Measures to Disseminate Stock Property

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Measures to Disseminate Stock Property MEASURES TO DISSEMINATE STOCK PROPERTY Report by the Emerging Markets Committee of the International Organization of Securities Commissions May 1999 Table of Contents Page • Introduction 1 • Conclusion 2 • Comparative Report 1. Market Statistics 9 2. Policies Towards Dissemination of Stock Property 17 3. Protection of Minorities 27 4. Developing a Culture of Investing 35 5. Employee’s Participation 41 6. Market – Liquidity and Practices 45 • Answers of the Members of the Emerging Markets Committee to the Questionnaire on Measures to Disseminate Stock Property 53 INTRODUCTION At IOSCO’s 1997 Annual Conference, the Emerging Markets Committee gave to the Working Group on Disclosure and Accounting (EMC-WG1) the mandate to study regulatory measures to facilitate the dissemination of stock property in emerging market countries. This comparative analysis focuses on enhancing the capital formation process among public companies or those willing to access capital markets, through regulatory policies that promotes incentives for a broader domestic investor participation in stocks of public companies. Fair distribution of wealth and granting citizens open access to property are paramount objectives of modern democratic societies. They also provide political stability for those nations, which is essential for sustained economic growth. The dissemination of stock property is one of the main tools available to achieve these goals. Developing a solid and diversified domestic shareholding basis is a key objective because it can act as a shock absorber during periods of international turmoils. In order to achieve liquidity and stability in stock markets, securities regulators can play an important role to facilitate a broad dissemination of stock property, mainly among retail investors. To achieve these goals certain conditions must be met and some regulatory tools are available to foster and encourage domestic retail investments. This report reviews the measures adopted by the jurisdictions surveyed and designed to promote the dissemination of stock property. Its contents neither intends to reach to a conclusion about which measures or policies are the best, nor to recommend any specific measures. The general objective of this report is to provide a comparative “checklist” of the different measures adopted by the jurisdictions included in the survey for the dissemination of stock property, with the expectation that it will be a useful tool for the Emerging Markets Committee member regulators when facing this complex issue. 1 CONCLUSION • Market statistics. The statistical information contained in charts 1 to 6 shows that a very low percentage of the total population of the emerging markets included in the survey invest in stocks. Except in Chinese Taipei and the Czech Republic, the level of dissemination of stock property is very low. Trading is concentrated in a reduced number of shares of big public companies, which are preferred by both local and foreign investors. We also note the lack of sufficient statistical data on this specific topic. • Policies towards dissemination of stock property. Most of the jurisdictions included in this survey adopted different types of policies in order to promote dissemination of stock property, except for Bulgaria, Jamaica, Korea, Morocco, Paraguay and Thailand, which have not yet done so. The identified measures are the following: • Specific legal provisions related, in particular: issuers’ capital requirements (in order to facilitate the distribution of primary offerings), maximum percentages of stock holdings for institutional investors, privileges granted to retail investors in order to facilitate their participation in public companies as shareholders; • Tax incentives; • Non-specific measures designed to directly improve markets liquidity and transparency, (considering that this improvement will increase investor participation and subsequently disseminate stock property). At the moment Argentina has no concrete measures in place to speciffically promote dissemination of stock property. By contrast to the Argentinian experience, in Venezuela, Singapore, Poland, Mauritius and Israel, the local regulation contains specific requirements (such as maximum percentages of shares that can be acquired by institutional investors, capital requirements for the issuers in order to be listed, first refusal choice granted to retail investors for the acquisition of new offerings) with the objective of ensuring dissemination of stock property from primary offerings. In Israel, the possibility of adopting an underwriting system, similar to the United States’ system, is under study. 2 Other jurisdictions, such as Chinese Taipei, Barbados and Chile, promote dispersion through measures that are designed to directly improve market operations, with expectations that they will also have a positive effect on the distribution of stock property. Privatization programs of state-owned companies adopted by Argentina, Tunisia, South Africa, Peru and the Czech Republic provide that a percentage of shares of privatized companies are to be sold in the domestic market in order to facilitate ownership by retail investors. Another percentage of these shares is also reserved for employees and company clients. Turkey offers a beneficial tax treatment related to the acquisition of shares in order to favor share distribution and also promotes the participation of retail investors in the market through mutual funds, which were recently regulated. • Incentives for small and family owned companies to go public. Requirements for their stock dissemination. Mechanisms to promote