Antarctic Science 8 (2): 147-154 (1996)

Biomass allocation in a clonal ( magellanica) u nd e r grazi n g by introduced rei n dee r

JON MOENl and DAVID W.H. WALTONl 'Department of Ecological Botany, Umed University, S-901 87 Umed, Sweden e-mail: [email protected] 'British Antarctic Survey, Natural Environment Research Council, High Cross, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 OET, UK

Abstract: Biomass allocation and growth by the clonal plant Acaena magellanica were characterized for three populations grazed by introduced reindeer on the subantarctic island of South Georgia. Annual growth markers (internode lengths) were used to divide each rhizome into current year's shoots, one-year-old and two- year-old rhizome segments. Total dry weights were significantly smaller in grazed than in ungrazed populations. Leaf biomass of current year's shoots was very much lower in grazed shoots. Rhizome length and number of leaves were less affected than dry weight by grazing, and the reindeer grazing thus seems to mainly influence biomass accumulation rather than morphology in Acaena. Interactions with contracta in both grazed and ungrazed areas were also studied in a two-year competition experiment. No apparent release of soil resources (as measured by an increase in plant growth) was apparent in plots where Festuca was removed, but the current year's shoots ofAcaenawere smaller and more numerous in these plots than in controls, especially in the ungrazed area.

Received 6 June 1995,accepted 29 November 1995 Key words: annual growth markers, herbivory, plant-plant interactions, reindeer, subantarctic

Introduction (Andersson & Jonasson 1986, Moen et al. 1993, Oksanen & Clonal, rhizomatous are a common and often dominant Moen 1994) and subantarctic areas (Leader-Williams 1988, plant group in subarctic/arctic areas (Billings & Mooney Lawrence & McClintock 1989). This may be especially 1968, Bliss 1971, Callaghan 1989), as well as in subantarctic important in subantarctic areas where all the vertebrate areas (Smith & Walton 1975). A specific feature of clonal herbivores are introduced . Many studies have plantsgrowingin these seasonal environmentsis the formation examined the growth and morphology of clonal plants under of annual growth markers, analogous to annual growth rings a variety of environmental conditions (see Hutchings & in trees (Callaghan & Collins 1976). The types of annual Mogie 1990and references therein), but none to our knowledge markers may differ: Lycopodium annotinum L. and have compared grazed and ungrazed, non-graminoid, clonal Polytrichum commune Hedw., for instance, produce plants by using annual markers. The aim of this study was compressed microphylls and smaller leaves, respectively, at to quantify long-term grazing effects on biomass and growth the beginning and end of each growing season (Callaghan of several populations of Acaena magellanica using annual et al. 1978, Callaghan 1980)Jlylocomium splendens (Hedw.) markers to divide the rhizome into yearly increments. B.S.G. typically grows as a layered mat in subarctic areas with each layer representing one year's growth due to winter conditions damaging the apex of the shoots (Callaghan et al. Materials and methods 1978)) whilst in the subantarctic Acaena magellanica Study site (Lam.) Vahl produces shorter internodes at the beginning and end of each growing season (Walton 1976). These South Georgia is a mountainous, subantarctic island (53'56'- annual markers may persist for ten years or more in some 54'553, 34'45'-38'15'W) over half of which is covered with species due to a low decomposition rate in the tundra, and can permanent ice and snow, confining the vegetation mainly to thus be used as historical records of growth (Callaghan & coastal areas. The vascular flora is impoverished with only Collins 1976, Havstrom et al. 1995). 26 native and an additional 30 or so introduced species, most Callaghan (1989) argues that abiotic factors, such as short of which have a very limited distribution (Walton & Smith cool summers, strong winds and infertile soils, provide the 1973, Greene & Walton 1975). major selection pressures for clonal plants in tundra In 1925, seven reindeer were introduced to HusvikHarbour environments. However, herbivores may also have a large on South Georgia by Norwegian whalers. The animals (three impact on plant community structure, and may act as a major males and four females) were brought from Norway to selection pressure on clonal plants, in both subarctic provide sport and additional meat for the personnel at the

147

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. Open University Library, on 21 Jan 2020 at 07:00:47, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954102096000211 148 J. MOEN and D.W.H WALTON

whaling stations in Stromness Bay. The introduction was Husdal. Vegetation consisted mostly of Festuca successful, and the herd had increased toc. 800 animals when contracta T. Kirk and Acaena magellanica, with last counted in 1973 (Leader-Williams 1988). The herd has scattered Phleum alpinum L., Rostkovia magellanica continued to expand its range (Moen & MacAlister 1994), (Lam.) Hook. f. and a variety of moss species. Rhizome and the reindeer have caused significant impacts on the plant systems from a reindeer exclosure erected in March 1974 communities (Leader-Williams et al. 1987). (Kightley & Smith 1976, Leader-Williams et al. 1987), and

