Tables and Indexes Table of technical reference material

The following table lists available scientific reference Cambridge, Mass. Center for Conservation and material relating to paintings discussed in the pre• Technical Studies of the Fogg sent volume. The data themselves are included in Art Museum, Harvard the text of our catalogue entries. Other than for the University dendrochronological data (listed on pp. 683-685), Professor Dr. W. Froentjes, as• no effort has been made to give a survey of the sisted by Mr. L. Kuiper, former individual information. As a specification of restorer at the , scientific data obtained and interpreted by different and Mr. W. Verschuren, chief methods may easily yield misleading results, only the assistant at the Forensic existence and amount of reference material are in• Science Laboratory of the dicated, together with the places where it was Ministry of Justice, Rijswijk examined and is currently kept. As for the X-rays (cf. De Vries, T6th-Ubbens, listed, most though not all are in the museum's or Froentjes) owner's records as well as in our files, as originals, London National Gallery Research La• copy films or paper prints. X-rays of the whole or boratory virtually whole area of paintings are listed in a differ• Los Angeles Los Angeles County Museum ent column from those covering only part of the of Art painting. A question mark indicates that the number Munich Doerner-Institut of samples taken and cross-sections prepared is un• Paris Laboratoire du Musee du known to us. The institutes where research was car• Louvre ried out are listed as follows: Stuttgart Institut fUr Technologie der Central Research Laboratory Malerei

Support Ground and paint Photographic Remarks documents ..; en bJJ v ..c 0 -a P... '0 ('(j ..c 6 ..c: P... ('(j '"bJJ P... >.. Q) bJJ .S ('(j ~'" ~'" u 0 >:: "0 '"bJJ >:: ('(j 0 Q) "0 '; en ';- u >:: ·E en 0 C P... >:: '0 v ::I '" '- ><; ..c: .5 0 P... ..c:'" 0 'E Q) I '"0 u u ..c: u ::I 0 u v Q) -u -0 '" v "@ v c::: ('(j ..0 "? -u'" '"('(j Vl -a ....., ('(j Q) v CJl '" >:: S 0 S > Q) ct: '" '"v ::I 0 '"('(j -u -5 '" >:: u'" u P... .5 ;:J A 1 The stoning of S. Stephen, Lyon Paris 1 1 + +

~------A 2 Balaam, Paris +

~-- A 3 Tobit and Anna, Amsterdam + + ------A 4 Driving-out of the moneychangers, + Moscow

- ~~-- A 5 Baptism of the eunuch, U trech t + Amsterdam i 19 16 + + + --- A 6 History painting, Leiden + Am""damJ' 12 + Amsterdam .~.. I A 7 Musical allegory, Amsterdam + 1 +

~--~~ -~---~ A 8 Man in gorget and cap, whereabouts + unknown

-~ ~-

A 9 David bifore Saul, Basle + ! ! Aro The rich man, Berlin + + ------All S. Paul in prison, Stuttgart Munich I + Stuttgart 4

1- ~---~ ------~~ A 12 , Hamburg + + -\ TABLE OF TECHNICAL REFERENCE MATERIAL

Support Ground and paint Photographic Remarks documents ...: en bJJ v ...c 0 P- o.. '0 a (\j...... c ...c (\j bJJ 0.. 0.. >-- en en 0 (\j V bJJ ~ ... , .... u 0 ;:: ;0 bJJ ;:: "0 E (\j 0 V ;:: '0 '8 en ...... U E en 0.. ~ 0 en ....0 :::l .S e.- .g ~ ...c ....V ...c 0 0 V 0.. 0 (.; u ...c .... u :::l I V ...V '"0 ....0 '"0 ....U V V 'l:: (\j ..0 'f' .... '"0 (\j en 0.. 3 (\j ;:: V V en ...... en a 0 a .... ~ :> V V :::l ..... 0 (\j '"0 .s .... ;:: u u 0.. .S ~ A 13 Old men disputing, Melbourne + + A 14 Self-portrait, Amsterdam + + Copy I of no. A 14, Kassel + Munich I + A 15 Judas repentant, private collection London I I I I +

-~ A 16 Supper at Emmaus,Jacquemart- + Andre, Paris A 18 , Boston + + A 19 Self-portrait, Munich + Munich I + - - -- - A20 Self-portrait, Stewart Gardner + + + * *taken before the cleaning of Museum, Boston - 1954 A21 Self-portrait, The Hague + The Hague 10 2 + A22 Self-portrait, Japan Munich ? ? + A23 Young man, Cleveland + +

~~- A24 Samson and Delilah, Berlin + + A25 David playing the harp to Saul, + + Frankfurt A26 S. Paul, Nuremberg +

---~-- A28 Jeremiah, Amsterdam + Amsterdam 2 I + A29 Old man in ajur cap, Innsbruck + + A30 Raising oj Lazarus, Los Angeles Los Angeles 4 4 + + + A31 Andromeda, The Hague + The Hague 12 2 + + + A32 Old woman, Windsor Castle + A33 Self-portrait, Liverpool + + -'---- A34 Simeon in the Temple, The Hague + The Hague 13 2 + + + A35 Christ on the Cross, Le Mas + d'Agenais A37 Old woman reading, Amsterdam + Amsterdam 2 2 + --r--- A38 , Berlin + + A39 Abduction oj Proserpina, Berlin + + A4° The artist in oriental costume, Petit + + +* ·detail with signature Palais, Paris

