Legal Defences for Battered Women Who Kill: the Battered Woman Syndrome, Expert Testimony and Law Reform

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Legal Defences for Battered Women Who Kill: the Battered Woman Syndrome, Expert Testimony and Law Reform Legal Defences for Battered Women who Kill: The Battered Woman Syndrome, Expert Testimony and Law Reform. by Juliette Casey. Submitted in satisfaction ofthe requirements for the degree ofPh.D in the University ofEdinburgh 1999. \ <, I certify that this thesis is entirely my own work and that no part ofit has been published previously in the form in which it is now presented. I dedicate this thesis to the memory ofEmma Humphreys. TABLE OF CONTENTS. Introduction 5 Part One 10 Cases for the Individualisation ofthe Reasonable Man in Provocation. .................. .. 10 Introduction 10 Chapter One ................................................................ .. 20 Interviews with Advocates ..................................................... .. 20 Introduction 20 The Advocates and their Responses . .. 21 Chapter Two................................................................ .. 38 Feminism and Law 38 Introduction 38 Part One: General Discussion ofFeminism 39 British Feminist Jurisprudence 39 American Feminist Jurisprudence 45 Part Two:Feminism, Honour and Provocation 52 Introduction 52 Honour and the Original Four Categories ofProvocation 53 The Man ofHonour, Anger as Outrage and Reason 58 The man ofHonour, Anger as Loss of SelfControl and Passion . .. 62 Feminism, Honour and Provocation in Mawgridge's Adultry Category 65 Feminism, Honour and Proportionality 67 Feminism, Honour and Reasonableness 69 Conclusion to Part One 74 Part Two 80 A Comparative Analysis ofEach ofthe Three Defences in Britain 80 Introduction 80 Chapter Three ............................................................... .. 81 SelfDefence ................................................................ .. 81 Introduction 81 The Law on SelfDefence in Scotland 85 Historical Introduction ........................................................ .. 85 The Modem Law on SelfDefence . .. 87 Imminent Danger 88 Duty to Retreat .............................................................. .. 92 Proportionality .............................................................. .. 94 The Law on SelfDefence in England ............................................ .. 101 Historical Introduction ....................................................... .. 101 The Modem Law on SelfDefence ". ............... .. 102 Imminent Danger 109 Duty to Retreat ............................................................. .. 112 Proportionality ............................................................. .. 113 Problems with SelfDefence and Certain Solutions 116 Chapter Four. .............................................................. .. 128 Diminished Responsibility .................................................... .. 128 Introduction 128 The Law on Diminished Responsiblity in Scotland 130 Historical Introduction ....................................................... .. 130 The Modem Law on Diminished Responsibility in Scotland. ......................... .. 139 The Law on Diminished Responsibility in England . .. 152 The Modem Law on Diminished Responsiblity in England. .......................... .. 152 Diminished Responsibility in Britain as a Solution to the Problems Posed by Battered Women who Kill 160 Chapter Five ............................................................... .. 164 Provocation 164 Introduction 164 The Law ofProvocation in Scotland 164 Provocation and SelfDefence 164 The Nature ofthe Provocation. ................................................ .. 168 Delay 175 Proportionality .. ........................................................... .. 183 The Law on Provocation in England 185 The Nature ofthe Provocation 187 Delay 190 Proportionality .......................... .. 199 The Reasonableness Test 201 Problems with Provocation in Britain and Certain Solutions .......................... .. 220 Part Three. ................................................................ .. 230 Battered Woman Syndrome and Provocation: A Skeleton Proposal for the Representation of Battered Women who Kill 230 Introduction 230 Chapter Six. ............................................................... .. 