Place Attachment to the Palestinian Landscape: an Art-Based Visual Discourse Analysis

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Place Attachment to the Palestinian Landscape: an Art-Based Visual Discourse Analysis Place Attachment to the Palestinian Landscape: An Art-based Visual Discourse Analysis by Sima Kuhail A Thesis presented to The University of Guelph In partial fulfilment of requirements for the degree of Master of Landscape Architecture Guelph, Ontario, Canada © Sima Kuhail, May, 2020 ABSTRACT PLACE ATTACHMENT TO THE PALESTINIAN LANDSCAPE: AN ART-BASED VISUAL DISCOURSE ANALYSIS Sima Kuhail Advisor: University of Guelph, 2020 Larry Harder Place attachment is a significant affective, cognitive and emotional bond between people and places of significance. Displaced populations draw on their attachment to a place of origin to help them develop attachment to their new places. Currently eight million Palestinians are living in diaspora as they continue to be displaced. Art-based research is an emerging method in place attachment studies. This research aims to construct a visual art-based place attachment narrative of the Palestinian landscape to inform future landscape design interventions for Palestinian communities. A visual discourse analysis method is applied on the content of the “Intimate Terrains” Exhibition in Birzeit, Palestine (2019) to interpret place attachment to the Palestinian landscape as portrayed by Palestinian artists. This research, while specific to Palestine, can be generalized and can be utilized by landscape architects who intend to better understand the communities they design for and who intend to create meaningful places. Key words: Palestinian visual arts, art-based research, visual discourse analysis, landscape narrative, memory, home, belonging, identity. iii DEDICATION To my family iv ACKNOWLEGMENTS To my advisor Larry Harder, thank you for your guidance and mentorship throughout my journey in this degree. I have enjoyed our conversation throughout the past three years. Thank you for the insightful conversations, comments, and directions throughout my time in the Landscape Architecture programme and the process of this thesis. To my committee members Martin Holland and Tina Sherwell, thank you for your insightful conversations and constructive comments. To Martin Holland thank you for your academic guidance and emotional support throughout the MLA journey. To Tina Sherwell, thank you for the resources and knowledge you provided. Special thanks to Karen Landman who chaired my examination committee. Thank you for your guidance and support throughout my journey in this degree. Thank you to the amazing faculty members. It was only possible for me, as a mother of two, to be where I am today with your continuous support and accommodation. Special thanks to Karen Landman, Brendan Stewart, Robert Corry, Sean Kelly and Nate Perkins for all the opportunities you have provided me. Special thanks Diana Foolen, our programme assistant: you really do amazing work. Thank you for all your efforts and support, and always keeping us up to date. I am grateful for the financial support provided to me during my degree. My gratitude goes towards the Ontario Association of Landscape Architects, Durante Kreuk Ltd, the SEDRD awards selection committee, the Graduate Committee, and the Ontario Agricultural College (OAC). I would like to thank the International Honor Society of Landscape Architecture for their recognition as well. Thank you to my amazing classmates, this journey was special alongside you all. I have learned a lot from you guys. Each one of you had something to offer; you are the best! I will always cherish our memories and special moments: the gatherings, the trips, and the late nights in studio. I’m deeply grateful to my husband Mohammad. This journey would have been impossible without you by my side. Thanks for being there throughout my ups and downs, for always being there for me, and for your sense of humour. To my kids Sabri and Sama, you are the greatest kids ever. You have been amazingly understanding and helpful through out this journey. I love you. To my parents Hisham and Samar, sisters Sarah and Mays, and brother Mahmoud, I wouldn’t be here without you. Thank you for all the deep conversations and brainstorming sessions Sarah. The shared master’s experience was enjoyable. Mom, special thanks to you for always pushing me out of my boundaries. You have always been my inspiration. v TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................. II DEDICATION............................................................................................................................. III ACKNOWLEGMENTS ............................................................................................................. IV LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................. VII MY PALESTINE ........................................................................................................................ XI CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................ 1 THE PALESTINIAN CONTEXT ................................................................................................................................... 4 Historical Background ......................................................................................................................................... 5 The Palestinian Landscape .................................................................................................................................. 9 Palestinian Landscape and Visual art ............................................................................................................... 13 GOALS AND OBJECTIVES ........................................................................................................................................ 15 THESIS ORGANIZATION .......................................................................................................................................... 16 CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW.................................................................................. 17 LANDSCAPE AND PLACE ATTACHMENT ................................................................................................................ 17 PLACE AND PLACE ATTACHMENT ......................................................................................................................... 19 TYPOLOGY OF PLACE ATTACHMENT .................................................................................................................... 20 PLACE ATTACHMENT INDICATORS ....................................................................................................................... 