Investigation of Algal Blooms and Possible Controls for Cliff Pond, Nickerson State Park, Brewster, Massachusetts

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Investigation of Algal Blooms and Possible Controls for Cliff Pond, Nickerson State Park, Brewster, Massachusetts INVESTIGATION OF ALGAL BLOOMS AND POSSIBLE CONTROLS FOR CLIFF POND, NICKERSON STATE PARK, BREWSTER, MASSACHUSETTS BY WATER RESOURCE SERVICES, INC. JUNE 2014 IN COOPERATION WITH AQUATIC CONTROL TECHNOLOGY Contents Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................................... 1 Project Background and Need ...................................................................................................................... 3 Cliff Pond Features .................................................................................................................................... 3 Watershed Features .................................................................................................................................. 7 Designated Uses ........................................................................................................................................ 9 Rehabilitation Needs and Objectives ........................................................................................................ 9 Additional Data Needs ............................................................................................................................ 10 Study Approach and Methods .................................................................................................................... 10 Historic Data Review ............................................................................................................................... 10 Watershed Assessment........................................................................................................................... 10 In-Lake Investigations ............................................................................................................................. 11 Water Quality ...................................................................................................................................... 11 Sediment Assessment ......................................................................................................................... 11 Seepage Assessment ........................................................................................................................... 14 Water Depth Assessment ................................................................................................................... 16 Biological Assessments ....................................................................................................................... 16 Investigative Results ................................................................................................................................... 18 Historic Data Review ............................................................................................................................... 18 Watershed Assessment........................................................................................................................... 23 In-Lake Investigations ............................................................................................................................. 25 Bathymetric Assessment ..................................................................................................................... 25 Water Quality Data ............................................................................................................................. 25 Seepage Quantity Assessment ............................................................................................................ 35 Seepage Quality Assessment .............................................................................................................. 36 Sediment Distribution Assessment ..................................................................................................... 38 Sediment Quality Assessment............................................................................................................. 38 Aluminum Dose Testing ...................................................................................................................... 41 Plankton Analysis ................................................................................................................................ 42 Macrophyte and Mussel Analysis ....................................................................................................... 45 Fishery Assessment ............................................................................................................................. 45 Data Analysis and Interpretation ................................................................................................................ 48 Oxygen Demand ...................................................................................................................................... 48 Hydrologic Loading.................................................................................................................................. 50 Nutrient Loading ..................................................................................................................................... 52 Biological Status ...................................................................................................................................... 54 Diagnostic Conclusions ............................................................................................................................... 56 Management Options ................................................................................................................................. 60 Overview ................................................................................................................................................. 60 Oxygenation ............................................................................................................................................ 79 Phosphorus Inactivation ......................................................................................................................... 83 Conclusions and Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 84 References .................................................................................................................................................. 86 APPENDIX A. Monitoring Data for Cliff Pond .............................................................................................. 89 APPENDIX B: Calculations and Analyses ................................................................................................... 108 Tables Table 1. Locations of wastewater disposal facilities near Cliff Pond. .............................................................. 25 Table 2. Seepage measurements for Cliff Pond in 2013 ........................................................................................ 36 Table 3. Seepage quantity and quality for delineated shoreline segments ................................................... 37 Table 4. Results of sediment quality testing and aluminum dosing assays................................................... 40 Table 5. Fish captured by gear type in Cliff Pond, August 21, 2013 ................................................................. 46 Table 6. Average and range of length for fish captured in Cliff Pond, August 21, 2013 ........................... 47 Table 7. Oxygen demand in Cliff Pond .......................................................................................................................... 49 Table 8. Hydrologic load to Cliff Pond ........................................................................................................................... 51 Table 9. Nutrient loads to Cliff Pond .............................................................................................................................. 53 Table 10. Algae management options review ........................................................................................................... 61 Figures Figure 1. Cliff Pond and Nickerson State Park location on Cape Cod ................................................................. 4 Figure 2. Cliff Pond immediate area ................................................................................................................................. 5 Figure 3. Bathymetric map of Cliff Pond ........................................................................................................................ 6 Figure 4. Ground water contours on east Cape Cod (Cliff Pond shown as red square).............................. 7 Figure 5. Ground water contours and drainage boundary and surface water drainage boundary ...... 8 Figure 6. Erosion on slopes around Cliff Pond in 2013 ........................................................................................... 9 Figure 7. Map of water quality sampling stations .................................................................................................... 12 Figure 8. Map of sediment sampling stations ............................................................................................................ 13 Figure 9. Map of seepage stations ................................................................................................................................... 14 Figure 10. Map of littoral interstitial porewater sampling stations ................................................................
