Pennard Action Group Report 1.1 Final
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Gr ŵp Gweithredu Pennard Pennard Action Group’s Report re. the LA's proposal to close Pennard Library “Culture is not a luxury: its importance is a vital element of everyone's life.” Pennard Action Group Report Contents Report Overview ......................................................................................................... 4 Purpose .................................................................................................................... 4 Content .................................................................................................................... 4 Contributors ............................................................................................................. 4 Report Author ........................................................................................................... 4 Contact: .................................................................................................................... 4 Recommendations ................................................................................................... 4 1. Introduction ........................................................................................................... 5 2. The LA’s Rationale for Closing Pennard Library ................................................... 5 3. The Context of Pennard Library............................................................................ 5 4. The LA’s Statutory Obligations ................................................................................ 7 4.1 The Minister’s expectation is that: ...................................................................... 7 4.2 WPLS 1: Location of Service Points and Access to Them ............................. 7 4.3 Swansea Library Audit 2012-2013 ................................................................. 8 4.4 Key Delivery Areas ........................................................................................ 8 4.5 Library Buildings ............................................................................................ 8 4.5.1 Grants for Building Refurbishment .................................................................. 9 4.5.2 The Morriston-Llansamlet Conundrum ............................................................ 9 4.6 United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child ....................................... 9 4.7 The Case of the: Proposed closure of Eastham Library in relation to the Inquiry Terms of Reference and the Libraries Act 1964 ..................................................... 10 5. Rural Deprivation ................................................................................................ 10 5.1 Welsh Index of Multiple Deprivation 2011 ........................................................ 10 5.2 The Impact Equality Assessment (EIA) ............................................................ 12 5.3 Digital Deprivation ............................................................................................ 12 6. City and County of Swansea Policy Documents ................................................... 12 6.1 Annual Review of Performance 2012-2013 ...................................................... 12 6.2 Libraries Inspire : the Strategic Development Framework for Welsh Libraries 2012-16 .................................................................................................................. 13 6.3 Labour Manifesto ............................................................................................. 13 6.4 Swansea’s Corporate Improvement Plan 2013-17 ........................................... 14 7. Statistical Comparisons and Data Analysis ........................................................... 15 7.1 Comparisons between Pennard and Llansamlet: April -Sept 2013 .................. 15 7.2 Population and Density .................................................................................... 15 7.3 Library Statistics ............................................................................................... 15 7.4 Footfall, Issues, Requests and Library Income ................................................ 15 7.5 Summary of Pennard and Llansamlet Comparisons ........................................ 16 7.6 New Users in Pennard ..................................................................................... 16 7.7 Geography of Pennard and Llansamlet ............................................................ 16 7.8 Opening Hours of Pennard and Llansamlet ..................................................... 17 7.9 Books issued in Swansea Libraries According to Population Density: 2012 - 2013 ....................................................................................................................... 17 7.10 Computer Usage ............................................................................................ 18 2 8. Potential Solutions and Recommendations ........................................................... 18 8.1 Avoiding Closure .............................................................................................. 18 8.2 Reducing Opening Hours Across the Library Service ...................................... 18 8.3 Extension Period to Consider Options ............................................................. 18 8.4 Failure of Community Volunteer Model ............................................................ 18 8.5 One-Stop-Shop Model ..................................................................................... 19 8.6 Accessing Available Grants ............................................................................. 19 8.7 UNCRC: Children’s Voice ................................................................................ 19 8.8 Rehousing Options ........................................................................................... 19 8.9 Costs of Decommissioning the Building ........................................................... 19 9. Appendices ........................................................................................................... 20 Appendix 1a: Books issued per library, per person, per year, highlighting library positions ................................................................................................................. 20 Appendix 1b: Book issues per library, per person, per year, based on No. of registered users ..................................................................................................... 21 Appendix 2: Number of books issued per person per visit ..................................... 22 Appendix 3a, 3b, 3c: Percentage of population based number of registered users per library et al ....................................................................................................... 23 Appendix 4: Best ratio of computers available per registered user ........................ 24 Appendix 5: Digital Deprivation .............................................................................. 25 Appendix 6: Health, Well-being and social benefits ............................................... 26 3 Pennard Action Group Report Report Overview Purpose To present the case for keeping Pennard Library open with the current librarian led service, whilst offering other financial solutions for saving c. £36,400 per annum from the LA’s budget. Content The report contains comment on: • the LA’s rationale for proposing to close Pennard Library; • the context of Pennard Library; • the statutory obligations of the Local Authority regarding Pennard Library; • rural deprivation; • the LA’s policies which cannot be implemented if the library closes; • statistical comparisons and data analysis; • potential solutions and recommendations. Contributors John Algar, Jude Davies, Rhian Ferguson, Susan Geary, Lynda James, Gillian Kearney Report Author Sarah Joiner Recommendations It is recommended that the LA notes this report and gives comment regarding its potential solutions and recommendations at a meeting with the Pennard Action Group and Community Council. Contact: Councillor Lynda James Mobile: 07789816374 Email: [email protected] 4 Pennard Action Group Report 1. Introduction 1.1 The City and County of Swansea (LA) has proposed the closure of Pennard Library in order to rationalise the library network and deliver budgetary savings of c. £36,400 per annum out of the LA’s budget. 1.2 The LA is also exploring the viability of other options: for example, a volunteer led service and housing the library either in the existing building, the community centre or the school (see Steve Hardman’s EIA report and 8.10). 2. The LA’s Rationale for Closing Pennard Library 2.1 The LA followed the decision making process below in ear-marking Pennard for closure: • Three libraries were identified as having dilapidated building stock: Pennard (category D), Sketty (category D) and Fforestfach (category C). See 4.5 for the report’s comments on this; • The LA then proposed that Pennard should close, as based on their calculations it had lower footfall than Sketty and Fforestfach. However, these figures do not take into account population density, which shows Pennard far more favourably than Sketty and Fforestfach. (See appendix 1a. for the relevant data.) The LA believed that there would be a “lower impact” on the Gower community if Pennard closed. 3. The Context of Pennard Library 3.1 Pennard Library is the only library on the Gower Peninsula. It serves a rural community, which is already deprived (in the bottom