A4I Young man, Toledo + A42 Old man in gorget and cap, Chicago + + + +

680 TABLE OF TECHNICAL REFERENCE MATERIAL

Support Ground and paint Photographic Remarks documents ! ..; en bJJ , ~ ..c:: 0 Ii 0.. 0 ro ..c:: E ~ ..c:: ro 'oJ: 0.. 0.. >-- C/J en ro ~ bJJ .S U 1::: ~ H 0 c "0 bJJ C .@ ro 0 ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ en u C ·E 0.. C 0 0 C Ul '"~ ... ;:J c '- ~ ..c:: ... ..c:: 0 0 ·5 0.. 0 u y ..c:: ... u 1::: ;:J ~ ~ "0 0 u ~ ~ c::: ... "0 ... ..0 ~ ro on Ii ] ... "0 ro ;JJ ro ~ ~ E 1:: c ... on ;:J 0 E <.t: > il.i il.i .... 0 til "0 -5 .... C u u 0.. .s ~ I B I Three singers, Cramer Gallery + ------B 2 The operation, Cramer Gallery + B 3 The spectacles-pedlar, colI. Cevat + ------,------,----- .. _-,----"---- B 4 Man in gorget and cap, Malibu -.+ + "of canvas covering back of panel

B 5 Self-portrait, Stockholm The Hague 2 2 ------B 6 Man laughing, The Hague The Hague 5 I + " + + "electron emission radiograph B 7 Old man, The Hague + Munich ? ? The Hague I I 2 + +

C I Samson and Delilah, Amsterdam + + C 2 Esther's feast, Raleigh + Amsterdam 4 2 + ------1--- - - ~--- C 3 Tobit and Anna, London London 5 4 + + C 4 Tobit, colI. Middendorf + + ------c------C 5 Flight into Egypt, Tours + + " "detail with signature C 6 Rest on the flight into Egypt, formerly + + + colI. Lennox

C 7 The tribute money, Ottawa + + + + ------._------."------I--- --I--- C 8 Christ at the column, private + + collection ------_._------C 9 Minerva, Denver + ------'" ------Cra Nocturnal scene, Tokyo + -- - 1------~ -- C I I Foot operation, private collection + ------1------I~ ------C 12 Travellers resting, The Hague -.+ The Hague 16 3 + + + "of panel on which paper has been stuck -- -- C 13 Old men disputing, Cramer Gallery + + -c----c-- c---1--- C 14 Man reading, London + London 3 3 + C 15 Scholar, Braunschweig + Munich I + C 16 Hermit, Paris + + C 17 Christian scholar, Stockholm + +. "detail with signature ------+------C 18 Man writing by candlelight, colI. + + Bader, Milwaukee ._------I------_ .. _----._--- C 19 Old woman reading, Wilton House + +

681 TABLE OF TECHNICAL REFERENCE MATERIAL

Support Ground and paint Photographic Remarks documents ...; en bD I It) ...c 8 -a P... 0 E ell ...c ...c ell '"bD P... P... ;>.. en en It) It) 0 bD ~ .... u 0 ;; C :.0 '"bD C ell It) '0 .:5 '@ en ';< 8 U c C 0 en 0 C en P... It) .... ::l C c- .g >< ...c ...... c 0 0 P... 0 v u u ~ ::l ...c .... It) It) "0 0 u It) It) 0::: -0 ...... 0 Of' .... "0'" ell ell en -a ] It) It) en c .... E 0 E .... c.'::'" :> It) It) ::l .... 0 ell "0 -5 ....'" C v u P... .S ~ C20 Old man with arms crossed, Boston + + C 21 Man in a turban, Philadelphia + + + C22 Old man, coll. Bader, Milwaukee + C23 Man in plumed cap, private collection + Amsterdam 16 12 + + + C24 Old man, Kassel + Munich 2 ? + C25 Old man, Leipzig + + C26 Old man wearing a cross, Kassel + Munich 4 ? + C28 Old man in gorget and cap, Leningrad + ------~- C29 Old man, Cambridge, Mass. + + C30 Old man, Kassel + Munich 3 ? + C32 Man wearing a gold chain, Leiden + + C34 Young man laughing, Amsterdam + Amsterdam 2 2 + C35 Young man, Cambridge, Mass. + + C36 Bust oj , private collection + Cambridge, 4 1 + + Mass. C37 Bust oj Rembrandt, private collection + + C38 Young man, New York + + C40 Young man, private collection + ------f-- --f------f-- C41 Old woman, The Hague + The Hague 4 1 + + + - -- Copy 12 of no. C 4 I, Braunschweig + ------C42 Old woman, private collection + C44 Young girl, Helsinki + Table of dendrochronological data

This survey of the dating of the wood of panels In cases where the presence of sapwood made it discussed in the present volume is based on den• possible to pinpoint the boundary between heart• drochronological examinations carried out by Prof. wood and sapwood, an average felling date for the Dr.]. Bauch and Dr. D. Eckstein, of the Ordinariat tree has been arrived at; depending on the age of the fUr Holzbiologie, University of Hamburg, who were tree, allowance then needs to be made for 20 ± 5 later joined by Dr. P. Klein; their findings will be annual rings of sapwood. published in:]. Bauch, D. Eckstein, P. Klein and G. In cases where no sapwood was present, and an Brauner, 'Dendrochronologische Untersuchungen unknown number of annual rings of heartwood an Holztafeln von Rembrandt-Gemalden', Jahrbuch might have been lost, the last ring of heartwood der Berliner Museen 24 (1982). No. C 36 was examined counted was used to arrive at the earliest possible by Mr.]. M. Fletcher, of the Research Laboratory felling date. for Archaeology and the History of Art, Oxford University.

last dated number of conclusion as other date panel was painted annual ring annual to felling da te information of heartwood rings of as as sapwood earliest stat. inscribed accepted present poss. aver. on picture

