An Assessment of Nysius Wekiuicola Populations and Thermal Microhabitat Conditions on Cinder Cones of the Maunakea Volcano, Hawai‘I
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
An Assessment of Nysius wekiuicola Populations and Thermal Microhabitat Conditions on Cinder Cones of the Maunakea Volcano, Hawai‘i A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE DIVISION OF THE UNIVERSITY OF HAWAI‘I AT HILO IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE IN TROPICAL CONSERVATION BIOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE FEBRUARY 2018 By Jessica Ann Kirkpatrick Thesis Committee: Jesse Eiben, Chairperson Kristina Paxton Ryan Perroy Fritz Klasner ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to sincerely thank the many hands and funders that made this research possible. I’d like to thank the Office of Maunakea Management and a Hau‘oli Mau Loa Foundation Fellowship for funding this project. I thank the Hawai‘i State Department of Land and Natural Resources- Division of Forestry and Wildlife, and Cynthia King for permission to conduct my study and collect arthropod specimens on State lands (Permit FHM17-431). Special mention goes to my enthusiastic advisor, Jesse Eiben; who is to blame for my love of insects. I wholeheartedly thank Jesse for his knowledge, guidance, encouragement, academic support, and friendship. Profound gratitude goes to my committee members Fritz Klasner, Kristina Paxton, and Ryan Perroy. Kristina in particular was extremely helpful throughout this process, and I’m very grateful for all of her support. Much appreciation to Koa Akima, Melissa Dean, Ellison Montgomery, Bradley Reil, Marleena Sheffield, Jeff Stallman, Nathan Stephenson, Heather Stever, Darcy Yogi, Jorden Zarders and the Maunakea Rangers. I’m also hugely appreciative to my mom, grandma and sister Maycie for the incredible support and encouragement. Finally, I would like to give a big mahalo to Maunakea for all the beautiful days and incredible observations; I dedicate this thesis to her. ii ABSTRACT The endemic Hawaiian wēkiu bug (Nysius wekiuicola) is a carnivorous scavenger that only inhabits volcanic cinder cones above ~3,500 m elevation on the mountain, Maunakea, Hawai‘i. As a species of conservation concern threatened by invasive species, climate change, and habitat alteration, a greater understanding of wēkiu bug populations and habitat use through time is needed to inform habitat restoration efforts and conservation management decisions. In this study, locations on a high elevation and a lower elevation cinder cone were sampled using attractant traps in a buffered random design six times from June 2016- 2017 to examine wēkiu bug distribution patterns within cinder cone habitats and across seasons. A generalized linear mixed model (GLMM) was used to explore the relative importance of cinder cone characteristics (topographic aspect, surficial minerals, and elevation) hypothesized to influence wēkiu bug distributions. Additionally, thermal conditions were described and compared within the insects’ habitat (within 2-30 cm depth of cinder substrate). Results indicate that wēkiu bugs had a highly aggregated distribution, with up to 40 times higher bug densities at the higher elevation cinder cone, and the density of bugs changed within and between cinder cones throughout the year. Our GLMM indicated that sample month, topographic aspect, and elevation on a cinder cone influences wēkiu bug distributions with abundance increasing with elevation within a cinder cone, and the highest captures are predicted to be on the northeast aspects of the higher elevation cinder cone year-round. Temperature data shows multiple microclimates exist throughout cinder cone habitats at any given time, and the ash substrate layer could provide an important habitat refuge for the wēkiu bug, as this layer rarely freezes. We recommend preserving contiguous cinder cone habitats for the persistence of the wēkiu bug and monitoring populations in a random sample design in known or restored habitats to effectively monitor wēkiu bug densities. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements ......................................................................................................................... ii Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... iii List of Tables ................................................................................................................................. vi List of Figures ................................................................................................................................ vi List of Appendix Tables & Figures .............................................................................................. vii Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 1 Alpine Ecosystem on Maunakea Volcano, HI ............................................................................ 2 The Wēkiu Bug ........................................................................................................................... 4 Wēkiu Bug Habitat ...................................................................................................................... 6 Wēkiu Bug Sampling Efforts: Past, Present, and Future .......................................................... 10 Research Objectives .................................................................................................................. 14 Objective 1: Assess Wēkiu Bug Abundance, Distribution, and Demography ...................... 14 Objective 2: Test Wēkiu Bug Habitat Associations .............................................................. 15 Objective 3: Describe Cinder Cone Thermal Habitat Conditions ......................................... 16 Methods......................................................................................................................................... 17 Data Collection .......................................................................................................................... 17 Field Sites .............................................................................................................................. 17 Wēkiu Bug Sampling and Trap Design ................................................................................. 19 Cinder Cone Thermal Habitat Sampling Design ................................................................... 22 Data Analyses ............................................................................................................................ 25 Objective 1: Assess Wēkiu Bug Abundance, Distribution, and Demography ...................... 25 Objective 2: Test Wēkiu Bug Habitat Associations .............................................................. 27 Objective 3: Describe Cinder Cone Thermal Habitat Conditions ......................................... 31 Results ........................................................................................................................................... 33 Objective 1: Assess Wēkiu Bug Abundance, Distribution, and Demography .......................... 33 Objective 2: Test Wēkiu Bug Habitat Associations .................................................................. 43 Objective 3: Describe Cinder Cone Thermal Habitat Conditions ............................................. 45 Discussion ..................................................................................................................................... 49 Objective 1: Assess Wēkiu Bug Abundance, Distribution, and Demography .......................... 49 iv Objective 2: Test Wēkiu Bug Habitat Associations .................................................................. 54 Objective 3: Describe Cinder Cone Thermal Habitat Conditions ............................................. 58 Management Recommendations ................................................................................................... 61 Conservation and Habitat Restoration ....................................................................................... 62 Wēkiu Bug Monitoring ............................................................................................................. 63 Climate Change ......................................................................................................................... 64 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 65 Appendix A- Data Collection Details ........................................................................................... 68 Field Sites .................................................................................................................................. 68 Wēkiu Bug Sampling and Trap Design ..................................................................................... 73 Cinder Cone Thermal Habitat Sampling Design ....................................................................... 75 Appendix B- Additional Data Analyses ....................................................................................... 77 Objective 1: Assess Wēkiu Bug Abundance, Distribution, and Demography .......................... 77 Objective 2: Test Wēkiu Bug Habitat Associations .................................................................. 80 Objective 3: Describe Cinder Cone Thermal Habitat Conditions ............................................. 81 Between Cinder Cone Sites ..................................................................................................