DOCSLIB.ORG

Addressing the Challenges of Globalization an Independent Evaluation of the World Bank’S Approach to Global Programs

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Addressing the Challenges of Globalization an Independent Evaluation of the World Bank’S Approach to Global Programs WORLD BANK OPERATIONS EVALUATION DEPARTMENT Addressing the Challenges of Globalization An Independent Evaluation of the World Bank’s Approach to Global Programs 2004 The World Bank http://www.worldbank.org/oed Washington, D.C. © 2004 The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank 1818 H Street, NW Washington, DC 20433 Telephone: 202-473-1000 Internet: www.worldbank.org E-mail: [email protected] All rights reserved Manufactured in the United States of America First edition December 2004 The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed here are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Board of Executive Directors of the World Bank or the governments they represent. The World Bank cannot guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this work. The boundaries, colors, denominations, and other information shown on any map in the work do not imply on the part of the World Bank any judgment of the legal status of any territory or the endorsement or acceptance of such boundaries. Rights and Permissions The material in this publication is copyrighted. Copying and/or transmitting portions or all of this work without permission may be a violation of applicable law. The World Bank encourages dissemination of its work and will normally grant permission promptly. For permission to photocopy or reprint any part of this work, please send a request with complete information to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA, telephone 978-750-8400, fax 978-750-4470, www.copyright.com. All other queries on rights and licenses, including subsidiary rights, should be addressed to the Office of the Publisher, World Bank, 1818 H Street NW, Washington, DC 20433, USA, fax 202-522-2422, e-mail [email protected]. Cover photo courtesy of the World Bank Photo Library. ISBN 0-8213-6065-5 e-ISBN 0-8213-6066-3 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication data have been applied for. World Bank InfoShop Operations Evaluation Department E-mail: [email protected] Knowledge Programs and Evaluation Capacity Telephone: 202-458-5454 Development (OEDKE) Facsimile: 202-522-1500 E-mail: [email protected] Telephone: 202-458-4497 Facsimile: 202-522-3125 Printed on Recycled Paper Contents vii Acknowledgments xi Foreword, Prólogo, Avant-propos xv Preface, Prefacio, Préface xxi Executive Summary xxxi Résumen ejecutivo xliii Résumé analytique lv List of Case Study Programs lvii Abbreviations and Acronyms 1 1 Introduction and Context: Global Challenges and the Need for Collective Action 3 Issues and Trends in Global Programs 9 2 Overview of the Case Study Programs 11 Program Objectives 15 Governance and Management 18 The Bank’s Roles 21 3 Program Relevance to Global Challenges, Bank Priorities, and Country Priorities 22 Evidence of International Consensus 27 Consistency with the Bank’s Sector Strategies 28 Consistency with the Subsidiarity Principle and the Bank’s Strategic Foci for Global Programs 30 Conclusions 33 4 Striving for Results: Assessing the Outcomes and Impacts of Global Programs 34 Quality of Monitoring and Evaluation Activities 41 Links Between Global Programs and Country Operations 45 Conclusions 53 5 Governance, Management, Partnerships, and Participation 53 Governance Functions, Principles, and Models 58 Clarity of Roles and Responsibilities iii ADDRESSING THE CHALLENGES OF GLOBALIZATION 60 Partnering with Developing Countries, Civil Society, and the Private Sector 65 Overall Assessment and Lessons 67 6 Global Programs Need Global Strategy 68 Funding Models of Global Programs That Combine the DGF, Trust Funds, and Bank Budget, Need Greater Clarity 69 Inconsistent Application of DGF Funding Rules Causes Confusion and Poses Reputational Risks 72 Bank-Administered Trust Funds for Global Programs Could Be Deployed