DOCSLIB.ORG

Cardinal Pell Finishes Testimony on Abuse with Rebuttals, Regrets

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Cardinal Pell Finishes Testimony on Abuse with Rebuttals, Regrets Cardinal Pell finishes testimony on abuse with rebuttals, regrets By Catholic News Service SYDNEY – Cardinal George Pell wrapped up his evidence before Australia’s Royal Commission Into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, answering questions, rebutting accusations and expressing regret. In so doing, he faced questions from 11 different lawyers for various survivors and other parties to the proceedings, before finally being examined by his own lawyer. The March 3 session in Sydney began at 9 p.m. March 2 in Rome and lasted until 3 a.m. Cardinal Pell testified via video link from a hotel; doctors said he should not make the long flight to Australia because of a medical condition. Justice Peter McClellan, commission chair, kept lawyers on task as he tried to ensure everyone had an opportunity to question the cardinal, who now serves as prefect of the Vatican’s Secretariat for the Economy. Lawyers grilled Cardinal Pell on a range of matters such as alleged conversations occurring 30 or 40 years ago, including when he was a priest in the Diocese of Ballarat. Cardinal Pell responded to each question and accusation put to him, outlining reasons that a number of the claims were implausible. In a previous hearing, a witness with the pseudonym BWF had told the commission that one day after school, he rode his bicycle to the Ballarat cathedral rectory to see then-Father George Pell and tell him about the physical and sexual abuse being suffered by his brother at the hands of Christian Brother Edward Dowlan. BWF alleged that Cardinal Pell had reacted angrily and told him to return to school. In his testimony, Cardinal Pell showed that he had never lived at the cathedral rectory and had a full-time academic position at a college away from the cathedral, which kept him in the office until evening. “This is false evidence,” the cardinal said. “Even the language that I was alleged to have used is ridiculous. The suggestion that I would speak like that to a young person in distress is absolutely false.” Another witness with the pseudonym BWE had given evidence that, while serving as an altar boy for a funeral concelebrated by Cardinal Pell at the cathedral in September 1983, he had overheard him tell Father Frank Madden that Father Gerald Ridsdale had been “rooting” boys again. (“Rooting” is an Australian vulgar expression for sexual intercourse). However, Father Madden had already told the commission in previous evidence that, at the time, he was based in a parish more than 100 miles away and had a practice of not returning to his previous parish for funerals because it was the duty and privilege of the current pastor to minister to the flock in that area. Cardinal Pell’s lawyer also presented the cardinal’s diary entries for each of the days on which the cathedral records had indicated a funeral had been held, showing that the cardinal had other activities scheduled for those days. Cardinal Pell began his testimony Feb. 29. Earlier, lawyers for the commission called it “implausible” when the cardinal insisted that Melbourne archdiocesan education office staff had not briefed him on serious sexual and other misconduct. But Cardinal Pell’s lawyer reminded the commission of evidence given by the former director of education in the Archdiocese of Melbourne that he did not at any time approach Cardinal Pell or any auxiliary bishop about the matter, dealing only with then- Archbishop Frank Little and the vicar general. The final day of testimony also gave Cardinal Pell an opportunity to express some of his regret about the way matters were handled. In particular, he told the commission that he should have done more with a 1974 allegation by a student that Brother Dowlan had been “misbehaving with boys.” At the time, Cardinal Pell reported the matter to the school chaplain, who told him the Christian Brothers were aware and dealing with it. He conceded that his response was inadequate. In a poignant exchange, a lawyer for a victim abused in the confessional as a young girl told Cardinal Pell that her client had not entered a confessional since. Cardinal Pell said it was a great lament that the abuse had seen so many