234 Battered Woman Syndrome and Substantive Law .................................. .. 234 The Syndrome 234 The United States Approach. .................................................. .. 254 The Canadian Approach 256 The Australian Approach ..................................................... .. 261 The British Approach ........................................................ .. 265 An Outline Proposal for the Representation ofBattered Women who Plead Provocation in Britain 268 An Assessment ofthe use ofBattered Woman Syndrome Evidence 280 Chapter Seven 290 Battered Woman Syndrome Evidence and the Law ofEvidence ....................... .. 290 Introduction 290 The Knowledge and Experience and Ultimate Issue Rules ofEvidence 291 The Jury's Knowledge and Experience. .......................................... .. 293 The Ultimate Issue 299 The Knowledge and Experience Rule ofEvidence 306 The Influence of Turner in England ............................................. .. 309 Normality and Abnormality 309 Personality Disorder and Personality in Lowery 314 Ordinary Experience 318 Turner and Battered Woman Syndrome Expert Testimony in Canada, The United States, Australia and Scotland 327 Conclusion 334 Bibliography. .............................................................. .. 340 Appendices. ............................................................... .. 357 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS. The first person whom I would like to acknowledge is Professor Beverley Brown. As a mentor and friend she was largely responsible for making my early days in Edinburgh some ofthe most happy and intellectually rewarding of my life. For her kindness and support as well as the hours and hours of stimulating supervision which we had while she was in Edinburgh I will always be grateful. More recently, Professor Zenon Bankowski, Professor Sandy McCall Smith and Mr David Sheldon guided me through to submission. I would like to thank all three for their encouragement and support. I would also like to thank a number ofpeople for their sound advice at crucial stages in this thesis: Dr. Peter Young, Dr. Caitriona Carter and Elizabeth Kingdom. I am equally grateful to a number ofpeople who made life considerably more easy in the closing stages. The staff at the law library, in particular Mrs Crozier, and Crystal Webster from the computing support services who helped me with the technical side ofthings. Completing this thesis would not have been possible without the financial support which I received from a number of different sources. I would like to thank the Law Department, the British Federation of Women Graduates, the Clark Foundation for Legal Education, the President's Award and George More of More and Co. solicitors. I would also like to thank my part-time employers Lynne and Andrew for being so flexible and understanding. A vital aspect ofthis thesis comprises an empirical study into how advocates practising at the Bar in Scotland viewed cases involving battered women who kill. To those nineteen advocates whom I interviewed I would like to extend my deepest thanks. In particular, I would like to thank two advocates, Edgar Prais and Ruth Anderson for their help over and above the call ofduty. Equally vital was the time I spent with Dr. Mairead Tagg of Greater Easterhouse Women's Aid who helped me to navigate the psychological literature as to the effects of male violence on women. I am very grateful to her for her support and generosity. I would also like to thank Mark Stephens of Stephens Innocent Solicitors for affording me the opportunity to see how a case involving a battered woman who kills is dealt with in England. There is one group ofpeople whose support, understanding and humour was invaluable; those 1 friends with whom I shared the post-graduate office. In the early days there was Miriam Aziz, Henriette Piene, David Berry, Murray Earle, Nathalie Potin, Christophe Kervegant, Fotini Papoudakis, and Rachael Wadia while more recently Peggy Dwyer, Oddny Arnardottir, Stephanie Eaton, Anna Verges, Michael 0' Neil, Niamh Nic Shuibhne and Tom Takahashi all helped me at various different stages to keep my feet on the ground. So many people have come and gone throughout the course ofthis thesis. To those who remained constant throughout lowe an inexpressible debt. As ever, my family was a tremendous source ofstrength and support and I am grateful to them for willing me