LISTING OF CITATIONS - CITY VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE

Hearing on 3rd December 2014 at 10.00 am in Committee Room 3, Woodhill House, Westburn Road, Aberdeen

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

1 49645/50099 RETAIL WAREHOUSE STEINHOFF UK GROUP PROPERTY LTD T 240,000 240,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 6A1 T/A HARVEYS FURNISHERS KITTYBREWSTER RETAIL PARK BEDFORD ROAD RAPLEYS A ABERDEEN

2 1255/50249 YARD BILFINGER SALAMIS UK LTD T 55,500 55,500 WITHDRAWN 26 ST MACHAR ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

3 81524/50225 DISTRICT HEATING FACILITY ABERDEEN HEAT & POWER CO LTD T 69,000 69,000 WITHDRAWN SEATON ENERGY CENTRE SCHOOL ROAD ABERDEEN

4 81524/50226 DISTRICT HEATING FACILITY ABERDEEN HEAT & POWER CO LTD T 105,000 105,000 WITHDRAWN SEATON ENERGY CENTRE SCHOOL ROAD ABERDEEN

5 2407/50209 OFFICE JOHNSTON CARMICHAEL O 155,000 155,000 WITHDRAWN 15-16 CARDEN PLACE ABERDEEN WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED A

6 2408/50238 OFFICE SANTANDER UK PLC O 114,000 114,000 WITHDRAWN 17 CARDEN PLACE C/O JONES LANG LASALLE ABERDEEN BUSINESS RATES JONES LANG LASALLE A

7 2607/50179 OFFICE BREWIN DOLPHIN T 50,500 50,500 WITHDRAWN 23 RUBISLAW TERRACE ABERDEEN JONES LANG LASALLE A

8 2904/50111 HOTEL MALMAISON ABERDEEN LTD T 480,000 480,000 WITHDRAWN MALMAISON 49-53 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

9 2905/50221 SCHOOL THE HAMILTON SCHOOL P 71,500 71,500 71,500 71,500 55 QUEEN'S ROAD PER MR MARK TAYLOR (DISMISSED) ABERDEEN SCHOOL BURSAR CAPA A

10 86005/50223 HOSPITAL NHS GRAMPIAN P 355,000 355,000 320,000 320,000 ABERDEEN COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE VILLAGE 50 FREDERICK STREET ABERDEEN BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE A

11 84817/50110 RESTAURANT WAGAMAMA LTD T 30,000 30,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 1 THE ACADEMY BELMONT STREET J & E SHEPHERD A ABERDEEN

12 31127/50145 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 31,500 31,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT 1 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

13 31128/50146 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 95,500 95,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT 2 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

01/10/2015 Page 1 of 11 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

14 31130/50147 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 125,000 125,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 3 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

15 31133/50148 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 142,000 142,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 4 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

16 31211/50149 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 279,000 279,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 5 & 33 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

17 31135/50150 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 144,000 144,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 6 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

18 31136/50151 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 147,000 147,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 7 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

19 31137/50152 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 118,000 118,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 8 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

20 31138/50153 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 224,000 224,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 9 & 10 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

21 31816/50154 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 120,000 120,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 11 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

22 33735/50157 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 44,250 44,250 WITHDRAWN UNIT 12C PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

23 33508/50156 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 29,000 29,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 12B PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

24 33773/50155 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 32,500 32,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT 12A PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

25 33506/50158 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 62,000 62,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 13 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

26 33531/50159 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 61,500 61,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT 14 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

27 32891/50160 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 54,000 54,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 15 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

01/10/2015 Page 2 of 11 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

28 31726/50161 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 76,500 76,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT 16 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

29 31240/50162 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 135,000 135,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 17-18 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

30 81910/50166 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 15,000 15,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 19K PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

31 31245/50164 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 358,000 358,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 19A PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

32 31247/50165 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 330,000 330,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 19B PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

33 31142/50167 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 155,000 155,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 20 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

34 31143/50168 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 139,000 139,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 21 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

35 31145/50169 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 120,000 120,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 22 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

36 31146/50170 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 139,000 139,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 23 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

37 31212/50171 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 368,000 368,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 24 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

38 31147/50172 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 211,000 211,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 25 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

39 31148/50173 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 71,000 71,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 26A PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

40 31149/50174 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 116,000 116,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 26B PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

41 31129/50175 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 97,500 97,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT 27 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

01/10/2015 Page 3 of 11 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

42 31131/50176 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 133,000 133,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 28 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

