Route to Reconciliation - Editorial - the Kathmandu Post

Route to reconciliation - Editorial - The Kathmandu Post http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition/news/2014-06-10...

 Print Edition (/printedition/2017-05-10)| Archive (/archive)

(http://www.ekantipur.com) (/)

PRINT EDITION - 2014-06-11 (/PRINTEDITION/2014-06-11) | EDITORIAL 0 Route to reconciliation SHARES ! Share " Share Moving forward requires greater concentration on locally- on facebook on twitter driven efforts and village-level activism # Share - Ram Kumar Bhandari (/printedition/author/ram+kumar+bhandari) on email (mailto:?Subject=Route%20to%20reconciliation& body=Eight%20years%20after%20the%20end%20of%20the%20Maoist%20insurgency %2C%20reconciliation%20efforts%20remain%20fragmented http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition/news/2014-06-10/route- to-reconciliation.html)

Main News

Social media a strong tool this poll season?

(http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com /printedition /news/2017-05-10 /social-media- Jun 10, 2014-Eight years after the end of the Maoist a-strong- insurgency, reconciliation efforts remain fragmented tool-this- and the grief of thousands of victims’ families is poll-season.html (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition being held hostage to political interests and a narrow /news/2017-05-10/social-media-a-strong-tool-this- legalistic understanding of transitional justice. poll-season.html) May 10, 2017 Nepal’s post-conflict politics and growing peace industry have seen the politicisation and Nepal to sign framework deal on OBOR (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition commodification of victims while neglecting their /news/2017-05-09/nepal-to-sign-framework-deal-on- individual dignity and failing to provide a obor.html) constructive role for families and their associations May 09, 2017

and justice initiatives. The political parties have Signs of thaw in Parliament’s frosty succeeded in instrumentalising the victims’ justice relations with judiciary agenda for political gain. Former Maoist combatants and ex-security forces have not been effectively (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com /printedition re-integrated in their respective societies, causing /news/2017-05-08 tensions while the current transitional justice /signs-of-thaw- in-parliaments- provisions fail to address the needs and demands of frosty- both victims and broader society for a fair and secure relations- with-judiciary.html future. (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition /news/2017-05-08/signs-of-thaw-in-parliaments- Focus on victims frosty-relations-with-judiciary.html) May 08, 2017

A recent compromise by political parties on the truth SC ruling puts House on horns of dilemma and reconciliation process has ended the (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition /news/2017-05-07/sc-ruling-puts-house-on-horns- reconciliation debate. This compromise, between the of-dilemma.html) political parties and security institutions, ensures May 07, 2017 amnesty for past crimes without addressing the need for institutional change or democratisation of the security system. This compromise further demonstrates the lack of political will to promote a victim-centric or citizen-centric transitional process. In short, those in charge have managed to institutionalise a system that fails to acknowledge the past while simultaneously instrumentalising it for immediate political gain. Reconciliation is both a goal and a process—long term, individual and communal healing can only be achieved at the community level

1 von 6 10.05.17, 15:17 Route to reconciliation - Editorial - The Kathmandu Post http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition/news/2014-06-10...

through engagement and sharing among community SC stays impeachment motion against members, including story-telling, and the creation of Karki spaces for families through community platforms and local dialogue groups. Ideally, this should take (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com (http://www.ekantipur.com) /printedition the form of a micro-level initiative where every /news/2017-05-06 individual and family feels comfortable to take part /sc-stays- impeachment- in the social unit, creating a progressive socio- motion- cultural environment. Unfortunately, to date, against- examples from local peace committees have largely karki.html) (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition failed to create such a foundation for reconciliation. /news/2017-05-06/sc-stays-impeachment-motion- Promoting a victim-centric approach that focuses on against-karki.html) May 06, 2017 victims’ participation and their needs within society can play a significant role to change such dynamics. Differences result in House meet deferral Various interests, particularly those prescribed by top-level actors, have taken control of the (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com /printedition reconciliation process. In particular, Kathmandu /news/2017-05-05 elites have dominated the failed process to /differences- result- promulgate transitional justice mechanisms. In a in-house- blatant disregard for transitional justice, political meet-deferral.html elites have continued to ignore the Supreme Court (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition /news/2017-05-05/differences-result-in-house- verdicts of June 1, 2007 and January 2 and neglected meet-deferral.html) the need for a Disappearance Commission. May 05, 2017

