“Children are children, “It’s a culture of secrecy and “We wanted to capture whether they are in the I think it’s deeply unhelpful such moments and share justice system or not.” both for staff and prisoners.” them with the world.” the National Newspaper for Prisoners & Detainees Keith Fraser Professor Graham Towl New animation from PET a voice for prisoners since Comment // page 21 Comment // page 28 Information // page 35 June 2021 / Issue No. 264 / www.insidetime.org / A ‘not for profit’ publication/ ISSN 1743-7342 WALKING FOR FAITH 18 // THE POETRY OF SPIES 31 LISTINGS INSIDE An average of 60,000 copies distributed monthly Independently verified by the Audit Bureau of Circulations DOUBLE PODDING! ‘Game changing’ proposals condemned by prison reform groups as ‘panic measures’ and ‘terrible step backwards’
Decent accommodation is made indecent. It would be a terrible step backwards if that now happened with cells bought explicitly to eliminate 47 the need to share.”
The scheme came to light when GFSL, the Government- ‘A sense of escapism’ owned maintenance contrac- tor, announced last month Street Heat man tells of journey from cells to airwaves that it had installed 80 pods at HMP Ford - which it de- scribed as 40 singles and 40 doubles, claiming they would soon be occupied by 120 men. We are delighted to announce the “Singles or doubles? Pods at Askham Grange” The MoJ later clarified that all arrival of Jeremy Moore, formerly of 80 would start off in sin- Carter Moore Solicitors Inside Time report 31 jails “can be converted into gle-occupancy use, but con- doubles with the use of a firmed that 40 could hold two bunk for two occupants”. The men in the future. It was una- Portable single cells being spokesman added that “dou- ble to say how much size dif- Jeremy Moore is one of the used to provide extra accom- ble occupancy is viewed as ference there is between pods modation during the pan- being a contingency only” that are considered suitable demic may be “doubled up” and would require the gover- for doubling-up and those leading solicitors in the with bunk beds to cope with nor’s approval. that are seen as too small. surging prisoner numbers. They are The pods installed so far, country for criminal defence Since the first wave of Covid- completely inap- known as Temporary Accom- 19 struck last year, the Minis- modation Units, were an- try of Justice has installed more propriate to put nounced as single occupancy and miscarriages of justice than 1,000 temporary units - two people in. cells to reduce virus transmis- known as “pods” - in the sion, and were obtained “off Specialising in complex and high profile grounds of English and Welsh That’s ridiculous. the shelf” from portable criminal defence and appeals. jails to reduce cell-sharing. building suppliers - the ma- The plan drew immediate jority from hire firm So far there has been only one criticism from prison reform Bunkabin. He is notable for acting in numerous occupant per pod. Each has a charities. Frances Crook, single bed, toilet and shower, chief executive of the Howard Looking beyond the pan- miscarriage of justice cases, and they have generally League for Penal Reform, demic, Justice Secretary Rob- including successfully representing proved popular. called it a “panic measure” ert Buckland has announced Barry George in his appeal against and said: “They are com- plans for a further 1,000 port- However, it has now emerged pletely inappropriate to put able units to increase prison conviction for the murder of Jill that the Prison Service is pre- two people in. That’s capacity. These will be known Dando and subsequent trials. pared to make prisoners share ridiculous.” as Rapid Deployment Cells pods, if necessary, to meet and will be custom-designed population pressures. Peter Dawson, director of the for the Prison Service to a To speak with Jeremy about your case Prison Reform Trust, said: higher security standard. please contact us at the address or on A spokesperson told Inside “Time and again, new single the number below. We represent Time that around half of the cells, designed and built for 1,070 units currently in use at one person, are doubled up. Continued on page 15 clients throughout England and Wales. 76 KING STREET, 0800 1444111 NEWS FLASH! JUSTICE COMMITTEE CALLS FOR EVIDENCE FROM PRISONERS! 33 MANCHESTER, M2 4NH 0161 393 4158 [email protected] 2 Mailbag ‘Mailbag’, Inside Time, Botley Mills, Botley, Southampton SO30 2GB. Insidetime June 2021 insidetime Approved Another language Mailbites a voice for prisoners since 1990 supplier Name supplied - HMP Whitemoor The mote in your eye the national newspaper for prisoners published Bradley Tucker - Steve Kidd - HMP Berwyn by Inside Time Limited, a wholly owned Sadly, I am led to believe that more people don’t graduate HMP The Mount subsidiary of The New Bridge Foundation, from personality disorder courses than those who do gradu- I write in response to a letter by GJM Goodsir founded in 1956 to create links between the ate on completion. A recurrent theme amongst those who of HMP Stafford (April issue). He wrote of offender and the community PUBLISHED Here at The Mount, we are were deselected/discharged is that they didn’t understand ‘miscreants’, as he called them, writing to WEEKLY ONLINE AND MONTHLY IN PRINT being told that our families the language used by their therapists, felt belittled, ignored Inside Time ‘bellyaching’ about prison life. He are only allowed to order or made to feel worthless, or rejected by those professionals states none of them write about remorse or books from ‘approved within the service. sorrow for the hurt they have caused to their Board of Directors suppliers’, and the reason victims. He then, sickeningly, goes on to lick staff give for this is due to Another theme is that men and women who complain about Trevor Grove - Chairman Former Editor Sunday the arse of the staff, no doubt in an attempt to Covid-19, but I have little service providers find they are given short shrift and before Telegraph, Journalist, Writer and former Magistrate curry favour. Nowhere in his letter, however, Dr Peter Bennett Trustee, New Bridge understanding of how they they know it, they are back on normal location and in a does he mention his own crime(s) or sorrow or Foundation and former Governor of HMP Grendon fi gure a book supplier is worse state than originally felt. remorse for any hurt he caused. And this from John D Roberts Company Director employing okay, but our families are a ‘miscreant’ who is being held in a sex former prisoners risky. I believe there was a “Some men and women who are autistic, dyslexic Louise Shorter CEO Inside Justice and former offender’s prison. Clearly, he is showing the ruling in 2013 that prisons producer BBC Rough Justice or who struggle with words or reading and writing, tell-tale signs of manipulation, as the majority cannot stop family members Alistair H E Smith BSc FCA Chartered Accountant, are at a greater disadvantage. Sadly, their recovery of sex offenders do. The words ‘pot’ and ‘kettle’ Trustee and Treasurer, New Bridge Foundation from sending books in to spring to mind. Fella, acknowledge your own Phil Wheatley Former Director General of Prison their loved ones. Some is massively impeded.” offending before slagging off other prisoners. Service prisons are using Covid-19 to abuse their powers and It has been said that men and women who have joined inte- The insideteam bypass our rights. I would grated personality disorder and therapeutic communities Why? be grateful for any advice from VP jails/wings are less likely to graduate to completion. Zena Bryan - HMP Foston Hall from others. Impeding recovery. I read an article in one of the professional psychology journals stating that there is huge concern I do have drug and alcohol issues myself. I remember when we used to be able to Editorial note throughout secure and community services that unless a per- son-centred approach is developed and delivered to offend- celebrate St George’s Day, dressed up to the The Incentives Policy ers; especially those with huge PTSD issues from childhood nines and drinking pints outside the pub, Framework, introduced in and institutional abuse experiences, then a huge litigation maybe have a sniff of cocaine and possibly a John Roberts 2015, states that prisoners in Publisher chasm will end up closing services. spliff. But I have never met such filthy Mamba England and Wales are and Director heads who litter the streets of Derby. I must entitled to receive new or Maybe there are men and women reading this who can iden- ask, why does the Queen send very dirty, second-hand books posted to tify with what I’ve written. I’d like to encourage them not to scummy, trampy, thieving, murdering, raping them directly by friends and suffer in silence - write or get someone to write for you to the criminals to my home town? Answers on a families. If you write to Inside governing governor of your establishment, give a detailed ac- postcard please. Time enclosing written count of your experience and explain your fears. evidence that your establish- No real selection Erwin James Rachel Noel Smith ment is not following this Above all, if you are alone and despairing, please speak to a Editor in Chief Billington OBE Commissioning rule, we will investigate. Listener, chaplain, or keyworker. Name withheld - HMP Deerbolt Associate Editor Editor I don’t know about other prisons and YOI’s, but here in Deerbolt we feel restricted and let Funding cuts have undermined the prison system for years down by the canteen and governors. Food items such as beans, hot dogs, tinned macker- making it more dangerous, less tolerant and poorly equipped. el, and a large variety of drinks are not allowed We have specialist solicitors who may be able to help you with: and have not been allowed for quite a long Ben Leapman Paul Sullivan David Roberts time. In other prisons, inmates have the luxury Reporter and Editorial Operations Criminal defence Serious injuries, long-term health of having a large selection of items on their Feature Writer Assistant Manager POCA proceedings conditions and terminal illness canteen list, but not us. Why? Also, we have been told that if we can find bedding that Discrimination based on disabilities, Lack of employment and training meets health and safety criteria laid down by gender, religion, ethnicity etc. opportunities the prison then we can purchase it, but numerous inmates have attempted to buy Reasonable adjustments Denial of risk reduction courses to bedding and their apps have come back Louise Van Justine Allison Carla Rowe Assaults by police or prison ‘denied’. We cannot order towels either. Why is Mechelen foreign nationals Head of Admin Deerbolt treating us like this? Administration Assistant Accounts o cers Access to supported housing upon Supervisor Excessive use of force release for disabled prisoners High-risk/unlawful restraint methods Access to education, both whilst Unauthorised use of handcu s/ in prison and in the community KEEP IN TOUCH! Send secure emails, photos & get replies back! chains Parole and recall • Fast and easy from any Colin Matthews Gary Bultitude John Bowers Restraint of ill and disabled Appeal against sentence or (mobile) device Website Design Proof Reading Layout and • Design and Advertising prisoners conviction Only 40p per message Care needs assessments and plans Challenges to unfair public • Available in all *UK prisons Correspondence • Receive a reply Assessments of carers policies/ prison practice • On your phone? Use our app! Inside Time Botley Mills, Botley, Southampton, Lack of mobility equipment Failure to apply prison policies ** Hampshire SO30 2GB. Telephone: 01489 795945 • Send photos [email protected] / www.insidetime.org Care in the community after release and procedures *Reply Service now available Facebook: InsideTime / Twitter: @InsideTimeUK in more than 60% of prisons Subscribe **In selected prisons only Contact us at our new o ce: More info on our website. Inside Time is distributed free of charge throughout the UK prison estate. It is available to 27 London Road, Bromley, emailaprisoner other readers via a postal subscription service. BR1 1DG SUBSCRIPTION CHARGES: £45 per annum with 03333 70 65 50 concessions available see website for details or Tel: 020 8181 3100 for further details or visit: [email protected] (see page 31 for updates) www.emailaprisoner.com Insidetime June 2021 ‘Mailbag’, Inside Time, Botley Mills, Botley, Southampton SO30 2GB. Mailbag 3
Star Letter of the Month No regime Chip on your shoulder Mailbag 2-11 Congratulations to this months winner Shannon Brown - HMP Drake Hall “My question is, who receives our £25 prize. An extra £10 D Minott - HMP Hull what do they bonus is now available, see page 54 for details. Here at Drake Hall we have 10 Portacabin really do?” isolation pods. Don’t get me wrong, they are I don’t know what is going on in the prison system these days Page 9 great. A decent site with en-suite, I can’t re- concerning the pandemic. Choose life ally moan about the living conditions. Newsround 12-17 I’m 40 years old and, unfortunately, I’ve been coming in and Name supplied - HMP Whatton “Prisons can Compared to other prisons, however, since out of prison for the last 25 years. I understand that it is a dif- manipulate moving from the main population to where ferent generation of people and the staff are far younger now, The hardest thing I find about prison is Mandatory we are now, the biggest downfall is the lack and there seems to be a lot of female staff. that there is no support. All of my life I Drug Tests.” have been involved in crime, drugs and of routine and communication between staff. Page 14 Also, the general way in which things are My point is, it seems that a large percentage of these new alcohol. I have done 5-years on this sen- Comment 18-32 tence, my brother died of a heroin over- run here is terrible. younger staff, here at HMP Hull and in other prisons as well, dose while I’ve been in prison and the rest seem to have a large chip on their shoulders, almost like they “I managed to beat of my family do not care and are not the First of all, prisons normally have a strict re- think they have something to prove. cancer and then I sort of family I need, them being alcohol- gime, which is non-existent here. Secondly, had to start again. ics or criminals. staff do not communicate efficiently at all, The new intake is very petty and sometimes act like children. I was released from one member of staff says one thing, and an- I understand that a lot of them have only just grown into Page 23 prison cancer free.” Through all of this, I am choosing to start other says something different, but they still adulthood, but prison can be a dangerous place and when a better life when I am released, yet there find time to gossip to inmates about other in- prisoners are subject to their kind of behaviour it is usually Information 33-41 is not a single person who believes in me. mate’s business, and even go as far as shar- us who suffer. “I had seen for I have completed everything, education ing their own personal business. But they myself how much courses, a diploma with the Open Univer- cannot find the time to process an applica- “During the pandemic I have noticed a lot of staff difference having sity, and still people just expect the worst tion or pass on important information which a job could from me. Is it possible to change your life directly impacts prisoners. taking advantage out of making inmates suffer Page 41 make.” for the better after you have lived a life of more than they should.” Legal 42-44 crime for so long? I believe it is possible, I have been suffering with my mental health. I have spoken to staff, who do random wel- so I’m going to do it, not for other people They constantly pester us in the hope of a reaction, in reality “What?! Nothing?! fare checks about needing to see a mental but for me. some of them are no more than bullies, but they know there You mean its free, health worker. After months of struggling is nothing we can do about it. If we complain the complaint you’ve got to be the healthcare worker came to see me to I am a strong-minded person, but I can either gets ‘lost’ or nothing is done. And, they know, if we kidding me, make an appointment. But he never showed now understand why so many people live stand up and fight back it is us who suffer. Page 42 right?” the bad life. I have dramatically changed up for the appointment. My mental health my life over the past 18-months and not a has broken down to the point that I am hav- Some older staff members in the system should be mentoring Jailbreak 45-60 ing thoughts about self-harming. Consider- single person has noticed. Anyone read- these staff, watching them to make sure they don’t overstep ing prison staff are supposed to have a duty “My story is an ing this - give yourself praise because no- the mark on bullying and hating. This prison is like a bad of care, I feel that they actually don’t care, example of why body else will, and before you know it secondary school where the younger staff are in their bully- and I have lost trust in them. your past or even everything will work out. I feel happy for ing element. In reality, these people wouldn’t last a day if the disability does not the first time in years and that is because roles were reversed, and they became prisoners. Stop the Page 59 The lack of professionalism and confidenti- have to defi ne I know how much I’ve changed, and it bullying. your future.” feels good. Prove it to yourself, not to oth- ality really has me nervous. On the other ers, because it is you who will benefit, not hand, there are a lot of staff here that are them. great and have really helped during the Covid lockdown. World turned upside down Darren King - HMP Whatton
Recently on the news there has been a lot of talk about racism, sexism, discrimination, etc. But this also applies to prison. I’ve personally never had a problem with these subjects, but there are people, including prison officers, that do. As I have spent most of my years here at Whatton I have seen and heard all kinds of discrimination. Extradition Specialists “If the staff don’t like sex offenders, transgender people, or people from specjaliści od ekstradycji · specialiști în different races, then they should get a job somewhere else.” extrădare · Специалисти по екстрадиция Проследима история на успеха I’ve heard the comment ‘All Muslims are terrorists’. Well, I’ve known quite a few Muslims in and out of prison, and I find them the most hospitable people around. The last thing I want to Частно финансиране mention is Black Lives Matter, this should be changed to All Lives Matter. It is a minority with a problem, not the rest of us. A TRACK RECORD OF SUCCESS udokumentowana historia sukcesu · Un palmares al succesului · Финансиране от Immigration Law Specialists Агенцията за Правна Помощ
Immigration BAIL Applications NATIONWIDE PRISON COVERAGE Deportation Appeals Our head office is based in the North West of Private · Legal Aid · Pro Bono Responding to Home Office Enquiries England but we provide nationwide coverage and due to the location of our staff we offer regular and Odpłatna i darmowa pomoc prawna · Judicial Review consistent coverage to the North West, Midlands, Emergency Flight London, South West and North East England. asistență juridică chasten · Безплатна защита Injunction Applications • Parole paper reviews and oral hearings FULL Representation • Recall reviews and oral hearings • Removal from open conditions ALL Other Immigration matters 020 3653 1832 • Pre-Tariff reviews • Category A reviews • Adjudications St Magnus House · 3 Lower Thames Street · Call our team: 0207 480 5840 For more information please London · EC3R 6HD Emergency: 0207 052 1134 contact Emma Gauden Raymond Saul & Co. LLP Fleet House Freepost HOWARDS AND HENRYS 8-12 New Bridge Street, 0161 872 9999 - howardssolicitors.co.uk London EC4V 6AL [email protected] 4 Mailbag ‘Mailbag’, Inside Time, Botley Mills, Botley, Southampton SO30 2GB. Insidetime June 2021
Letter from? Take legal Trying to find Stephen Faulkner - HMP Maghaberry action
I received a very interesting letter, which I am assuming has Mahalia - the positive come from Shadow Justice Secretary David Lammy MP. I say HMP Bronzefield Bruce Child - HMP The Verne ‘assuming’ because nobody has put their name to it, but he and the Justice Select Committee were the only ones who I have been reading Inside My attempts to share thoughts more widely wrote about IPP sentences and the way the letter is written Time for months now and through Inside Time was interrupted by the makes me think that the author is Mr Lammy. So, I think it is have been pleasantly sur- February issue not arriving here until the only fair that my fellow hostages and political prisoners of prised by the content. This last day of that month. I assume it was the British justice system (IPP prisoners) hear what this un- letter is as a result of read- locked down like the rest of us so I’m proba- signed letter says. It says, word for word, as follows… ing ‘No right to complain’, bly behind the times, as usual. by ‘Adam’ (May issue). “Dear Stephen Faulkner, thank you for getting in touch r My vaccine thoughts have been overtaken by egarding the issue of Imprisonment for Public Protection (IPP). I am both appalled and events and now I too have been jabbed. I was Additionally, the issue of IPP sentencing is an extremely disgusted at the fact that initially happy to wait but now I see that jab- No consolation important one and a matter I take extremely seriously. Adam’s complaints are bing us all is a sensible course of action. The being dismissed and he is alternative is overburdening the NHS with When originally introduced in 2005, IPP sentences were being treated like a non- our vulnerable inmates as the virus took Any updates? intended to protect the public from the incredibly dangerous entity whilst also being hold here. Already we’ve taken up too many offenders whose crimes did not warrant a life sentence. While dehumanised for exercis- hospital beds and suffered three deaths in a Name supplied - HMP North Sea Camp the original intention was to protect the public from very ing the rights he still has week despite all the precautions. high-risk offenders, it is clear that the implementation of IPP available to him. As he has On the 8th of July 2020, the MoJ published has been tragically flawed. stated he has written sev- Reaction to the stupidity of Grant Shapps the National Incentives Policy Framework. In eral complaints and has proposing 10-year sentences on selfish quar- Annex D it lists the games consoles approved When the IPP sentence was first created, it was originally had no response, I sug- antine avoiders has probably come and gone. by InfoSec and Services Team, and this up- estimated that only 900 sentences would be handed down gest he does one of three Now the POA are calling for courts to be closed date includes ‘Modified Microsoft Xbox One’. by the courts; today almost ten times that number have been things: as they can’t cope - it’s good to see they’ve at The framework states: purchased only imposed. It is now painfully clear that the IPP sentence was 1) Get his solicitor or last acknowledged that the current system is through Gema Records. far too broad, and many low-risk offenders are serving IPP someone he trusts to unsustainable. Though, didn’t they want to sentences today for committing minor offences in the past. email the governor di- keep the lockdown after the pandemic ends? Towards the end of 2020, Gema Records were rectly with his complaint What do they think will happen when the giving people a tentative release date for the The mental trauma of being subject to an IPP sentence is sim- and wait for a response. courts reopen, and longer sentences are im- console of the first week of November 2020. ply horrendous. A 2016 report by the Prison Trusts showed that 2) If you have logged the posed, and all of those extra police do their However, in late October their website was IPP prisoners had one of the highest rates of self-harm in the dates when previous com- best to keep the conveyor belt running? updated to say they were awaiting informa- prison population and many develop serious mental condi- tions due to the uncertainty of their future. Those subject to plaints were made, still tion from a third party before being able to forward the complaints to supply Xbox One’s. No update has been pub- IPP sentences were more that 200% likely to self-harm than “Don’t they realise that just doing those on standard determinate sentences. PPO stating the dates and lished since. issues along with the more of the same, which doesn’t As IPP prisoners spend longer and longer in prison without any treatment you got due to work and isn’t likely to produce a Xbox 360s are now over 15-years old, becom- prospect of release, their mental health continues to decline, complaining. Create a ing rarer and more unreliable - increasing better outcome.” and they start to display behavioural traits which makes their paper trail. Also, please the price considerably. Having access to be aware that all authori- release even less likely. Of those people who do secure parole, I always try to find the positive news and Xbox Ones would be a huge incentive - espe- tative personnel have a set figures show many IPP prisoners are returned to prison on let’s hope Amnesty can have more affect on cially to those with an interest in gaming. amount of time in which to recall for minor breaches of their license. These prisoners are the IPP fiasco than the ex-Ministers who respond, usually 30 days. caught in a hugely vicious cycle, with no hope in sight. only admit their mistakes long after they As Gema Records are one of your regular ad- 3) Play dead and roll over have left office. And a Parliamentary report vertisers, would it be possible to prompt like the staff clearly want Although the sentence itself was scrapped in 2012 due to a recommending older prisoners be placed in them for an official response/update please? ruling from the European Court of Human Rights, the changes you to. So many of us have been saving up for prisons that truly reflect their risk of escape made in 2012 were not retrospective and roughly 2,000 offend- or harm, rather than keeping them in over- months now for this. These are the options. I ers remain on IPP sentences today. Let me be clear, this is a crowded, unsuitable jails, is definitely a pos- urge you to keep going grave injustice. No prisoner who can show they pose no threat itive sign. I just wonder if there are enough A response from Gema Records while remembering this to society should ever remain in prison once they have done sensible MPs to support such a measure, un- Due to an unprecedented change in circum- quote - ‘The most common their time. fortunately we all know that prison reform stances Gema Records could not launch the way people give up their isn’t exactly a vote winner. Xbox One product range as intended in In the coming months I look forward to working with the power is by thinking they November 2020. Subsequently, we have been government in a constructive manner, to identify how the great don’t have any’ - Alice So, I will content myself with hoping that my in regular contact with the MoJ in an attempt damage that IPP sentencing has caused can be put right, Walker. Good luck Adam, jab and all the others allows us to return to to launch the Xbox One product range ASAP. in a way that serves the interests of justice, while protecting keep fighting for your the gym and workshops to take out our frus- We are currently waiting for a response from members of society.” rights, diplomatically of trations there. Even a small step forward is the MoJ and cannot therefore progress further course. for the moment. There you have it. better than nothing. Contributing to Mailbag INSIDE TIME APP Disclaimer DOWNLOAD NOW! Inside Time is wholly responsible If you would like to contribute to Mailbag, please send your letters to the Scan the QR Code to for its editorial content. address on the left. It is very important that you ensure the following details are download the FREE Comments or complaints should on all paperwork sent to Inside Time: YOUR NAME, PRISON NUMBER, Mobile App. Please be directed to the publisher and PRISON AND DOB. Failure to do so will prevent us responding to you and your encourage your family not to New Bridge. Views submission being withheld from publication. Please note letters for publication ‘Mailbag’, members and friends to expressed are those of the may be edited. Inside Time, download it and enjoy authors and not necessarily Botley Mills, the simple access it representative of those held by To avoid any possible misunderstanding, if you have a query and for whatever Botley, provides. either Inside Time or the New reason do not wish your letter to be published in Inside Time or appear on the Southampton, Bridge Foundation. If you wish to website, or yourself to be identified, please make this clear. Hampshire reproduce or publish any of the SO30 2GB. Corrections and Clarifications content published by Inside Time We advise that wherever possible, when sending original documents such as legal in the newspaper or online, you papers, you send photocopies as we are unable to accept liability if they are lost. The policy of Inside Time is to correct significant errors as soon as possible. Corrections will appear in the mailbag should first contact us for written permission. Full terms & condi- We may need to forward your letter and/or documents to Prison Service HQ or section of each issue and on the relevant web page. If you tions can be found at another appropriate body for comment or advice, therefore only send informa- notice an error please feel free to write to us at the usual www.insidetime.org. Inside Time tion you are willing to have forwarded on your behalf. address providing the date and page number from the newspaper. is a ‘not for profit’ publication. YOU DON’T HAVE TO STOMACH THESE JUST BECAUSE YOU’RE IN PRISON
Being in prison is hard enough to swallow, being denied your basic rights is totally unacceptable. If you’ve suffered from any form of personal injury, negligence or an accident at work you have the right to compensation… just the same as those not in prison. As one of the country’s leading personal injury lawyers we have been representing prisoners for many years winning claims from hundreds to many thousands of pounds. All on a no win no fee basis.