towards submission from afar. However, on daily basis it was David who remained steadfast during the highs and lows of the thesis. I thank him for his selflessness, patience and understanding which in no small way helped me to bring this particular chapter to an end. 2 ABSTRACT. Law's representation ofwomen has long been a source ofdebate among feminists. In this thesis, I engage with this debate on a number ofdifferent levels specifically in the context ofbattered women who kill. Although three defences are commonly canvassed, self defence, provocation and diminished responsibility, I limit my proposal for reform to the defence of provocation. My particular proposal involves looking at the possibility ofcombining expert testimony on the battered woman syndrome with the substantive elements ofthat defence in Britain. In part one I begin by setting the defence ofprovocation in its proper doctrinal framework. Thus, in the introduction I argue that provocation is properly conceptualised as a partial excuse. Using Fletcher's theory ofthe individualisation
Recommended publications
  • Council Seeks to Keep Police out of Politics
    Our second Today's weather: century NO" PROfiT ORG Partly sunny; of excellence US POSTAG! chance of PAID showers,. .high 75. ::c Ne"""cHk Qpl Prrm•l No 2& TGIF Student Center, University of De~ware, Newark, Delaware 19716 Vol. 113 No. 30-= Friday, May 15, 1987 Budget Council seeks will top \ to keep police \ $1 billion \ First time out of politics ever in Del. by James Colvard According to Mayor William Staff Reporter M. Redd Jr., the possibility of by Debbie Kalvlnsky a charter change was sparked Staff Reporter A report on a possible change in Newark's charter, by a change in the Police Bill Delaware's 1987-1988 budget to allow c;ity employees to ac­ of Rights which removed will be the state's first to top tively campaign for can­ restrictions on the political ac­ one billion dollars. didates in city elections added tivity of police officers. According to Bob Dowd, fuel to the ongoing dispute bet­ The Police Bill of Rights chief of fiscal and policy ween the mayor and police establishes a uniform set of analysis, the new budget will · force at Monday's City Coun­ rights to forces throughout the · be $1,004,723,500- a substan­ cil meeting. state, and allows police to par­ tial increase over the present In its report, the City ticipate in political cam­ operating budget of Charter Committee recom­ paigns, according to James $928,961,300. mended no change in the cur­ Weldin of the Newark Frater­ The rise is due to a $34 rent charter, which forbids nal Order of Police.
    [Show full text]
  • Psychology: an International 11
    WOMEN'S STUDIES LIBRARIAN The University ofWisconsin System EMINIST ERIODICALS A CURRENT LISTING OF CONTENTS VOLUME 13, NUMBER 3 FALL 1993 Published by Phyllis Holman Weisbard Women's Studies Librarian University of Wisconsin System 430 Memorial Library / 728 State Street Madison, Wisconsin 53706 (608) 263-5754 EMINIST ERIODICALS A CURRENT LISTING OF CONTENTS Volume 13, Number 3 Fall 1993 Periodical literature is the cutting edge of women's scholarship, feminist theory, and much ofwomen'sculture. Feminist Periodicals: A Current Listing of Contents is published by the Office of the University of Wisconsin System Women's Studies Librarian on a quarterly basis with the intent of increasing pUblic awareness of feminist periodicals. It is our hope that Feminist Periodicals will serve several purposes: to keep the reader abreast of current topics in feminist literature; to increase readers' familiarity with a wide spectrum of feminist periodicals; and to provide the requisite bibliographic information should a reader wish to subscribe to ajournal or to obtain a particular article at her library or through interlibrary lOan. (Users will need to be aware of the limitations of the new copyright law with regard to photocopying of copyrighted materials.) Tabie of contents pages from current issues of majorfeminist journals are reproduced in each issue ofFeminist Periodicals, preceded by a comprehensive annotated listing of all journals we have selected. As pUblication schedules vary enormously, not every periodical will have table of contents pages reproduced in each issue of IT. The annotated listing provides the following information on each journal: 1. Year of first publication. 2. Frequency of pUblication.