More Strategically 73 7 World Bank Performance in Global Programs 74 Comparative Advantage 74 Global-Country Links 77 Oversight 80 Exit Strategy 83 8 Findings and Recommendations 83 OED Findings 88 OED Recommendations 91 Annexes 93 A: Previous OED Recommendations in Relation to Global Programs 97 B: Progress in Implementing the Phase 1 Recommendations Relating to Strategic and Programmatic Management 101 C: Evaluation Framework for Phase 2 Report and 26 Case Studies 109 D: Suggested Appraisal Template for Global Programs 113 E: OED’s Summary of the Known Outcomes and Impacts of Case Study Global Programs 127 F: Source Material 129 G: People Consulted 151 H: Case Study Summary Information 241 I: Management Response 247 J: Chairman’s Summary: Committee on Development Effectiveness (CODE) 251 Endnotes 263 References Boxes 2 1.1 Definition and Management of Global Programs by the World Bank 3 1.2 What Is the World Bank’s Comparative Advantage with Respect to Global Programs? 5 1.3 Global Public Goods, Merit Goods, and the Logic of Global Collective Action 12 2.1 Subsidiarity: Who Does What 14 2.2 Both “Approaches” and “Standards” Raise Practical Issues: The Devil Is in the Details 25 3.1 AIDS Programs Face Continuing Implementation Challenges 35 4.1 UNAIDS-Funded and Bank-Administered Monitoring and Evaluation of HIV/AIDS Programs Face the Challenge of Donor Coordination 36 4.2 To Deliver Global Public Goods of Benefit to the Poor, Global Programs Need Analytical Foundations with a Results-Based Orientation iv CONTENTS 37 4.3 Key Terms in Results-Based Management and Evaluation 38 4.4 Partners in Poverty-Focused CGAP Disagree on Need to Verify Program Impact on the Poor 39 4.5 Impacts of Global Agricultural and Health Research 55 5.1 The Two Largest Programs Show the Roots of Diversity and Complexity 56 5.2 What Are Partnerships? Who Are Members and Partners? 56 5.3 Shareholder and Stakeholder Models 70 6.1 The DGF Has Had Difficulty Applying Its Selectivity Criteria to the Bank’s Global Programs 75 7.1 The Effectiveness of Bank Cosponsorship as a Governance Tool Is Underexplored Tables 7 1.1 Management Actions Following OED’s Phase 1 Report 10 2.1 Environment and Agriculture Are the Largest Case Study Programs 13 2.2 Most Programs Primarily Address National Public Goods or Capacity 16 2.3 Governance and Management Arrangements Are Diverse 17 2.4 Unlike Programs Housed outside the Bank, Those Housed inside the Bank Tend to Be Chaired by the Bank 19 2.5 World Bank Plays Multiple Roles in Global Programs 20 2.6 Many Programs Contribute Financial Resources That Supplement the Bank’s Administrative Budget 23 3.1 Genesis Is One Indicator of International Consensus for a Program 34 4.1 Most Recent Program-Level Evaluations 42 4.2 The Bank Has Difficulty Linking Global Programs with Country Operations Where Bank Staff Are Not Implementing Global Program Activities 48 4.3 Programs Financing Investments Have More Known Benefits to Developing Countries 57 5.1 Most Programs Now Involve Stakeholders beyond Donors on Their Governing and Executive Bodies 68 6.1 Disconnects Between Program Objectives and Their Funding Arrangements Create Problems 71 6.2 Eight of 18 DGF-Supported Programs Violate DGF’s 15 Percent Guideline in FY04, and Windows 1 and 2 Need to Be Revisited 78 7.1 Bank Oversight of Case Study Programs, by Governance Model Figures 6 1.1 Official Development Assistance Has Fluctuated, but Not Grown, since 1990 10 2.1 Age of Case Study Programs 11 2.2 The Programs Are Engaged in a Wide Range of Activities 26 3.1 Donor Participation Varies in the Case Study Programs 41 4.1 Overall OED Assessment of Monitoring and Evaluation 45 4.2 New Commitments to HIV/AIDS and Other Communicable Diseases Have Grown Rapidly 66 5.1 Overall OED Assessment of Governance and Management 88 8.1 Overall OED Assessment of Current Consistency of Case Study Programs with the Development Committee Criteria v Acknowledgments This report was written by Uma Lele and Chris Vijay L. Kelkar, Cyrus D.R. Rustomjee, Rosemary Gerrard and builds on case-study analyses by Stevenson , and J. de Beaufort Wijnholds. the OED Global Team. The Team included Man- The team also benefited from the information mohan Agarwal, Yusuf Ahmad, Caroline Bahnson, and insight provided by Managing Directors Jef- Edward Bresnyan, Tomas Caspellan, Jozefina Cu- frey Goldstein, Mamphela Ramphele, Sven Sand- tura, Ramesh Govindaraj, Maisha Hyman, Jef- strom and Shengman Zhang; from Senior Vice frey Jordan, Kristina Kavaliunas, Lauren Kelly, Presidents Francois J. Bourguignon, Jean Louis Yianni Konstantopoulos, Kavita Mathur, Karin Sarbib, and Nicholas Stern; from the Vice Pres- Perkins, Saeed Rana, Naveen Sarna, Kirsten idents in charge of Operations, Networks, and Ex- Spainhower, David Spielman, and Rod Stubina. ternal Relations, including James Adams, Ian The report benefited from the editorial contri- Goldin, Ian Johnson, Motoo Kusakabe, Geoffrey butions of Caroline McEuen, Brian Fitzpatrick, Lamb, Frannie Leautier, Gobind Nankani, Jozef William Hurlbut, and Rachel Weaving. Ritzen, Nemat Shafik, and Anil Sood; and from The OED Team would like to acknowledge the the Director of the Quality Assessment Group, valuable contributions of OED management and Prem Garg. colleagues—Martha Ainsworth, Rema Balasun- The OED Team thanks the following Country daram, Lily Chu, Laurie Effron, John Eriksson, Directors: Michael F. Carter, Mats Karlsson, Ed- Alice Galenson, Madhur Gautam, Roy Gilbert, ward Lim, Andrew Steer, and Vinod Thomas. We Patrick Grasso, Catherine Gwin, Andres Lieben- also thank numerous Bank staff from many pro- thal, Fernando Manibog, Ridley Nelson, Keith grams and units, including the Global Programs Pitman, and Yvonne Tsikata—to the earlier drafts and Partnership Group and the DGF Secre- of this report and to the case studies. tariat: Paul Hubbard, Jane Kirby-Zaki, Sophia The authors and contributors also appreciate Drewnowski, Judy Lu, Randall Purcell, and Anju the perspectives and inputs from World Bank Sharma; and the Trust Fund Operations and Group Executive Directors Tanwir Ali Agha, Jaime Trust Fund Quality Assurance and Compliance Alvarez, Yahya Alyahya, Gino Alzetta, Carole Unit: Arif Zulfiqar, Dale Hill, Paul Cadario, Diana Brookins, Alieto Guadagni, Louis Kasekende, Corbin, and Caroline Harper.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Role of Indigenous Peoples in Biodiversity Conservation the Natural but Often Forgotten Partners
    The Role of Indigenous Peoples in Biodiversity Conservation The Role of Indigenous Peoples THE WORLD BANK 1818 H Street, NW in Biodiversity Conservation Washington, DC 20433 USA Telephone: 202-473-1000 Internet: www.worldbank.org/biodiversity E-mail: [email protected] The Natural but Often Forgotten Partners THE WORLD BANK The Role of Indigenous Peoples in Biodiversity Conservation The Natural but Often Forgotten Partners Claudia Sobrevila Senior Biodiversity Specialist May 2008 Author: Claudia Sobrevila Graphic design: The Word Express, Inc. Editing: Ellen Kwiatkowski & Linda Starke Administrative support: Grace Aguilar Copyright © 2008. The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / THE WORLD BANK 1818 H Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20433, U.S.A Papers in this series are not formal publications of the World Bank. They are circulated to encourage thought and discussion. The use and citation of this paper should take this into account. The views expressed are those of the author and should not be attributed to the World Bank. Copies are available from the Environ- ment Department of the World Bank by calling (202) 473-3641. Photos courtesy of: Claudia Sobrevila, Adalberto Dominguez, Instituto Rais (El Salvador). “ I do not see a delegation For the four-legged. I see no seat for the eagles. We forget and we consider Ourselves superior. But we are after all A mere part of Creation. And we must consider To understand where we are. And we stand somewhere between The mountain and the Ant Somewhere and only there As part and parcel Of the Creation. Chief Oren Lyons Source: Steve Wall and Harvey Arden, Wisdomkeepers, Beyond Words, Hillsboro, 1990, p.