IF YOU THINK YOU’VE BEEN A VICTIM OF NEGLIGENCE, PERSONAL INJURY OR AN ACCIDENT AT WORK CONTACT US NOW AND CLAIM THE COMPENSATION THAT’S DUE TO YOU!
N ON I JUR IS Y R L P A W E Y H E
T R
S
F
A
O
S
S S
O R
E
pilaC
B I
A
M
T
E
I O
M Call: 0161 925 4155 I Click: jefferies-solicitors.com I email: [email protected] N write to us at: Jefferies Solicitors Limited I The Triangle I 8 Cross Street I Altrincham I Cheshire I WA14 1EQ
2294-InsideTime_Prisoner Adverts_FP_265wx332H.indd 5 23/02/2021 09:32 6 Mailbag ‘Mailbag’, Inside Time, Botley Mills, Botley, Southampton SO30 2GB. Insidetime June 2021
Maintaining progress. Children/families are more af- Mailbites Second class citizens fected by the imprisonment of female prison- innocence Name supplied - HMP Drake Hall ers who are usually the main caregivers/ homemakers. Women are stuck in a system Meals mix beware S Marples - HMP Doncaster K C Valentine - HMP Frankland I am a female prisoner and to date I have designed by men for men. In light of the re- cent media spotlight on the treatment and Here are some top tips for served three years of a 12-year prison sentence, A lot of prisoners will be aware that DHL are doing special with three years left to serve. I have served the way women are perceived, this is surely prisoners who are genuinely offers of their new ready-meals, £1.99 each or two for £3.00. half of my custodial sentence. I was recently an equalities issue - blatant male bias in its innocent. That’s great, but buyers beware. If you mix and match a couple reviewed for re-categorisation; women only purist form - is it not our human right to be of meals at the special price you will have to pay the full price of have two categories - open or closed. I was treated equally? 1) Have an overall goal. one should your other choice be out of stock. I ordered the refused re-categorisation on the basis that I Focus your attention and all-day breakfast and a beef lasagne; I did not get the breakfast have more than two years left to serve, this is A lot of women are in prison because of a as it was out of stock, so I was charged the full price of £1.99 for time spent in prison on win- in accordance with PS139 - (2011) female cat- “man” and because they are women are the lasagne. If you do order two meals then you should make ning your appeal, being re- egorisation and re-categorisation policy. dealt with harsher by the courts, this is a leased on license as soon as sure you don’t mix and match, order two of the same meal. perception issue! Many women were ar- possible. Once you set your What really gets me though is that the ready meals are brand This policy states two years is considered to rested, charged and indicted alongside male goal, create a plan and work co-defendants, they went on to be convicted new in our canteen, which makes me wonder how so many can be the maximum time a prisoner should towards achieving it. the same as these men, they have been given be out of stock already? spend in open conditions; however, assess- ment of a prisoner’s individual risks and the same prison sentence as these men, 2) Stay calm. Don’t waste needs may support earlier re-categorisation throughout this entire process there was Joking aside… unnecessary energy on dis- to open conditions, such cases must have never any exceptions made nor any special Paul Buffery - HMP Highpoint tractions that may get you their reasons for their categorisation fully measures to differentiate between male and into trouble. Keep your nose female, but now because we are not male we My life of crime started when I was 15. I hated my next-door documented and confirmed in writing by the down and don’t let anger get governing governor. are being treated differently and overlooked neighbour so much that I used to gather up slugs and stick the better of you, use it in- when new prison sentence instructions are them on his window. I did it every day for a month and he got stead as a tool for achieving I have recently become aware of a change in being changed and implemented, is this not so fed up with it that he called the police. I got done for sluggish your goal. Work for justice, the male re-categorisation PSI which has discrimination? behaviour. After that I changed my MO and started putting ants not for revenge. been updated in January 2020 replaced and through his letter box. He got fed up and again phoned the ruled out in February 2020. This new PSI Men who have been given the same sentence police. This time they put me on an anty social order. Next, I length as women will be able to progress to 3) Beware of the criminal now allows male prisoners to be considered used to go to his door and shout through the letter box ‘Sorry open conditions 12 months before these justice system. They are all for categorisation to open conditions when for the ant and slug stuff, please forgive me!’ I did this every day women, where is the equality, where is the out to get you, the police, they have three years of the sentence left to for a month and he called the police on me again, this time I fairness? Self-harm in the female estate is at CPS, prison, and probation serve. got arrested for menacing manners. We moved to a new house its highest, this act of discrimination will service, even your own law- in the end, which I am glad about. Happy to get away from that only help to push the figures higher. yer will let you down. Be Obviously, this is an issue that raises con- weirdo! cerns throughout the female prison popula- very careful what you say. How can we expect the general public to treat Maintain your innocence tion. If we females are part of the prison system, why are we not given the same con- women fairly and equally if our government It’s just obscene! and don’t allow them to sideration as male prisoners, surely the rules is seen to be doing the opposite? On behalf of Bernard Haunch - HMP Ashfield force you into submission. should apply across the board? female prisoners, I would like to thank you You cannot be prevented I’ve been in prison for some 8 years now, so I’m well accus- for your time and consideration on these from progressing and re- tomed to prison life. What you can do, what you can’t do and Women are being denied the opportunity to matters. lease on parole simply be- so on and so forth, I quickly got used to it. One thing, however, cause you are maintaining surprises and shocks me, and that is the cascade of obscene innocence. Look at the risk language I hear all day and everywhere. This was something to factors on your OASys report which I am quite unused to. My distaste for such language and take the necessary steps remains. While little now surprises me, I am still shocked, to addressing them. When particularly when I hear prison staff booming out vile exple- dealing with any officials, tives, and no more so when it comes from the mouths of write everything down, de- female members of staff. We prisoners are ‘bad boys and girls’, tailing what was said, what inside to pay for crimes we may or may not have committed. To you observed, what you help us, prison will put us on to a variety of courses, which I agreed, and what was find ironic. If reformation means that you can happily use filthy planned. language, then all these courses are just a joke. OUR SERVICES / SHERBIMET TONA 4) You are not in denial. If Beating the habit you are told that you are ‘in 1- IMMIGRATION DETENTION/PRISON, BAIL & DEPORTATION. Brian Taylor - HMP Holme House denial’ set a firm boundary 2- ASYLUM AND HUMAN RIGHTS by saying that you are not 3- VICTIM OF TRAFFICKING Hi, it’s the Bird Man of Holme House here. I am on the thera- happy with the term used peutic community programme in order to help me with my and would prefer it if they 4- IMMIGRATION APPEALS AND drug problems. They have lots of animals here for the wing use the term ‘maintaining JUDICIAL REVIEW - chickens, ducks, guinea pigs, fish, a turtle, and I have two innocence’. Tell them you cockatiels that I look after. They keep me busy and stop me are not denying anything, from thinking about using drugs. I would like to thank the you are telling the truth. 1- PARABURGIMI / BURGIM,APLIKIM BAIL-I,DHE DËBIMI. treatment manager Sue Ford, Mr Boynton and our CM, Mr Stand firmly on the moral 2- AZILI DHE TË DREJTAT E NJERIUT Wintersgill, for giving us the opportunity to learn about animals high ground. through nature and through the recovery programme on 3- VIKTIME E TRAFIKIMIT Houseblock 6. Thank you. 5) Be organised. By making 4- APELIMET E IMIGRACIONIT DHE sure you have a structured RISHIKIMI GJYQËSOR Defending Whatton plan to achieve your goal. Simon Porritt - HMP Whatton Have the correct legal argu- ments and evidence in your Office: 0208 090 2488 I must defend Whatton from the narrow view expressed by mind, lay it all out systemat- IRDI: 07503545344 ‘Adam’ HMP Whatton - ‘No right to complain’, April issue. ically and clearly on paper. Adam’s experience is alarming, I have every sympathy, however, Write up a clear statement, ANA: 07435119343 myself and at least some others have had an opposite experi- what you accept and what ence. On a daily basis I see dedicated officers and administra- you don’t accept about your Address: tion going the extra mile. Others I know tell me they thank god conviction and the corre- they have ultimately arrived in Whatton. It is true that mistakes sponding evidence to sup- 11 Millington Road, London Hayes, UB3 4AZ are occasionally made, appropriate corrections and apologies port this. inevitably follow. Supporting the administration and all working together surely leads to the best environment. Win, win. You are not alone. Insidetime June 2021 ‘Mailbag’, Inside Time, Botley Mills, Botley, Southampton SO30 2GB. Mailbag 7
Presiding Mercy instead of risk When CR Brown - HMP Moorland over injustice will it end? Name withheld - To the IPP brother of HMP Rye Hill who wrote the ‘No good IPP James M - HMP Whatton news’ letter in the April issue, brother, you are so right! Abso- lutely spot-on. I, too, am an IPP hostage, no one can understand, HMP Holme House The article on the CCRC, ‘In and no one really cares, you have to be an IPP to know the the interests of justice’, con- anguish and mental torture that we rehearse every day. I am a white male with a firms what I have often been lot of different backgrounds told, it is not worth the effort It is impossible whilst in prison to lower one’s risk in the in my family. I think most submitting an application to community. The smiling assassins, i.e., prison psychologists, people will agree that it is the CCRC. Let’s look at the etc, will not take a risk unless we prove ourselves superhu- just unbelievable that we Ongoing symptoms have seen on the news © Andy Aitchison/Library image figures you published: around man, and even then it would be debatable. The bar gets another young black man 1300 applications a year, 99% higher and higher as long as prisons and TC Units are getting has been killed by police of all applications rejected. paid for courses and programmes, then we IPPs will always Long jail Covid in the USA. After the Average of 13 applications a be in them and on them. John R Davis - HMP Liverpool year investigated. Giving killing of George Floyd, we all thought or hoped that them a generous 75% success It is a shameful scar on the criminal justice system and on action would be taken to I’ve been in prison for 14 months now. Since December 2020 I rate, would mean an average humanity in general. Morally it’s wrong, ethically it’s wrong, prevent the police have had Covid-19 twice. Due to underlying medical conditions, of 10 successful appeals and the 65 IPP martyrs bear testament to this ungodly sentence. unlawfully killing people, I’ve now had my first vaccine. I’m writing so that those read- against conviction or sen- I am a highly responsible prisoner, totally outstanding record, ers who have been unlucky enough to catch Covid, but have tence. Annually obliged to but for an experienced red-band status, more positivity than you could shake a stick police officer to come out been very lucky to have survived, know that you are not alone have 11 commissioners - at, full release plan in place including a private house and a with ongoing ‘long Covid’ symptoms. My ongoing symptoms and say that the death overall level of full time is concrete offer of gainful employment in the community (I’m are worse than when Covid-19 was active in my body. I’ll list was due to her mistaking now equivalent to 2.5 com- a fully qualified BAE systems engineer), but all to no avail. the symptoms I still have so that if any Covid-19 survivors see missioners. Massive budget her gun for a Taser just isn’t this letter, and are still struggling with symptoms, they will good enough. I thought cuts since 2003. Conclusion - I have been totally destroyed by an over-zealous prison psy- know what is common and won’t worry themselves to death. those maintaining innocence police officers were chologist who I refused to suck up to, and an outside OM who supposed to be fully applying to have their case has not visited in 5 years and who appears to have only one 1) Random bouts of breathlessness and breathing issues when trained and not be able to reviewed have 0.15% of word - ‘risk’ - which he gladly defines in ways which are un- doing very little, such as going up stairs or making your bed. make this sort of ‘mistake’. achieving a successful outcome. cannily favourable to himself. 2) Deep, unreachable, muscle and joint aches and pains, mainly elbows. Hips may ache when lying in bed and wake Proof once again, if it were For those who think that My IPP brothers, all we are asking for is mercy but in re- them up. Knees hurt when bending. needed, that the British sys- this may be none of my sponse we get ‘risk’, which is just an easy excuse for the au- 3) Hot and cold sweats, mainly at night. tem of justice has no real in- business, or that it doesn’t thorities. I’ve blown off some truthful steam here, but my 4) Constantly tired and sleeping at every opportunity, I now terest in justice, only matter because it didn’t message is that we must press on and unite, we are only sleep 18 hours per day. keeping everyone locked up happen here - it does. strong together. I don’t know the answers, but we must keep 5) Constantly hungry and thirsty, weight gain and weight loss. for as long as possible. We Black men in the UK are asking the questions. There is an online petition, a campaign 6) Lack of interest or motivation. have a Justice Secretary of stopped and searched created by Katherine Gleeson MP (Release the Remaining IPP State, Ministers, and a Min- often without reason, and There may be more symptoms but the ones on this list are what I istry of Justice getting paid Prisoners) and our voices should be heard. Get everyone you many are left mentally am personally enduring. It would be good if people who have to preside over a gross injus- can outside to sign it. Every prisoner gets two free letters a scarred by this discrimi- had Covid could write in with their ‘long Covid’ symptoms so tice. I call on them to fully week, there are approximately 3,000 IPPs, including recall nation. We are in 2021, that we can all know the full story. So many of us are suffer- staff and fund the CCRC, IPPs, who still have no release dates, so use one of those let- this needs to stop. Just ing in silence. You are not alone, use Inside Time to spread whilst implementing the re- ters, even if it is only a few heartfelt lines, and send it to the ask yourself, would this the word, to make a much-needed psychological difference port recommendations in office of the Rt Honourable Robert Buckland MP. Keep knock- ‘mistake’ have been made in these uncertain and difficult times. I hope you all recover their entirety. Give us a fair ing on the door and one day it has to open. if the young man in that as well as possible. Pick yourselves up and keep fighting this and just chance of appeal car was white? Think terrible virus. against false accusations. Grace to all my IPP brothers. about it.