A 3 Tobit and Anna, 1602 5 1622 ± 5 because of dense I626 I626 Amsterdam structure after rather than before 1622 A 5 Baptism oj the eunuch, I598 8 1618±5 because of age of 1626 I626 Utrecht tree after rather than before I 6 I 8 A 6 History painting, Leiden I596 - 161 I 1626 1626 A 7 Musical allegory, I593 - I608 because of age of I626 1626 Amsterdam tree after rather than before 1613 AlO Rich man, Berlin 1594 - 1609 I627 162 7 AI2 Simeon in the Temple, 1593 4 I613±5 because of age of - 162 7/28 Hamburg tree after rather than before 16 I 3; from same tree as nos. A 38 and B 7 A 13 Two old men disputing, ? - ? radial board, not 1628 1628 Melbourne datable (formerly) A14 Self-portrait, Amsterdam ? - ? - 1628 A14 Copy I, Kassel ? - ? - ? A I9 Self-portrait, Munich 1610 5 1630 ± 5 1629 1629 A21 Self-portrait, The Hague 1595 - I610 probably a few - 1629 rings lost through later reduction in SIze A24 Samson and Delilah, Berlin 1603 6 162 3 ± 5 1628 162 9/30 A25 David playing the harp to ? 7 ? - 1629/30 Saul, Frankfurt A28 Jeremiah, Amsterdam 1609 - 1624 1630 1630 A3 I Andromeda, The Hague I603 - 16I8 some rings lost - 1630/3 1 through later re- duction in size A34 Simeon in the Temple, The 1589 - 1605 from same tree as 1631 1631 Hague no. A37 and therefore from same date A37 Old woman reading, I59° - 1605 from same tree as 1631 163I Amsterdam no. A34 TABLE OF DENDROCHRONOLOGICAL DATA

last dated number of conclusion as other date panel was painted annual ring annual to felling date information of heartwood rings of as as sapwood earliest stat. inscribed accepted present poss. aver. on picture

A38 Minerva, Berlin 1593 8 161 3 ± 5 because of age of - 1631 tree after rather than before 1613; from same tree as nos. A 12 and B 7 A39 Abduction of Proserpina, ? - ? radial board, not - 1631 Berlin dated A40 The artist in oriental 1609 - 1629 1631 1631 costume, Peti t Palais A42 Half-lengthfigure of old 1599 - 161 9 from same tree as 1631 man, Chicago Br. 338 B 7 Old man, The Hague 1569 - 161 3 ± 5 from the same soon after tree as nos. A 12 1630? and A38 and therefore from the same date C I Samson and Delilah, 160 7 - 1622 162 7 Amsterdam C 7 The tribute money, Ottawa 1610 - 1630 because of age of 1629 not before tree possibly 1631 somewhat after 1630

C 12 Travellers resting, The 1630 ( I ) 1650 ± 5 the painting is on - - Hague paper stuck on wood C 14 Man reading, London 1594 - 161 4 - ? C 15 Scholar, Braunschweig 1606 1621 - c. 1630? C 16 Hermit, Paris ? - ? 163(0?) earlY'30s C20 Old man with arms crossed, ? I ? - soon after 163 I Boston C23 Man in plumed cap, priv. 1601 - 1616 1629 1629? colI. C24 Old man, Kassel 1601 I 1616 ± 5 1632 early 1630S C25 Old man, Leipzig 1552 - 1567 from middle of - between 1629 trunk, numerous and 1633? rings thus lost C26 Old man wearing a cross, ? 6 ? radial board not 1630 ? Kassel datable C29 Old man, Cambridge, ? - ? - ? Mass. C30 Old man, Kassel 1573 - 1586 - ? C32 Man wearing a gold chain, 161 3 - 1628 - ? Leiden C34 Young man laughing, ? 8 ? - early 1630S Amsterdam C35 Young man, Cambridge, 161 4 - 1629 the wood 1629 ? Mass. examined is that of a narrow fram- ing, not of the panel proper C36 Bust if Rembrandt, 1610 - 1629 1630/40 whereabouts unknown C37 Bust of Rembrandt, private ? ? colI. C38 Young man, New York 1593 13 161 3 ± 5 - well after 1630 C41 Old woman, The Hague 1596 4 1616 ± 5 - after 1631 C41 Copy 12, Braunschweig 1585 - 1600 - after 1631 I TABLE OF DENDROCHRONOLOGICAL DATA

It was found impossible to date the panels of four lish, since there is usually a great deal of uncertainty authentic works (nos. A 13, A 14, A 25, A 39) and of about the date of painting. In only one case (no. C 7) a number of paintings which may safely be con• has dendrochronology confirmed the dating of a sidered approximately contemporaneous (such as work, already thought to be by a follower for reasons nos. A I4 copy I, C 16, C 20, C 24, C 34). In a of style, as later than the year inscribed on the number of cases the panels concerned were radial picture. boards (nos. A 13, A39). Apart from the da ting of wood, dendrochronolog• In the case of six panels where datable planks still ical examination has yielded interesting information show some sapwood, and where it is thus possible to on several panels, as having been made of wood that estimate the felling date with greater certainty than comes from one and the same tree. This may be when an unknown number of rings of heartwood taken to mean that panels thus connected were have been lost (nos. A 3, A 5, A 12, A 19, A 24, A 38), manufactured and sold by the same joiner and, more the period between the statistically average felling likely than not, purchased by the same painter or, at date and the date of painting is, respectively, 4, 8, 14 least, by painters in the same town at about the same to 15, - I, 6 to 7 and 18 years. The average of 8t lies time. As far as the panels dealt with in this volume well above the normal 5 years! and three cases show are concerned, this applies to three groups of panels: a considerable deviation, two (nos. A 12 and A 38) nos. A 12, A 38 and B 7, nos. A 34 and A 37, and nos. above and one (no. A 19) below the average period. A 42 and Br. 338. In the case of no. A 42 the panel's It should be borne in mind, however, that quite connexion with that of a portrait from Rembrandt's often the considerable age of the tree suggests a Amsterdam period points to it having been painted greater number of sapwood than the average of 20 after he had moved to that city during 163 I. and, therefore, a later felling date than is indicated by the statistical average (nos. A 3, A 5, A 12, A 38). In the case of fifteen authentic or roughly contem• poraneous paintings the datable planks of which do not con tain sapwood (nos. A 6, A 7, A 10, A 2 I, A 28, A3 I , A34, A37, A40, B7, C I, C7, C 15, C23, C 24) research yielded an average period, from ear• liest possible felling date to date of painting, of up• wards of 15 years, the estimated number of years varying between 2 (no. A40) and 26 (no. A34). Where the large panels (no. A 6 and to a lesser degree no. A 34) are concerned this ties up with a tendency - noted in a totally different context2 - to use for these panels planks of wood that had laid in storage longer or been less economically sawn. In general a less economical way of working when sawing the wood - resulting in the loss of an un• known number of annual rings of heartwood - does offer a possible explanation in the case of smaller paintings as well (nos. A 10, A 2 I, A 28, A 37, B 7, C 25). On top of this, however, account has to be taken of the fact that several panels have more or less demonstrably been reduced on the sapwood side (nos. A 2 I, A 3 I, B 7); this naturally leads to the loss of annual rings and - if information derived from other panels from the same tree is lacking - to the felling date being estimated too early. The time elapsing between the hypothetical felling date and the date of painting is, for the panels of paintings we regard as later works or imitations, difficult to estab-