    [Show full text]
  • United Nations Conference on Trade and Development
    UNITED NATIONS TD United Nations Distr. GENERAL Conference on Trade and TD/B/49/INF.1 21 January 2003 Development ENGLISH/FRENCH/SPANISH TRADE AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD Forty-ninth session Geneva, 7–18 October 2002 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS Note: The format and data of the entries in this list are as provided to the secretariat. GE.03-50092 TD/B/49/INF.1 Page 2 MEMBERS AFRIQUE DU SUD H.E. Mr. Sipho George NENE, Ambassador, Permanent Representative, Geneva Mr. Patrick KRAPPIE, Economic Counsellor, Permanent Mission, Geneva ALBANIE H.E. Mr. Vladimir THANATI, Ambassador, Permanent Representative, Geneva Mr. Adrian MARA, Second Secretary, Permanent Mission, Geneva ALGERIE S.E. M. Mohamed-Salah DEMBRI, Ambassadeur, Représentant permanent, Genève M. Kheireddine RAMOUL, Conseiller, Mission permanente, Genève M. Ali DROUICHE, Secrétaire, Mission permanente, Genève ALLEMAGNE H.E. Mr. Karl Walter LEWALTER, Ambassador, Permanent Representative, Geneva Mr. Eberhard VON SCHUBERT, First Counsellor, Permanent Mission, Geneva Mr. Thilo KÖHLER, Federal Foreign Office Mr. Thomas KLAUS, Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology Mr. Hans-Jürgen FROESE, Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology Ms. Christina WILD, Intern, Permanent Mission, Geneva ANGOLA Mr. Amadeu de Jesus Alves LEITÃO NUNES, Commercial Attaché, Permanent Mission, Geneva ARABIE SAOUDITE Mr. Mohammed Ben IBRAHEEM ALHEZAN, Economic Counselor, Ministry of Finance and National Economy ARGENTINE S.E. Sr. Alfredo Vicente CHIARADIA, Embajador, Representante Permanente, Ginebra Sr. Eduardo VARELA, Consejero, Misión Permanente, Ginebra Sr. Roberto BOSCH ESTEVEZ, Secretario de Embajada, Misión Permanente, Ginebra AUTRICHE Mr. Herbert KRÖLL, Director of the Department for Multilateral Development Cooperation, Federal Ministry for Foreign Affairs Ms. Elke ATZLER, Minister, Chargé d'affaires ad interim, Permanent Mission, Geneva Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • Abstracts of Current Studies 1983
    Abstracts of Current Studies 1983 . T'he \\rorld Bank I~esearch Program Public Disclosure Authorized ............_.,_...._ ......, ............... .__........ ., ...... ....._ .. a.. ··-- ........ ~lAlla"-"-~ .... ~ 0...., twr <"- W) ........ .,.....,. ,_,. ........ c-,....,. -~fii....._,T...._,.....,._ e,...,_.,,..o--- • ._~ ........ artllllltt.,.,...,... ..... ..... "--.,.....,_.. ........ ~ ..... -~ ........... Ao.nl "'-** ........,_ (OAllll} ,.,...... .,..... ,... ............. ._.__ ,........,...,...,.,.. ....... .,~ ~-. ......... ............ .........,. .... r..,~..,., --...... ., .... ~ .. """"- ,......, ..,....,. ..__........ a.... .. ~ ....................... ....... .,... ........... .. a....""'-" .. .._..,....,.....,_,.._. .. a.-ta.....,............ ,.,....._ -T-.............. e..,a- - ~-=':':---·Lftf'l' -~ -=~a:::.:..~.... .,......, ............. ._.. ::;::;:: ~ 1U• •.~. , ........ ,....... , ~._ ............. w.w: .._ ~ A 0.... Ail** Nodlili.. .,.._ (O.UU) ........ ........, ........ aadlo ...... ~ . A~o-.11 .............. l'W&I7 --T--...:A........,. ... ~Q-1117 .,u-, ..... ._ ...._...,_., ........_. ......, ....... =--=t ...... .. ....... __ . ........... 0...,. .. ~1---'11 ----­ =:t..."':.'::..:.:r:: .-....:..,....... ........ ., ........... ~-- . ~ ~ . --- ~.~~~. ......... ~ ............ ,..~--~ ....... ._.__.., c....... ~ ........... ............ ~ ............ Public Disclosure Authorized --- t:c~~~~ t>o~!(~"- ..._.......,_..._._ ... CJGto.~ol"­ ............. ~.,......, .. ..,. :-::.:...-e-rn.,..... .. ........ ~u.