Recommended publications
  • January 2012 #119
    January 2012 #119 www.nemba.org SSingleingleTTrackS NEMBA, the New England Mountain Bike January 2012, Number 119 Association, is a non-profit 501 (c) (3) organi- zation dedicated to promoting trail access, maintaining trails open for mountain bicyclists, and educating mountain bicyclists to use these trails sensitively and responsibly. Cape Cod, Exit 7 SingleTracks is published six times a year by the Are your trails snowbound? Maybe it’s time for a New England Mountain Bike Association for road trip to Cape Cod. Willow Street, AKA, Exit 7 is the trail community. one of the best rides on the Cape. By Bill Boles. ©SingleTracks Editor & Publisher: Philip Keyes Contributing Writers: Bill Boles, Jeff Cutler, Thom Parsons 10 Cartoonist: Philippe Guillerm Copy Editor: Nanyee Keyes Executive Director: Philip Keyes [email protected] NEMBA 8 PO Box 2221 Acton MA 01720 Board of Directors Harold Green, President Adam Glick, Vice-President The Ultimate Road Trip Matt Schulde, Vice-President Anne Shepard, Treasurer Glenn and Paula’s excellent adventure took them on great sin- Tom Grimble, Secretary gletracks across the US of A, from Michigan to Park City. Read all about them! By Glenn Vernes and Paula Burton Rob Adair, White Mountains NEMBA Brian Alexander, CeMeNEMBA John Anders, Midcoast Maine NEMBA John Barley, White Mountains NEMBA Matt Bowser, Central NH NEMBA Eammon Carleton, BV NEMBA Matt Caron, Southern NH NEMBA SingleTracks Hey, get creative! We wel- Steve Cobble, SE MA NEMBA come submissions, photos and artwork. This is Leo Corrigan, RI NEMBA Peter DeSantis, Southern NH NEMBA your forum and your magazine. Be nice, and Adam Glick, Greater Boston NEMBA Paper Trail share! David Hughes, Carrabassett Region NEMBA On the Cover: Todd Swinton mountain biking Steve LaFlame, Central NH NEMBA Frank Lane, NS NEMBA Letters — 6 in the Fore River Sanctuary, Portland Maine.
    [Show full text]
  • Section 2. Shawme-Crowell State Forest
    Campers arriving at Shawme-Crowell. (See Appendix G for photo information.) SECTION 2. SHAWME-CROWELL STATE FOREST 2.1. INTRODUCTION Today, Shawme-Crowell is best known as a campground from which visitors explore Cape Cod Shawme-Crowell State Forest is located in the towns and southeastern Massachusetts. It is the only year- of Bourne and Sandwich, south of the Cape Cod round campground in the Nickerson Complex. Canal. (Figure 2.1) It is accessed via Route 130 in Sandwich. The forest’s physical, political, and regulatory attributes are summarized below. (Table 2.1.1) The history of Shawme-Crowell is one of early, rapid expansion followed by decades of reduction in Table 2.1.1. Physical, political, and regulatory settings of Shawme-Crowell State Forest. area. Acquisition of forest lands began in 1909 and Shawme State Forest, as it was then known, was Setting Name or Metric formally dedicated in 1922. By 1925 it had Location: Bourne, Sandwich a expanded to nearly 8,400 acres, making it the largest Area (acres) : 605.47 parcel of public land on Cape Cod at that time. The Perimeter (miles)a: 12.35 years leading up to World War II brought military Landscape Designation(s)b: Parkland training to the forest. Much of the forest’s acreage Legislative Districts: was eventually transferred to the Special Military House Fifth Barnstable Reservation Commission to create the Massachusetts Senate Plymouth and Barnstable Military Reservation, now called Joint Base Cape Regulatory Designations: Priority Habitat Cod. The construction of Route 6 and a variety of Old King’s Highway land transfers and easements for municipal and state Regional Historic District projects has reduced Shawme-Crowell to its current a.
