DOCSLIB.ORG

How Has Your Understanding of Personal Perspectives Been Illuminated by Your Comparative Study of the Poetry of Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes?

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
How Has Your Understanding of Personal Perspectives Been Illuminated by Your Comparative Study of the Poetry of Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes? How has your understanding of personal perspectives been illuminated by your comparative study of the poetry of Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes? The comparative study of the poetry of Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes illuminates how the differing perspectives change the ideas authors present in their texts. Plath’s confessional poems, ‘Daddy’ and ‘A Birthday Present’, Ariel (2001), assert her disconnection from the neglectful men in her life to show her newfound independence. Additionally, Plath shows how stifling domesticity caused her to seek freedom through death. Hughes provides his personal perspective to reframe Plath’s ideas in ‘The Shot’ and ‘Red’, Birthday Letters (1999), to argue that Plath’s unstable psyche was the cause of her suicide, rather than his neglect as a husband. Hughes also inverts Plath’s ideas to show that her unstable psyche caused her suicide, not the patriarchy. Comparing the work of Plath and Hughes illuminates how the personal perspectives of these authors change the narratives that they present in their work. Plath asserts her disconnection from her neglectful father and husband to show her newfound independence in ‘Daddy’. Plath’s father, Otto, neglected his own health and died when Plath was only eight years old, traumatising her for life. This prompted Plath to disconnect from Otto, as evidenced by the repetition of “You do not do, you do not do” to share her perspective on the inadequacy of Otto as a father. Plath uses Nazi symbolism, “Chuffing me off like a Jew. A Jew to Dachau”, to illuminate the neglect she received from Otto. Plath claims that “Every woman adores a fascist”, using the extended ‘Nazi’ metaphor, to justify her acceptance of her mistreatment. Plath states that “I made a model of you”, using metaphor to illuminate Hughes’ neglect of her. Plath portrays a feminist metanarrative by disconnecting from Otto and Hughes, using pause to declare “Daddy, daddy, you bastard, I’m through”, providing her new personal perspective on these men. Plath uses her enlightened perspective to paint herself as powerful and independent by criticising and disconnecting from the neglectful male figures in her life. While Plath asserts her disconnection from the neglectful men in her life, Hughes uses ‘The Shot’ to reframe these events from his perspective and argue that Plath’s unstable psyche was the cause of her suicide, rather than his neglect as a husband. Hughes’ writing of ‘The Shot’ followed the societal embrace of the Western feminist movement causing him to absolve himself of any blame after the backlash he received from Plath’s death. Hughes demonstrates Plath’s obsessive personality to distance himself from any accusations, using the extended ‘god’ metaphor to prove that she had existing deep-seated issues with her psyche, “Your worship needed a god.” This is contrary to Plath’s claim that “I made a model of you”, which asserts that Hughes’ treatment of her echoed that of her father. Hughes elaborates and explains how Otto’s death traumatised Plath, using the bullet metaphor, “Your Daddy had been aiming you at God when his death pulled the trigger”, to provide his perspective on why Plath was so unstable. Hughes uses metonyms of depression, “sob-sodden Kleenex”, “Saturday night panics”, to highlight Plath’s depression from his perspective and show that he was not the root cause of her issues. Hughes continues his use of symbolism to explain that Plath’s ‘god’ was her father, “you had gone clean through me – to bury yourself at last in the heart of the god”, to show how he was powerless against her will to die. Hughes shifts the perspective from Plath’s to his own, to illuminate and provide insight into how Plath’s psyche ultimately led to her death. In 'A Birthday Present', Plath demonstrates how patriarchal oppression caused her to feel that suicide was the only way she could be free. While Plath was married to Hughes, she was resigned to most domestic duties, while raising their children, writing poetry