Ability-To-Pay Principle 277 Absolute Advantage Theory (Smith) Normative
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
JOBNAME: Pirlot PAGE: 1 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Fri Sep 15 09:29:28 2017 Index ability-to-pay principle 277 Belgium absolute advantage theory (Smith) carbon equalisation mechanism 77 normative comparative advantage energy taxes 128 vs. 90–91 BEPS (Base Erosion and Profit revised theory and environmental Shifting) project (OECD) 20, BTAs 85–86, 88–89, 97 284 traditional BTAs and 14, 31, 44–47 bilateral/double tax adjustment concept agreement/convention 1, 279 in environmental BTA tax design border carbon adjustment, use of term 122–124 49–50, 121–122 in traditional BTA tax design border concept 102–103 in environmental BTA tax design Agreement on Subsidies and 119–120 Countervailing Measures in traditional BTA tax design (ASCM) 165, 177, 192–195, 222 101–102 Annex I, footnote 58 179, 195–196, border tax adjustments (BTAs) 229 overview 1–5 Annex I, footnote 61 203–204 definition 23–25 Article 1.1/1.1(a)(1)(ii) 178–179, neutrality of 28–29, 33–34 196–197 tax models and 181–183 Article 3.1(a) 177, 178–180, 197 British thermal unit (BTU) energy tax, Article 8 246 proposed 72–73 direct vs. indirect taxes 179 exemptions from national Canada regulations 234 carbon taxes 128 indirect taxes, definition 195–196 disposal fees and BTAs 56–57 aim-and-effect test 214–215 carbon equalisation mechanism anti-dumping measures 97, 98, 120, 76–79, 148 153, 177–178 carbon/pollution leakage 2, 50–51, 66, Australia 68, 76, 82, 145, 247, 254 carbon pricing mechanism 85 carbon taxes 64, 75, 91–92, 127–129 Clean Energy Act (2011) 83, 84–85 model based on environmental Customs Tariff Act (1995) 124 excise duty 133–137 tax system and environmental BTAs carbon-added tax (CAT) 137–146 83–85, 129 carbon value vs. purchase price averaging, in tax rates 32, 73, 80–81, 139–142 194, 206, 236–238, 252 comparison to VAT system 139–142 aviation sector 78–80, 125, 262–263, critique of 144–146 267–268 environmental BTAs and 236–238 323 Alice Pirlot - 9781786435514 Downloaded from Elgar Online at 10/01/2021 02:22:39PM via free access Columns Design XML Ltd / Job: Pirlot-Environmental_border_tax_adjustments / Division: Index /Pg. Position: 1 / Date: 6/9 JOBNAME: Pirlot PAGE: 2 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Fri Sep 15 09:29:28 2017 324 Environmental border tax adjustments and international trade law green-added tax and 142–143 corporate income taxes 190–191 retail carbon tax (RCT) and countervailing measures 49–50, 147–148 97–98, 120 carbon-related BTAs 68–69 see also Agreement on Subsidies cascade taxes 32, 41–42, 106–107, and Countervailing Measures 206 (ASCM) certification systems 150, 153–154, customs duties 24–25, 97, 98, 237–238 102–103, 110, 120, 153 Common but Differentiated customs value 139–142, 151, 166–167 Responsibilities (CBDR) principle 268–274 Denmark comparative advantage theory carbon taxes 127–128 (Ricardo) 184 general vs. specific taxes 25–26 energy taxes 127 in the efficiency-relevant sense value-added tax (1960s) 18 (Howse) 91 destination principle 23–24, 33, normative comparative advantage 39–43, 74, 80–81, 108, 115, vs. 91 184–188 OECD report citation of 59 destination-based corporate taxes (de revised theory and environmental la Feria and Devereux) 187–188, BTAs 85–88, 97, 189–190 194 tax neutrality 15–16, 28 destination-based X tax (Bradford) traditional BTAs and 12–17, 30–31, 182–183 44, 45, 103 developing countries 268–271 competitive advantage vs. 17 adoption of BTAs and 33–34, 69, competitiveness argument 2, 66 71–72, 145, 203–204, 236, absolute advantage theory (Smith) 256–257 46 CBDR principle and 268–271 adoption of environmental BTAs polluter-pays principle and 273–274 and 58–59, 62–63, 88–89, 97, direct vs. indirect taxes 13, 26–32, 132–134 39–40, 179, 188 double dividend hypothesis and 156 see also legal framework, of environmental border taxes and environmental BTAs; legal 50–51 framework, of traditional BTAs in EU 75–76, 81 directly competitive or substitutable excise taxes and 127–128, 226–227 (DCS) products 218–222 subsidies and 158 discriminatory taxes 34, 41, 80–81, see also legitimate absolute 210–211 advantage theory see also legal framework, of conflict diamonds 154, 244–245 environmental BTAs; legal consumption taxes 26–31, 107–114, framework, of traditional BTAs 189, 225–228, 277–278 dissimilar taxation concept 222 see also individual types double dividend hypothesis 156 Convention on Biological Diversity double taxation concept 59, 109–111, 266–267, 274 117, 123, 239–240, 245, Convention on International Trade in 278–281 Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) 275 economic allegiance 187–188 Alice Pirlot - 9781786435514 Downloaded from Elgar Online at 10/01/2021 02:22:39PM via free access Columns Design XML Ltd / Job: Pirlot-Environmental_border_tax_adjustments / Division: Index /Pg. Position: 2 / Date: 13/9 JOBNAME: Pirlot PAGE: 3 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Fri