AGENDA MEETING OF HERITAGE BELCOM, ON WEDNESDAY, 25 APRIL 2018, ON THE 1ST FLOOR BOARDROOM, PROTEA ASSURANCE BUILDING, , AT 09H00

Item Case No Subject Reference Case Officer Documents to be tabled Matter 1 Opening 2 Attendance 3 Apologies 4 Approval of the agenda 4.1 Dated 25 April 2018 5 Approval of the previous minutes 5.1 Dated 28 March 2018 6 Disclosure of Interest 7 Confidential Matters 7.1 None 8 Administration Matters 8.1 Outcome of the Appeals and Tribunal Committees 8.2 Report back on Stop Works Orders and Charges 8.3 Formal Protection of Buildings refused for Demolition 9 Standing Items 9.1 Site Inspections 9.2 Report back on Council and ExCo Meetings KDS 9.3 Potential Site Visits 10 Appointments 10.1 None MATTERS TO BE DISCUSSED 11 PROVINCIAL HERITAGE SITE: SECTION 27 PERMIT APPLICATIONS

18030608WD0 Proposed Internal Alterations, Erf 1967, HM/CAPE WINELANDS/ Waseefa Dhansay Application documents - 1713 - 100 - 200 to be tabled New Matter 307M Andringa Street, Stellenbosch STELLENBOSCH/ ERF 1967 11.1 HM/ CAPE TOWN Proposed Additions, Alterations and METROPOLITAN/ 16112213WD1 Landscaping, Re of Portion 12 of the / RE OF Application Documents - 16003_2 180412 Integrated services drawing; Waseefa Dhansay Matter Arising 123M Vergenoegd Farm No 653, Somerset PORTION 12 OF THE 16003_H 180411 Integrated Services guideline to be tabled West VERGENOEGD FARM NO 653 11.2

Proposed Mandela Statue and Visitor HM/ CAPE TOWN 17022104WD0 Center, Erf 4942, , METROPOLITAN/ CAPE Waseefa Dhansay Application documents to be tabled Matter Arising 221E Cape Town CBD TOWN CBD/ ERF 4942 11.3 Proposed Partial Demolition, Additions HM/CAPE 15080507HB0 and Restorations, Erf 177447,The Progress Report 4: Construction Progress Report prepared by Gapp METROPOLITAN/CAPE Heidi Boise Matter Arising 812M Granary, 11 Buitenkant Street, Cape Architects/ Urban Designers dated 26 August 2016 to be tabled TOWN/ ERF 177447 Town 11.4

Final BELCom Agenda_25 April 2018 Page 1 HM/ CAPE TOWN Proposed Guest Cottages and Spa - RE 17102704WD0 METROPOLITAN/ of Farm 1319 Morgenster, Somerset Waseefa Dhansay Application documents to be tabled Matter Arising 206M SOMERSET WEST/ RE OF West FARM 1319 11.5

Proposed Site Development Plan for 17013110AS0 HM/STELLENBOSCH/FARM Hazendal, Farm Haasendal 222, Andrew September Revised SDP and Heritage Statements including proposals to be tabled Matter Arising 201E HAASENDAL 222 Stellenbosch 11.6

Proposed Total Demolition of 18030106AS0 Outbuildings, Addition and Alterations to HM/PAARL/ERF 3424 Andrew September Permit application and addendum to be tabled New Matter 307E Erf 3424, 52 Main Street, Paarl 11.7

Proposed Additions and Alterations at HM/ CAPE 18020706HB0 Annexure A section 27 application & drawings prepared by VIZI Erf 1396, 17 Van Riebeeck Street, WINELANDS/STELLENBOSC Heidi Boise New Matter 207M Architects to be tabled Stellenbosch H/ ERF 1396 11.8

HM/ CAPE WINELANDS/ 18030627WD0 Proposed Additions and Alterations, Erf DRAKENSTEIN/ PAARL/ ERF Waseefa Dhansay Application documents to be tabled New Matter 307M 31396 132 Main Road, Paarl 31396 11.9