I cr.]. Bauch and D. Eckstein in: Studies in con,lervation 15 (1970), esp. p. 47. 2 cr. data given in D. Eckstein and]. Bauch, 'Dendrochronologische Alters• bestimmung von Bildtafcln' in: exhibition cat. Var Stefan Lochner. Die KOiner i'.1.aler von 1300 his 1430, Cologne 1974, pp. 21 -2:,. Index of paintings catalogued in volume I

Present owners LONDON, The British Museum A 12 copies I and 2 AMSTERDAM, A3,A7, AI4, -, The National Gallery C 3, C 14 A 28, A 32 copy 2, -, coil. A. S60s A34 copy 2 A 37, B 4 copy I, ·LOS ANGELES, CaL, Los Angeles County A30 C I, C 34 Museum of Art ARLES, Musee Reattu A 22 copy 6 LUDLOW, Downton Castle, colI. D. C6 BASLE, Offentliche Kunstsammlung Ag, C 16 copy I Lennox (formerly) Basel LYON, Musee des Beaux-Arts AI -, private collection C43 MALIBU, Cal., J. Paul Getty Museum B4 BELGIUM, private collection A36, C8 MELBOURNE, National Gallery of A 13 BERLIN (West), Staatliche Museen A 10, A24, A38, Victoria Preussischer Kulturbesitz, A39 MILWAUKEE, Wisc., coil. Dr. A. Bader CI8,C22 Gemaldegalerie MONTE CARLO, coil. J. Kronig A21 copy 2 BOSTON, Mass., Museum of Fine Arts A 18, C 20 MOSCOW, Pushkin Museum of Fine Arts A4 -, The Isabella Stewart Gardner A20 MUNICH, Bayerische Staatsgemalde- A 19 Museum sammlungen, Alte Pinakothek BRAUNSCHWEIG, Herzog Anton Ulrich• CIS, C41 copy 12 NEW YORK, N.Y., The Metropolitan C38 Museum Museum of Art BURGHLEY HOUSE, Northamptonshire, B4 copy 2 -, coil. J. William Middendorf II C4 colI. Lady Exeter NUREMBERG, Germanisches A 2 I copy I, A 26 CAMBRIDGE, Mass., The Fogg Art C2g, C3S, C4I N a tionalm useum Museum, Harvard University copy 8 OTTAWA, The National Gallery of C7 CHICAGO, 111., The Art Institute of A 30 copy I, A42 Canada Chicago OXFORD, Ashmolean Museum C 31 CLEVELAND, Ohio, The Cleveland A23 PARIS, Musee Cognacq-Jay A2 Museum of Art -, coil. Dr. E. Hahn C 2g copy 2 COPENHAGEN, Statens ~1useum for A2I copy 3, C27, -, MuseeJacquemart-Andre A 16 Kunst C 29 copy I -, Musee du Louvre C 16 DENVER, Col., The Denver Art Museum C9 -, Musee du Petit Palais A 12 copy 3, A40 DRESDEN, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen A34 copy I PHILADELPHIA, Penn., John G. Johnson C 3 copy I Dresden, Gemaldegalerie Alte Meister Collection ENGLAND, private collection A IS, A42 copy I -, The Philadelphia Museum of Art C 21 ESSEN, colI. H. von Bohlen und Halbach C42 POMMERSFELDEN, coil. Count Schonborn A 29 copy 2 FRANKFURT AM MAIN, Stadelsches A2S PRAGUE, N arodni Galerie A IS copy I Kunstinstitut PRIVATE COLLECTION C36, C37, C39 GLASGOW, Art Gallery A 28 copy 3 -, Baron Edmond de Rothschild C33 GOTHENBURG, colI. Svanstrom C 19 copy 2 RALEIGH, N.C., The North Carolina C2 THE HAGUE, Cramer Gallery BI,B2, CI 3 Museum of Art -, Koninklijk Kabinet van Schilderijen, A 2 I, A 3 I, A 34, ROME, Galleria Doria C 22 copy 2 Mauritshuis B6, B7, C 12, C4I ROSSMORE, Lord Rossmore C 41 copy 10 -, State-owned art collections A6, A IS copy 2 SALISBURY, Wilts., Wilton House, coil. C 19 department Earl of Pembroke HAMBURG, Hamburger Kunsthalle A 12 SALZBURG, Salzburger A27 HEIDELBERG, coil. G. K. Korn C 20 copy I Landessammlungen -Residenzgalerie HELSINKI, Sinebrychoff Art Museum, C44 SCHLEISSHEIM, Staatsgalerie A 29 copy I The Fine Arts Academy of Finland STOCKHOLM, Nationalmuseum BS, C 17 HOUSTON, Texas, The Museum of Fine C 31 copy I ST. PETER PORT, Guernsey, colI. D. H. B3 Arts Cevat INDIANAPOLIS, Indiana, Indianapolis A 22 copy I STUTTGART, private collection AI2COPY4 Museum of Art, Clowes Collection -, Staatsgalerie A I I INNSBRUCK, Tiroler Landesmuseum A29 SWEDEN, private collection C40 Ferdinandeum SWITZERLAND, private collection C I I JAPAN, MOA Museum A22 TIVERTON, Devonshire, Knightshayes A 14 sub copy I KARLSRUHE, Staatliche Kunsthalle C 13 copy I Court, coil. Sir John Heathcoat-Amery KASSEL, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen A 14 copy I, C 24, TOKYO, Bridgestone Museum of Art C 10 Kassel, Schloss Wilhelmshohe C26, C 30 TOLEDO, Ohio, The Toledo Museum of A41 LEERDAM, Hofje van Aerden C 3 copy 2 Art LEIDEN, Stedelijk Museum de Lakenhal A6, C 32 TOURS, Musee des Beaux-Arts Cs LEIPZIG DDR, Museum der bildenden C2S TURIN, Galleria Sabauda A17 Kiinste USA, private collection A8 copy I, C 23, LE MAS D' AGENAIS, Lot et Garonne, A3S C 2S copy I parish church UTRECHT, Rijksmuseum het Catharijne AS LENINGRAD, The Hermitage Museum C28 Convent LIVERPOOL, Walker Art Gallery A33