victims, their friends and families, and even the wider community lose their faith as a result of such experiences. Speaking to media at the conclusion of the commission hearings, Cardinal Pell said the hardest part of giving testimony had been revisiting the harrowing details of the abuse suffered by so many. Cardinal Pell then met with survivors of sexual abuse who traveled to Rome to watch him give evidence. He said he was working with them to try to arrange a meeting with Pope Francis before they left Rome. Also see: Interfaith and ecumenical delegation from Baltimore meets Pope Francis Copyright ©2016 Catholic News Service/U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Thank You Would All Parishioners, Especially LATE COMERS Please
    st MARIAN LINEN ROSTER : 21 April – P. Jacob RECENTLY DECEASED: Archbishop Frank Little, St. Mary’s Parish, 160 Foster St, Dandenong ALTAR SOCIETY: 18 th April – Group 3 Jan Deszcz, Crisanieto Ebuna and Sr Dominica. Postal Address: PO Box 22, Dandenong 3175 Telephone: 9791 4611 Fax: 9791 7119 ************ ANNIVERSARIES: Email [email protected] THANKSGIVING ENVELOPES: $2,166.00 Dora Philp, Jean Pascoe, Website: www. stmarysdandenong.org DIRECT DEBIT: $292.00 Jude Fernando, Gladys de Zoysa, Parish Priest: Father A. Guelen PRESBYTERY: $1,354.00 Winifred Jayaraja, Earl & Dorothy Maxwell, Pastoral Associate: Sister Margaret Fields OP Thank you Antonia & Marcelina Pereira and Andre Lazer. Polish Chaplain: Father Grzegorz Gawel SC Telephone: 9701 6071 SICK : Ken McIntyre, Alex Vecchio, Trish Sykes, Would all Parishioners, especially LATE COMERS Parish Secretaries: Mrs Jocelyn Kennedy please observe all regulations re parking, and Ruby Carroll, Seevali Kalansuriya and Laura Mrs Fay Gubbels respect all : No Parking” signs. Health Potter. Office Hours: Monday to Friday 9.30am – 4.00pm. The privacy legislation requires us to have written permission by an regulations require ample access for Ambulance Authorised person before any name can be printed in the Marian St. Mary’s Primary School New St, Dandenong: Telephone: 9791 7650 World Youth Day Cross and Icon will arrive at Raffle to Support World Youth Day Parish Principal: Mr Greg White Dandenong Station on Monday, 5 th May at Committee 5.30pm. Please return sold books. Only 50 tickets left St. John’s Regional College Caroline St, Dandenong: Telephone 9791 3366 Thank you for your support. Principal: Mr Patrick Power THERE WILL BE NO 5.30PM MASS TODAY SUNDAY, 13 TH APRIL.
    [Show full text]
  • Casts out Fear" from 1 John 4:18
    ECUMENICAL BULLETIN ISSUED BY THE ECUMENICAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION OF THE ARCHDIOCESE OF MELBOURNE, 406 ALBERT ST., EAST MELBOURNE, 3002. TEL. (03) 662 1962 No. 11 APRIL-MAY, 1988. 1988 Week of Prayer for Christian Unity - May 15-22 Our Annual Week of Prayer begins on Sunday, May 15 and ends on Pentecost Sunday, May 22 . Many Parishes have prayer services. This year's theme is ·"Love Casts Out Fear" from 1 John 4:18. Liturgy leaflets with appropriate prayer, readings and further suggestions, are available from our office on Wednesdays, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Tel. 662 1962 or by mail order from : ECUMENICAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION , P.O. BOX 146, EAST MELBOURNE, 3002. We invite every Melbourne parish and liturgy committee to insert Ecumenical Prayer into daily and Sunday liturgies. The leaflet gives a penitential prayer, a profession of faith and a litany. The only place in Italy where the Catholic and Protestant communities have been living side by side for centuries, is where the material for this year's Week of Prayer for Christian Unity originated. The initial preparation of the material was done by the local Roman Catholic/Waldensian group in the region of Pinerolo (Turin, Italy) . Out of their own experiences the people of that region know that one of the most important tasks of the ecumenical movement is to reconcile Christians through the force of God 's love , and this is reflected in the theme chosen for this year­ "The love of God casts our fear". In their material fo r the Week of Prayer for Christian Unity those focal; communities challenge us noHV> be satfsfied with a mere ecumenica l facade, but to seek to tackle as frankly as possible the fundamental problems of theology and ecclesio logy.