and publishing the couple’s work. Plath uses anthropomorphism of ‘death’, “When I am quiet at my cooking I can feel it looking”, to explain how her subjugation to her patriarchal role degrades her mental health. Plath accentuates her hatred for her role by using the symbol of “rules, to rules” to show how she lacks self-government and freedom. Plath provides her perspective using an unapologetic tone, “I would have killed myself gladly”, to demonstrate how stifling domesticity induces her suicidal urges. The middle of the poem marks a turning point to demonstrate her desperation for freedom from her domestic life, as evidenced by the ‘veil’ motif, “Only let down the veil… If it were death.” Plath ultimately glorifies suicide with the use of simile, “Pure and clean as the cry of a baby”, to show her deep and inherent desire to end her life as a result of her forced domesticity. Plath shows the reader how her domestic lifestyle under the patriarchy causes her to wish for freedom through death. While Plath shows how domesticity made her wish for death, Hughes recontextualises Plath’s narrative in ‘Red’ to contradict Plath and prove that her volatility actively destroyed their family, not the patriarchy. During their relationship, Hughes benefitted from Plath’s prolific talents, but at the expense of her volatility and anger. Hughes uses symbolism, “Red was your colour… Blood-red.”, to highlight the extent of Plath’s inner turmoil and anger. Hughes shows how Plath’s volatility invaded even their intimate life, using symbolism, “Our room was red”, to explain how Plath’s volatility was inescapable. Hughes uses connotations of purity associated with ‘white’, “Only the bookshelves escaped into whiteness”, to show how Plath’s writing painted her in a greater light. Hughes claims that “Blue was your kindly spirit… electrified, a guardian, thoughtful”, using the motif of colour to demonstrate Plath’s dual nature. Hughes displays how Plath’s instability controlled her life with metaphor, “In the pit of red… the jewel you lost was blue”, to show how Plath’s volatility ultimately destroyed their family and relationship. Hughes provides his personal perspective to illuminate how Plath’s volatility and anger destroyed their relationship, and not her domestic role. Through the comparative analysis of Plath and Hughes poems, we are given an insight into how personal perspectives affect one’s retelling of events. Plath asserts her disconnection from neglectful men and her suffering as a result of her domesticity in her poems. However, upon reading Hughes work where we are shown how Hughes believes he was not responsible for Plath’s death and that her volatility and anger destroyed their relationship, we can use both perspectives of these poets to have a better understanding of their lives. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Ethnicity, Lyricism, and John Berryman's Dream Songs
    Imaginary Jews and True Confessions: Ethnicity, Lyricism, and John Berryman’s Dream Songs ANDREW GROSS . Jews, who have changed much in the course of history, are certainly no race, [but] the anti‐Semites in a way are a race, because they always use the same slogans, display the same attitudes, indeed almost look alike. —Max Horkheimer1 John Berryman’s “The Imaginary Jew,” published in the Kenyon Review of 1945, is in some ways a rather programmatic account of one man’s conversion from parlor anti‐ Semitism to a feeling of solidarity with Jews. The climax occurs when a bigot accuses the narrator of being Jewish in order to discredit him in an argument over Roosevelt’s foreign policy prior to the American entry into World War II. The accusation completely unnerves the narrator in ways he does not immediately understand, and he is shocked to see that it discredits him in the eyes of the crowd, which has assembled at Union Square to hear impromptu debates. Later, after leaving the scene of his embarrassment, he decides to lay claim to this mistaken, or imaginary, identity, and comes to the following conclusion about the nature of prejudice: “My persecutors were right: I was a Jew. The imaginary Jew I was was as real as the imaginary Jew hunted down, on other nights and days, in a real Jew. Every murderer strikes the mirror, the lash of the torturer falls on the mirror and cuts the real image, and the real and the imaginary blood flow down together.”2 The story garnered some attention when it appeared in 1945.