43 31132/50177 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 113,000 113,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 29 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

44 31134/50178 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 120,000 120,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 30 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

45 31139/50180 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 245,000 245,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 31-32 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

46 31140/50181 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 56,000 56,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 34 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

47 31157/50182 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 51,000 51,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 35 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

48 31630/50183 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 50,000 50,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 36 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

49 31150/50184 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 60,000 60,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 37 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

50 31151/50185 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 66,000 66,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 38 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

51 31631/50186 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 101,000 101,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 39 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

52 31962/50142 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 640,000 640,000 WITHDRAWN BON ACCORD CENTRE PER SAVILLS ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

53 31154/50187 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 117,000 117,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 44-45 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

54 31155/50188 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 51,500 51,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT 46 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

55 63445/50133 CAFE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 40,000 40,000 WITHDRAWN ATRIUM PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

01/10/2015 Page 4 of 11 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

56 31742/50163 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 80,000 80,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT 19 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

57 31612/50191 CAR PARK ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD P 1,100,000 1,100,000 WITHDRAWN BON ACCORD CENTRE PER SAVILLS ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

58 82120/50137 CAR WASH ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 15,000 15,000 WITHDRAWN LOCH STREET CAR PARK PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

59 84147/50136 CAR WASH ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 10,000 10,000 WITHDRAWN HARRIET STREET CAR PARK PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

60 84399/50138 STANCES ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 800 800 WITHDRAWN KIDDIE RIDES PER SAVILLS LOCH STREET CAR PARK BON ACCORD CENTRE ERIC YOUNG & CO A ABERDEEN

61 31344/50135 INDOOR BOWLING CLUB ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 51,000 51,000 WITHDRAWN BON ACCORD INDOOR BOWLING CENTRE PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

62 83103/50134 RESTAURANT ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 50,000 50,000 WITHDRAWN UPPER LEVEL PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD INDOOR BOWLING CENTRE BON ACCORD CENTRE ERIC YOUNG & CO A ABERDEEN

63 31248/50196 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD P 560,000 560,000 WITHDRAWN BON ACCORD CENTRE PER SAVILLS ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

64 31249/50143 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 573,000 573,000 WITHDRAWN BON ACCORD CENTRE PER SAVILLS ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

65 31156/50140 OFFICES ETC ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 29,750 29,750 WITHDRAWN BON ACCORD CENTRE PER SAVILLS ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

66 84032/50192 RESTAURANT ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD P 77,500 77,500 WITHDRAWN FOOD UNIT 1 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

67 84033/50193 RESTAURANT ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD P 48,750 48,750 WITHDRAWN FOOD UNIT 2 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

68 84034/50194 RESTAURANT ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD P 57,000 57,000 WITHDRAWN FOOD UNIT 3 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

69 84035/50195 RESTAURANT ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD P 75,000 75,000 WITHDRAWN FOOD UNIT 4 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

01/10/2015 Page 5 of 11 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

70 85456/50190 STANCE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 5,000 5,000 WITHDRAWN STROLLEX MINI SHOPPERS PER SAVILLS UPPER MALL BON ACCORD CENTRE ERIC YOUNG & CO A ABERDEEN

71 82764/50189 STANCE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 6,000 6,000 WITHDRAWN RMU 2 PER SAVILLS UPPER MALL BON ACCORD CENTRE ERIC YOUNG & CO A ABERDEEN

72 82765/50141 STANCE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 6,000 6,000 WITHDRAWN RMU 3 PER SAVILLS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

73 72205/50144 STANCE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 10,000 10,000 WITHDRAWN BON ACCORD CENTRE PER SAVILLS ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

74 84145/50139 STANCE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 10,000 10,000 WITHDRAWN MAGNOLIA PER SAVILLS LOWER MALL BON ACCORD CENTRE ERIC YOUNG & CO A ABERDEEN

75 4666/50093 PUBLIC HOUSE ETC THE BRIDGE STREET PARTNERSHIP P 61,000 61,000 30,000 30,000 CLUB FOUNDATION CARNEGIE'S BRAE ABERDEEN J & E SHEPHERD A

76 4993/49966 HOTEL COPTHORNE HOTEL ABERDEEN LTD P 300,000 300,000 300,000 300,000 THE COPTHORNE HOTEL (DISMISSED) 122 HUNTLY STREET ABERDEEN EDWARD SYMMONS A

77 5249/50123 SUPERMARKET ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 186,000 186,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT W1 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

78 5250/50124 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 121,000 121,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT W2 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

