How San Bernardino Terror Attack Survivors Are Struggling with PTSD’S ‘Invisible Wounds’ 2 Years Later – Press Enterprise

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

How San Bernardino Terror Attack Survivors Are Struggling with PTSD’S ‘Invisible Wounds’ 2 Years Later – Press Enterprise 11/17/2017 How San Bernardino terror attack survivors are struggling with PTSD’s ‘invisible wounds’ 2 years later – Press Enterprise LOCAL NEWS How San Bernardino terror attack survivors are struggling with PTSD’s ‘invisible wounds’ 2 years later Paula Harold has a moment with Heidi, a horse she spent time with in a horse therapy program through Equus Medendi Equine Assisted Therapy in Redlands on Wednesday, May 24, 2017. In back is her husband Anthony. Paula is a survivor from the Dec. 2nd terrorist attack in San Bernardino and is now dealing with PTSD. She has completed at least a dozen sessions of the horse therapy program to help her deal with the issues. (Stan Lim, The Press-Enterprise/SCNG) By SUZANNE HURT | [email protected] | The Press-Enterprise November 17, 2017 at 8:22 am She’d never been afraid of horses before. Yet she froze outside the corral — her mind racing with fear as she watched the palomino quarterhorse walk around the corral in an isolated box canyon. Since the Dec. 2, 2015, terrorist attack in San Bernardino, Paula Harold had been afraid, distressed and despondent — diagnosed with post- traumatic stress disorder. Now she was supposed to go in there and begin equine therapy. But she stood behind the fence – heart beating fast, breathing shallow, her body ooded with anxiety. “I’m scared,” she said soly to horse expert Angie Sheer and therapist Susan Lilly at Buffalo Meadows Ranch in Redlands. “I don’t know if it’s going to charge me.” Most days, Paula just stayed home. Reading. Doing housework. Afraid to go out. http://www.pe.com/2017/11/17/how-san-bernardino-terror-attack-survivors-are-struggling-with-ptsds-invisible-wounds-2-years-later/?utm_so… 1/10 11/17/2017 How San Bernardino terror attack survivors are struggling with PTSD’s ‘invisible wounds’ 2 years later – Press Enterprise She had tried things to stop the anxiety and the depression and the fear aer the attack, when she’d seen bullets come through walls as she crawled down a hall to get away while a grazed coworker fell to the oor. Now she wondered how she could return to her job as a San Bernardino County Environmental Health Services supervisor when she no longer believed in herself. Interview with Paula Harold SCNG Invisible wounds Paula is among 57 county workers trying to put their lives back together aer an attack by their coworker, health inspector Syed Rizwan Farook, and his Pakistani-immigrant wife, Tashfeen Malik, at the Inland Regional Center in San Bernardino. Fourteen people were killed and 22 others wounded when a couple bent on hatred walked into a county holiday party/training event with assault ries and opened re shortly aer pledging allegiance to the Islamic State. At the time, the FBI called the mass shooting the deadliest terrorist attack on U.S. soil since 9/11. RELATED: A look back on the San Bernardino terror attack on its rst anniversary Trauma experts say survivors were le with the invisible wounds of post-traumatic stress, which can haunt people like Paula for years or the rest of their lives. http://www.pe.com/2017/11/17/how-san-bernardino-terror-attack-survivors-are-struggling-with-ptsds-invisible-wounds-2-years-later/?utm_so… 2/10 11/17/2017 How San Bernardino terror attack survivors are struggling with PTSD’s ‘invisible wounds’ 2 years later – Press Enterprise http://www.pe.com/2017/11/17/how-san-bernardino-terror-attack-survivors-are-struggling-with-ptsds-invisible-wounds-2-years-later/?utm_so… 3/10 11/17/2017 How San Bernardino terror attack survivors are struggling with PTSD’s ‘invisible wounds’ 2 years later – Press Enterprise Sources: National Institute for Mental Health; PTSD: National Center for PTSD<br />Graphic by: Paul Penzella —SCNG Documented as early as Homer’s “Iliad,” the condition has been known by many names, including “soldier’s heart” and “shell shock,” but was seared into public consciousness by the troubling experiences of returning Vietnam War vets. In the late 1970s, it was given the name post-traumatic stress disorder or PTSD. Researchers estimate 70 percent of U.S. residents, or 226.2 million people, have experienced trauma, and at least eight percent later developed post-traumatic stress. There don’t appear to be studies less than 10 years old updating gures for the new millennium’s era of increased terrorism and mass shootings. In 2005, the National Institutes of Health reported PTSD would likely rise sharply in the next decade and become one of the century’s top health issues. Post-traumatic stress can occur aer someone has experienced or witnessed a frightening event, such as