    [Show full text]
  • Double Image : the Hughes-Plath Relationship As Told in Birthday Letters
    Copyright is owned by the Author of the thesis. Permission is given for a copy to be downloaded by an individual for the purpose of research and private study only. The thesis may not be reproduced elsewhere without the permission of the Author. Double Image: The Hughes-Plath Relationship As Told in Birthday Letters. .A thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Philosophy in English at Massey University Helen Jacqueline Cain 2002 II CONTENTS Abstract................................................ .iii Acknowledgements ....................................... .iv Introduction.............................................. 1 Chapter One -Ted Hughes on Trial. ......................... 10 Chapter Two - The Structure of Birthday Letters. ...............22 Chapter Three - Delivered of Yourself........................ .40 Chapter Four - The Man in Black. .................... 53 Chapter Five - Daddy Coming Up From Out of the Well......... 69 Chapter Six - Fixed Stars Govern a Life ........................74 Conclusion............................................... 80 Works Cited.............................................. 83 Works Consulted......................................... 87 iii ABSTRACT Proceeding from a close reading of both Birthdqy Letters and the poems of Sylvia Plath, and also from a consideration of secondary and biographical works, I argue that implicit within Birthdqy Letters is an explanation for Sylvia Plath's death and Ted Hughes's role in it. Birthdqy Letters is a collection of 88 poems written by Ted Hughes to his first wife, the poet Sylvia Plath, in the years following her death. There are two aspects to the explanation Ted Hughes provides. Both are connected to Sylvia Plath's poetry. Her development as a poet not only causes her death as told in Birthdqy Letters, but it also renders Ted Hughes incapable of helping her, because through her poetry he is made to adopt the role of Plath's father.
    [Show full text]
  • Confronted Patriarchy in Sylvia Plath's Poems
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by TEFLIN (Teaching English as a Foreign Language in Indonesia) Journal (State University... CONFRONTED PATRIARCHY IN SYLVIA PLATH'S POEMS Kukuh Prayitno Subagyo Universitas Negeri Malang, Indonesia Abstract: The American literary canons, mainly those of the nineteen fifties and the nineteen sixties, had consistently portrayed women as subservient citizens. Women in the American culture had been put under men s domina- tion and thus lost their identity and been unable to determine their own fate. They played roles long prescribed by men, both in the home and in their so- cial milieu. As products of the era, a number of Sylvia Plath s poems depict confrontation against this phenomenon of patriarchy in which women have been inferior to and abused by men; they fight for freedom and to regain their true roles as women and human beings. Key words: the American literary canons, patriarchy, Sylvia Plath s poems The American nineteen fifties and sixties have witnessed the advent of literary works portraying women s struggle for liberation, the so-called Women s Movement, whose members turned out to be assertive activists struggling for the sake of their fellow woman citizens. The Women s Movement for libera- tion gained its momentum during these decades, and continued to color the lit- erary works of all genres even in the ensuing years. In fact, such woman- related themes as feminism, women studies, and women s emancipation have dominated not only the American literary genres but those of the world as well beyond the turn of the second millennium.
    [Show full text]
  • Sylvia and the Absence of Life Before Ted
    http://dx.doi.org/10.5007/2175-7917.2018v23n1p133 SYLVIA AND THE ABSENCE OF LIFE BEFORE TED. Mariana Chaves Petersen* Instituto Federal de Educação, Ciência e Tecnologia do Rio Grande do Sul Abstract: As Bronwyn Polaschek mentions in The Postfeminist Biopic, the film Sylvia (Christine Jeffs, 2003) is based on biographies of Sylvia Plath that focus on her relationship with husband Ted Hughes – such as Janet Malcolm’s The Silent Woman. In this paper, grounded in the works of Linda Hutcheon, Mary E. Hawkesworth, and Tracy Brain, I argue that this biography works as a palimpsest of Sylvia and that the film constructs Plath as the Ariel persona, neglecting her “Juvenilia” – her early poetry, as it has been defined by Hughes. Sylvia actually leaves Plath’s early life – before she met Hughes – aside and it thus ends up portraying her more as a wife than as a writer. Finally, by bringing information on Plath’s life before she met Hughes from a more recent biography (by Andrew Wilson), I analyze how a different image of Plath might have been created if this part of her life were not missing in the film. Keywords: Sylvia. Sylvia Plath. Adaptation studies. Biopic. Feminist criticism. She wanted to be everything, I think. She was always searching for the self that she was going to be. — Elinor Friedman Klein, qtd. in Andrew Wilson, Mad Girl Love’s Song How can you be so many women to so many people, oh you strange girl? — Sylvia Plath, from her journals Introduction: a chosen branch Several were the attempts to fictionalize Sylvia Plath by making her a character in novels, poems, films, and biographies.