    [Show full text]
  • The Millennium World Peace Summit of Religious and Spiritual Leaders Opening at the United Nations, August 28,2000
    THE MILLENNIUM WORLD PEACE SUMMIT OF RELIGIOUS AND SPIRITUAL LEADERS OPENING AT THE UNITED NATIONS, AUGUST 28,2000 For Immediate Release Contact: Millicent White Press Liaison New York: (212) 715-1571 [email protected] RELIGIOUS LEADERS CALL TO SUPPORT THE INTERNATIONAL DAY AGAINST RACISM Millennium World Peace Summit brings Religious and Spiritual Leaders to support and join the United Nations in the battle against all forms of intolerance and racism A book commemorating this battle “Sacred Rights” will be published in May featuring statements by Pope John Paul II and the Dalai Lama New York, New York (March 22, 2001)—Religious leaders from all the world’s faith traditions joined the call from United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Mary Robinson, by calling upon their faith communities to battle all forms of intolerance and racism. Gathering support yesterday in Geneva, for the World Conference Against Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance—August 31-September 7, 2001 in Durban, South Africa—Robinson called on the leaders to support a United Nations awareness campaign laddering up to the conference as well as to participate in the conference. The invitation to religious leaders to participate in this year’s World Conference Against Racismreflects the growing recognition that religion plays a critical role in the global agenda. Forum leaders are calling for an integrated framework that includes business and political leaders, civil society and religion to address the major challenges facing the human community. Religious leaders stressed their aim to be the voice for all sectors of society and to foster an inclusive rather than exclusive economic order.
    [Show full text]
  • WTO Documents Online
    WORLD TRADE WT/COMTD/37/Rev.1 27 June 2002 ORGANIZATION (02-3578) Pledging Conference PLEDGING CONFERENCE FOR THE DOHA DEVELOPMENT AGENDA GLOBAL TRUST FUND Coherence, Technical assistance and Capacity Building Report by the Secretariat Revision I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1. The Pledging Conference for the Doha Development Agenda Global Trust Fund was held on 11 March 2002, in pursuance of the General Council's decision on the establishment of the DDA GTF and the convening of a Pledging Conference. The General Council, at that time, set a target amount for the DDA GTF of CHF15 million for 2002. The Director-General, in his opening statement, identified the seven pillars of the Secretariat strategic response to the Doha Development Agenda mandates. 2. Pledges amounted to a total of CHF30,872,000, including amounts announced for 2003 and 2006 in some cases. For 2002, announced pledges amount to CHF25,236,000, including a pledge by Nigeria of CHF1,000 and larger pledges from Chinese Taipei, Korea, Estonia and the Czech Republic (See document WT/BFA/SPEC/73). General information on bilateral assistance and specific announcements of contributions made to other international organizations were also included in the statements of some donor WTO Members (see Annex II). 3. The Conference was a stand-alone WTO event, to which all WTO Members and Observers, plus a number of multilateral agencies were invited. Its proceedings were divided into four segments (see programme in Annex I): first, a number of selected speakers were asked to address different substantive aspects of technical assistance and capacity building, with a view to launching a policy dialogue on these issues; second, developed and developing WTO Members were invited to make statements, including their pledges for the Trust Fund; third, representatives of multilateral agencies were invited to speak on their intended contributions to the implementation of the Doha Development Agenda; and fourth, other WTO Members and Observers were also invited to make statements (See list of speakers in Annex III).