natural disasters, terrorist attacks, military combat, rape and sexual abuse, neglect, serious accidents, violent attacks, hostage situations and diagnosis of a life- threatening condition. According to trauma experts and the American Psychiatric Association’s latest diagnostic manual, PTSD involves disabling, simultaneous reactions to trauma lasting more than a month. Those reactions include distressing, intrusive memories taking shape as nightmares and ashbacks; avoidance; negative thoughts or feelings like guilt and helplessness; hypervigilance and fear, which limits sleep, concentration and feeling secure. While anatomical or physiological differences in the brain and harmful childhood experiences such as abuse or illness can leave people more at risk for PTSD, the most inuential factor is how close they were to the traumatizing event, said trauma science pioneer Frank Ochberg. “A perfectly normal person will get PTSD given enough stress,” he said. Journey toward healing Paula was standing in the conference room, waiting to be in a group photo, when she saw a man in black walk in with a rie. She remembers her confusion as bullets and gunpowder ew. She heard the shots but can’t remember seeing or hearing anything else. Her mind blanks until she’s in the hall, crawling away while Marilyn Krichbaum, a coworker returning from the bathroom, drops to the ground aer a bullet grazes her stomach. Paula crawled into a nearby room following others who’d escaped, then saw there was no way out. She crammed into a storage cabinet and prayed the shooting would stop. Coworkers hid in other cabinets while lead Environmental Health Specialist Hal Houser, Vector Control Program Manager Jason Phillippe and Public Health Assistant Director Corwin Porter held the doors closed. Paula’s husband, Tony Harold, drove her home that night and held her the rest of the evening. They’d always been a strong team. Shaken up aer not reaching her for hours, Tony knew he’d have to be mentally tough — the backbone who’d pull the family together. He answered the front door when journalists came knocking – which sounded to Paula like gunshots. http://www.pe.com/2017/11/17/how-san-bernardino-terror-attack-survivors-are-struggling-with-ptsds-invisible-wounds-2-years-later/?utm_so… 4/10 11/17/2017 How San Bernardino terror attack survivors are struggling with PTSD’s ‘invisible wounds’ 2 years later – Press Enterprise He set up cameras outside the house. Applied for a concealed weapons permit. And never le her side. When it was clear she’d been le with post-traumatic stress disorder, they began a journey toward healing whose end remains out of sight. “I’m not a cheap tent. I’m not going to fold up when things are bad,” he said. Panic and fear Post-traumatic stress can last for decades or become a life-long condition. Those who get early, effective treatment usually recover quicker and are less likely to have long-term PTSD. Dec. 2 survivors didn’t get counseling the day of the attack, yet rst responders did – as did survivors of the North Park Elementary School shooting that killed a teacher and student in San Bernardino this year. Houser said what people need to know about that day is no trauma experts helped survivors at the scene. “I don’t think there’s a dedicated, trained, terrorist response aer-effects team – and that really needs to happen,” he said. Time, his family and focusing on everyday life — lugging the kids to school, getting groceries and walking the dogs — have helped reduce his post-traumatic stress. “All these things help you realize your life is still going. But you do always look over your shoulder,” Houser said, sounding sad. Interview with Hal Houser SCNG He’s felt relief and guilt over surviving. He’d like the public, including mental health professionals, to better understand post-traumatic stress and legitimize what survivors feel aer terrorist attacks. “Especially for some of the survivors that laid on that oor in that room while the killer went around and shot people methodically that were still in agony, or sat there wondering whether he was going to come and shoot them – listening to these sounds for ve minutes, wondering when the police were gonna be there to rescue them – that’s a lot of terror that can really mess up somebody’s mind,” he said. Ray Britain, who was interim chief of the Environmental Health Services division Dec. 2, and other survivors never understood the term PTSD until they experienced the physical and emotional symptoms. He’s had high anxiety that’s kept him home. Depression. And tension, with his body aching from adrenalin that ows in ght-or-ight reactions stuck on overdrive. Insomnia – both going to sleep and staying asleep – comes as the event replays over and over in his head. He’s had panic attacks where his heart raced and he felt about to asphyxiate. “I never experienced a panic attack before.
