Injuries from Foul Balls, Broken Bats, and Railing Fall-Overs: Who Is Liable?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
$%&'()*+#,(-.#/-'0#1200+3#1(-4*%#125+3#2%6# 72)0)%8#/2009:;*(+<#=>-#)+#?)2@0*A# BCDD$/C7#1CC1CE# !"#$%&'()*$&+#(,-#&.(/#0(11&/#(/*2/&4567&8-16591#&52)-$5#/:&5;&2*6& <(/-(165#/:& $#/-1652,& ;$*8& ;1%52,& 0(/#0(11& 0(6/& (23& 0(/#0(11/& #26#$52,& 67#& /6(23/&(6&-258(,52(01#&/9##3/:&*$&#(,#$&/9#<6(6*$/&;(1152,&*"#$&67#&$(5152,/& 6$%52,&6*&<(6<7&(&/*-"#25$=&>7#&?1152*5/&.(/#0(11&@(<5156%&+5(05156%&A<6&(3B 3$#//#/&47*&5/&15(01#&47#2&67#/#&-2;*$6-2(6#&/56-(65*2/&*<<-$=&C*4#"#$:&67#& A<6&;(51/&6*&,5"#&<*2<$#6#&/(;#,-($3/&67(6&<*-13&0#&5891#8#26#3&52&9$*;#/B /5*2(1&0(/#0(11&/6(35-8/&6*&7#19&(11#"5(6#&/*8#&*;&67#&52)-$5#/&67(6&<*2652-#& 6*&*<<-$=&A33565*2(11%:&67#&A<6&;(51/&6*&,5"#&67*/#&-2;*$6-2(6#&"5<658/&*;&67#/#& 52)-$5#/&*$&<(/-(165#/&(&<1#($&53#(&(/&6*&47#2&67#%&4*-13&0#&/-<<#//;-1&52&(& 1#,(1&(<65*2&(,(52/6&67#&0(119($D=&E#B4$5652,&67#&?1152*5/&.(/#0(11&@(<5156%& +5(05156%&A<6&<*-13&8(D#&56&<1#($&6*&0*67&67#&"5<658/:&(/&4#11&(/&67#&0(119($D& 9#$/*22#1:&(/&6*&47(6&/(;#,-($3/&($#&$#F-5$#3&(6&67#&9$*;#//5*2(1&0(119($D/:& (/&4#11&(/&47*&5/&15(01#&47#2&52)-$5#/&3*&*<<-$=& & $F#########$DG7:HIJG$:D#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#!!! $$F########?$K$GCH#?$L1$?$GM#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#!N! $$$F######O$PG:7M#LDH#JOLDQCP#G:#GOC#QLKC#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#RS! $TF######PGLG$PG$JP#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#RU! TF#######DC=#TF#:?H#1L??VL7WP#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#RX! T$F####$DBI7$CP#GO7:IQO:IG#GOC#MCL7P#HIC#G:#PL/CGM#DCGP#LDH# GOC# 1L??VL7W#:=DC7P#V7CTL$?$DQ#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#R!! T$$F#####/LGL?$G$CP#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#NY! T$$$F###H$//C7CDG#PGLGC#7I?CP#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#NS! $ZF######DCGG$DQ<#=OLG#GOC#V?LMC7P#LDH#PVCJGLG:7P#GO$DW#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#NU! ZF########17:WCD#1LGPFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#N[! Z$F#######7L$?$DQ#OC$QOGP#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#N"! Z$$F#####=OLG#1L??VL7W#:=DC7P#L7C#JI77CDG?M#H:$DQ#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#N!! Z$$$F####JI77CDG#J?LPP#LJG$:D#?L=PI$G#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#NR! Z$TF####J:KK$PP$:DC7#JOLDQ$DQ#GOC#DCGG$DQ#7C\I$7CKCDGP#FFFFFFFFFFFF#NR! ZTF######J:DJ?IP$:D#FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#N]! & # # # E# G>*#2'5>-(#^-'06#0)4*#5-#5>2%4#>*(#>'+@2%63#H2;)63#,-(#>)+#+'__-(5#2%6#20^2`+# reminding her that “you can do anything you put your mind to.”#P>*#^-'06#20+-#0)4*#5-#5>2%4# >*(#.-.3#@(-5>*(+3#2%6#+)+5*(+3#2+#5>*`#2(*#@2+*@200#,2%+#2+#^*003#2%6#^)5>-'5#5>*.3#5>)+#L(5)a0*# ^-'06#%-5#>2;*#@**%#_-++)@0*F#?2+50`3#5>*#2'5>-(#^-'06#0)4*#5-#5>2%4#J-0*#H*102*`3#^>-#5-06# >*(#+>*#a-'06#^()5*#2@-'5#2%`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ose continued to say, “[z]>7%"A=4;A>"8;"2=85"3%7&9J" 4"@4;"58228;<"78<=2"2=>7>"%R>7"%F7"9F<%F2"A%F&9"7>4A2"'"'"'"'”D)"U%5>"A%;28;F>9" 2%"?>;28%;"2=42"@4;5"OF52"34;2"2%">;O%:"2=>"<4?>J"4;9"2=42"@4;5"38&&"A%;28;F>" " " " D0' 123'24'153627'829:'*59;<=>?7'%=94'.@459'A5;3B'%;4'C7'A9<:53'A24J"YZB+"[\F;>" !J" )SDP]J" =22K^__>5K;'<%'A%?_?&G_52%7:_`_89_DLS)DP)!_@4;N8;OF7>9N@>;34:NK47CNG>8;<N=82N K472NG7>22N&4378>NG7%C>;NG42'" " )0' (D0' " L0' (D0' " M'" a>;"-%5>;2=4&J"E)A'8?2759>F'A9<:53'A24'(3G=97'H<=?D'%2I5'A553'895I5345DJ" 6.b"ZB.-,Z"[\F;>"WJ")SDPJ"(^)L"Ec]J"=22K^__333'@%V5K%725'A%?_?&G_52%7:_G%52%;N7>9N5%VN @>;34:NK47CN?&GNG7%C>;NG42N8;OF7>9N@4;N54@>2:N;>228;<NS!SWDP'" " P'" YZB+J">=J92';%2>"D'" " !'" 142=>78;>"Z&%;C5;85J"8?2759>'#;J'E)A'@<9'!<4'$2:;3B'123'*2@547'E<95'*59;<=>?7J" ZH" +E,*.+" [EF<'" )MJ" )SDPJ" X^PL" Ec]J" =22K^__333'5G;428%;'A%?_)SDP_(_))_XDX))!X_?&GN @4;N54@>2:N;>228;<N9>27%82N28<>75NG%52%;N7>9N5%V'" " W0' (D0' " (0' (D0' " X0' (D0' " DS0' (D0' " DD'" 142=>78;>"Z&%;C5;85J"8?2759>'#;J'E)A'@<9'!<4'$2:;3B'123'*2@547'E<95'*59;<=>?7J" ZH" +E,*.+" [EF<'" )MJ" )SDPJ" X^PL" Ec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`@9-&KE&!"##_E& .((8abb1;19>;?)1b+*36b04(5?9*b!#C'A"""b;& & #K6( !76( & #M6( !76( & !"6( !76( & !#;& T0@90&S025/+*E&)89<('B@:>(D9('>87:EF('8=;>G(HI89A;<E&PJTD&]L@/;&!$E&!"##_E& .((8abb*68+;/);?)1b*68+b)(9b6()4-bcb5:b'KMM'MKb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land Athletics’ Ballpark.