    [Show full text]
  • White Pond As a Resource for All: a Vision for Water Quality, Usage and Sustainability
    White Pond as a Resource for All: A Vision for Water Quality, Usage and Sustainability Prepared by White Pond Advisory Committee Cheryl Baggen, Josh Galper, Beth Kelly, Jeff Parker Town of Concord, Massachusetts Discussion Draft for August 25, 2021 White Pond as a Resource for All 1 Table of Contents Executive Overview ............................................................................................................................. 3 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................... 4 Water Quality Management .............................................................................................................. 4 Water Quality Detection, Prevention and Control .................................................................... 8 People Management ............................................................................................................................ 9 Call to Action ....................................................................................................................................... 11 Appendix A: Guiding Principles ................................................................................................... 13 Appendix B: White Pond Testing and Water Level ................................................................ 13 Appendix C: Causes and Effects of Cyanobacteria Blooms ................................................... 16 Appendix D: Monitoring, Testing and Pond
    [Show full text]
  • OUR MISSION DCR’S Universal Access Program Is Dedicated to Providing Outdoor Recreation Opportunities in Massachusetts State Parks for Visitors of All Abilities
    DCR UAP Program Schedule Summer/FallAccess News 2019Page 1 OUR MISSION DCR’s Universal Access Program is dedicated to providing outdoor recreation opportunities in Massachusetts State Parks for visitors of all abilities. Accessibility is achieved through site improvements, specialized adaptive recreation equipment, and accessible recreation programs. Pre-registration is required for all programs. To pre-register, contact the providing organization. Get into the activity sooner by bringing your release form filled out: mass.gov/dcr/universal-access/release Our structured programs feature adaptive equipment, professional staff, and instruction and support. Friends, family, and companions are welcome to take part in our programs alongside participants with disabilities. Visit our website to keep up-to-date with our activities! mass.gov/dcr/universal-access Donations welcome! DCR’s Conservation Trust and Urban Parks Trust Fund accepts contributions to support and enhance outdoor recreation in Massachusetts for people of all abilities. Your tax-deductible donation will help provide access to our parks. Ask us about matching funds! To learn more, visit: mass.gov/dcr/universal-access/donate Checks should be made out to The Commonwealth of Massachusetts, noting that the funds are for the Universal Access Program (UAP), and sent to: DCR’s Universal Access Program P.O. Box 484 Amherst, MA 01004 Access News Page 2 Hiking program that travels around the state! Take a gentle hike with Stavros Outdoor Access. Date Location Adaptive equipment and staff assistance provided. June 20 George’s Island, Bring a lunch and enjoy nature activities, Boston Harbor scavenger hunts, letterboxing, and more. June 27 Great Brook Farm State Park, Carlisle Cost: $3/person, $12/family, $25/group July 11 Walden Pond State Reservation, Concord July 18 Mt.
    [Show full text]
  • Use of Thematic Mapper Imagery to Assess Water Quality, Trophic State, and Macrophyte Distributions in Massachusetts Lakes
    U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey Use of Thematic Mapper Imagery to Assess Water Quality, Trophic State, and Macrophyte Distributions in Massachusetts Lakes By MARCUS C. WALDRON, PETER A. STEEVES, and JOHN T. FINN (Department of Forestry and Wildlife Management, University of Massachusetts, Amherst) Water-Resources Investigations Report 01-4016 Prepared in cooperation with the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Management Northborough, Massachusetts 2001 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR GALE A. NORTON, Secretary U.S. GEOLOGICAL SURVEY Charles G. Groat, Director The use of trade or product names in this report is for identification purposes only and does not constitute endorsement by the U.S. Government. For additional information write to: Copies of this report can be purchased from: Chief, Massachusetts-Rhode Island District U.S. Geological Survey U.S. Geological Survey Branch of Information Services Water Resources Division Box 25286 10 Bearfoot Road Denver, CO 80225-0286 Northborough, MA 01532 or visit our web site at http://ma.water.usgs.gov CONTENTS Abstract ................................................................................................................................................................................. 1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Study Methods......................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • MDPH Beaches Annual Report 2008
    Marine and Freshwater Beach Testing in Massachusetts Annual Report: 2008 Season Massachusetts Department of Public Health Bureau of Environmental Health Environmental Toxicology Program http://www.mass.gov/dph/topics/beaches.htm July 2009 PART ONE: THE MDPH/BEH BEACHES PROJECT 3 I. Overview ......................................................................................................5 II. Background ..................................................................................................6 A. Beach Water Quality & Health: the need for testing......................................................... 6 B. Establishment of the MDPH/BEHP Beaches Project ....................................................... 6 III. Beach Water Quality Monitoring...................................................................8 A. Sample collection..............................................................................................................8 B. Sample analysis................................................................................................................9 1. The MDPH contract laboratory program ...................................................................... 9 2. The use of indicators .................................................................................................... 9 3. Enterococci................................................................................................................... 10 4. E. coli...........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • M & F WQTF Minutes