Recommended publications
  • San Bernardino County California, U
    ADELANTO CITY SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY CALIFORNIA, U. S. A. San Bernardino County. Condado de San Bernardino Officially the County of San Bernardino, is a county located in the Oficialmente, el Condado de San Bernardino, es un condado ubicado en la southern portion of the U.S. state of California, and is located within the parte sur del estado de California en los Estados Unidos, y se encuentra dentro Inland Empire area. As of the 2010 U.S. Census, the population was del área del Inland Empire. A partir del censo estadounidense de 2010, la 2,035,210, making it the fifth-most populous county in California and the población era de 2.035.210, lo que lo convierte en el quinto condado más 14th-most populous in the United States. The county seat is San Bernardino. poblado de California y el 14º más poblado de los Estados Unidos. La sede del condado es San Bernardino. While included within the Greater Los Angeles area, San Bernardino Si bien se incluye dentro del área metropolitana de Los Ángeles, el County is included in the Riverside–San Bernardino–Ontario metropolitan condado de San Bernardino se incluye en el área estadística metropolitana statistical area (also known as the Inland Empire), as well as the Los Riverside-San Bernardino-Ontario (también conocida como Inland Empire), así Angeles–Long Beach combined statistical area. como el área estadística combinada Los Ángeles-Long Beach. With an area of 20,105 square miles (52,070 km2), San Bernardino Con un área de 20,105 millas cuadradas (52,070 km2), el condado de San County is the largest county in the United States by area, although some of Bernardino es el condado más grande de los Estados Unidos por área, aunque Alaska's boroughs and census areas are larger.
    [Show full text]
  • 2017 Major League and Minor League Baseball Attendance Highlights
    2017 MAJOR LEAGUE AND MINOR LEAGUE BASEBALL ATTENDANCE HIGHLIGHTS This is a brief summary of 2017 Major League and Minor League Baseball attendance. It includes league and team attendance totals in the pages that follow the notes below. The Minor League highlights summary, and their team and league attendance listings, can be found starting on Page 13, after the Major League notes and statistics. The 2017 full Minor League Baseball Attendance Analysis is expected to be posted on numbertamer.com by late December, 2017 or early January, 2018. The 2017 complete Major League Analysis should be ready by May, 2018. The full analyses for each season from 2009 through 2016 are available on the ‘Baseball Reports’ page of numbertamer.com. An updated version of the 2016 Major League Analysis, showing 2016 and 2017 attendance data in other sports besides baseball, has been posted, and it will be updated again in early December, 2017. If you need any further information before the 2017 comprehensive reports are published, please contact David Kronheim – [email protected], 718-591-2043. This data will be provided free-of-charge. SOURCES: Major League attendance data was obtained from the Major League Baseball Information System. The office of Minor League Baseball (formerly known as the NAPBL) provided figures for the Major League affiliated leagues. Independent leagues data came from each league’s Website. In general, Major and Minor League attendance data is compiled from figures announced in box scores, includes tickets sold but not used, and may include tickets distributed for free. Attendance for the Pecos Baseball League was provided by the league, and only includes tickets sold and used.
