1095 Market Street 415.558.6377 Assessor's Block/Lot: 3703/059 Zoning District: C-3-G Staff Contact: Corey A
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
.~P~o covNTro~ u ~ z SAN FRANCISCO w ~'' ~f PLANNING DEPARTMENT o of`as o~s~ 1650 Mission St. Letter of Determination Suite 400 San Francisco, CA 94103-2479 February 29, 2016 Reception: 415.558.6378 Sue Hestor Fax: 870 Market Street, Suite 1128 415.558.6409 San Francisco, CA 94102 Planning Information: Site Address: 1095 Market Street 415.558.6377 Assessor's Block/Lot: 3703/059 Zoning District: C-3-G Staff Contact: Corey A. Teague,(415) 575-9081 or [email protected]~ Record No.: 2015-018012ZAD Dear Ms. Hestor: This letter is in response to your request for a Letter of Determination regarding the distinction, if any, in how the Planning Code defines and regulates hotels and hostels. Specifically, you request a determination as to whether the Planning Code distinguishes between guest rooms and guest beds in relation to the project at 1095 Market Street. T'he subject property is within the C-3-G Zoning District, which requires a Conditional Use Authorization for any new or significantly expanding hotel use. A hostel is not defined as a distinct use in the Planning Code, rather it is considered to be a hotel use. On October 12, 2010, the Planning Commission granted a Conditional Use Authorization (Case No. 2009.11000 -Motion No. 18199) to convert the subject building to a hotel hostel with up to 94 guest rooms and associated restaurant, bar, and nightclub uses. As noted in the market demand study submitted with the application, the project proposed up to 484 beds. On November 21, 2013, the Planning Commission granted a three year extension of the performance period for the project (Case No. 2013.12850 —Motion No. 19027). While the number of proposed guest rooms was called out in each motion as part of the project description, the Planning Commission did not place any conditions on the approval related to the overall number of guest rooms. Your letter references multiple areas of the Planning Code that use the number of hotel rooms as a trigger or limit for hotel uses, and requests a determination as to whether hotel beds may be substituted for hotel rooms in Planning Code requirements. Any Planning Code trigger or limit based on the number of hotel rooms cannot be substituted with beds. However, the C-3-G Zoning District includes no limit on the number of hotel hostel rooms permitted, nor do a specific number of rooms trigger any additional land use authorizations. Additionally, the specific Planning Commission review criteria for hotels under Planning Code Section 303(g) do not include any criteria or other guidance related to the number of rooms provided. www.sfplanning.org Sue Hestor February 29, 2016 870 Market Street, Suite 1128 Letter of Determination San Francisco, CA 94102 1095 Market Street On September 11, 2014, the Project Sponsor submitted Building Permit Application No. 201409116118 for an updated proposal which included 203 guest rooms with 239 beds. The Planning Department initially approved the subject permit on June 22, 2015. The Planning Department approved a subsequent revision of the same permit on November 13, 2015. This permit was issued by the Department of Building Inspection on November 17, 2015. In reviewing this permit, the Zoning Administrator only had to determine if the scope of work under this permit was in "general conformity" with the Conditional Use Authorization (Motion Nos. 18199 & 19027). The Zoning Administrator determined, and verifies such determination by this letter, that the updated scope of work under Building Permit Application No. 201409116118 was in general conformity with the original Conditional Use Authorization because 1) the Conditional Use Authorization was required for the hotel use itself, and neither the Planning Code nor the Planning Commission approval provided conditions related to the total number of rooms, 2) the updated scope of work continued to fall under the land use definition of a hotel, 3) there was no increase in gross floor area of the subject building or the floor area ratio on the subject property (i.e. no physical expansion of the project), 4) there was no significant increase in guest occupancy (in fact, the number of beds was reduced from 484 to 239), and 5) the updated scope of work met all other conditions of approval and applicable Planning Code requirements. Please note that a Letter of Determination is a determination regarding the classification of uses and interpretation and applicability of the provisions of the Planning Code. This Letter of Determination is not a permit to commence any work or change occupancy. Permits from appropriate. Departments must be secured before work is started or occupancy is changed. APPEAL: If you believe this determination represents an error in interpretation of the Planning Code or abuse in