Baseball's Cheating Scandal Has Lessons for All Employers by Dennis J

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Baseball's Cheating Scandal Has Lessons for All Employers by Dennis J Baseball's Cheating Scandal Has Lessons For All Employers by Dennis J. Merley - Monday, January 20, 2020 Assume you just found out that some of your managers and their direct reports had implemented a scheme to use technology to unlawfully steal your competitor’s business secrets. That is exactly what happened in Major League Baseball (MLB) and the fallout has been dramatic. The Houston Astros, winners of the 2017 World Series, were found to have used a video camera in center field to spot the opposing catcher signaling the next pitch the pitcher should throw (one finger for a fastball, two for a curve, etc.). The video feed was monitored by a team employee near the dugout who would then loudly bang a bat on a trash can to signal that an off- speed pitch was coming (no bang meant that the batter should anticipate a fastball). Armed with this knowledge, the batter could better anticipate the pace of the pitch and adjust his swing to enhance his ability to hit the ball squarely. Team Gets Caught This ploy went public two years later when a former Astros pitcher detailed the scheme in an interview with a sports journal. MLB investigated and confirmed that the sign stealing had in fact taken place. They therefore issued the following sanctions: The team’s Field Manager, A.J. Hinch, was suspended for one year. Hinch did not participate in the scheme and actually took some steps to disable the technology but MLB concluded that he never actually directed the players to stop (the team subsequently fired Hinch); 1 / 3 The team’s General Manager Jeff Luhnow was also suspended for a year (and also fired by the team) because it was determined that he likely knew about the scheme as well. The team was fined $5 million and deprived of their first and second round draft picks in each of the next two years. No players were punished despite the fact that MLB’s report concluded that “[v]irtually all of the Astros’ players had some involvement or knowledge of the scheme.” Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred explained it was impossible to determine the degree of accountability that each player might have had, and that punishing them was “impractical” due to the large number of players involved and the fact that many of them now play for other teams. While not said, it is likely that the players’ contracts and the collective bargaining agreement with the players union might also have contributed to the decision not to pursue individual punishment. Cheating Sends Wrong Signals The scandal has impacted other teams as well. The Astros’ 2017 bench manager, Alex Cora, was found to have been intimately involved with the scheme and was therefore fired by the Boston Red Sox, who had hired him to manage the team in 2018. Former Astros player Carlos Beltran, supposedly one of the ringleaders of the video ploy, subsequently stepped down from his job as the just-hired manager of the New York Mets. The Astros have paid a heavy price for their anti-competitive behavior. Their championship is forever tainted in the eyes of many as having been won unfairly. Two previously respected managers have been jettisoned and their careers jeopardized, and the forfeited draft choices will impede their ability to secure new on-field talent in the near future. Lessons Learned The lessons that can be learned from this cheating scandal should not be ignored just because it happened in the sports arena and not the real world. What if employees seek a competitive edge by improperly using secrets learned from hiring a competitor’s former employee? What if a manager disregards safety issues or a hostile work environment in the interest of maintaining production? What if employees are hesitant to report wrongdoing out of fear of retaliation? Here are some critical points to consider: Culture Matters. How a company does things, how employees carry out their duties and how everyone represents the organization to the public are critical drivers of the operation. Employers should make sure that the organization’s culture influences everyone’s behavior and decisions, and that it is not merely a phrase to be cited at orientation and ignored thereafter. The situation involving the Houston Astros demonstrates that wrongs attributable to a deficient culture are likely to garner harsher scrutiny and greater punishment than those involving merely a few bad actors. 2 / 3 Role Modeling is Critical. Managers must demonstrate through both words and actions that doing the right thing is demanded. This includes supervising their employees effectively and holding them accountable when they lapse. The Astros’ manager did not approve of the sign stealing but he failed to stop it and did not appear to try very hard to do so. This creates the impression that such lapses are tolerated or condoned in the interest of advancing the bottom line. When that attitude is aired in court or in public, responses are usually more severe and consequences more long-lasting. Stop the Behavior. If an employee does act contrary to organizational culture, the manager must act to correct the behavior. Failure to do so just embeds the practice further into the employer’s culture and breeds an atmosphere where employees focus more on not getting caught than on advancing the employer’s mission. Consequences are required and must be severe enough to truly garner everyone’s attention. See Something. Say Something. Hear Something. An employer must make it clear that employees can feel safe raising concerns and that those concerns will be listened to. Merely having a policy or telling the employee that they did the right thing in coming forward is not enough – an effective response is needed. Bottom Line It seems reasonable to assume that when an organization decides to cheat, they waste a great deal of time, effort and resources into trying not to get caught. Despite those efforts, they often do get caught and pay a heavy price. A judge or jury is likely to be more sympathetic to an employer that tries hard to do things correctly than to one who tries to get away with something or just does not seem to care. An employer that devotes all of its energies to doing business the right way is likely to come out ahead, and their managers will sleep better at night too. 220 South 6th St, Suite 2200, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402 612-339-6321 | 800-989-6321 3 / 3 Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org).