Furthermore, the new TRC Act, signed by President Around 44,000 nominations filed for Ram Baran Yadav on May 11, ignores the May 14 polls Commission of Inquiry on Enforced Disappearance and does not recognise disappearance as a crime (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com /printedition against humanity. Achieving meaningful progress /news/2017-05-04 and reconciliation amidst these challenges will /around- require new approaches and new ways of thinking 44000- nominations- about transitional justice, both nationally and locally. filed-for-may- 14-polls.html) Bottom up (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition /news/2017-05-04/around-44000-nominations-filed- for-may-14-polls.html) As discussed earlier, the current political approach of May 04, 2017 reconciliation has failed to address the micro-level Nominations conclude for May 14 agenda of building peace from the community level. polls True reconciliation requires recognition and respect

for the dignity of individual families and (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com communities. However, the Nepali process, centred /printedition /news/2017-05-03 in politics, excludes a community approach to /nominations- reconciliation. The recent TRC legislation has fueled conclude- for-may- new conflicts, not only at the political level, but 14-polls.html) socially as well; criticised for its faulty process and (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition amnesty provisions that not only fail to address /news/2017-05-03/nominations-conclude-for-may- 14-polls.html) victims’ agendas but add to the culture of revenge. May 03, 2017 Politically, the government must seek to ground Congress-Maoist move threatens transitional efforts at the local level, working closely separation of powers? with those most affected to build the trust and

relationships necessary to move towards (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com reconciliation. /printedition /news/2017-05-02 /congress- Politics aside, local efforts have the potential to maoist- create a space for reconciliation. For example, move-threatens- separation- Hateymalo, an accompaniment programme of the of-powers.html) International Committee of the Red Cross, has (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition greatly benefitted relatives of the disappeared, /news/2017-05-02/congress-maoist-move-threatens- separation-of-powers.html) creating an initiative to practice healing at the May 02, 2017 community level in support of true reconciliation and helping families to overcome psychological and social trauma. This programme has reached a majority of families of the disappeared and has been supportive in bringing them together to share their pain, suffering and life experiences. This has not only

2 von 6 10.05.17, 15:17 Route to reconciliation - Editorial - The Kathmandu Post http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition/news/2014-06-10...

created a space for families but has also provided 60 houses destroyed in Banke fire families with a path to a shared truth and empowerment within the community. Storytelling and sharing among family members has helped heal (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com (http://www.ekantipur.com) /printedition individuals and community members. /news/2017-04-29 /60-houses- Aditionally, a Berlin-based organisation, Inmedio, destroyed- in-banke- has worked to reconcile and train ex-combatants, fire.html) conflict victims and community members in rural (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition /news/2017-04-29/60-houses-destroyed-in-banke- villages. Inmedio has initiated community-based fire.html) programmes and directly engaged with former Apr 29, 2017 fighters and local peoples to reconcile ‘new’ and ‘old’ community members. Such cooperation between victims and the wider community has created a harmonious route to bring people together. Understanding such dynamics and engaging constructively in the community is not only useful in comprehending conflict analysis but also to foster comprehensive solutions in our post- conflict environment.

Local initiatives

There are several local initiatives in the villages to strengthen community processes and locally-driven campaigns. Various family associations in the districts have been organising interactions and dialogue within victim’s families and with the media, civil society, women groups, youth clubs and local government and politicians to create spaces for themselves. In many cases, the victims’ initiative for local campaigns and to lead community reconciliation has not only given them agency but also a productive channel to establish their social and economic agendas. The Conflict Victims Committee Bardiya’s example of social harmony initiatives, various micro-level income generating activities of families, publishing memory books or smarikas, building local memorials such as monuments, gates, chautaris, naming schools and streets, building taps and community meeting halls provide social recognition which is part of repairing and healing. Government and other agencies could learn from such initiatives that have created a potential route to reconciliation through mobilisation, dialogue and promoting local processes to support victims and the broader community to strengthen local democracy and respect peoples’ rights on a need basis, not from the prescription of outsiders.

The value of a bottom up process at the individual and village level to the district level is an example of local efforts that should be encouraged and replicated. Programmes such as Hateymalo and Inmedio’s support through facilitation, mediation and constructive dialogue show the tangible impacts of locally-driven reconciliation mechanisms. Whilst political efforts to reform state and security institutions will be crucial for long term national peace and sustainability, post-conflict reconciliation must reach all citizens of Nepal, whatever their relationship to the fissures of the conflict. To move forward effectively will require a greater concentration on locally-driven efforts and

3 von 6 10.05.17, 15:17 Route to reconciliation - Editorial - The Kathmandu Post http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition/news/2014-06-10...

village-level activism that will allow us to transcend the problems that persist nationally.

Bhandari is founder-coordinator of the National (http://www.ekantipur.comNetwork of Families) of Disappeared and Missing

Published: 11-06-2014 08:47 Like 0

The Kathmandu Post (/) › Editorial (/printedition/category/editorial)

› Ram Kumar Bhandari (/printedition/author/ram+kumar+bhandari)

Decision time (/printedition › /news/2014-06-10/decision-time.html)

User's Feedback

Click here for your comments

Comment via Facebook

0 Comments Sort by Oldest

Add a comment...

