Experiences of Various Forms of Commercial Partnerships in Indian Railways1
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Experiences of Various Forms of Commercial Partnerships in Indian Railways1 G Raghuram Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad Introduction This paper brings out issues of governance between the Ministry of Railways and various service delivering commercial entities under the Ministry. Some of this is accentuated by both the ministerial and administrative powers vested in the same body, namely the Railway Board. We examine a set of eight case situations, wherein there has been an attempt to focus on a commercial approach. However, the extent of success/failure is varied. A study of these cases brings out the potential of improving railway infrastructure under a governance framework of (i) distancing the ministerial role from the commercial activity, (ii) increased private participation, (iii) improving transparency, contestability and competition, and (iv) appropriate regulations We describe salient features of each of the cases, with comments from the perspective of commercial viability. A concluding section brings out some of the key concepts which would be relevant for such commercial partnerships in the future. At a broader level, given the budgetary constraints, under exploited potential of the IR’s assets and service possibilities, lack of commercially oriented professional and accountable management, such commercial partnerships have implicitly been accepted (by both the central government and the top management of IR) as the way forward. Case Situations The eight case situations with the nature of stake of the Indian Railways (IR) are listed below. There is an attempt to order them on the dimension of decreasing stakes of the IR in the investment. Cases Nature of IR’s Stake 1. CONCOR Wholly owned autonomous company 2. Palace on Wheels (POW) Revenue, cost and investment sharing 3. Railway Sidings Investment sharing 4. Pipavav Railway Corporation Limited SPV with equity partnership (PRCL) 5. Konkan Railway Corporation (KRC) BOT 6. BOLT Schemes for Gauge Conversion BOLT 7. Own Your Wagon Scheme (OYW) Lease payments and service guarantees 8. Catering Contracts License fee and revenue sharing basis 1 We acknowledge the Railway Board, and Mr R K Jain (EDPP) for providing some of the inputs for this documentation. The concept of this paper arose as a result of compiling and analyzing such inputs for the Report of the Expert Group on Railways, 2001. Research assistance by Ms Sushma Chaudhary and Ms Deepa Kheskani is acknowledged. 1 1. CONCOR Introduction CONCOR was incorporated in March 1988 as a Public Sector Undertaking under the Ministry of Railways with the main objective of being a catalyst for promoting containerization and to give a boost to India's international and internal trade and commerce by organizing multimodal logistics support. CONCOR is viewed as one of the success stories of creating a focused corporate entity under the IR. It was established as a separate organisation for undertaking certain concentrated and specialised intermodal activities in the field of containerization where IR had not been able to focus adequate attention. The mission is to develop multimodal logistics support for the country's international and domestic trade and commerce. The objectives are: • To provide transportation logistics services for export-import as well as domestic cargo in containers. • To expand CONCOR's terminal network in the country so as to enhance its market share in container business. • To bring back less than trainload general goods cargo from road to rail in containers through extensive marketing efforts. • To provide multimodal transportation logistics consultancy services to potential operators who would help CONCOR grow its business. Performance Highlights (1998-99) As compared to the previous year (1997-98) 1. Traffic turnover grew by over 11% to 8,01,946 TEUs. 2. Financial turnover increased to Rs 684.77 crores, registering a growth rate of 12.95%. 3. International traffic grew by 17.36%. 4. Domestic general cargo traffic volumes increased by 80% to 57,316. 5. Net profit increased to Rs 140.65 crores from Rs 115.80 crores. 6. Earning per share increased to Rs 21.64 from Rs 17.82. 