• Abstract and Figures
• Public Full-text

Cusp in the Symmetry Energy, PREX-II And Pseudo-Conformal Sound Speed in Neutron Stars Hyun Kyu Lee,1, ∗ Yong-Liang Ma,2, 3, y Won-Gi Paeng,4, z and Mannque Rho5, x 1Department of Physics, Hanyang University, Seoul 133-791, Korea 2School of Fundamental Physics and Mathematical Sciences, Hangzhou Institute for Advanced Study, UCAS, Hangzhou, 310024, China 3International Center for Theoretical Physics Asia-Pacific (ICTP-AP) (Beijing/Hangzhou), UCAS, Beijing 100190, China 4A I Lab., Clunix, Seoul 07209, Korea 5Institut de Physique Th´eorique,Universit´eParis-Saclay, CNRS, CEA, 91191, Gif-sur-Yvette, France (Dated: July 23, 2021) The recent announcement of the PREX-II measurement of the neutron skin of 208Pb that suggests a stiff symmetry energy near nuclear matter density n0 and its impact on the EoS of massive compact stars raise the issue as to whether the widely accepted lore in nuclear astrophysics that the EoS determined at n0 necessarily gives a stringent \constraint" at high densities relevant to massive compact stars. We present the argument that the \cusp" structure in the symmetry energy at n1=2 >∼ 2n0 predicted by a topology change in dense matter could obstruct the validity of the lore. The topology change, encoding the emergence of QCD degrees of freedom in terms of hidden local and scale symmetries, predicts an EoS that is soft below and stiff above n >∼ n1=2, involving no low-order phase transitions, and yields the macrophysical properties of neutron stars overall consistent with the astrophysical observations including the maximum mass 2:0 <∼ M=M <∼ 2:2 as well as the GW data. Furthermore it describes the interior core of the massive stars constituted of baryon-charge-fractionalized quasi-fermions, that are neither baryonic nor quarkonic, with the 2 2 \pseudo-conformal" sound speed vpcs=c ≈ 1=3 converged from below at n1=2 with a nonzero trace of energy-momentum tensor. In the renormalization-group approach to interacting fermions dubbed GnEFT, the strangeness degrees of freedom play no role in the density regime relevant to the massive stars considered. I. INTRODUCTION available it has the power to go beyond the standard chi- ral effective field theory (SχEFT), currently heralded as In accessing dense neutron-star matter in terms of a as a possible “first-principles approach" to nuclear the- topology change for the putative hadron-quark continu- ory at low energy and densitiy, and gives extremely sim- ity, it was discovered in 2011 [1] that a cusp is present in ple predictions that have the merit to be unambiguously confronted by experiments in the density regime inacces- the nuclear symmetry energy Esym at a density ∼ (2 − 3) sible by SχEFT. It has thus far accounted with no un- times the normal nuclear matter density n = n0 ' 0:16 fm−3. This cusp structure has been found to play the surmountable tension for all macro-physical observables most important role in the approach to the EoS of dense available in both terrestrial and astrophysical laborato- compact-star matter developed entirely independently of ries. See for the current status, e.g., [2]. other on-going approaches in nuclear astrophysics. 1 For- In this paper, we show that this cusp structure zeroes mulated with the minimum number of degrees of freedom in on the recent issue raised by the PREX-II measure- ment of the neutron skin thickness of 208Pb [3] and the impact on the equation of state (EoS) of massive com- 208 pact stars. An analysis using the new Rskin and certain ∗ [email protected] correlations with the symmetry energy J and its slope L y [email protected] z (to be defined) at n = n0 led to the 1 σ intervals [4] arXiv:2107.01879v2 [nucl-th] 22 Jul 2021 [email protected] x [email protected] J = (38:1 ± 4:7) MeV;L = (106 ± 37) MeV: (1) 1 When the idea of [1] was first submitted to Phys. Rev. Lett., it was summarily rejected by the DA Editor of PRL at the time on the ground that \the skyrmion approach to nuclear physics was never considered as a viable alternative to more traditional ab initio calculations ... and is now more or less abandoned ..." matter, string theory etc. became much too difficult for many The DAE's decision followed two concurrent events that took nuclear theorists { except for a few diehard enthusiasts. The sec- place then. First, all the mathematically astute { mostly par- ond event was that at the time the paper [1] was written, chiral ticle { theorists who contributed to resuscitating, in the light EFT was becoming very popular in the nuclear theory commu- of QCD, the Skyrme model which had been left totally ignored nity. It was also a lot easier to access numerically for quick results for two decades in nuclear physics community, quickly moved for publication. What transpired in this paper and is continu- over to string theory which was then beginning to undergo its ing to transpire in current developments, as briefly mentioned first \string revolution for theory of everything." In the absence in Conclusion regarding the BPS skyrmion and holographic dual of those string theorists, making progress with highly intricate approaches to nuclear physics, aptly illustrates an unfortunately mathematics involved in skyrmion physics as is now being abun- prevalent short-sightedness on truly novel and unconventional dantly recognized in other areas of physics such as condensed ideas in the field too often dismissed as \conjectural." 