79 38984/50125 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 81,000 81,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT W3 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

80 5252/50126 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 80,500 80,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT W4 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

81 5253/50127 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 80,000 80,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT W5 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

82 5254/50128 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 166,000 166,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT W6 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

83 5255/50129 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 80,500 80,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT W7 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

01/10/2015 Page 6 of 11 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

84 5256/50130 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 102,000 102,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT W8 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

85 5257/50131 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 37,000 37,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT W9A PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

86 40572/50132 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 68,000 68,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT W9B PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

87 5258/50116 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 196,000 196,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT E1 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

88 5259/50117 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 178,000 178,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT E2-E3 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

89 5259/50247 SHOP OFFICE HOLDINGS T 178,000 178,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT E2-E3 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A

90 5260/50118 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 103,000 103,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT E4 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

91 5261/50119 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 237,000 237,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT E5 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

92 38071/50121 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 188,000 188,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT E8 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

93 83747/50120 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 322,000 322,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT E6 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

94 5265/50122 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 176,000 176,000 WITHDRAWN UNIT E9 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

95 5266/50112 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 20,000 20,000 WITHDRAWN (KIOSK) PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

96 5267/50115 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 36,500 36,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT DE2-DE3 PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

97 5270/50114 OFFICE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 7,200 7,200 WITHDRAWN ST NICHOLAS CENTRE PER SAVILLS ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

01/10/2015 Page 7 of 11 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

98 5271/50113 OFFICE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 180,000 180,000 WITHDRAWN KIRKGATE HOUSE PER SAVILLS ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A

99 5498/50104 SHOP POUNDWORLD RETAIL TD T 155,000 155,000 WITHDRAWN 122 UNION STREET ABERDEEN PRESTON TAIT A

100 5498/50201 SHOP POUNDWORLD RETAIL TD T 155,000 155,000 WITHDRAWN 122 UNION STREET ABERDEEN PRESTON TAIT A

101 86016/50239 CIVIC AMENITY SITE SITA UK LTD T 67,500 67,500 WITHDRAWN HAZLEHEAD AVENUE ABERDEEN GVA JAMES BARR A

102 6190/50237 LICENSED RESTAURANT CUMIN CATERING LTD T 87,500 87,500 WITHDRAWN JIMMY CHUNG'S 401 UNION STREET ABERDEEN

103 85910/50092 SHOP THE WHITE COMPANY T 106,000 106,000 WITHDRAWN 12 GROUND LEVEL MALL G L HEARN A

104 7348/50246 OIL SERVICE DEPOT ASCO UK LTD T 164,000 164,000 WITHDRAWN TORRY BASE SINCLAIR ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

105 7348/50250 OIL SERVICE DEPOT ASCO UK LTD T 144,000 144,000 WITHDRAWN TORRY BASE SINCLAIR ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

106 7937/50063 UNIVERSITY BUILDINGS THE GOVERNORS OF THE P 2,850,000 2,850,000 WITHDRAWN GARTHDEE CAMPUS ROBERT GORDON UNIVERSITY GARTHDEE ROAD ESTATES & PROPERTY SERVICES ABERDEEN D M HALL A

107 83874/50227 ATM SITE DOLPHIN RETAIL MANAGEMENT LTD P 3,750 3,750 WITHDRAWN NORTHERN LIGHTS FILLING STATION (IN LIQUIDATION) STONEHAVEN ROAD ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

108 8143/50095 OFFICE ETC WEATHERFORD (UK) LTD T 194,000 194,000 DELETED BLACKNESS ROAD PER RYDEN ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

109 85930/50098 OFFICE AMEC GROUP LTD T 274,000 274,000 DELETED UNIT 1 MERGED WITH 85551 CITY VIEW CRAIGSHAW DRIVE GVA JAMES BARR A ABERDEEN

110 8358/50208 OFFICE ETC MTM CONSTRUCTION P 81,500 81,500 80,500 80,500 GORDON HOUSE GREENBANK ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

01/10/2015 Page 8 of 11 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

111 84504/50207 OFFICE MTM CONSTRUCTION P 3,400 3,400 2,900 2,900 1ST FLOOR COMMS ROOM GORDON HOUSE GREENBANK ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

112 34298/50101 HOTEL ROBERTSON PROPERTY LTD T 25,000 25,000 WITHDRAWN LAURIES MOTEL HARENESS ROAD ABERDEEN ROBERTSON PROPERTY LTD A