    [Show full text]
  • DA's Report on San Bernardino Terrorist Attack Highlights Police
    5/25/2017 DA’s report on San Bernardino terrorist attack highlights police bravery in gun battle – Press Enterprise NEWS DA’s report on San Bernardino terrorist attack highlights police bravery in gun battle Law enforcement personnel toward the scene where the perpetrators of the Inland Regional Center attack were shot and killed on Wednesday, Dec. 2, 2015. A recent report lays out exactly how law enforcement officers from multiple agencies responded to the attack and killed the attackers. File photo by David Danelski, staff) By SUZANNE HURT | [email protected] | The Press-Enterprise PUBLISHED: May 24, 2017 at 9:05 pm | UPDATED: May 25, 2017 at 12:17 am San Bernardino terrorist attack survivors and victims’ relatives will get a chance Thursday, May 25, to ask questions about a report released this week detailing how police of툁cers took down the assailants on Dec. 2, 2015. The San Bernardino County District Attorney’s 55-page interof툁ce memo, whose subject is simply “Of툁cer Involved Fatal Incident,” lays out exactly how law enforcement of툁cers from multiple agencies responded to the Inland Regional Center within minutes of the attack and killed the attackers in a massive gun툁ght nearby several hours later. http://www.pe.com/2017/05/24/das-report-on-san-bernardino-terrorist-attack-highlights-police-bravery-in-gun-battle/ 1/3 5/25/2017 DA’s report on San Bernardino terrorist attack highlights police bravery in gun battle – Press Enterprise San Bernardino County employee Syed Rizwan Farook was hit by at least 27 gunshots while his wife was struck by at least 15 – two to the top of the head — as of툁cers 툁red about 440 rounds from ri㰀es, shotguns and handguns – which the report found were proper uses of deadly force in self-defense and the defense of others.
    [Show full text]
  • Santa Clara Magazine, Volume 59 Number 1, Spring 2018 Santa Clara University
    Santa Clara University Scholar Commons Santa Clara Magazine SCU Publications Spring 2018 Santa Clara Magazine, Volume 59 Number 1, Spring 2018 Santa Clara University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.scu.edu/sc_mag Part of the Arts and Humanities Commons, Business Commons, Education Commons, Engineering Commons, Law Commons, Life Sciences Commons, Medicine and Health Sciences Commons, Physical Sciences and Mathematics Commons, and the Social and Behavioral Sciences Commons Recommended Citation Santa Clara University, "Santa Clara Magazine, Volume 59 Number 1, Spring 2018" (2018). Santa Clara Magazine. 33. https://scholarcommons.scu.edu/sc_mag/33 This Book is brought to you for free and open access by the SCU Publications at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Santa Clara Magazine by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Santa Clara Magazine A global effort based at Nobel origins: Hersh Grief, loss, and Poet Dana Gioia on SCU to restore trust in Shefrin and behavioral recovery in the wake true crime and a journalism. Page 22 economics. Page 28 of disaster. Page 32 cowboy ballad. Page 50 TRUST 09/08/17 BRACING FOR IRMA: The hurricane barreled through the Turks and Caicos Islands en route to Florida. It was one of several major hurricanes in the Atlantic last season—along with Harvey, Maria, and Jose. Why was the season so destructive? Climate change was likely a factor. Though scientists are careful to avoid pointing to one event and saying, “See? We told you so!” notes Iris Stewart-Frey, an associate professor of environmental studies and sciences whose research focuses on water cycles.
    [Show full text]
  • The MONTEREY Amberjacks Begin Their Second Season
    Playing Two on, two Since its out, bottom of the inception in 2010, Photos by Nic Coury ninth. With the score knotted the Pecos League has been at 2-2, Paul Garcia digs in at the through ups and downs. Last plate. year, however, the league expanded, It’s the Friday night home opener for adding the Monterey squad and experi- the Monterey Amberjacks. Maybe a hundred encing perhaps its most stable season, and fans remain and now many of them lean toward headed into 2018 with a sense of security. But the edge of their seats with interest in the game’s everything changed in March, when Congress outcome renewed. The team pushed across runs in passed a federal budget that included an obscure the fifth and sixth innings to even the score, but had item—known as the Save America’s Pastime Act—at offered little threat since. Now, without hitting a ball the behest of major league owners. out of the infield, the Amberjacks have an opportunity Minor leaguers playing for affiliated teams in the to win. Batting ahead of Garcia, Chuck Rocker reached major league system earn salaries that often fall below second on an infield error. The potential game-winning run minimum wage, particularly when overtime—travel, pre- stands on third, in the form of a player named Caldwell—G. game workouts, team meetings—is accounted for. Average Caldwell according to the box score—a pinch hitter who monthly income in the lower reaches of Class A ball was at waited out a 3-2 count and drew a walk, advancing on the $1,100 last year, rising to $2,150 at the AAA level.