Sep 15 09:29:28 2017 Index 325 electricity (taxes on electricity) 65, revised absolute advantage theory 72–73, 80–82, 127–128 85–86, 88–89, 97 energy taxes 83, 127–128 revised comparative advantage energy-intensive products 73, 74, theory 85–88, 97 75–76, 91–92, 128–129, role of GATT in tax matters 55 133–137, 145, 148, 203–204, role of OECD in tax matters 54 252 summary conclusions 98 environmental border tax adjustments Swiss proposals for 82–83 (BTAs) taxes on inputs as eligible for overview 1–5, 287–288 adjustments 63–65 background of 56–57 US views on 70–74 call to political actors/stakeholders environmental law principles, and 286–288 Critical Legal Studies approach to environmental BTAs 265–276 4–5, 282–284 environmental tariffs 50 definition 58 see also countervailing measures economic foundation of 49–53 environmental taxes summary conclusions 282–288 with cross-border character environmental border taxes 50–53 278–280 environmental BTA history, and distinguished from traditional taxes GATT-WTO/OECD 48–98 224–225 background of 56–57 fiscal nature of 122 definition 58 market-based measures vs. 121–122 direct/indirect and on producers 148 production/product taxes as regulations vs. 3, 231–235 eligible for adjustments 60–63 revenue from 155–158 economic foundation of environmental value of products environmental border taxes 149–151 49–53 environmental VAT model 143–144, EU views on 74–82 146–147 externalities to be internalised 91, equalisation taxes see border tax 95–96, 97 adjustments (BTAs) externality costs 92–94 European Coal and Steel Community GATT/WTO Notes (1997) overview (ECSC) 57–58 Community of Experts, Tinbergen interactions between report 39–42 traditional/environmental BTAs European Court of Justice (ECJ) foundations 96–98 on compatibility with domestic Japanese reports on 82 electricity duty with EU law legitimate absolute advantage 80–81 theory 60, 85–86, 89–92, 95, on inclusion of aviation sector into 97, 285 EU ETS 262–263, 267–268 OECD Note (1994) overview 57–58 on polluter-pays principle 272 other international developments see also Table of Cases 66–69 European Economic Community rationales for 58–60 (EEC) reception of OECD/GATT reports Commission White Paper (1985) 65–66 42–43 Alice Pirlot - 9781786435514 Downloaded from Elgar Online at 10/01/2021 02:22:39PM via free access Columns Design XML Ltd / Job: Pirlot-Environmental_border_tax_adjustments / Division: Index /Pg. Position: 3 / Date: 6/9 JOBNAME: Pirlot PAGE: 4 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Fri Sep 15 09:29:28 2017 326 Environmental border tax adjustments and international trade law tax harmonisation working group Article I, most-favoured nation 11, reports 40–44 166, 238–240, 243, 245, European Union (EU) 256–257, 268–269, 271, 280 Aviation Directive 78–80, 125, Article II/II:2(a) 167–177, 180, 192, 262–263, 267–268 199–201, 204, 242, 283 carbon equalisation mechanism Article III/III:1/III:2/III:4 167–177, 76–79 180, 184, 192–193, 199–202, Directive on energy products and 204–223, 231, 234, 242, 283 electricity 81 Article VI 177–180 emission-trading scheme (ETS) Article VII 166–167, 199 76–78, 121, 125, 148, 232, 234 Article XIX 243–244 excise taxes 43–44, 112–114 Article XVI 177, 180, 192–193, release for consumption, definition 195–196 112–113 Article XX 242–257, 274–276 VAT system 35, 41–43, 105, Article XXI 243–244 107–112, 172, 198, 229–230, Article XXIII 177 237 Article XXIV 243–244 views on environmental BTAs certification systems 154 74–82 Havana Charter 184 views on traditional BTAs 38–44, ‘Industrial Pollution Control and 78 International Trade’ (1971) 55, excise taxes 56, 61 competitiveness argument and Subsidies Code 177 127–128, 226–227 ‘Trade effects of Environmental during 1960s 106–107 Measures’ (1993) 61–62 in EU 43–44, 112–114 Working Party on BTAs 21–24, as models for environmental BTAs 33–34 125–129, 229–230 see also Agreement on Subsidies ODC taxes and 129–137, 236 and Countervailing Measures see also individual types (ASCM); legal framework, of exhaustible natural resources 253–255 environmental BTAs; legal framework, of traditional externalities, definitions 92–94 BTAs; Table of Cases; externality costs 90, 92–96, 146 traditional BTA history, and extraterritoriality 258–263, 278 GATT/OECD; World Trade Organisation (WTO) fair international trade concept 90 General Agreement on Trade in Finland, electricity taxes 80–81 Services (GATS) fiscal sovereignty principle 278 advertising services 201–202 fixed exchange rates 30 Article XIV 245 France exceptions provisions 243–245 carbon equalisation mechanism 77 taxes on services 104–106 TVA taxes 26, 106–107 GHG emissions 68, 124–125, 134, free-rider issues, and MEAs 78 142, 230, 264, 267 goods and services General Agreement on Tariffs and in environmental BTA tax design Trade (GATT) (1947) 11 124–125 Alice Pirlot - 9781786435514 Downloaded from Elgar Online at 10/01/2021 02:22:39PM via free access Columns Design XML Ltd / Job: Pirlot-Environmental_border_tax_adjustments / Division: Index /Pg.