liquidity of small business. Half of the jurisdictions surveyed have not adopted incentives for small and family owned companies for going public. Those jurisdictions are Peru, Poland, Paraguay, Panama, Mauritius, Korea, Jamaica, Hungary, the Czech Republic, Chile, Bulgaria and Argentina. The other half of the jurisdictions surveyed adopted one or more of the following measures to stimulate small and family owned companies into going public: • Creation of special markets to negotiate shares and bonds of small businesses (Singapore, Brazil and Barbados). • Favorable requirements for small business listing at local exchanges (Thailand, South Africa, Morocco and Israel). • Legal provisions appointing special capital requirements for small and family owned companies as well as a minimum number of shareholders (Chinese Taipei) and flexible requirements for disclosure of financial information and presentation of financial statements (Turkey). • Advantageous tax treatment (Turkey, Venezuela). The following jurisdictions have not implemented any related measures: Argentina, Chile, Israel, Jamaica, Korea, Morocco, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Thailand and Tunisia. Some specific measures were adopted in Brazil for small companies (regulation of market makers’ activities, which provides liquidity for companies listed in the Electronic Quotation System (SOMA)). In Mauritius small company shares are negotiated in the over-the-counter market which provides a fair liquidity. In Poland a market maker system provides increasing liquidity in the over-the- counter market designed for listing small companies. Other specific measures were also implemented in Singapore, South Africa, Chinese Taipei and Turkey. 3 • Ability to issue non-voting shares. The legislation of all the jurisdictions included in the survey, except for Bulgaria, Poland and Singapore, provide that public companies can issue non-voting shares. Not all shareholders are interested in exercising their voting rights. Most of the jurisdictions surveyed therefore provide the alternative of issuing non-voting shares, which can or cannot give the right to receive a preferred dividend. This provision affects the traditional relationship between capital and voting rights, but facilitates the flow of savings towards equity investments. • Main factors preventing investments in the capital market. Among the various common factors mentioned in response to the questionnaire circulated are: - Lack of investment culture and education; - Market volatility and low liquidity; - Deficiency in market transparency; - Stronger banking investment culture and related investment opportunities. These factors fall within the responsibility of domestic market regulators, whose missions are partly related to the general improvement of market activities. Several of them indicated that they are in the process of addressing them in light of the IOSCO Principles and Objectives of Securities Regulation. • Local corporate law provisions addressing the protection of minority shareholders from controlling shareholders’ abuse or misconduct. All the jurisdictions surveyed describe their domestic regulation related to the protection of minority shareholders (ref. Table 10). They also indicated which factors, in their opinion, could be considered the most relevant to foster investors confidence (chart 11): - Corporate law provisions (Argentina, Brazil, Poland); 4 - Provisions related to shareholders’ right to seek a court of law revision of decisions adopted by the general meeting of shareholders as well as the judicial protection of individual shareholder’s rights (Barbados, Bulgaria, Korea, Singapore, Paraguay, Chinese Taipei); - Provisions specially addressing minority shareholder protection (Mauritius, Morocco, Tunisia and Turkey); - All the capital markets’ regulatory framework (Chile, Hungary); - Provisions referred to the disclosure of company financial and
Recommended publications
  • Pricing and Spread Components at the Lima Stock Exchange
    Pricing and spread components at the Lima Stock Exchange Luis Chávez-Bedoya, Carlos Loaiza Álamo and Giannio Téllez De Vettori ABSTRT AC This paper analyses three aspects of the share market operated by the Lima Stock Exchange: (i) the short-term relationship between the pricing, direction and volume of order flows; (ii) the components of the spread and the equilibrium point of the limit order book per share, and (iii) the pricing, order direction and trading volume dynamic resulting from shocks in the same variables when lagged. The econometric results for intraday data from 2012 show that the short-run dynamic of the most and least liquid shares in the General Index of the Lima Stock Exchange is explained by the direction of order flow, whose price impact is temporary in both cases. KEYWORDS Stock markets, stocks, prices, econometric models, Peru JEL CLASSIFICATION G11, G12, G15 AUS THOR Luis Chávez-Bedoya teaches finance at the esan Graduate School of Business, Lima, Peru. [email protected] Carlos Loaiza Álamo teaches at the Faculty of Administration and Finance of the Peruvian University of Applied Sciences (upc), Lima, Peru. [email protected] Giannio Téllez De Vettori is a teaching assistant at the Department of Economics of the Catholic University of Peru and a researcher affiliated with the esan Graduate School of Business, Lima, Peru. [email protected] CEPAL_Review_115_3.indd 115 06/08/15 08:18 116 CEPAL REVIEW 115 • april 2015 I Introduction The Peruvian stock market has struggled to develop obtain this information for the present study, however, sustainably as an investment alternative, yet little with a view to obtaining a better understanding of the basic or applied research has been done on it.
