DOCSLIB.ORG

Rhetorical and Argumentative Perspectives Gabrijela Kišiček University of Zagreb

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Rhetorical and Argumentative Perspectives Gabrijela Kišiček University of Zagreb University of Windsor Scholarship at UWindsor Philosophy Books Department of Philosophy 9-1-2013 What Do We Know About The orW ld? Rhetorical and Argumentative Perspectives Gabrijela Kišiček University of Zagreb Igor Ž. Žagar University of Maribor Follow this and additional works at: http://scholar.uwindsor.ca/philosophybooks Part of the Communication Commons, Epistemology Commons, and the Rhetoric and Composition Commons Recommended Citation Kišiček, Gabrijela and Žagar, Igor Ž., "What Do We Know About The orldW ? Rhetorical and Argumentative Perspectives" (2013). Philosophy Books. Book 2. http://scholar.uwindsor.ca/philosophybooks/2 This Book is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of Philosophy at Scholarship at UWindsor. It has been accepted for inclusion in Philosophy Books by an authorized administrator of Scholarship at UWindsor. For more information, please contact [email protected]. WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE WORLD? RHETORICAL AND ARGUMENTATIVE PERSPECTIVES WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE WORLD? RHETORICAL AND ARGUMENTATIVE PERSPECTIVES Edited by Gabrijela Kišiček (University of Zagreb) & Igor Ž. Žagar ∫University of Maribor & University of Primorska) Windsor Studies in Argumentation Open Monograph Press Editors in Chief Leo Groarke (University of Windsor) Christopher Tindale (University of Windsor) Board of Editors Mark Battersby (Capilano University) Camille Cameron (University of Windsor) Emmanuelle Danblon (Université libre de Bruxelles) Ian Dove (University of Nevada Las Vegas) Bart Garssen (University of Amsterdam) Michael Gilbert (York University) David Godden (Old Dominion University) Jean Goodwin (Iowa State University) Hans Hansen (University of Windsor) Gabrijela Kišiček (University of Zagreb) Marcin Koszowy (University of Białystok) Marcin Lewiński (New University of Lisbon) Catherine H. Palczewski (University of Northern Iowa) Steven Patterson (Marygrove College) Chris Reed (University of Dundee) Andrea Rocci (University of Lugano) Paul van den Hoven (Tilburg University) Cristián Santibáñez Yáñez (Diego Portales University) Igor Ž. Žagar (University of Maribor & University of Primorska) Frank Zenker (Lund University) Co-published in: Digital Library Dissertationes series (volume 25): http://193.2.222.157/Sifranti/StaticPage.aspx?id=45. Editorial Board: Igor Ž. Žagar, Editor in Chief Jonatan Vinkler Janja Žmavc Alenka Gril. © Individual authors and WSIA 2013. All rights reserved. PREFACE .................................................................................................................................. 1 PROLOGUE ............................................................................................................................... 3 Gordana Varošanec-Škarić, University of Zagreb I. THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVES ........................................................................................ 5 The Elements of Argument: Six Steps To A Thick Theory ................................................... 6 Leo Groarke, University of Windsor Argumentation as poliphony: one speaker, several voices................................................... 29 Igor Ž. Žagar, Educational Research Institute & University of Primorska The linguistic-discursive creation of the speaker’s ethos for the sake of persuasion: a key aspect of rhetoric and argumentation ................................................................................... 64 Paul Danler, University of Innsbruck The Sokal affair and beyond: on the strategic use of parody in the “science wars” ............ 84 Ana Dimiškovska, Ss. Cyril and Methodius University of Skopje The acts and strategies of defining ..................................................................................... 115 Fabrizio Macagno, Universidade Nova de Lisboa Intolerance and the Zero Tolerance Fallacy ....................................................................... 143 Sheldon Wein, Saint Mary’s University II POLITICAL DISCOURSE ................................................................................................ 162 Political Discourse and Argumentation Profiles ................................................................ 163 Hans V. Hansen, University of Windsor Rhetoric of the Crisis. Polish parliamentarian debates on the future of the EU ................ 178 Agnieszka Kampka, Warsaw University of Life Sciences - SGGW The Political Discourse on Croatia’s EU Accession: a Rhetorical Analysis of the Presentation of the European Union among Supporters and Opponents of the EU ........... 204 Gabrijela Kišiček, University of Zagreb Rhetoric ― Martial Art or the Art of Winning the Soul by Discourse? ............................ 234 Language of Politicians vs. Ethos, Pathos and Logos.......................................................... 234 Joanna Szczepańska-Włoch, Jagiellonian University The Analysis of Insulting Practices - Sticks and Stones in the Croatian Parliament ......... 262 Alma Vančura, University of Osijek & Diana Tomić, University of Zagreb III. LEGAL DISCOURSE ...................................................................................................... 293 Taking Judges Seriously ..................................................................................................... 294 Argumentation and Rhetoric in Legal Decisions ............................................................... 