    [Show full text]
  • Monthly Quiz List February 2021 Q Uiz # Q Uiz Type Fiction / N on Title
    Monthly Quiz List February 2021 Reading Practice (RP) Quizzes Quiz # Quiz Type Fiction/ Non Title Author ISBN Publisher Level Interest Points Level Book Series Sweet Cherry 239741 RP F Alphablocks: ABC Publishing 978-1-78226-597-9 Sweet Cherry Publishing LY 0.5 1.7 Alphablocks 232827 RP F Dave Pigeon Swapna Haddow 978-0-571-32330-2 Faber and Faber LY 1 4.2 Dave Pigeon 239546 RP F Princess is Tired Jay Dale 978-1-4747-9960-7 Raintree LY 0.5 3 Engage Literacy Gold 239545 RP N Healthy Habits Kelly Gaffney 978-1-4747-9959-1 Raintree LY 0.5 3.2 Engage Literacy Gold 239547 RP N Reptiles Kelly Gaffney 978-1-4747-9957-7 Raintree LY 0.5 3.1 Engage Literacy Gold 239471 RP N Why People Move Kelly Gaffney 978-1-4747-9938-6 Raintree LY 0.5 3.8 Engage Literacy Lime 239474 RP F Nature Neighbours Jay Dale 978-1-4747-9952-2 Raintree LY 0.5 2 Engage Literacy Orange 239477 RP F Where's Farmer Belle? Jay Dale 978-1-4747-9943-0 Raintree LY 0.5 1.9 Engage Literacy Orange 239473 RP N Harvest Time Kelly Gaffney 978-1-4747-9946-1 Raintree LY 0.5 2.5 Engage Literacy Orange 239475 RP N Life in the Arctic Anne Giulieri 978-1-4747-9941-6 Raintree LY 0.5 2.9 Engage Literacy Purple 239476 RP N History of Flight Anne Giulieri 978-1-4747-9942-3 Raintree LY 0.5 3.2 Engage Literacy Purple 239023 RP F Gigantosaurus: Don't Cave In Cyber Group Studios 978-1-78741-314-6 Templar Publishing LY 0.5 3.4 Gigantosaurus 239024 RP F Gigantosaurus: The Lost Egg Cyber Group Studios 978-1-78741-313-9 Templar Publishing LY 0.5 3.2 Gigantosaurus 239731 RP N Rubbish Collectors Emily Raij
    [Show full text]
  • WELLINGTON SHIRE LIBRARY NEW & Forthcoming BOOKS & Audio Visual
    WELLINGTON SHIRE LIBRARY NEW & forthcoming BOOKS & Audio visual - april 2020 fiction Author Title Spine* Alderson, Sarah, In her eyes / AF Allcott, Charlene. More than a Mum / AF Andrews, V. C. Out of the attic / AF Baldwin, Jo, The good friend / AF Barrett, Julia, My sister is missing / AF Bell, Christine, No small shame / AF Belle, Kimberly, Dear wife / AF Bishop, Anne, The queen's bargain / AF Box, C. J., Long range / AF Brennan, Allison, The third to die / AF Briggs, David J. The claim / AF Broady, Sylvia, Daughter of the sea / AF Bryndza, Robert, Nine Elms / AF Butler, Sarah, Jack & Bet / AF Cavanagh, Steve, Fifty fifty / AF Chadwick, The Irish princess / AF Chambers, Queenie / AF Chater, Lauren, Gulliver's wife / AF Chavez, Heather, No bad deed / AF Cleave, Paul, Whatever it takes / AF Coates, Darcy, Voices in the snow / AF Cox, Helen (Helen Murder by the Minster / AF Cussler, Clive, Journey of the pharaohs / AF D'Alpuget, Blanche, The lioness wakes / AF Darke, Minnie, The lost love song / AF Diamond, Lucy, An almost perfect holiday / AF Dickinson, Miranda, The day we meet again / AF Docker, Sandie, The Banksia Bay Beach Shack / AF Dolan, Eva, Between two evils / AF Donohue, Rachel, The Temple House vanishing / AF Douglas, Donna, A mother's journey / AF Douglas-Home, The driftwood girls / AF Drinkwater, Carol, House on the edge of the cliff / AF Everett, Felicity, The move / AF Ewart, Andrew, Forget me / AF Fforde, Katie, A springtime affair / AF Fleet, Rebecca, The second wife / AF Foley, Lucy The guest list / AF French, Jackie, Lilies, lies and love / AF Gardner, Lisa, When you see me / AF Goldie, Luan, Nightingale Point / AF Goldsworthy, Anna, Melting moments / AF Goodman, Carol, The sea of lost girls : a novel / AF Goodwin, Rosie, Time to say goodbye / AF Gray, Alex.