    [Show full text]
  • Integration Level of Equity Markets in APEC's Emerging
    Integration level of equity markets in APEC’s emerging countries: Are emerging markets regionally or globally integrated? Authors: Cynthia Ho Szee Yah Dinh Thi Quynh Anh Supervisor: Per Nilsson Student Umeå School of Business Autumn semester 2010 Master thesis, two-year, 30 hp Integration level of equity markets in APEC’s emerging countries: Are emerging markets regionally or globally integrated? Anh Dinh Cynthia Ho Abstract Supported by the investment barriers removal, financial deregulation and improved macroeconomic policies during the last three decades, the process of financial integration in those markets, emerging markets in general and emerging markets within Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) in particular, has been pro-actively accessed these days. Moreover, recent trend in globalization in many APEC countries and especially in the emerging markets has triggered a stronger financial integration progress across countries. Nevertheless, it is surprising to find that these countries not only benefited from regional financial integration but also experienced global financial integration in the same period. Markets over the last two decades, which have been highlighted by financial crises occurred among those APEC emerging countries in the early of the year 1997, have raised political, social and economic questions. One of prominent questions among them: “Are emerging markets in APEC regionally or globally integrated?” has raised our interest in measuring the integration level in these countries. Our thesis paper, therefore, seeks to answer the question on the degree of financial integration level in nine APEC emerging countries. Collecting stock indexes from the Chile (Santiago Stock Exchange), China (Shanghai Stock Exchange), Indonesia (Indonesia Stock Exchange), Malaysia (Bursa Malaysia), Mexico (Mexican Stock Exchange), Philippines (Philippines Stock Exchange), Peru (Lima Stock Exchange), Russia (RTS Russian Stock Exchange), Thailand (Thailand Stock Exchange), we compute empirically the integration scores for these nine countries.
    [Show full text]
  • Equity Market Development in Latin America
    1. INTRODUCTION 1 Equity Market Development in Latin America Peru This report examines and makes recommendations aimed at strengthening equity market development in Peru. It was developed as part of the work of the OECD Latin American Corporate Governance Roundtable’s Task Force on Equity Market Development, and served as a reference for Task Force discussions that took place in Argentina in June 2018. The report on Peru and additional country reports on Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia and Mexico have drawn upon an OECD survey of company and investor perceptions in these six countries as well as additional research and interviews with market regulators, participants and other stakeholders. The six country chapters have also served as a reference for the 2019 OECD publication, “Equity Market Development in Latin America: Enhancing Access to Corporate Finance”, which provides a more comparative perspective on developments across all six countries. The report was prepared by Andres Bernal ([email protected]) and Edna Correa, under the supervision of .Daniel Blume, Senior Policy Analyst, OECD Corporate Governance and Corporate Finance Division Special thanks are due to Marco Antonio Saldivar and Magaly Martinez of BVL, Gerardo Gonzalez of Procapitales, Miguel Puga of PWC and Enrique Solano. SMV also helped us to acquire information, interviews and data required to prepare this document. This work is published under the responsibility of the Secretary-General of the OECD. The opinions expressed and arguments employed herein do not necessarily reflect the official views of the OECD or of the governments of its member countries or those of the European Union. This document and any map included herein are without prejudice to the status of or sovereignty over any territory, to the delimitation of international frontiers and boundaries and to the name of any territory, city or area.