Recommended publications
  • The Astros' Sign-Stealing Scandal
    The Astros’ Sign-Stealing Scandal Major League Baseball (MLB) fosters an extremely competitive environment. Tens of millions of dollars in salary (and endorsements) can hang in the balance, depending on whether a player performs well or poorly. Likewise, hundreds of millions of dollars of value are at stake for the owners as teams vie for World Series glory. Plus, fans, players and owners just want their team to win. And everyone hates to lose! It is no surprise, then, that the history of big-time baseball is dotted with cheating scandals ranging from the Black Sox scandal of 1919 (“Say it ain’t so, Joe!”), to Gaylord Perry’s spitter, to the corked bats of Albert Belle and Sammy Sosa, to the widespread use of performance enhancing drugs (PEDs) in the 1990s and early 2000s. Now, the Houston Astros have joined this inglorious list. Catchers signal to pitchers which type of pitch to throw, typically by holding down a certain number of fingers on their non-gloved hand between their legs as they crouch behind the plate. It is typically not as simple as just one finger for a fastball and two for a curve, but not a lot more complicated than that. In September 2016, an Astros intern named Derek Vigoa gave a PowerPoint presentation to general manager Jeff Luhnow that featured an Excel-based application that was programmed with an algorithm. The algorithm was designed to (and could) decode the pitching signs that opposing teams’ catchers flashed to their pitchers. The Astros called it “Codebreaker.” One Astros employee referred to the sign- stealing system that evolved as the “dark arts.”1 MLB rules allowed a runner standing on second base to steal signs and relay them to the batter, but the MLB rules strictly forbade using electronic means to decipher signs.
    [Show full text]
  • * Text Features
    The Boston Red Sox Friday, November 15, 2019 * The Boston Globe Xander Bogaerts finishes fifth in American League MVP race Julian McWilliams Xander Bogaerts finished fifth in American League MVP Award voting, the highest of his career. The Red Sox shortstop was 13th in 2013. Bogaerts hit .309 with a career-high 33 homers and 117 RBIs. Bogaerts tied Nomar Garciaparra for the most extra-base hits in a season by a Red Sox shortstop (85). Garciaparra did it in 1997 and 2002. Bogaerts’s 117 RBIs were the most in a season by a Red Sox shortstop since Garciaparra had 120 in 2002. Bogaerts was just the third shortstop in MLB history with at least a .300 batting average, 85 extra-base hits, and 115-plus RBIs. The others are Alex Rodriguez, in 1996 with the Mariners and 2001 and 2002 with the Texas, and Garciaparra. Bogaerts finished behind the Yankees’ DJ LeMahieu, who pulled in 10 fourth-place votes to Bogaerts’s six. Mookie Betts was eighth, Rafael Devers 12th, and J.D. Martinez was tied for 21st in AL voting. MLB speaks with Alex Cora as it investigates Astros’ sign-stealing Peter Abraham and Alex Speier SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. — Red Sox manager Alex Cora is one of the key figures into Major League Baseball’s investigation of the Houston Astros, an appraisal that goes beyond charges of sign stealing in 2017. Cora, who was bench coach of the Astros in 2017, has spoken to officials charged with determining to what degree Houston flouted rules against using cameras to pick up signs from opposing catchers.
