Gastropoda, Caenogastropoda
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
B2016-14-Kronenberg:Basteria-2015 9/7/2016 10:21 PM Page 82 Revision of Euprotomus Gill, 1870. 5 1. A third putative hybrid in Euprotomus (Gastropoda , Caenogastropoda) with some additional remarks on hybridization in Euprotomus Gijs C. Kronenberg Associate, Naturalis Biodiversity Center , P.O. Box 9517, NL-2300 RA Leiden, The Netherlands; [email protected] E. chrysostomus Kuroda, 1942 , by Liverani (2002). The A putative hybrid Euprotomus aratrum (Röding, 1798) third combination, E. bulla x E. aratrum has been listed 82 x E. bulla (Röding, 1798) is reported upon. It is com - by Kronenberg (2008b: Table 1) as a unique record. pared with the two supposed parental species. Some This listing was based on a photograph made avail - additional remarks on putative Euprotomus hybrids able by Jean-Pierre Barbier (Cebu, Philippines ) of a are made . specimen collected at North Palawan (Coron Island), but that specimen was not discussed in detail. Kronen - Key words: Euprotomus aratrum , Euprotomus bulla , hybridization, berg (2008b) however , overlooked the specimen illus - Indo-Pacific . trated that same year in Kronenberg (2008a: pl. 230 fig. 6a, b); after re-examination of the image it turned out 1 For no. 4 in this series see: Kronenberg, G.C. & Harzhauser, M., that this specimen also appears to be a hybrid of 2012. Europrotomus (Mollusca: Caenogastropoda: Strombidae): a E. aratrum x E. bulla. A putative case of hybridization new Middle Miocene European strombid genus. – Paläontologis - involving a species of Euprotomus reported by Thach che Zeitschrift 86 (2): 147-159. (2007) has been dismissed by Kronenberg (2008b), who, based on the illustration of the specimen (Thach, 2007: 18, fig. 39), concluded that the specimen was a Introduction malformed E. aratrum (Röding, 1798). In 2012 Dr. Nguyen Ngoc Thach (Nha Trang City, Putative cases of hybridization in Indo-Pacific strom - Vietnam ) made some images available of what at first bids have been documented for a large number of glance seemed to be a specimen of E. aratrum . cases [for a preliminary overview see Kronenberg Dr. Thach however , already noted that there were (2008b) – but since then more cases have been re - some remarkable differences with E. aratrum . And in - ported, for an overview see Liverani (2013: 5) ]. So far, deed, upon closer examination of the images, the spec - three putative combinations of parental species form - imen could not be identified as that species with ing hybrids have been reported within the genus certainty. Provisionally it was identified as E. aratrum Euprotomus Gill, 1870 (Kronenberg, 2008b). Two of x E. bulla . Subsequently , Dr. Thach made the specimen these combinations have been discussed, viz. E. vomer available for examination. The results are presented (Röding, 1798) x E. bulla (Röding, 1798) (erroneously below. I also take the opportunity to illustrate for the described as Strombus hirasei Kuroda, 1942 ) by Kro - first time the specimen mentioned in Table 1 by nenberg (1999; 2002) and Dekkers (2012) , and E. bulla x Kronenberg (2008b) . Basteria 80 (1-3): 82-88 (2016) B2016-14-Kronenberg:Basteria-2015 9/7/2016 10:21 PM Page 83 Descriptive part tural direction. When fully grown , the cavity thus formed is filled with callus and subsequent thin layers Class Gastropoda Cuvier, 1795 of callus cover the rim of the outer lip , resulting in a Subclass Caenogastropoda Cox, 1960 subangled outer lip with a glaze. Anterior canal rather Order Littorinimorpha Golikov & Starobogatov, 1975 long, curved addorsally, (almost) perpendicular to the Superfamily Stromboidea Rafinesque, 1815 shell axis. Between the thickened outer lip and the pro - Family Strombidae Rafinesque, 1815 jection , a low, very poorly developed secondary notch is present. On the adapertural side of the outer lip, a Euprotomus Gill, 1870 few poorly developed to very faint plicae are present on the adapical part; at the point of attachment to the Euprotomus bulla x Euprotomus aratrum (Figs 1- 10) spire there is a shallow canal. Adapertural side be - Euprotomus bulla (Röding, 1798) – Kronenberg 2008a: pl. 120 figs tween strombid notch and anterior canal with a few 6a-b . poorly developed plicae. Colour pattern very variable Euprotomus bulla x E. aratrum – Kronenberg 2008b: 332 [Table 1]. [see illustrations herein and Kronenberg in Poppe (2008a: pl. 120 fig. 6a-b) and discussion below]. All Diagnosis . ― Adult shell with one digit at the adapi - three specimens share a dark brown callus deposit on cal part of the outer lip, more or less parallel to the the spire, the rim on the outer lip at the digit-like ex - shell’s axis, with columellar and parietal callus well tension, and the part of the outer lip attachment to the developed, slightly thicker at adbasal part of the last spire and near the stromboid notch. whorl, apex and part