    [Show full text]
  • Market Highlights for First Half-Year 2012
    23 July 2012 Market highlights for first half-year 2012 The size of global markets (the global market capitalization) increased by 5.3% in the first half of 2012. In Americas and Asia Pacific, the relative good performance of stock markets in the first half of 2012 (market capitalization up 9.1% and 4.6% respectively) was not sufficient for market capitalization to reach the levels observed one year ago, before the sharp decline in the summer 2011. In EAME region, the market capitalization in USD did not grow. It was mainly due to the lower performance of stock markets in Europe following the sovereign debt crisis as well as the exchange rates. In constant USD, the EAME region’s market capitalization did increase by 2.1% in the first half of 2012. In Asia Pacific region, the growth rate of market capitalization in constant USD1 was also higher (+6%) than in current USD. Growth in market capitalization is sometimes the result of an increased number of listed companies, but in the first half of 2011 the total number of listed companies at WFE level was steady. Decline of trading volumes on stock exchange Despite the higher market capitalization, the total value of share trading2 of WFE member exchanges continued to decrease significantly falling 14% in the first half of 2012 after an earlier drop of 4% in second half-year of 2011. The most significant decrease was observed in the Americas region (-20%). This was mostly due to US exchanges (accounting for 90% of the value of share trading) that decreased by 21%.
    [Show full text]
  • Stock Market Indicators
    Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Science 20 (2015) 74–83 Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Science www.elsevier.es/jefas Article Emerging Markets Integration in Latin America (MILA) Stock market indicators: Chile, Colombia, and Peru a,∗ b c d Edmundo R. Lizarzaburu Bolanos˜ , Kurt Burneo , Hamilton Galindo , Luis Berggrun a Universidad ESAN, Lima, Peru b Universidad San Ignacio de Loyola, Lima, Peru c Universidad del Pacífico, Lima, Peru d Universidad Icesi, Cali, Colombia a b s t r a c t a r t i c l e i n f o Article history: This study aims to determine the impact of the Latin American Integrated Market (MILA) start-up in Received 7 May 2015 the main indicators of the stock markets of the countries that conform it (Chile, Colombia, and Peru). Accepted 18 August 2015 At the end, several indicators were reviewed to measure the impact on profitability, risk, correlation, and trading volume between markets, using indicators such as: annual profitability, standard deviation, JEL classification: correlation coefficient, and trading volume. The sample period runs from November 2008 to August 2013; G15 and involves the three stock markets associated with MILA: Bolsa de Comercio de Santiago (BCS), Bolsa Keywords: de Valores de Colombia (BVC) y Bolsa de Valores de Lima (BVL). MILA An additional evaluation for further research would consist of the calculation of relevant indicators to Integration corroborate the validity of the effects found in this investigation corresponding to the integration of the Risk stock exchanges of Lima, Santiago and Bogota, after the integration of the Mexican stock exchange that Emerging markets occurred in 2014.
    [Show full text]
  • MSCI Global Market Accessibility Review
    MSCI Global Market Accessibility Review June 2014 msci.com MSCI Global Market Accessibility Review June 2014 Contents Contents ....................................................................................... 1 I ‐ Introduction ............................................................................. 3 II ‐ Assessing accessibility ............................................................ 4 III ‐ Review Summary ................................................................... 8 IV ‐ Developed Markets ............................................................ 12 V ‐ Emerging Markets ................................................................ 15 VI ‐ Frontier Markets ................................................................. 26 VII ‐ Standalone Markets ........................................................... 35 VIII ‐ Appendices ........................................................................ 40 Appendix I: MSCI Market Classification Framework ............................................ 40 Appendix II: Assessment Results............................................................................. 42 Appendix III: Market Accessibility Measures......................................................... 49 Client Service Information is Available 24 Hours a Day ....................................... 51 Notice and Disclaimer .............................................................................................. 51 About MSCI ..............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Doing Data Differently