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. Open University Library, on 21 Jan 2020 at 07:00:47, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954102096000211 BIOMASS ALLOCATION IN ACAENA MAGELLANICA 149

and rhizomes were dried at 50°C for three days and weighed. 500 I The branching angle was also measured before the side I *** *** *** 1 branches were cut from the main rhizome. Data on internode lengths, branching angles and branching potential will be used in a future computer simulation of growth. All equivalent shoot parts of the same year-class from the same population were used as replicates in the analyses. Ideally the analyses should have been done on a genet basis, 200 but it proved impossible to excavate entire rhizome systems in any of the populations. Table I shows the sample sizes for 100 all populations and measurements. All comparisons were by student t-tests. U GU GU G Fellfield PioneerI Interactions with Festuca In February 1991, a removal experiment designed to study Fig. 1. Total shoot weight (meanfSE) of current year’s shoots in the interaction of and competition between Acaena and three different habitats. G=grazed, U=ungrazed. Festuca contracta was initiated. Twenty 50 x 50 cm plots *** = P

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. Open University Library, on 21 Jan 2020 at 07:00:47, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954102096000211 J. MOEN and D.W.H. WALTON

500 *** ** 150 C 400 1 1201 300 t I t

30 0 nfl r GU GU GU “1: n U GU GU G Fellfield Bog Pioneer Fellfield Bog Pioneer

*t cluu *** *** 1 h c+1 c+1 E

vE s 300 cs, l-+ 6 4001 -a, 60 a, E 0 300 .-N GU A= U llU GU GU GU GU GU Fellfield Bog Pioneer Fellfield Bog Pioneer

150 I 500 * c+2 I c+2

90

120!60 200 :::I :::I I

GU GU GU GU GU GU Fellfield Bog Pioneer Fellfield 50g Pioneer Fig. 2. Rhizome weight (meankSE) in three habitats for three Fig. 3. Rhizome length (meanfse) in three habitats for three age-class segments. G=grazed, U=ungrazed. * = P<0.05, age-class segments. G=grazed, U=ungrazed. ** = P ~0.01, ** = P <0.01, *** = P ~0.0001(t-test). *** = P <0.0001 (t-test).

C+l segment of the ungrazed fellfield shoots. habitat (Fig. 3). The total rhizome length did not differ in current year’s The number of leaves was significantly lower in ungrazed shoots in any habitat, but was significantly higher in the current year’s shoots in the pioneer habitat, while the number ungrazed C+l segments in both the fellfield and the bog of leaf scars was significantly higher in ungrazed C+l

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. Open University Library, on 21 Jan 2020 at 07:00:47, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954102096000211 Number of leaves

A 1

t * 7%c

0 E) m m 0 0 *c *C L

TIE) b' 0 0 3 No data + No data + 'Dc N A 2 I I

m b Number per plot Dry weight per shoot (mg) Dry weight per plot (mg) P w I cn =I 3 0 cn (0 8 0 O, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O,0 1 r: + t D- I + I + I0 L D Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. Open University Library, on 21 Jan 2020 at 07:00:47, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954102096000211 152 J. MOEN and D.W.H. WALTON

Table III. Interactions withFestuca contructu.Analyses of variance using Table 1V.Comparisons of ungrazed current year’s shoots from this study Habitat (grazed vs. ungrazed) and Treatment (Festucu hand-weeded vs. with data from Walton (1976). Mean values (k se) are shown. controls) as fixed factors. Total weights and numbers of shoots were log- transformed, while individualweightsweresquare-root transformed. Population Dry weight (mg) No. of leaves

