Motivating Experiences in an Extended Chinese As a Foreign Language
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Motivating Experiences in an Extended Chinese as a Foreign Language Learning Career: Identifying what sustains learners to advanced-skill levels Dissertation Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Junqing Jia, M.A. Graduate Program in East Asian Languages and Literatures The Ohio State University 2017 Dissertation Committee: Galal Walker, Advisor Mari Noda Xiaobin Jian Copyright by Junqing Jia 2017 Abstract What learning experiences can be pedagogically designed to motivate students and make them be continuously engaged with learning and using Chinese language is a fundamental concern of this dissertation. The chapters in this dissertation provide a comprehensive understanding of Chinese language learning motivation in the classroom setting and beyond with a focus on learners who have tested at advanced levels of proficiency in Chinese and have gone on to use the language in their careers. The definition of learning motivation and its significance in the context of Chinese pedagogy is clarified in the first chapter through a critical literature review. Chapter two to Chapter four are organized upon a longitudinal pathway of understanding and creating motivating experiences from beginning to advanced levels of learning. Chapter two focuses on motivation construction in the Chinese classrooms, using discourse analysis to investigate the micro-level contexts of motivating factors and motivated learning behaviors at different levels of instruction. Chapter three addresses a critical period of language training where students are transitioning from learning the foreign language to learning domain knowledge in the foreign language. Few studies have touched upon the language learning motivation of Chinese learners at advanced and superior levels. Chapter four fills this gap by investigating a group of Chinese learners who not only reach a high level of language proficiency but also function in Chinese working environments with demonstrable cultural expertise. A toolkit for designing motivational foreign language learning ii experiences is presented in the last chapter. The classroom data in this study is collected at the Ohio State University. Over forty classes of different levels given at the university are observed for the purposes of data construction, with each class lasting fifty minutes. Selected videos are analyzed through a line-by-line discourse analysis and through retrospective video-enhanced analysis. To enhance the understanding of advanced-level language learner motivation, a questionnaire consisting of fifteen close-ended Likert scale questions was administered to thirty-three students who attended the Midwest US-China Flagship Program in the past ten years. One-on-one interviews were conducted with selected learners and their Chinese associates. Various experiences in their language learning journeys were collected, categorized and analyzed through a motivation map. Two case studies on representative individual language learners were reported and analyzed. Based on the empirical findings, the rich interactions that occur inside and outside the classroom among the language students, teachers, and native speakers of the target culture play various roles in constructing sustainable motivation. Moreover, successful language learners at each stage develop specific mechanisms to perceive their periodic progress. With the expeditious adoption of technology and the emerging needs for cross-cultural working expertise, it is almost a natural but urgent undertaking for the Chinese programs in the United States to motivate 21st Century Chinese learners with a dynamic vision of utilizing their language skills to connect with the Chinese speaking communities. iii Dedication Dedicated to a motivating scholar, Jingyao Sun. iv Acknowledgements This journey of graduate school and dissertation has matured me in a way I would never have imagined seven years ago. I want to thank each mentor, friend and family member who has generously supported me and made this rewarding journey possible. I owe my deepest gratitude to my advisor, Professor Galal Walker, whose wisdom, guidance and encouragement initiated and extended my interest in language pedagogy. I especially thank him for guiding me to combine my personal interest, future career aspirations with my research directions. Being a person who has a wide range of hobbies and who rarely develops expertise in one, I know clearly that I would not be able to sustain the motivation and enjoy this long journey without his advising. I am also sincerely grateful to Professor Mari Noda, from whom I have learned how to better construct and present my research data, how to design pedagogical materials with authenticity, how to be a dedicated and motivational language teacher, and, how to stay strong when being doubted. With her words of wisdom, I have grown into a better scholar and a stronger woman. My research pathway would be completely different without Professor Xiaobin Jian’s continuous guidance and support. His sharp understanding of training language learners to reach working expertise in Chinese directly inspired me in writing Chapter three and four. I especially appreciate and truly admire his full presence for each meeting of ours when his family needs were most critical. v Besides the members of my dissertation committee, I have received tremendous help from all the professors, teachers, fellow graduate students, Chinese language students in the Department of East Asian Languages and Literatures, for which I am truly grateful. I especially thank Minru Li and Debbie Knicely for all the wise advice and enjoyable moments they shared with me. I am also indebted to my mentors at Williams College. Both Professor Cornelius Kubler and Professor Li Yu have greatly enhanced my understanding of language pedagogy. I want to thank Zhini Zeng, Xin Zhang, and Cong Li for being the most understanding, supportive and interesting friends. Whenever I am lost, they are always there to take care of every little feeling of mine and pull me back in. I also thank Lulei Su for being like a brother to me. Those good old days we spent on training Chewie (a very sweet beagle dog) certainly contribute to my thinking of learning motivation. I dedicate my special thanks to my friend and writing buddy, Yanfei Yin. With her warm company and encouragement, even the hardest writing days were full of joy and laughter. Finally, I must thank my wonderful parents and my loving husband. My dissertation or my heart would never be complete without their unconditional trust, patience, and love. vi Vita March 26, 1985.......................Born - Shanghai, P.R. China 2003-2007...............................B.A. Department of Chinese language and literature, Shanghai Normal University 2007-2010................................M.A. Department of comparative literature and foreign literatures, Shanghai Normal University 2010 - 2012 ............................M.A., Graduate Teaching Associate Department of East Asian Languages and Literatures The Ohio State University 2012-2013................................Chinese Language Fellow Department of Asian Studies, Williams College 2013 to present ........................Graduate Teaching Associate Department of East Asian Languages and Literatures The Ohio State University Fields of Study Major Field: East Asian Languages and Literatures Area of Specialization: Chinese Language Pedagogy vii Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................ ii Dedication ............................................................................................................ iv Acknowledgements ............................................................................................... v Vita ..................................................................................................................... vii Table of Contents ............................................................................................... viii List of Tables ........................................................................................................ xi List of Figures ...................................................................................................... xii Chapter One: Developing Motivation in Language Learning: the key of cultivating successful Chinese learners for the 21st Century ..................................................... 1 1.1 Human motivation in the context of language pedagogy ......................................... 1 1.1.1 Hierarchy of needs ................................................................................................... 2 1.1.2 Cognitive dissonance theory .................................................................................... 4 1.1.3 Sustainable motivators............................................................................................. 5 1.2 L2 motivation ......................................................................................................... 7 1.2.1 Social-psychological research: dominated by the work of Gardner and his associates .......................................................................................................................... 8 1.2.2 Cognitive-situated studies ...................................................................................... 12 1.2.3 Beyond the cognitive-situative