    [Show full text]
  • Alan Lomax: Selected Writings 1934-1997
    ALAN LOMAX ALAN LOMAX SELECTED WRITINGS 1934–1997 Edited by Ronald D.Cohen With Introductory Essays by Gage Averill, Matthew Barton, Ronald D.Cohen, Ed Kahn, and Andrew L.Kaye ROUTLEDGE NEW YORK • LONDON Published in 2003 by Routledge 29 West 35th Street New York, NY 10001 www.routledge-ny.com Published in Great Britain by Routledge 11 New Fetter Lane London EC4P 4EE www.routledge.co.uk Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group. This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2005. “To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.” All writings and photographs by Alan Lomax are copyright © 2003 by Alan Lomax estate. The material on “Sources and Permissions” on pp. 350–51 constitutes a continuation of this copyright page. All of the writings by Alan Lomax in this book are reprinted as they originally appeared, without emendation, except for small changes to regularize spelling. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Lomax, Alan, 1915–2002 [Selections] Alan Lomax : selected writings, 1934–1997 /edited by Ronald D.Cohen; with introductory essays by Gage Averill, Matthew Barton, Ronald D.Cohen, Ed Kahn, and Andrew Kaye.
    [Show full text]
  • Titles Ordered February 5 - 12, 2020
    Titles ordered February 5 - 12, 2020 Blu-Ray Adventure Blu-Ray Release Date: Hanks, Tom News Of The World (BD/DVD Combo) http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688843 3/23/2021 Jovovich, Milla Monster Hunter http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688842 3/2/2021 Book Adult Non-Fiction Release Date: Blow, Charles M., 1970- author. The devil you know : a Black power manifesto / http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688405 1/26/2021 Charles M. Blow. Lotz, Anne Graham, 1948- author. The light of His presence : prayers to draw you near http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688845 10/6/2020 to the heart of God / Anne Graham Lotz. Children's Fiction Release Date: Albus, Kate, author. A place to hang the moon / Kate Albus. http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688846 2/2/2021 Children's Graphic Novels Release Date: Abdo, Dan/ Patterson, Jason (ILT) Blue, Barry & Pancakes 1 http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688993 3/9/2021 Ambrosio, Stefano, author. Wizards of Mickey. Origins volume one, Origins / http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688976 11/17/2020 story by Stefano Ambrosio ; art by Lorenzo Pastrovicchio, Marco Gervaslo, Marco Palazzi, Alessandra Perina, Marco Mazzarello, Vitale Mangiatordi, Alessandro Pastrovicchio ; translation by Linda Ghio and Ste Aoki, Akira Star Wars Rebels 1 http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688978 11/17/2020 Atkinson, Cale, author, artist. Simon and Chester : super detectives! / by Cale http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688931 2/9/2021 Atkinson. Ayoub, Jenna, author, artist. Forever home / Jenna Ayoub. http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688990 2/23/2021 Baltazar, Art Gillbert 3 : The Flaming Carats Evolution http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688953 11/24/2020 Behling, Steve/ Usai, Luca (ILT)/ Florio, Silence and Science http://catalog.waukeganpl.org/record=b1688977 3/31/2021 Gianfranco (ILT)/ Cangialosi, Ciro (ILT) Benton, Jim, author, artist.
