LOW ENERGY PIONS in NUCLEAR PHYSICS Mannque Rho
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
LOW ENERGY PIONS IN NUCLEAR PHYSICS Mannque Rho To cite this version: Mannque Rho. LOW ENERGY PIONS IN NUCLEAR PHYSICS. Journal de Physique Colloques, 1972, 33 (C5), pp.C5-155-C5-169. 10.1051/jphyscol:1972512. jpa-00215114 HAL Id: jpa-00215114 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00215114 Submitted on 1 Jan 1972 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE Calloque C5, supplement au no 8-9, Tome 33, ~oOt-Septembre 1972, page C5-155 LOW ENERGY PIONS IN NUCLFAR PHYSICS Mannque RiiO Service de Physique Theorique, CEN-Saclay - France Rdsumd - On discute d'une faqon unifide 1es effets despiuns virtuels en physique nu- c- et l'rnteraction dwpions r&ls avec les noyaux & basse dnergie en termes du th&oreme de pions mous. Lcs sujets trait& de cette manihre sont les sufvants : les phd- nomisnes de courant d'echange, les rcgles de some reliant ceux-ci aux quantitds mesurdescims lesexperiences a haute hergie, la production, l'absorption et la diffusion despions par 1.2s noyaux prhs du seuil, et Itextraction & partir des donndes d'atomes X-m8siques des il~formationssur la symktrie chirakbrisec dans l'inter~ctionforte. Abstract - The effect of virtual pions in low-energy properties of nuclei and the inter- action wxth nuclei of low-energy real pions are discussed in terms of the information extracted from the exact soft-pion limit. The subjects treated in this way are the exchange current phenomena, the sum rules connecting these to quantities measurable in high energy sxperiments, the production, absorption and scattering of pions near threshold, and the extraction from x-mcsic data of an Information on the rhiral symmetry breaking in strong rnteract ion Hamiltonfan. I - IE*"TROWCTION - The pion was predicted in 1935 on the longest range part of it. Thus the pion by Yukawa and discovered in the laboratory in 1947. plays an essential role here just as the small mass It fs now well-known that just as the photon media- of pion plays a crucial role in the theories of tes the atomic and molecular forces, the pion me- elementary particle physics. The aim of this talk diates the nuclear force, responsible mainly for is to discuss the relevance of pions to nuclear the long range part. The pion mediating such force physics in as unified manner as it is possible to- is virtual just as the photon mediating the atomic day. Let me first explain what I mean by a unified and molecular forces is. However a pion can also be ma.-iner. The pion is a pseudoscalar object, spin produced if sufficient energy is given or it can be zero and parity-1 and may be described besides its absorbed by releasing energy. We say that the pion quantum numbers by the mmentum four vector -* invalved in this Latter process is real, i.e., on qk= (q i ) . A real plon satisfies the mass-shell q0 its mass shell.Just as the real photon has no mass, condition the pion 1s almost massless, in any case the smal- q2 = q2-q2 :-m2 . (1) lest among the known hadrons. This fact is quite X imf)ortant as we shall see later. The non-zero mass, However a virtual pion need not satisfy this. In however small it may br, turns out to raise many fact one defines a virtual pion by the fact that 2 2 interesting questions. For these reasons, even after q differs front -m7[. Suppose a pion is exchanged so many years of research on pions, we still try to between two nucleons as in a two-nualeon scattering learn more about them and will continue to do so. process of Fig.1. Here the pion is space-like. This means simply that in my metric qL: is a positive Nuclear Physics bas developed on the con- quantity. Now if all the nucleons are inside a nu- cept of potential. Much of low-energy properties cleus (in other words, within the Fermi sea), then studied in nuclear laboratories depend intimately Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphyscol:1972512 even by a virtual pion. Nevertheless this one plays a very important role for pion physics and has also a great deal of relevance even for interactigns with nuclei. The point corresponding to q =m 0 T( and lGl= 0 evidently describes a real pion at, rest and we call it the threshold. A pion being ex- changed in a nucleus docs not have well-defined 121, and qo . They range over a considerable spread in although may be localized within a small Fig.1 (GI , qo One-pion exchange graph in N-N collision strip. On the average, a single-pion exchange is 4> centered around q2-m; , so the point relevant for q2 is usually small compared with q6 which is of nuclei ("1n nucleie* in the plot) is for convenience o:der of a few ( kf )2 where kf is the Fermi mo- put at m4 As we will emphasize again and again, mentum, roughly two pion mass. So one can say that 7i . we are interested in the phenomena where the long in a nucleus range one-pion-exchange picture is relevant. 