Fighting for you, Always protecting your rights Reece Thomas Watson are specialists in Peer & Co. have 15 years experience Prison Law. We are based in London and with DETENTION, BAIL and PRISON LAW o er a Nationwide service. DEPORTATION cases and Removal Cases • Specialists in parole board cases • Lifer & IPP reviews Isn’t it time you choose the right • Recall appeals & hearings Our team are experts in: legal team? Call or write now! • Experienced advocates with over ten years expertise in parole board hearings Parole Boards, IPP and Lifer Reviews BAIL applications & representation at the • Legal Aid Available for most parole/recall reviews Immigration Tribunal & hearings Pre Tari Review • Other areas of Prison Law work undertaken under DEPORTATIONS – Appeal the deportation Recalls private funding decision and fullrepresentation at the Cat A Reviews Immigration Courts National HMP Coverage CSU Temporary Admissions Over 20 Years Criminal Law Experience Independent Adjudications Section 120 Notices and Responses FAMILY LAW & CRIMINAL 47/49 Transfer Detention and Release CHILDCARE LAW Detentions under the Mental Health Act 1983 Prison and Detention Centre Legal visits • Police Investigations Judicial Review FREE INITIAL PHONE CONSULTATION AVAILABLE • Contact With Children • Magistrates Court • Divorce • Crown Court Cases London: 0207 1833 706 • Care Proceedings Contact: Sara Watson • Confiscation Birmingham: 0121 5540565 Phone: 0203 841 8580 Watford: 01923 901150 07000 818283 Write: 758 Holloway Road, Islington, London N19 3JF Emergency 24/7: 07833675415 26-28 Stuart Street, Luton, Bedfordshire LU1 2SW Email: [email protected] Birmingham 420 Witton Road, Aston, Birmingham B6 6PP [email protected] / www.noblesolicitors.co.uk 8 Mailbag ‘Mailbag’, Inside Time, Botley Mills, Botley, Southampton SO30 2GB. Insidetime June 2021 Any address? Thanks to Alex Toth - HMP Wayland New Bridge We have been told by DHL Hayley Turner - that HMPPS set the canteen HMP Isle of Wight prices and whenever I make a complaint about the prices I received a letter in Febru- I am fobbed off. Can you tell ary from the charity New me if there is an official ad- Bridge regarding getting the dress we can write to in word out to more prisoners about their service. I know order to get answers about Mark, time to cheer us up! prison canteens? Bad decisions they run adverts in Inside © Andy Aitchison © Deposit Photos Time, but a lot of prisoners don’t look at the ads unless Depressing words Reply from HMPPS they are looking for some- The Prison Retail team within Christian - HMP Wymott Close the skies thing in particular. Every- HM Prison & Probation Ser- Name supplied - HMP Oakwood one I know reads the The more I read the comments of Mark Fairhurst, the national vice (HMPPS) set the prices mailbag pages, so I thought chair of the Prison Officers Association, over the last for the products sold on the It really is starting to alarm me how badly this government is I could draw attention to 12-months, the more it depresses me. As chairman, it is his National Product List (NPL) handling the pandemic. The most simple and obvious thing New Bridge via a letter to job to speak officially for prison officers, but I worry that he also known as the Canteen to have done would be to close the borders, after all, we live mailbags. actually DOES speak for prison officers in general. list. Our pricing policy is on an ISLAND! This has worked for New Zealand and other Manufacturers Recom- island nations, it’s not exactly rocket science, is it? And yet I would like to thank New He appears to welcome the restricted regime caused by the mended Retail Price (MRRP). our weak, greedy shambles of a government failed to do this. Bridge for being there for pandemic. He cites things like a reduction in violent incidents We can sell below the MRRP, Now we have foreign variants of the virus popping up all myself and all prisoners who as his reasoning. Of course, violence will be reduced with when we receive financial over England. use their support and people locked in their cells for most of the day. Fewer people support in the way of a price befriender service. When I caught the flu last year because of the lockdown, but that reduction from the manufac- The latest one, ‘the Indian variant’, is now here and it does came to prison in 2010 as a wouldn’t be reason to lock the country down every winter. turer but never higher. not take a lot of brainpower to work out why. This same gov- transgender, I contacted a ernment has been scrambling around the world for trade LGBT+ service for a pen-pal Covid deaths aside, prisons in a pandemic look excellent on as I had no one else. I got a Correspondence concerning deals, like a beggar with the hand out, in order to pretend paper - less violence, less access to drugs, fewer opportunities that Brexit was not the absolute disaster that it really is, and trans-male pen-pal who the NPL can be sent to the for bullying. From a prison officer’s perspective, I can also part of that begging for deals was from India. And while the wrote to me for years but following address: Public Sector see why they don’t want things to change. The current condi- negotiations for this deal was going on, the government de- then decided life was too tions make a thankless and risky job a lot simpler and safer. Prison Industries, Catering, liberately decided not to put India on their ‘red list’, despite complicated to continue. However, I believe that Mr Fairhurst’s comments speak to Retail & PE (PSPI), Central the fact that the virus is running wild in India. everything that is wrong with the culture of the Prison Service. Operational Services Directo- For the next few years, I had rate, Her Majesty’s Prison It would seem obvious to all of those except the densest, that no one, then another In my experience the priority of prison staff is for the pris- and Probation Service, 102 if you close the air borders these variants could not enter the prisoner told me about New oner to be locked away and for them to know their place. Ac- Petty France, 8th Floor, Zone country. Typical of this shabby government to put money be- Bridge, and I wrote to them cording to the BBC, prison officers in the UK have the least C 8.37, London SW1H 9AJ. fore lives. for an application form for a amount of training of anywhere in the world. The job is dan- befriender. I haven’t looked gerous and of unfairly low status, it should be a profession. back since. I now have a be- The result of this is unqualified and, at times, completely in- friender who has been writ- appropriate people joining the service. ing to me for a year and a half and wishes to visit me Staff are recruited to work with a prison population which as soon as Covid restrictions largely consists of angry, insecure young men, brimming allow. Having a befriender with toxic masculinity. Many of those who enter the role with writing to me and offering the right aptitude and eagerness to make a difference are emotional support and tell- soon disillusioned and either leave or get sucked into the ing me about life outside the cynical macho culture (readers will have seen this countless prison walls makes me feel times). Naturally, I’m not referring to all officers, but too few that even with a life sentence of them seem to see their role as anything to do with rehabili- I still have a fingerhold on tation or meaningful engagement. WWW.LARTEYANDCO.COM [email protected] society. Imagine our prisons staffed with officers who didn’t take any DO YOU REQUIRE REPRESENTATION? If you don’t receive letters or crap but were self-controlled, emotionally intelligent people visits, I strongly recommend who helped the damaged men and women on their wings to DO YOU WISH TO APPEAL A CONVICTION? that you contact New Bridge understand and control their own emotions, issues, and ad- for an application form. dictions. It may sound far-fetched, but it doesn’t have to be. On the 20th January 2021 Lartey & Co Solicitors were able to overturn a See page 21 for details See Justice Select Committee call for evidence page 33 conviction for murder at the Court of Appeal, with a retrial now ordered. We act on a variety of cases nationwide at all stages of Criminal Proceedings. Should you require representation on a case Lartey & Co Solicitors are able to act on a OLR, the Scottish IPP privately funded basis. Kevin McPhee - HMP Glenochil
This is an open letter to the Cabinet Secretary of Justice for Scotland. Within the English • CRIMINAL LAW • IMMIGRATION prison system, the IPP was widely used, and, in many cases, abused by the very people who • PRISON LAW • FAMILY LAW later deemed them as wholly inhumane and unjust, and many inmates down south commit- ted a crime not deserving of a life sentence. England then abolished IPP. • EXTRADITION • APPEALS Sadly, the people subject to IPP are still inside prison having served their time. My point is, Lartey & Co Solicitors England abolished because it breached many human rights, and other things such as access Romer House to courses, and so on. When will the powers-that-be in Scotland look at the OLR (Order of Life 132 Lewisham High Street Restriction) as it is the Scottish equivalent to the IPP and should also be abolished? London, SE13 6EE OLR inmates have all the same problems and issues with daily life in prisons as our IPP www.larteyandco.com [email protected] neighbours do. Amnesty International are actively looking into the treatment of IPP inmates. Might I invite them to also look into OLR sentences too. I can tell you now that most IPP and OLR prisoners, given the option, may have actually preferred the death penalty. I know this sounds extreme, but at least we would know once and for all. Because as of this moment no one 0208 692 9006 knows anything of what will happen. So, can I ask what you plan to do about OLR sentences? Insidetime June 2021 ‘Mailbag’, Inside Time, Botley Mills, Botley, Southampton SO30 2GB. Mailbag 9
Mailbites The right to Team hard labour?
Officer recognition be forgotten Name supplied - HMP Stafford Paul Willetts - It’s not very often that you come across an officer that truly HMP Oakwood deserves recognition for the work that he does. Here at Stafford if you say the name ‘Mr D’ from C wing to any one of the 755 The saying goes that ‘today’s inmates, you will really struggle to find anyone that has a single news is tomorrow’s toilet bad word to say about this gentleman of an officer. This is an paper’, but that is no longer officer that has over 25-years experience under his belt. You the case in the 21st century. will not find anyone like this officer anywhere within the prison Crimes worth reporting only system, he is one of the most genuine, polite, hard-working and in local rags, previously a very thoughtful officer. We all appreciate everything he does, printed and distributed nothing is ever too much trouble. Not wishing to denigrate or within a boundary, hardly be disrespectful to all the other staff, they do a great job, but read by anyone, thrown out Mr D is an absolute legend - thanks for making our stay here as with the rubbish never to be pleasant and peaceful as possible. seen again, are now placed in online versions. Pin-alised K Henry - HMP Peterborough It takes only one person to What are they for? see it and share it on social My learned friend Paul (Phone Farce - March issue) has hit the media, and all of a sudden it Michael X - HMP Wandsworth proverbial nail on the head. The financial limits imposed on is global, pinging up on pro- The recent death of Prince Philip has once again unleashed a tide of national grovelling, prisoners are insane. I do not have anyone to call on the outside files each year to mark the mainly by the media, sucking up to the royal family as though they really matter in the 21st so my account has built a healthy balance, which I cannot use. I anniversary of what’s trend- century. My question is, what do they really do? fully understand that the free phone credit is not an entitlement, ing. Even the police social however, with other residents calling friends and family they have media sites are ‘high flying’ their income supplemented by the £5 that they have to spend. their achievements in ‘pub- “The only time you see a member of that family ‘working’ it involves shaking But due to my limited pin-credit I no longer receive the extra lic interest announcements’. hands, waving, and pulling bits of string in order to ‘open’ something, usually £5. Although I do not use it, where does it go? Just a thought. a plaque or statue.” Golden “Are they really in the public interest? Who The people who claim the family are ‘hard workers’ have obviously never done a day’s work in Miles Drake - HMP Rochester their lives. And as for the argument that they pull in tourists that make our country richer - In the March issue, Rachel Billington suggests that Purple Visits decides this and how what a load of nonsense, there are tourist destinations all around the world that have not a should be renamed ‘Golden Visits’. My question is, should we much consideration royal in sight. People holiday in the UK for a lot of good reasons - the history, architecture, then refer to a group of residents being escorted to said visits as goes into deciding what and beauty spots - but I’d guess that if you were to ask a selection then ‘seeing the Queen’ a ‘Golden Shower’? would not be high on their list of things to do in the UK. is ‘interest’ and what is Sick of the nonsense ‘gossip’?” As a lifelong republican I would be interested to hear from any royal lovers with serious argu- ments of why, in this day and age, we are still bowing and scraping to a family who are no Kam Dhaliwal - HMP Sudbury Given that this is a perma- more ‘special’ than you or me? And what actual work do they do? I’m getting fed up with those who do not want the Covid vaccine, nent sentence, to be tagged so I’ve had a thought - why not set up a database recording the forever more and long after details of those who have refused. In my opinion they are usually death, with something that What must I do? Prosocial, or ignorant, uneducated conspiracy theorists. The reason for the may have been a devastating database could be so that if they catch the virus further down Louis B - HMP Swaleside result, completely out of the line then the NHS will be able to refuse them treatment. character due to a set of cir- bullying? Statistically these people are most likely to be on state benefits, I write to you in the hope that you will pub- cumstances, how can any- more likely to end up in prison, so think of the millions of lish this plea for help. Unfortunately, in Jan- Name supplied - HMP Whatton one ever be rehabilitated pounds that could be saved by the DWP, the Prison Service and uary of this year my gran passed away. She carrying such a tag which is NHS, and let’s face it, we would be a better society without these was like a second mum to me, and it hit me As someone who used to work in the legal easily accessible by people. I am absolutely sick of hearing the absolute nonsense like a ton of bricks. I put a brave face on for sector, I feel it is my inherent duty to speak would-be employers? from these stupid people and, incidentally, David Icke is their god three months, becoming even more de- out for all my fellow prisoners and detainees on an urgent and prominent matter. and he used to be a footballer, it has been proved that repeated pressed as the days went by. Until, eventu- The reports are never bal- heading of the ball causes brain damage. I rest my case. ally, I decided I needed to seek help. anced, of course, and rarely All creatures are entitled to and have a are good news stories of suc- human right to be treated with respect as di- Price gone up A referral was then made to the mental cessful turnarounds equally rected by the Human Rights Act. Further- Hannah Willey - HMP Guernsey health team for bereavement counselling. publicly shared. I under- more, it is HMPPS mission statement that In response to the letter regarding the 9p price hike on 88vapes, stood that data protection The mental health team came to see me, and clearly instructs their warders of what is ex- I think you are quite lucky as here in Guernsey we have to pay laws provide the right to be I was told - ‘there’s not a lot we can do for pected of them. We all know of a few profi- £6 for a box! We have argued that this is an outrageous price, forgotten. How can we ob- you’. They stated that they are not doing one- cient and honourable prison officers, alas, but they will not lower it. Also, we are only allowed to buy four serve this right if stories are to-one work. This is a lie. I know it’s a lie be- there are a very deal of lamentable, idle, ma- boxes each. so frivolously shared under cause I know of others here who are having licious ones. There are numerous examples the guise of public interest? one-to-one work. of such here at Whatton and they relish bul- Forced labour camps UK lying people. Name supplied - HMP Oakwood Given the huge advances in “All I was offered was a ‘distraction technology, is any official in I don’t see how this government can say anything about forced I believe that, by way of redress, a governor authority considering the pack’ of crosswords, sudoku, etc.” labour camps in China as this country does exactly the same should be appointed in every establishment thing. Prisoners in this country don’t even get minimum wage impact of such lasting re- with the role of ‘Respect Patron’. This person ports on the offender, the So, it begs the question, what have I got to would ensure that each and every day there for a day’s work, we are lucky if we are paid more than £2 a day. do to get the help I need? Cut myself? At- If you refuse to take part in the forced labour you are nicked families, the victims, and is a wing walkabout to ascertain how staff tempt suicide? Take an overdose? Or all of the and it is put on file, you lose privileges and sometimes end up also, if unable to rehabili- are treating residents. This should be a pro- above? It was hard enough as it is to admit I in segregation confined on your own without even a mattress. tate, the wider community? active daily commitment to ensuring a truly needed help, now I am being told that doing Every complaint the UK makes about China’s prisoners rings We should not be easily ex- prosocial ethos that promotes a genuine re- hollow as some of the same things are being done here. The empt of the need for infor- a puzzle will help me through the grieving habilitative culture. Ungar’s are forced to do indoctrination courses, courses are mation to be shared process. also forced on British prisoners. So, this country should stop proportionately and justifia- Residents must be treated in the exact same being so hypocritical and sort out its own problems first. This bly. I would be very inter- Let’s just hope that if anybody else loses a way that HMPPS expects us to treat every- country should shut up about the failings of other countries ested on readers views of loved-one they have plenty of crosswords, so body, both in custody and out. After all, while we still have IPP prisoners locked up with no end in sight. this. it saves the mental health team a trip. aren’t we supposed to all be equal? 10 Mailbag ‘Mailbag’, Inside Time, Botley Mills, Botley, Southampton SO30 2GB. Insidetime June 2021
“A higher quality of life” travel will make electric cars more practical. Covid is sowing the seeds for part of such Money Thank you! change, with people working from home and laundering? staying local for most of the time. Reducing Not fit for purpose distant contact reduces viral spread, the ulti- T Jobling - HMP Full Sutton mate revival of small-town high streets J Yusuf - HMP Warren Hill where the majority of the population lives, I’m writing to express my I refer to the letter from ‘Adam’ of HMP Whatton in the April brings improvement all round. concerns about the new fi- issue titled ‘No right to complain’. Having read this, it certainly nance policy regarding pris- hits the point and resonates with many. The complaints system We are already seeing growth in small local oners money sent in and out is not fit for purpose despite previous Justice Secretary Chris producers of high street goods and food. and the use of and misuse of Government is also a beneficiary of improv- Grayling saying it would address issues prisoners faced. If accounts. ing shire economies, with more wealth and, complaints are not processed, allocated serial numbers, and thus, revenue generated, far less economic simply vanish into thin air, what are you supposed to do? At the If the Finance Department of support is required. Our climate change obli- other end of the system, you have promotion hungry CMs or the Prison Service cannot gations are met sooner and with little or no governors who equally think it is acceptable to threaten us with spot when an account has pain. sanctions/transfers, etc as their targets are skewed and out of been used for ‘money laun- sync. Is it not time that complaints in prison were overseen by dering’ or financing other Hydrogen has a future; it lends itself to low incriminating projects, then an external body to monitor outcome and success? The PPO loss storage (low pressure) and can provide surely they should be edu- leaves a lot to be desired. Having a complaint policy framework for peak energy demands such as heating cated, because I’m sure if document, and it being ‘complied with’, are two different things and power generation. The UK gas network that was the case, I would be in any event. © Deposit Photos will complete conversion to hydrogen com- able to spot a dodgy account patibility by around 2030. The latest boilers Electric cars are hydrogen compatible. Surplus wind, tide straight away. Gym is a godsend and solar power can now be converted to hy- Taffy Dan - HMP Littlehey Simon Porritt - HMP Whatton drogen production at about 65% efficiency, “Maybe they are just factoring in best storage and distribution not that bright, or their As a regular reader of your publication, I have read countless Thank you Paul Sullivan for the recent arti- overheads, overall boiler efficiency is about letters from prisoners who have really struggled with the cle, no doubt stimulating the debate, I’d like 52% (energy). abacus may be broken.” lockdown. Spending up to 23 hours per day in a cell and being to add a measure of future development com- confined to the same wing for over a year has massively taken mon sense. Hydrogen powered vehicles, so far, overall I had a direct debit order its toll on prisoners mental health. I have also had issues trying operate at about 23% energy efficiency (hy- coming in every week for the to keep my head in check. Now to the point of my letter. past 5 years and even after Recent electric cars, cradle to grave (including drogen production to power at wheels). Cur- During this time the one thing that had such a positive effect on putting in several apps to be recycling) can produce 50% less climate rently, with hydrogen, three times more primary me and others is the one single hour of gym we get every exempt from the new fi- change and pollution than comparable regular energy is needed to achieve the same milage. Wednesday morning outside on the AstroTurf. Come rain or nance policy, and explain- cars. That is, given green energy throughout. Thus, it has little appeal in terms of energy shine, or even heavy snow, the gym staff and orderlies have set Scandinavia already leads in this, and the ing the inconvenience to my efficiency. New battery technology may up weights for us. But one person has gone above and beyond, UK is playing catch-up. The grid has more change things. NASA and Honda are work- family outside, the governor can you please say a huge thank you to Big Stu G. Stu has run than sufficient capacity, given charging ing on a fluorine battery which promises has said - ‘it’s out of my circuits for us all through the winter, and I can honestly say he overnight, while the producers have ample much more capacity and near instant charg- hands’. He tried to get it left space capacity. The UK will have its own ing. The race is on to reduce the operating as it was as it is a help to me, has kept us sane, and we look forward to the beastings he gives Lithium supply, sufficient for the home mar- temperature further, currently 80c, this bat- but to no avail. Now prison- us every week! Thank you, Big Stu. ket, from a Cornish mine that has been tery has industrial applications already. ers will have to get Power of under development for the last two years. Attorney given to a family Officer saved my life member and then get a bank For those thinking about an electric car, here Martin Hostler - HMP Wakefield The biggest driver of climate change, pollution is some outline information - individual card and get money sent in and energy waste is excessive centralisation models may vary. through the card. I would like to say a big thank you to officer Mick Daffor who of production, distribution, and supply. We found me slumped on a chair with no response from me. He all witness the impact of congestion, long All electric models (e.g. - Nissan) - current If I want to send £300 out to then called for Healthcare, who responded very promptly and commutes, white van man, shortness of fam- range 180-300 miles. Home charge time family and grandchildren it then called for an ambulance. I was told by various staff that I ily time, declining high streets and limited 3kw (regular socket) 4 hours = 40 miles. has to be done in £50 instal- had died and was brought back to life and put into an induced ments, so, six times more public transport. There is no need for much 7kw (special socket) 2 hours = 40 miles. coma for 3 weeks. I was brought out of the coma and then over of the food from thousands of miles away. paperwork for the financial 2 weeks I recovered. The hospital did a blood test and told me I With adjustments we can produce all we need. Charging station - 40 minutes = 80% capacity. team, six times more post- was now clear of Covid. I was discharged back to prison where I Producing local, dramatically improves local Battery warranty - up to 8 years. Road tax - 0. age and a lot more work for was put on the hospital wing for 10 days to recover. Covid has economies, climate change, and reduces Congestion charge - 0. Servicing - none re- everyone. This is obviously many other problems. quired but annual check recommended. an idea concocted by affected me both mentally and physically to where I cannot pen-pushers. I don’t know hardly walk, my grip is weak, and I have uncontrolled shakes Individual components include higher qual- Hybrids - these come in a wide variety of ca- about running a finance de- and feel light-headed and dizzy. I would like to say thank you to ity of life, less travel, less congestion, and pability. All need careful checking against partment, I think they the officers who sat with me 24-hours a day. Covid has left me work stress. There is more family time and use patterns. Some may offer little improve- would have trouble running unable to sleep properly because I am paranoid that I might more disposable income. The reduction in ment to climate and cost. Good luck! a bath. not wake up. So, I say thank you everybody, this virus is real.
Important Parole Case Coming Up? Get Someone A dedicated team of human rights Who Gives a $@*#! solicitors acting for prisoners “I can’t believe how fortunate we were in choosing in claims for compensation and 99% of Clients happy with the Emmersons. You were amazing, I would recommend Contact us: outcome of their case Emmersons to anyone looking for an approachable and judicial review and with specific reliable firm of Solicitors.” expertise in: Leigh Day 52 John Street, 137A Back High Street, Gosforth, Priory House Nearly all clients achieved release or Sunderland SR1 1QN Newcastle NE3 4ET 25 St John’s Lane open conditions • All areas of discrimination London EC1M 4LB 0191 567 6667 0191 284 6989 • Access to healthcare We are experts in category A reviews Freephone • Deaths in custody [email protected] +44 (0)20 7650 1200 and independent adjudications 0800 193 0146 emmersons-solicitors.co.uk Members of the Association of Prison Lawyers and leighday.co.uk Legal Aid specialists. @LeighDay_Law Parole Hearings • Adjudications • Recalls • Category A Reviews EMAP Registered with Members of the Association of Prison Lawyers compensationfollowing food poisoning complications Mo was left with long-term complications following a bout of food poisoning in prison. Our lawyers secured him more than £12,000 in compensation.
Mo was fasting during Ramadan but was provided with food for after fasting hours in a flask by the prison. One evening, he was given a flask containing rice, chicken and lentils, which had gone cold. After eating the food he became ill later in the night and for the next 3 days, he suffered sudden onset diarrhoea and vomiting. There had been an outbreak of food poisoning amongst the prisoners who had been observing Ramadan due to the substandard food.