    General Company Overview Doing data differently V.14.9. Company Overview Helping the global financial community make informed decisions through the provision of fast, accurate, timely and affordable reference data services With more than 20 years of experience, we offer comprehensive and complete securities reference and pricing data for equities, fixed income and derivative instruments around the globe. Our customers can rely on our successful track record to efficiently deliver high quality data sets including: § Worldwide Corporate Actions § Worldwide Fixed Income § Security Reference File § Worldwide End-of-Day Prices Exchange Data International has recently expanded its data coverage to include economic data. Currently it has three products: § African Economic Data www.africadata.com § Economic Indicator Service (EIS) § Global Economic Data Our professional sales, support and data/research teams deliver the lowest cost of ownership whilst at the same time being the most responsive to client requests. As a result of our on-going commitment to providing cost effective and innovative data solutions, whilst at the same time ensuring the highest standards, we have been awarded the internationally recognized symbol of quality ISO 9001. Headquartered in United Kingdom, we have staff in Canada, India, Morocco, South Africa and United States. www.exchange-data.com 2 Company Overview Contents Reference Data ............................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • List of Approved Regulated Stock Exchanges
    Index Governance LIST OF APPROVED REGULATED STOCK EXCHANGES The following announcement applies to all equity indices calculated and owned by Solactive AG (“Solactive”). With respect to the term “regulated stock exchange” as widely used throughout the guidelines of our Indices, Solactive has decided to apply following definition: A Regulated Stock Exchange must – to be approved by Solactive for the purpose calculation of its indices - fulfil a set of criteria to enable foreign investors to trade listed shares without undue restrictions. Solactive will regularly review and update a list of eligible Regulated Stock Exchanges which at least 1) are Regulated Markets comparable to the definition in Art. 4(1) 21 of Directive 2014/65/EU, except Title III thereof; and 2) provide for an investor registration procedure, if any, not unduly restricting foreign investors. Other factors taken into account are the limits on foreign ownership, if any, imposed by the jurisdiction in which the Regulated Stock Exchange is located and other factors related to market accessibility and investability. Using above definition, Solactive has evaluated the global stock exchanges and decided to include the following in its List of Approved Regulated Stock Exchanges. This List will henceforth be used for calculating all of Solactive’s equity indices and will be reviewed and updated, if necessary, at least annually. List of Approved Regulated Stock Exchanges (February 2017): Argentina Bosnia and Herzegovina Bolsa de Comercio de Buenos Aires Banja Luka Stock Exchange
    [Show full text]
  • Nomura Investment Solutions Plc PROSPECTUS 21 DECEMBER 2020
    The Directors of the Company whose names appear in the “Management and Administration” section accept responsibility for the information contained in this document. To the best of the knowledge and belief of the Directors (who have taken all reasonable care to ensure that such is the case) the information contained in this document is in accordance with the facts and does not omit anything likely to affect the importance of such information. The Directors accept responsibility accordingly. Nomura Investment Solutions plc (An investment company with variable capital constituted as an umbrella fund with segregated liability between sub-funds under the laws of Ireland and authorised by the Central Bank of Ireland pursuant to the UCITS Regulations PROSPECTUS 21 DECEMBER 2020 MANAGER NOMURA ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT FRANCE S.A.S Neither the Company nor any Portfolio is, or will be, registered as an investment company in the United States under the U.S. Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the “1940 Act”), and the Shares are not, and will not be, registered under the U.S. Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the “1933 Act”). Sales or transfers of the Shares (or any beneficial interest therein) may be effected only in a transaction (A) (i) pursuant to an effective registration statement under the 1933 Act, (ii) pursuant to an available exemption from the registration requirements of the 1933 Act (and applicable state securities laws of the U.S.) or (iii) that meets the requirements of Regulation S under the 1933 Act (“Regulation S”) to persons who are not “US Persons” as such term is defined in Regulation S, and (B) that would not require the Company or any Portfolio to become subject to the 1940 Act.