    [Show full text]
  • The Vineyard
    THE VINEYARD Congregation of the Blessed Sacrament Australia Province of the Holy Spirit June 2018 ST FRANCIS’ PASTORAL CENTRE SILVER JUBILEE: 1993 - 2018 Perhaps it was the sadness of Pat Negri’s second to see a parallel with biblical stories of barren anniversary on February 7 that diverted every- couples divinely blessed with offspring late in life. one’s attention. Whatever the reason, no-one If the difficult conception and birth of the Pastoral seems to have noticed that another and much Centre deserves documentation, so too does its happier anniversary fell on the very same day: development from infancy through to its present the silver jubilee of the St Francis’ Pastoral maturity, but for now a brief sketch will have to Centre. It was on the 7th February 1993 that the suffice. First a word about personnel. Apart from Archbishop of Melbourne, Frank Little, declared some temporary interludes, three women in the newly completed St Francis’ Pastoral Centre succession have overseen the activities of the open. Centre. Barbara Marron blazed the pioneering trail; Sr Bernadette Clear LCM consolidated the Centre’s operation; and Sharma Saunders has built further on her predecessors’ foundations. The Archbishop of Melbourne, Frank Little, at the opening of the St Francis’ Pastoral Centre in 1993. The story of the Centre’s conception and birth is told concisely in Damien Cash’s magisterial history of the Province, The Road to Emmaus.i It could be summed up even more briefly. The Centre was born from the cross-fertilisation of two powerful desires. One was the Province’s wish for a reliable income stream to support the Congregation’s mission in Australia, India, Sri Lanka and beyond.
    [Show full text]
  • Catholic Archdiocese of Melbourne Media Release –Tuesday 8 April 2008
    CATHOLIC ARCHDIOCESE OF MELBOURNE MEDIA RELEASE –TUESDAY 8 APRIL 2008 VALE ARCHBISHOP FRANK LITTLE DD KBE The former Catholic Archbishop of Melbourne Thomas Francis Little died peacefully in his sleep last night at his home in Camberwell at the age of 82 years. He was appointed the sixth Archbishop of Melbourne by Pope Paul VI, succeeding Cardinal Knox on the 1 July 1974. He resigned from the position in 1996 for health reasons. He is predeceased by his parents Gerald and Kathleen (nee McCormack) and his brother Jack and is survived by his brother Gerald. He was a passionate supporter of the Essendon Football Club. Melbourne’s Catholic Archbishop Denis Hart said today that the death of Archbishop Little will be felt deeply by many people in Melbourne. “Archbishop Little will be fondly remembered as a dedicated caring leader of the Church for 22 years,” Archbishop Hart said today. “His sincere pastoral style and concern for his people was admired by all who met him.” Archbishop Little was born in Werribee on 30 November 1925. He entered Corpus Christi College, then at Werribee, in 1943 to begin studies for the priesthood. In 1947, he continued his studies at Propaganda Fide College, Rome, and was ordained to the priesthood in the chapel of the College on 3 October 1950, by Cardinal Fumasoni Biondi. For the next three years he pursued his doctoral studies through the Urban University in Rome and was awarded his doctorate in 1953. On his return to Melbourne in 1953 he was appointed as assistant priest to Carlton, then assistant at St Patrick's Cathedral in 1955.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix 7 - No 1: the Price of Battling Paedophilia Date September 17, 2012
    Appendix 7 - No 1: The price of battling paedophilia Date September 17, 2012 3 reading now Read later Barney Zwartz Former teacher Graeme Sleeman lost his career, health and financial security when he took a stand against a sexually abusive priest in Doveton. Graeme Sleeman. Photo: Penny Stephens GRAEME Sleeman knew Peter Searson was trouble even before Searson arrived as parish priest of Doveton in 1984. Searson liked to dress in military fatigues, often carried a revolver, and had a bad reputation when it came to money - and sexually abusing children. The two locked horns immediately when Sleeman, principal of the Holy Family school, told the priest he knew of his reputation and would be watching him, and Searson replied that as priest he was the boss. Their main battleground was bizarre: the sacred Catholic sacrament of confession, where Searson could get the children alone and unsupervised. "I was concerned about his addiction to confession," Sleeman recalls. Peter Searson (bottom row, second from right) and Carmel Rafferty (top row, second from right). "Sometimes he would get children to sit on his lap, or kneel between his legs." Later he would help a church investigation into two sexual assaults during confession. Advertisement Sleeman was a respected educator and a devout Catholic. The latter cost him his career, his health and economic security for his family, as he sought to protect the children under his charge from a predatory priest while also trying to protect the good name of the church. When Sleeman resigned as principal in 1986 in a vain bid to force the church and Catholic Education Office (CEO) to act against Searson, he was besieged by media wanting to know about the priest's behaviour.