    Marine and Fresh Water Quality Task Force I Skaket Room, Orleans Town Hall January 9, 2017 10:00 AM t7 v Task Force Members attending: Carolyn Kennedy( chair), Judy Scanlon ( vice- chair), Mike Brink, Carol Etzold, Betsy Furtney( temp clerk). Also Charles Harris (Eastham) and Ed Maroney( Cape Cod Chronicle). ORLEANS Tuwk CLCRk Meeting called to order at 10: 15 AM 1 F B 21 : 11:P Minutes of December 19, 2016 were reviewed and final changes will be added for review and approval. e-4)) kat Proposed Revision of Charge: Proposal was reviewed, additional suggestions were provided. The Chair will revise the document and send out via email. She also provided a draft memo to BOS for transmittal of the proposal. Fresh Water Pond Data: Carolyn and Judy used Excel spreadsheets to input and display pond data from 16 ponds. These are being sent to Ed Eichner, Water Scientist, for his work with the Freshwater Ponds Management Planning Work Group. He will combine this data with the results of the chemical analyses done by SMAST and other labs to give an analysis of the health of each pond. This data will be used to prioritize ponds for future individual management plans. Carolyn led a discussion of the unusual factors that can affect individual ponds which included large populations of gulls and ducks being attracted to Crystal lake in the past, very cold groundwater in Boland Pond, and the growth of plants within ponds. Carol remarked that she had seen a Glacier Bay Presentation with excellent graphics that she thought might be useful for the display of pond data.
    [Show full text]
  • 2019 WATER HEALTH REPORT-Draft
    State of the Waters: Cape Cod 2019 Cape Cod Water Health Report State of the Waters: Cape Cod 2019 Cape Cod Water Health Report Association to Preserve Cape Cod October 1, 2019 Prepared by: Andrew Gottlieb, Jo Ann Muramoto, Ph.D., Jordanne Feldman, Bryan Horsley, Kristin Andres and Don Keeran 1. Introduction The State of the Waters: Cape Cod is an assessment of the Cape’s water quality, designed to help you understand the water quality problems that we face and the actions that are needed to address these problems. The Association to Preserve Cape Cod (APCC) launched this project in 2019 in order to answer the question: “How healthy are Cape Cod’s waters?” This website is the place to find out about the Cape’s water quality and what can be done to address water pollution and achieve clean water. For this multi-year project, APCC collected existing data on water quality on Cape Cod for the purpose of determining the health of Cape Cod’s waters. APCC evaluated water quality in coastal waters (saltwater), freshwater ponds and lakes, and public drinking water supplies. APCC used existing methods to score water quality and used the scores to distinguish between degraded surface waters where immediate action is needed to improve water quality vs. surface waters with acceptable quality where ongoing protection is needed to avoid any decline in quality. The results are summarized in this annual water health report. To guide public action, APCC prepared a Water Action Plan that contains recommendations for changes in policies, actions, and regulations to improve and protect our waters.
    [Show full text]
  • Outdoor Recreation Recreation Outdoor Massachusetts the Wildlife
    Photos by MassWildlife by Photos Photo © Kindra Clineff massvacation.com mass.gov/massgrown Office of Fishing & Boating Access * = Access to coastal waters A = General Access: Boats and trailer parking B = Fisherman Access: Smaller boats and trailers C = Cartop Access: Small boats, canoes, kayaks D = River Access: Canoes and kayaks Other Massachusetts Outdoor Information Outdoor Massachusetts Other E = Sportfishing Pier: Barrier free fishing area F = Shorefishing Area: Onshore fishing access mass.gov/eea/agencies/dfg/fba/ Western Massachusetts boundaries and access points. mass.gov/dfw/pond-maps points. access and boundaries BOAT ACCESS SITE TOWN SITE ACCESS then head outdoors with your friends and family! and friends your with outdoors head then publicly accessible ponds providing approximate depths, depths, approximate providing ponds accessible publicly ID# TYPE Conservation & Recreation websites. Make a plan and and plan a Make websites. Recreation & Conservation Ashmere Lake Hinsdale 202 B Pond Maps – Suitable for printing, this is a list of maps to to maps of list a is this printing, for Suitable – Maps Pond Benedict Pond Monterey 15 B Department of Fish & Game and the Department of of Department the and Game & Fish of Department Big Pond Otis 125 B properties and recreational activities, visit the the visit activities, recreational and properties customize and print maps. mass.gov/dfw/wildlife-lands maps. print and customize Center Pond Becket 147 C For interactive maps and information on other other on information and maps interactive For Cheshire Lake Cheshire 210 B displays all MassWildlife properties and allows you to to you allows and properties MassWildlife all displays Cheshire Lake-Farnams Causeway Cheshire 273 F Wildlife Lands Maps – The MassWildlife Lands Viewer Viewer Lands MassWildlife The – Maps Lands Wildlife Cranberry Pond West Stockbridge 233 C Commonwealth’s properties and recreation activities.