    [Show full text]
  • Health and Human Rights: Towards a WHO Health and Human Rights Strategy WHO Geneva 3-4 April 2000
    HSD/GCP/June 2000 Original: English Distr.: Restricted Draft Meeting Report Second Informal Consultation on Health and Human Rights: Towards a WHO Health and Human Rights Strategy WHO Geneva 3-4 April 2000 Globalization, Cross-Sectoral Policies and Human Rights (GCP) Department of Health in Sustainable Development (HSD) World Health Organization (WHO) HSD/GCP/June 2000 Original: English Distr.: Restricted TABLE OF CONTENTS I Introduction……………………………………………………..1 II. Opening session…………………………………………………2 III. Dialogue with UN agencies to identify key issues and “best practices” for mainstreaming human rights ………………6 IV. Discussion on a draft WHO Strategy on Health and Human Rights……………………………………………………………12 V. Identifying priority areas and activities for implementing a WHO Health and Human Rights Strategy………………………13 Annex 1: Meeting agenda………………………………………………15 Annex 2: List of participants……………………………………………18 HSD/GCP/June 2000 Original: English Distr.: Restricted I. Introduction An Informal Consultation: Towards a WHO Health and Human Rights Strategy was held at WHO Headquarters, April 3-4, 2000. It had the overall objective of defining how human rights will be integrated in WHO, including the formulation of a strategy for WHO on health and human rights. It built upon a previous Informal Consultation on Health and Human Rights, held 13-14 December 1999, to which all WHO Clusters were invited. The Informal Consultation had the following specific objectives: 1. To engage WHO staff in a dialogue with other UN agencies and human rights experts with a view to identifying “best practices” for mainstreaming human rights in WHO. 2. To elicit comments on a draft document titled “the WHO Strategy on Health and Human Rights” with a view to: a) spelling out the links between the new WHO Corporate Strategy and human rights as outlined in the draft document under consideration; b) identifying priority areas and activities for implementing a Health and Human Rights Strategy.
    [Show full text]
  • Excerpt from the Report on the Twenty-Fifth, Twenty-Sixth and Twenty- Seventh Sessions (E/2002/22 - E/C.12/2001/17), Paras
    Excerpt from the Report on the Twenty-Fifth, Twenty-Sixth and Twenty- Seventh Sessions (E/2002/22 - E/C.12/2001/17), paras. 958-1015 Day of general discussion INTERNATIONAL CONSULTATION ON ECONOMIC, SOCIAL AND CULTURAL RIGHTS IN DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES OF INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTIONS ORGANIZED IN COOPERATION WITH THE HIGH COUNCIL FOR INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION (FRANCE) A. Introduction 958. At its twenty-fifth session, on 7 May 2001, the Committee held an international consultation, organized in cooperation with the Haut conseil de la coopération internationale (High Council for International Cooperation, or HCCI), on economic, social and cultural rights in relation to the development activities of international institutions. The Committee decided to have this international consultation, in the light of its efforts to engage United Nations specialized agencies, programmes and funds, and other international and regional organizations, in a dialogue and relationship of cooperation. 959. Speakers and panel discussants at the international consultation were the following: Mr. Jean-Louis Bianco and Ms. Catherine Lalumière (HCCI), Mr. François Gianviti (IMF), Mr. Hoe Lim (WTO), Mr. Omar Noman and Mr. Simon Munzu (UNDP), Mr. Bertrand Ramcharan (Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights), Mr. Rubens Ricupero (UNCTAD), Mr. Alfredo Sfeir-Younis (World Bank), Mr. Juan Somavía and Mr. Lee Swepston (ILO), Mr. Jean-Claude Faure (Development Assistance Committee, OECD), Mr. Carlo Trojan (European Commission, European Union), Ms. Patricia Feeney (Oxfam GB), and Mr. Nyameko Barney Pityana (South African Human Rights Commission). Mr. Paul Hunt, Rapporteur of the Committee, and Mr. Philippe Texier made interventions as members of the Committee. Mr. Gustave Massiah (HCCI) and Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • United Nations Conference on Trade and Development
