DOCSLIB.ORG

Agatha Christie's Doctors (BMJ 2010;341:C6438)—Web Appendix

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Agatha Christie's Doctors (BMJ 2010;341:C6438)—Web Appendix Agatha Christie’s doctors (BMJ 2010;341:c6438)—web appendix Herbert G Kinnell Incompetent doctors Newly qualified Dr Sarah King thinks the murder victim in Appointment with Death died of natural causes. A couple of “tame psychiatrists” are mentioned in Crooked House. The rich wife‟s doctor is an incompetent in A Caribbean Mystery. In The Adventure of the Christmas Pudding we hear hospital treatment being compared unfavourably with previous times: “Ah, doctors nowadays, they have you out of hospital before you can hardly stand on your feet.” Aunt Ada in By the Pricking of My Thumbs says: “That‟s how doctors make their living. Giving them boxes and boxes and bottles and bottles of tablets. Yellow tablets, pink tablets, green tablets, even black tablets … Brimstone and treacle they used to use in my grandmother‟s day. I bet they were as good as anything …” The murderous Dr Roberts in Cards on the Table falsely claims: “When we poison our patients it‟s entirely by accident.” The GP in The Tragedy at Marsdon Manor concludes that his 45 years of medical experience is sometimes “not worth a jot.” The arrogant, insolent, “obstinate as a pig” Dr Adams in The Cornish Mystery insists vehemently that the poisoned dentist died from gastritis. Poirot responds that if a doctor “lacks doubt he is not a doctor, he is an executioner.” Dr Stillingfleet believes the millionaire‟s murder is suicide in The Dream. In Endless Night Dr Shaw, a main character in the novel, goes largely unnoticed, even though one character comments: “Some doctor or other is always giving them powders and pills, stimulants or pep pills, or tranquillisers, things that on the whole they‟d be better without.” Dr Burton in The House of Lurking Death opines that three recent poisonings of people in big houses were down to socialist agitation. However, not all of Christie‟s doctors are incompetent, with one even boasting in The Case of the Caretaker that he has solved the case and goads Miss Marple to see if she can match his conclusion. Doctors with foibles Dr Blacklock in A Murder is Announced is a fierce tyrant who has “probably killed hundreds of patients,” and refuses to allow his daughter to have an operation for her disfiguring goitre. The unnamed greedy GP also makes his inevitable appearance in Taken at the Flood, charging 20 guineas for vitamins: he steals his morphia-addicted patient‟s vials of the drug and replaces them with castor oil, to fuel his own morphine addiction. Likewise one of the two doctors in another Poirot story, The Sittaford Mystery, has been struck off, probably for drug abuse, and attempts to extort money. Virologist Dr Louis Barron in Destination Unknown is described as willing to “sell his grandmother to the knackers‟ yard to get equipment for his work.” Of the „„unpleasant-looking brute‟‟ Dr Horriston, who appears in Partners in Crime—The Case of the Missing Lady, Tuppence says that the doctor gives: “injections of some sort (armadillo glands), and he makes a deadly secret of it, and charges through the nose. I daresay he is a quack—but he‟s a damned successful one!” He and the Austrian Dr Kleber, who could double as a concentration camp doctor, run a private slimming clinic where the „„missing lady‟‟ is strapped to a bed to receive the quack treatment. Dr Lutz in The Erymanthian Boar is a plastic surgeon for criminals and also pretends to be a psychoanalyst. In The Case of the Rich Woman bogus medic Dr Claudius Constantine makes a lady sign away her power of attorney to him after drugging her and he tries to treat patients by using a transmigration of souls technique. In The Dream, which featured a murdered millionaire who had dreamt of suicide, three doctors come up with bizarre interpretations of dreams. The murder victim in The Hollow is arrogant married philanderer Dr John Cristo, who abuses his private Harley Street patients. He reveals their names to his friends, and tries out experimental drugs on them to try to cure “Ridgeways Disease”. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Studies in Crime Writing – Issue 2 – 2019 © Reshmi Dutta-Flanders The
    The Plotting of Criminal Relevance in the Story of Crime: Agatha Christie’s Five Little Pigs Reshmi Dutta-Flanders University of Kent, United Kingdom Abstract The way a cause-and-effect relation between events is organized in a plot-based crime story depends upon a hinge point in the discourse, which unravels a competing story logic that shapes a “story of intentionality” embedded first in the story of crime and second in the story of investigation. The aim of this paper is to evaluate the “intent.” If intent is considered as a hinge point against which the causality of events takes place, then it is necessary to work out the causation. Following a ‘‘discourse- based’’ frame analysis, an “intent frame” is evaluated using an “inference-making” process. The intent frame is then mapped along the horizontal and vertical axes of a narrative frame in the application of a logical fallacy. Such application of narratological concepts with stylistic strategy is effective for the revelation of participant relevance to an offense in the story of crime adapted from Agatha Christie’s Five Little Pigs. * 1.1 Introduction A perpetrator distorts the original sequence of events for concealment and reader suspense in a crime story. There is a systematic application of logical fallacy by the teller in the way of forming consequential relations (chronology) that confuse the consecution (the logic) of events so that “what comes after is being read in the narrative as what is caused by,” inducing causal reversal in the sequence of events (Barthes 94). To evaluate this post-murder causality in the story, we need to follow the plot line in the way the readers move from one narrative level to the next.