    [Show full text]
  • Alumnigazette
    ALUMNIGAZETTE NO. 4 VOL. I JAN 2018 MEXICO CITY ASF ALUMNI GAZETTE ALUMINIGAZETTE POLITICS Democrat Mark Rodríguez (‘01) makes city council in Annapolis, re- ceiving 610 votes in Ward 5. 1 MAJOR LEAGUES CONGRATULATIONS! An ASF BEAR brings the Houston Astros to the World Series. ¡Sí Alexis Fridman (‘01), Head of Production and Development at Lem- señor! Jeff Luhnow is Astro’s general manager and has changed the on Films, receives an Emmy Award for his TV Series Sr. Ávila. Such a game for this Texan team. big deal! ALUMNI HELP THE ART FAIR GO GREEN This year, ASF Alumni wanted to contribute in lowering the waste generated during the Art Fair. Robb Wright, ASF parent, donated 5000 green plastic reusable plates to ASF, which the Alumni distrib- uted to 14 vendors. In total, 2000 plates were used and reused during the Art Fair, greatly lessening the need for plastic and reducing our impact on the environment. Cafeteria staff, paid by the Alumni Association, cleaned each plate after it was used, and the student members of the ASF Sustainabil- ity Committee, under the leadership of Mr. José Alaniz, set shop at two recycling stations, where Mr. Alaniz helped Art Fair attendees to properly separate the trash and place the plates in containers to be washed. It was amazing to see how the whole community contributed in this effort, and we are happy to announce that we now have 5000 plates in stock so staff, clubs and committees don’t have to use disposable plastic plates during any school event. Seeing how successful this campaign was, next year we
    [Show full text]
  • Stolen Signs to Stolen Wins?
    Venkataraman and Bozzella 1 Devan Venkataraman & Nathaniel Bozzella EC 107 Empirical Project Sergio Turner 12/20/20 Stolen Signs to Stolen Wins? The Trash Can Banging Scandal Heard ‘Round the World Question To what extent, and in what ways, was the Houston Astros cheating scandal in the 2017 season effective in improving team performance? Introduction For the majority of the 2010’s, the Houston Astros were a very middle of the pack team. From 2010-2014, the team did not finish higher than 4th in their division. For most of their history, the Houston Astros participated in the National League Central Division, up until the 2013 season. Since the 2013 season, the Astros have competed in the American League West Division, where they have seen much more success. In 2011, the Astros, one of the worst teams in baseball with a record of 56-106, were sold to Jim Crane where he moved on from ex-GM Ed Wade, and hired Jeff Luhnow two days after the sale. While Ed Wade made some good decisions: debuting Jose Altuve in the 2011 season and drafting George Springer in the 2011 draft, his overall performance was not satisfactory for the new owner. The new GM, Jeff Luhnow, made some notable decisions as well, drafting Carlos Correa in the 2012 draft (debuting him in 2015) and drafting Alex Bregman in the 2015 draft (debuting him in the 2017 season). After another few unsuccessful seasons with records of 55-107, 51-111, and 70-92 in the 2012-2014 seasons, Jeff Luhnow decided to fire the current manager of the team, whom he had a Venkataraman and Bozzella 2 falling out with towards the end of the 2014 season.