    [Show full text]
  • 2015 Journal
    Journal of the Australian Catholic Historical Society Volume 36 2015 1 Bob Reece, The Invincibles: New Norcia’s aboriginal cricketers 1879-1906, reviewed by Rosa MacGinley, p 287 Odhran O’Brien, Martin Griver Unearthed reviewed by Clement Mulcahy, p 285 Wanda Skowronska, Catholic Converts Roy Williams, Post-God Nation?, from Down Under … And All Over, reviewed by James Franklin, p 308 reviewed by Robert Stove, p 301 2 Journal Editor: James Franklin ISSN: 0084-7259 Contact General Correspondence, including membership applications and renewals, should be addressed to The Secretary ACHS PO Box A621 Sydney South, NSW, 1235 Enquiries may also be directed to: [email protected] Executive members of the Society President: Dr John Carmody Vice Presidents: Prof James Franklin Mr Geoffrey Hogan Secretary: Dr Lesley Hughes Treasurer: Ms Helen Scanlon ACHS Chaplain: Fr George Connolly Cover image: Archbishop Mannix makes a regular visit to the Little Sisters of the Poor hostel for the aged, 1940s. Original image supplied by Michael Gilchrist. See book reviews, p 289 3 Journal of the Australian Catholic Historical Society Volume 36 2015 Contents Julia Horne, Political machinations and sectarian intrigue in the making of Sydney University. 4 Peter Cunich, The coadjutorship of Roger Bede Vaughan, 1873-77. 16 Cherrie de Leiuen, Remembering the significant: St John’s Kapunda, South Australia .......................................................43 Lesley Hughes, The Sydney ‘House of Mercy’: The Mater Misericordiae Servants’ Home and Training School,
    [Show full text]
  • Pell, Hart Were Leaders in Addressing Child Sex Abuse
    KL Pell, Hart were leaders in addressing child sex abuse Gerard Henderson Published: June 4, 2013 - 12:14PM Cardinal George Pell in Sydney and Archbishop Denis Hart in Melbourne have become public targets for criticism concerning sexual abuse by priests and brothers within the Catholic Church in Australia. The evidence suggests that paedophiles have been active in religious and secular institutions and elsewhere over the years, particularly between the 1950s and the 1980s. The situation within the Catholic Church has been particularly serious. During their recent appearances before the Victorian parliamentary inq uiry into child abuse, Pell and Hart were subjected to hectoring by some parliamentarians, along with occasional demonstrations and generally hostile media coverage, particularly on the ABC and in The Age . Yet it appears they were among the first Catholic leaders in the world to address the issue in a serious way. A lot of the commentary on this issue has been replete with an ignorance as to how the Catholic Church operates by those who should know better. For example, on ABC1's News Breakfast last week Way ne Chamley of Broken Rites said the Church "runs on anarchy". It doesn't. Last July, the Four Corners program ''Unholy Silence'', by Geoff Thompson and Mary Ann Jolley, failed to make the point that Pell is not responsible for archdioceses or dioceses othe r than his own. Each bishop reports direct to the Pope in what is an authoritarian structure. More seriously, Four Corners refused to run Pell's comment to this effect, either in the program itself or in the extended interview which is on the Four Corners website.