    [Show full text]
  • Poirot: the Hollow Free
    FREE POIROT: THE HOLLOW PDF Agatha Christie | 240 pages | 22 Sep 2008 | HarperCollins Publishers | 9780007121021 | English | London, United Kingdom Investigating Agatha Christie's Poirot: Episode-by-episode: The Hollow Lucy Angkatell invited Hercule Poirot to lunch. To tease the great detective, her guests stage a mock murder beside the swimming pool. Unfortunately, the victim plays the scene for real. In the confusion, a gun sinks to the bottom of the pool. It seems everyone in the drama is a suspect — and each a victim of love. Suddenly, with Poirot: The Hollow terrific shock, with that feeling as of blurring on a cinematograph screen before the picture comes to focus, Hercule Poirot realised that this artificially set scene had a point of reality. First published as a novel in the US in by Dodd, Mead and Company, The Hollow remains an example of classic Christie: a gathering of guests at a country house is disturbed by a sudden death and luckily Poirot is in attendance. The main players include a downtrodden wife, her successful husband, and the reappearance of an old Poirot: The Hollow. It was originally published in the US as Murder after Hours. So the play was adapted, Poirot ousted, and it was produced in under the same title, The Hollow. It was adapted for TV in and starred David Suchet. Some changes were made to the Poirot: The Hollow, but overall it remained fairly true to the novel. Skip to main navigation Skip to content. Home Stories The Hollow. The Hollow Buy. First published: Murder methods:. A Hercule Poirot story.
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliography
    BIBLIOGRAPHY PRIMARY SOURCES BY AGATHA CHRISTIE Christie, Agatha. An Autobiography [1977] (London: Harper, 2011). ———. The Big Four (London: Collins, 1927). ———. The Body in the Library [1942] (New York, London, Toronto: Harper, 2011). ———. “The Capture of Cerberus” [1941], in Agatha Christie ’ s Secret Notebooks : Fifty Years of Mysteries in the Making , ed. by John Curran (London: HarperCollins, 2009), 425-52. ———. “The Capture of Cerberus” [1947], in Herucle Poirot : The Complete Short Stories (London: HarperCollins, 1999), 831-51. ———. Cards on the Table [1936] (Glasgow: Fontana, 1969). ———. Cards on the Table : Marple Tie-In (London: HarperCollins, 2005). ———. A Caribbean Mystery (London: Book Club, 1964). ———. “The Case of the Discontented Soldier” [1934], in Parker Pyne Investigates (New York: William Morrow, 2012), 17-38. ———. “The Case of the Rich Woman” [1934], in Parker Pyne Investigates (New York: William Morrow, 2012), 87-104. ———. “The Cornish Mystery” [1923], in Poirot ’ s Early Cases (London: Harper, 2002), 57-80. ———. Crooked House [1949] (Glasgow: Fontana, 1990). ———. Curtain : Poirot ’ s Last Case [1975] (London: Harper, 2002). ———. Dead Man ’ s Folly [1956] (London: Collins, 1956). ———. Death on the Nile [1937] (New York, London, Toronto: Harper, 2011). © The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s) 2016 271 J.C. Bernthal, Queering Agatha Christie, DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-33533-9 272 BIBLIOGRAPHY ———. “The Double Clue” [1923], in Hercule Poirot : The Complete Short Stories (London: HarperCollins, 1999), 282-90. ———. Dumb Witness (London: Book Club, 1937). ———. Elephants Can Remember [1972] (London: HarperCollins, 2002). ———. Evil under the Sun [1941] (Glasgow, London: Fontana, 1988). ———. The Grand Tour (London: HarperCollins, 2012). ———. Hallowe ’ en Party [1969] (London: HarperCollins, 1994).