294 Maurizio Manzin, Research Centre on Legal Methodology (CERMEG), University of Trento IV. EDUCATION .................................................................................................................. 320 Debate as an Educational Tool: Is Polarization a Debate side effect? ............................... 321 Manuele De Conti, University of Padua Teaching the writing of argumentative genre through imitatio: A solid basis for the ‘beginner’ writers ............................................................................................................... 354 Fotini Egglezou, Athens V. MEDIA .............................................................................................................................. 384 Challenges of Rhetoric in the Era of ‘Bytes and Likes’ ..................................................... 385 Petra Aczél, Corvinus University of Budapest The Cowboys, the Poets, the Professor... – Antonomasia in Croatian Sports Discourse ... 408 Ana Grgić & Davor Nikolić, University of Zagreb Stakeholders in promotional genres. A rhetorical perspective on marketing communication ............................................................................................................................................ 430 Sabrina Mazzali-Lurati & Chiara Pollaroli, University of Lugano The Representation and Reception of Paraphrase in Newspaper Headlines ...................... 459 Anita Runjić-Stoilova & Josip Galić, University of Split ABOUT THE AUTHORS ..................................................................................................... 484 INDEX ................................................................................................................................... 489 PREFACE What do we know about the world? Rhetorical and Argumentative Perspectives is a book trying to answer the title question by contributing to rhetorical and argumentative studies. It consists of papers presented at the “First International Conference on Rhetoric in Croatia: the Days of Ivo Škarić”. The Conference was organized with the intent of paying respect to the Croatian rhetorician and professor emeritus Ivo Škarić who was the first to introduce rhetoric at the Department of Phonetics at the Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Zagreb. As a phonetician, professor Škarić was interested in all aspects of speech and therefore revealed natural connections between phonetics and rhetoric. As a founder of the School of Rhetoric, he trained many of his students to become teachers of rhetoric and to get involved with rhetorical and argumentation analysis. This conference was a sign of gratitude from his students. The conference was held at the island of Brač, professor Škarić's birthplace, between April 19th and 22nd 2012, and it gathered 60 rhetoricians and argumentation scholars from 10 European countries as well as North America. The papers presented at the conference are distributed into six chapters of the book: Theoretical Perspectives discussing argumentation theory, relations between philosophy and rhetoric, and visual argumentation; Political Discourse presents papers interested in rhetorical strategies and argumentation analysis in various types of pubic discourse, i.e. parliamentary debates, persuasion in political speeches etc; The Media chapter presents papers containing rhetorical analyses of the media discourse, especially those interested in figures of speech and the New Media; the Legal Discourse discusses argumentation and rhetorical strategies in legal discourse; while Education presents a chapter involved in the importance of the rhetoric in education system, i.e. implementation of debate in education, writings of the argumentative genre, etc. The final chapter Other 1 Approaches shows different approaches to rhetoric illustrating the multidisciplinarity of the conference. The common feature of all the papers in the book is the attempt to understand the role of rhetoric and argumentation in various types of public discourse and to present interdisciplinary work connecting linguists, phoneticians, philosophers, law experts and
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Bios Westvac
    WestVAC / WestVPR Conference March 6-7, 2014 Inn at Laurel Point, Victoria B.C . SPEAKER BIOGRAPHIES Mr. Stephen Mandel , Former Mayor, City of Edmonton Session #1 – PSE in Time of Austerity: An Alberta Perspective 9:00am Thursday, March 6, 2014 Stephen Mandel led the City of Edmonton as Mayor for nine years since being first elected to the role in October 2004. As an accomplished businessman, he brought 30 years of private sector experience to City Hall. Stephen is known for being a strong advocate for Alberta municipalities, ensuring they receive a fair share of funding to pay for vital infrastructure and community services in a rapidly growing community. His bold vision to improve the integration of services in the Edmonton region encouraged the Province to create a new governance body responsible for building a more effective regional plan, which has marked a new era of cooperation and growth. Stephen is a strong advocate and voice for the most vulnerable in society, including low-income families, seniors, newcomers and the homeless. His passion for people was the driving force behind several major initiatives including Edmonton's 10-Year Plan to End Homelessness, REACH Edmonton Council for Safe Communities, and the Africa Centre. Stephen has been a supporter of the arts which he believes are a critical factor in the confidence and character of a city. He also committed to preserving Edmonton's reputation as a global environmental leader, stewarding green and sustainable initiatives. He has been married to wife Lynn for 40 years. They have two grown children and one grandchild.