7. Net worth increased to Rs 472.35 crores from Rs 363.86 crores. Over the past four years, the following growth was achieved: 1994-95 1998-99 CAGR (%) Sales (Rs Crores) 217.34 684.77 33 Profit (Rs Crores) 23.89 140.66 56 TEU's (Lacs) 4.03 8.02 19 2 9 8.02 8 7.04 7.22 7 5.94 6 5 4.03 4 3 2.37 2 1.56 1.08 1 0.52 0.66 0 1989-90 1990-91 1991-92 1992-93 1993-94 1994-95 1995-96 1996-97 1997-98 1998-99 Financial Issues CONCOR was incorporated with an authorized capital of Rs 100 crores. The IR subscribed an amount of Rs 64.99 crores in phases. CONCOR is a profit making company and have been granted 'Mini Ratna' status by the GOI. All the capital requirements are met with by CONCOR either through its internal resources or from a loan sanctioned by International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD). Government of India (GOI) has already disinvested 129 lakh shares in 1994-95 at an average price of Rs 71.15. Thus GOI disinvested their stake in the Company by 23% upto 1995-96. Disinvestment commission studied various aspects of CONCOR and recommended that disinvestment of GOI holding in CONCOR may be restricted to 100 lakh shares and the company may also go in for public issue of 125 lakh shares. This would bring down GOI holding to 51% and therefore, the Company would continue under the control of GOI. Accordingly, GOI further disinvested 9 million shares in Nov ' 98 at a price of Rs 250/- per share. Another one million shares of GOI are required to be disinvested to retail subscribers. A decision in this regard is awaited. GOI shareholding is now reduced to 63%. Remaining shares of about 37% are now held by FIIs, Domestic Financial Institutions, mutual funds, banks and individuals etc. In view of the present cash surplus position of the Company it does not contemplate to raise resources through issue of fresh equity in near future. Management CONCOR is functioning under the direction and supervision of a Board of Directors consisting of a Part time chairman, Managing Director, three functional Directors, two Govt. Directors and three part time non- official Directors. One more post of a Director to look after the domestic traffic is likely to be filled in shortly. The day-to-day function of the company is managed by the Managing Director assisted by three functional Directors viz Director (M&O), Director (Finance) and Director (P&S). Privatization/JVs Over the years, CONCOR has responded to the environment by setting up own container terminals, obtaining new rolling stock and cutting down transit times on key routes (Delhi-Mumbai). Substantial portion of container traffic is transported through IR. Door-to-Door services and transportation of containers from some of the CONCOR facilities which are not connected with IR are undertaken through road. The road transportation is completely outsourced to private contractors. Handling of containers in most of the facilities has also been privatized. Most of the ancillary activities have also been outsourced. 3 Business arrangements have been made with Madhya Pradesh State Warehousing Corporation and the ICD Malanpur at Gwalior is being run with their association. Some more projects for Joint Ventures (JVs) are under consideration by the company. Source: (i) CONCOR, Annual Report, New Delhi,1998-99. (ii) Communication from Railway Board, New Delhi, 2000 (Regarding Financial Issues, Management and Privatization/JVs of CONCOR) Comments While CONCOR is moving in the right direction of creating the necessary infrastructure and service concepts, the pricing for the usage of IR track capacity - a key input cost for CONCOR - is currently an internal administrative matter and not subject to tests of competition or even transparency. 2. Palace on Wheels Introduction The Palace on Wheels (POW) is a joint venture between the IR and Rajasthan Tourism Development Corporation (RTDC). It was introduced with the objective of increasing (i) India's foreign exchange, (ii) overall flow of tourists to India significantly (contributing to India's image abroad), (iii) opportunities for employment, promoting potential of RTDC, by offering a unique rail travel experience. It was first started as a meter gauge service in 1982, using the erstwhile royal saloons of the various princely states of Rajasthan. The over the first five years of service, the average occupancy went up from 41% to 58%. The risk for this service has been shared both by IR and RTDC. In the initial days, the fare was arrived at on a cost plus basis, with 50 % occupancy assumption. The service has grown popular over the years. The entire train was replaced by a newly manufactured meter gauge train set, into which both the parties had invested, in the late eighties. Broad Gauge POW With conversion to broad gauge of the various routes in Rajasthan, the broad gauge POW train was introduced during 1995-96 as a 50-50 joint venture between IR and RTDC. The rake of the POW comprises of 21 coaches. IR and RTDC have mutually decided to run the train in the Rajasthan Sector on the following tourist circuit: Day 1 Wednesday Delhi Cantt Day 2 Thursday Jaipur Day 3 Friday Chittaurgarh & Udaipur Day 4 Saturday Sawai Madhopur Day 5 Sunday Jaisalmer Day 6 Monday Jodhpur Day 7 Tuesday Bharatpur & Agra Day 8 Wednesday Delhi Cantt The financial and management arrangements of the POW between IR and RTDC are currently as under: • IR and RTDC have invested equal share in the capital cost of the rake. The actual cost of the rake as worked out by ICF came to Rs 22.48 crores.