    [Show full text]
  • Easychair Preprint Hercule Poirot, Mon (Faux)
    EasyChair Preprint № 6064 Hercule Poirot, Mon (Faux) Ami: a Corpus Study on Agatha Christie’s Use of Language to Develop Character Ellen Carter EasyChair preprints are intended for rapid dissemination of research results and are integrated with the rest of EasyChair. July 13, 2021 Hercule Poirot, Mon (Faux) Ami 1 Hercule Poirot, Mon (Faux) Ami: A Corpus Study on Agatha Christie’s Use of Language to Develop Character Ellen Carter1 11LiLPa – Linguistique, Langues, Parole – UR 1339, Université de Strasbourg, France Author Note The author declares that there no conflicts of interest with respect to this preprint. Correspondence should be addressed to Ellen Carter, Université de Strasbourg, 22 Rue René Descartes, 67084 Strasbourg CEDEX, France. https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9249-5298 Email: [email protected] Hercule Poirot, Mon (Faux) Ami 2 Abstract This corpus analysis investigates Agatha Christie’s use of discourse in the person of her fictional Belgian detective, Hercule Poirot. By focusing on a specific linguistic trait – false friends – it presents evidence of how Christie used this trait to develop Poirot’s character across his thirty- three novels. Moreover, it shows that this trait is almost completely absent from the four novels featuring Poirot written by Sophie Hannah, who was chosen by Christie’s estate to continue his adventures. Keywords: discourse analysis, corpus stylistics, false friends, Agatha Christie Hercule Poirot, Mon (Faux) Ami 3 Hercule Poirot, Mon (Faux) Ami: A Corpus Study on Agatha Christie’s Use of Language to Develop Character Corpora have been used to analyze various text types and targets, including discourse analysis (Baker & McEnery, 2015), corpus stylistics of speech presentation (Semino & Short, 2004), corpus stylistics of popular fiction (Mahlberg & McIntyre, 2011) and the process of characterization in fiction (Mahlberg, 2012).
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliography
    Bibliography Works by Agatha Christie The following works are referred to in the text. They are listed under the standard British titles, with American titles in brackets. Date of the first publication is given. Works are referred to in the text by an abbreviated form of the British title, given in square brackets in this list. Since there have been so many editions of the novels, references are to the chapter numbers and not to the page. The current standard edition is published by Harper-Collins in the United Kingdom and by Dodd Mead in the United States. 4.50 from Paddington (What Mrs McGillicuddy Saw), 1957 [4.50] The ABC Murders, 1936 [ABC] The Adventure of the Christmas Pudding, 1960 [Pudding] After the Funeral (Funerals Are Fatal), 1953 [Funeral] And Then There Were None, 1939 [None] Appointment with Death, 1938 [Appointment] At Bertram’s Hotel, 1965 [Bertram] Autobiography, 1977 The Body in the Library, 1942 [Library] By the Pricking of My Thumbs, 1968 [Pricking] Cards on the Table, 1936 [Cards] A Caribbean Mystery, 1964 [Caribbean] Cat among the Pigeons, 1959 [Cat] The Clocks, 1963 [Clocks] Crooked House, 1949 [Crooked] Curtain, 1975 [Curtain] Dead Man’s Folly, 1956 [Folly] Death Comes As the End, 1945 [Comes End] Death in the Clouds (Death in the Air), 1935 [Clouds] Death on the Nile, 1937 [Nile] Destination Unknown (So Many Steps to Death), 1954 [Destination] Dumb Witness (Poirot Loses a Client), 1937 [Witness] Elephants Can Remember, 1972 [Elephants] Endless Night, 1967 [Endless] Evil under the Sun, 1941 [Sun] Five Little Pigs
