Agenda Reports Pack (Public) 23/05/2012, 10.00
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SCRUTINY COMMITTEE Wednesday, 23rd May, 2012 10.00 am Darent Room, Sessions House, County Hall, Maidstone AGENDA SCRUTINY COMMITTEE Wednesday, 23rd May, 2012, at 10.00 am Ask for: Anna Taylor Darent Room, Sessions House, County Telephone: 01622 694764 Hall, Maidstone Membership Conservative (7): Mr R F Manning (Chairman), Mr B R Cope, Mr D A Hirst, Mrs S V Hohler, Mr R A Marsh, Mr J E Scholes and Mr C T Wells Liberal Democrat (1): Mrs T Dean Labour (1) Mr G Cowan Independent (1) Mr R J Lees Church Dr A Bamford, The Reverend N Genders and Mr A Tear Representatives (3): Parent Governor (2): Mr P Myers and Mr B Critchley Refreshments will be available 15 minutes before the start of the meeting Timing of items as shown below is approximate and subject to change. County Councillors who are not Members of the Committee but who wish to ask questions at the meeting are asked to notify the Chairman of their questions in advance. Webcasting Notice Please note: this meeting may be filmed for live or subsequent broadcast via the Council’s internet site – at the start of the meeting the Chairman will confirm if all or part of the meeting is being filmed. By entering the meeting room you are consenting to being filmed and to the possible use of those images and sound recordings for webcasting and/or training purposes. If you do not wish to have your image captured then you should make the Clerk of the meeting aware. UNRESTRICTED ITEMS (During these items the meeting is likely to be open to the public) A - Committee Business A1 Introduction/Webcast announcement A2 Substitutes A3 Election of Vice Chairman A4 Declarations of Interests by Members in items on the Agenda for this Meeting A5 Minutes of the meeting held on 29 March 2012 (Pages 1 - 2) B - Any item placed on the agenda by any Member of the Council for discussion B1 Hawkinge Household Waste Recycling Centre Consultation (Pages 3 - 106) Item from Ms Carey Following Cabinet’s agreement to proposals set out in a report on 19 March 2012 Mr Sweetland took a decision on 3 April 2012 to agree changes to both the operating policy and the network infrastructure of the Household Waste Recycling Centres provided by Kent County Council, this included the closure of the Hawkinge household waste recycling centre. Ms Carey has indicated that she wishes to raise the following points: 1. Out of date figures were being used; 2. Hawkinge is the only site not open at weekends; 3. No statistical information was available as to the number of users; 4. The figures quoted by way of savings appear to include costs which would be transferred to alternative sites upon closure; and 5. The public questionnaire was biased in the way Hawkinge was referred to. EXEMPT ITEMS (At the time of preparing the agenda there were no exempt items. During any such items which may arise the meeting is likely NOT to be open to the public) Peter Sass Head of Democratic Services (01622) 694002 Tuesday, 15 May 2012 Please note that any background documents referred to in the accompanying papers maybe inspected by arrangement with the officer responsible for preparing the relevant report. This page is intentionally left blank Agenda Item A5 KENT COUNTY COUNCIL SCRUTINY COMMITTEE MINUTES of a meeting of the Scrutiny Committee held in the on Thursday, 29 March 2012. PRESENT: Mr B R Cope, Mr G Cowan, Mrs T Dean, Mr D A Hirst, Mrs S V Hohler, Mr R F Manning, Mr R A Marsh, Mr J R Bullock, MBE (Substitute for Mr J E Scholes) and Mr M J Jarvis (Substitute for Mr C T Wells) ALSO PRESENT: Mrs P A V Stockell IN ATTENDANCE: Mr P Sass (Head of Democratic Services) UNRESTRICTED ITEMS 1. Membership (Item 1) The Committee noted its Membership as set out on the agenda. 2. Election of Chairman (Item 3) (1) Mr G Cowan proposed and Mrs T Dean seconded that Mrs T Dean be elected Chairman. On being put to the vote this proposal was lost. (2) Mr D A Hirst proposed and Mr B R Cope seconded that Mr R F Manning be elected Chairman. On being put to the vote this proposal was carried. (3) RESOLVED that Mr R F Manning be elected Chairman of the Committee. Page1 1 This page is intentionally left blank Page 2 Agenda Item B1 By: Peter Sass: Head of Democratic Services To: Scrutiny Committee – 23 May 2012 Subject: Hawkinge Household Waste Recycling Centre Consultation Background (1) Following Cabinet’s agreement to proposals set out in a report on 19 March 2012 Mr Sweetland took a decision on 3 April 2012 to agree changes to both the operating policy and the network infrastructure of the Household Waste Recycling Centre provided by Kent County Council, this included the closure of the Hawkinge household waste recycling centre. (2) In accordance with the terms