carriers,” taxicabs are required to serve everyone who is able to pay and to satisfy specific service standards. Standards are established in the following regulations for the licensing and inspection of taxicabs, the inspection of taximeters, the examination of applicants for a license to drive such taxicabs, the licensing of taxicab drivers, and the permitting of taxicab dispatch services. These Taxicab regulations are promulgated to ensure that the public health, safety and welfare is protected, public needs are provided for, and public convenience is promoted in the Town of Brookline.
    [Show full text]
  • DRAFT Islandwide Taxi Regulations
    T OW N OF EDGARTOWN REGULATIONS TO TRANSPORT PERSONS ARTICLE II. EXCEPTIONS Nothing herein contained shall be construed as prohibiting a driver of a taxicab, transportation network company vehicle, or other private TOWN vehicle , licensed to perform such service within the County of Dukes County or by the OF Commonwealth, from driving through the Town of Edgartown or from accepting passengers or EDGARTOWN goods if summoned at the request of such passenger or client, by means of a telephone or radio dispatch from their principal place of business. ARTICLE III. AUTHORITY The Board of Selectmen as authorized pursuant to Section 22 of Chapter 40 of Massachusetts General Law may approve the adoption of regulations relative to the licensing and operation of taxicab, transportation network company, or other private vehicle services in Edgartown; and may, after providing public REGULATIONS TO notice, conduct hearings to amend the TRANSPORT PERSONS regulations. Any such amendments shall not take effect until published or posted in accordance with law. ARTICLE IV. PUBLIC ACCOMMODATION BOARD OF SELECTMEN As a place of public accommodation, a taxicab, EDGARTOWN, MASSACHUSETTS transportation network company, or other private vehicle business licensed by the Town shall reasonably afford full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities and privileges to all persons, subject only to the conditions and limitations established by law. Any act of adverse treatment, distinction, discrimination, or restriction because of a person’s race, color, religious creed, national ARTICLE I. PREAMBLE origin, sex, sexual orientation, physical In the Town of Edgartown, no person, business, disability, or mental disability, shall be deemed or corporation driving or having charge of a an unlawful act of discrimination.
    [Show full text]
  • Taxicab Ordinance 2008
    Taxicab Ordinance SAVANNAH CODE Part 6, Licensing and Regulation Chapter 1, Businesses and Occupations ARTICLE Q, Taxicabs Mobility & Parking Services Department Post Office Box 2101 Savannah, Georgia 31402 Phone (912) 651-6468 SAVANNAH CODE Part 6 Licensing and Regulation Chapter 1 Businesses and Occupations ARTICLE Q Taxicabs Section 6-1421. Title. This ordinance shall be known and may be recited as “The Taxicab Ordinance”. Section 6-1422. Definitions. (a) City. The word “city” shall mean the Mayor and Aldermen of the City of Savannah, Georgia a municipal corporation, said definition to include all areas within the corporate limits of the City of Savannah. (b) Taxicab. A motor vehicle engaged in the business of carrying passengers for hire, or offering to carry passengers for hire, except motor vehicles used as ambulances, sight-seeing cars or buses, and except for limousines and buses operating on a fixed route. (c) Taxicab Regulatory Permit. The right and privilege granted by the City for the operation of a taxicab within the corporate limits of the City issued upon the receipt of a regulatory fee established in the Revenue Ordinance. (d) Taxicab Company. The holder of one or more taxicab regulatory permits to operate a taxicab under the provisions of this ordinance, whether a person, firm, partnership, or corporation. (e) Driver. Any person who drives or operates a taxicab on the streets of Savannah. (f) Taxicab Driver’s Permit. The written authority granted by the City for an individual to drive or operate a taxicab within the City of Savannah. (g) Street. The word “street” shall mean and include any street, alley, lane, avenue, court, or public place in the City of Savannah.
    [Show full text]