    [Show full text]
  • Uniform Requirements
    QUICK GUIDE UNIFORM REQUIREMENTS As a representative of your state at the Regional Tournament you are required to dress appropriately. The Official Baseball Rules allow a league to provide that each team wears a distinctive uniform at all times [Rule 1.11b-1]. In accordance with that the following regulations have been adapted for the Regional Tournament. 1. All players on a team shall where uniforms identical in style. [Official Baseball Rule 1.11a-1]. 2. All players’ uniforms shall include minimal 6” numbers on their backs. [Official Baseball Rule 1.11a-1 ] 3. Sleeve lengths may vary for individual players, but the sleeves of each individual player shall be approximately the same lengths. [Official Baseball Rule 1.11c-1]. 4. No player shall wear ragged, frayed, or slit sleeves [Official Baseball Rule 1.11c-2]. No cutoff or sleeveless shirts will be permitted unless a t-shirt with sleeves is worn under it. 5. All players will be required to wear solid baseball over the calf socks, OR white over the calf socks with stirrups, OR all-in-one stirrup socks. Ankle length socks are not permitted. 6. Managers and coaches are required to be in baseball pants and shirts similar in style and color to the player uniforms. 7. Shorts are not classified as baseball pants and are not permitted. 8. Caps must be worn by every player while playing the game but may be omitted during infield practice. Caps must also be worn by each coach in the first and third base coach’s box. 9. Players taking infield practice must be in uniform.
    [Show full text]
  • Job-Creators-V-Mlb.Pdf
    Case 1:21-cv-04818-VEC Document 1 Filed 05/31/21 Page 1 of 21 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK --------------------------------------------------------------- x JOB CREATORS NETWORK, ) ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) COMPLAINT ) OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF ) JURY TRIAL DEMANDED BASEBALL D/B/A MAJOR LEAGUE ) BASEBALL, ROBERT D. MANFRED JR., ) MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL ) PLAYERS ASSOCIATION, TONY CLARK, ) AND JOHN DOES 1-50, ) ) Defendants. ) --------------------------------------------------------------- x Plaintiff, through its undersigned counsel, for its complaint, hereby avers: Nature of Action 1. In July 2019, Major League Baseball publicly announced that the 2021 All-Star Game would be played in July 2021 at SunTrust Park (now named Truist Park), the home field of the Atlanta Braves in Cobb County, Georgia. The All-Star Game is a national attraction that generates extraordinary revenue for the host city. Businesses from mom-and-pop restaurants and bars to national hotel chains prepare years and months in advance for the event. Tables are reserved, hotel rooms are booked, events are planned, people are hired. Cobb County budgeted expenses of $2 million for improvements and municipal hiring to meet the expected influx of tourists and fans for the big event. Businesses in the Atlanta metro region stood to earn $100 million. Multiple municipalities were counting on millions more in tax revenues. 2. Thousands of hard-working ordinary men and women in the Atlanta area, many reeling from the psychological trauma and economic havoc of the COVID-19 pandemic, relied Case 1:21-cv-04818-VEC Document 1 Filed 05/31/21 Page 2 of 21 on MLB’s unqualified promise to hold the 2021 All-Star Game in Truist Park.
    [Show full text]
  • Corporate Espionage and America's Pastime
    WWW. NYLJ.COM White-Collar Crime VOLUME 256—NO. 60 MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 26, 2016 Of Redbirds and Rockets: Corporate Espionage and America’s Pastime BY ANDREW GARbaRINO ith the baseball season about to enter the post- Wseason, perhaps it’s time to revisit an interesting off-the-field legal drama from the 2015 season, namely the corporate espionage case involving two former National League Central rivals. As originally reported in the New York Times,1 the St. Louis Cardinals PYTEL, ISTOCK RAFAL made news in connection with the alleged hacking of a database owned by the Houston Astros. The attack appears to have been in furtherance of a variety of potential motives: A The FBI conducted an investigation pay $279,038 in restitution.2 Pros- desire to obtain intelligence from into the allegations. ecutors alleged that Correa caused the Astros proprietary “Ground In December 2015, as a result of approximately $1.7 million in loss Control” database, to embarrass Jeff the FBI’s investigation, Christo- to the Astros.3 Luhnow, a former Cardinals execu- pher Correa, then-scouting direc- Let that sink in for a moment. A tive who is now the Astros General tor for the Cardinals, was charged Major League Baseball team was Manager, or to determine whether in a five-count indictment for his investigated by federal authorities Luhnow took data or other intel- illegal access of Ground Control. for cybercrimes allegedly commit- lectual property developed by the In January 2016, he pled guilty to ted against another baseball team. Cardinals with him to a competitor. Unauthorized Access to a Protected And someone will be going to jail Computer in connection with the for nearly four years as a result.