686 VIENNE, Isere, Musee d'Archeologie et A40 copy 2 Previous owners des Beaux-Arts WHEREABOUTS UNKNOWN Listed arc previous owners (under proper names), WINDSOR, Windsor Castle, H.M. Queen Elizabeth II institutions (under place names) and anonymous ZURICH, Rindermarkt Gallery (1962) A21 copy 4 sales (under place names in chronological order). -, Prof. Dr. L. Ruzicka C 34 copy 2 Aalst, C.J. K. van BI,B2,C4 Aalst, N.]. van BI,B2,C4 Aberdeen, Earl of C 19 copy 1 Adda, F. C33 Agnew, C. C40 Agnew & Sons, Th. C I, C 21, C 35 Ahmanson, Howard F. A3° Alewijn, Jacob A 28, A42 Alexander, Robert A 15 Alexander, W. C. C 41 copy II Algarotti, Count C24 Amsterdam, 10June 1705, no. 30 A40 -, 15 April 1739, no. 88 C 18 -,17/18 April 1759, no. 103 A3 -, I I June 1764, no. 2 C 16 copy 2 -, 10 June 1767, no. 13 A28 -, IOJune 1767, no. 14 A42 -, 14 August 177I, no. 10 A25 -, 11-13 December 1923, no. 963 C 39 copy 1 -,27 October 1927, no. 48 C 18 copy 2 -,8 November 1927, no. 10 A 15 copy 1 Ancram, Earl of, see Kerr, Sir Robert Andrassy, Count Julius C37 Andre, Edouard A 16 Angelis, de C4I Angell-Norris A30 copy 1 Ansell, Robert C4 Araignon C 15 Argyll, Duke of C39 Arkwright, Morton C I I Arundell, Anne Lucy, Lady C4 Arundell, Earl of C4 Asscher & Koetser C40 Asscher, Koetser & Welker A6 Asscher & Welker C4 Attems, Count A21 copy 4 Auspitz, Stephan von C 8, C 3 I copy 2 Aved, J. A.J. C. A 17, C 16, C 27 A ynard, Edouard C8 Bachstitz, K. W. C 8, C 31 copy 2 Barry, ComteJean du A 12 Bass, Edward A33 Becker, H. C 13 Beckerath, von C 34 copy 3 Beer, Jules A30 Beets, N. C35 Beit, Alfred C7 Beit, Lady C7 Beit, Sir Alfred Lane C7 Beit, Sir Otto John C7 Bell,John C3 Bentinck-Thyssen Bornemisza, A3 G. W. H. M. Baroness Beraudiere, Cornlesse de La A36 copy I Berens, R. B. C36 Bergh, Sidney J. van den C22 Berlin, 14 March 1905, no. 46 C 24 copy I Bernardi, Bartolo A 13 Beyer, F. A 26 copy 1 Beyers, A. M. A40 copy I Cottier & Co C42 Bingham, D. C22 Coymans, B. C4 Birnbaum, D. A 13 Cripps, F. A7 Bode, Catharina Elizabeth A35 Crozat, Fran<;ois C28 Bodeck-Ellgau A26 Crozat, Pierre C28 Boer, P. de A25 copy I, C2, Czernin, Count A27 C 13 Davies, Sir Francis john C 14 Bohler, julius A42, C 29 Davies, Warburton C'4 Bohn, H.G. C25 Dehn, Mrs. von C43 Boissiere, Ch. de B6 Delaborde, Countess Henri B5 Bonde, Count A21 Destouches A 17, A40 Bondy, O. C41 copy 9 Diemen, van C22 Borthwick Norton, Mrs. A33 Donaldson, Sir George C42 Bosch, jhr. van den A3 1 Donovan C 21 Bottenwieser C 13 Douwes, E. C 31 copy I Boughton Knight, A. R. C6 Dubois C 18 Boulton, M. P. W. A42 Dudley, Sir Henry Bate B4 Bout, Adriaan A34 Dubi-Muller, Mrs. A30 Boymans, F.j. O. C41 Dusseldorf, 17 October 19 I 3, no. 19 C41 copy 3 Braamcamp, Gerrit C4 Duffour, Xavier A35 Brandt, Gerard C 15 Duits, Ch. E. A33, C22 Brandt, Mortimer A8 copy I Duits, W. E. C 31 copy I Bredajr., Lucas van C 17 Dutuit, Auguste A40 Bredius, Dr. A. A31, B 7, C41 Dutuit, Eugene A40 Brimon, Vicomte de A30 Duval, jean Fran<;ois Andre A30 Brussels, 2 I july 1738, no. 3 I 2 C 19 copy I Epstein, M. AI6 -, 10 March 1927, no. 85 A22 copy 3 Escher, W. C. CII -, 16 December 1929, no. 29 C41 copy 2 Esterhazy, Count C34 -, 16 December 1936, no. 80 C2 Evers Bros. C 39 copy I -, 19 November 1956, no. 28 C34 copy I Eversdijck, M. D. van A 10, C 17 Buckingham, Duke of A20 Favre A 18 Burckhard t-Sarasin C23 Fechenbach, Carl Freiherr von A26 Burlet, Charles A. de C2 Fesch, Cardinal A 12 copy 4 Busch, R. C29 Fitzgerald, Mrs. Derek CI Buytene, Pieter van A3 Frankfurt, I I March 1907, no. 26 A 14 copy 2 Cailleux, P. C31 Franssen, C.j. H. C41 Calonne, de A 17 Fraula, Comte de C 19 copy I Carl, Landgrave of Hesse C26 Frederik Hendrik, Prince of Orange A 12, A24, A38, Cate, H. E. ten C37 A39 Catherine II, Empress of Russia C28 Friedrich I, King of Prussia A24, A39 Cavens, Count A22 copy 3 Friedrich Wilhelm I, King of Prussia A24, A38 Ceel, van der B6, C34 Frieson, von C30 Cesar A28 Gardner, Isabella Stewart A20 Cevat, D.H. A 14, C4 Gates, W. A30 copy I Chabot, ].]. M. A6 Gatschina Palace A22 copy 4 Chamberlain, W. B. B4 Gelder, M. van A36 copy 3 Charbonneaux, P. C9 Geldner, Max A9 Charlemont, james, 1st Earl of A 15 Gevigney, de A 17 Charles I, King of England A32, A33 Gheyn III, jacques de A 13, A 17, A32 Chase, William M. A 18 copy I copy I Chaussemiche, Benjamin C5 Giraud, P. C. A4 Choiseul-Praslin, Comte de A36 Goldschmidt, Salomon Benedikt A 14 copy 2 Christ, Tobias C43 Gonzaga, Prince C22 Churston, Lord A 18 Gotha, Herzogliches Museum AI9 Clowes, Dr. G. H. A. A22 copy I Gottschald, julius Otto C25 Coburg, Herzoglich Sachsen-Coburg- A 19 Gotzkowski, johann Ernst A27 Gotha'sche Familienstiftung Goudstikker, J. A2, A3, A9, A25 Coen, jean de C 19 copy I copy 2, C44 Cognacq, Ernest A2 Goudstikker /Miedl A 15 copy 2 Collet A 17 Gray, james CII Colnaghi, P & D A20 Grill, A. C37 Colnaghi, P & D and 0 bach A42 Guiche, Comte de la AI2 Conti, Prince de C 16 Gump, S. and G. A9 copy I Contini, Count A 15 copy 2 Gustav III, King of Sweden C 17 Cook, Sir Francis AIO Habet, Pieter A36, C 16 copy 2 Cosway, Richard C 14 Habich C30 688 INDEX OF PAINTINGS CATALOGUED IN VOLUME I