    [Show full text]
  • Review of the Spoken Word: Sylvia Plath (British Library 2010), ISBN
    Plath Profiles 361 Review of The Spoken Word: Sylvia Plath (British Library 2010), ISBN: 978-0-712351-02-7 and The Spoken Word: Ted Hughes: Poems and Short Stories (British Library and BBC 2008), ISBN: 978-0-712305-49-5 Carol Bere Dramatic, visceral, occasionally mesmerizing, memorable—there is little question that these separate recordings from the archives of the BBC and the British Library of live and studio broadcasts of Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes reading their poetry offer sheer pleasure in themselves. Yet let me offer a brief caveat at the outset: this review is in no way meant to be a comparison of the poetry of Plath and Hughes, or a critical analysis of the ways in which they influenced each other's work—although I do assume mutual influence at various stages in their writing (and lives)—but rather a commentary on the separate BBC recordings, and perhaps a recognition of areas or periods of intersection in their careers. Hughes obviously had a much longer career, and these BBC recordings (two discs) reflect a span of over 30 years of writing, while the Plath recording (one disc) includes poems and interviews beginning in late l960 through January 1963. Along with knowledgeable introductions to the recordings by Peter K. Steinberg (Plath) and Alice Oswald (Hughes), respectively, these recordings are also invaluable guides to the early work (particularly in Plath's case), "hearing" both poets in the process of becoming, and, perhaps, gaining additional perspective on the poetry of both poets. What is also apparent in these recordings of Plath and Hughes is the necessity, or more realistically, the benefits of hearing poetry read aloud to fully understand the range of a poet's enterprise and achievement.
    [Show full text]
  • Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes: Layers of Literary Collaboration and The
    Plath Profiles 275 Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes: Layers of Literary Collaboration and the Perpetuation of the Poetic Voice Natalie Chambers The partnership of Ted Hughes and Sylvia Plath was arguably one of the most mutually productive literary pairings of the twentieth century, and while the work produced during their six-and-a-half year marriage was substantial in its sheer volume and artistic merit, the bulk of the critical discussion regarding their partnership focuses not on their prolific literary production but on the marriage itself and the events that led up to Plath's suicide in February of 1963. While countless books and critical essays have been written, at a distance, about this relationship—their partnership and the tumultuous passion that fueled their creative fires—these texts are inextricably rooted in speculation, cultivated by critical hypotheses and, ultimately, dependent upon the interpretations of outsiders. Even the most in-depth investigations of their marriage and respective works—like the many biographies and essays written by major Plath scholars Susan Van Dyne, Jacqueline Rose, Lynda Bundtzen, and Anne Stevenson, as well as the biography of their marriage written by Diane Middlebrook—still remain mere versions of the truth, individual interpretations of the details that constituted a collaborative life, the work it created, and the eventual culmination in Plath's death. It is not uncommon for artists to gain posthumous notoriety and critical attention, and thus sell more of their work, as was the case with Sylvia Plath. Though her death was undoubtedly a tragic loss of talent and silencing of a powerful poetic voice, it also evoked a conflagration of public and critical interest in her work and created a flurry of activity among the literary community to publish it.
    [Show full text]
  • Sylvia Plath's “Daddy” As Autobiography
    IAFOR Journal of Arts & Humanities Volume 7 – Issue 1 – Summer 2020 Sylvia Plath’s “Daddy” as Autobiography Najoua Stambouli University of Sfax, Tunisia Abstract Sylvia Plath’s Ariel collection of poems placed her among the United States’ most important confessional poets of the twentieth century. Almost all the poems in Ariel, which were written during the last few months of Plath’s life and published after her death, are “personal, confessional, felt” (Lowell, 1996, p. xiii). Several events that are mentioned in these poems make reference to the poet’s own life experience. Plath, indeed, “transformed her own life into writing” (Bassnett, 2005, p. 5). Analyses such as these have led some critics to consider much of Plath’s poetry to be an eloquent expression of her own factual experience. “Daddy”, one of the best-known poems in the Ariel volume, incorporates several autobiographical details worthy of note. The first part of this research paper is an investigation into the diverse autobiographical elements present in “Daddy”; the second part is an analysis of Plath’s faithfulness in transforming details about her private life into art. Keywords: confessional poetry, autobiography, personal reality, Confessional School 69 IAFOR Journal of Arts & Humanities Volume 7 – Issue 1 – Summer 2020 Introduction Sylvia Plath is considered one of the prominent figures of the confessional school of poetry. Both her prose and poetry are marked by the confessional mode. Because the purpose of this paper is to explore the way Plath handles and unmasks very personal life details directly in her poem “Daddy”, it will be crucial to shed some light on the confessional style adopted in her poetry.
