Distribution of Sea Turtles in Lavaca And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Final Report DISTRIBUTION OF SEA TURTLES IN LAVACA AND MATAGORDA BAYS, TEXAS - A PRELIMINARY SURVEY OF ECOLOGY AND TOXICOLOGY OF SEA TURTLES AS RELATED TO FORMOSA PLASTICS CORPORATION’S WASTEWATER DISCHARGE Submitted by the Texas A&M Research Foundation Room 112, Bell Building University Drive and Wellborn Road College Station, Texas 77843-3578 to the Environmental Protection Agency Federal Activities Branch 1445 Ross Avenue Dallas, Texas 75202 Prepared by André M. Landry, Jr., David T. Costa, F. Leonard Kenyon, Karen E. St. John, Michael S. Coyne, and Marc C. Hadler Department of Marine Biology Texas A&M University at Galveston Galveston, Texas 77551 August 1997 i EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Results of a study assessing sea turtle use of Lavaca and Matagorda Bays and the potential for toxicological risk to these organisms from wastewater discharged by Formosa Plastics Corporation’s Point Comfort Plant are reported herein. Objectives of this research were to: 1) document historical occurrence and distribution of sea turtles in Lavaca and Matagorda Bays; 2) execute entanglement netting operations characterizing present-day distribution, population dynamics and toxicological risks of these protected species; and 3) generate preliminary baseline data on trace metal concentration in the blood of captured turtles. Historical occurrence and distribution of sea turtles in Lavaca and Matagorda Bays were documented through a variety of survey methods including: on-line bibliographic searches of sea turtle and fisheries literature; personal interviews with a former Texas Parks and Wildlife Department (TPWD) biologist and recreational fishing guide; questionnaires sent to commercial shrimp and crab fishermen, recreational fishing guides, and TPWD enforcement officers and biologists; advertisements in the Port Lavaca Wave newspaper and Sea Grant Program and Gulf Coast Conservation Association magazines targeting the marine user; and posters strategically placed at boat ramps, bait shops, stores and restaurants throughout the study area. Historical occurrence of sea turtles in the Matagorda Bay System during the last 20 years can be characterized as seasonal utilization of Matagorda Bay (south of its juncture with Lavaca Bay) by a limited assemblage of greens (Chelonia mydas), Kemp’s ridleys (Lepidochelys kempii), and loggerheads (Caretta caretta). Peak utilization of the System’s habitats typically occurred in lower reaches of Matagorda Bay and near Pass Cavallo. Historical occupation of Lavaca Bay by sea turtles appears to have been infrequent. Present-day distribution, population dynamics and toxicological risks of sea turtles were characterized through entanglement netting operations staged in the northwest corner of Matagorda Bay at its juncture with Lavaca Bay. These operations were conducted monthly from May through October 1996. Turtles taken in entanglement nets were identified to species and enumerated, meristically examined, equipped with flipper and PIT tags, and sampled for blood used in sex and trace metal assessments. Hydrographic and nekton surveys documented environmental conditions and prey availability, respectively, in the study area during entanglement netting operations. Approximately 500 entanglement net-hours (a net-hour being defined as each hour one 91.5-m entanglement net is fished at a monitoring station) of effort yielded 12 sea turtle captures comprised of 7 Kemp’s ridleys and 4 greens (one of which was captured twice). Captures occurred during 4 of 6 monitoring months, with May-July accounting for 10 of these. All turtles were netted in the northwest corner of Matagorda Bay adjacent to Magnolia and Indianola Beaches, immediately south of the mouth of Lavaca Bay. Peak CPUE (0.43 turtle/km-hr) was achieved in May, while capture rate during other months was noticeably reduced (0.0-0.25 turtle/km-hr). Kemp’s ridleys, the majority being juveniles typically ≤40 cm carapace length, were taken only May-July, All ridley constituents were wild (as opposed to captive-reared “headstarts”) whose sex was partitioned between three females and four males. Post pelagic cohorts (≤40 cm carapace length) comprised the green turtle assemblage whose capture was limited to June, July and September. Gender of three greens which could be sexed was one female and two males. A 37.5 cm green turtle originally netted in Matagorda Bay on 19 June 1996 was recaptured 28 July, during which time (38 days) it gained 2.6 cm and 1.25 kg. A second recapture involved a Kemp’s ridley, originally taken in Matagorda Bay on 26 July 1996, which was netted off the Sabine Pass, Texas beachfront on 20 May 1997. This ridley gained 0.9 cm and 0.9 kg during 298 days of liberty. ii Sea turtle captures in Matagorda Bay during May-October 1996, when compared with those from a similar netting effort at Sabine Pass over the same period, reflected low relative abundance and catch rate. Sabine Pass yielded an overall CPUE nearly four times higher than that recorded in Matagorda Bay. However, abnormally