    [Show full text]
  • Pitching Grips
    Pitching Grips Pitch #1 – Four Seam Fastball The four seam fastball is a pitcher’s bread and butter pitch. It is the pitch you can throw the hardest and with the best control. Place your index and middle fingertips directly on the perpendicular seam of the baseball. The “horseshoe seam” should face into your ring finger of your throwing hand. Next, place your thumb directly beneath the baseball, resting on the smooth leather. Grip this pitch softly, like an egg, in your fingertips. A loose grip minimizes friction between your hand and the baseball. Less friction = more velocity. Pitch #2 – Change-up This pitch is important because: “hitting is timing and pitching is interrupting that timing.” Pitchers must throw a change-up to keep hitters honest, otherwise they will tee off on the fastball. Hold the ball deep in the palm. Circle around the ball with the hand. Use same mechanics as the fastball – except lengthen the stride and drag the back foot. BaseballTutorials.com 1 Pitch #3 – Cut Fastball While the four seam fastball is more or less a straight pitch, the cut fastball has late break toward the glove side of the pitcher. Start with a four-seam fastball grip, and move your top two fingers slightly off center. The arm motion and arm speed for the cutter are just like for a fastball. At the point of release, with the grip slightly off center and pressure from the middle finger, turn your wrist ever so lightly. This off center grip and slight turn of the wrist will result into a pitch with lots of velocity and a late downward break.
    [Show full text]
  • HOUSTON ASTROS, LLC and § HOUSTON ASTROS MANAGEMENT, § INC., § § DEFENDANTS § 152Nd JUDICIAL DISTRICT
    5/4/2020 2:14 PM Marilyn Burgess - District Clerk Harris County Envelope No. 42723583 By: KATINA WILLIAMS Filed: 5/4/2020 2:14 PM NO. 2020-10637 ADAM WALLACH, on behalf of himself § IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF and all other similarly situated, § § PLAINTIFFS § v. § § HARRIS COUNTY, TEXAS HOUSTON ASTROS, LLC and § HOUSTON ASTROS MANAGEMENT, § INC., § § DEFENDANTS § 152nd JUDICIAL DISTRICT NO. 2020-11192 ROGER CONTRERAS, on behalf of himself § IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF and all other similarly situated, § § PLAINTIFFS § v. § § HARRIS COUNTY, TEXAS HOUSTON ASTROS, LLC and § HOUSTON ASTROS MANAGEMENT, § INC., § § DEFENDANTS § 152nd JUDICIAL DISTRICT NO. 2020- 11221 KENNETH YOUNG, on behalf of himself § IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF and all other similarly situated, § § PLAINTIFFS § v. § UnofficialCopyOfficeofMarilynBurgessDistrictClerk § HARRIS COUNTY, TEXAS HOUSTON ASTROS, LLC and § HOUSTON ASTROS MANAGEMENT, § INC., § § DEFENDANTS § 152nd JUDICIAL DISTRICT CONSOLIDATED AMENDED CLASS ACTION PETITION AND JURY DEMAND “There’s something about baseball, something magical, that will always make it America’s sport, America’s pastime.” – Micah Chen “Baseball is about talent, hard work, and strategy. But at the deepest level, it’s about love, integrity, and respect.” – Pat Gillick “[Baseball] is the most honest pastime in the world. It has to be, or it could not last a season out. Crookedness and baseball don’t mix.” – Charles Comiskey TO THE HONORABLE COURT: Plaintiffs Adam Wallach, Donald R. Rao, CHA, Inc., Brian Dobbins, Roger Contreras, and Kenneth Young (collectively, “Plaintiffs”), for themselves and all similarly situated individuals and entities, complain of the actions of Defendants Houston Astros, LLC and Houston Astros Management, Inc. (together, “Astros” or “Defendants”), and respectfully show the following: NATURE OF THE CASE 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Dynamical Chaos in a Simple Model of a Knuckleball