    [Show full text]
  • Candente Gold Announces Lima Stock Exchange Listing
    NEWS RELEASE BVL:CDG TSX:CDG Candente Gold Announces Lima Stock Exchange Listing Vancouver, British Columbia, August 23 2010. Candente Gold Corp. (BVL:CDG / TSX:CDG) ("Candente Gold") is pleased to announce that its common shares have been listed for trading on the Bolsa de Valores de Lima ("BVL"). Trading will be conducted under the ticker symbol ‘CDG’. Kallpa Securities S.A.B. is acting as Candente Gold's sponsoring broker and was instrumental in assisting Candente Gold to secure the necessary approvals from the BVL and the Comision Nacional Supervisora de Empresas y Valores. The history of the BVL dates from December 31, 1860 and today it is one of the most important markets in South America. A new initiative by the BVL to join markets with the stock exchanges of Chile and Colombia is expected to enter its first stage in 2011. This step is aimed to create the third largest stock exchange in Latin America with a combined capitalization of nearly US$500 billion, which will add excellent exposure to investors from many countries for companies listed on the BVL. Additional information about the BVL may be found in Spanish at www.bvl.com.pe. "Peru ranks as one of the top 5 producers worldwide of gold, silver, copper, and zinc, and Peruvians understand mining and know what it takes to be successful at it,” remarked Joanne Freeze, President, CEO and Director of Candente Gold. “Candente Gold’s sister company, Candente Copper (BVL:DNT) obtained their listing on the BVL in 2007 and found it to be very strategic, with over 20% of DNT shares now held by Peruvians.” Candente Gold hopes to replicate this success, by exposing the highly knowledgeable Peruvian mining investors to the immense potential of Candente Gold’s Mexican and Peruvian properties.
    [Show full text]
  • Exchanges Maturing in Their Sustainability Efforts
    WFE Sustainability Survey May 2018 WFE SustainabilityExchanges Survey MayMaturing 2018 Exchangesin Their Maturing Sustainability in Their SustainabilityEfforts Efforts Contents 1. Executive Summary………………………………………………………………………………………………….3 2. Introduction….………….………………………………………………………………………………………………4 3. Survey Results and Discussions………………………………………………………………………….……5 3.1 Exchanges and Sustainability…………………………………………………….…………………………..5 3.2 Transparency and Reporting…………………………………………………….……….…………………..9 3.3 Sustainability Products and Investor Demand……………………………………………………...11 4. Concluding Remarks: Exchanges Maturing in Their ESG Efforts…………………………...13 Annex 1: Survey Approach………………………………………………………………………………………………...14 Annex 2: Survey Respondents…………………………………………………………………………………..……….15 Annex 3: Additional Responses……………………………………………………………………………………….…16 Annex 3: Survey Questionnaire……………………………………………………………………………………….…18 2 1. Executive Summary As sustainable finance becomes increasingly mainstream, exchanges are expanding the scope and extent of their involvement. This 2017 survey of the World Federation of Exchanges' membership examines exchanges sustainability initiatives and highlights exchange efforts to improve ESG disclosure by listed companies, and to enable the financing of a transition to a more sustainable economy. For the first time this year, the WFE asked members about their efforts in relation to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs) and the Recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD).
    [Show full text]
  • The London Stock Exchange
    The Journal of Applied Business Research – January/February 2014 Volume 30, Number 1 The London Stock Exchange: Strategic Corporate Governance Restructuring After Demutualization Laura Padilla Angulo, Groupe ESC Troyes en Champagne, France Faten Ben Slimane, IRG Institute - University Paris-Est-Marne la Vallée, France Djaoudath Alidou, Université de Bourgogne, France & IUT de Parakou, Republic of Benin ABSTRACT This study uses the London Stock Exchange (LSE), forced to demutualize due to major changes in its business environment, notably due to increased competition and technological advances, as field experiment to study corporate governance restructuring to adapt to new market conditions. The LSE improved its financial situation after demutualization and is an example of successful corporate governance restructuring. The LSE significantly restructured the composition of its board of directors following demutualization. The number of exchange members on the LSE board decreased after demutualization while the number of independent directors increased, pointing to a more “monitoring board”, in support of an agency theory approach. Interestingly, the large majority of these independent directors had experiences in diverse business. The LSE significantly reorganized its management team to adapt to the new strategies triggered by demutualization and modified its compensation by increasing performance-related payments. Results suggest that demutualization brings efficiencies if accompanied by changes in the governing bodies and in the incentive structures of the exchanges. Most of our results could be relevant also, for example, for firms going public, for smaller firms that are expanding their activities and searching for outside investors and for companies facing major changes in their business environments. Keywords: Corporate Governance; Business Strategy; Demutualization; London Stock Exchange 1.
    [Show full text]