    [Show full text]
  • Rhetoric and Communications, Issue 13, July 2014 Ivanka
    Rhetoric and Communications, Issue 13, July 2014 Ivanka Mavrodieva, Gergana Apostolova Leo A. Groarke, Christopher W. Tindalе, “Good Reasoning Matters! A Cognitive Approach to Critical Thinking” The book Good Reasoning Matters! A Cognitive Approach to Critical Thinking was first published in 1989 by Oxford University Press. Next issues follow in 1997, 2004, 2008. The latest 5th edition was published in 2013 by Oxford University Press Canada. The two authors, Leo A. Groarke and Christopher W. Tindalе have included 13 parts plus Preface, three Appendices and an Index. The 5th edition is expanded and contains a Glossary of the terms, which is a great aid for the students of argumentation. There are also examples from current practices and the classical examples are combined with modernized tasks and exercises, which is a challenging and attractive method of leading the learners to study the rhetorical terminology. It is only natural to start with short profiles of the authors. Leo A. Groarke is the Vice-President at the University of Windsor, Canada where he was appointed in 2010. He is a philosopher and his research fields extend to cover the fields of the history of ideas, social and political philosophy, informal logic and argumentation theory. His academic training started at the University of Calgary and then followed Simon Fraser University, the University of Helsinki, and the University of Western Ontario. He received his PhD in 1982 г. His academic career is active and dynamic, he was professor of Philosophy at Wilfrid Laurier University, where he held a number of administrative positions: Chair of the Philosophy Department, Assistant Dean of Arts and Science, Dean of the Brantford Campus.
    [Show full text]
  • Informal Logic: a 'Canadian' Approach to Argument
    Informal Logic: A 'Canadian' Approach to Argument INFORMAL LOGIC: A 'CANADIAN' APPROACH TO ARGUMENT FEDERIC O PUPPO Windsor Studies in Argumentation Windsor, ON Editorial and formatting assistance provided by Tamilyn Mulvaney. Cover Image “School of Fish” by Thomas Quine was generously made available under a Creative Commons Attribution license (https://commons.wikimedia.org/ wiki/File:School_of_fish_(29627924482).jpg) Permission to reproduce previously published works has been obtained from the rights holder(s). Please refer to the Acknowledgements section of each chapter for more details. Copyright (2019) Windsor Studies in Argumentation & the original authors, unless otherwise noted. Windsor Studies In Argumentation Centre for Research in Reasoning, Argumentation and Rhetoric University of Windsor 401 Sunset Avenue, Windsor, Ontario, Canada Digital Edition of this book are available under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial 4.0 License. ISBN: 978-0-920233-91-7 CONTENTS 1. Introduction 1 Federico Puppo 2. Pioneering Informal Logic and Argumentation 35 Studies Anthony J. Blair 3. Formal Models 61 John Woods 4. The Problem of Missing Premisses 104 David Hitchcock 5. Are There Methods of Informal Logic? 130 Hans V. Hansen 6. Duets, Cartoons, and Tragedies: Struggles with 153 the Fallacy of Composition Trudy Govier 7. The Dialectical Tier Revisited 176 Ralph H. Johnson 8. How the Context of Dialogue of an Argument 196 Influences its Evaluation Douglas Walton 9. Inquiry: A Dialectical Approach to Teaching Criti- 234 cal Thinking Sharon Bailin and Mark Battersby 10. Argumentation and the Force of Reasons 251 Robert C. Pinto 11. Aggression, Politeness, and Abstract Adversaries 287 Catherine Hundleby 12. MULTI-MODAL 2010: Multi-Modal Argumenta- 313 tion 20 Years Later Michael A.
    [Show full text]
  • DIA Volume 26 Issue 3 Cover and Front Matter
    Canadian Philosophical Review Revue canadienne de philosophic Articles Solitude et sociabilite: Rousseau et Sartre PHILIP KNEE Moral Truth ETHICS RESEARCH CROUP Two Conceptions of the Structure of Happiness JOSEPH SHEA Les structures de la verite chez Descartes GEORGES J. D. MOYAL Pleasure J. F. M. HUNTER Piaget's Genetic Epistemology and the Problem of Truth GARY F. GREIF Critical Notices/Etudes critiques L'affect est-il toujours conscient? GERARD VACHON Justice Contracted L. W. SUMNER Intervention Parmenides" Timeless Universe, Again LEO GROARKE Book Reviews/Comptes rend us Books Received/Livres recus Announce ments/Chroniques VOL. XXVI, NO. 3 Automne/Autumn 1987 Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. 30 Sep 2021 at 20:39:50, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use. Revue trimestrielle de 1'Association canadienne de philosophic publiee avec l'assistance financiere du Conseil de recherches en sciences humaines. Dialogue beneficie egalement du soutien de 1'Universite de Montreal et de l'Universite de Waterloo. Published quarterly for the Canadian Philosophical Association with grant support from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council. The assistance and support of the University of Waterloo and the University of Montreal is also gratefully acknowledged. Publiee par Wilfrid Laurier University Press pour l'Association canadienne de philosophic Published by Wilfrid Laurier University Press for the Canadian Philosophical Association President/President: JOHN TRENTMAN Huron College, University of Western Ontario Editors/Redaction: FRANCOIS DUCHESNEAU Universite de Montreal MICHAEL F. MCDONALD University of Waterloo Board of Referees/Comite d'experts E. J. ASH WORTH University of Waterloo ROBERT NADEAU Universite du Quebec a j.