    [Show full text]
  • London Reclaim the Night 2019 Still Angry After 40 Years
    STILL ANGRY AFTER 40 YEARS LONDON RECLAIM THE NIGHT 2019 A MARCH TO END MALE VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN. Saturday 23rd November 2019 - Assemble at 6pm at Hanover Square, London, W1 for a women-only march http://www.reclaimthenight.co.uk LONDON RECLAIM THE NIGHT 2019 To mark the United Nations International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women, take to the streets and demand justice for rape survivors, freedom from harassment, and an end to all forms of male violence. Join Reclaim the Night 2019! WHY RECLAIM THE NIGHT? • Nearly 1 in 3 women in the UK will experience domestic abuse in their lifetime • Every year around 400,000 women are sexually assaulted and 80,000 women are raped • Around 66,000 women are living with FGM in England & Wales, and 20,000 girls are at risk • 79% of women aged 18-24 recently reported that sexual harrassment was 'the norm' on nights out. • The NSPCC found that teenage girls aged 13-15 were as likely to experience abusive relationships as women aged 16 or more • Two women are murdered by their partners or ex-partners every week Reclaim The Night remains as relevant now as it did in 1977 when the first marches took place in the UK. The women only march will be followed by a rally which is open to all. Speakers include Mandu Reid (Women's Equality Party), Lee Nurse (Justice for Women) and Frances Scott (50:50 Parliament). Further details about the event including the men's vigil will be available at: www.reclaimthenight.co.uk JOIN THE FEMINIST RESURGENCE! To join LFN go to www.londonfeministnetwork.org.uk or our facebook page and follow the instructions.
    [Show full text]
  • How to Organise a Reclaim the Night March
    How to organise a Reclaim the Night march First of all, it’s good to point out what Reclaim the Night (RTN) is. It’s traditionally a women’s march to reclaim the streets after dark, a show of resistance and strength against sexual harassment and assault. It is to make the point that women do not have the right to use public space alone, or with female friends, especially at night, without being seen as ‘fair game’ for harassment and the threat or reality of sexual violence. We should not need chaperones (though that whole Mr Darcy scene is arguably a bit cool, as is Victorian clothing, but not the values). We should not need to have a man with us at all times to protect us from other men. This is also the reason why the marches are traditionally women-only; having men there dilutes our visi- ble point. Our message has much more symbolism if we are women together. How many marches do you see through your town centre that are made up of just women? Exactly. So do think before ruling out your biggest unique selling point. Anyway, the RTN marches first started in several cities in Britain in November 1977, when the Women’s Liberation Movement (WLM) was last at its height, a period called the Second Wave. The idea for the marches was copied from co-ordinated midnight marches across West German cities earlier that same year in April 1977. The marches came to stand for women’s protest against all forms of male violence against women, but particularly sexual vio- lence.
    [Show full text]
  • In Mr. Knox's Country
    In Mr. Knox's Country By Martin Ross IN MR. KNOX'S COUNTRY I THE AUSSOLAS MARTIN CAT Flurry Knox and I had driven some fourteen miles to a tryst with one David Courtney, of Fanaghy. But, at the appointed cross-roads, David Courtney was not. It was a gleaming morning in mid-May, when everything was young and tense and thin and fit to run for its life, like a Derby horse. Above us was such of the spacious bare country as we had not already climbed, with nothing on it taller than a thorn-bush from one end of it to the other. The hill-top blazed with yellow furze, and great silver balls of cloud looked over its edge. Nearly as white were the little white-washed houses that were tucked in and out of the grey rocks on the hill-side. "It's up there somewhere he lives," said Flurry, turning his cart across the road; "which'll you do, hold the horse or go look for him?" I said I would go to look for him. I mounted the hill by a wandering bohireen resembling nothing so much as a series of bony elbows; a white-washed cottage presently confronted me, clinging, like a sea-anemone, to a rock. I knocked at the closed door, I tapped at a window held up by a great, speckled foreign shell, but without success. Climbing another elbow, I repeated the process at two successive houses, but without avail. All was as deserted as Pompeii, and, as at Pompeii, the live rock in the road was worn smooth by feet and scarred with wheel tracks.