22 Memory ............................................................................................................................................................... 22 Nostalgia ............................................................................................................................................................. 25 Identity ................................................................................................................................................................ 26 Belonging and Sense of Home .......................................................................................................................... 28 Detachment ........................................................................................................................................................ 30 HISTORY OF PALESTINIAN VISUAL ART ................................................................................................................ 32 Pre-1948: Pre-Nakba ......................................................................................................................................... 33 1948-1967: Nakba .............................................................................................................................................. 34 1967-1987: Naksa .............................................................................................................................................. 36 1987-1993: First Intifada ................................................................................................................................... 37 1993-2000: Prospects of a Palestinian State ..................................................................................................... 38 2000- Present: The Second Intifada and The Following Years ....................................................................... 39 SYMBOLISM IN PALESTINIAN LANDSCAPE ART .................................................................................................... 40 Native Plants ...................................................................................................................................................... 41 The Palestinian Village ...................................................................................................................................... 43 Motherland and Homeland ............................................................................................................................... 43 Key of Return and Keffiyeh ............................................................................................................................... 44 CHAPTER 3: RESEARCH DESIGN & METHODS ............................................................. 45 ART-BASED RESEARCH AND
Recommended publications
  • Culture and Politics in the Visual Arts of the Occupied Palestinian Territories Olga González Macalester College
    Macalester International Volume 23 The Israeli-Palestinian Impasse: Dialogic Article 16 Transformations Spring 2009 Culture and Politics in the Visual Arts of the Occupied Palestinian Territories Olga González Macalester College Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/macintl Recommended Citation González, Olga (2009) "Culture and Politics in the Visual Arts of the Occupied Palestinian Territories," Macalester International: Vol. 23, Article 16. Available at: http://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/macintl/vol23/iss1/16 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Institute for Global Citizenship at DigitalCommons@Macalester College. It has been accepted for inclusion in Macalester International by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Macalester College. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Culture and Politics in the Visual Arts of the Occupied Palestinian Territories Olga González What makes Palestinian art “Palestinian”? This became a central question in my attempt to understand the emphasis on national iden- tity that Palestinian visual artists put on their artwork, particularly given that what I saw at art exhibits and the studios and homes of artists during my short visit in Jerusalem, Ramallah, and Bethlehem could be basically classified under the broad category of contemporary visual art. Whether realistic, figurative, abstract, or conceptual in their styles, the five artists I interviewed presented me with a varied assort- ment of images meant to highlight the “Palestinian-ness” in the con- temporary art of the Occupied Palestinian Territories. These artists use the authoritative language of Western art, seeking to create a more forceful and distinctive art that is regarded as Palestin- ian.
    [Show full text]
  • Arts and Disability in Occupied Palestinian Territories Literature and Practice Review – Summary March 2021
    Arts and Disability in Occupied Palestinian Territories Literature and Practice Review – Summary March 2021 Background The Disability Under Siege project seeks to examine what are the opportunities and barriers to promoting discussion of culture, disability, and inclusive education in Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT). And how can such discussions be developed through collaborative partnerships between cultural partners and disability-led organisations? This review undertaken from December 2020 to February 2021 mapped and reviewed available literature and cultural practices relating to arts and disability in Occupied Palestinian Territories. This report provides a summary of available literature and practice to help the project engage the following key questions • How do contemporary cultural practices engage with disability? • How do disability organisations engage with contemporary cultural practices? • What can these models of engagement tell us about the priorities of each institution? • Are there productive ways of engaging the institutional structures of cultural practices to reflect upon the issue of inclusion and disability education? • How can discourses and social practices related to disability reflect upon political concerns about marginalisation within cultural practices, including issues around identity, ideology, the body, and social injustice? All arts practices identified as a result of this study have been mapped to a database which can be viewed here1 The full Literature and Practice Review of Arts and Disability in Lebanon, the Occupied Palestinian Territories, and Jordan can be found at https://disabilityundersiege.org/current-research/. Summary The Palestinian art and cultural scene is beset by multiple local and international concerns. The prevailing social, political, and economic volatility has created significant instability within the arts sector that impacts upon cultural production, visual representation, and cultural infrastructure alike.