    UNITED NATIONS TD United Nations Distr. GENERAL Conference on Trade and TD/B/48/INF.1 25 October 2001 Development ENGLISH/FRENCH/SPANISH TRADE AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD Forty-eighth session 1-12 October 2001 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS Note : The format and data of the entries in this list are as provided to the secretariat. GE. 00- TD/B/48/INF.1 Page 2 MEMBERS ALBANIE H.E. Mr. Ksenofon KRISAFI, Ambassador, Permanent Representative, Geneva Ms. Mira SCHNEIDER, Second Secretary, Permanent Mission, Geneva ALGERIE S.E. M. Mohamed-Salah DEMBRI, Ambassadeur, Représentant permanent, Genève M. Kheireddine RAMOUL, Conseiller, Mission permanente, Genève M. Nor-Eddine BENFREHA, Conseiller, Mission permanente, Genève ALLEMAGNE H.E. Mr. Karl Walter LEWALTER, Ambassador, Permanent Representative, Geneva Mr. Eberhard VON SCHUBERT, Permanent Mission, Geneva Mr. Thilo KÖHLER, Federal Foreign Office Mr. Dieter ROTHE, Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology Mr. Hans-Peter HOFMANN, Second Secretary, Permanent Mission, Geneva ANGOLA S.E. M. João Felipe MARTINS, Ambassadeur, Représentant permanent, Genève M. Amadeu de Jesus Leitão NUNES, Conseiller commercial, Mission permanente, Genève ARABIE SAOUDITE Mr. Saleh SHOAIB, Acting Commercial Attaché, Permanent Mission, Geneva ARGENTINE S.E. Sr. Roberto LAVAGNA, Embajador, Representante Permanente, Ginebra Sr. Alberto DUMONT, Ministro, Represantante Permanente Alterno, Ginebra Sra. Eduardo TEMPONE, Consejero, Misión Permanente, Ginebra Sra. Andrea REPETTI, Secretario de Embajada, Misión Permanente, Ginebra Sr. Roberto Sebastian BOSCH ESTEVEZ, Misión Permanente, Ginebra Sr. Gustavo Nerio LUNAZZI, Secretario de Embajada, Misión Permanente, Ginebra AUSTRALIE H.E. Mr. David SPENCER, Ambassador, Permanent Representative, Geneva Ms. Sonja WEINBERG, Executive Officer, Trade Negotiations Division, Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade Ms.
    [Show full text]
  • Sustainable Value Management: Leading Organizations for an Integrated Triple Bottom Line Marco Tavanti, Depaul University
    DePaul University From the SelectedWorks of Marco Tavanti 2010 Sustainable Value Management: Leading organizations for an integrated triple bottom line Marco Tavanti, DePaul University Available at: https://works.bepress.com/marcotavanti/9/ Marco TAVANTI DePaul University, Chicago, USA School of Public Service SUSTAINABLE VALUE MANAGEMENT – LEADING ORGANIZATIONS TOWARDS AN INTEGRATED BOTTOM LINE Summary. An organization without an integrated bottom line approach is not designed to last. Value management is the organizational glue which makes it possible to integrate financial sustainability with social responsibility and environmental concerns. This paper suggests sustainable value management in the context of recent developments in corporate social responsibility, sustainability and the triple bottom line. The author argues that economic, social, and environmental sustainability needs to be integrated into value-centered management. Sustainable value creation with leaders and managers leads to sustainable growth for 21st century managerial practices aiming to benefit both shareholders and stakeholders. Keywords: social responsibility, integrated bottom line, triple bottom line, sustainability ZARZĄDZANIE POPRZEZ WARTOŚCI – W KIERUNKU ROZWOJU ORGANIZACJI Streszczenie. Organizacja pozbawiona podejścia zintegrowanej linii przewodniej nie została zaprojektowana, by przetrwać. Zarządzanie wartością jest klejem organizacyjnym, który stwarza możliwości dla integracji równowagi finansowej ze społeczną odpowiedzialnością i troską o środowisko.
    [Show full text]
  • International Society for Environmental Ethics
    INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS NEWSLETTER _____________________________________________________ Volume 21, No. 1, Winter 2010 _____________________________________________________ GENERAL ANNOUNCEMENTS ISEE Membership: ISEE membership dues are now due annually by Earth Day—22 April—of each year. Please pay your 2010-2011 dues now if you have not already done so. You can either use the form on the last page of this Newsletter to mail check to ISEE Treasurer Marion Hourdequin, or you can use PayPal with a credit card from the membership page of the ISEE website at: <http://www.cep.unt.edu/iseememb.html>. ISEE at APAs: Please see the “Conferences and Calls” section of this Newsletter for calls for papers for the 2010 Eastern American Philosophical Association (APA) meeting on 27-30 December 2010 in Boston and the 2011 Pacific APA meeting on 20-23 April 2011 in San Diego. ISEE Sessions at the Upcoming APA, Pacific Division Meeting, Westin St. Francis, San Francisco, California, 31 March-3 April 2010: Wednesday, 31 March, 1800-2100: Topic: Environmental Metaphysics Chair: Geoffrey Frasz (College of Southern Nevada) Speakers: 1. Nathan Kowalsky (University of Alberta) “The Metaphysics of Crisis: Maintaining Moral Contingency in Environmental Philosophy” Commentator: John Basl (University of Wisconsin—Madison) 2. Bob Sandmeyer (University of Kentucky) “An Existential Interpretation of Aldo Leopold’s Concept of Land” Commentator: Dylan Trigg (University of Sussex) 3. Tim Christion (University of North Texas) “Nature’s Agency or Nature’s Response? What It Is for the Natural World to Relate to Us” Commentator: Avram Hiller (Portland State University) Friday, 2 April 1900-2200: Topic: Moral Responsibilities to Nature Chair: Christina M.