    [Show full text]
  • Agatha Christie Third Girl
    Agatha Christie Third Girl A Hercule Poirot Mystery To Norah Blackmore Contents Cover Title Page Dedication Chapter One Chapter Two Chapter Three Chapter Four Chapter Five Chapter Six Chapter Seven Chapter Eight Chapter Nine Chapter Ten Chapter Eleven Chapter Twelve Chapter Thirteen Chapter Fourteen Chapter Fifteen Chapter Sixteen Chapter Seventeen Chapter Eighteen Chapter Nineteen Chapter Twenty Chapter Twenty-One Chapter Twenty-Two Chapter Twenty-Three Chapter Twenty-Four Chapter Twenty-Five About the Author Other Books by Agatha Christie Credits Copyright About the Publisher One Hercule Poirot was sitting at the breakfast table. At his right hand was a steaming cup of chocolate. He had always had a sweet tooth. To accompany the chocolate was a brioche. It went agreeably with chocolate. He nodded his approval. This was from the fourth shop he had tried. It was a Danish pâtisserie but infinitely superior to the so-called French one nearby. That had been nothing less than a fraud. He was satisfied gastronomically. His stomach was at peace. His mind also was at peace, perhaps somewhat too much so. He had finished his Magnum Opus, an analysis of great writers of detective fiction. He had dared to speak scathingly of Edgar Allen Poe, he had complained of the lack of method or order in the romantic outpourings of Wilkie Collins, had lauded to the skies two American authors who were practically unknown, and had in various other ways given honour where honour was due and sternly withheld it where he considered it was not. He had seen the volume through the press, had looked upon the results and, apart from a really incredible number of printer’s errors, pronounced that it was good.
    [Show full text]
  • Agatha Christie
    book & film club: Agatha Christie Discussion Questions & Activities Discussion Questions 1 For her first novel,The Mysterious Affair at Styles, Agatha Christie wanted her detective to be “someone who hadn’t been used before.” Thus, the fastidious retired policeman Hercule Poirot was born—a fish-out-of-water, inspired by Belgian refugees she encountered during World War I in the seaside town of Torquay, where she grew up. When a later Poirot mystery, The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, was adapted into a stage play, Christie was unhappy that the role of Dr. Sheppard’s spinster sister had been rewritten for a much younger actress. So she created elderly amateur detective Jane Marple to show English village life through the eyes of an “old maid”—an often overlooked and patronized character. How are Miss Marple and Monsieur Poirot different from “classic” crime solvers such as police officials or hard-boiled private eyes? How do their personalities help them to be more effective than the local authorities? Which modern fictional sleuths, in literature, film, and television, seem to be inspired by Christie’s creations? 2 Miss Marple and Poirot crossed paths only once—in a not-so-classic 1965 British film adaptation of The ABC Murders called The Alphabet Murders (played, respectively, by Margaret Rutherford and Tony Randall). In her autobiography, Christie writes that her readers often suggested that she should have her two iconic sleuths meet. “But why should they?” she countered. “I am sure they would not enjoy it at all.” Imagine a new scenario in which the shrewd amateur and the egotistical professional might join forces.