source ss d€ F P Walton (1976) Moist peat 803268 14.0k0.2 A. Total weight Dry scree 649k38 12.820.2 Habitat 0.51 1 13.14 0.001 Pioneer 1916k148 16.020.3 Treatment 0.02 1 0.60 0.44 Bog 366226 12.4k0.2 HxT 0.00 1 0.01 0.91 Error 1.33 34 This study Fellfield 389.4k33.3 10.320.2 B. Individualweight Bog 223.4k15.4 9.9k0.2 Habitat 341.92 1 470.34 <0.0001 Pioneer 268.2235.0 9.3k0.3 Treatment 5.26 1 7.24 0.01 HXT 2.71 1 3.72 0.06 Error 24.72 34 increments is less influenced. Sometimes grazed shoots had initiated new side branches C. Number of shoots on older parts of the rhizome, indicating a reserve of dormant Habitat 3.47 1 107.91 <0.0001 buds on the rhizome. The initation of side branches could be Treatment 0.16 1 4.83 0.04 HxT 0.01 1 0.46 0.50 a response to broken apical dominance as has been shown for Error 1.09 34 other clonal plants, e.g. Carex bigelowii Torr. (J6nsd6ttir & Callaghan 1988), and Lycopodium annotinum (Svensson & Callaghan 1988). Other studies have also shown a substantial translocation of resources from physiologically integrated segments in the fellfield habitat (Fig. 4). parts of the rhizomes to defoliated shoots (Pitelka & Ashmun 1985, Slade & Hutchings 1987, J6nsdBttir & Callaghan Interactions with Festuca 1989, Marshall 1990). It is not known to what extent resources are translocated within rhizome systems ofkaena, Removal of Festuca contracta did not have any effect on but preliminary studies (Walton 1982) have shown that in total dry weight per plot of current year’s shoots of Acaena ungrazed rhizome systems leaf bases are used for temporary in either of the habitats (Fig. 5a, Table 111). The control plots carbohydrate storage and sideshoots are primarily dependent in Husdal had only approximately half of the biomass of the on the leaves subtending them. At least in the short term it ungrazed plots on Grass Island, and the mean individual appears that each current year’s shoots acts as a relatively weight of the shoots was much smaller in Husdal but the self-contained unit, retaining most of the carbohydrate number per plot was higher (Fig. 5b & c). produced. Older rhizome segments must eventually depend However, the morphology seemed to change as a response on carbohydrates from photosynthetic leaves in the youngest to the removal treatment, especially on the ungrazed Grass segment, and the use of annual segments as replicates, rather Island. Acaena shoots in hand-weeded plots were smaller than entire rhizomes, is a limitation of this study. However, and more numerous than in the control plots even though if each branch system of the rhizome is seen as an integrated total biomass was very similar (Fig. 5, Table 111). The same physiological unit (sensu Watson & Caspar 1984), each unit trend was seen in Husdal although the differences were would respond independently to the grazing and could thus smaller. be treated as replicates. This assumption appears to be supported by the limited 14Ctranslocation studies on Acaena Discussion (Walton 1982). Reindeer grazing had a profound effect on the Acaena Walton (1976) investigated the biomass allocation in populations as was expected: most of the measured ungrazed Acaena rhizomes. The sampling was done in the characteristics were significantly smaller for grazed shoots Grytviken area (c. 18 km southeast of Husvik) in the austral than for ungrazed ones. Continuous defoliation will deplete summer of 1973/74. Four populations were studied: the resource reserve of plants and thus decrease biomass monospecific stands of Acaena on moist peat and dry scree, production (Chapin 1980). Rhizome weight (Fig. 2) was also isolated plants on dry gravel in Grytviken whaling station, more affected than rhizome length (Fig. 3) in current year’s and scattered plants in a Rostkovia-Tortula mire. shoots and C+2 segments. However, the proportional Comparisons with ungrazed current year’svegetative shoots allocation to leaves and rhizomes was similar, at least for the in the present study show that his plants were larger and had bog populations (Table 11). The reindeer grazing thus a higher number of leaves (Table IV). Thismay be attributable reduces biomass accumulation in both rhizomes and leaves, in part to a later date (March) for the harvest, to what is while relative allocation of resources and annual length believed to be a generally warmer and more protected local

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. Open University Library, on 21 Jan 2020 at 07:00:47, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954102096000211 BIOMASS ALLOCATION IN ACAENA MAGELLANICA 153