    [Show full text]
  • Diyar Board of Directors
    DiyarConsortium DiyarConsortium DiyarProductions Content Diyar Board of Directors Foreword 2 Bishop Dr. Munib Younan (Chair) Dar al-Kalima University College of Arts and Culture 6 Dr. Ghada Asfour-Najjar (Vice Chair) International Conferences 16 Mr. Jalal Odeh (Treasurer) The Model Adult Education Center 20 Dr. Versen Aghabekian (Secretary) Religion & State III 22 Mr. Albert Aghazarian The Civic Engagement Program 26 Mr. Ghassan Kasabreh Ajyal Elderly Care Program 30 Azwaj Program 32 Mr. Zahi Khouri Celebrate Recovery Project 34 Mr. Issa Kassis Diyar Academy for Children and Youth 35 Dr. Bernard Sabella Culture Program 41 Rev. Dr. Mitri Raheb (Founder & Authentic Tourism Program 44 President, ex officio) Gift Shop Sales for 2015 46 Diyar Publisher 48 Media Coverage 50 Construction Projects 53 1 In all of the construction projects, Diyar emphasized alternative itineraries into their schedules. When we aesthetics, cultural heritage, and green buildings. started in 1995, there were only 60 Palestinian tour FOREWORD Thanks to utilizing solar energy, Diyar was able in 2015 guides (out of a total of 4000 guides); all of them were to generate 40% of its energy consumption through over 60 years old and had received their license from solar. By 2020, we hope to reach zero-energy goal. the Jordanian government prior to 1967. Thanks to Dar Dear Friends, al-Kalima University College of Arts and Culture, today In all these years Diyar programs were highlighted in there are over 500 trained and accredited Palestinian ANNUAL REPORT 2015 ANNUALREPORT Salaam from Bethlehem. The year 2015 marked Diyar’s 20th anniversary. It was on many media outlets including the BBC, CNN, ABC, tour guides, who became Palestine’s ambassadors, September 28, 1995 that we inaugurated Dar Annadwa in the newly renovated CBS, HBO, ARD, ZDF, ORF, BR, al-Jazeera, Ma’an News sharing the Palestinian narrative with international crypt of Christmas Lutheran Church, as a place for worldwide encounter.
    [Show full text]
  • Reviewing Education in Palestine
    199 alestineNovember 2014 Reviewing Education in Palestine Inside the small rooms of This Week in Palestine In this issue we started to call this November issue on reviewing education a benchmark as soon as the idea hit us. It Reviewing Education is a leap in our aspirations to push the magazine’s content, look, and role in our society to a whole in Palestine new level. Palestinians have placed a lot of value and hope on this subject. Education was at one time THE 4 The Gorgeous Robe of Our King commodity to invest in for the future of Palestinian families after the loss of their houses, properties, lands, and natural habitats during 199 10 Healing from Modern Superstitions November 2014 Al-Nakba, the forced exodus. Palestine used to be a thriving place for education, which is reflected in the following pages through a new and interesting research 20 Why I Left School and Never Went alestine project conducted by Jehad Alshwaikh. Also, during the first Intifada, Palestinians Back! came up with their own flexible and practical form of education, which is the subject 28 Why Do We Pursue University of an important article we have for you by Alessandro Petti. Degrees? At present, however, education has become a topic shrouded in controversy. The 34 Rethinking Palestinian Education system has not been producing the results it promised. So we decided that it was time to take a fresh look at education in Palestine and pose a few questions. Is 40 Palestinian Cultural/Historical knowledge really the focal point of our educational system? How does Palestinian Geography education compare with educational advancements around the world? 46 Reclaiming Diversity in Education We sought out the most prolific and professional writers on education to give us Reviewing Education in Palestine their views and suggestions on how to move forward.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Introduction the Palestine Liberation Organization Has Been Extensively Studied in the Social Sciences and Humanities Particul