    [Show full text]
  • Boston, Massachusetts Date: 25 August 1953 Pages: 1, 26
    Title: Boston Traveler City, State: Boston, Massachusetts Date: 25 August 1953 Pages: 1, 26 Posse Hunts Smith Girl Woods and ponds in Wellesley were searched today for a bril- liant [brilliant] Smith College student who disappeared from home yester- day afternoon. POLICE SAID Boy Scouts were being called out to search the area around Lake Waban and Morse's pond for a trace of Miss Sylvia Plath, 20, of Elmwood St. A state police bloodhound from the Andover barracks failed to pick up the girl's scent because of last night's rain. MISSING (Continued on Page Twenty-six) [Photograph, reversed, of SP wearing white collar shirt and sweater] SYLVIA PLATH Missing student MISSING Continued from First Page SYLVIA, a PRETTY girl with considerable literary talent, was to have returned to Smith as a senior next month. Yesterday she left home at 2 p.m. leaving a note saying that she was taking a hike and would be back the same day. HER MOTHER, Mrs. Aurelia S. Plath a Boston University pro- fessor [professor], instituted a search when Sylvia failed to return. The girl had been under a doc- tor's [doctor's] care for several months be- cause [because] of a nervous condition in- duced [induced ]by her intense application to literary work. She has been writing poetry for national maga- zines [magazines]. SYLVIA IS a scholarship stu- dent and topped her class scho- lastically last year. She was editor of the college literary magazine, a member of the college's press board and correspondent for a newspaper. She won two college poetry awards and had three poems ac- cepted [accepted] by Harper's Magazine.
    [Show full text]
  • Bodies and Self-Disclosure in American Female Confessional Poetry
    THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF LIFE WRITING VOLUME X (2021) SV33–SV56 Bodies and self-disclosure in American female confessional poetry Carmen Bonasera University of Pisa Abstract Far from being a mere thematic device, the body plays a crucial role in poetry, especially for modern women poets. The inward turn to an intimate autobiographical dimension, which is commonly seen as characteristic of female writing, usually complies with the requests of feminist theorists, urging writers to reconquer their identity through the assertion of their bodies. However, inscribing the body in verse is often problematic, since it frequently emerges from a complicated interaction between positive self-redefinition, life writing, and the confession of trauma. This is especially true for authors writing under the influence of the American confessional trend, whose biographies were often scarred by mental illness and self-destructive inclinations. This paper assesses the role of the body in the representation of the self in a selection of texts by American women poets—namely Sylvia Plath, Anne Sexton, Elizabeth Bishop, Adrienne Rich, and Louise Glück—where the body and its disclosure act as vehicles for a heterogeneous redefinition of the female identity. Keywords: Body, Confessional poetry, Self-disclosure, Life writing, Women poets Copyright © 2021 Carmen Bonasera https://doi.org/10.21827/ejlw.10.37638 This article is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) Carmen Bonasera – Bodies and self-disclosure in American female confessional poetry 34 Abstract Lungi dal configurarsi come mero nodo tematico, la corporeità esercita un ruolo fondamentale nella lirica, in special modo per le poetesse del Novecento.