Afterwards, Mo developed post-infective irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), the effects of which were permanent. He had to alter his diet by avoiding certain foods and take medication to control his symptoms. 1-2 years later, his symptoms had not resolved and he would occasionally suffer from abdominal pain, bloating or diarrhoea. After contacting Jefferies, we arranged for Mo to be assessed by an expert gastroenterologist who looked into his medical history and gave a prognosis. In the end, the case settled for £12,419 in August 2019.
“We understand prisoners and prison injury claims. We are the UK’s leading Prison Injury Lawyers and will fight for what you deserve.”
At Prison Injury Lawyers, we can help you claim for:
Dental negligence Workplace accidents Bunk bed falls Medical negligence Burns Transport accidents Slips, trips and falls Assaults Accidents in the gym
N ON I JUR IS Y R L P A W E Y H E
T R
S
F
A
O
S
S S
O R
E
pilaC
B I
A
M
T
E
I O M N
0800 808 9577 I prisoninjurylawyers.co.uk The Triangle 8 Cross Street Altrincham [email protected] Cheshire WA14 1EQ
Prison Injury Lawyers is a trading name of Jefferies Solicitors Limited
3233_PIL_IT_FP_Adverts_265x332.indd 9 15/03/2021 16:24 12 Newsround www.insidetime.org Insidetime June 2021
Self-harm in Newsbites prisons near record level Unis invite prisoners to study Four universities are inviting prisoners to start degree courses The lockdown year of 2020 from their cells this autumn. The institutions feature in the first was one of the worst years undergraduate prospectus published by DWRM, a consultancy ever for self-harm in prisons, launched last year to bring higher education into jails. Courses according to annual figures offered for the 2021/22 academic year are: from the Ministry of Justice. • BA(Hons) in business with management or marketing, with The rate of self-harm the University of Central Lancashire. incidents during the year • BA(Hons) or BMus(Hons) in music or music management with was 691 per 1,000 prisoners the London College of Creative Media. in England and Wales, the • BSc(Hons) in Maths with the University of Greenwich. second-worst on record. • Law and social sciences foundation year with the University An end to purposelessness? There were a total of 55,542 of Westminster. © Andy Aitchison incidents, of which 2,657 As well as publishing the guide, DWRM will advise would-be were serious enough to students on what to study and help them apply for tuition fee loans. * For a copy write to: DWRM Consultants, PO Box 6741, Warwick Regime reform will take three years require hospital attendance. CV34 9SF or freephone 0800 987 5953. The Prison Service has set out details of a three-year reform The all-time high was in 2019 Probation officers should only supervise 50 at once when there were 767 programme which could transform how prisoners spend their days. Probation officers should not supervise more than 50 people at incidents per 1,000 prison- once, a report by MPs has recommended. An inquiry by the The review of prison regimes will aim to learn space and staffing, this is likely to mean ers. Ministers have seized on Commons Justice Committee found that many staff currently lessons from the coronavirus lockdown, prisoners spending more time locked in their the 10% year-on-year have caseloads of more than 60, with some supervising over 70 following claims that keeping prisoners cells than they did before the pandemic struck. reduction as evidence that or even over 80. In their report on the future of probation, locked in their cells for most of the day eased lockdown conditions published in April, the MPs said: “It is clear from Inspectorate tensions and led to reductions in violence Details of the FRD and the three-year reform benefited some prisoners research that caseloads of more than 50 affect the quality of and self-harm in men’s jails. programme have been briefed to the POA and who welcomed having less work, and thus the ability of probation to meet the aims of to charity leaders, although there has been contact with others. rehabilitation and public protection.” The committee praised The work will be done in two stages. Over no public announcement. A joint statement extra spending on “through the gate” support for prison leavers in this summer, a project called Future Regime signed by POA leaders and senior HMPPS Figures revealed a sharply recent years. It welcomed a commitment by the Probation Service Design (FRD) will seek views on what officials in April said: “Though the work is at different pattern between to recruit 150 ex-offenders to work as mentors, and called for a changes should be made and define what an a very early stage, the POA national execu- male and female jails. timetable on how they would be recruited and deployed. improved regime will look like. As part of tive committee has made it clear to HMPPS Among male prisoners, there FRD, HM Prison and Probation Service that the POA believes we should not return to was a 13% year-on-year Prison has more illicit phones than prisoners (HMPPS) has launched an online survey for mass unlock and full association in prisons. decline in the rate of The number of illicit mobile phones seized at one prison exceeds staff to complete, asking how prisoners could HMPPS and the POA are committed to self-harm incidents. the number of prisoners it holds. Staff confiscated 653 phones make better use of their time. working together to develop safe and more However, among female from residents at HMP Kirkham over a 15-month period from purposeful regimes and recognise any prisoners there was a 13% the start of 2019 to March 2020. At the time the prison held 634 Following this, changes will be introduced benefits of a small group approach.” year-on-year increase to a men. The finding emerged in a Prison Service table showing the gradually in a three-year programme of new record high. Female number of phones seized at every jail in England and Wales. regime reform. The idea is that as coronavi- The Ministry of Justice says it has sought jails saw 11,988 self-harm Kirkham, an open prison in Lancashire, had among the highest rus restrictions are gradually eased, regimes prisoners’ opinions via surveys or “engagement incidents, an average of 3.6 totals despite being a smaller jail than others at the top of the will not return to their pre-Covid form but events” at some prisons, and with a session on per prisoner. list. Kirkham’s Independent Monitoring Board has said adopt the new look. Within the review, prison radio. Comments have been fed back residents find it “easy” to smuggle contraband into the jail after HMPPS will examine how it defines and to officials in charge of the consultation. When Commenting on the figures, going out to work on day release. Figures in the Prison Service measures purposeful activity, how services Inside Time asked Buckland in April whether Lyn Brown, Labour’s shadow Annual Digest covering the five years from 2015 to 2020 show can be tailored to individuals’ needs, and prisoners would be listened to, he replied: “I minister for prisons and that Forest Bank had the most phone seizures, with 2,408, what role new technology can play. think we need to go into this review in an probation, said: “This is followed by Altcourse with 2,189, then Kirkham with 1,743. open-minded spirit that actually does look at clear evidence that the Although Justice Secretary Robert Buckland things from the point of view of the prisoner. mental health toll on women Rise in IPP recalls during pandemic has said that the review will be carried out in I would expect, as part of that review, informed prisoners locked up 23 hours New official figures have highlighted the situation of prisoners an “open-minded spirit”, there have been discussion and that sense of life from the a day away from children still detained on Imprisonment for Public Protection (IPP) suggestions from many quarters - including viewpoint of the prisoner being part of it.” and families has been dire.” sentences, nine years after they were abolished. At the end of the Prison Officers’ Association (POA), the March, there were 3,134 people being held on the sentences in Prison Governors’ Association, HMPPS top Questions being asked in the staff survey The annual Safety in Custody English and Welsh prisons - of whom 96 per cent had passed brass and Buckland himself - that the free include “What activities for prisoners do you figures from the MoJ, pub- their tariff, the minimum term which the judge said they must mixing of prisoners in traditional “associa- think we should ramp up first as we move lished in April, also showed serve. Statistics from the Ministry of Justice showed that during tion time” should be limited, and socialising through recovery?” and “In what ways could that prisons recorded 21,489 the first year of the Covid-19 pandemic, from March 2020 to should be restricted to smaller “family” we help prisoners use their time in cell more assaults during 2020, a March 2021, the number of IPP prisoners who were still groups of residents. Given constraints on constructively?” reduction of 34 per cent on awaiting their first release fell from 2,039 to 1,784, a 13 per cent the previous 12 months. For fall. However, the number held on recall increased slightly from ELIZABETH WREAKES, PRISON LAW SPECIALIST the first time since 2008, the 1,328 to 1,350, a 2 per cent rise. In March this year there were OXLEY & COWARD SOLICITORS LLP rate of assaults was higher in 525 IPP prisoners who were still awaiting their initial release Elizabeth is renowned for her expertise and female jails than in male jails. despite being at least 10 years past their tariff. representation in Prison Law and her reputation in this eld is held in high esteem. She can assist you with any of the following areas: - A total of 408 prisoners died Lawyers criticise videolink hearings during the year to March, an • Parole Barristers from across the UK and Ireland have spoken out • Licence Recall increase from 287 in the against court hearings being held via videolink, saying they are • Adjudications previous 12 months. The rise “markedly inferior” to face-to-face hearings. The use of technolo- • Police Interviews in Prison was driven by coronavirus, gy to hold remand or pre-trial hearings without bringing prisoners • Category A Reviews while the number of self- to court has accelerated during the Covid-19 pandemic, as Crown • Categorisation & Appeals • Home Detention Curfew & Appeals inflicted deaths showed a Courts in England and Wales have struggled with a growing • Sentence Calculation slight reduction, from 82 to 79. backlog of criminal cases. However, the trend was criticised in a • Transfers joint statement from the Bar Councils of England and Wales, • Sentence Plan / Progression Frances Crook, chief execu- Northern Ireland, and Ireland, together with Scotland’s Faculty • Closed Visits / Banned Visitors / Contact • Licence Conditions tive of the Howard League of Advocates. The professional bodies said that virtual hearings Please call on 01709 510 999 or for Penal Reform, said the have “multiple and multi-faceted disadvantages” compared with you can write to: death figures revealed “the in-person proceedings. They added: “The universal sentiment Oxley & Coward Solicitors LLP devastating impact of across the four bars is that remote hearings deliver a markedly 34/46 Moorgate Street Covid-19 on people living inferior experience. The diverse and complex needs of our clients Rotherham S60 2HB and working behind bars”. must be protected and their participation must be safeguarded.” Insidetime June 2021 www.insidetime.org Newsround 13
Looking Probation Newsbites Back... shake-up Lawns and trees reduce violence in jails through Inside Time Planting more lawns and trees in jails could reduce violence and self-harm among residents, a study has claimed. Researchers June 2013 The Probation Service used aerial photos to determine how much green space lies will undergo a major inside the walls of each prison, and compared their findings shake-up this month, with data on prison life. They concluded that increasing green with the merger of cover by 10 per cent can reduce prisoner-on-prisoner assaults by 6.6 per cent, prisoner-on-staff assaults by 3.2 per cent and Dying inside different organisations © Deposit Photos into a single national self-harm by 3.5 per cent. The study, involving more than 90 jails in England and Wales, was carried out by a team from the body. University of Birmingham and Utrecht University in The Hospices call for better Netherlands. Lead author Professor Dominique Moran told The From June 26, the 21 Independent: “These findings show that presence of green space care for dying prisoners regional Community in prisons reduces self-harm and violence. Nature contact is Homo respect Rehabilitation Companies known to be calming, reducing stress and tension, and this may “I am a homosexual prisoner Leaders of Britain’s hospices have said that (CRCs), which supervise be the reason why green space has these effects in prisons.” in a Scottish prison and I am prisons must do more to look after residents lower-risk people on really disheartened and angry in their last stage of life. probation, will cease to Prisoner overdosed after hospital visits cancelled at the way homophobic abuse exist. Their work will be A prisoner died from an overdose of illicitly-acquired painkillers after hospital appointments to deal with his chronic pain were gets dealt with by the Scottish A report by Hospice UK warned that a rise in the number of taken over by an expand- cancelled nine times. Imre Paul Thomas, 47, died after taking Prison Service. Over the past 4 elderly prisoners had led to a growing number of people ed National Probation tramadol and other medicines at HMP Garth in 2019. Following years of my sentence I have dying from natural causes in custody, bringing a need for Service (NPS), the body been in 3 establishments an inquest in Preston in April, coroner Nicholas Rheinberg specialist care. The report concluded: “This need for end of which already managed which all differ when dealing called for hospital consultants to hold clinics inside prisons, life care for imprisoned people is not being met.” higher-risk cases. with homophobic incidents. I saying this would reduce the number of cancelled appoint- Staff from the CRCs will ments. Thomas broke a bone in his hand in 2014 and it later have been the victim of The charity analysed Ombudsman’s reports into 95 cases transfer to the NPS. Some became infected, leading him to suffer increasing pain. In 2017 several homophobic incidents where people had died foreseeably from natural causes in prisoners and people a prison GP prescribed him dihydrocodeine but he continued which have included verbal, custody. It identified mistakes which were made repeatedly, under supervision in the to experience pain, and asked for help from a hospital consult- physical and mental abuse. ” including: community may experi- ant. Four of the nine cancellations were due to a shortage of Mailbag – HMP Glenochil • failure to apply for compassionate release which could let escorts, whilst two appointments were said to have been can- people die at home; ence a change to their celled by Thomas himself. Get IPP real • inappropriate use of restraints during hospital visits; probation officer or the “I’m sat here watching the • healthcare that was not equivalent to what the patient location of their probation Prisoner convicted of coughing House of Commons statement would have received in the community. office. on Reforming Rehabilitation, A prisoner who coughed in the face of a prison officer and said “I hope you get Covid” has been convicted in court of assault. given by Justice Secretary The report, called Dying Behind Bars, said: “As those The reform marks a The 41-year-old resident at HMP Nottingham was threatening Chris Grayling, and one of the supporting and championing high quality palliative and end Government U-turn on the to self-harm in protest at being in a double cell with a man he MPs in particular really needs of life care for all, we must take action to ensure this unac- 2013 decision by former did not want to share with last October. When officers cuffed to do a bit of research before ceptable state of affairs changes. A prison sentence is the Justice Secretary Chris him and led him back to the cell, he launched his cough attack. he comments. He stood up deprivation of an individual’s liberties, it is not a sentence to Grayling to split and The officer was sent for tests three days later, and it was con- and asked Mr Grayling why he poor health and social care.” part-privatise the had ‘abolished’ the IPP when firmed he had Covid. However, the prisoner who coughed was probation service. tested five times and never found to have Covid, suggesting it had the lowest reoffending Rini Jones, Policy and Advocacy Officer of Hospice UK and the that the officer caught the disease from a different source. The rates after release. We all know report’s author, added in an article for politics.co.uk: “As part prisoner pleaded guilty to assault at Mansfield Magistrates’ why the IPP has the lowest of my research into this problem, accounts I’ve heard include “Several inquiries Court and was remanded to be sentenced at the Crown Court, reoffending rates after release, people with dementia who didn’t know they were in prison have found that the to tie in with his sentencing on other matters. it’s because hardly any IPPs being locked in cells alone; widespread inappropriate use of have ever been released!!!” restraints, including frail, elderly people being cuffed to changes introduced ‘Think of kids before jailing parents’ Mailbag - HMP Peterborough hospital beds; and terminally ill people dying in their cells by Grayling were a while awaiting the outcomes of application for compassionate Judges should consider the needs of children before deciding Prison overcrowding release (with the pandemic halting the process for many). failure.” to send their parents to prison, according to an influential committee of MPs and peers. The Joint Committee on Human is illegal These examples, sadly, are all too common.” Rights published draft laws which would require any judge “A great many prisoners are The new organisation will considering handing down a custodial sentence to look at a forced to share cells illegally Examples of good care are also highlighted in the report, have 16,000 staff and pre-sentence report and consider the impact that parental in overcrowded British prisons. including praise for the Buddy Support Worker scheme supervise 223,000 people. imprisonment would have on any children. The measures would The Penitentiary Act 1799 sets operating in six English prisons, in which the charity Recoop A report last month by affect primary carers - often mothers, but also including single out those prisons must provide trains prisoners to support elderly or frail fellow residents. HM Inspectorate of fathers. The draft laws were tabled last month as amendments one prisoner per cell. Article 8 The report praised the “immensely valuable and compassion- Probation found the to the Government’s Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill of the Human Rights Act 1998 ate support that Buddies provide to fellow incarcerated merger plans were on which is currently going through Parliament. Labour MP gives humans the right to a people with terminal and life-limiting conditions”. track. In a report in April, Harriet Harman, the Chair of the Committee, said: “A young private life where they are the Commons Justice child’s separation from its mother when she’s sent to prison sufficiently secluded from In some cases, prisons have arrangements to transfer dying Committee welcomed the risks lifelong damage to that crucial relationship. Yet, too often, people, to be alone and not prisoners to a local hospice so they can die away from the jail. reunification of probation the child is invisible in the court process. This must change.” watched, heard or disturbed Hospice UK surveyed hospices and identified 25 which as a single national by others.” provide care at a total of 34 English prisons, ranging from Mailbag - HMP ChannIngs offering advice to prison doctors and nurses, to accepting service but said the risons around globe count Covid cost Wood prisoners as residents. disruption of the past Prisoners around the world have borne the brunt of the seven years had damaged coronavirus pandemic, according to a major international Newsround The report, published in April, suggested that some hospices the service, and called for report. Of the 11 million people in prison around the world, “‘Transforming legal aid is had been reluctant to work with prisoners, either due to a commitment from the more than 500,000 have caught Covid-19 and almost 4,000 needed to boost public concerns among staff or because they feared a backlash from Government that the new have died with the disease. At the same time, measures to curb confidence’. Chris Grayling, the public. structure would remain in the spread of the virus in jails - including medical isolation of prisoners and bans on visits - have led to prisoners’ rights being Justice Secretary, speaking to place for decades, not violated and sparked a mental health crisis. The findings come the Law Society Gazette on In a foreword, Juliet Lyon CBE, chair of the Independent years. Monday 20 May 2013. During Advisory Panel on Deaths in Custody, and Ann Norman, justice from the campaign group Penal Reform International in its and forensic nursing professional lead at the Royal College of annual publication Global Prison Trends 2021. According to the the interview with the Gazette See next month’s Inside Nursing, welcomed what they called a “pivotal report” and report, “Prisons remain hotbeds for virus transmission. The the former TV producer Time for a full explanation wrote: “It is all too easy to see innovation in practice lost due pandemic has exposed the impact of overcrowding and offered no hard evidence that of the changes and how the public had lost confidence to funding restrictions or overly bureaucratic processes which under-resourcing of prisons in the gravest of terms - through they could affect you. in the legal aid system. ” can be better organised to meet people’s needs.” the loss of life.” 14 Newsround www.insidetime.org Insidetime June 2021 Forensic science failings ‘risk Prisoners banned from marrying outside jail newspaper quoted “a senior Tory source” miscarriages