Hamilton C 14 Liphart, K. E. von A 28 copy I Harrington, Earl of C 14 Locq uet, Pieter A27 Harrison, Mrs. B7 London, 20 March 1899, no. 52 CI9coPY I Hartogs, Mrs. C34 -, 25]uly 1924, no. 127 C 19 copy I Heinemann, R. A9 -,6 May 1927, no. 48 A36 copy 6 Helflinger, Mrs. C 16 -, 19 December 1933, no. 120 A36 copy 4 Hellberg,lvar C40 -, 21]une 1950, no. 76 C 36 eopy I Herbst, Dr. A 36 copy 5 -,23 May 1951, no. 100 C8 Hermann, Ferdinand A2 -,25 May 1952, no. 148 A8 copy I Herzog, Baron B 6 eopy I -,27 May 1959, no. 135 A 14 Heugel, Henri C 34 copy I -,29 March 1974, no. S4 A8 Heydt, Karl von der C 10 -,4 May 1979, no. 106 C6 Hoeven, Elias van der B5 Loon, ] an van C 18 Hohenzollern-Hechingen, Furst zu A 12 Lopez, Alfonso A2 Hoogendijk, D. A. A 13 Louise Ulrika, Queen of Sweden C 17 Hope,]ames A 22 copy 3 Lubomirska, Princess Cecilia A 27 copy I Hoppe, de A29 Lubomirski, Prince A22 copy I Hoschek von Muhlheim, Gustav Ritter A2, C44 Lucerne, 30 August 1937, no. 1660 C 34 copy 2 Howgate, W. C 12 Lugt, F. BS Huck, Wolfgang C 13 MackaY,]ames E. A 14 Hussey, Eyre A9 Macquoid, Percy C25 letswaard, David C 14 Mandl, Ludwig C29 Isle and Dudley, Lord de l' A33 Marck Ezn., J. van der B S, C 18 I veagh, Lord A 15 Maris, Simon A2 Janssen, August A9 Marlborough Gallery C7 ] ariges, Philippus] oseph de A3° Marsmayer Ag copy I ]eude, Marinus de A 12 Matsukata, K. C 10 ]urschewitz C41 copy 5 Matsvansky A 14 copy 2 Kaempfen, Albert C 16 May, Mrs. F. C 21 K[ahn] A23 Mayer, M. C 18 Katz, D. A 7, A 9, C 4, C 34, Mayer, F. X. C 18 C36, C37 Mestral de Saint-Saphorin, Armand- A 22 eopy 5, A 3 I Katz, N. A7, A 15 copy 2, Fran<;ois-Louis de B I, C 36 Mettes C40 Kerr, Sir Robert A32 Meyer, Dr. Gotthelf A 14 copy 2 Keyzer, Louis C 19 copy I Mir A23 Kimball, W. W. A42 Mogin-Zorn, F. A40 copy 3 Kincaid-Lennox, W. M. P. C6 Mont, F. A22 copy I Kinschot, ]ohan Antony van A37 Montesquiou, Marquis de CII, CI3 Kleykamp A 14 sub copy I Morny, Comte de A30 Kleinberger, F. A2, B6, C9, C32, Morton, Earl of A18,C12 C 34, C 38, C 44 Mountain, Sir Edward B4 Klenglin, de C 10 Moyne, Lord A IS Knoedler & Co, M. A 14 sub copy I, Munnicks van Cleef B6 A23,A41 Murray, C. Fairfax C 18 copy I Krupp von Bohlen und Halbach C42 Nardus, L. C32 Kums, E. A40 copy I Nemes, Marczell von A42 Laan, W. F.J. C41 copy 6 Neufville, Pieter Leendert de A27 Lamann C 13 copy 2 Neufville-Goutard, Sophie Franziska de A25 Lamm, Carl Robert C36 Newcombe, F. C20 Lanckoronski, Count A 36 copy 2 New York, 16 May 1917, no. 250 A 18 copy I Langlois B6 Nikolaijevna, Grand Duchess Maria C43 Langton Douglas, R. A 18, A30, C 7 Norris, Mrs. Delara A. A 30 copy I Lareyniere, de C 13 Oldenburg, Grand-Ducal Gallery A37 La Roque A 18, C 12 Onnes van Nijenrode, M. C39 Lasse, Comte de A 12 Orange, Prince ]ohan Willem Friso A32 copy 2 Lawley, Stephen A4 1 Oudry, Alphonse A23 Lebrun,]. B. P. AI2,AI8,CI6, Oulmont, Dr. C 22 copy I C 18 Oxenden de Dene Ag Lennox, Denis C6 Pacully A 22 copy 2 Leopold II, King of the Belgians C38 Palmer, Eric C. C 16 copy 2 Lepelletier, General A 12 copy 4 Pama, P. A 16 Le Roy de la Faudignere C 13 Paris, 4 May 1903, no. 41 A22 copy 2 Leroy d'Estiolles A 16 ~ Is]une 19 14,no. 24 C 18 copy I Libbey, Edward Drummond A4 1 -,26 November 1974, no. 28 C36 Limburger, B. C 3 copy 3 -, Musee Napoleon Aq