of reference of the Scrutiny Committee, Ms Carey has exercised her right to place the issue of the consultation undertaken in relation to the decision to close the Hawkinge household waste recycling centre on the agenda of the Scrutiny Committee. (3) Any Member has a legal right to place an item on the Scrutiny Committee agenda. In this case, Mr Sweetland’s decision is not being ‘called in’ and therefore its implementation cannot be delayed or overturned by it being placed on the Scrutiny Committee agenda. The Committee may decide, however, to make comments or recommendations to the Cabinet Member for his consideration and response. Documents (4) The Chairman has determined that the following reports be attached: • Decision report attached at Appendix A. • Cabinet Report attached at Appendix B. • Public Consultation Report attached at Appendix C. • Equalities Impact Assessments attached at Appendix D. Guests (5) Mr B Sweetland, Cabinet Member, Environment, Highways and Waste has been invited to attend the meeting for this item. Page 3 Options for the Scrutiny Committee (6) The Scrutiny Committee may: (a) make no comments (b) express comments but not require reconsideration of the decision Contact: Anna Taylor Tel: 01622 694764 Page 4 Appendix A Page 5 Page 6 Page 7 Page 8 Appendix B By: Bryan Sweetland, Cabinet Member for Environment, Highways and Waste Mike Austerberry, Corporate Director, Enterprise and Environment To: Cabinet 19 March 2012 Subject: Review of Household Waste Recycling Centres and Future Service Delivery For Decision Classification: Unrestricted Summary: This report sets out the findings of the Review of the Household Waste Recycling Centres (HWRCs) in Kent and recommends changes to the way the sites are to be operated and provided. 1. Introduction and Review Process 1.1 On 8th April 2011 the Environment Highways and Waste Policy Overview and Scrutiny Committee (POSC), agreed the terms of reference of a review of the Household Waste Recycling Centre (HWRC) service. The POSC agreed that an Informal Member Group (IMG) should guide the review. The Informal Member Group comprised: Councillors John Cubitt (chair), Mike Harrison, Steve Manion, Malcolm Robertson, and Elizabeth Tweed 1.2 The Informal Members Group reported the review findings back to POSC on 27 September 2011. The Committee supported the findings and referred the matter for public consultation. The report from the Informal Members Group considered in detail the options for change relating to the operating policy of the sites and the household waste recycling centre network. The financial implications of the changes were confirmed as being consistent with the medium term financial plan and the current capital programme. It was resolved that the recommendations of the Informal Members Group were supported. Page 9 1.3 Following the end of the public consultation on 9 February 2012, the Informal Members’ Group met on 21 February 2012 to consider the outcomes, which have led to the recommendations in this report. 1.4 This decision report is structured as follows. Section Heading Page No. 1 Introduction and Review process 1 2 Current arrangements 2 3 Public Consultation & Equalities Impact 4 Assessment 4 HWRC: Operating policy 4 5 HWRC: Current network provision 9 6 HWRC: Future network provision 13 7 Operational Risk Management 18 8 Financial Considerations 19 9 Recommendations 19 2. Current arrangements 2.1 As the waste disposal authority for Kent, Kent County Council has a statutory obligation under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 “for places to be provided at which persons resident in its area may deposit their household waste and for the disposal of waste so deposited”. There is no duty to receive trade waste and the household waste recycling centres are not licensed to do so. 2.2 The Act does not specify how many sites, the ratio of sites to households, or travel times. Most of the population of Kent is within a 20 minute drive of a HWRC. 2.3 Kent has 19 HWRCs, of which 6 are co-located with waste transfer stations. The sites are located largely as a reflection of historic factors, particularly in respect of those locations which are associated with closed landfill sites. Their distribution does, however, broadly reflect the centres of population in the county. 2.4 Map 1 below shows the network of transfer stations and household waste recycling centres across Kent with drive times. Page 10 Page 11 Map 1: Location of Household Waste Recycling Centres and Waste Transfer Stations, including journey times. 3. Public Consultation and Equalities Impact Assessment 3.1 Following the POSC meeting on 27 September 2011, a 10 week public consultation commenced on 1 December 2011 and ran until 9 February 2012 on options for change.