2 q2 rv m (2 > X There has been a considerable progress in Both points (1) and (2) are not too far from the both nuclear and subnuclear physics in describing point where q2 = 0 , certainly if one considers the threshold process involving nucleons starting these on the ather hadron scale, namely nucleon from the soft-pion limit. Like the soft-photon for which is as large as 7m It seems only natural which low-energy theorems are well known, the soft X . then to treat both cases (1) and (2) together, ho- pion limit gives us a model-independent result, ping that it makes some sense. quite similar in many aspects to the soft-photon results. The major progress concerns then the link between this point and the physical threshold. Now it seems reasonable to think that if one can go in 4 the q direction in the /q/ vs. qo plane, one should 1 Physical Threshold also bi able to go in GI direction. Thus one would expect that the soft-pion limit is as relevant to the threshold as to the nuclear matter region. This talk deals thus on a same footing the pion which is exchanged between nucleons and the pion which is produced or captured or scat- ters by nucleons or nuclei, The major advantagedte pion in nuclear physics is that it generates the potential which governs a great deal of nuclear dy- namics as well as it can be used as a probe, diffe- rent from the usual nuclear or efectromagnctic pro- bes. I1 - PlON CLOUD - What takes place when two nu- cleons approach each other at close distance is not k~ownat all. But we think we know a little about I have dram in Pig.2 the points in the what happens when they are at a large distance, say 1:1 1:1 vs. qo plot where the phenomena of our inte- mare than one pion Compton wave length apart. Around rests lie. The origin where I:/ = 0 , qo= 0 is cal- this range and beyond it, one pion exchange is impor- led the "soft-pion limit" which is cloarly an unphy- tant. sical mathematical point. This may not be reached MW ENERGY PIONS ... C5-157 We also know that each nucleon carries a Now how many mesons are exchanged on the average ? meson cloud srctund it. Suppose now two nucleons ap- One can have a rough idea about this by looking at proach each other at a distance at which two clouds the contribution to the norm of the basic Heitler- can overlap. The question one inay ask is, what is London state coming from one, two, ... meson ex- the distribution of meson clouds when there is a changes. This is shown in Fig.4. Clearly, at largo simulated creation and annihilation of pions ? distances, one-meson exchange seems enough. This is -1 There must be a certain distortion but this must certainly so for r > m As the distance becomes 71 . depend upon the distance. The only treatment on smaller, more and more pions are exchanged as one this question that I know of which has some credibi- would expect. lity 1s that of Cutkosky published some 14 years agoC1I. It is based on the Heitler-London model ba- sed on the static approximation. In this model, pat- terned after molecular structure, the simulated ex- change of pions as well as the excitation of nucle- on resonances can be correctly taken into account. The static model tells us that a nucleon carries,on the average, about 3 pions. Thus nun-interacting system of two nucleons would contain roughly 6 pions in the cloud. As the exchange occurs due to inter- actions, the distribution of meson clouds is expec- ted to be distorted. Cutkosky investigated this question and found that the deviation of the avera- ge number of pions in deuteron from that of two iso- lated nucleons was small at large distance, typical- Fig.4 ly $ to 1- pion at the distance of one-pion Campton The ono-, two-, and three-meson contributions to 2 the norm of the basic state in deuteron.