The Oti Program in East Timor
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FINAL EVALUATION: THE OTI PROGRAM IN EAST TIMOR Submitted to: U.S. Agency for International Development Under: CDIE/PPC/Evaluation IQC AEP-I-00-00-00023-00 Prepared by: Jeffrey Clark With input from: Ann von Briesen Lewis Lia Juliani Submitted by: Development Associates, Inc. 1730 North Lynn St. Arlington, VA, 22209-2023 February 2003 TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Acronyms.......................................................................................................................iii Executive Summary..................................................................................................................iv Part One: OTI In East Timor...............................................................................................1 I. Introduction ..................................................................................................................1 Country Background......................................................................................................1 Crisis of 1999. ................................................................................................................2 Aftermath........................................................................................................................3 Evaluation of OTI. .........................................................................................................4 II. Methodology..................................................................................................................6 III. Overview of OTI Operations in East Timor............................................................7 A. Management Structures.....................................................................................9 1. Overall Management of the OTI Program in East Timor...................9 Background............................................................................................9 OTI Management ..................................................................................10 Analysis and Conclusions.....................................................................11 2. Procurement Procedures .......................................................................12 Background............................................................................................12 OTI Procurement Procedures in East Timor. ......................................12 Analysis and Conclusions.....................................................................14 3. Record Keeping/Databanks ..................................................................15 Background............................................................................................15 Analysis and Conclusions.....................................................................15 B. OTI’S Exit from East Timor..............................................................................16 Background. .......................................................................................................16 Analysis and Conclusions. ................................................................................16 C. General Conclusions of the Evaluation............................................................18 Did OTI stay too long in East Timor?..............................................................19 Did OTI spend too much money in East Timor?.............................................20 Part Two: Meeting Specific Program Objectives...............................................................20 I. OTI and Economic Recovery .....................................................................................20 Background. ...........................................................................................................20 OTI Engagement....................................................................................................20 Analysis and Conclusions. ....................................................................................22 Final Evaluation: OTI Program in East Timor i February 2003 Development Associates, Inc. II. OTI and Democratic Evolution..................................................................................24 A. Increasing the Public’s Access to Information//Citizen Participation in Government Increased...........................................................................................26 B. Political Institutions Strengthened ........................................................................29 C. Justice/Rule of Law................................................................................................31 Part Three: OTI Interaction with Key Actors....................................................................34 A. OTI and the NGO Sector.......................................................................................34 B. OTI and the Media.................................................................................................38 C. OTI and UNTAET .................................................................................................42 D. OTI and Other Donors...........................................................................................46 E. OTI and the Government of East Timor...............................................................47 F. OTI and the Civilian/Military Relationship Question .........................................50 G. OTI and the Decommissioned Soldiers of FALINTIL........................................52 Part Four: Looking Ahead//Lessons Learned......................................................................54 ANNEXES Annex A Bibliography ...........................................................................................................A-1 Annex B List of Interviewed Individuals............................................................................B-1 Annex C Annotated Evaluations ...........................................................................................C-1 Annex D Timeline: East Timor’s Long Path to Nationhood ............................................D-1 Annex E The Social Kaleidoscope of East Timor...............................................................E-1 Annex F Map of East Timor..................................................................................................F-1 Final Evaluation: OTI Program in East Timor ii February 2003 LIST OF ACRONYMS AusAid Australian Agency for International Development BELE Building Empowerment, Leadership and Engagement BHR Bureau of Humanitarian Response CDIE Center for Development Information and Evaluation CEP Community Empowerment and Local Governance Project CFET Consolidated Fund for East Timor (transitional) CNRT National Council of Timorese Resistance DAI Development Alternatives Incorporated ETPA East Timor Public Administration ETTA East Timor Transitional Administration FALINTIL Forcas Armadas de Liberacao Nacional de Timor Leste ( East Timor National Liberation Army) FRAP FALINTIL Reinsertion Assistance Program FRETELIN Frente Revolucionaria de Timor Leste Independente (Revolutionary Front of Independent East Timor) GET Government of East Timor GPA Governance and Public Administration INTERFET International Force in East Timor IOM International Organization for Migration NCBA National Coffee Business Association NGO Non Governmental Organization OFDA Office of Foreign Disaster Assistance OTI USAID Office of Transition Initiatives RDTL Republica Democratica de Timor Leste (Democratic Republic of East Timor) SWIFT Support Which Implements Fast Transition TEP Transitional Employment Program TEPS II Transitional Engagement for Population Support TFET Trust Fund for East Timor (IBRD,ADB) TLJA Timor Lorosae Journalists Association UNESCO United Nations Education, Scientific and Cultural Organization UNHCR United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees UNTAET United Nations Transitional Administration in East Timor UNMISET United Nations Mission in Support of East Timor USAID United States Agency for International Development Final Evaluation: OTI Program in East Timor iii February 2003 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The report which follows constitutes the final evaluation of the three year Office of Transition Initiatives operation in East Timor. It stems from an independent examination and analysis of OTI’s program in that country, as it emerged from the violence of September 1999 and faced the multiple challenges inherent in constructing a new government and in defining a new nation. The evaluation, conducted in October and November of 2002, was undertaken through a big picture approach meant to capture the entirety of OTI’s experience in East Timor. The evaluators concentrated on two fundamental questions: Is there evidence that OTI’s interventions had impact? Did the interventions deliver on the stated objectives? The evaluation team closely examined the primary components of OTI programming in East Timor. Of primary interest were various projects meant to promote economic recovery and to strengthen the democratic development of East Timor, which were the fundamental objectives pursued by OTI. For the democratic development aspect, the evaluation team focused on efforts to: Increase the public’s access to information pertinent to the establishment of government; Strengthen the political institutions; Increase citizen participation in the governance of the country; and Solidify the rule of law and strengthen the justice sector. The report offers an analysis specific to the economic recovery and strengthened democratic