    This is the accepted version of an article that will be published by Duke University Press in Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East: https://www.dukeupress.edu/comparative-studies-of-south-asia-africa-and-the-middle- east/?viewby=journal Accepted version downloaded from SOAS Research Online: http://eprints.soas.ac.uk/24506/ PLO Cultural Activism: Mediating Liberation aesthetics in revolutionary contexts Dina Matar, Centre for Global Media and Communications, SOAS University of London [email protected] Abstract This paper addresses the PLO's cultural activism, in other words, its investment in diverse spheres of popular culture, at the beginning of the revolutionary period 1968- 1982 in its history. Drawing on archival research of the main spheres of the PLO's cultural output, it traces how the PLO strategized popular culture to enhance its image, create a new visibility for the Palestinians and mediate a Palestinian-centric liberation aesthetic rooted in real experiences of, and participation in, the Palestinian revolution. As such, the PLO's cultural activism combined an agential understanding of what it means to be Palestinian with popular armed struggle, language and image to conjure power in grassroots action, turn attention to the Palestinians themselves and evoke enduring affective identifications with the organization despite various setbacks and the passage of time. The argument is not intended to romanticize the role of the PLO or popular culture in a golden age of liberation politics. Rather it underlines
    [Show full text]
  • Seized in Beirut the Plundered Archives of the Palestinian Cinema Institution and Cultural Arts Section
    Seized in Beirut The Plundered Archives of the Palestinian Cinema Institution and Cultural Arts Section Rona Sela Abstract: One of the biggest acts of plunder by Israel was of a vast Palestinian film archive looted by Israeli military forces in Beirut in 1982. The films are managed under the repressive colonial control of the Israel Defense Forces Archive, which thus conceals many of them and information regarding their origin. This article documents my efforts to disclose the films and locate their institutions in Beirut, to chart their history, name their film-makers and open a discussion about returning them. It also provides a deeper understanding of colonial mechanisms of looting and truth production. I discuss the Third Palestine Cinema Movement and the various institutions that were part of the Palestinian revolution in the 1970s, with a focus on the Cultural Arts Section managed by Ismail Shammout. Keywords: art looting, colonial archives, Cultural Arts Section, Israel Defense Forces Archive (IDFA), Palestinian archives, Palestinian Cinema Institution, The United Media Israeli Colonial Mechanisms: Military Plunder, Looting, Censorship and Erasure of Palestinian History This article discusses Palestinian film archives plundered by Israeli forces in Beirut in 1982, held by the Israel Defense Forces Archive (IDFA) and cata- logued as ‘Seized Films from the PLO Archive in Beirut’ (Figure 1). The plun- dered archives contain historical documentation of daily life in Palestine before the Nakba (the Palestinian catastrophe and exile, 1948) that were gathered Anthropology of the Middle East, Vol. 12, No. 1, Summer 2017: 83–114 © Berghahn Books doi:10.3167/ame.2017.120107 • ISSN 1746-0719 (Print) • ISSN 1746-0727 (Online) 84 ← Rona Sela Figure 1: ‘IDF and Defense Establishment Archives.
    [Show full text]
  • The Occupation of Palestinian Art: Maps, Land, Destruction and Concealment
    The Occupation of Palestinian Art: Maps, Land, Destruction and Concealment Garrett Bailey A New Middle East?: Diagrams, Diagnosis and Power June 2016 1 Abstract Violence in the Middle East has been the focal point in news media. My paper has shifted the focus to forms of non-violent resistance as it pertains to Israel- Palestine. Palestinians have used art as a means of resistance before Israel declared itself a state in 1948. By focusing on Palestinian artists, I am able to show the ways in which art can reveal and counter Israeli Zionists rhetoric. Artists tear down the fallacies of Zionist propaganda through non-violent means. Resistance art is expressed in different forms, from maps, architecture and sculpture to film and graffiti. By examining Palestinian artists' work throughout the history of the Israeli-Palestine conflict, I am able to find out more about Israel's settlement building, border technology, pro-Israel lobbies, the tactics of the Israel Defense Force, and the censorship of Palestinian art. 2 Palestinians have engaged in non-violent resistance from the beginning of Israel's military occupation. Through an examination of maps, architecture, graffiti and film, I explore Israel's military tactics and their mechanisms of control. How does art shape the perceptions and realities of Israel/Palestine? Palestinian art is a necessary tool in exposing the oppression of the Israeli government and countering Zionist rhetoric. Zionism's purpose in the early 20th century was to find a homeland for the Jewish people living in the diaspora, proving the fall of the Ottoman Empire after World War One disastrous for the Palestinians.