18030615WD0 Proposed Signage, Erf 1967, Andringa HM/ CAPE WINELANDS/ Waseefa Dhansay Application documents - 12 ZD to be tabled New Matter 307M Street, Stellenbosch STELLENBOSCH/ ERF 1967 11.10 12 STRUCTURES OLDER THAN 60 YEARS: SECTION 34 PERMIT FOR TOTAL DEMOLITION

18030508AS0 Proposed total Demolition and SDP on HM//ERF Permit application, Heritage Statement prepared by Urban Design Andrew September New Matter 307E Erf 15654, 38 Queen Street, Durbanville 15654 Services and Addendum to be tabled 12.1 HM\OVERBERG\ 18030115WD0 Proposed Total Demolition, Erf 363, 5 OVERSTRAND\ Waseefa Dhansay Application documents to be tabled New Matter 403E West Cliff Road, Hermanus HERMANUS\ERF 363 12.2 HM/CAPE 18020605HB0 Proposed Total Demolition at Erf 66993, Heritage Statement prepared by Andrew Berman dated February 2018 METROPOLITAN/WYNBERG/ Heidi Boise New Matter 208M 10 Wellington Road, Wynberg to be tabled 12.3 ERF 66993

Proposed Total Demolition at 17040408HB0 HM/CAPE METROPOLITAN/ Report prepared by P. J. Smidt from A19 Inspectorate(Pty) Ltd dated 14 Remainder Erf 14915, 79 Upper Duke Heidi Boise New Matter 411E REM - ERF 14915 November 2017 to be tabled Street, 12.4

18021205SB0 Proposed Total Demolition of Erf 25889, HM/OBSERVATORY/ERF Permit application prepared by Jason Green and associated documents Stephanie Barnardt New Matter 228M 321 Main Road, Observatory 25889 to be tabled 12.5

Final BELCom Agenda_25 April 2018 Page 2 HM/ CAPE TOWN Proposed Total Demolition of 18020604ZK02 METROPOLITAN/SOMERSE Application form, Motivational Heritage Statement, Resolution letter, Remainder Erf 22, , Zethembe Khuluse New Matter 07M T WEST/ REMAINDER ERF POA, Title Deed to be table Somerset West 22 12.6

Proposed Total Demolition of structures HM/WEST 16092705KR0 Application documents, Saldanha Bay Municipality comment, IRASA on Erf 1097-3, West Point Procrssors COAST/SALDARNHA BAY/ST Andrew September New Matter 728E comment to be tabled (Pty) Ltd) , Main Road, St Helena Bay HELENA BAY/ERF 1097-3 12.7 13 STRUCTURES OLDER THAN 60 YEARS: SECTION 34 PERMIT FOR PARTIAL DEMOLITION/ ALTERATIONS AND ADDITIONS

Proposed Alterations to "Agricultural 16090602AS0 Reasons for Illegal Work by WA Carstens as per the requirements of Shed" on Farm D'olyfboom, Farm HM/PAARL/FARM 29112 Andrew September Matter Arising 907E HWC Decision May 2017 to be table 29112, Napier Street, Paarl 13.1

Proposed Addition of an Ablution Block HM/CAPE TOWN 17063003KR0 to Erf 60991, 50 Church Street, METROPOLITAN/LANSDOW Stephanie Barnardt Application documents, CoCT HRS comment, and drawings to be tabled Matter Arising 714E Lansdown N/ERF 60991 13.2

Proposed Additions and Alterations, Erf 18030603WD0 HM/CAPE METROPOLITAN/ 11274, 28 Cavendish Street, Waseefa Dhansay Application documents to be tabled New Matter 320M WOODSTOCK/ ERF 11274 Woodstock 13.3 HM/CAPE Proposed Alterations and Additions, 17041004KR0 METROPOLITAN/ST Heritage Statement prepared by Eugenie Marincowitz dated January Erven 88379 & 88381, 9 St James & 10 Heidi Boise New Matter 413E JAMES/ERVEN 88379 & 2018 to be table Sandhurst Roads, St James 88381 13.4