of justice’, say peers stating: “Mr Buckland is absolutely furious a governor thought this a sensible use of Members of the House of peer who chairs the Science in doing something more temporary release. This rule is in place to Lords have claimed that a and Technology Committee, about this is an underlying visit dying relatives, not to go on a jolly. lack of funding for forensic said: “The quality and problem and it reflects What next? Lags out for a round of golf? It is science risks creating delivery of forensic science extremely badly, in my view, not government policy to let drug traffickers miscarriages of justice. in England and Wales is on the Government.” out for weddings!” inadequate. We heard this The Government scrapped repeatedly in our inquiry.” And Conservative peer Lord “No entitlement” A Sun comment alongside the news report the state-owned Forensic Griffiths of Fforestfach said: © Deposit Photos said “Justice Secretary Robert Buckland must Science Service in 2012 and Labour peer Baroness Warwick “The quality of forensic tighten day release rules” - an instruction he police forces now do their of Undercliffe said the 2019 science is not at present fit Rules on prisoners’ weddings have been appeared to have followed within a fortnight. own analysis or contract it report showed the service for purpose nor up to our tightened after Justice Secretary Robert out to private labs. A report was “a shambles”, with poor traditional reputation.” Buckland QC was said to be “absolutely The bridegroom at the wedding was reported by the Lords Science and quality work and a lack of furious” that a man was allowed out of a to have been escorted by two prison officers. Technology Committee in 2019 high-level leadership. She Responding for the closed prison to get married. The Sun claimed that taxpayers had picked found that too little research said: “If resources are not Government, Home Office up the bill - but if so this went against the was being carried out, while put into the development of minister Baroness Williams From April, Category C prisoners who wish to rules, set out in PSI 14/2016, which state: Legal Aid cuts meant new forensic science, there of Trafford said ministers marry will normally be required to do so inside “Prisoners and their partners are expected to defendants could not always will be more miscarriages of had invested more than £50 their prison, rather than being allowed out. pay any costs associated with the marriage/ hire their own experts to justice and unnecessarily million over the past two Under the previous rules, men in Categories A civil partnership. If the ceremony/registration challenge forensic evidence. unsolved crimes.” years in strengthening police and B could only marry in jail but those in is to take place outside the establishment the forensic services, including Categories C and D could attend outside prisoner will be required to pay for the cost of In a Lords debate in April, peers Lord Winston, the TV doctor digital forensics. ceremonies. transport and any escort to the place where from all parties complained and Labour peer, said: “It is the registration will take place.” that the Government had obvious that major deficien- She added: “This country The change in the rules came two weeks after failed to act on the report’s cies have left some cruel has some of the world’s best The Sun reported that a 27-year-old man who Under human rights law, prisoners are entitled recommendations. results and great distress - or forensic scientists ... Every was a few months into a six-year sentence for to marry, but this right can be satisfied with a even worse - for a number of day, their expertise is drug trafficking had been allowed out on day wedding inside prison grounds - there is no Lord Patel, a former hospital people, often entirely deployed to solve crime and release from Humber, a Category C prison, to entitlement to an outside ceremony. consultant and cross bench innocent citizens. The delay deliver justice.” marry at a Registry Office 30 miles away. The Coronavirus: Prison Timeline ‘Prisons can manipulate MDTs’ April 15 April 19 A former HM Chief Inspector Speaking in a parliamentary Key date in the UK’s vaccination Prisoners describe their loneliness and frustration during the of Prisons has criticised debate in April, Lord campaign, as all over-50s and random drug testing in jails, Ramsbotham said: “When I at-risk groups have now been long months of lockdown. Eight men at one unnamed Scottish claiming governors can was Chief Inspector, I once offered a first dose. Official jail exchanged letters with researchers at the University of manipulate the system to went into a cell and noticed figures show take-up among Dundee. All spent most of their time locked in their single cells achieve the results they want. some certificates on the wall. over-50s in the community is On asking the prisoner what 94 per cent, whereas in pris- as part of efforts to curb the spread of the virus. One wrote: “It Lord Ramsbotham said he they were for, I was told that ons only 85 per cent of those is very lonely and boring, reading and television … Prisoners are had observed cases of they were for testing drug- eligible have had the jab. The residents who were known to free, which it was known he stressed and some have smashed cells and caused trouble. difference is thought to be be drug-free being deliber- was, and that if I came back due to more prisoners declin- Most are accepting but there is a tense atmosphere.” Writing in ately selected for testing, so the next month, there would ing to be immunised; a survey the British Journal of Criminology, the authors commented: as to make it appear that the Lord Ramsbotham: be another one. by EP:IC Consultants pointed scale of the problem was less “[MDT’s] Have always been “The pre-lockdown regime and associated routine was some- to high rates of vaccine refus- than it actually was. capable of manipulation.” “Another time, I went into a al among people in custody. thing that a number of participants wanted to get back to.” prison where there were Under current rules, prisons alleged to be no drug users, May 7 Prison Service headquarters April 30 in England and Wales are and used to assess the scale which I simply did not believe. With the Government still required to carry out random I found that the prison made a A solicitor claims on social media that because of Covid publishing no regular data on of the problem at each restrictions, his client on remand at Wandsworth was left “mandatory drug tests” each establishment. Separately, practice of testing only the progress of the vaccination month on between 5 per cent vulnerable prisoners, who without clean underwear for 11 weeks. Edward Jones of individuals who are thought campaign in prisons, figures and 10 per cent of their were notoriously drug-free. I Hodge, Jones & Allen Solicitors tells the prison via Twitter: leaked to Inside Time show to be using drugs can be told residents. The results, as to to take suspicion-based ordered an immediate test of “He says there are restrictions on laundry facilities, his family that 35 per cent of prisoners what proportion test the whole prison, which found can’t send him clean clothes due to Covid restrictions, and in England and Wales have tests, which do not count positive, are collected by towards the jail’s score. that 47 per cent were users.” when I asked at the visits desk about the possibility of bring- now had their first dose - still ing them into the prison I was told that this wasn’t possible, a long way behind the rate of again due to Covid.” A Prison Service spokesman responded: 65 per cent in the community. “Whilst HMP Wandsworth has paused the delivery of pris- The main reason for the dif- oners’ own clothes in line with COVID-19 restrictions, no ference is that vaccination is BARTFIELDS prisoner would have been without clean, prison-issued being done in priority groups by age, and a large proportion FORENSIC ACCOUNTANTS clothing or underwear for 11 weeks.” of prisoners are young adults. We take pride in providing a CONFISCATION PROCEEDINGS UNDER POCA! May 14 May 12 full range of Bartfields have considerable UK wide experience of Official monthly figures show Prisoners around the world have borne the brunt of the coro- analysing and revising prosecution benefit calculations Criminal and Prison Law within tight deadlines. (Legal aid available) a welcome drop in the num- navirus pandemic, according to the annual Global Prison Trends Free prison visit for all pre-confiscation hearing cases ber of prisoners dying with 2021 report. Of 11 million people in prison, more than 500,000 Services. Recent Cases: Prosecution Benefit Bartfields Benefit Covid-19. Only three prison- have caught Covid-19 and almost 4,000 have died. According to FOR ASSISTANCE PLEASE CONTACT Mr M £190,000 £52,500 ers in England and Wales died the report, “Prisons remain hotbeds for virus transmission … The Mr H £667,000 £67,000 with the virus in April, com- pandemic has exposed the impact of overcrowding and under- Mrs D £271,000 £45,000 Hannah Rumgay Mr R £1,280,000 £134,000 pared with 24 in March and a resourcing of prisons in the gravest of terms - through the loss Mr O £378,000 £16,000 record 32 in February. There of life.” Countries around the world have introduced measures Prison Law Solicitor Contact Elisabeth Scott or Emma Whitaker on 0333 222 4445 (option 3) were only 150 confirmed new to combat the virus in jails including medical isolation of pris- Tates, 12 Park Place, Leeds LS1 2RU Bartfields Forensic Accountants cases among prisoners in oners and bans on visits. The report says: “The prevention of St Paul’s House,23 Park Square,Leeds,LS1 2ND April, a drop of 91% on the Covid-19 outbreaks in many prisons came at a cost to human info@bartfieldsforensic.co.uk 0113 242 2290 www.bartfieldsforensic.co.uk previous month’s total. rights. Many rights have been violated under severe restrictions.” Insidetime June 2021 www.insidetime.org Newsround 15 Double Discharge grant to rise to £76 World Prison News The discharge grant handed in cash to You’re morons, judge tells podding! prison leavers is to increase from £46 to £76, prison bosses Many prisoners have been on following a 26-year freeze. the receiving end of blunt Continued from front page remarks from judges during The move was announced by Justice Secretary Robert sentencing. But now prison Buckland QC, who said it would bring the payment into line The MoJ spokesperson said it bosses have found out how it with the rise in cost of living since it was last fixed in 1995. had not yet been decided if feels to be insulted from the The increase will take effect “this summer”, although a the Rapid Deployment Cells bench. A senior New York precise date has not been set. For the next three years there would be singles or doubles. judge told a court hearing that will be annual uplifts to ensure the grant keeps pace with If they are doubles, then by two jails in the city are “run inflation. next year there could be 2,000 “Any requests?” by morons”. Speaking at the portable cells in total, holding Credit: TMZ sentencing of a woman for up to 3,500 prisoners. Buckland said the extra money would help meet ex-prisoners’ Justin Bieber plays prison gig drug dealing, Judge Colleen immediate needs and discourage them from returning to Singer Justin Bieber dropped in at a maximum-security prison McMahon continued: “There Prisoner numbers are expected crime. where he performed for residents and learned about rehabili- is no continuity, there is no to surge over the next few tation programmes. The 27-year-old Canadian star, who had his leadership, there is no ability years as courts recover from The announcement was made at an event hosted by the first platinum single at the age of 15, sang three or four songs to to get anything done. They the coronavirus pandemic, rehabilitation charity Nacro. It was immediately welcomed by around a dozen prisoners flanked by guards at California State lurch from crisis to crisis … It extra police officers make the charity’s chief executive, Campbell Robb, who said it “will Prison in Los Angeles County. The set included Lonely, his bal- is the finding of this Court more arrests, and the effects make a very significant difference to people’s lives”. lad about his struggle to cope with early fame. Bieber, who has that the conditions to which of longer sentences start to be spoken about how he became addicted to prescription pills she was subjected are as dis- felt. MoJ forecasts last year In addition to increasing the discharge grant, Buckland said and cannabis at 13, was accompanied on the visit by his wife gusting, inhuman as anything show the prison population he was considering wider issues “including the extent to Hilary, a model, and by his pastor Judah Smith. The singer met I’ve heard about any increasing by around 20,000 which this one-off payment should remain in its current prisoners involved with The Urban Ministry Institute, a Colombian prison, but more over the next five years. The form”. He said he was exploring “the potential link to Christian organisation, as well as the Paws for Life K9 Rescue so because we’re supposed to Government is spending £4 prisoner earnings” and trying to get quicker access for programme, in which prisoners train dogs to become service be better than that.” The billion building 18,000 extra ex-prisoners to Universal Credit. animals for military veterans. After conversations with resi- comments, at Manhattan places, but with sites not yet dents, Bieber pledged to provide buses to transport their family federal court hearing, were confirmed for several of the When he announced last July that he was reviewing the level members to the jail for visits, after visitation was suspended directed at the chiefs of the new jails there are doubts of the discharge grant, with a view to setting it at a more during the Covid-19 pandemic. Following the visit in March, Metropolitan Correctional over whether their construc- realistic level, Buckland said: “I want to do something Bieber said: “It was a life-changing experience that I will never Center in Manhattan and the tion will be completed in time. different in this space rather than just index-link the figure. I forget. It was such an honour listening to their stories and see- Metropolitan Detention think if I index-linked it, it would come up to £72, so that ing how strong their faith is.” Center in Brooklyn. Antonia Romeo, Permanent doesn’t actually solve the fundamental issue.” Secretary at the MoJ, told a The kids are alright 20-metre tunnel falls just short Parliamentary committee the During the coronavirus pandemic, hundreds of prisoners A controversial research study from America has A detainee dug an escape tunnel 20 metres Rapid Deployment Cells would allowed out under Covid early release schemes were given suggested that children can benefit from a long - but fell just short of freedom. The tun- be a “game changer” in ensur- one-off payments at a higher rate of £80, whilst those leaving parent being sent to prison. Using 30 years of nel began in a room at Yongah Hill ing there were enough places. prison on their normal release dates continued to receive £46. data from the state of Ohio, the authors com- Immigration Detention Centre in Western pared children whose parents were jailed with Australia, its entrance hidden beneath a chest children whose parents were convicted of sim- of drawers. Running three metres below ilar crimes but not given custodial sentences. ground, it extended away from the building The children whose parents were jailed were and below two inner fences. Another five less likely to end up in prison themselves, and metres would have taken it beyond the perim- were more likely to live in wealthier neigh- bourhoods when they grew up. Writing in the eter fence, enabling a breakout. However, CRIMINAL DEFENCE, APPEALS & REVIEW AND PRISON LAW SPECIALISTS American Economic Review, the authors state: guards discovered the operation last month Has the justice system let you down? “Parental incarceration has beneficial effects before anyone could get away, and have referred the matter to Australian Federal Why not contact our friendly team for free and friendly advice? on some important outcomes for children.” Possible explanations could be that having a Police. Reports suggested that an unnamed parent sent to prison scares a child into avoiding Polish detainee had spent five months on the • APPEALS AGAINST CONVICTION a life of crime, or that removing a bad influence escape plan, using improvised tools including from the home allows those left behind to parts of a fridge and a wooden drawer, in the • APPEALS AGAINST SENTENCE thrive. In a study published last year, the same light of a mobile phone or candles. It was not • APPEALS AGAINST IPP SENTENCE authors calculated that imprisonment saves clear whether he had help or was working 1,800 lives a year in the US, because people alone. The centre holds around 320 detainees. • PAROLE BOARD REPRESENTATION with criminal convictions were less likely to die While there have been several escapes over its from homicide, overdose or natural causes (ORAL & PAPER HEARINGS) fence, this was the first reported tunnelling while in prison than they would be if living in attempt. • INDEPENDENT ADJUDICATION the community.
• SENTENCE CALCULATION Prisoner is sent 7,000 books • RE-CATEGORISATION (PRIVATE) When a political prisoner wrote to his wife asking for books to be sent to him at his jail in Iran, he was overwhelmed by the response. She posted the appeal on Twitter, and it was picked up in • JUDICIAL REVIEW news reports. Within days, 7,000 books had been posted to Mohammad Sharifi Moghadami at Great Tehran Penitentiary. In his letter, Moghadami explained that reading was a pleasure in pris- • MAGISTRATE/CROWN on due to the amount of free time and the absence of other distractions. He wrote: “The beauty COURT REPRESENTATION of the pages of a novel becomes more enjoyable for the prisoner … Books break the con- crete-iron prison environment.” He specifically asked for works of fiction, pointing out that the • CONFISCATION CASES prison library - known as the “cultural room” - mostly offered religious books and official mem- oirs of the country’s war heroes, which were not popular reading material for residents. He NATIONWIDE SERVICE claimed it was easier to get hold of drugs than books. Radio Free Europe, the US-based media For an immediate advice and representation, please contact outlet which reported the story, said the works donated in April - which include novels, poetry, Anita or Jo on: 02074697010 or 02086914464 and history books - would be available to the 15,000 residents at the jail. Moghadami’s wife, Faezeh Adibpour, said she thought the public had responded to the appeal as a form of protest or write to against state repression. She said: “I think this created a safe space for people to help political GANS & CO. SOLICITORS LLP prisoners and to express solidarity.” Moghadami is a dervish - a member of a religious order who 214 - 216 Rye Lane, London SE15 4NL have taken vows of poverty and austerity. He is serving a seven-year sentence on charges includ- OFFICE ALSO AT DEPTFORD ing “spreading propaganda” following violent clashes between his community and the Iranian security forces in 2018. 16 Newsround // Local www.insidetime.org Insidetime June 2021 Prisons: The good, the bad and the ugly
Ranby officer wins North Not quite a slap up, but getting there Midlands Changing Lives Award The North Midlands Prisons are a group which consists of Ranby, Nottingham, Stocken and Sudbury. Each year staff and prisoners nominate those who they feel are ex- ceptional individuals. One of We all count the categories is ‘Changing New clothes at Downview Lives’ nominated by the pris- A lot of people in prison think they are totally LGBT Origami oners. This year Ranby’s Of- forgotten but there are actually a multitude of All around the prison estate men have been ficer H won the award. organisations and even individuals who are discovering hidden skills. This is a piece of ori- doing their bit to help. This bundle of brand- Image credit - Serco - credit Image Nominees said that H is re- gami made by a Moorland man to celebrate new clothing (above) was donated and paid nowned for helping and sup- Better food at Serco prisons LGBT diversity. How did he get such fine work for by staff at a local M&S store and given to porting the men and always Serco have announced that the prisons they run (Ashfield, with just paper? Downview for their ladies. Doncaster, Dovegate, Kilmarnock, Lowdham Grange and going the extra mile; he gen- Thameside) have changed their food suppliers to the Ministry uinely believes he can help Whitemoor investigation of Justice (MoJ) main supplier Bidfood UK. They say that this will and support the men, to bet- improve food supply and offer safer allergen control and spe- ter themselves and live better leads to worker’s arrest cial diets. lives. A member of Whitemoor’s staff has been arrested after Confusion over High Down trying to smuggle contraband Cat change into the prison. During the Five years after High Down Covid lockdown an operation had been told it would led by the Eastern Region change to a ‘C Cat’, and with Special Operations Unit’s the majority of the prisoners Prisons Intelligence Unit in that category, the prison found a number of ways has now been told it will re- items could be smuggled in, main a category B local including by people working prison. It still does not have in the prison. Their actions full-time activity or Offending Behaviour Programmes Warren Hill artists show their talent resulted in the arrest of the needed by its ‘C Cat’ popula- Two more great pieces of art from the men at Warren Hill man on suspicion of miscon- tion. Commenting on the de- (above). Demonstrating, once again, the high level of talent duct in a public office and cision, HM Chief Inspector of within our prisons. offences under the Offender Prisons, Charlie Taylor, said: Management Act. “It is a serious indictment of HMPPS leadership that the governor and her team Feltham beekeepers in action should have been asked to Always willing to help, the beekeepers from Feltham swung spend so much of the pan- into action to remove a swarm of bees (above) that landed demic distracted by a change on someone’s fence near the prison. They were safely in function which was ulti- removed and now live alongside the Feltham colony. mately suspended.”