    [Show full text]
  • Sylvia Plath's Daddy
    44 Sylvia Plath’s Daddy: The Intersection of the Personal and the Historical Anita Luther Bhasin Awarded the Pulitzer Prize posthumously in 1982 for her Collected Poems, Sylvia Plath’s “Daddy”, written in 1962, which appears in this collection, is perhaps her best known poem. It has elicited a variety of critical reactions, from feminist praise for its unadulterated rage towards male dominance, to wariness in its usage of Holocaust imagery. It has been reviewed and criticized by scores of scholars, and is upheld as one of the best examples of confessional poetry. Written a few months before her suicide, “Daddy” gives a voyeuristic view of Plath’s life as she skillfully combines the personal and the private with the historical to mount a brutal and venomous attack on her father Otto Plath and, indirectly on her husband, Ted Hughes. As Sylvia Plath is acknowledged to be a major confessional poet it follows that “Daddy” has autobiographical elements in it. It is therefore essential to know something about her father and the over-powering influence he had on her. Otto Plath immigrated to America from Grabow, a town in the Polish Corridor. He was a Professor of Biology in the University of Boston and died of diabetes when Sylvia Plath was nine. Sylvia, who hero-worshipped her father, never wholly recovered from this emotional loss. For this supposed act of desertion and betrayal she attacked him in several poems. While in her earlier poems her rage was turned inwards resulting in bitter self- reproach, in her later ones she directly attacked her father since her love for him was mingled with sadomasochistic feelings: ..
    [Show full text]
  • A Passage to "Ariel": Sylvia Plath and the Evolution of Self Author(S): GREG JOHNSON Source: Southwest Review, Vol
    Southern Methodist University A Passage to "Ariel": Sylvia Plath and the Evolution of Self Author(s): GREG JOHNSON Source: Southwest Review, Vol. 65, No. 1 (WINTER 1980), pp. 1-11 Published by: Southern Methodist University Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/43469198 Accessed: 21-05-2016 12:24 UTC Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://about.jstor.org/terms JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Southern Methodist University is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Southwest Review This content downloaded from 128.82.252.58 on Sat, 21 May 2016 12:24:17 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms A Passage to ' 'Ariel " Sylvia Plath and the Evolution of Self GREG JOHNSON Sylvia plath's poetry has been misinterpreted as "confessional" per- haps in an attempt to grant her - both as woman and as poet - a measure of the compassion she seemingly would not grant herself. This kind of compassionate acceptance has been offered, quite understandably, by poets such as Robert Lowell, Anne Sexton, and A. Alvarez, yet their individual assessments of Plath's work are disappointing because of their insistence upon the intimate connection between Plath's life and her poetry; this connection has been emphasized to such an extent that other, more meaningful connections have been ignored - or worse, made to seem irrelevant - and the result has been to exaggerate the significance of Plath's life while minimizing the importance of her art.
    [Show full text]
  • D.H. Lawrence's Influence on the Marriage of Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes
    MARGE MOUNT D.H. Lawrence’s Influence on the Marriage of Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes “How frail the human heart must be – a mirrored pool of thought.” – SYLVIA PLATH Plath was enraptured with Lawrence’s way of thinking. It was as if he was her moral conscience. Why else should she claim: “...and D. H. Lawrence did have something after all...”(Unabridged Journals 105). More to the point, what were Lawrence’s ways of thinking? Let’s start with a discussion of the original dream he had to found a communal utopian community before delving into the reality of his and Frieda’s personal life together. His dream community placed three or four couples, hand picked by him, to form a colony of like-minded souls withdrawing from the materialistic society that he saw destroying itself. This ideal included a new social order based on enlightened egalitarian principles. His name for it was Ramanim, after the song. “Lawrence half- remembered a word from this song which he heard on a walk with his friend Koteliansky, a Russian Jew who had sung in Hebrew the 23rd Psalm – the word was ‘Ramanim’” (Footless Crow, 1). Lawrence actually did make overtures in this direction when he settled in the cottages at High Tregwerthen, midway between Gunar’s Head and St. Ives. (The Lawrences were expelled from Cornwall when bad timing made them suspect of being spies for the Germans during the First World War.) He fell out of favor with his potential colonists at this point. He would later express the same desire of a shared community while encamped in New Mexico, high in the mountainous area of Taos.
    [Show full text]