HM/ CAPE TOWN Application form, locality map, CoCT cComments, proposed building 17102510ZK02 Proposed Alterations and Additions, Erf METROPOLITAN/SALT Zethembe Khuluse plans, Internal, external, and contextual Images, POA, SG diagrams, New Matter 08M 16685, 1 Swift Street, Salt River RIVER/ ERF 16685 Title Deeds to be table 13.5

Proposed Alterations and Additions on HM/ CAPE TOWN Application form, CoCT comments, Renaissance Foundation 17102408ZK10 Erf 19716, 25 Lourensford Road, METROPOLITAN/SOMERSE Zethembe Khuluse comments, locality plan, proposed building plans, purchase agreement, New Matter 31E Somerset West T WEST/ ERF 19716 resolution letter, site images to be tabled 13.6

Proposed Additions and Alterations at 17120413HB0 HM/CAPE METROPOLITAN/ Drawings prepared by Bernicchi Architects drawing no. HP.02.100C Rev Erf 390, 34 Woodside Road, Heidi Boise New Matter 221E /ERF 390 D dated 3 March 2017 to be tabled Tamboerskloof 13.7

Proposed Additions and Alterations at HM/ CAPE 18030512HB0 Erf 609, 27 Alexandra Avenue, METROPOLITAN/ORANJEZI Heidi Boise Report prepared by Claire Abrahamse dated January 2018 to be tabled New Matter 315E CHT/ERF 609 13.8

Final BELCom Agenda_25 April 2018 Page 3 HM/CAPE 17120803HB1 Proposed Addition and Alteration at Erf Drawings prepared by Rousseau Pienaar Architecture drawing no. METROPOLITAN/PINELAND Heidi Boise New Matter 208E 1827, 34 Elizabeth Avenue Pinelands 29_LA.01 & 29_LA.02 Rev E dated 5 December 2017 to be tabled S/ERF 1827 13.9

HM/CAPE 18030205HB0 Proposed Additions and Alterations at Drawings prepared by R & R Drawing Studio dated November 2017 to METROPOLITAN/DE Heidi Boise New Matter 319E Erf 586, 2 Hoop Street, De Rust be tabled RUST/ERF 586 13.10

18022613WD0 Proposed Additions and Alterations, Erf HM/CAPE WINELANDS/ Waseefa Dhansay Application documents, drawings D1_101; D_102 to be tabled New Matter 307M 792, 99 Dorp Street, Stellenbosch STELLENBOSCH/ ERF 792 13.11

Proposed Alteration, Additions and 17110109SB0 Permit application and Heritage Statement prepared by Raymond Smith Partial Demolition of Erf 419, HM/STANFORD/ERF 419 Stephanie Barnardt New Matter 307M and associated documents to be table Longmarket Street, Stanford Village 13.12

Proposed Additions and Alterations, Erf HM/ CAPE TOWN 18030604WD0 15982 62 - 80 Goldsmith Street, METROPOLITAN/WOODSTO Waseefa Dhansay Application documents to be tabled New Matter 404E Woodstock CK/ ERF 15982 13.13

Unauthorised Work, Additions and HM/CAPE Heritage Report prepared by Claire Abrahamse dated February 2018 18030114HB0 Alterations at Erf 46391, 84 Dean METROPOLITAN/NEWLAND Heidi Boise and drawings prepared by Avril Jason (drawing no. DEA028.1) dated 12 New Matter 302E Street, Newlands S/ERF 46391 February 2018 to be tabled 13.14

HM/CAPE 18040312HB0 Proposed Additions and Alterations at Heritage Report prepared by Louise van Riet, drawings (drawing no. METROPOLITAN/MOWBRAY Heidi Boise New Matter 405E Erf 32029, 21 Pillans Road, Mowbray 1712_1-01 Rev 6) dated 5 March 2018 to be tabled /ERF 32029 13.15

17120312HB1 Proposed Additions and Alterations at HM/ CAPE WINELANDS/ Draawings prepared by Malherbe Rust Architects (drawing no 8201 Rev 208E;1503180 Erf 715, 14 Huguenot Road, Heidi Boise New Matter FRANSCHOEK /ERF 715 A) dated 08 -12-2017 to be tabled 4KR0327M Franschoek 13.16