Prisoner declined stay in “dirty” healthcare unit A prison has been told to Prison Law Experts / Legal 500 Recommendation clean up its inpatient unit after its Head of Healthcare Nationwide Coverage - in-house video link facilities available admitted she was concerned about its state. An investiga- Picture credit - WMHR tion into the death of Alvin Specialist advice on Hedgehogs enter custody Black at HMP Whitemoor in In March, two Swinfen Hall staff (CM Stuart Edwards and November 2019 found that he died in his cell from a parole reviews police interviews Officer Henzie Miller) paid a visit to the West Midlands blood clot on his lungs. He Hedgehog Rescue (WMHR) run by a wonderful lady called Joan recalls had undergone surgery four criminal appeals Lockley (above). She showed them round her house which she days earlier and had been ad- extradition adjudications has turned into a centre for helping and caring for disabled and vised to stay in the healthcare orphaned hedgehogs. It was sobering to think that they can unit for observation but re- criminal defence con scation & come to harm and suffer. Joan said that in the summer months fused, apparently because the she can be looking after up to 600 hedgehogs. There are no last time he was there he had proceeds of crime national or government funded schemes to support individuals seen excrement smeared on like Joan so they rely on donations. CM Edwards was tasked by the walls. A report by the Members of the Association of Prison Lawyers Governor Ian West to help and assist in any way possible, and Prisons and Probation Om- in March the prison accepted its first rehabilitated hedgehog. A budsman stated: “If Mr Black house and kitchen were built and he has his own garden oppo- had gone to the inpatient unit Contact our Prison Law Department when he returned from hos- site the grounds department. The response from staff has been pital, he would have been positive and it finally feels as if something is being given back to monitored more closely by 01904 431421 nature. healthcare staff.” According to The plan going forward is to help Joan further by rehabilitating the report, published in April, [email protected] more hedgehogs and working towards erecting sheds so that “Healthcare staff considered Howard and Byrne the men can help look after them and release them back into that the standards fell below the countryside. what was expected in an NHS Chestnut Court, 148 Lawrence Street, York YO10 3EB For more information about WMHR go to: www.wmhr.org.uk/ service.” Insidetime June 2021 www.insidetime.org Newsround // Local 17
MoJ reject arts centre for Bad news for Greenock IMB Watch Reading Gaol Greenock is 110 years old and The bid by Reading Borough has been allowed to decay Council to buy the old into what has been described Dartmoor Reading Gaol for £2.6million as a ‘dilapidated’ condition, so The Board say: “The to turn it into an arts centre much so that forty cells have continued uncertainty as and affordable housing has had to be taken out of service to the future of the prison is been rejected by the Ministry after being declared unfit for having a real impact. Lack of Justice who say they wer- human habitation. For years of capital spending on the en’t offering enough money. the Scottish Prison Service has infrastructure is affecting Councillor Jason Brock, Reading been planning a replacement the quality of life in the Borough Council Leader, said: and has spent £8million on a Reverend royalty visits Peterborough prison. The uncertainty Fitness returns to Brixton “This bid may have had the proposed site for the new The Brixton PE staff have been ramping up the The Rev. Richard Coles (above left ) visited Pe- over the future of the Council’s name on it, but it prison. Now plans for the terborough last month and met up with the prison is affecting staff exercise and been out on the exercise yard in was submitted for the Reading new prison have been all-weather (above) giving men advice on their multi-faith chaplain to get an insight into what morale. Urgent considera- community who have shelved until at least 2026. happens inside the prison. During his tour he tion needs to be given to fitness regime. The men have stood up to the demonstrated huge enthusiasm challenge and have been doing bodyweight met with staff and prisoners and was keen to making sure that the prison and passion to transform exercise, battling it out on the bikes and row- know what support was offered to residents continues to be fit for Reading Gaol into something ing machines and doing bleep tests. The in- throughout the pandemic. Impressed about purpose until its planned truly special. Our job was to door gym space has been prepared to be what he saw, he described the women’s section closure in 2023, and that harness the strength of that opened so the men will have more variety and as “a progressive and positive environment.” prisoners are treated local community support and help the prison to begin to return to normal. Coles was a member of the pop group the equally alongside others in create a unique beacon, not Communards in the 80’s and later trained and just for Reading, but as a site the prison estate.” became the vicar in Finedon. He is a co-host
of national significance.” The Photo credit: Serco of BBC Radio 4’s Saturday Live programme. Berwyn attack man jailed MoJ countered: “Following Grendon New mail scanning machine A man who threw urine and faeces over discussions with the Council, In their latest report the Lowdham Grange have in- It’s a snip for Peterborough three staff at Berwyn has been jailed. The the prison will be put back on IMB say: “With residents stalled a ‘RapidScanTM’ scan- Peterborough were proud to announce, last staff concerned had had to visit hospital for the property market. Any sale spending up to 22 hours in ner to scan all incoming post month, the resumption of their ‘Hair for tetanus injections. Rachael Wood, defend- will seek the best value for their cells during the pan- and parcels for illicit items Homeless’ service. Local homeless people can ing, told the court: “There’s nothing I can taxpayers and be reinvested demic, the shortcomings (above). Anyone who is iden- get a free haircut at the Outside Links Centre. say about the circumstances which will into the justice system, while of the ageing system were tified as the source of any- They say having a decent haircut can really lift assist the defendant. They were deeply ensuring planning requirements exposed.” They did a ques- thing found is referred to the spirits and it is great to support the local unpleasant and very serious.” for the historic site are met.” tionnaire on the subject police for possible prosecution. homeless people. with men describing the system and the requirement Toughest prisons revealed in table of staff stress leave to use potties, which they HMP Manchester has been revealed as the toughest jail to say has increased despite a work in, according to a Prison Service table of how many staff smaller population, as ‘de- at establishments have signed off work with stress. Over five grading’, ‘disgusting’ and years, from 2015 to 2020, Manchester saw 112 of its staff go off ‘dehumanising’. There were on leave with stress. Next highest was Berwyn, with 96. Men’s reports throughout the year local prisons, which have been seen as the biggest trou- of waste being thrown out ble-spots for violence and drugs in recent years, filled many of New way to send photos to of cell windows. How resi- the slots near the top of the table. By contrast, open prisons prisoners dents can dispose of waste Is this ‘Prison Food’? and women’s prisons tended to have fewer staff off with stress There is a Facebook group Prisoners will be able to matter and then clean - even accounting for the smaller size of the establishments. their cell pot was not a named ‘Rate My Plate’. A lady receive photos sent electroni- The lowest rates of stress leave were at Askham Grange and part of the questionnaire Prison in the pink posted a photo of her plate of cally by their families and East Sutton Park, both women’s open prisons, where fewer but is an unresolved de- breakfast which consisted of friends using new technology than three staff went off with stress over the five-year period. cency and hygiene issue. Prison praised for letting a dollop of scrambled egg, being trialled at one private residents choose cell wall two pieces of unidentifiable prison. Users of the PixNow meat slices and a dollop of Hollesley Bay colour service at HMP Lowdham brown stuff (above). She got “The Board considers the A prison has been praised for Grange will upload pictures 11,000 comments, mostly prison to be a safe place online (above), paying £1 per allowing residents to choose negative, and her meal was for the vast majority of what colour their cell walls image. They will print out at a prisoners and staff. To our dubbed ‘Prison Food’. What are painted. After a visit to dedicated kiosk in the mail knowledge, there has been do you think? CRIMINAL LAW Peterborough Women’s jail, room, and the prisoner will no official serious incident Charlie Taylor, HM Chief In- receive them as high-quality Conspiracies Robbery in the past six years. “I’m a spector of Prisons, wrote: 4in-by-6in colour prints. Gang offences Murder Prisoners are treated fairly, winner” Manslaughter Fraud “Women were able to per- Lowdham Grange, operated humanely and consistently Drug offences POCA sonalise their cells, which by Serco, will be the first UK and there is a culture prison to offer the service, they appreciated, and many within the prison that after it was pioneered at a jail PRISON LAW we saw were painted in bright encourages dignity and in New York. The Photo colours, which women said Recall respect between staff, Booth Company, the private Parole made them feel more staff and prisoners, and supplier providing the Re-cat Apps/Appeals homely.” His report included It’s a fail for Barney prisoner to prisoner.” equipment, said it hoped Guittard Applications a photo of a cell with pink All didn’t go well for Bar- HDC Apps/Appeals other prisons would follow walls matched with pink cur- ney a trainee sniffer dog at Transfers Long Lartin suit. Many UK jails now Given the restrictions placed tains, bed linen and laundry Dovegate (above). The Sentence Calculation photocopy incoming mail Cat A Review on prisoners by COVID-19, bag. The Daily Mail reprinted Labrador was deemed too and issue residents with Pre-tariff review the Board believes that their the picture with the headline aggressive after biting his copies rather than the Independant Adjudications treatment by staff is largely “If Barbie did prison cells” and handler’s hand and sinking original version, as a security Lifer/IPP removal from open SOLICITORS fair and consistent. The conditions an article which began: “The his teeth into his stomach. measure to keep out drugs cells on four wings lack cm bijou dimensions and vivid The ten-month-old dog - meaning that photos may running water and sanita- www.rcmsolicitors.com décor suggest Barbie’s budget had arrived from a dog be received only as tion, falling below modern boudoir, but this is actually a rescue centre to be trained poor-quality photocopies. [email protected] standards of decency for jail cell.” When Downview al- Mark Hanson, Director of about half of all prisoners. as a drug detection dog. 07477511076 | 01422 381550 lowed prisoners to choose Lowdham Grange, said: “First The Board believes that He has now been found a the colour of their cell walls in indications are that this will action on this by the new home with an experi- 2017, The Sun called it an become a very popular government is long overdue. enced owner. “outrage”. service.” 18 Comment www.insidetime.org Insidetime June 2021
One of the strangest is Lali- bela in the Ethiopian High- lands. Eleven churches stand Walking for faith in a vast pit, their roofs open to the sky but their bodies carved from stone, each one ‘It is the journey that matters not the arrival’ different, with arabesque windows, Greek pillars or del- icate wall paintings, each one Month by Month dedicated to a different saint in the Orthodox Christian church. Steep steps lead the in the late fourteenth century. ago with a group of student visitors downwards to caves The language is not easy for a friends. We wore the conch and grottoes and under- modern reader but even so shell round our neck, the sign Kumbh Mela, the largest festival in the World
Rachel Billington ground tunnels so that they © Deposit Photos the twenty-four stories told by of St James, and were excited can decide which church to the pilgrims as they wend to meet other travellers after visit. Some choose to stay their ribald way to Canter- what was a mostly solitary Japan, although a mere 430 Belief of this sort is very unu- above ground and worship at Pilgrimage is a word from the bury Cathedral give a vibrant journey. Now, 300,000 go are inhabited. The temples sual now and generally the Greek cross engraved on past. Or is it? Before Covid picture of something between there every year. form a circular pilgrim way thought ridiculous, which the roof of Bete Giyorgis (The brought the curtain down, a package holiday and a where Shintoism and Bud- makes the increase in visits to House of St. George). There there had been a huge surge church outing. Probably the dhism live respectfully to- the places I’ve described and The routes vary but the long- was a King Lalibela but no- in people going on journeys, Wife of Bath gets top points gether. Their history dates many, many more all the est starts in France and is body really knows how or often on foot, to destinations for drama; she also reveals back 1,200 years, founded in more interesting. In the UK 1,200 kilometres long. A friend when these buildings ap- which would have previously that, over the years, she has 774 by Kobo Daishi, or Great alone there are enough his- peared - somewhere between been only taken by self-de- Teacher. The site has become toric destinations to keep the the 7th and 13th century scribed ‘pilgrims’. Peter Stan- more and more popular re- British Pilgrimage Trust web- maybe. Bets on the builders ford, journalist, author and cently and even some foreign- site fully stocked with won- generally favour the angels. Director of the Longford ers, or ‘gaijin henro’, have derful historic sites like Trust, has just published a been leaving the wonders of Walsingham (another Marian book called, ‘Pilgrimage’, At the opposite geographical spectrum is the Hindu festi- monasteries, ryokans and site) which was visited by sub-titled, ‘Journeys of Mean- volcanoes to make their way every English king from Ed- ing’. He refutes the argument val of Kumbh Mela held at three places along the sacred here. It is on my personal list ward I to Henry VIII. Rather that it is merely a new kind of of places I’d like to visit. sadly, since the reformation, tourism and suggests that River Ganges in India. The most holy is Prayag (meaning Anglican and Catholics have these journeys, to places of In European countries the separate sites but on a recent historic and religious impor- Place of Sacrifice) in Uttar Pradesh where the Ganges Marian shrines may not be radio programme Peter de- tance, are taken by people ancient but they are still ever scribed the mile long walk seeking a deeper meaning in meets two other rivers. As- semblies are in a 12 year cycle very popular. Lourdes is the into Walsingham in terms their life - which includes the most famous because of the that put that on my list too. health effect of daily and in 2019, 120 million pil- Santiago de Compostela 67 miracles performed there walking. grims made the journey. Per- haps this vast number is not and those are only the ones Others may prefer to walk of mine walked a stretch each authenticated by the Vatican from St. Ives to Penzance at At this point, my readers en- travelled to Jerusalem, Rome quite so surprising when, as after lengthy scientific inves- the very South-West of Eng- closed behind high walls may and Cologne - the last to see year and found the experience Peter points out, Hindus tigation by the Lourdes Med- land on St. Michael’s Way, wonder what on earth it has the remains of The Three so uplifting that when he had make up 15% of the world’s ical Bureau. It all started in going coast to coast on a sa- to do with them. But perhaps Kings who visited the baby finished, he went back to work population. The event in- 1858 when the Virgin Mary cred and very beautiful jour- the enjoyment in virtual Jesus at Bethlehem. in the hostels that have lined cludes holy rituals such as appeared to a young peasant ney through the land of saints travel in the imagination is the way since medieval times. washing in the holy waters, and giants, stones, miracles even greater for those behind Peter’s book describes and In 2010 a film called ‘The Way’ and wars. That is a relatively bars and even for those tells the history of twelve was a huge box office hit. Mar- One of the 88 short distance and the Pil- where, because of Covid re- places of pilgrimage round tin Sheen plays a doctor who temples on Shikoku grimage Trust is meticulous strictions, ‘foreign’ has be- the world, from India to Peru is suffering from the death of in reporting mileage, with come a foreign word. At any to Japan, from cathedrals to his son and finds the pilgrim- maps alongside. So you can rate, apart from the wind in caves, mountains, rivers and age helps him towards accept- choose St. Cuthbert’s Way, 62 our hair, and the blisters on islands. He starts with Santi- ance. Healing of mental and ago de Compostela, the burial miles from Melrose to Lindis- our feet, we can all make jour- spiritual ills is high among the place of St. James whose body farne, one of Scotland’s great neys in our mind and plan for reasons people now take to a more adventurous future. arrived in a boat washed up trails, following the saint the roads. on the shores of Galicia a cou- from hills to sea. Or if you The height of enthusiasm for ple of millenniums ago. The want to trek for even longer Last month, Mental Health such travel took place in me- mysteries that surround so there is the late Middle Ages dieval times. The most fa- much of the great pilgrim sto- Awareness Week took as its trail of 92 miles from Chester mous description of a ries serve to heighten the theme, Nature. A big subject, to Lichfield. pilgrimage in Western litera- emotional awe that have af- certainly, but one discussed ture is ‘The Canterbury Tales’ fect so many. I first journeyed more during lockdown than Whether you aim for a mon- written by Geoffrey Chaucer to Santiago nearly sixty years ever. This month, the Inside but it is also a glorious festi- girl, Bernadette Soubirous, 18 astery on an island or a cathe- Time star poem is from a man val where bejewelled ele- times. Mary left behind a dral in the middle of a city, or celebrating being able to start phants parade, along with spring where bathers soon even a faraway mountain or up his gardening job again. painted sacred cows, and came to cure their ills. Now river, the journey remains monks (sadhus) not only Every month we have poems there is an airport and the paramount. As many sages preach but demonstrate their about birds and trees and disabled are joined by those have pronounced in different spiritual prowess by walking clouds and animals, some- who want spiritual healing contexts over the centuries: on spikes or enduring ex- and many helpers, including ‘It is the journey that matters times only seen through a cell tremes of heat and cold. window, and yet meaningful quite a few of my friends. My not the arrival.’ to the writer. Pilgrims, walk- Moving from India to Japan, mother-in-law went once or ing as they do, are inevitably we find a very different place twice with a church group and in old age, when she had close to nature at its most se- of pilgrimage, comprising 88 ‘Pilgrimage - suspected throat cancer, she ductive and its most vicious, temples, this time above Journeys of asked a friend to bring back a although wolves don’t seem ground, and with numbers Meaning’ by the same problem they were in not names. Shikoku is a bottle of Lourdes water. She Peter Stanford medieval times. And then sub-tropical island, the 4th always said that it was the p. Thames & many pilgrimage sites are in largest, and greenest of the water that ensured a positive Hudson. £25 Lalibela, eleven churches carved into the ground In Arcadia I paint… © Deposit Photos secret or isolated areas. thousands that make up diagnosis. Insidetime June 2021 www.insidetime.org Comment 19 Three million and counting… That’s the number of bees that prisoners are helping to care for keeping in other climates from this prisoner.
The project supports the men’s well-being and Honey mummy… gives them an additional skill and hobby, and Picture credit: HMPPS the opportunity to gain beekeeping qualifica- tions. One of the staff involved advised that Category Bee the key is to be calm around bees; they sense With its black and gold stripes, trans- anger and can sting! lucent wings and signature furry HMP Warren Hill body, the bee is a common sight A few years ago, beehives were placed in the around the world. But do you know PIPE (Psychologically Informed Planned En- how important this creature is to our vironment) Unit at Warren Hill, where a small planet, and the threats it is facing? group of people live in a community setting in the grounds of the prison. The Unit has its own Why are bees important? “Anyone seen the bees?” garden, an ideal place for locating beehives While to many they are simply the fuzzy Picture credit: HMPPS and for developing the skills needed to face flying insects we see darting among the the outside world through the rehabilitation flowers during the warmer months, bees are around 20,000 bees. Therefore, around 70,000 programme. so much more than this, and have an im- bees live within the walls of the prison. portant part to play in maintaining our Bea Finch Most residents on the scheme are nearing the planet. Where trees and woods are essential To become a qualified beekeeper can take an end of their sentences with the focus underly- to filter our air, bees are vital to both polli- individual around three to four years. One ing the project being ‘progression’. As Mark nate the food we need to survive and polli- Across the prison estate in England and Wales, officer, Andy Leak, is currently in his second Jones, a prison officer on the PIPE Unit with nate many of the trees and flowers that residents and staff look after 104 active bee- year of the course, and says: “Without bees the responsibility for the beekeeping programme provide habitats for wildlife. hives. According to the British Beekeeping world would ‘bee’ a honeyless place!” says: “It’s about rehabilitation, about trying to Association, in the height of summer there are prepare people to go back into civvy street, and Perfect pollinators an average of 35,000 to 40,000 bees per hive Beekeepers can produce a range of products, I think this is a good tool to help that. It’s about According to the Food and Agricultural Or- - which means we have a total of three million from edible honey to candles and lip balms. working in a team and sharing as a group, and ganisation of the United Nations, approxi- bees in our protection. Let’s hear about some it is good for mental health.” mately 80 per cent of all flowering plants of the projects… Prior to Covid-19, the men were being introduced are specialised for pollination by animals, to the bees. One prisoner worked with staff to A member of the Ipswich and East Suffolk Bee- mostly insects (which includes bees). Polli- HMP Liverpool maintain the hives and care for the bees. This keeping Association currently teaches the nation is crucial because many of our veg- At present, HMP Liverpool have three hives, individual had previous experience of bee- British Beekeeping Association Basic course etables, fruits and the crops that feed our with the largest hive housing around 30,000 keeping, as his family owned a bee farm in in the prison. The first course began in spring livestock rely on it to be fertilised, so without bees and the two smaller hives each house another country. Staff learned a lot about bee- 2019. It proved to be popular, and some of the it, we could go hungry. Vegetables such as participants expressed a desire to keep bees broccoli, asparagus and cucumber rely on once they are released. the pollination of bees, as do apricots, straw- berries, apples, tomatoes and almonds. Both honey and cut comb are sold in the prison cafe, and the proceeds help to fund the apiary While there are other methods of pollina- costs. In addition, the prison makes hives in tion, including by the wind, birds, bats and its carpentry workshop which go to other pris- other insects, bees are among the most im- ons, generating more funds to support the portant pollinators because they are capa- Shaw and Co beekeeping. ble of pollinating on a much bigger scale. It Specialist Accident Compensation Solicitors has been estimated that it would cost farm- OVER 20 YEARS EXPERIENCE IN PERSONAL INJURY CLAIMS HMP Hull ers in the UK an incredible £1.8 billion per “Bees behind bars” were first brought to Hull year to manually pollinate their crops. in 2019, in partnership with the Beverley Bee- keepers Association, who come on site to de- The importance of honey Dental Treatment liver practical beekeeping training to staff and As well as being pollinators, honeybees, inmates. Prisoners also have access to a dis- Apis mellifera, also produce honey. This tance-based learning course offered by the sickly-sweet golden liquid is a valuable Medical Care British Beekeeping Association to give them product not only for its taste, but also due the theory skills in addition to the practical to its medicinal properties and the fact it is General Accident Claims training. They currently have two hives on site so energy-dense. which are tended by the trained inmates. All Call Chris or Sharon about your claim on: the honey produced gets purified in the prison Why are bees disappearing? kitchens, from where it is put into jars and sold Bees are in decline on a global scale as they in the staff mess. face many threats, from habitat loss to the FREEPHONE 0800 389 1590 use of toxic pesticides. If these threats aren’t Or you can email us at: When the bees arrived, staff made their site as brought under control, we could be looking bee friendly as possible by planting a range of at a future without bees. bee-friendly plants and continuing with their [email protected] drive to stop using herbicides as a weed control Types of bee measure in sterile areas. Not all bees are the same. There are over Shaw and Co Solicitors Ltd Three Indian Kings House 20,000 known species of bee globally. Staff involved in setting up this project have Around 270 species of bee have been re- 31 The Quayside both been awarded a Butler Trust award for Newcastle upon Tyne corded in the UK. The famous honeybee is the work they have done with prisoners in the just one of these. Most honeybees are kept NE1 3DE gardens team. by beekeepers in colonies of managed All calls are confidential. hives. The rest of our bees are wild, includ- Across HM Prison and Probation Service, we ing 25 bumblebee species and more than Your claim will be represented on a No Win No Fee basis. in headquarters are looking to encourage more 220 types of solitary bee. sustainable activities in prisons, working with NO WIN NO FEE colleagues in the MoJ to identify opportunities Bea Finch is part of the HM Prison and for improvement, strengthen and scale up good Probation Service Sustainability Team practice, and develop new green initiatives. 20 Comment www.insidetime.org Insidetime June 2021
while’. There wasn’t a sense of follow- Face to face teaching continued some qualifications available to ing a curriculum or tailoring learning through much of the pandemic at prison learners are not widely recog- to individual needs.” Young Offender Institutions. In adult nised by employers. Quick said: jails, a few areas of specialist train- “Ex-prisoners are going to find it Teachers prepared the packs and ing survived, such as industrial hard enough to find employment. gave them to prison officers to hand cleaning and some kitchen work. We’re doing them a disservice by pre- out on wings but, according to Quick, During the past couple of months, as tending that whatever we’re deliver- the Prison Service officials who over- restrictions are slowly eased, some ing is going to equip them in the job see the contracts showed little inter- workshops have reopened and some market.” est in their content: “They weren’t jails have allowed teachers to meet looking for educational quality in small groups of learners. The UCU Further recommendations include what was being produced, it was the has been told by Prison Service offi- in-cell laptops, apprenticeship quantity. They were measuring it in cials to expect some restrictions to schemes, and rates of pay high the same way they would measure stay in place until next Spring. enough to encourage prisoners to how many toilet rolls they get from attend classes. their facilities contract.” Looking beyond coronavirus, the union has many criticisms of the Central to the union’s concerns is a Teachers struggling to teach way prison education is run, and © Andy Aitchison In a survey by the union, just over view that the current system, suggestions as to how it could be half of prison teachers said that dur- whereby education at English and improved. Now Quick is pinning her ing the lockdown they were unable Welsh prisons is contracted out to to talk to the people they were meant hopes on an inquiry by MPs which four providers - Novus, PeoplePlus, to be teaching, due to prisoners being may prove a turning point for the Milton Keynes College and Weston A whole lotta love! Quality missing quality of teaching in jails. confined to their cells, education College - is not working. According staff being barred from visiting wings to Quick, on the frequent occasions Prison education system ‘failing learners and and no technology being available. The House of Commons Education when prisoners are transferred be- Quick said: “Teachers couldn’t con- Committee inquiry, called “Are pris- failing staff’ tween jails “they are passed from tact their learners and see how they oners being left behind?”, will hear were doing through a simple phone evidence and grill ministers before one commercial education provider Inside Time report Marianne Quick is unhappy about call, or an email, or a webinar, all producing a report setting out rec- to another, with each trying to max- this. She represents 1,100 teachers those sort of things we have in edu- ommendations. Already 65 organi- imise the funding from the individ- and instructors in English, Welsh cation elsewhere. So education infra- sations and individuals, including ual before transfer”. A further Prison education has been a casualty and Northern Irish prisons, as the structure in prisons wasn’t former prisoners, have given written problem is that each contract is “cal- of Covid. Like so many features of lead for prison education at the Uni- prepared.” evidence. A 17-page dossier submit- culated within an inch of its life” as the life we took for granted, classroom versity and College Union (UCU). She ted by the UCU is packed with exam- to the number of courses, learners sessions came to a halt in March spoke to Inside Time on the day Although teachers could not teach, ples of what is going wrong and and teaching hours to be provided - 2020 in adult jails. More than a year members took their first strike ac- they were sometimes told to come in suggestions for making things all completely overtaken by the pan- on, they have mostly not resumed. tion in a decade, walking out at 49 to work anyway - even being given better. demic. She says the system is “failing prisons in a dispute over working tasks like painting classrooms or ti- learners and failing staff”. Schools and universities in the out- conditions during the pandemic. But dying noticeboards to fill the time. Among the union’s complaints are side world also had to suspend first, what about those in-cell packs? The union believes it would have poor facilities and under-invest- The union’s answer would be to re- classes. But they carried on teaching been safer for its members to work ment. It points to horticulture nationalise prison education as a via video calls, emails and the in- Quick says the Prison Service “just from home - and it was disagree- classes at a prison that no longer has single service and transfer responsi- ternet - none of which was possible weren’t ready” when the pandemic ments of this kind that escalated into a garden, bricklaying workshops bility from the Ministry of Justice to in prisons. For most prisoners, “ed- struck, and asked their contracted last month’s two-day walkout, affect- which have shut due to poor ventila- ucation” for the past 15 months has the Department for Education. It re- education providers to print off ing 49 prisons where teaching is con- tion, and a car mechanics workshop meant “in-cell packs” pushed under mains to be seen whether the MPs’ worksheets as a stopgap measure. tracted to the education provider without the modern equipment that the door - perhaps crosswords and inquiry will come down in favour of She says: “Initially, I think the ask Novus. Further strike days are a worker would use in a real-life ga- word searches, perhaps coursework such a radical solution; but whatever was ‘Just give them stuff to keep planned this month unless the dis- rage. One teacher said: “The interac- (which, if completed and handed it recommends, it could have a them occupied, because they’re pute has been resolved. Novus denies tive whiteboards in three of our six back, might or might not be marked). going to be locked in their cells for a far-reaching impact on how prison- that it put anyone at risk. classrooms don’t work.” Moreover, ers are taught.