discretion by the Zoning Administrator, an appeal may be filed with the Board of Appeals within 15 days of the date of this letter. For information regarding the appeals process, please contact the Board of Appeals located at 1650 Mission Street, Room 304, San Francisco, or call (415)575-6880. Sincerely, Scott F. Sanchez Zoning Administrator cc: Corey A. Teague, Assistant Zoning Administrator Carly Grob, Planner Ian Lewis Cynthia Gomez Neighborhood Groups SAN FflANCISCO PLANNING D6P4RTMENT SUE C. HESTOR Attorney at Law 870 Market Street, Suite 1128 San Francisco, CA 94102 office (415) 362-2778 cell (415)846-1021 hestor(c~earthlink.net December 4, 2015 Scott Sanchez ~~~ F`~~12 1/ Zoning Administrator 1650 Mission Street Sth fl San Francisco CA 94103 Request for Letter of Determination - Number of Rooms allowed -Hotels and Hostels(1095 Market) Dear Zoning Administrator Sanchez: My client UNITE HERE Local 2 requests a Letter of Determination on whether the Planning Code regulates the number of hotel rooms or the number of beds. Local 2 asserts that Hotels and hostels are defined and regulated by the number of guest rooms available to be rented. The Conditional Use requirement for hotels becomes irrelevant if Commission approval of a 94 room hostel can be changed to a 303 room hotel by Department staff because the number of beds remains the same. ACTIONS REGARDING 1095 MARKET STREET CONVERSION FROM OFFICE TO HOTEL Planning Code motions 18199(10/14/10) and 19027(11/21/13) approved conversion of 1095 Market Street from office use to a hotel/hostel with up to 94 rooms. Exhibit B plans for both motions show 94 hotel/hostel rooms. Both motions require Recordation of conditions with a limit of 94 hotel rooms. Building Permit 2014.09.11.1185 includes the project description "change of occupancy from office to hotel. New (202 -stricken and overwritten) 203 hotel rooms." Carly Grob signed off on behalf of Planning Department on 6/22/15 for: change of use from office to hotel w/ground floor retail. Construction of(202 -stricken and overwritten) 203 hotel rooms and roof deck..." The permit fora 203 room hotel was issued 11/17/2015. UNITE HERE Local 2 filed an appeal which was rejected by Board of Appeals because 1095 Market had been approved as a conditional use. The most recent Conditional Use approval was 11/21/13. The application fora (202)203 HOTEL ROOM was filed 9/11/14 -SIGNIFICANTLY AFTER the 12/21/13 deadline to appeal the 94 HOTEL ROOM project. From Cynthia Goldstein I understand your position to be the permit (for 1095 Market) was issued pursuant to the Conditional Use Authorization even though the number of rooms has changed. He said while the number of rooms has increased, the overall number of beds has decreased and there's been no increase or decrease in the size of the building, just the interior configuration. Scott also said Planning determined that the change in the number of rooms was insubstantial conformity with the CU given that the overall use is consistent. He explained that there are often minor changes made to projects after the CU hearing and before the site permit is approved. December 4, 2015 - page3 Article 8 -Mixed Use Districts This article similarly defines and limits their location tourist hotels by ROOMS - SEC. 890.46. HOTEL, TOURIST. A retail use which provides tourist accommodations including guest rooms or suites, which are intended or designed to be used, rented, or hired out to guests (transient visitors) intending to occupy the room for less than 32 consecutive days. This definition also applies to buildings containing six or more guest rooms designated and certified as tourist units, under Chapter 41 of the San Francisco Administrative Code. For purposes of this Code, a "tourist hotel" does not include a tourist motel..... Tourist hotels shall be designed to include all lobbies, offices and internal circulation to guest rooms and suites within and integral to the same enclosed building or buildings as the guest rooms or suites. Individual mixed use districts that permit tourist hotels control the size of the hotels by limits on the number of rooms. One such District-which permits hotels but limits number of rooms - WSOMA MIXED USE-OFFICE DISTRICT 845.49 Tourist Hotel (§ 890.46) - P up to 75 rooms SSO -SERVICE/SECONDARY OFFICE DISTRICT 818.78 Small hotels of 75 rooms or less are permitted in this District only as a conditional use. Any such conditional use authorizations requires a conditional use finding that disallows project proposals that displace existing Production, Distribution and Repair (PDR) uses. PLANNING CODE AL50 REGULATES RESIDENTIAL HOTELS BASED ON ROOMS The Planning Code also regulates RESIDENTIAL HOTELS based on the number of guest rooms, including in Mixed Use Districts SEC. 890.47. HOTEL, RESIDENTIAL. A hotel, as defined in Chapter 41 of the San Francisco Administrative Code, which contains one or more residential hotel units.