    [Show full text]
  • Nation's Bishops Arrive for Golden Tribute Catholic Bishops From
    Nation's Bishops Arrive for Golden Tribute Catholic bishops from across the nation have begun arriving in Adelaide for tomorrow's tribute to Adelaide's Archbishop Leonard Faulkner. Twenty four bishops and 109 priests from all corners of Australia will celebrate a golden anniversary for Archbishop Faulkner in St Francis Xavier's Cathedral at 10:30am. The Mass will celebrate a significant milestone in the life of Adelaide's Catholic community - the 50th anniversary of Archbishop Faulkner's ordination as a priest in Rome on January 1, 1950. The Apostolic Nuncio, Archbishop Francesco Canalini, who is the Vatican's official representative in Australia, will concelebrate the Mass with the Australian bishops, including the Archbishop of Melbourne, Perth and Canberra/Goulburn. Bishop Eugene Hurley, Bishop of Port Pirie, and many priests from his diocese, will also attend. In an act which represents the continuity and harmony of the leadership of the Adelaide church, the homily will be delivered by Archbishop James Gleeson, Emeritus Archbishop of Adelaide - who retired from his active leadership role when Archbishop Faulkner was appointed Archbishop of Adelaide in 1985. A full list of bishops attending is below. As always, members of the public are welcome to attend the Mass, irrespective of religious belief. Media attendance at the Mass is welcome, but please respect the integrity of the occasion. Media inquiries to Matthew Abraham on 08 8210 8117 or 0418 822 924 Bishops Attending:Archbishop Leonard Faulkner, Archbishop of AdelaideHis Excellency
    [Show full text]
  • Ecumenical Bulletin
    ECUMENICAL BULLETIN ISSUED BY THE ECUMENICAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION OF THE ARCHDIOCESE OF MELBOURNE, 406 ALBERT ST., EAST MELBOURNE, 3002. TEL.(03) 9662 1962 PRINT POST PUBLICATION No.PP381667/00474 No. 43, SEPTEMBER, 1996. ARCHBISHOP LITTLE: THANKYOU The Ecumenical Affairs Commission of the Catholic Relations. He has often attended the many Synods or Archdiocese of Melbourne is now thirty years old. Most of Assemblies or Anniversaries of other Churches and has those years have linked it with Archbishop Little. As Dean always been present when visiting dignitaries of other of St Patrick's Cathedral and later as an auxiliary Bishop of churches are here. And credit for the setting up of the Heads the Archdiocese he took and active interest in Ecumenism of Churches meetings must go jointly to him and to his close and hence in the work of our Commission. And for twenty friend the late Archbishop Frank Woods. two years, as Archbishop, he has been an enthusiastic leader The writer of the history of the Melbourne Ecumenical in the ecumenical field. The various significant events in the Commission, Sister Mary Lou Moorhead, made the com­ life of our Commission reflect this interest, and it is suffi­ ment that "perhaps the most notable success (of the cient to name a few such as the entry of the Archdiocese into Commission) is in the area of friendship". Archbishop Little Membership of the Victorian Council of Churches, the annu­ has been the one who has fostered and maintained that al Summer School on Ecumenism, the service of welcome friendship by the leadership he has given based on his own for the Archbishop of Canterbury in St Patrick's Cathedral enthusiasm for the bringing about of unity of Christians.