Specialists in Crime, Prison law, Criminal Appeals, and Claims against the Police, Prisons or Local Authorities as well as Housing, Family and Mental Health advice CONTACT US NOW 020 8299 6000 Central Admin Team 158-162 London Road Croydon, CR0 2TD [email protected]
ASHFORD BIRMINGHAM CROYDON DARTFORD LEEDS LONDON MANCHESTER PETERBOROUGH Insidetime June 2021 www.insidetime.org Comment 21
because of the behaviour of I remember once, during my you see on the news, I find their siblings; e.g. their sib- lunch break, I was getting my that extremely difficult to ling could be in and around car tax from the post office, I deal with. I do also have tears the justice system and they was in my civilian suit. Two of joy rather than sadness. I get seen through the same men armed with a knife in the have only cried in work once lens as this sibling. I remem- queue in front of me attacked and that was when I told my ber one individual who told another man in an unpro- line manager that I was dys- me about how teachers judged voked and violent way. The lexic, and the response him because of his brother post office was rammed with floored me. and their expectations of him people. I dived at the person were reduced as a result. It with the knife. It was quite a Who inspires you, and how was one teacher who showed nasty struggle and I was on can you, or do you, inspire that they cared which ena- my own. The whole post of- others? bled him to go on and com- fice emptied, with just one plete a degree, even though it member of the public staying People in general inspire me, appeared that the teachers in behind to help. When backup not just those who have secondary school had written arrived, I went back to the of- achieved a significant level of him off. fice and continued with my fame, but also ordinary peo- work. It wasn’t until the crim- ple who deal with ordinary Your parents instilled values in inal investigation department issues on a day-to-day basis. you, how has that enabled you or CID rang to speak with me Many people I interacted with in life? that my colleagues in the of- as a police officer have left a A whole lotta love! fice found out what had hap- trace on me and supported my Not just by parents, when you pened. They were shocked onward journey and develop- have a loving upbringing and that I calmly walked back into ment. These people have a loving extended family, it the office and got on with my touched and strengthened my Pipeline to hope… provides you with an inner work without saying any- life. strength and a strong sense of thing. I was commended by your own values. I was told on the judge at court and by a You seem to take all decisions Keith Fraser tells leading criminologist and prisons numerous occasions ‘I love senior police officer for my carefully, retirement plans 5 you’ by my aunties and some- actions. years in advance, exit strategy, commentator what makes him laugh and cry… times my uncles. Even my giving back, life split into stra- cousins would say privately What makes you happy/ tegic areas, very upfront on just over 34 years, our inde- person’s brain, when it’s in to me that they love me - when laugh? what work/time you can com- pendence of thinking and that developmental stage. Ba- someone says that to you, and mit to. If you reach saturation hopefully visionary approach sically, people under the age you are not expecting it, it is Now this is a hard one. I do point you are no use to anyone. Faith Spear which is not dependent on the of 25 are likely to be less risk really powerful in a positive laugh or smile a lot. Things Is this a good summary of you? support and expectations of averse, more impulsive, take way. that make me happy are cele- others. risks and are more easily in- brating family occasions such I do think ahead, which is a After a30-year career in the fluenced by their peers and What obstacles did you en- as birthdays, christenings, benefit and a challenge. Just police, Keith Fraser is now the Young people’s pipeline to their surroundings. counter with your dream of also the similar type of things because I’m passionate, Chair of the Youth Justice youth justice services - impact being a police officer? with friends. I enjoy socialis- doesn’t mean I can’t change Board. He is also the Non-Ex- of words and actions, we have Children are children, ing, chatting with friends, I my mind… It has its down- ecutive Director/Trustee at more power than we realise. whether they are in the justice I suppose some of the barriers love a good debate about cur- sides too, for example if my The Work Force Development Can you expand on this? system or not. Their vulnera- I had - I failed getting into the rent affairs and enjoy objec- vision goes against the pre- Trust Limited, Advisor for the bilities, education, keeping police cadets and I didn’t get tive conversations about what vailing thinking. If it’s irra- National Police Chiefs Coun- As my knowledge of people, them safe and supporting into the West Midlands police makes the world tick. tional and/or unfair I find it cil Digital Engagement Pro- children, adults, increases, them into a future life, when I first applied. That is difficult to follow, even if it’s ject for Young People, and I’m actually getting to under- whether they feel part of soci- why I went to London. I loved What makes you cry? policy, law, etc. It does not Chair of Employability UK. stand the science better be- ety, are important for all my time in London and I have mean that I would go against hind human relationships children. made really amazing friends. I have found as I get older that policies and laws without un- In July 2020 you were ap- and also our development. But 20 years later, they recog- some of the injustices and derstanding the conse- pointed as a Commissioner to The maturity of a person’s Look for the potential … don’t nised the error of their ways suffering I see on the news quences of them. a new Commission on Race brain is not fully developed judge young people by their (ha! ha!) and accepted me as have made me cry, it never and Ethnic Disparities, what until the age of 24 years. sibling’s actions … there is a a Chief Inspector and I retired used to, but I see more and I’m not a maverick an organ- do you hope to bring to the Therefore any interactions better way. A few points you as Superintendent in my more how people suffer be- isation cannot trust, but I am table? that we have with a person recently raised with me. Can home region, where I was cause of an accident at birth prepared to stand up to things during that 24-year period you give examples? born and bred, and that filled or where they live, rather than which are unfair. My professional and personal can have and does have a sig- me with a sense of pride. anything that they have done experiences, rooted in sup- nificant impact on their de- This is just as a result of peo- in their lives. Those that have porting many charities, being velopment and their actions. ple I have met who told me ‘Just get on with it and don’t made others suffer upset me, Faith Spear FRSA is an part of and in and around the It’s possible to physically about many instances in make a fuss’ … is that your especially when you hear the independent criminologist criminal justice system for change the wiring of a which they have been judged attitude? back stories behind the faces www.faithspear.wordpress.com Forensic Accountants CANTERS CRIME with over We are a friendly rm, with solicitors and legally PURCELL PARKER 20 Years Experience quali ed sta who are experts in their particular Solicitors • Proceeds of Crime & Confiscation areas of law BIRMINGHAM’S TOP • Money Laundering • Tax Investigations AREAS OF WORK PRISON LAWYERS • Fees with Legal Aid Funding • Ex-Serious Fraud Office Forensic Accountant LICENSE RECALL PAROLE REVIEWS Licence Recalls “The case settled very favourably thanks in large IPP REVIEWS ADJUDICATIONS Prisoner Adjudications measure to your report. It is not often that one IPP & Lifer Parole finds an expert who is so thorough” Other Prison Law issues considered HDC Client Benefit Amount Riley Moss Benefit but payment may be on a private fee basis Sentence Calculations Mr M £783,000 £6,000 All areas of Criminal work including Police Mr D £1,176,000 £18,000 Re - Categorisation Mr A £2,040,000 £77,000 Interviews/ Court Appearances Contact Waseem Yasin or John Rafferty for Call now to speak with: FREE no obligation advice CONTACT US Tiernan Davis, Sadie Rice or Jan Arkwright 0161 832 1438 0151 239 1020 Purcell Parker Solicitors [email protected] [email protected] 204 - 206 Corporation Street Birmingham B4 6QB www.rileymoss.co.uk Suite 4 1st Floor 1 Derby Square, 184 Cheetham Hill Road, Manchester, M8 8LQ Liverpool L2 9QR 0121 236 9781 22 Comment www.insidetime.org Insidetime June 2021
really looks like? Try this: Outside Voices Lance Armstrong at the Tour de France.
This was a deception that was Beware the 1997 Prevention meticulously planned and ex- ecuted over multiple years that spanned continents, cost of Harassment Act millions, enmeshed thou- sands and left broken people Peter Martin - Journalist acting in a rational manner. But we need to and livelihoods in its wake - read on and also be familiar with the 2004 Lance Armstrong: winner but really a loser oh, and all covered by the Domestic Violence and Criminal Victims Act. elaborate smokescreen that Many of us will have grown up with the idea Section 12 of this Act introduced section 5A was his ‘charity work’. that we, in the UK, are entitled to a measure into the PHA 1997, which allows the court to of free speech. It is not, of course, without its make a restraining order after acquitting a It’s just not right! Where is Armstrong now? limits. What we say or write has to be reason- defendant of any offence, regardless, and de- Still got his house and family able under the circumstances. We cannot in- spite the name of the Act, of whether there has Life enhancer sports coach almost hits and some people are still giv- dulge in hate speech against anyone, and ever been any threat of violence, whether that ing him employment. What’s especially on the grounds of their race, sexual the brick wall be domestic or otherwise. An ‘acquittal’ under he lost? Seven yellow T-shirts, orientation or gender. Most of us have no prob- section 5A of the PHA 1997 originally meant a few sponsors, and not that lem in complying with laws to prevent this. We previously but that has been any occasion when proceedings are dismissed much of his fortune (he also do however reserve the right to call out some- with ‘at risk of offending’ following the hearing of evidence at trial. A settled a few things out of one for their misdemeanours or crimes if we groups in the community: later ruling interpreted this to also include the court, a few folks quite rea- believe they need to be brought to a wider at- Andy Mouncey this is a ‘first’ for me to work situation when the prosecution offers no evi- sonably took their awards tention. We should not do this lightly. We need with this group in a custodial dence with regard to the substantive charge. back and he got stuck with a to be absolutely certain that what we are say- setting. I had a little cry the night I life ban - but seems to have ing is totally accurate and we can show the So, the situation now does not look good at all. finished the work at HMP fared considerably better evidence to support this when challenged. There is a clear legal mechanism for anyone And here’s the thing about a Brinsford; which was a bit of than your average 19 year-old who displeases the legal establishment to be custodial setting in the spring The 1997 Prevention of Harassment Act (PHA) a shock. Mrs Mouncey and I of 2021. While COVID restric- at HMP Brinsford). charged with harassment. It does not matter went for a walkie-talkie when has changed this significantly. The law was in the slightest that there is no chance of success tions ease in society in gen- I got home that evening and, Though I do very occasionally introduced for a variety of perfectly under- in achieving a guilty verdict. This is no longer eral, prisons lag behind. For well…waterworks. She took it wonder what his kids think of standable reasons to prevent victims being the meaning of success. The prosecution will the past year there has been rather well, I thought. it all. So yeah: that’s ‘organ- unfairly targeted. It does, however, have its offer no evidence on the day, we will be formally no education, no work-based ised’ crime; and a justice gap drawbacks. It can be used to silence those who acquitted, but the court will impose a restrain- training, no organised physi- Here’s the thing. In the 8 the size of the Grand Canyon. are perceived to be a threat to the legal estab- ing order to prevent us doing what we were cal activity - and no family years I’ve been in this kind of That’s just a particularly lishment. So how does the Act operate? The previously doing totally legally. The penalties visits. There are reasons for work, nothing else has pro- high-profile example from the Act says you must have experienced at least for breaking the order are much more severe this and I’ve written about voked a reaction like this - world of sport. Other exam- two incidents by the same person or group of than under the original charge of harassment. those reasons previously - which begs the question why ples from business and poli- people for it to be harassment. It is for the There is up to a five-year prison sentence. and the fact remains: my courts to decide if something is harassment this and why now? Not an group have been mainly in tics are also available. If you insignificant number of easy under the Act. The courts will look at whether Furthermore, suppose the establishment is their cells with very little to really want to depress your- biking and running hours most people, or a reasonable person, would faced with someone who carefully reads the do and very few people to do self you can come up with later - this also doubles as my consider whether the behaviour in question restraining order, takes legal advice on the it with - and a few were still your own list - though I figure ‘Making Sense of Stuff’ time amounts to harassment. This is already well extent of its meaning, but pushes the interpre- experiencing the most basic you’ll throw in the towel in - I arrived at some conclu- known. We can also look at the lesser-known tation slightly too far for its liking. Again, there version of that regime. disgust long before you run sions. Then I tested those con- wording of the Act. What if, for example, we is no problem for them, but there is for us. The out of examples. clusions with someone who want to say on a public forum that a prominent CPS and police can act to bring a charge of And to my eyes they’re still knows me enough, has been prosecution witness seriously misled the court breaking the order. There need not be any in- just kids - but with a very par- And that, right there, is what in this line of work for way in such a way as to pervert the course of justice tention to actually win a guilty verdict or even ticular model of the world. I think got me: I experienced longer than me and who, I and achieve an incorrect guilty verdict? Can bring any evidence before the court at all. The Not exactly master criminals what I experienced with my believe, really knows his we fall foul of the Act even though we might prosecution simply brings an ultra-flimsy case either: most are - to my mind group AND I’m aware of this onions. be totally confident of the veracity of what we to court but presents no evidence on the day. anyway - doing time because other sh**. They’re just kids… are saying? On the face of it we cannot. We can The defendant is again formally acquitted. A they couldn’t control their not a million miles away from Most of my group of young look this up, under section 1(3)(a), which ex- new restraining order is then issued which can emotions. They are in prison mine. It’s not fair - and it’s not men were in their early 20’s empts liability for a course of conduct ‘pursued be considerably tighter than the first and close because of a crime of the right. but there were also a good for the purpose of preventing or detecting off what might have been perceived to be loop- heart in a moment in time - or number who were 19. My eld- crime’. A later Supreme Court ruling added the holes in the original. two moments in the case of a Andy Mouncey is an endur- proviso that the exemption only applies to a est son is 14 - which is only 5 second offence. I’d argue ance athlete, professional person who has acted rationally. But, you might be thinking, this is England, short years away. And as a that’s not a crime of the head coach, trainer and speaker with supposedly the best justice system in the parent that’s way too close for - it’s not thought through and since 2000 - on a prison mis- So far, so good. We have to be confident that world. Surely such a thing could never happen comfort. Now I have done it’s not organised. You want sion to help heal damaged what we are alleging is correct and that we are here? It already has. work with this age group to know what organised crime lives
Dedicated Prison Lawyers For You Over 60 years’ combined experience Money Laundering Reece Thomas Watson are specialists in Prison Law, Judicial Review, Mental Health IPP & Lifer Parole Reviews Criminal We are based in Teesside & cover all prisons in North East. Licence Recalls Appeals Our team are experts in: Independent Adjudications Proceeds Parole Boards, IPP and Lifer Reviews CSU of Crime Sentence Calculations Pre Tari Review Cat A Reviews Criminal Defence Work Recalls Independent Adjudications Lucinda Nicholls Detentions under the Mental Health Act 1983 47/49 Transfer Call Stephanie Brownlees today on Legal Aid Available for 01902 275 042 Criminal Matters Contact: Kathryn Reece-Thomas Phone: 01642 033440 0207 842 1995 Write to Lucinda at: Write: Gloucester House, 72 Church Road TS18 1TW West Midlands House, Gipsy Lane, Freepost LAWYERS Email: [email protected] Willenhall WV13 2HA www.nicholls-nicholls.com Insidetime June 2021 www.insidetime.org Comment 23
usual, I was hanging around How did you end up in again. I was released from with the wrong people and Thailand? prison cancer free. Weapons down at last started to nick cars, nicking car stereos and that sort of I went over there backpacking So what are you up to now? ‘I was sitting in Walton jail when my film premièred’ thing. And then I got into originally, then I got a job as drugs and my crimes became Sylvester Stallone’s stuntman Well, I had my first child at more serious. on Rambo III and just stayed the age of 47, a boy, so that’s Time were lucky enough to on over there. When the work my world. I’ve got a brother, speak to Billy. What kind of drugs? was finished, I got back into Joe, who has autism, and I drugs - this time it was ‘Yaba’, spend a lot of time with him. Can you tell us about your Heroin and crack, it was very which is a kind of Thai meth. I’m involved with Weapons background? prevalent in Liverpool, in fact It’s a crazy drug and I got ad- Down, Gloves Up, talking to all over the country in those dicted and started doing a bit kids about how to solve differ- Well, I grew up around Tox- days. My first arrest was for of low-level dealing to cover ences without resorting to teth and Speke in Liverpool. nicking cars and going my own habit. Then, one day, stabbing each other. I’ve My dad was very violent, equipped to steal, but when I got raided by the Thai police started my own podcast; I’ve angry, and unpredictable. He the drugs took hold, I started and, believe it or not, I got 3 got 15,000 subscriptions in was very ‘old school’ and more serious money-getting years prison for handling a six months and had 35 inter- didn’t show any love. There crimes, like burglary, robbery, stolen mobile phone. That’s esting guests. I do talks in was six of us kids, with me and plenty of violence. This is when I started writing my prison, I still get in the gym being the oldest. But my mum when I had my first taste of first book - A Prayer Before and stay active, I do therapy was great. I always felt a bit prison - I got 12-months for a Dawn - just writing it down by with other addicts. different when I was a kid, I robbery/snatch and got sent hand. Then I managed to get was lonely, always trying to to HMYOI Hindley. transferred back to the UK It sounds like you’ve really fit in and be accepted, it was and got held in HMP Wand- turned your life around. What like I was always searching What was your first impres- sworth. I was in there for advice would you give to those for friendship. sion of prison? 8-months and finished the still in prison? whole book with help from How was school for you? It was a nightmare; they were the Education Department in I think the main thing is to be still slopping out in those days the prison. selective about your life, I have to admit that I never and it was filth and stink and think long before you make a Billy Moore: winning the fi ght enjoyed school because the to make it worse I was suffering It must have been quite a feel- choice. Think about conse- school I went to wasn’t in my drug withdrawal. The days ing when your book was turned quences and think about your eventually, he reached rock own community. I had grown and nights seemed to go on into a major feature film, how family because everything we bottom, serving a sentence for up in poverty, so I got bullied forever. I promised myself, and was the premiere? do has a ripple effect that hits theft offences in Thailand. for all the obvious reasons. I Noel Smith everyone else, that I would other people. Focus. And, if These days, Billy Moore is a ended up having lots of fights, never go back to prison. I don’t know, I was sitting in you can, use your past as a much more settled man, hav- so, in order to impress my dad Walton jail again when the driving force to change. Billy Moore grew up in the ing managed to put the mer- really, as he had been a You obviously did go back, film premiered. I was released melting pot that was Toxteth ry-go-round of crime and fighter, I started boxing and what happened? on Christmas Eve 2018. I had and Speke in 1970s/80s Liver- imprisonment behind him. joined a local boxing club. It been diagnosed with cancer pool when the city had been He works hard to make turned out that I was pretty You know what it’s like, you get in 2016 and cleared of it in all but abandoned by succes- youngsters, and anyone who good and even got to fight for used to it, get complacent and 2017, and the worry of this sive governments and unem- cares to listen, aware of the England as a schoolboy. end up in that cycle. It was so had contributed to my offend- ployment and poverty were at dangers of crime and drugs. bad that at one stage I was ing. I had got a job with the high levels. Drugs were prev- He has had a major feature So when did you start to get in released from Walton jail on NHS at the time, then I under- alent and crime became a way film about his life released to trouble with the law? a Monday, and by Wednesday went 6 months of chemother- of life for many of the youths much acclaim and has just I was back in Walton. In all, I apy, I lost my hair and lost my he grew up with. He fought released his second book, That would be when I was spent around 18 or 19 years in job. I managed to beat the his way into prison and, ‘Fighting for My Life’. Inside around 15 or 16. It was the prison. cancer and then I had to start