    [Show full text]
  • Little Cliff Pond, Brewster
    Little Cliff Pond, Brewster General Information Useful Links: Little Cliff Pond is a 36-acre natural kettlehole pond located within Nickerson State Park with a maximum depth of 37 feet and an average depth of 14 feet. Get your Fishing License In the past, it was also called Long Pond because of its long thin shape. Transparency is very good, extending to 18 feet, and the bottom is composed Freshwater Fishing of sand with mud present in the deeper areas. Aquatic vegetation is common particularly along the shoreline edges which are bordered with bullrushes. Trout Stocking Information The 1.3 miles of shoreline are wooded and undeveloped. The pond is does not stratify during the summer months and trout habitat is limited to spring Freshwater Sportfishing Awards areas. Program Recreational Access Nickerson State Park is located off of Route 6A, which can be reached from Exit 12 off Route 6. Little Cliff Pond is located between Cliff and Higgins Ponds. It can be reached by entering the park and taking a left onto Flax Pond Road. At the end of the road, Little Cliff is the small pond on the left (Cliff Pond is on the right). A paved ramp is suitable for launching cartop boats and light trailered craft. (70° 1'4.11"W 41°45'35.95"N). Parking is available at the ramp for approximately 6 cars with trailers. Please contact DCR for additional Learn more: information, fee structure, and/or restrictions pertaining to public access of Mass.gov/MassWildlife Little Cliff Pond. Connect with us: Fish Populations Facebook.com/MassWildlife The following fish species were found during MassWildlife surveys: Largemouth Bass, Smallmouth Bass, Brown Bullhead, Yellow Perch, Pumpkinseed, Golden Shiners, Banded Killifish, and Goldfish.
    [Show full text]
  • Ocm39986872-1951-HB-2127.Pdf (849.2Kb)
    HOUSE 2127 Che Commontocalth of Massachusetts SPECIAL REPORT I OF THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS ON SURVEYS OF THE GREAT PONDS OF THE COMMONWEALTH AND THE RIGHTS OF WAY THERETO Under Chapter 24 of the Resolves of 1960 December, 1950 I BOSTON WRIGHT & POTTER PRINTING CO., LEGISLATIVE PRINTERS 32 DERNE STREET 1951 C&e Commontuealtf) of 00assacljusett0 SPECIAL REPORT OF THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS ON SURVEYS OF GREAT PONDS OF THE COMMONWEALTH. I Department of Pddlic Works, 100 Nashua Street, Boston, December 28, 1950 To the Honorable Senate and the House of Representatives of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts In accordance with the provisions of chapter 24, Resolves of 1950, the Department of Public Works submits its report on its progress on making surveys and measurements of all ponds within the Commonwealth, which are or formerly were great ponds, including ponds whose area has been increased by artificial flowing, but in which is included in part a natural great pond. Chapter 24, Resolves of 1950, is as follows: Resolved, That the department of public works, acting through its division of waterways, shall proceed forthwith to make a survey and measurement of all ponds within the commonwealth which are or formerly were great ponds, including ponds whose area has been in- creased by artificial flowing but in which is included in part a natural great pond. Said department shall report to the general court on or before December thirty-first of the current year, giving the names and the locations of the ponds which have definitely been determined to be great ponds, and shall annually report on December thirty-first thereafter until the status of all ponds which are or may have been great ponds has been definitely established.
    [Show full text]
  • Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Report to the Senate and House of Representatives on Water Quality at Beach
    Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Report to the Senate and House of Representatives on water quality at beaches under the care and control of the Department of Conservation and Recreation This information is available in alternate format. Call Michelle Waters-Ekanem, Diversity Director, at 617-292-5751. TDD# 1-866-539-7622 or 1-617-574-6868 MassDEP Website: www.mass.gov/dep Printed on Recycled Paper Table of Contents Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................................... 1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................... 4 Methods ........................................................................................................................................................ 6 Yearly Beach Safety Scores ............................................................................................................................ 6 Overall Beach Safety Scores .......................................................................................................................... 7 Results ........................................................................................................................................................... 7 Metropolitan Boston Area Marine Beaches .................................................................................................. 8 Other Coastal Marine Beaches
    [Show full text]