    [Show full text]
  • Bitch the Politics of Angry Women
    Bitch The Politics of Angry Women Kylie Murphy Bachelor of Arts with First Class Honours in Communication Studies This thesis is presented for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of Murdoch University 2002. DECLARATION I declare that this thesis is my own account of my research and contains as its main content work which has not previously been submitted for a degree at any tertiary education institution. Kylie Murphy ii ABSTRACT ‘Bitch: the Politics of Angry Women’ investigates the scholarly challenges and strengths in retheorising popular culture and feminism. It traces the connections and schisms between academic feminism and the feminism that punctuates popular culture. By tracing a series of specific bitch trajectories, this thesis accesses an archaeology of women’s battle to gain power. Feminism is a large and brawling paradigm that struggles to incorporate a diversity of feminist voices. This thesis joins the fight. It argues that feminism is partly constituted through popular cultural representations. The separation between the academy and popular culture is damaging theoretically and politically. Academic feminism needs to work with the popular, as opposed to undermining or dismissing its relevancy. Cultural studies provides the tools necessary to interpret popular modes of feminism. It allows a consideration of the discourses of race, gender, age and class that plait their way through any construction of feminism. I do not present an easy identity politics. These bitches refuse simple narratives. The chapters clash and interrogate one another, allowing difference its own space. I mine a series of sites for feminist meanings and potential, ranging across television, popular music, governmental politics, feminist books and journals, magazines and the popular press.
    [Show full text]
  • Newsletter No4 09-10
    Feminist Archive North Newsletter No. 4 Winter 2009-10 www.feministarchivenorth.org.uk/ blog - http://fanorth.wordpress.com/ T-shirts from the Helen John archive This bumper Newsletter celebrates Women’s ensure our materials are properly preserved, Activism, with reports on recent donations to so we have an article on the Life of a FAN and activities we have been involved in Donation, and news of a recent grant from over the last year. These activities are the the Co-op, which was only achieved through reason why it’s been so long since the last the initiative of a volunteer. issue. Primarily, the two volunteers who It’s also important that FAN makes use of usually work on the Newsletter have been new methods for the electronic age. One totally focussed on completing our Education example is the Learning Journey, which went Pack, now on-line and called a Learning live in April, as Feminist Activism – Education Journey. But more of that later. and Job Opportunities, thanks to training Here, you can read about exciting new from the MLA (Museums, Libraries & donations from the Bolton Women’s Archives). Another is the user-friendly guide Liberation Group Archive, which chronicles to blogging. the wealth of their achievements from 1971 But until everyone has the blogging habit, we to 1994, and about the ongoing work of the still include brief news items. Justice for Women campaign. The Treasures Finally, it’s good to note that this issue has series features an archive donated by the been much more of a team effort, with six veteran women’s peace campaigner Helen volunteers making contributions.
    [Show full text]
  • The Criminal Justice Response to Women Who Kill an Interview with Helena Kennedy Sheila Quaid and Catherine Itzin Introduction
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Sunderland University Institutional Repository The criminal justice response to women who kill An interview with Helena Kennedy Sheila Quaid and Catherine Itzin Introduction This chapter is based on an interview with Helena Kennedy QC by Catherine Itzin. It has been edited into the form of a narrative, covering a range of issues relating to women and the criminal justice system, and in particular explores the question of 'Why do women kill?'. In Helena Kennedy's experience of defending women, she asserts that most women kill in desperation, in self... defence or in the defence of their children. Women's experience of violence and escape from violence has received much critical comment and campaigning for law reform over the past few years and some cases such as Sara Thornton, Kiranjit Ahluwalia and Emma Humphreys have achieved a high public profile as campaigners have fought for their release from life sentences. All three women had sustained years of violence and abuse from their partners and had killed in their attempts to stop the violence. Who women kill Women are rarely involved in serial killing and they almost never go out and plan the anonymous killing of a victim with whom who they have no connection at all. For the most part women kill people they know and primarily these people are men. They kill within the domestic arena: they kill their husbands, their lovers, their boyfriends and sometimes they kill their children. Occasion... ally it might stretch beyond the domestic parameter, but the numbers are incredibly small, and when women kill it is when something is going very wrong with their domestic environment.
    [Show full text]