    [Show full text]
  • The Church in Springtime
    The Church in Springtime Remembering Catholic Action 1940–1965 Helen Praetz, Editor 1 Copyright © Helen Praetz 2011 3 Melville Lane, Brighton, Victoria 3186, Australia All rights reserved. Apart from any use permitted under the Copyright Act, no part may be reproduced by any process, or any other exclusive right exercised, without the permission of the copyright owner. These transcriptions have been typed from the recordings of interviews. I cannot guarantee their complete accuracy because of the possibility of mishearing and occasional difficulties in identifying speakers. I have deleted those repetitions and hesitations that are not necessary for meaning. The interviews, from which these transcriptions have been made, constitute an oral archive deposited in the Melbourne College of Divinity Research Repository. Readers are urged to listen to the contributors’ voices, which give added vitality to their words. 2 Contents Preface 9 1 Frank Maher 14 Paul Maher’s memories of his father, Frank Maher 14 Campion Society (CS) 14 Rural movements 15 Catholic Action and Santamaria 16 Later life 16 2 Max Charlesworth 17 Distributism 17 Anti-Communism 17 Santamaria 18 Rural cooperatives 19 The Spanish Civil War 19 The Catholic Worker (CW) 19 Catholic Action 19 Clergy 20 3 Frank Keating 21 Jack Keating’s memories of his father, Frank Keating 21 An anomaly 21 The Catholic Worker (CW) 21 Friendship with Arthur Calwell 22 The Groupers 22 Frank’s wife 23 What went wrong with the Movement? 23 Source of ideas 24 Part 2 24 An interesting character 25 Cooperative
    [Show full text]
  • Alumni Times April 2018
    Alumni Issue Times April 2018 Nuns from the Religious Order of the Sacred Heart arrive at Christ the King. Circa 1965. IN THIS ISSUE Buildings & Facilities Update From the Principal In the Media Looking Back Alumni Profile: Where are they now? College News The Last Word Mary, Mother of From the Principal the Church Welcome to this edition of Alumni Times. the foundress of the Religious Sisters and Our alumni community continues to grow of the Sacred Heart. each year and it’s important we continue Our College has continued to improve its The Monday after Pentecost to celebrate your contributions, as well as share with you what we’ve been up to. results over the years and I am grateful Pope Francis has proclaimed the to the hardworking staff at this College new feast of “the Blessed Virgin Caroline Chisholm Catholic College who have ensured that our last five years Mary, Mother of the Church” on the continues to grow and change – you have seen the biggest consistent growth Monday following Pentecost. The feast would expect this of any school. As for Caroline Chisholm Catholic College. encourages the growth of the maternal Principal, I am well aware of the legacy of We are inspired to work harder because of sense of the church in the pastors, our fine College and it is never far from these results. religious and faithful, as well as a my mind. growth of genuine Marian piety. We recently received the news that Sister Median Better Year Study Education McGivern passed away at the age of 100.
    [Show full text]
  • In Today's Round of Hearings for the Royal Commission Into Institutional
    In today’s round of hearings for the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, the Commission heard from Assistant Commissioner Stephen Fontana and began the second- round of evidence from Bishop Peter Connors. Testimony of Assistant Commissioner Stephen Fontana Assistant Commissioner Fontana has been with Victoria Police since 1975. His testimony was aimed at providing a description of policies and procedures of Victoria Police based on the documents he had reviewed and his experience of investigations, including investigations of Priests. It was not based on his personal experience of any of the cases discussed in evidence. In relation to the Searson matter, Assistant Commissioner Fontana discussed the various reports from Victoria Police. In relation to previous evidence from survivor Julie Stewart, who testified that she had been interviewed by Constable Ben Condon alone, Assistant Commissioner Fontana said it would be very unusual that this interview would have been conducted by a sole Police officer, particularly one with the rank of probationary constable (as Condon had at the time.) He said that he disagreed with the conclusion in the reports that no offences were disclosed during the investigation, because he considered Searson’s conduct to be indecent. Assistant Commissioner Fontana explained that the Child Exploitation Unit was very small and relatively new division, so possibly lacked the expertise necessary to fully investigate the matter. He also said that the gravity of the crime, the likelihood of successful prosecution and the wishes of the parents were taken into account when dealing with cases involving child witnesses. Assistant Commissioner Fontana recalled that the Senior Constable who investigated the knife incident described Searson as “the coolest and the most polished suspect” he had ever interviewed.
    [Show full text]