    [Show full text]
  • Hercule Poirot Mysteries in Chronological Order
    Hercule Poirot/Miss Jane Marple Christie, Agatha Dame Agatha Christie (1890-1976), the “queen” of British mystery writers, published more than ninety stories between 1920 and 1976. Her best-loved stories revolve around two brilliant and quite dissimilar detectives, the Belgian émigré Hercule Poirot and the English spinster Miss Jane Marple. Other stories feature the “flapper” couple Tommy and Tuppence Beresford, the mysterious Harley Quin, the private detective Parker Pyne, or Police Superintendent Battle as investigators. Dame Agatha’s works have been adapted numerous times for the stage, movies, radio, and television. Most of the Christie mysteries are available from the New Bern-Craven County Public library in book form or audio tape. Hercule Poirot The Mysterious Affair at Styles [1920] Murder on the Links [1923] Poirot Investigates [1924] Short story collection containing: The Adventure of "The Western Star", TheTragedy at Marsdon Manor, The Adventure of the Cheap Flat , The Mystery of Hunter's Lodge, The Million Dollar Bond Robbery, The Adventure of the Egyptian Tomb, The Jewel Robbery at the Grand Metropolitan, The Kidnapped Prime Minister, The Disappearance of Mr. Davenheim, The Adventure of the Italian Nobleman, The Case of the Missing Will, The Veiled Lady, The Lost Mine, and The Chocolate Box. The Murder of Roger Ackroyd [1926] The Under Dog and Other Stories [1926] Short story collection containing: The Underdog, The Plymouth Express, The Affair at the Victory Ball, The Market Basing Mystery, The Lemesurier Inheritance, The Cornish Mystery, The King of Clubs, The Submarine Plans, and The Adventure of the Clapham Cook. The Big Four [1927] The Mystery of the Blue Train [1928] Peril at End House [1928] Lord Edgware Dies [1933] Murder on the Orient Express [1934] Three Act Tragedy [1935] Death in the Clouds [1935] The A.B.C.
    [Show full text]
  • If You Want to Read the Books in Publication
    If you want to read the books in publication order before you discuss them this is the list for you. For the books the year indicates the first publication, whether in the US or UK, and where possible we have given the alternative US/UK titles. The collections listed are those that feature the first book appearance of one or more stories: 1920 The Mysterious Affair at Styles 1922 The Secret Adversary 1923 Murder on the Links 1924 The Man in the Brown Suit 1924 Poirot Investigates – containing: The Adventure of the ‘Western Star’ The Tragedy at Marsdon Manor The Adventure of the Cheap Flat The Mystery of Hunter’s Lodge The Million Dollar Bond Robbery The Adventure of the Egyptian Tomb The Jewel Robbery at the Grand Metropolitan The Kidnapped Prime Minister The Disappearance of Mr Davenheim The Adventure of the Italian Nobleman The Case of the Missing Will 1925 The Secret of Chimneys 1926 The Murder of Roger Ackroyd 1927 The Big Four 1928 The Mystery of the Blue Train 1929 The Seven Dials Mystery 1929 Partners in Crime – containing: A Fairy in the Flat A Pot of Tea The Affair of the Pink Pearl The Adventure of the Sinister Stranger Finessing the King/The Gentleman Dressed in Newspaper The Case of the Missing Lady Blindman’s Buff The Man in the Mist The Crackler The Sunningdale Mystery The House of Lurking Death The Unbreakable Alibi The Clergyman’s Daughter/The Red House The Ambassador’s Boots The Man Who Was No.16 1930 The Mysterious Mr Quin – containing: The Coming of Mr Quin www.AgathaChristie.com The Shadow on the Glass At the ‘Bells
    [Show full text]
  • Poirot Reading List
    Suggested Reading order for Christie’s Poirot novels and short story collections The most important point to note is – make sure you read Curtain last. Other points to note are: 1. Lord Edgware Dies should be read before After the Funeral 2. Five Little Pigs should be read before Elephants Can Remember 3. Cat Among the Pigeons should be read before Hallowe’en Party 4. Mrs McGinty’s Dead should be read before Hallowe’en Party and Elephants Can Remember 5. Murder on the Orient Express should be read before Murder in Mesopotamia 6. Three Act Tragedy should be read before Hercule Poirot’s Christmas Otherwise, it’s possible to read the Poirot books in any order – but we suggest the following: The Mysterious Affair at Styles 1920 Murder on the Links 1923 Christmas Adventure (short story) 1923 Poirot Investigates (short stories) 