689 INDEX OF PAINTINGS CATALOGUED IN VOLUME I

Patino, Antenor C36 Tschugin A3 Patterson, Alexander A 14 Turner, P. M. C 31 Pein, Otto C 10 Vassal de Saint-Hubert A 12 Pembroke, Thomas Earl of C 19 Vaudreuil, Comte de A40 Perier A25 Vienna, 28 March 1928, no. 84 A 22 copy 2 Perret C44 Vis, E. C37 Pierpont Morgan,]. C38 Voute, M. P. A37 Pitcairn, Theodore C 21 Warburg, james P. C 29, C 35 Preh,]. A28 copy 1 Warburg, Paul M. C 29, C35 Preyer, A. A 15 copy I, C42 Ward, Lord A20 Proli, Count Ch. de A3 I Ward, T. Humphry C 21 Rasch, H. A28 Warneck, E. A22 copy 2, C33 Reichenbach A 12 Wassenaer Obdam, Count of C27 Reinhardt, H. A4 I, A42 Wassermann, Dr. Max A27 copy 2 Remond A 17 Watson, Denis Elliot C3 Renouard C 16 Watson, Sir Remy C3 Reus, de A37 copy 2 Weber, E.F. A 12 Richardson, Frank R. A9 Westminster, Duke of C 13 Riddell, Sir] ohn B3 Whitting, W. B4 Riddell, Walter B3 Wildenstein C9 Robiano, Comte F. de A 16 Wilhelm II, Emperor of Germany A24 Robinson, Sir Charles j. A 10, C 34 copy I Wilhelm VIII, Landgrave of Hesse C 24, C 26 Robinson, Sir john Charles C 19 copy I Willem V, Prince of Orange A2I, A34 Rochard, Fran<,:ois Theodore A23 Winkler, Gottfried A30, C 38 Rover, Valerius A35 Winter, Mary A. A 14 Sagan, Ducal Castle A 12 W ttenbogaert, j oannes A 13, A 17 Sagert Cro Yerkes, Ch. Th. A30 copy I Saint Victor, Robert de C 18 Zetlerwalls, F olke A2I Salavin, L. A36 copy I Salzdahlum, Schloss C 15 Samuel, Lord B4 Sanderson, Arthur C42 Sawyer A20 Saxony, Elector of A37 copy I Schaeffer, Hans C2 Schamp d'Aveschoot,j. A40 Schellinger, Cornelia B6 Scheurleer, D. F. C44 Schickler, Baron Arthur de A 15 copy 1, A40 copy I Schley, Evander B. C38 Schmetz, A. C 24 copy I Schmidt van Gelder, P. A9 Scholten, Hendrick A 17 Schonborn, Count AII,A37 Sed elm eyer, Ch. A 16, A 30, C 9, C 21, C 34 copy I, C 4 I copy I, C 42 Severance, john L. A23 Sherman, Zoe Oliver A 18 Sichterman,]. A. A 13 SinebrychofT C44 Slingeland t, Govert van A2I Sommelinck, B. C2 Speelman, E. A7, B4 Steyn, Pieter B6 Stockholm (Bukowski), 8-1 I November C40 1961, no. 218 Stoop, F. C34 Strantwijk, johannes Lodewijk C5 Stratum, j. H. van A8 Stroganoff, Count Sergei A28 Thysscn-Borncmisza, H. Baron A3, A8 Tindinghorste, Everard George van A 12 Tooth A20 Tschager, j. A29