    [Show full text]
  • An Open Letter to Chairman Hagman and the Board of Supervisors - News - Vvdailypress.Com - Victorville, CA
    6/24/2019 An open letter to Chairman Hagman and the Board of Supervisors - News - vvdailypress.com - Victorville, CA An open letter to Chairman Hagman and the Board of Supervisors By Joseph W. Brady Posted Jun 23, 2019 at 6:37 AM Dear Chairman Hagman and Members of the Board: With negotiations currently underway between San Bernardino County and the Sheriff’s Employee Benefits Association, it is imperative that I once again call your attention to the need for more law enforcement personnel to be deployed to the High Desert portion of the County, as well as the importance of offering competitive compensation to the County’s law enforcement officers. After going without pay increases for five years during the Great Recession, SEBA negotiated a nine percent pay increase (three percent annually from 2016- 19) in an effort to close the gap between compensation offered by our county and law enforcement salaries in neighboring jurisdictions. With these recent increases, the salaries paid to our sheriff’s deputies are now more competitive; it is essential that this progress be maintained in the current round of negotiations. Of even greater importance is the need to increase Sheriff’s Department staffing, particularly in the High Desert. In a recent conversation I had with Sheriff John McMahon, he indicated that 52 additional deputies were needed in the High Desert in order to reach appropriate staffing levels. It is, therefore, not sufficient to merely maintain salaries at a competitive level; the number of deputies must be significantly increased as well. Over the past several years on the pages of the Daily Press, I have written extensively about the crime problems we face in the High Desert and the negative effects that high crime and the public’s perception of our region as a high crime area have had on housing sales and commercial and economic development.
    [Show full text]
  • Southern California Journalism Awards
    LOS ANGELES PRESS CLUB SIXTY-FIRST 6ANNUAL SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA 1JOURNALISM AWARDS 61st ANNUAL SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA 2019 JOURNALISM AWARDS Honored to receive A LETTER FROM THE PRESS CLUB PRESIDENT OOD EVENING and welcome to the 61st annual 56 Southern California Journalism awards. GI can’t tell you how happy I am to be serving as president of a press organization that is setting records in 2019. We did it again, Los Angeles with more than 1,700 entries to the Southern California Journalism KCET President & CEO Michael Riley and CCO Juan Devis invite you to join us in Awards this year. To put that in perspective, when our Executive Director Diana Press Club Ljungaeus took over we were averaging about 300 entries annually. Hats off to Diana and her amazing team who do such a great job JournalismSHINING A LIGHT every year putting together the ceremony. You can see in the categories and the nominees the changing Award Chris Palmeri nature of our industry. As brilliant as the individual work we are ON L.A. honoring today is, the fact is that what we do has never been nominations! more ubiquitous, nor more important in Southern California and Help celebrate the launch of new seasons of KCET Original around the world. Series SoCal Connected, Town Hall Los Angeles and Lost L.A. Our Club and our members have had a strong start to 2019 More than any local through events such as the private tour of the Ruth Bader Ginsberg exhibit at the Skirball Cultural Center we organized in January, L.A.
