What Constitutes Right-Wing Extremism? an Analysis of Three European Political Parties
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
What constitutes right-wing extremism? An analysis of three European political parties Author: Erik Mellander Supervisor: Åsa Boholm Master Thesis in Global Studies Word count: 19996 Abstract The end of World War II resulted in the dissolvent of the German Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (NSDAP) and the Italian Partito Nazionale Fascista (PNF). The strength of fascist and national socialist ideologies was significantly weakened after the war. However, the ideas survived and are still visible in European societies in the form of right-wing extremism. Right-wing extreme features such as anti-globalisation, nationalism, and xenophobia exist globally as well, for example the political and societal development in the Philippines, India, Brazil, China, and the United States indicates right-wing extreme tendencies. Although many right-wing extreme studies has been made, scholars cannot agree on an uncontested definition of the concept. The aim of this study is to contribute to the development of an analytical and comparative framework for the study of political parties. Theoretical inspiration draws from Cas Mudde’s work on right-wing extremism. The analytical framework is used to examine three political parties in three countries: the Swedish Nordic Resistance Movement, German Alternative for Germany, and the Swiss People’s Party. The analytical framework is used to dissect the selected party’s association with right-wing extremism. A content analysis of each party’s manifesto enables a more detailed analysis of the specific associations to right-wing extremism in each case. Right-wing extremism is a broad phenomenon which includes several distinct dimensions that might be present to a greater or lesser extent. The thesis offers a systematic account of the ideological content of party programs which enables comparison between organisations. Although branded as “right-wing extremist” the thesis shows that there is considerable variation between the political parties. Acknowledgement I would like to give a big thanks to my supervisor Åsa Boholm whose advice and guidance has played a big role throughout the process of this thesis. Your pertinent email responses and all the meetings we have had, has helped me through difficult phases. I also want to express gratitude to Jennie Sivenbring at the Segerstedt institute. The constructive criticism and support from you have contributed greatly to the thesis which I am very grateful for. Abbreviation list AfD Alternative for Germany, Alternative für Deutschland AoIR The Association of Internet Researchers BNP British National Party GD Golden Dawn GDP Gross domestic product EU European Union NATO North Atlantic Treaty Organization NMR Nordic Resistance Movement, Nordiska Motståndsrörelsen SD Swedish Democrats SMR Swedish Resistance Movement SVP Swiss People’s Party, Schweizerische Volkspartei Table of contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................................... 2 Acknowledgement ................................................................................................................................... 3 Abbreviation list ...................................................................................................................................... 4 List of tables ............................................................................................................................................ 7 1 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 1 2 Aim and research question.............................................................................................................. 2 3 Delimitations ................................................................................................................................... 2 4 Relevance to Global Studies ............................................................................................................ 3 5 Background ...................................................................................................................................... 4 5.1 The far right in Europe ............................................................................................................. 4 5.2 Alternative for Germany .......................................................................................................... 5 5.3 Nordic Resistance Movement ................................................................................................. 5 5.4 Swiss People’s Party ................................................................................................................ 6 6 Previous research ............................................................................................................................ 7 7 Theoretical framework .................................................................................................................... 9 7.1 How to define right-wing extremism ...................................................................................... 9 7.2 Conceptualising the features ................................................................................................. 11 7.3 Features and sub-features .................................................................................................... 11 7.3.1 Nationalism .................................................................................................................... 11 7.3.2 Racism............................................................................................................................ 12 7.3.3 Xenophobia.................................................................................................................... 12 7.3.4 Anti-democracy ............................................................................................................. 13 7.3.5 Strong state ................................................................................................................... 14 7.4 Application of theory ............................................................................................................. 14 8 Method .......................................................................................................................................... 16 8.1 Selection of sample documents ............................................................................................ 16 8.2 What should be quantified? .................................................................................................. 17 8.3 Coding .................................................................................................................................... 18 8.4 Manifesto overview ............................................................................................................... 19 8.4.1 AfD’s manifesto ............................................................................................................. 19 8.4.2 NMR’s manifesto ........................................................................................................... 20 8.4.3 SVP’s manifesto ............................................................................................................. 20 8.5 Ethical consideration ............................................................................................................. 20 9 Analysis and result ......................................................................................................................... 21 9.1 Alternative for Germany ........................................................................................................ 21 9.1.1 Nationalism .................................................................................................................... 21 9.1.2 Exclusionism .................................................................................................................. 24 9.1.3 Anti-democracy ............................................................................................................. 27 9.1.4 Strong state ................................................................................................................... 29 9.2 Nordic Resistance Movement ............................................................................................... 32 9.2.1 Nationalism .................................................................................................................... 32 9.2.2 Exclusionism .................................................................................................................. 35 9.2.3 Anti-democracy ............................................................................................................. 38 9.2.4 Strong state ................................................................................................................... 41 9.3 Swiss People’s Party .............................................................................................................. 44 9.3.1 Nationalism .................................................................................................................... 44 9.3.2 Exclusionism .................................................................................................................. 46 9.3.3 Anti-democracy ............................................................................................................