    [Show full text]
  • CURRICULUM VITAE Louis F
    CURRICULUM VITAE Louis F. Groarke PERSONAL Born London, England; Canadian, Irish, British Citizen ADDRESS Professional: Philosophy Department St. Francis Xavier University P.O. Box 5000 Antigonish, Nova Scotia B2G 2W5 [email protected] Office: 902-867-3611 Fax: 902-867-3243 (Department of Philosophy: c/o Janice Munroe (902-867-4983) Quebec Residence: 122 rue Bourbeau Louis Groarke 2 Trois-Rivières, Québec G8T 1M5 (819) 379-5492 [email protected] RESEARCH/SELECTED PUBLICATIONS: Single-Authored Books: Moral Reasoning: Rediscovering the Ethical Tradition (Toronto, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011), 480 pages. (This book is a detailed history of Western Ethics from the Pre-Socratics to contemporary authors.) An Aristotelian Account of Induction: Creating Something From Nothing (Montreal, Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2009), 470 pages. (Awarded Aids to Scholarly Publications SHRRC Grant; in McGill-Queen’s Studies in the History of Ideas Series.) The Good Rebel: Understanding Freedom and Morality, (Madison, NJ: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press; London: Associated University Presses, 2002), 326 pages. Books in Progress: Louis Groarke, Paul Groarke, Paolo Biondi, Living Wisely, Broadview Press, under contract, the manuscript has passed through all refereeing, only copy-editing left; forthcoming, between 500-600 pages. Parallel Lines Converge at Infinity: Aristotle, Religion and Literature (presently under review at a Canadian publisher). Co-Edited Books: (Equal contributors) Paolo Biondi, Louis Groarke, editors, Shifting the Paradigm: Alternative Perspectives on Induction (Frankfurt, Germany: Ontos Verlag / De Gruyter, 2014). (Contributing Editor) Jonathan Lavery, Louis Groarke, William Sweet, editors, Ideas Under Fire: Historical Studies of Philosophy and Science in Adversity ( (Madison, Teaneck NJ: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press; Lanham MY: Rowman & Littlefield, 2013), 374 pages.
    [Show full text]
  • The Rise of Informal Logic
    Studies in Critical Thinking and Informal Logic 1. C. L. Hamblin Fallacies 2. Ralph H. Johnson The Rise of lnformal Logic The Rise of Informal Logic Essays on Argumentation, Critical Thinking, Reasoning and Politics Ralph H. Johnson With four chapters co-authored by J. Anthony Blair Edited by John Hoaglund with Prefaces by Trudy Govier, Christopher Tindale & Leo Groarke Note to the Windsor Studies In Argumentation Digital Edition, 2014 The Rise of Informal Logic, by Ralph Johnson, has chapters co-authored by J. Anthony Blair, and prefaces by Trudy Govier, John Hoagland, and Leo Groarke & Christopher Tindale. The content of this edition of the book is the same as the 1996 Vale Press edition, with a number of minor typographical corrections. The cover of this edition was designed by Dave Johnston for WSIA and is an image of the cupola of Dillon Hall, an iconic building at the University of Windsor. Dillon hall was one of the original buildings at the Assumption College before the university became public. We have included this as a cover image to recognize the University of Windsor as the centre of much of the work that gave birth to informal logic as a discipline. E-editions of works in the WSIA series on argumentation are made available under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommerical-NoDerivs 4.0 license. E-edition ISBN 978-0-920233-71-9 Windsor Studies in Argumentation Volume 1: Gabrijela Kišiček and Igor Ž. Žagar, eds. What do We Know about the World? Rhetorical and Argumentative Perspectives Volume 2: Ralph Johnson, The Rise of Informal Logic The WSIA series is overseen by the following editorial board Mark Battersby (Capilano University) Camille Cameron (University of Windsor) Emmanuelle Danblon (Université libre de Bruxelles) Ian Dove (University of Nevada Las Vegas) Bart Garssen (University of Amsterdam) Michael Gilbert (York University) David Godden (Old Dominion University) Jean Goodwin (Iowa State University) Hans V.
    [Show full text]