The Johnson Partnership HCA consultancy Our dedicatedSolicitors prison law team have years of experience Putting your family first representing prisoners and fighting for their rights. when additional pressure is on. Our team ensure all prisoners nationwide can have the best representation available. Your family might be in isolation while you’re prison paying We have specialist and expert knowledge in the areas of your debt to society. If a Proceeds of Crime Order is in parole board proceedings, adjudications and other areas place the present COVID-19 crisis isn’t going to ease the such as HDC and re-categorisation. Open 7 days a week, 9am–8pm pressure on you or them. On a legal aid basis we can represent clients for: This free line allows you to leave a It falls on your family to arrange all the finances and message with your prayer request, and ensure that bills are paid. Help is at hand. Forensic Adjudication Before The Judge Licence Recalls Lifer/IPP Reviews Judicial Reviews Cat A Reviews accountants HCA Consultancy can arrange remote we commit to pray for you. For more Pre Tarriff Reviews Oral Hearings meetings with your partners via Skype, Whatsapp or details, please speak to Chaplaincy. telephone to explain how we can help resolve your We are also able to represent prison law clients on a financial commitments and make sure you repay only number of other prisons law matters for which what is required.. If your home is under threat HCA can legal aid is not available which include: help you arrange property sales or equity release so Challenging License Conditions your family’s needs are met without additional pressure Adjudications Before The Governor on you or them. Contact Us For A Quote HCA works with your legal team or can recommend professionals who are experts in this field. Help can also Prison Law Department Call to me, be available in obtaining funds for your case. The service is unique. Call 0115 9419141 and I will 24 Hours a day An initial consultation is free. But time is of the essence. answer you. You need to move quickly. To set up a remote meeting call 7 days a week Nottingham Office Jeremiah 33:3 HCA today. There is no commitment on your part but J Cannon Courtyeard P HCA can relieve the pressure on your family. Off Long Row Email us on: [email protected] Nottingham, NG1 6JE Charity Registered in Call us on: 07469 859 854 available 24/7 [email protected] England & Wales No 1102254 69 Ringley Road, Whitefield, Manchester M45 7LH OFFICES NATIONWIDE 24 Comment www.insidetime.org Insidetime June 2021 Tales of Wisdom Inside Voices Fighting for privacy
Christian Barabutu - HMP Whitemoor disproportionate, on the other hand, the ap- peal judges concluded that such a person, medical officer, conducting such tasks was the In early 2020 I was being denied the opportu- least invasive measure available and was not nity to communicate with NHS England under excessive, therefore overturning the ruling. Confidential Access. Prison rules state that as a prisoner, my medical information and re- It would be a breach of cords are private, staff cannot touch nor have access to such information. But, for some bi- patient confidentiality if zarre reason, if I’m required to or wish to com- anything discovered or disclosed Don’t bite… © Deposit Photos municate with NHS England, I must allow my to a healthcare professional letter to be read first by prison officers. Sid Arter calm and composed. crowd said, “If I refused to by a patient is disclosed to a Eventually the protester, feel- accept the gift then it would Clearly, such procedures infringe on Article 8 third party. The only exception ing that they had made their continue to be yours.” of the Human Rights Act, and the reading of The gifts point departed. A number of such letters, if necessary, should only be con- is when such information other stallholders and mem- The stallholder nodded and ducted by medical officers and individuals threatens the safety of A market stallholder was bers of the public immediately said, “People may decide to bound by duties of medical confidence. This working one day selling her gathered around the stall and waste their time giving insults led me to filing a civil claim challenging these individuals and others. meat-based pies and pastries offered their support and and making verbal attacks, actions. The MoJ then filed for a strike-out of However, in relation to my proceedings, the when a shopper approached asked the stallholder why she and we can choose whether my claim and a request that it is certified as reading of my confidential medical corre- her and started to rant and had let the stranger abuse her we want to accept them or ‘totally without merit’. They accepted that the spondence was carried out by those third par- rave about her produce. The in such a way. not, just as we would with any opening and reading of letters addressed to ties not bound by medical-in-confidence and shopper protested that sell- other gift. If you take the in- NHS England, if proven, may amount to an therefore amounted to invasive measures. At ing meat was not only very The stallholder smiled and sults and attacks you are ac- the time, the prison failed in its duty under bad for people to eat, its pro- asked the small crowd, “If I cepting them. And if not, who- interference of the Right to Respect…for cor- Article 8 to appoint a medical officer to inspect duction was ruining the plan- gave you a gift such as a silk ever insults you is simply left respondence in Article 8(1) of the Human my letters, if such inspections were necessary et and meat eating is animal scarf or a basket of fine soaps with the insult in their own Rights Act. However, they claimed it was jus- at all. Prison Service standard 22 requires that cruelty. The protester let loose but you refused to accept or hands.” tified because, in their view, it was in accord- medical information is managed in accordance a tirade of abuse and offen- take the gift, who would the ance with the law and Prison Service with relevant legislation and the NHS code of sive comments. However, the scarf or soaps belong to?” The Instructions 41/2011 set out detailed, clear and practise on confidentiality. It would be a stallholder responded by crowd were silent at first and accessible rules on the confidential handling Sid Arter is a teacher and breach of patient confidentiality if anything saying nothing and staying eventually a young man in the entertainer of prisoner correspondence, and those ar- discovered or disclosed to a healthcare profes- rangements do not apply to letters sent to NHS sional by a patient is disclosed to a third party. England. They then pleaded that any interfer- The only exception is when such information ence pursued legitimate aims, namely the threatens the safety of individuals and others. prevention of crime and disorder, protection Therefore, the only way of meeting the correct of the freedom of others and so on, blah, blah, balance is by appointing a medical officer, or blah. Really? to refer such letters to healthcare staff for National Prison Law Solicitors inspection. My counterargument is as follows - in the case www.instalaw.co.uk of R(SZULUK) v Governor of HMP Full Sutton I also expressed to the courts the fact that I [2004] all ER(D) 419 (Oct), the Judge in that tried very hard to engage with the prison on this matter through the internal complaints case, Collins J, found that correspondence We have over 25 Prison Law Experts who can help you with: system, even the IMB had input in attempting with an NHS consultant regarding an existing to get the prison to answer my complaint. The • Parole Board oral hearings • Breach of Data Protection medical condition should be treated as invio- prison refused to respond. But, funnily lable. Even though this decision was later • Paper Parole Reviews • False Imprisonment enough, when the court proceedings were overturned by the Appeal Court, this condi- lodged, the prison started assigning my med- • Recalls • Independent Adjudications tion was only overturned due to the fact that ical correspondence to medical staff to inspect. • Judicial Review • Private cases (Transfer/HDC) the findings of Collins J was in relation to per- I find it ridiculous for the MoJ to imply that •- MandatoryPersonal LifersInjury/Workplace accidents + more mitting the prison medical officer to read such correspondence with NHS England would be correspondence, which Collins J found to be sinister if not read by prison staff.
Call us today for free advice on: 01782 560 155 To get started please write to Award winning Higher Carla Riozzi, Eden Legal Services, Nottingham office: Instalaw, 4th Floor Parliament House, Court Advocate Carla West Midlands House 42 - 46 Upper Parliament Street, Nottingham, NG1 2AG Gipsy Lane, Willenhall WV13 2HA Riozzi specialising in please include: Staffordshire office: Instalaw, 2nd Floor Copthall House, King Street, Parole and recall • Name Newcastle-under-Lyme, Staffordshire, ST5 1UE • Prisoner No • Prison Location Carla Riozzi is a Higher Court Solicitor-Advocate based in the Advice in relation to: Winners of Law Society’s Law Firm of the Year 2019 Midlands specialising in successfully representing prisoners at • Recall Parole Board Oral Hearings for life, IPP, determinate and recalled • Cat A Review prisoners. She also represents prisoners at Independent • Pre-tarrif Review Winners of Client Care Initiative of the Year 2019 Adjudications, Category A reviews and pre-tari Parole reviews. • Independant Adjudication • Parole Carla was previously awarded Leicestershire Law Society's Young Solicitor of the year due to her commitment to • Other (please note, other cases prisoner's rights and her international work undertaken with require a privately funded xed fee prisoners detained abroad. (quote provided)
O ce telephone: 01902 275042 email: [email protected] Insidetime June 2021 www.insidetime.org Comment 25
Concepts regards forms of monitoring and regulation - The research draws upon and enhances a Norway’s dimension score is significantly framework that has recently been developed higher than England & Wales’s score. In Eng- by Ben Crewe and colleagues to conceptualise land & Wales, for example, 75% of prisoners different aspects of the prison experience.In agreed with the item: ‘I have to be careful brief, ‘depth’ refers mainly to matters of secu- about everything I do in this prison, or it can rity, control and the various sensations of feel- be used against me’, compared to 58% in Nor- ing a long way from freedom; ‘weight’ relates way; 36% with the item: ‘This prison is trying mainly to interpersonal treatment and condi- to mess with my head’, compared to 22% in tions, and levels of oppressiveness; ‘tightness’ Norway. seeks to capture the reach, grip and invasive- ness of forms of psychological power; and Overall, while the results are indisputably ‘breadth’ refers to the reach and impact of the more positive in Norway than in England & sentence beyond prison, for example, restric- Wales - supporting the claim that punishment tions and the forms of stigma that ex-prisoners practices in Norway are more humane - there experience on release. At the same time, the is equally no doubt that pain and suffering are research also foregrounds the roles of shame still integral to the prisoner experience in Nor- and guilt in shaping prisoners’ attitudes and way. In the sections that follow, we move on adaptations to imprisonment. We obtained to discuss more specific findings. 1,082 surveys from prisoners in England & Wales and Norway, alongside 728 in-depth Differences between Open and Closed interviews, working in over 20 prisons. prisons Bastoy prison island – we all get along The differences between the two jurisdictions Credit: Dr Sarah Lewis Feedback are much greater in relation to open prisons Throughout the research process, we thought than closed prisons. Indeed, comparing peo- long and hard about how to do comparative ple held in closed prisons in the two jurisdic- Norway v England and Wales work across different countries. Our deci- tions, the scores are only marginally more sion-making was shaped throughout by our positive in Norway. In contrast, the compari- Research on prisoners’ experiences from Norway and ambition to assess the typical experiences of son of open prisons between the two countries England & Wales - which is best? particular prisoner groups - that is, what it is shows significantly more positive scores in like in each jurisdiction to serve a sentence - Norway. While it might be noted that the Nor- Anna Schliehe exceptionalism thesis - put at its simplest, the rather than treat the institution as the key axis wegian sample comprises a much greater pro- idea that punishment practices in the Nordic of comparison. In other words, rather than portion of prisoners in open prisons than the (inclusionary) countries are more liberal and trying to compare prisons of equal size in the England & Wales sample (36% compared to The Comparative Penology Group (COMPEN) humane than those in neo-liberal (exclusion- two jurisdictions, we sought to include prisons 9%), these figures roughly correspond with the based at the Prisons Research Centre (Univer- that were of a typical size within their ary) nations like England & Wales or the US. proportion of prisoners in each system who are sity of Cambridge) has been working on a re- country. held in such conditions. Indeed, in Norway, We want to use this platform in Inside Time to search project since 2016 titled: ‘Penal an estimated 50% of the prison population feedback various findings from different policymaking and the prisoner experience: a Our goal in this first article is to feedback from spends at least some time in an open estab- sub-studies in the coming months and will comparative analysis’ which is funded by the some general comparative findings. Overall, lishment, compared to an estimated 5% in European Research Council. At its core, the start here with an overview of the project and the basic pattern of our results is clear and England & Wales. project aims to interrogate the Nordic some broad statistical findings. consistent. On all but one of the dimensions, the results for Norwegian prisons are signifi- The experience of remand in Norway cantly higher - which means better - than for One of the main criticisms of imprisonment in those in England & Wales, often by a very con- Norway is that prisoners on remand are placed siderable degree. This means that, as judged in conditions that are highly restrictive - sim- by prisoners themselves, on the whole the ilar to solitary confinement. When we compare experience of imprisonment is not as painful those on remand and sentenced in closed con- in Norway as it is in England & Wales. ditions in Norway, the scores are more negative for remand compared to sentenced. Bearing in Wrongly convicted Statements of truth mind that those held on remand are not yet of a crime? To provide some examples of ‘weight’: in Nor- convicted of any offence, and that they account way, 60% of prisoners agreed with the state- for around one-third of the Norwegian prison ment: ‘I feel cared about most of the time in population, our results lend support to the this prison’, compared to 29% in England & claim that it is the ‘presumed innocent’ who Wales. Almost two-thirds of prisoners in Nor- experience their imprisonment as most pain- way (66%) disagreed with the statement: ‘I am ful. However, the experience of being a remand Lost your appeal? not treated as a human being in here’, com- prisoner in Norway compared to England & pared to just under half (48%) in England & Wales is relatively similar. Wales, while the proportion of prisoners who agreed that: ‘My living conditions in this Conclusion prison are poor’ was considerably higher in Overall, while the survey findings are broadly England & Wales (45%) compared to Norway consistent with the conclusions we drew about What next? (21%). For the item: ‘This system treats me the ‘texture’ of each prison system from our more like a number than a person’, 63% of qualitative data, if anything, we were sur- prisoners agreed in England & Wales com- prised not to find more substantial differences pared to 41% in Norway, while 26% of prison- between the survey results for closed prisons ers in England & Wales agreed that: ‘Generally, in England & Wales and Norway. Here, it is I fear for my physical safety’, compared to 13% worth noting that while researchers tend to The CCRC can look again in Norway. compare jurisdictions, prisoners are very If you think your conviction or sentence is wrong rarely making such judgments. Rather, they apply to the CCRC Which is best? evaluate their current circumstances by con- • It won’t cost anything Prisoners in Norway also reported consistently trasting them to what life was like immediately • Your sentence can’t be increased if you apply more favourably than those in England & before: custody is compared to freedom; open • You don't need a lawyer to apply, but a good one Wales on many aspects of ‘depth’: 66% of pris- prisons are compared to closed; and assess- can help oners in England & Wales agreed with the ments of the quality of treatment are shaped statement: ‘I feel cut off from the outside world by standards that are taken for granted in con- You can get some more information and a copy of the in here’ compared to 56% in Norway, while, texts beyond the prison. CCRC's Easy Read application form by writing to us at 5 St Philip’s Place, Birmingham, B3 2PW. or calling 0121 233 1473 for the item: “Wherever I am in this prison, I still feel confined’ 62% of prisoners in England Anna Schliehe - (on behalf of the COMPEN Prisoners in Scotland should contact; The Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission, 5th Floor, & Wales agreed, compared to 45% in Norway. research team Ben Crewe, Alice Levins, Julie Portland House, 17 Renfi eld Street, Glasgow, G2 5AH. Phone: 0141 270 7030 Email: [email protected] For the dimension ‘tightness’ - much of which Laursen, Kristian Mjåland) 26 Comment www.insidetime.org Insidetime June 2021
A friend to Eric McGraw: “This is such sad news. Our thoughts are with Eric’s family, friends, colleagues and all the friendless an appreciation those supported and uplifted by his work.” Unlock Legendary Inside Time John O’Connor - Journalist columnist Terry Waite “What a remarkable legacy. With the deepest sympathies of all at Clinks to Eric’s reflects on his and our It’s almost 20 years since I first made contact family, friends and those who carry on his with Eric McGraw. And it was with his strong dear friend’s passing tremendous work at Inside Time.” encouragement that I soon became a regular Anne Fox (Clinks CEO) I first met Eric when I was re- contributor to Inside Time (fifty plus feature leased from captivity some articles so far). Over the years we became good “When we founded National Prison Radio thirty years ago. He felt that friends, which continued long after I had been in 2009, we took enormous inspiration and given my experience of incar- released from prison. Then we would occasion- learning from the Inside Time model that ceration as a hostage I might ally meet at criminal justice-related events, Eric established. This is terribly sad news. be able to make a contribution and sometimes Eric would ask me to cover for His legacy is immense. RIP.” to Inside Time. I accepted and him at an event after accidentally committing Prison Radio Association was a columnist on this news- himself to be elsewhere. And now, two decades paper for many years. Eric later, I have to accept the fact that Eric is no “So sorry to read this sad news. Eric was was indeed a ‘one off’ charac- longer with us. quite simply a lovely man.” Eric – a true life enhancer ter. Deeply intelligent with an Prof David Wilson infectious humour he was But what he achieved in his lifetime will re- able to make friendships “So sad to read this. Eric was an absolute main his enduring legacy. For Eric, uniquely, which ranged from the Duke gent and an inspiration. Inside Time is such The Last Farewell gave prisoners something they had never had of Edinburgh to many a pris- a valuable legacy, bringing news, views, in- before - a voice. This is something even the A tribute to Eric McGraw, Director of New Bridge (1986- oner languishing in UK pris- formation and most importantly hope to so great penal reformers - John Howard, Elizabeth 2002) and founder of Inside Time (1990) ons. In the best traditions of many. I have often left my copy on public Fry, and more recently Lord Longford - were journalism, through Inside transport open on the poems page for a It was with much sadness that New Bridge prisoners, volunteers, Time he was able to give a never able to achieve. This is not to belittle random person to read.” staff and trustees received news of Eric McGraw’s death on 18 voice to the voiceless and en- their pioneering work: it is simply to place into Nina Champion April 2021. Many of us have fond memories of Eric as a larger courage those who recog- context the significance of what Eric achieved (Director of Criminal Justice Alliance) than life character and raconteur who was a passionate cham- nised that they had made a when creating a voice for the voiceless. “Oh no, such sad news. Eric had an amaz- pion of prisoners’ rights. Eric helped many prisoners to maintain mess of their lives. Eric was a ing commitment to rehabilitating people precious contact with the outside world through visiting New true friend to the friendless For me, Eric’s most endearing personal char- back to life after the dark days inside. He Bridge befrienders, besides making sure that they were kept and a great humanitarian. acteristic was his wonderful sense of humour. was always a pleasure to work with.” well-informed, and had a voice, in the pages of the prison Perhaps this was an essential attribute when Andy Aitchison (photographer) newspaper he founded. dealing with the many obstacles he encoun- “Eric helped an immeasur- tered when interacting with the more Neander- able number of people & “I’m so sorry to hear of the death of Eric Eric was the director of New Bridge for some sixteen years (1986- thal-minded bureaucrats at Prison Service HQ. 2002) and the inspiration for ‘Inside Time’, the newspaper for families through his work. McGraw - a lovely man who did so much Yet at a local level within the confines of the prisoners which New Bridge launched in December 1990 and Inside Time is an impor- good for people affected by prison and was many prisons he visited he was made welcome which has been a huge success ever since. As Eric recalled, the tant outlet & gives a voice a champion for prisoners voices. Sharing reason for its launch was simple. “I went almost every day to to people in prison. The by staff and prisoners alike, such was his cha- condolences from all of us at Prison Advice the Lord Woolf Inquiry into the Strangeways riots,” he said, newspaper itself is a life- risma. Given his background with the United to his family, friends and co-workers. “And what came across very clearly was that prisoners did not line to hundreds of thou- Nations, this may explain why Eric was also Requiescat in Pace.” feel they had a voice. So I contacted the Prison Service and asked sands every year & helps an inveterate traveller - resulting in many in- Andy Keen-Downs (CEO of Pact) if it would be interested in me setting up a newspaper for pris- them to feel more con- teresting articles emerging about life in prisons oners - to which the answer was yes.” The first issue numbered nected & valued. Thank in other countries. “Eric was a great friend and supporter of 12,000 copies and was distributed to prisons, young offender you Eric.” PRG and we’ll miss him - his wit, his sarto- institutions and special hospitals around the country. Today, Phil Martin (Author and Without doubt the driving force behind Eric rial dash and his absolute commitment to keeping prisoners alert and informed Inside Time has a print circulation of over 60,000 and thou- former prisoner) was his determination to ensure that each edi- through good journalism.” sands of visitors to its website every month. tion of Inside Time had in it something of in- Prison Reading Groups “A man of deep compas- terest to its broad range of readers. But there sion and boundless energy. Eric was also a keen supporter and member of the Inside Justice was one occasion when I couldn’t complete an Advisory Panel, a charity conducting investigations on behalf I will forever be grateful “We are really sorry to hear the sad news article he was expecting because my beloved of people who claim they have been wrongly convicted. for all he did for me. A about Eric McGraw. He was a great champion quiet man who walked electric typewriter had finally given up the of our work and an important innovator in We, the volunteers, staff and trustees at New Bridge, including giant steps in the corridors ghost. No sooner had Eric heard of this than the movement to give prisoners a voice - a those prisoners and former prisoners who knew him, send our of power.” within a matter of days he had a replacement commitment we proudly share. Our heartfelt condolences to his wife, Svetlana, and his family. Eric Ben Gunn machine sent directly to me. So I got a new thoughts are with his family and friends.” leaves a very special legacy in the annals of New Bridge and the (former prisoner) typewriter and Eric got his article (and many Koestler Arts pages of Inside Time. more thereafter).