    [Show full text]
  • ¬¬¬Press Release
    PRESS RELEASE Institute of Contemporary Arts, Theatre, London 26 June – 21 July 2013 Private View Tuesday, 25 June 2013, POINTS OF DEPARTURE 19:00-21:00 Basel Abbas and Ruanne Abou-Rahme, Jumana Emil Abboud, Bisan Abu Eisheh, Bashar Alhroub, Jeremy Hutchison, Olivia Plender Delfina Foundation is delighted to announce Points of Departure, an exhibition that culminates a year of collaboration with ArtSchool Palestine, the British Council and the Institute of Contemporary Arts (ICA). Presented at the ICA, the exhibition will be among the highlights of the 2013 Shubbak Festival in London (22 June - 6 July). Points of Departure begins as a set of thoughtful explorations into the phenomena of liminality. A condition in which one's sense of identity is diffused, liminality leads not only to states of dislocation and disorientation, but also to new perspectives. From this starting point, all the exhibiting artists undertook research-orientated projects in the UK and Palestine, seeking to make meaning, and create new narratives, in response to urgent contemporary questions around nationalism and identity, history and place. Points of Departure presents new commissions by Palestinian artists Jumana Emil Abboud, Bashar Alhroub, Bisan Abu Eisheh, and UK artists Jeremy Hutchison and Olivia Plender - all of whom undertook eight-week residencies in London and Ramallah respectively. In relation to themes raised by the project and the works produced, the exhibition also features a seminal work by Ramallah-based artists Basel Abbas and Ruanne Abou-Rahme. The exhibition has been curated by Rebecca Heald with the support of Mirna Bamieh. Bisan Abu-Eisheh’s installation acts as an introduction to the exhibition.
    [Show full text]
  • Artists Under Occupation: Collective Memory & the Performing Arts in Palestine, 1948-2011
    Artists Under Occupation: Collective Memory & the Performing Arts in Palestine, 1948-2011 By Rozina S. Gilani Submitted to Central European University History Department In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Supervisor: Professor Nadia Al-Bagdadi Second Reader: Professor Tolga Esmer CEU eTD Collection Budapest, Hungary 2012 Copyright in the text of this thesis rests with the Author. Copies by any process, either in full CEU eTD Collection or part, may be made only in accordance with the instructions given by the Author and lodged in the Central European Library. Details may be obtained from the librarian. This page must form a part of any such copies made. Further copies made in accordance with such instructions may not be made without the written permission of the Author. i Abstract This project explores the relationship between art, politics and collective memory as represented in Palestinian performing arts. By looking at the historical trajectory of art movements in Palestine and identifying key moments of change in artistic style and trends, I hope to support the argument that Palestinian art is inherently political and holds political functions in its society. Furthermore, while I initially anticipated discovering artists reproducing motifs of resistance as found in the early works of painters as a means of participating in salvage ethnography, my findings actually show a growing enthusiasm for new works that reappropriate older narratives and breathe new life into older aesthetic representations. The thesis will also explore issues of identity and pinpoint ways in which the Palestinian diaspora are participating in art production and efforts to resist the occupation through cultural means.