    [Show full text]
  • 2017 Mega-Rankings
    No. TEAM AVERAGE LEVEL OF PLAY LEAGUE CITY STATE 1 Indianapolis Indians 9,159 AAA International Indianapolis IN 2 Charlotte Knights 9,109 AAA International Charlotte NC 3 Columbus Clippers 9,060 AAA International Columbus OH 4 Nashville Sounds 8,861 AAA Pacific Coast Nashville TN 5 Round Rock Express 8,724 AAA Pacific Coast Round Rock TX 6 Lehigh Valley IronPigs 8,541 AAA International Allentown PA 7 St. Paul Saints 8,296 Independent Pro Amer Assn St. Paul MN 8 Buffalo Bison 8,101 AAA International Buffalo NY 9 Dayton Dragons 8,038 A-Low Midwest Daytona OH 10 Sacramento River Cats 8,032 AAA Pacific Coast Sacramento CA 11 Albuquerque Isotopes 7,978 AAA Pacific Coast Albuquerque NM 12 El Paso Chihuahuas 7,894 AAA Pacific Coast El Paso TX 13 Iowa Cubs 7,763 AAA Pacific Coast Des Moines IA 14 Durham Bulls 7,716 AAA International Durham NC 15 Toledo Mud Hens 7,614 AAA International Toledo OH 16 Salt Lake Bees 6,903 AAA Pacific Coast Salt Lake City UT 17 Louisville Bats 6,868 AAA International Louisville KY 18 Frisco RoughRiders 6,812 AA Texas Frisco TX 19 Rochester Red Wings 6,553 AAA International Rochester NY 19 Oklahoma City Dodgers 6,533 AAA Pacific Coast Oklahoma City OK 21 Scranton/W-B RailRiders 6,462 AAA International Moosic PA 22 Pawtucket Red Sox 6,406 AAA International Pawtucket RI 23 Madison Mallards 6,308 Summer Collegiate Northwoods Madison WI 24 Vancouver Canadians 6,303 A-Short Season Northwest Vancouver BC 25 Fresno Grizzlies 6,208 AAA Pacific Coast Fresno CA 26 Reading Fightin Phils 6,054 AA Eastern Reading PA 27 Richmond
    [Show full text]
  • High Desert Report
    Spring 2017 l Volume 56 The RADCO CompaniesHigh Desert Report An economic overview of the High Desert region affiliated with The Bradco Companies, a commercial real estate group Having begun our First, I wish to welcome our current, nities that life has to offer. first edition of the future, and long-standing subscribers I would like to welcome and thank many Bradco High Desert and sponsors of the 56th Edition of The of our article suppliers who continuous- Report in May of Bradco High Desert Report, the first ly support our efforts to prompt the High 1993, how could we and only full economic overview of the Desert region. We are extremely excited ever have thought High Desert region, covering the North- to introduce Ontario International Air- that in 2017 we ern portion of San Bernardino County port Authority, an article by Mr. Daniel would be preparing and,most specifically, the Cities of Ad- Adamus, MPA and Chief Marketing Of- for the 56th Edition elanto, Barstow, Hesperia, Victorville, ficer of this truly exceptional economic of this publication? and the Town of Apple Valley. asset located in Ontario, California. Inside This Issue For those who continuously inquire into If you have never flown in or out of On- the medical condition of our original ed- tario, I strongly urge you to do so. Now “flyOntario” - Under Local Control and Look- itor, Dr. Alfred Gobar, he continues “to the airport is controlled by a local entity, ing to Grow .................................................2 beat cancer,” continues to work with his and I believe that reading this article Caltrans Continues Work in the doctors in maintaining his lifestyle in will be very exciting to everyone who High Desert ................................................5 retirement, and spending all day doing Looking Forward as We Set Priorities for The has any understanding of the long battle Future ..........................................................5 “stock trading.” We talk to Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • California As Music to American Ears
    CALIFORNIA AS MUSIC TO AMERICAN EARS: Migration, Technology, and Rock and Roll in the Golden State, 1946-2000 A Thesis presented to the Faculty of California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts in History by Toby Thomas Willett Winter 2010 “http://digitalcommons.calpoly.edu/theses/264/” © 2010 Toby Thomas Willett ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii COMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP TITLE: California as Music to American Ears: Migration, Technology, and Rock and Roll in the Golden State, 1946-2000 AUTHOR: Toby Thomas Willett DATE SUBMITTED: March 2010 COMMITTEE CHAIR: George Cotkin, Professor COMMITTEE MEMBER: Tom Trice, Professor COMMITTEE MEMBER: John Snetsinger, Professor iii ABSTRACT California as Music to American Ears: Migration, Technology, and Rock and Roll in the Golden State, 1946-2000 Toby Thomas Willett Migrations and technological advances in California following World War II, spurred radical changes in the production and development of popular music, most notably rock and roll. California largely lacked the entrenched traditions of the American Northeast, and in many ways its exploding population translated into the growth of a culture built around embracing newer methodologies, whether technological innovations or radical artistic departures. In large part owing to its increasing ethnic diversity during the economic expansion, California was uniquely poised to become a center of incredible postwar dynamism, especially when seen in the production , consumption , and stylistic development of music. Nevertheless, many of the radical departures in American music were contingent upon the contributions of a small group of inter-connected musical equipment manufacturers and musicians in California from the 1940s through the 1960s.
    [Show full text]