113 8479/50230 PUBLIC HOUSE C K INNS LTD T 44,500 44,500 WITHDRAWN LANGDYKES LOIRSTON AVENUE COVE BAY

114 36268/50100 OFFICE ETC WEATHERFORD (UK) LTD P 1,400,000 1,400,000 1,560,000 1,560,000 WEATHERFORD CENTRE PER RYDEN (MERGED ENTRY) SOUTER HEAD ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

115 8914/50248 BUILDINGS SAC T 9,100 9,100 WITHDRAWN EXPERIMENTAL FARM PROPERTY & ESTATES GROUP BUCKSBURN ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

116 33287/49984 HOTEL SPEEDBIRD DEVELOPMENTS P 520,000 520,000 500,000 500,000 SPEEDBIRD INN PORTLAND HOTEL MANAGEMENT ARGYLL ROAD C/O CAPITAL HOTEL DYCE PETER HENRY A

117 33287/50204 HOTEL SPEEDBIRD DEVELOPMENTS P 520,000 520,000 WITHDRAWN SPEEDBIRD INN PORTLAND HOTEL MANAGEMENT ARGYLL ROAD C/O EDINBURGH CAPITAL HOTEL DYCE PETER HENRY A

118 85552/50015 HOTEL MARRIOTT HOTELS LTD P 485,000 485,000 WITHDRAWN COURTYARD BY MARRIOTT ABERDEEN AIRPORT ARGYLL ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A DYCE

119 85553/50017 HOTEL PREMIER TRAVEL INN LTD P 275,000 275,000 254,000 254,000 PREMIER INN ABERDEEN AIRPORT (DYCE) PER GERALD EVE ARGYLL WAY DYCE GERALD EVE LLP A

120 9268/50253 WORKSHOP ALASTAIR CHALMERS P 91,500 91,500 WITHDRAWN WALTON ROAD L & N DYCE J & E SHEPHERD A

121 9269/50254 WORKSHOP ETC L & N (SCOTLAND) LTD P 135,000 135,000 WITHDRAWN WALTON ROAD DYCE J & E SHEPHERD A

122 9388/50205 AIRPORT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 3,680,000 3,680,000 3,575,000 3,575,000 ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT PROPERTY DEPARTMENT DYCE GERALD EVE LLP A

123 48450/50206 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 8,800 8,800 DELETED ROOM 29 & 29A PROPERTY DEPARTMENT AVIATION SERVICES CENTRE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT GERALD EVE LLP A DYCE

01/10/2015 Page 9 of 11 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

124 9602/50108 HOTEL BRITANNIA HOTELS LTD P 360,000 360,000 360,000 360,000 BRITANNIA HOTEL (DISMISSED) MALCOLM ROAD BUCKSBURN SANDERSON WEATHERALL LLP A

125 85999/50228 OFFICE APACHE NORTH SEA LTD T 1,620,000 1,620,000 1,580,000 1,580,000 CALEDONIA HOUSE UNIT 2 KINGSWELLS CAUSEWAY PRIME FOUR BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A KINGSWELLS

126 86026/50229 OFFICE TRANSOCEAN DRILLING UK LTD T 1,590,000 1,590,000 1,550,000 1,550,000 DEEPWATER HOUSE UNIT 3 & 4 KINGSWELLS CAUSEWAY PRIME FOUR BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A KINGSWELLS

127 38272/50235 SHOP CO-OPERATIVE GROUP T 38,500 38,500 WITHDRAWN UNIT 1-2 PROPERTY DIVISION KINGSWELLS VILLAGE CENTRE KINGSWOOD DRIVE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A KINGSWELLS

128 49178/50252 OFFICE ABERDEEN SCIENCE PARKS LP P 58,000 58,000 WITHDRAWN 1ST FLOOR NORTH PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL THE HUB, ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A BRIDGE OF DON

129 37100/50251 TELECOMMUNICATIONS NETWORK TELEFONICA UK LTD P 536,000 536,000 (PART) (TELEFONICA) ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL AREA CLUTTONS LLP A

130 83446/50105 TELECOMMUNICATIONS NETWORK EVERYTHING EVERYWHERE LIMITED P 523,000 523,000 523,000 523,000 (PART) (DISMISSED) (EVERYTHING EVERYWHERE) ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL AREA GVA A

01/10/2015 Page 10 of 11 CASES CONTINUED FROM 04/06/2014 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

64 9388/49906 AIRPORT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 3,680,000 3,680,000 WITHDRAWN ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT PROPERTY DEPARTMENT DYCE GERALD EVE LLP A

01/10/2015 Page 11 of 11