    [Show full text]
  • Sites and Senses Mapping Palestinian Territories in Mona Hatoum’S Sculpture Present Tense
    Sites And Senses 11 Chapter 1 Sites and Senses Mapping Palestinian Territories in Mona Hatoum’s Sculpture Present Tense Anneke Schulenberg In April 1996, Mona Hatoum, a British artist of Palestinian origin, installed a work entitled Present Tense at the Anadiel Gallery in East Jerusalem, an area annexed by Israel in 1967 (Figs 1.1–1.2).1 On the floor of the gallery, Hatoum laid 2400 pieces of soap in a rectangular shape. The soap was Nablus soap, a tradi- tional Palestinian product made of olive oil. Hatoum pressed tiny red glass beads in curved lines into the soap (Fig. 1.2). At first sight, the lines seem to make up abstract forms, but in fact they depict part of the occupied Palestinian territories that, as determined by the 1993 Oslo Accords, Israel should have handed back to the Palestinian authorities. Hatoum came across a map of these territories on the first day of her visit to Jerusalem. In Present Tense, she omitted the outlines of the map of Israel, only drawing the Palestinian territo- ries: fragmented parcels of land, scattered across Israel, resembling an archi- pelago. Present Tense was originally a site-specific sculpture as the work was made specifically for that exhibition in Jerusalem and was an immediate response to the site. By inscribing the map of the Oslo Accords on a local traditional prod- uct, Hatoum investigated the political, social and cultural dynamics at play within the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Drawing only the Palestinian territories in Israel on the soap, Hatoum focused on the Palestinian situation within the conflict.
    [Show full text]
  • The Case of the Visual Arts in Palestine
    Strategics Sectors | Culture & Society Panorama Cultural Creations in Times of Occupation: The Case of the Visual Arts in Palestine Marion Slitine Since the 1993 Oslo Accords, this colonial system PhD Candidate in Anthropology, École des Hautes has been stepped up through a policy of extreme Études en Sciences Sociales (EHESS), Paris fragmentation dividing the West Bank into three Research Associate, Institut français du zones: Zone A, under Palestinian military and civil Proche-Orient (Ifpo) Strategics Sectors | Culture & Society control (less than 10% of the territory); Zone B, under Palestinian civil but Israeli military control (30% of the territory); and Zone C (60% of the West Bank with Social sciences literature on Palestine, overabun- the Jordan Valley and most of its water resources) dant insofar as geopolitical, social and economic completely under Israeli (military and civil) control. aspects, proves quite discrete with regard to its ar- The multiplication of colonies in the West Bank and tistic and cultural dimensions. However, the art East Jerusalem continues. More than 500 check- scene in the Occupied Palestinian Territories is a points reduce Palestinian movement between towns. particularly faithful reflection of the dynamics in con- In addition there is the dividing wall, which has con- 1 330 temporary Palestinian society. Here, art is not the siderably aggravated their situation. Gaza sustains preserve of the elite, and artists, considered spokes- such major restrictions of movement – not only ap- people for the national interests of their homeland plied by the Israeli authorities but also the Egyptian (watan), fulfil a major social role. and Jordanian governments – that its 1.8 million in- habitants (one of the highest population densities in the world) are forced to live in extreme isolation.
    [Show full text]
  • 70 Years of Nakba: a Programme of 9 Palestinian Shorts
    70 YEARS OF NAKBA: A PROGRAMME OF 9 PALESTINIAN SHORTS This programme was curated on the 70th Part 1 : History and exile anniversary of the Nakba (The Catastrophe), by the Palestine Strand of the Creative House | Ahmed Saleh |2011 Interruptions research project. The research For generations, a family lived in a spacious has aimed to explore how Palestinian and beautiful house. Guests were always filmmakers have used their cinema to give welcome to enjoy a pleasant stay. Until one voice to their history and experience. It has guest arrived with a different plan in mind. been concerned with self-representation (4mins) rather than with the work of solidarity filmmakers. www.creativeinterruptions.com Alyasiini | SaheraDirbas | 2012 Mahmad Alyasiini is a Palestinian survivor The programme makes use of the rich from Deir Yassin, west of Jerusalem. He collection of short films produced by a diverse recounts his life in the village before the group of creative practitioners living both Nakba and tells how he survived the massacre within the borders of historic Palestine and on April 1948. On 9 April 1948, a month outside it. It enables us to understand the before the establishment of the state of diversity of Palestinian experience from exile, Israel. 100 of the 600 residents in Deir Yassin to occupation, to living under siege as well as were killed and the rest forced to flee, an in refugee camps as stateless citizens. event which precipitated the occupants of Screening Palestinian shorts enables us to many other villages to flee in fear. (22 mins) appreciate the diversity of talent within Palestinian film production because many Glow of Memories | Ismail Shammout |1972 filmmakers find it difficult to secure funding Centring around an old Palestinian man who and support for their projects as stateless is the subject of Ismail Shammout’s painting people.
    [Show full text]