    [Show full text]
  • VI. the Sacred Sites of the Americas: Connecting the Subtle Knots
    VI. The Sacred Sites Of The Americas: Connecting The Subtle Knots All along history, people visit sacred sites from time to time. They may be under the rubric of pilgrimages or simply, a visit to a very special site. In some cases, these sacred sites may be temples, ruins, cemeteries, or just a part of nature (trees, mountains, rivers, rocks). These sites have a specific significance to those who make the effort to be there. These may be religious, spiritual, scientific or to reconnect with a non- material energy. There are important sacred sites all over the world. They are visited frequently and they represent a major source of tourism. What is important to know is that the sacredness of those sites is not only related to faith or a religious positioning, but many of these sites have a special rhythm and vibration, a unique energy, or simply a unique sensation people enjoy and get benefit from. The power of silence, for example, has attracted many people to these sacred sites. They visit them and spend a lot of time in prayer, contemplation, meditation, chanting or simply tapping on the power of their silence and the silence of others. These are spaces that have something special and one would greatly benefit from entering those spaces. Many members and volunteers associated with the Institute have been visiting sacred places all over the Planet (e.g., Portugal, France, Italy, Greece, Russia, Europe, USA, China, Tibet, Indonesia, Africa, Guatemala, Mexico, Brazil). The benefits from those sites come from a very specific way of carrying out the visits.
    [Show full text]
  • [ESSD] Day at the United Nations - New York - September 30, 1998 - General Correspondence
    THE WORLD BANK GROUP ARCHIVES PUBLIC DISCLOSURE AUTHORIZED Folder Title: Conferences and Seminars - Environmentally and Socially Sustainable Development Network [ESSD] Day at the United Nations - New York - September 30, 1998 - General Correspondence Folder ID: 1832591 Series: ESSD Vice President's conference attendance and participation Dates: 5/15/1998 - 9/25/1998 Fonds: Records of the Environmentally and Socially Sustainable Development Network ISAD Reference Code: WB IBRD/IDA 92 WBIBRD/IDA_92-03 Digitized: 8/31/2019 To cite materials from this archival folder, please follow the following format: [Descriptive name of item], [Folder Title], Folder ID [Folder ID], ISAD(G) Reference Code [Reference Code], [Each Level Label as applicable], World Bank Group Archives, Washington, D.C., United States. The records in this folder were created or received by The World Bank in the course of its business. The records that were created by the staff of The World Bank are subject to the Bank's copyright. Please refer to http://www.worldbank.org/terms-of-use-earchives for full copyright terms of use and disclaimers. THE WORLD BANK Washington, D.C. @ International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / International Development Association or The World Bank 1818 H Street NW Washington DC 20433 Telephone: 202-473-1000 Internet: www.worldbank.org PUBLIC DISCLOSURE AUTHORIZED ArG~i~w~i1832691 R2004-012 Othe#: 20 207HO Cornce and Senfnsr - EnvlronMWmay sad S04MOV Sutalnabit Devlopmt e ESSDI Day a the Unied Nations - New York - September 30, 1 M6- Geral World Bank at the United Nations From: Clare Fleming on 09/25/98 09:48 AM To: Nick Van Praag/Person/World Bank@WorldBank, Maria Elena Matheus-Atchley/PersonWorld Bank@WorldBank, M.
    [Show full text]