climate around Grytviken than around Husdal in any year, to References the variability in production between years which is evident ANDERSON,M. & JONASSON, S. 1986. Rodent cycles in relation to food in Fig. 3, and to the greater carbohydrate reserves which must resources on an alpine heath. Oikos, 46.93-106. accumulate in a favourable environment. BELL,A.D. 1991. Pkmt Form: an illustrated guide to morphology. Oxford Oxford University Press, 341 pp. BUGS, W.D. &MooNEY,H.A.1968. Theecologyofarcticandalpineplants. Interactions with Festuca Biological Review, 43,481-529. BLISS,L.C. 1971. Arctic and alpine plant life cycles. Annual Review of The lack of response in total dry weight per plot of Acaena Ecology and Systematics, 2,405-438. shoots when Festuca was removed (Fig. 5), seems to show CALLAGHAN,T.V. 1980. Age-related patterns of nutrient allocation in that, at least on a two year timescale, Acaena andFestuca do Lycopodium annotinum from Swedish Lapland. Oikos, 35,373-386. not show any detectable signs of competitionfor soil resources CALLAOHAN, T.V. 1989. Physiological and demographic implications of in these two habitats. An excavation of roots in andcuenu- modular constructionincold environments.InDAW,kJ.,HLT~Gs,M.J. & WATKINSON,A.R., eds. Plantpopulation ecology. Oxford: Blackwell, Festuca grassland in Husdal showed that the two species 111-135. have different rooting depths (Moen, personal observation) CALLAGHAN,T.V. &Coms,N.J. 1976. Strategies of growth and population which could serve as a niche separation between the species: dynamics of tundra plants. Oikos, 27,383-388. Festuca had very shallow roots, most of which were in the top CALLAGHAN,T.V., Corns, N.J. & CALLAOHAN,C.H. 1978. Photosynthesis, 10 cm of soil, while Acaena rhizomes extended far deeper. growth and reproduction of Hylmomium splendens and Polytrichwn commune in Swedish Lapland. Oikos, 31,7348. Walton (1979a) recorded Acaena rhizomes throughout a CHAPM, F.S., HI. 1980. Nutrient allocation and responses to defoliation in peat profile to depths of up to 1.5 m. tundra plants Arctic andAlpine Research, 12,553-563. However, the removal of neighbours caused a morphological DONG,M. 1993. Morphological plasticity of the clonal herb Lamiastrum response in Acaena, which also differed between the grazed galeobdolon (L.) Ehrend. & Polatschek in response to partial shading.New and the ungrazed area. One explanation for the change in Phytologist, 124,291-300. GREENE,S.W. & WALTON,D.W.H. 1975. An annotated check list of the sub- morphology may be that the removal ofFestuca increased Antarctic and Antarctic vascular flora. Polar Records, 17,473-484. the amount of light reaching the ground, and thus changed HAVSTROM,M.,CALLAGHAN,T.V., JONASSON, S. &SVOBODA,J. 1995. LittleIce the red/far-red ratio (Novoplansky et al. 1990, Schmitt & Age temperature estimated by growth and flowering differences between Wulff 1993). This ratio has been shown to be important in subfossil and extant shoots of Cassiope tetrugona, an arctic heather. determining internode growth versus lateral bud growth in Functional Ecology, 9,650-654. HLTCHINGS,M.J. & MOGIE, M. 1990. The spatial structure of cIonal plants: other clonal plants (Hutchings & Mogie 1990, Dong 1993). control and consequences. In VAN GROWENDAL,J & DE KROON,H., eds. If a change in the red/far-red ratio induced lateral bud growth Clonal growth in plants: regulation and function. The Hague: SPB m Acaena, together with no apparent release of soil AcademicPublishing, 57-76. resources as indicated by the lack of response in total J~NSD~T~IR,I.S. & CALLAGHAN,T.V.1988. Interrelationshipsbetween different biomass, then a higher number of shoots using the same generationsofinterconnected tillers ofCarexbigelowii. Oikos,52,120-128. J~NsD~T~R,~.~.& CUGHAN,T.V. 1989. Localizeddefoliationstressandthe amount of resources would result in smaller individual movement of,,C-photoassimilates between tillers ofCarw bigelowii. Oikos, shoots. The morphological response in the grazed plots was 54, 211-219. not of the same magnitude as in the ungrazed ones (Fig. 5), KIGHTLEY,S.P.J. & SMITH,R.I.L. 1976. The influence of reindeer on the possibly because grazing had already induced bud growth in vegetationofSouthGeorgia:I. Long-term effectsofunrestrictedgrazingand these rhizomes. Thus, the plants did not have the same the establishmentof exclosure experiments in various plant communities. British Antarctic Survey Bulletin, No. 44,57-76. potential for responding to neighbour removal. An alternative LAwRwa, J. & MCCLINTTOCK,J.B. 1989. Biomass plasticity of the leaves and explanation for the morphological response is that in the of Acaena magelknica (Lam.) Vahl (Rosaceae) on process of removing the Festuca, the rhizomes of Acaena subantarctic Iles Kerguelen. Polar Biology, 9,409-413. were damaged and this may have induced lateral bud growth. LEADER-~LLLIA~IS,N. 1988. Reindeer on South Georgia. Cambridge: However, the removal was done very carefully, and no broken Cambridgeuniversity Press, 319 pp. LEADER-WILLIAMS,N., SMITH, R.I.L. & ROTHERY,P. 1987. Influence of or damaged rhizomes were seen. introduced reindeer on thevegetationof South Georgia: results from along- term exclusion experiment. Journal ofApplied Ecology, 24,801-822. WSHAU,C. 1990. Source-sink relations of interconnected ramets. In VAN Acknowledgements GROENENDAL,J. &DE KROON, H., eds. Clonal growth inplants: regulation JM would like to thank Hector MacAlister, Ash Morton and andfunctwn. The Hague: SPB Academic Publishing, 23-41. MOW,J. & MAcAusm,H. 1994. Continued range expansionof introduced Olof Olsson for help with the field work, and Tom Ambom, reindeer on South Georgia. Polar Biology, 14,459462. Mike Fedak, Ian Boyd and the harbour master at Grytviken MoEN,J.,L~DBERG,P.A&OKsANm,L. 1993. Lemminggrazingonsnowbed for transport to Grass Island. Bengt-Gunnar Jonsson identified vegetation during a population peak, northern Norway. Arctic andAlpine the mosses. We would also like to thank Yves Frenot, Colin Research, 25, 136135. Meurk and an anonymous referee for their constructive NOVOPLANSKY,A, Corn, D. & SAW, T. 1990. How Portulacea seedlings avoid their neighbours. Oecologia, 82,490-493. comments. This study was supported by the Swedish Polar OKSANW,L. &Mom. J. 1994. Species-specificplantresponsesto exclusionof Research Secretariat (SWEDARP) and British Antarctic grazers in three Fennoscandiantundra habitats. kcoscience, 1,31-39. Survey.