1924 Poirot's Early Cases (short stories) 1974 The Murder of Roger Ackroyd 1926 The Big Four 1927 The Mystery of the Blue Train 1928 Black Coffee (play novelisation by Charles Osborne) 1997 Peril at End House 1932 The Mystery of the Baghdad Chest (short story) 1932 Second Gong (short story) 1932 Lord Edgware Dies 1933 Murder on the Orient Express 1934 Three Act Tragedy 1935 Death in the Clouds 1935 The ABC Murders 1936 Murder in Mesopotamia 1936 Cards on the Table 1936 Yellow Iris (short story) 1937 Murder in the Mews (four novellas) 1937 Dumb Witness 1937 Death on the Nile 1937 Appointment with Death 1938 Hercule Poirot's Christmas 1938 Sad Cypress 1940 One, Two Buckle my Shoe 1940 Evil Under
    [Show full text]
  • Poirot: the Hollow Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    POIROT: THE HOLLOW PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Agatha Christie | 240 pages | 22 Sep 2008 | HarperCollins Publishers | 9780007121021 | English | London, United Kingdom Poirot: The Hollow PDF Book Full Cast and Crew. User Ratings. This is a very accurate summing up of yet another thrilling Christie. David Suchet is perfect in his role, and the rest of the cast is perfect in their respective roles either. Beryl Collins Dale Rapley Lucy Angkatell. Get some picks. All Douglas County Libraries locations are open with modified hours, services, and safety protocols. On their first night here, they get an get an unexpected visit from their neighbor, Veronica Clay, who John used to be madly and engaged to 15 years earlier. More Info Place Hold. Check Out OverDrive. Watched List - Episode's. John Christow Megan Dodds Sergeant Coombes. Midge Hardcastle Jamie de Courcey The Apples of Hesperides. Before he had died as he was laying on the floor Lucy, Henrietta, Edward, and the detective Hercule Poirot we was invited to have lunch with them. Plot Keywords. Maybe she comes off as a cliche because the other characters are so well-drawn! Open search form. BRiAN Help. Carol Sutton 5. David Suchet is perfect in his role, and the rest of the cast is perfect in their respective roles either. Unaware of his flaws, she has placed him on the highest pedestal of virtues and worships the ground he walks on. Inspector Grange Edward Hardwicke Annette O'Toole 2. You are commenting using your Twitter account. Parents Guide. May 13, May 15, Njkinny 1 Comment 5 stars , classics , hercule poirot.
    [Show full text]
  • 77-2440 Laborde, Charles Bernard, Jr., 1949- FORM and FORMULA in DETECTIVE DRAMA: a STRUCTURAL STUDY of SELECTED TWENTIETH- CENTURY MYSTERY PLAYS
    77-2440 LaBORDE, Charles Bernard, Jr., 1949- FORM AND FORMULA IN DETECTIVE DRAMA: A STRUCTURAL STUDY OF SELECTED TWENTIETH- CENTURY MYSTERY PLAYS. The Ohio State University, Ph.D., 1976 Theater Xerox University Microfilms,Ann Arbor, Michigan 48106 © 1976 CHARLES BERNARD LaBORDE, JR. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED FORM AND FORMULA IN DETECTIVE DRAMA* A STRUCTURAL STUDY OF SELECTED TWENTIETH-CENTURY MYSTERY PLAYS DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Charles Bernard LaBorde, Jr., B.A., M.A. ***** The Ohio State University 1976 Reading Committee* Approved By Donald Glancy Roy Bowen Charles Ritter ^ A'dviser Department of Theatre ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I am grateful to Professor Donald Glancy for his guidance In the writing of this dissertation and to the other members of my committee. Dr, Roy Bowen and Dr. Charles Ritter, for their criticism. I am also indebted to Dr. Clifford Ashby for suggesting to me that the topic of detective drama was suitable for exploration in a dissertation. ii VITA October 6, 19^9 .... Born - Beaumont, Texas 1971 ......... B.A., Lamar State College of Technology, Beaumont, Texas 1971-1973 .......... Teaching Assistant, Department of Speech and Theatre Arts, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas 1973 .............. M.A., Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas 1973-1975 ....... Teaching Associate, Department of Theatre, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 1975-1976 ....... University Fellow, Graduate School, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio PUBLICATIONS "Sherlock Holmes on the Stage after William Gillette." Baker Street Journal. N. S., 2k (June 1974), 109-19. "Sherlock Holmes on the Stage: William Gillette," Accepted for publication by Baker Street Journal.
    [Show full text]