of the spire covered with a dark Known records. ― So far only three specimens are brown callus deposit. known, viz. (1) Philippines, near Palawan at about 3 m Description. ― Adult shells with characters typi - depth ; (2) Philippines, Olango Island at 10 m; and (3) cal of species attributed to the genus Euprotomus Gill, Vietnam, off Nha Trang, at unknown depth. These 1870, measuring about 62-71 mm in length , with specimens are kept in the collections of , respectively , about eight teleoconch whorls; the number of nuclear Jean-Pierre Barbier (Cebu) and Guido T. Poppe (Cebu) , whorls unknown. The first two to five teleoconch and the author’s private collection (no. 6416). The latter whorls more or less extensively covered by the callus, specimen will be deposited in Naturalis Biodiversity thereby obscuring the sculpture. First teleoconch Center (Leiden) at some point in the future. 83 whorls with fine axial and spiral cords, resulting in a reticulate sculpture. From the third whorl onwards Discussion the axial cords gradually develop into ribs, overlaid by the spiral sculpture. Simultaneously a subsutural All three specimens appear to have a mixture of char - cord develops, broader than the other spiral cords. acters of both E. bulla and E. aratrum , although they On this cord an axially sculpture persists, but in other differ remarkably from one another. A difference spiral cords the axials gradually turn obsolete. From with E. aratrum is the extensive callus deposit, reach - the third or fourth whorl onwards a row of knobs on ing the apex and covering a (large) part of the apex the shoulder develops, gradually increasing in size. and initial post nuclear whorls, which much more re - Last whorl with an extensive callus on the adaper - sembles E. bulla . tural side, slightly thicker at the adbasal side, obscur - The colour of the callus deposits on the ventral ing about 45% of sculpture of the total of the last side of the shells shows a great variability. The speci - whorl. On the last whorl there are about 11 knobs ; on men in the Barbier collection is most reminiscent of E. the ventral side of the shell the knobs are covered by bulla . It is white except for (1) a patch with a light or - the callus, more or less obscuring their presence. ange hue near the adapical part of the columella, and Abapical of this row of knobs spiral cords are present, (2) the spire callus , which is dark brown (Figs 1-4) . with two cords being broader, bearing low knobs. A The specimen in the Poppe collection is intermediate third cord of intermediate broadness may be present in that character (see Kronenberg , 2008 a: pl. 230 fig. (Figs 6 -8), but this third cord can also be absent (Figs 6a) and the specimen in the Kronenberg collection 2-4). Suture of last whorl acutely curved adapically (Fig. 5) is much closer to E. aratrum . Another differ - and crossing the suture of the penultimate whorl. ence with E. aratrum is the much paler colouration of Outer lip not broadly expanded, with a distinct, the extended columellar callus where the outer lip is deep, stromboid notch and a projection at the adapical attached to the columella. This columellar callus is part, slightly diverging from the shell’s axis, reaching whitish in the Kronenberg specimen, contrary to E. beyond the apex. At early adult stage the rim of the aratrum where this patch is always dark, even in the outer lip, abapically of the projection and adapically of palest specimens. The Barbier and Poppe specimens the stromboid notch , is slightly curved into adaper - are less prominently coloured and do not show this Kronenberg, G.C. – A third putative hybrid in Euprotomus B2016-14-Kronenberg:Basteria-2015 9/7/2016 10:21 PM Page 84 character clearly. The colour of the aperture is much Unfortunately, like all other cases of presumed hy - more intense orange as is usually the case in E. ara - bridization in Indo-Pacific Strombidae (Kronenberg, trum , which usually is (much) paler. Only exception - 2008 b), there is no definite proof of it . The animal of a ally the colour of specimens of E. aratrum may reach specimen that was considered to represent a putative the same intensity. Also the sculpture and colour pat - case of hybridization in a specimen of Lambis compa - tern of the dorsal side of the specimen differ slightly rable to specimens figured in De Turck et al. (1999: pl. from that in E. aratrum . 30 fig. 3) and Kronenberg (2008a: pl. 210 figs 1a, 1b) As far as the colour pattern of the shell is con - has become available for examination. Preliminary re - cerned, the pattern of the shell in the collection Kro - sults of the dissection of that specimen showed that its nenberg (Figs. 5- 8) is most reminiscent of E. aratrum , anatomy differs from either of the putative parent with the irregular of light brown speckles and mot - species and, surprisingly, not being intermediate (Si - tling on a cream background.