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. Open University Library, on 21 Jan 2020 at 07:00:47, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954102096000211 154 J. MOEN and D.W.H. WALTON

hmL.F. &ASHMIIN,J.W. 1985. Physiology and integrationof rametsin WALTON,D.W.H. 1977a. Studies odcaena (Rosaceae):I. Seedgermination, clonalplants.hJAacsoN,J.B.C.,Buss,L.W.&COO~,R.E.,eds.Population growth and establishment in A. magellanica (Lam.) Vahl and A. tenera biology and evolution of clonal organism. New Haven: Yale University Alboff. British Antarctic Survey Bulfetin,No. 45,2940. Press, 399435. WALTON,D.W.H. 1977b. Studies odcaena (Rosaceae): II. Leaf production he,T. & BONNFA,W.N. 1980. Feral brown rats,Rattrcsnorvegicus,in South and senescence in A. magellanica (Lam.) Vahl. British Antarctic Survey Georgia (South Atlantic Ocean). Journal of Zoology, 192,237-255. Bulletin, No. 45,93400. SCHMITT, J. & Ww,R.D. 1993. Light spectralquality, phytochromeand plant WALTON,D.W.H. 1979a. StudiesonAcaena(Rosaceae): IV. Distributionand competition. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 8,47-51. ecology of the sub-antarcticspecies. BritkhAntarcticSurvey Bulletin, No. SLADE,A.J. & HUTCHINOS,M.J. 1987. An analysis of the costs and benefits of 49, 59-72. physiological integration between ramets in the clonal perennial herb WALTON,D.W.H. 1979b. Studies ondcaena (Rosaceae): III. Flowering and Glechoma hederacea. Oecologia, 13,425431. hybridization on South Georgia. BritishAntarcticSurvey Bulletin, No. 48, SMITH,R.I.L. & WALTON,D.W.H. 1975. South Georgia, subantarctic. In 1-13. Rossw~u,T. & HEAL, O.W. eds. Structure and function of tundra WALTON,D.W.H. 1982. Translocation patterns in South Georgian plants. ecosystems. Ecological Bulletin, 20,399-423. CNFRA,No. 51,538. SVENSSON,B.M. & CALLAOHAN, T.V. 1988. Apical dominance and the WALTON,D.W.H. & SMITH,R.I.L. 1973. Status of the alien vascular flora of simulationof metapopulationdynamics inLycopodim annotinm. Oikos, South Georgia. British Antarctic Survey Bulletin, No. 36,79-97. 51, 331-342. WATSON,M.A. & CASPAR,B.B. 1984. Morphogeneticconstraints on patterns WALTON,D.W.H. 1976. Dry matter production in Acaena (Rosaceae) on a of carbon in plants.AnnualReviewofEcologyandSystematics,15,223-258. subantarctic island. Journal of Ecology, 64,399415.

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. Open University Library, on 21 Jan 2020 at 07:00:47, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954102096000211