    Dynamical Chaos in a Simple Model of a Knuckleball Nicholas J. Nelson, Eric Strauss Department of Physics California State University, Chico 400 W. 1st St. Chico, CA 95929 Abstract The knuckleball is perhaps the most enigmatic pitch in baseball. Relying on the presence of raised seams on the surface of the ball to create asymmetric flow, a knuckleball's trajectory has proven very challenging to predict compared to other baseball pitches, such as fastballs or curveballs. Previous experimental tracking of large numbers of knuckleballs has shown that they can move in essentially any direction relative to what would be expected from a drag-only trajectory. This has led to speculation that knuckleballs exhibit chaotic motion. Here we develop a relatively simple model of a knuckleball that includes quadratic drag and lift from asymmetric flow which is taken from experimental measurements of slowly rotating baseballs. Our models can indeed exhibit dynamical chaos as long In contrast, models that omit torques on the ball in flight do not show chaotic behavior. Uncertainties in the phase space position of the knuckleball are shown to grow by factors as large as 106 over the flight of the ball from the pitcher to home plate. We quantify the impact of our model parameters on the chaos realized in our models, specifically showing that maximum Lyapunov exponent is roughly proportional to the square root of the effective lever arm of the torque, and also roughly proportional to the initial velocity of the pitch. We demonstrate the existence of bifurcations that can produce changes in the location of the ball when it reaches the plate of as much as 1.2 m for specific initial conditions similar to those used by professional knuckleball pitchers.
    [Show full text]
  • A.J. Hinch Astros Pregame 4 Since Coming Over from Cuba? and He's Only 34, the MODERATOR: Questions for A.J
    AL Championship Series: Astros vs Red Sox Wednesday, October 17, 2018 A.J. Hinch Astros pregame 4 since coming over from Cuba? And he's only 34, THE MODERATOR: Questions for A.J. Hinch. he has a couple of more years on his contract. What have you seen that suggests to you that he Q. Could you just run down the advantages of might continue being steady for a couple more having Alex lead off? years? A.J. HINCH: You know, I can't wait for him to hit first. A.J. HINCH: Yuli is very experienced. And we see it And really it's tough because George is doing with guys that come in the middle to latter parts of their everything you ask out of the leadoff spot. It had professional careers. A lot of guys from Japan, guys nothing to do with him. It's a different look for our from different countries, when they join us they're not lineup; he gets the most at-bats. He has Springer really rookies, they're first-timers when it comes to the behind him. Big Leagues. So Yuli's been through some of the highest pressure-packed baseball before he got here. I'm not sure if that changes their approach with him -- maybe in the first at-bat they have to go after him a He was the best international player in Cuba for a little bit. But why not? I think the first three guys are number of years. He was a high-profile guy. So when pretty interchangeable.
    [Show full text]
  • Alex Cora Astros Pregame 1 ALEX CORA: I Love It
    AL Championship Series: Astros vs Red Sox Saturday, October 13, 2018 Alex Cora Astros pregame 1 ALEX CORA: I love it. (Laughter) no, it's tough. We THE MODERATOR: We'll open it up for questions to had some tough ones this year? When we played Alex. Baltimore, I know Buck didn't like that one -- Showalter. It's not easy. It's hard to play the game when you don't Q. Any advantage playing in cold weather against feel your hands. And you get jammed or hit one off the the Astros? end of the bat and you will not feel your hands for a ALEX CORA: We're about to find out. But, man, these while. And that's tough. guys they get a lot of stuff now. You know, like back in the day it was a pair of sleeves and that was it. Now But in our case, I think we got the right guy on the they've got all kinds of stuff. They've got the cage mound tonight. He really doesn't care about, like -- inside. he'll go out there without sleeves because he promised somebody in Chicago that he will never wear sleeves, They've got ways to stay warm. So probably going to which I don't understand. (Laughter). be a few ski masks out there. I got my money on Gurriel wearing a ski mask tonight. (Laughter) he So, yeah, it's uncomfortable. It's very uncomfortable. doesn't like the cold weather. But like I told you guys in February, you know, it's amazing how baseball players complain of cold Q.
    [Show full text]