2 These values seemingly overshoot greatly the currently where α = (N −P )=(N +P ) is the neutron-proton asym- \accepted" values [5] 2, metry with P (N) standing for the number of protons (neutrons) in A = N + P nucleon system. The J and L J = (31:7 ± 1:1) MeV;L = (59:8 ± 4:1) MeV: (2) concerned are This result means the EoS must be a lot stiffer at normal @Esym(n) J = Esym(n0);L = 3 jn=n : (4) nuclear matter density than what has been considered up @n 0 to date. A similar observation termed as a \dilemma" is The issue associated with the Pb skin thickness puzzle arrived at by Piekarewicz from the electric dipole polar- involves this symmetry energy on which our discussion izability of neutron-rich nuclei [6]. Naively extrapolated will be focused. In standard nuclear physics approaches 208 to the massive compact-star density, the Rskin data could (SNPA) anchored on effective density functionals such as rule out most of, or at least put in serious tension, the the Skyrme potential, relativistic mean field (RMF) and EoS' currently available in the literature for compact-star varieties thereof as well as SχPT up to manageable chi- physics. ral order, equipped with a certain number of parameters The stiff EoS implied by the dilemma turns out, as fit to available empirical data, the E(n; α) can be more we will discuss later, to have a dramatic effect on the or less reliably determined in the vicinity of the nuclear properties of massive stars such as the composition of matter equilibrium density n0. It has also been extended, the star core and sound speed. We will show that the with albeit significant uncertainty, up to slightly above cusp structure discovered in [1] gives rise to a totally dif- n0 from heavy-ion collision experiments. Thus one can ferent picture. This has a close connection to the lore say that the nuclear symmetry energy Esym is fairly well popularly accepted in certain nuclear astrophysics circles determined up to n0 in SNPAs. It should, however, be that the EoS determined accurately at low density, say, stressed that its slope in density, namely, L and higher as ∼ n0, should make an indispensable constraint to the derivatives remain uncertain, say in SχPT, unless chiral- m EoS at higher densities. Put differently, the lore that order terms up to N LO for m >∼ 4 are fully included. we shall refer to as nuclear-astrophysics lore (nLORE This is closely tied to the fact that the chiral power ex- κ for short) states that what happens in the core of com- pansion (say, in SχEFT) is bound to break down for kF pact stars must be constrained by what happens in nu- for κ >∼ 5 ((e.g., [9]) as the hadron-quark crossover den- clear matter. This of course must be true in a uniguely sity is approached. So the problem is how Esym and given theory, namely, QCD. However given that QCD can its derivatives behave beyond the equilibrium density n0. directly access neither nuclear matter nor compact-star This is where heavy degrees of freedom (HDsF) need to matter, what's available is effective field theory (EFT) in enter. the sense defined by Weinberg's Folk Theorem. In EFT, this nLORE cannot be valid if there are phase changes or crossovers. In fact, we will argue the presence of the cusp A. Cusp in Skyrmion Crystal at O(1=Nc) in our approach debunks the nLORE on constraints on EoS. What turns out to importantly figure in our argu- We address this problem exploiting a topological struc- ment is the existence of that cusp at a density >∼ (2−3)n0 ture of dense baryonic matter. This is because in the in the symmetry energy induced by a (what we consider large Nc limit in QCD, the only known non-perturbative to be robust) topology change in dense matter that ef- tool available in strong interaction physics applicable to fectively encodes the putative hadron-quark continuity baryonic matter at large density { in the absence of lat- expected in QCD. This point is signaled also in a dif- tice QCD { is putting skyrmions (or instantons in holo- ferent context in [7].

Load more

  12

Copy Link