Application form, cover Letter prepared by Peter Buttgens, Gallery Proposed Amendment of conditions of HM/ CAPE TOWN Space Introduction prepared by Delve, previous application history, 18030611ZK03 previously approved Record of METROPOLITAN/ CAPE Zethembe Khuluse previous RODs and permits issued by HWC, previously approved New Matter 07E Decision, Erf 3032, 150 Buitengracht TOWN CBD/ ERF 3032 building plans, introduction to new proposal, HWC Legal Opinion, Street, Cape Town, (CBD) resolution to be tabled 13.17 Proposed Restoration and Alteration Application form, proposed municipal plans, condonation letter, Title and Additions on Erf 177932 (Portion of HM/ CAPE TOWN 17101713KR1 Deed, CoCT comments, Philip Smith correspondence Erf 46741) , 79 Albion Road, METROPOLITAN/ Zethembe Khuluse New Matter 026E comment,architects response to comments,internal, external and also known as "the RONDEBOSCH/ 177932 contextual photo's, POA, locality and satellite Image to be tabled 13.18 Cobbles"

Final BELCom Agenda_25 April 2018 Page 4 18030601WD0 Proposed Additions and Alterations, Erf HM/CAPE METROPOLITAN/ Waseefa Dhansay Application documents to be tabled New Matter 404E 11481, 62D Essex Street, Woodstock WOODSTOCK/ ERF 11481 13.19

Proposed Additions, Alterations and HM/DRAKENSTEIN Application form, Title Deed, company resolution, POA, SG diagram, 18040318ZK04 Partial Demolition of structures on Erf MUNICIPALITY/ PAARL/ ERF Zethembe Khuluse photo sheet, I&AP, Heritage Statement, public participation, plans and New Matter 04E 3427 3427 elevations to be tabled 13.20

14 HERITAGE AREAS: SECTION 31 CONSENT APPLICATION 14.1 None

15 PROVINCIAL PROTECTION: SECTION 29 PERMIT 15.1 None

16 PROVINCIAL PROTECTION: SECTION 29 REFUSAL 16.1 None

17 HERITAGE REGISTER: SECTION 30 PROCESS 17.1 None

18 PUBLIC MONUMENTS & MEMORIALS: SECTION 37 PROCESS 18.1 None

19 REQUEST FOR OPINION/ ADVICE Proposed Development Guidelines and Maintenance Methodology Report for 18030208AS0 HM/LLADUDNO/ERVEN 1430, S27 application, Methodology Report and Development Guidelines to be 19.1 The Apostles Battery, Erven 1430, Andrew September Matter Arising 307M 1432, 1434 & CA902-1 tabled 1432, 1434 and CA902-1, Victoria Avenue, Llandudno

Heritage Statement Draft 2 prepared by Bridget O'Donoghue dated Proposed Additions and Alterations at HM/CAPE 18030626HB0 March 2018; Church Square Urban Design Concept prepared by GAPP 19.2 Church Square, Parliament & Spin METROPOLITAN/CAPE Heidi Boise New Matter 370M dated 17 September 2017 and Technical Presentation dated 27 Street, Cape Town TOWN/ CHURCH SQUARE September 2017 to be tabled

20 OTHER HM\CAPE TOWN Proposed Development of Underground 15101401GT1 METROPOLITAN\GREEN Parking for the Cape Quarter on Erf Stephanie Barnardt 019E POINT\NAPIER STREET ERF 173320, Napier Street, 20.1 173320 HIA and AIA prepared by D Halkett Dated November 2015 to be tabled Matter Arising

HM/WYNBERG/VALLIE Heritage Survey of Vallie Properties Andrew September ERVEN 20.2 Heritage Survey Report prepared by Aikman Associates to be tabled New Matter

21 Adoption of decisions and resolutions 22 Date of next meeting 30-May-18 23 Closure

Final BELCom Agenda_25 April 2018 Page 5 Final BELCom Agenda_25 April 2018 Page 6 Final BELCom Agenda_25 April 2018 Page 7