high salinity conditions and westward expansion of a hypoxic/anoxic “dead” zone across the northwest Gulf may mean that 1996 catch statistics are conservative estimates of sea turtle occurrence in nearshore habitats such as Matagorda Bay and Sabine Pass. The 1996 catches, when combined with the aforementioned historical survey and literature on sea turtle natural history, suggest that Kemp’s ridley and green turtles taken in reduced abundances near Lavaca Bay during the present study probably represent remnants of larger assemblages that: 1) naturally occur in lower reaches of the Matagorda Bay System which possess habitats more conducive to a herbivorous life style (i.e., green turtle) or benthic feeding habits (i.e., Kemp’s ridley); and 2) prefer shallow, nearshore Gulf waters but were attracted to upper reaches of Matagorda Bay by abnormally high salinities which facilitated extended feeding opportunities in this area. These same factors suggest that long-term, wide-ranging occupation of Lavaca Bay by either species is much reduced from that expected in lower reaches of the Matagorda Bay System and nearshore Gulf. Trace metal analyses of 6 sea turtles (5 Kemp’s ridleys and 1 green) captured during the current study were compared with those conducted on 106 Kemp’s ridleys taken at Sabine Pass in 1995 and 1996. Four of five Matagorda Bay ridleys exhibited mercury concentrations exceeding both the mean and maximum levels detected in Sabine Pass conspecifics of similar size. One ridley possessed five times more mercury (181 ppb) than the maximum concentration (35.6 ppb) in Sabine Pass counterparts. Adding to this was the noticeable reduction in mercury exhibited by a ridley originally captured in Matagorda Bay and subsequently netted 298 days later at Sabine Pass. Mercury concentration in the only green turtle analyzed from Matagorda Bay was well above the mean value detected for Sabine Pass ridleys of similar size. Copper levels in Matagorda Bay ridleys never exceeded maximum concentrations exhibited by Sabine Pass counterparts but they were slightly higher than the mean value detected in the former. Lead concentrations from Matagorda Bay ridleys fell in line with those for Sabine Pass conspecifics. The most noteworthy result from silver analyses was an elevated concentration (well beyond that in all other blood samples from Matagorda Bay) in the ridley recaptured at Sabine Pass in 1997. Zinc concentrations were similar in turtles from both sites. Significance of trace metal findings generated by this study is difficult to assess due, in large part, to a research void in sea turtle toxicology and an incomplete understanding of the degree to which blood can be used as a barometer of bioaccumulation. Nevertheless, the present study provides an albeit preliminary but repeated trend for sea turtles (particularly Kemp’s ridleys) from Matagorda Bay to exhibit elevated mercury concentrations beyond those from a more “toxic free” site like the Sabine Pass beachfront. This preliminary finding is not unexpected since Lavaca and Matagorda Bay sediments containing mercury are reworked by benthic prey organisms which are eaten by shrimp, crabs and fish that serve as food for Kemp’s ridleys. Clarification of the toxicological risk potential inherent to sea turtles using areas within and adjacent to Lavaca Bay will be complete only after more information is available on: 1) sea turtle occurrence in the area of concern; and 2) significance of trace metal concentrations in blood of these protected species. Preliminary results from the present study mandate consideration be given to facilitating more detailed investigations of trace metal uptake by sea turtles occupying Lavaca-Matagorda Bay environs. iii Table of Contents P a ge Executive Summary i List of Tables iv List of Figures v List of Appendix Tables vi INTRODUCTION 1 MATERIALS AND METHODS 2 A. Historical Occurrence of Sea Turtles 2 B. Sea Turtle Capture and Related Activities 7 Netting areas 7 Entanglement netting 9 Turtle work-up 9 Tagging protocol 11 Blood sampling - sex and trace metal analysis 11 Habitat characterization 12 RESULTS 13 A. Historical Occurrence of Sea Turtles 13 Literature survey 13 Questionnaires and related surveys 13 TPWD field surveys 15 B. Sea Turtle Capture and Population Dynamics 17 Sea turtle capture effort 17 Sea turtle population dynamics 17 Tag-recapture and tracking 26 Trace metal analysis 28 Habitat characterization 34 Hydrographics 36 DISCUSSION 36 Historical Occurrence of Sea Turtles in Lavaca Bay 36 Present Occurrence of Sea Turtles in Matagorda Bay 38 Toxicological Risks to Sea Turtles 41 REFERENCES 44 iv List of Tables T a ble P a ge 1 Sea turtles captured by the Texas Parks & Wildlife Department during seasonal 16 fishery surveys of the Matagorda Bay System from 1979-94. 2 Sea turtle species abundance and status across Matagorda Bay netting stations 21 during 1996. 3 Sea turtle species captured by entanglement netting operations in Matagorda Bay 22 during 1996. 4 Mercury concentration (ppb, wet weight) in whole blood of sea turtles captured 29 from Matagorda Bay and Sabine Pass during 1994-97.