City Council Agenda
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CHERRY HILLS VILLAGE COLORADO 2450 E. Quincy Avenue City Hall Cherry Hills Village, CO 80113 Telephone 303-789-2541 www.cherryhillsvillage.com FAX 303-761-9386 Parks, Trails and Recreation Commission Agenda Thursday, November 12, 2020 at 5:30 p.m. This meeting is being held electronically with no in-person attendance at City Hall. To provide oral comments during Audience Participation: Please email Parks & Recreation Coordinator Emily Black by 5:00 p.m. on Nov. 12th at [email protected] with your full name and home address. You will receive an email with the electronic meeting information. To watch the meeting (no participation): 1) City website – City Council Videos, Agendas, Packets, Minutes 2) City YouTube channel – City of Cherry Hills Village YouTube 1. Call to Order 2. Roll Call of Members 3. Audience Participation Period (limit 5 minutes per speaker) 4. Consent Agenda th a. Approval of Minutes – September 10 , 2020 th b. Approval of Minutes – October 8 , 2020 5. Unfinished Business a. PTRC Projects and Priorities List 6. New Business a. E-Bikes and Motorized Vehicles on Trails 7. Reports a. Chair b. Commissioners c. Staff i. December meeting ii. High Line Canal signs iii. Alan Hutto Memorial Commons policy 8. Adjournment Notice: Agenda is subject to change. If you will need special assistance in order to attend any of the City’s public meetings, please notify the City of Cherry Hills Village at 303-789-2541, 72 hours in advance. Minutes of the Parks, Trails & Recreation Commission of the City of Cherry Hills Village, Colorado Held on Thursday, September 10, 2020 at 5:30 p.m. at the City Center PARKS, TRAILS AND RECREATION COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING Chair Stephanie Dahl called the meeting to order at 5:33 p.m. ROLL CALL Chair Stephanie Dahl, Vice-Chair Fred Wolfe, Commissioners Rob Eber, Aron Grodinsky, and Chelsea Scott. Also present were Emily Black, Parks and Recreation Coordinator, Jay Goldie, Deputy City Manager and Director of Public Works, Jeff Roberts, Parks Operation Supervisor, and Pamela Broyles, Administrative Assistant Commissioner Tory Leviton attended virtually. Assistant City Attorney Randall Sampson attended virtually. Absent: Commissioner Kate Murphy. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The PTRC conducted the Pledge of Allegiance. AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION PERIOD Klasina Vanderwerf 5250 E. Chenango Avenue Ms. Vanderwerf stated that she is in favor of vacating the bridle path and right-of-way adjacent to 4501 South Vine Way and in favor of the dedication of the public trail easement on 4501 and 4505 South Vine Way. She shared that she served on the Parks and Trails Commission several years ago and also served as a City Council member. While on the Parks and Trails Commission, she walked the trail being considered for vacation and determined that it would take tremendous infrastructure and would be a difficult trail to do anything with. She said she walked the trail again in February 2020 and it was even more clear that due to erosion there is nothing left to make a trail connection. She expressed her belief that it would be a tremendous benefit for the City to get an off-street trail in exchange for vacating the current bridle path. She said the off- street trail provides a nicer experience with wonderful trees and getting off the street feels like you are more in nature. She said she hopes the Commission will approve the dedication. Parks & Trails Commission 09/10/2020 - 1 - Janney Carpenter 9 Random Road Ms. Carpenter stated that she is speaking to the Commission on behalf of the Cherry Hills Land Preserve. She said she and several people from the Land Preserve walked the trail and they are in favor of the proposed vacation and dedication as the existing trail has limited potential for connectivity. She said they believe the proposal to demolish the home and provide more open space in that neighborhood is a great opportunity for the community. The Land Preserve believes the path along the side of S. Vine Way creates an activity versus people just walking on the street, and it will be safer for little children who want to explore a more natural space that also creates a habitat for trees and wildlife. The Land Preserve also feels that it is a good deal financially for the City. Chris Bittman 4601 S. Vine Way Participated Virtually Mr. Bittman said he is speaking on behalf of the Cherrymoor HOA. He said he is directly impacted by the considered action as it relates to the petition. He referenced the letter from the HOA that states the board fully supports the first portion of the application to vacate the existing bridle path easement on the back of the property and supports the purchase of the