Facebook Comments Plugin

Don't have facebook account? Use this form to comment

MORE FROM EDITORIAL (/CATEGORY/EDITORIAL‹ › )

Facing starvation (/printedition /news/2017-05-10/facing- starvation.html)

Facing starvation (/printedition Time to vote /news/2017-05-10/facing- /news/2017-05-10/time-to-vote.htm starvation.html) May 10, 2017 May 10, 2017 full story » (/news/2017-05-10/time-to full story » (/news/2017-05-10/facing- starvation.html)

TRENDING

Cabinet endorses govt plan of Peace and compassion developing new town (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com /news/2017-05-10/peace- /news/2017-05-10/cabinet- and-compassion.html)

4 von 6 10.05.17, 15:17 Route to reconciliation - Editorial - The Kathmandu Post http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition/news/2014-06-10...

full story » (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-05-10/peace-and-compassion.htmlendorses-govt-plan- ) of-developing-new-town.html) NEA defends plan to buy LED com/news/2017-05-10/cabinet-endorses-govt-plan-of-developing-new-town.html) bulbs from Indian company (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com (http://www.ekantipur.com) /news/2017-05-10 /nea-defends-plan-to-buy-led- bulbs-from-indian- company.html) http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-05-10/nea-defends-plan-to-buy-led-bulbs-from-indian-company.html)

Half of polling centres most sensitive: MoHA

(http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com Nepal to sign framework deal on /news/2017-05-10/half- OBOR of-polling-centres-most-sensitive- (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com moha.html) /news/2017-05-09/nepal-to-sign- t.ekantipur.com/news/2017-05-10/half-of-polling-centres-most-sensitive-moha.html) framework-deal-on-obor.html) full story » (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-05-09/nepal-to-sign-framework-deal-on-obor.html)

‘Nothing teamwork can’t solve’ High-way of change (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com /news/2017-05-08/nothing- /news/2017-05-10/high-way-of- teamwork-cant-solve.html) change.html) athmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-05-08/nothing-teamwork-cant-solve.htmlfull story » (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-05-10/high-way-of-change.html) )

Quota system worries Kailash Lumbini marks Buddha Jayanti tour operators with special programme (with (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com photos) (http://bit.ly/2pj4veD) /news/2017-05-10/quota-system- full story » (http://bit.ly/2pj4veD) worries-kailash- tour-operators.html) .ekantipur.com/news/2017-05-10/quota-system-worries-kailash-tour-operators.html)

Notorious gangster Chakre Milan arrested (http://bit.ly/2pgszii) full story » (http://bit.ly/2pgszii)

The Kathmandu Post's Categories

Blog (/category/blog) Capital (/category/capital) Editor's Pick (/category/editors-pick) Editorial (/category/editorial) Entertainment (/category/entertainment) Escalate (/category/escalate) Featured (/category/featured) Fiction Park (/category/fiction-park) General (/category/general) Health & Living (/category/health-living) Health & Style (/category/health-style) Int'l Coverage (/category/intl-coverage) INTERVIEW (/category/interview) Local Level Elections 2017 (/category/local-level-elections-2017) MAIN NEWS (/category/main-news) Money (/category/money) National (/category/national) news (/category/news) Off The Beat (/category/off-the-beat-odd-news) Oped (/category/oped) Photo-feature (/category/photo-feature) POST TRIVIA (/category/trivia-nepal-facts-about-nepal) Saturday Features (/category/saturday-features) Sports (/category/sports) Video (/category/video) World (/category/world)

(http://www.kmg.com.np)

About Us Advertise Contact Address

Established in February 1993, the To advertise on ekantipur click here » Kantipur Publications Pvt. Ltd. Kathmandu Post, Nepal’s first privately (http://www.ekantipur.com/advertisement) Central Business Park, Thapathali owned English broadsheet daily, is today To advertise on print media click here » Kathmandu, Nepal Nepal’s leading English language (http://www.kmg.com.np/advertise/) newspaper, with a daily circulation of 82,000  +977-01-5135000 copies. This makes the Post Nepal’s  +977-01-5135001 Feedback second-most widely circulated newspaper ✉ Contact Us »

—after Kantipur daily. The Kathmandu Post Send us your feedback »

5 von 6 10.05.17, 15:17 Route to reconciliation - Editorial - The Kathmandu Post http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition/news/2014-06-10...

is also a member of Asia News Network that has over 15 members and is known for its insightful, unbiased journalistic work of the highest calibre.

(http://www.ekantipur.comRead more» (http://kmg.com.np/kantipur-) publication/#The-Kathmandu-Post)

A member of ekantipur (http://www.ekantipur.com)

6 von 6 10.05.17, 15:17