Multi-Phase Late-Neogene Exhumation History of the Aar Massif, Swiss Central Alps
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
doi: 10.1111/ter.12231 Multi-phase late-Neogene exhumation history of the Aar massif, Swiss central Alps Pierre G. Valla,1,2 Meinert Rahn,3,4 David L. Shuster5,6 and Peter A. van der Beek7 1Institute of Earth Surface Dynamics, University of Lausanne, Lausanne CH-1015, Switzerland; 2Department of Earth Sciences, ETH Zurich,€ Zurich€ CH-8092, Switzerland; 3Swiss Federal Nuclear Safety Inspectorate, Brugg CH-5200, Switzerland; 4Department of Mineral- ogy and Geochemistry, University of Freiburg, Freiburg D-79104, Germany; 5Department of Earth & Planetary Science, University of Cal- ifornia, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA; 6Berkeley Geochronology Center, Berkeley, CA 94707, USA; 7Institute of Earth Sciences (ISTerre), Universite Grenoble Alpes, Grenoble F-38400, France ABSTRACT The late-Neogene evolution of the European Alps was influ- exhumation phases in the Late Miocene–Pliocene and better enced by both tectonic and climatically driven erosion pro- constrain the onset of glacial valley carving. The hydrother- cesses, which are difficult to disentangle. We use low- mal activity and geothermal anomalies currently observed in temperature thermochronometry data from surface and bore- the borehole have been local and short-lived, with only a hole samples in the Aar massif–Rhone^ valley (Swiss central minor influence on thermochronometric observations. We thus Alps) to constrain the exhumation history of the region. Mul- suggest that late-stage glacial valley carving may have trig- tiple exhumation events are distinguished and linked to regio- gered topography-driven fluid flow and transient hydrother- nal-scale tectonic deformation (before 5 Ma), short-lived mal circulation. climatically driven orogen contraction (between 4 and 3 Ma), and glacial valley carving since c. 1 Ma. Compared with previ- Terra Nova, 00: 1–12, 2016 ous studies, we clearly show the existence of two separate deformation from the frontal Jura processes were the primary drivers Introduction (Becker, 2000) to the internal parts of the late-stage Alpine evolution. Quantifying mountain evolution, as of the belt (Willett et al., 2006). In this study, we apply multiple well as sediment transfer to sur- However, exhumation histories low-temperature thermochronometric rounding basins, is important for across the European Alps have led systems to bedrock samples along understanding potential feedbacks to contrasting conclusions concern- both a 2 km surface elevation profile between climate, erosion and tecton- ing the existence and precise timing and a 500 m deep borehole in the ics (e.g. Molnar and England, 1990; of this increase, as well as the nat- Swiss central Alps. Our objective is Raymo and Ruddiman, 1992). How- ure of the forcing processes. Ongo- to quantitatively constrain the late- ever, those couplings are difficult to ing tectonic deformation and crustal Neogene exhumation history of the decipher because the involved pro- accretion (Persaud and Pfiffner, region and assess the potential cli- cesses are often interrelated (Roe 2004; Schlunegger and Mosar, matic or tectonic controls on it. et al., 2008; Whipple, 2009), pro- 2011), orogen-perpendicular exten- moting transient erosion or topo- sion (e.g. Reinecker et al., 2008; Setting and methods graphic response (Willett and Cardello et al., 2015) and regional- Brandon, 2002; Whipple and Meade, scale slab unloading (Baran et al., The Visp-Brigerbad area lies in the 2006). The late-Neogene evolution 2014; Fox et al., 2015) have been upper Rhone^ valley between the crys- of the European Alps is a classic proposed as potential tectonic trig- talline Aar massif and the sedimen- illustration of such a debate (see gers. Drainage rearrangement lead- tary Helvetic and Penninic nappes review in Willett, 2010). Sediment ing to river capture and transient (Fig. 1). It encompasses two major budgets from basins surrounding the incision has also been proposed tectonic boundaries: the Penninic Alps suggest a significant increase in (Ziegler and Fraefel, 2009; Schluneg- frontal thrust (PFT) and the Rhone-^ accumulation rates since c. 5 Ma ger and Mosar, 2011; Yanites et al., Simplon fault (RSF) (Mancktelow, (Kuhlemann et al., 2002), roughly 2013). Alternatively, climatic pro- 1985, 1992; Seward and Mancktelow, concordant with (1) the onset of cesses have been suggested, includ- 1994; Campani et al., 2010). The denudation in the northern Alpine ing a transition to wetter conditions modern drainage pattern follows the foreland basin (Cederbom et al., (Cederbom et al., 2004, 2011; Willett tectonic structures (Kuhni€ and Pfiff- 2004, 2011), (2) increased Alpine et al., 2006) or the (more recent) ner, 2001), influenced by the exhuma- exhumation (Vernon et al., 2008) impact of Pliocene–Quaternary tion of the External Crystalline and (3) potential migration of glaciation (Haeuselmann et al., 2007; Massifs (ECMs) since Oligocene– Glotzbach et al., 2011; Valla et al., Early Miocene times (Schmid et al., 2011, 2012; Maheo et al., 2012; Fox 2004), while the overall high Alpine Correspondence: Pierre G. Valla, Institute et al., 2015). Better temporal con- of Earth Surface Dynamics, University of elevation has been acquired at least Lausanne, Lausanne CH-1015, Switzer- straints on bedrock exhumation since Miocene times (Campani et al., land. E-mail: [email protected] should help to elucidate which 2012). The current kinematics of the © 2016 John Wiley & Sons Ltd 1 Multi-phase Alpine exhumation history • P. G. Valla et al. Terra Nova, Vol 0, No. 0, 1–11 ............................................................................................................................................................. occur along the Rhone^ valley, appar- 7°40‘0.7 7°50‘ 8°00‘ 8°10‘ ently associated with major tectonic 1.1 1.2 structures (e.g. Sonney and Vuataz, 1.0 0.8 2008, 2009). The importance and 1.3 persistence of these hydrothermal 46°25‘ systems remain poorly constrained. 0.9 We use low-temperature apatite 1.4 (U–Th–Sm)/He (AHe) and fission- track (AFT) thermochronometry, Profile in Fig. 2 including fission-track length (TL) measurements, to quantify the late- 46°20‘ Neogene exhumation history of the area. The AHe and AFT systems are BR-02 Penninic frontal thrust characterised by closure temperatures of 50–90 °C (Shuster et al., 2006) Visp and 100–120 °C (Gallagher et al., R 1998), respectively, and are sensitive hô ne 1.2 -Simp 46°15‘ to topographic changes (e.g. Stuwe€ lo t n f aul I et al., 1994; Braun, 2002). Geother- 1.3 CH mal anomalies and topography-dri- ven hydrothermal circulation may 10 km also affect low-temperature ther- mochronometers (Ehlers, 2005; Aar massif, Infra-Penninic sedimentary crystalline basement units Dempster and Persano, 2006; Whipp Autochthonous cover of Post-Variscan sediments and Ehlers, 2007); this sensitivity can Aar massif (Helvetics) of middle-Penninic nappes help in assessing the persistence of Allochthonous Helvetic Pre-Variscan cryst. basem. near-surface geothermal systems (e.g. sedimentary nappes of middle-Penninic nappes Gotthard nappe, Pre-Variscan crystalline Gorynski et al., 2014). Here, we crystalline basement nappes of Lepontine combine six surface samples (VIS) Parautochthonous cover Sample location collected along an elevation profile of Gotthard nappe -1 (Valla et al., 2011) with three new Major tectonic structures 1.3 Geodetic uplift (mm yr ) 43˚ 45˚ 47˚ samples (MRP) obtained along a 6˚ 9˚ Boundary between Italy (I) Quaternary valley infill and Switzerland (CH) 500 m deep geothermal borehole, covering ~3 km elevation in total Fig. 1 Geological sketch map of the Swiss central Alps (after Schmid et al., 2004) with (Table 1). AHe ages for the VIS main litho-tectonic units and major tectonic structures (see legend). White circles rep- samples have been previously resent sampling locations (BR-02 is the geothermal borehole, see Fig. 7B), the thick reported (Valla et al., 2011). We black line indicates the cross-section shown in Fig. 2A, and thin black lines depict sur- report here new AFT data including face-uplift rates from geodetic measurements with respect to Laufenburg (Schlatter, TL distributions for all VIS and 2014). Inset shows the location of the study area within the European Alps. MRP samples (Table 2) and central Swiss Alps show no active convergence (Nocquet and Calais, 2004) but evidence for orogen-paral- Sample locations for the elevation profile from the Garsthorn to Visp-Bri- lel extension (Champagnac et al., Table 1 € 2004). The area shows a strong gla- gerbad (VIS), with additional samples from the Brigerbad geothermal borehole (MRP). Asterisks mark samples from Valla et al. (2011). All sampled rocks are cial imprint with high topographic relief and glacially shaped cross-pro- orthogneisses from the Aar crystalline basement. files along the Rhone^ valley (Norton Elevation (m) et al., 2010). This valley has been Sample Longitude (°E) Latitude (°N) (depth below valley floor) glacially deepened during Quaternary times (Valla et al., 2011), with large VIS-01* 7.91667 46.34390 2925 glacial overdeepenings (Finckh and VIS-03* 7.92035 46.32918 2100 Frei, 1991; Rosselli and Olivier, VIS-04* 7.92432 46.31988 1600 2003) filled by post-glacial sediments VIS-05* 7.93780 46.31788 1400 VIS-06* 7.98339 46.32999 850 (Hinderer, 2001). Average Quater- VIS-07* 7.95333 46.30967 670 nary and Holocene erosion patterns MRP-424 7.93032 46.30220 487 ( 167) À (Champagnac et al., 2007, 2009) clo- MRP-425 7.93032 46.30220 321 ( 333) sely correlate with surface-uplift rates À 1 MRP-426 7.93032 46.30220 157 ( 497)