property by the Armstrongs. He said the board does not support the creation of a new easement along South Vine Way as it would not be in keeping with the amended declarations and covenants and restrictions of Cherrymoor South. He referenced Section 4 of the HOA regulations and said the board is in agreement that the creation of a bridle path easement along the front of the property would remove any future residential status if that property were to ever be sold, therefore affecting the use and the value of that property. He said he has written his own letter in support of the vacation of the existing bridle trail and his opposition to the easement along Vine Way. He respectfully requested that the Commission acknowledge the concerns of the people most impacted and deny the proposed dedication. Kevin and Jennifer Allen 4502 S. Vine Way Participated Virtually Mr. Allen said that they fully support the vacation of the existing easement, but they do object to the creation of the new easement along the front of the property that creates an undue permanent burden on the property so it cannot be used the way it was intended under the covenants. The Allens respectfully requested that the Commission deny the easement along Vine Way. David Aspinwall 4401 S. Vine Way Participated Virtually Parks & Trails Commission 09/10/2020 - 2 - Mr. Aspinwall said that he is a direct neighbor to the property involved and he and his wife support everything except the placement of the trail along S. Vine Way. He expressed that the logical solution is to vacate Race Street and the existing bridle trail as the trail is not used and is not well maintained. He said there is probably a potential liability to the Village and by vacating the trail the Village is losing nothing. He expressed several concerns with the proposed bridle path on the east side of the property stating that it makes the Brega property unsalable if it ever has to be sold. He believes it also changes the character of the Cherrymoor neighborhood as there is no other trail that runs along a street in Cherrymoor. Mr. Aspinwall expressed concern that it also affects his property value because the trail would dead-end at the front side of his property on S. Vine Way. He pointed out that if the Armstrongs or whoever owns the property stops maintaining the trail, the City would have additional costs to take over maintenance. He said he understands that the City does not want to set a precedent by vacating a trail, but the difference is that this trail is never used. Be Aspinwall 4401 S. Vine Way Participated Virtually Ms. Aspinwall concurred with her husband’s previous comments. Mary Kay Waddington 1809 E. Tufts Avenue Participated Virtually Ms. Waddington said she disagrees with the comments that no one uses the proposed trail to be vacated. She said even though the trail dead ends, it is a lovely trail and she uses it a lot. She asked if it would be possible to create a short trail that goes up to Vine Way on the north side of 4501 S. Vine Way instead of vacating the trail. Chair Dahl thanked everyone for their public comment. CONSENT AGENDA Commissioner Aron Grodinsky moved, seconded by Vice-Chair Fred Wolfe to approve the following items on the Consent Agenda: 1. Approval of Minutes – August 13, 2020 The motion passed with 5 ayes and 1 abstention. NEW BUSINESS a. Vacation of the Bridle Path Easement and Right-of-Way Adjacent to 4501 S. Vine Way and Dedication of Non-Motorized Public Trail Easements on 4501 and 4595 S. Vine Way Parks & Trails Commission 09/10/2020 - 3 - Coordinator Black explained that the question before PTRC is whether PTRC will make a recommendation to the Planning and Zoning Commission to vacate a bridle path easement and right-of-way adjacent to 4501 S. Vine Way and dedicate a non-motorized public trail easement on 4501 and 4595 S. Vine Way. The Commission received the City’s municipal code that outlines the specific process for the vacation of right-of-way easements in their packets. Ms. Black noted that City Council considered this preliminary petition back in November 2019 and determined that it possessed sufficient merit to move forward. She said the City had now received a complete submittal from Charles Brega and Stanford and Vine, LLC and notice of this meeting was sent to every homeowner within 500 feet of the property. Coordinator Black reviewed the existing conditions for the Cherry’s Garden subdivision. She explained that the application for vacation requests vacation of both the Race Street right-of-way and the bridle path component of the bridle path, utility, and drainage easement on the west side of 4501 S. Vine Way. She said if the vacation of the right-of- way and bridle path easement is approved, the right-of-way will become part of the 4501 South Vine property and will be used for private purposes.