69 0 INDEX OF PAINTINGS CATALOGUED IN VOLUME I

Engravers Subjects

Only engravers from before the end of the 18th History paintings century mentioned in 6. Graphic Reproductions and in Bible Introduction, Chapter III, The documentary value OLD TESTAMENT of early graphic reproductions, are listed. Balaam and the ass A2 Samson betrayed by Dclilah A 24, C I Bailliu, Pieter de C [7 (fig. 5) and David with the head of Goliath before A9 Chapter III, pp. Saul 46-47 (fig. 23) David playing the harp before Saul Bernard, Johann A 22 (fig. 8) Esther's feast Bernard, Louis A22 Jeremiah lamenting the destruction of Bierweiller, F. C. A34 Jerusalem Bissel, A. C [3 Tobit and Anna Ciartres, see Langlois Tobit and Anna with the kid Cooper, Richard A20 Tobit at his son's return Dethier, Hendrik C 25 and Chapter III, pp. 44-45 (fig. NEW TESTAMENT 19) Simeon in the Temple Eeckhout, Gerbrand van den C 31 An old woman reading, probably the Frey, Johannes Pieter de A34 prophetess Anna (commonly called Goujon-Devilliers, Antoine Abraham A34 Rembrandt's mother) Hollar, Wenzel A 15, B6 The flight into Egypt Klauber, Ignaz Sebastian A30 The rest on the flight into Egypt Koninck, Salomon C 31 The raising of Lazarus Langlois, Fran<,:ois A29, B6 The rich man from the parable Le Bas A 12 Christ driving the moneychangers from Lebrun, Jean-Baptiste Pierre C 18 (fig. 2) the Temple Leeuw, Willem de A 25 (fig. 5), C::; The tribute money (fig. 4) and Chap• Judas, repentant, returning the pieces of ter III, pp. 46-5 I silver (figs. 24-27, 29) Christ at the column C8 Longhi, Giuseppe C25 Christ on the cross A35 Martin, David C39 The supper at Emmaus A 16 Michailoff, Pavel Nikolaivich A30 The stoning of S. Stephen AI Moitte, Fran<,:ois Auguste A 17 (fig. 4) The baptism of the eunuch A5 , Pietro A 13 (fig. 7) S. Peter in prison A36 Noordt, Joan van C 31 S. Paul in prison A I I Picart, Bernard A22 S. Paul at his writing-desk A26 Preisler, Valentin Daniel C24 S. Peter and S. Paul A [3 Rembrandt Chapter III, p. 35 Savery, Salomon Chapter III, p. 50 Mytholof!JI (fig. 30) Andromeda A3 I Schmidt, Georg Friedrich A27 (fig. 3), A28 Minerva in her study A38, C9 (fig. 7), A 36 (fig. 4) Proserpina, The abduction of - A39 Schnell, Michael A29 Schroter, Johann Friedrich C 38 (fig. 3) Unidentified subjects C [0 Stolker, Jan A 12 (fig. 6), A42 A biblical or historical nocturnal scene (fragment) Triere, Philippe AIl Visscher, Claes J ansz. Chapter III, p. 38 A Christian scholar in a vaulted room see under Other ('S. Anastasius') (fig. 5) scenes ... , Single Vliet, J. G. van A 14 (fig. 3), A 15, figures, full-length History painting A6 A29 (fig. 6), A37 (fig. 7), B6 (fig. 2), Musical allegory A7 C 22 (fig. 3) and Chapter III, pp. Scenes other than history paintings and figures other than portraits 35-46 (figs. I, 3, 6, 7,9, I I, 13-16, 18, Several figures 22) C [I Weisbrod, Carl Wilhelm A 12 (fig. 5) The foot operation B2 Worlidge, Thomas C39 (fig. 2) The operation crouch) The spectacles-pedlar (Sight) B3 Three singers (Hearing) BI Travellers resting C 12 Two old men disputing C 13 INDEX OF PAINTINGS CATALOGUED IN VOLUME I

Two old men disputing see under Bible, WOMEN New Testament, An old woman at prayer A27 S. Peter and Bust of an old woman (commonly called A32, C4I, C42, S. Paul Rembrandt's mother) C43 Single figuresJull-length and half-length MEN CHILDREN A Christian scholar in a vaulted room C 17 Bust of a young girl A hermit reading C 16 A man reading in a lofty room C 14 Portraits A man writing by candlelight C 18 A scholar reading C 15 Single sitters, identified An old man asleep by the fire, perhaps AI7 MEN typifying Sloth Rembrandt see under Single An old man with his arms crossed over figures, heads and his chest busts ... , men Half-length figure of a man in a turban Half-length figure of an old man in a gorget and black cap The artist in his studio The artist in oriental costume, with a poodle at his feet

WOMEN An old woman reading C 19, see also under Bible, New Testament, The prophetess Anna Single figures, heads and busts (' tronies'), including informal por• traits if the artist and his relatives MEN A man in a gorget and a plumed cap An old man in a gorget and cap (com- monly called Rembrandt's father) Bust of a laughing man (commonly called a Self-portrait of Rembrandt) Bust of a laughing man in a gorget B6 Bust of a man in a cap (commonly called Rembrandt's father) Bust of a man in a gorget and cap A8 Bust of a man in a plumed cap C23 Bust of a man looking downwards C3 I Bust of a man wearing a gold chain C32 Bust of a young man A23 Bust of a young man (commonly called C 35, C 38, C 39, a Self-portrait of Rembrandt) C40 Bust of a young man in a plumed cap A4 I Bust of a young man laughing C34 Bust of an old man C25 Bust of an old man in a cap (commonly B7 called Rembrandt's father) Bust of an old man in a fur cap (com- monly called Rembrandt's father) Bust of an old man looking downwards C27 Bust of an old man wearing a cross C26 Bust of an old man with a bald head C24 Bust of Rembrandt C36, C37 Head of an old man C22 Self-portrai t A 14, A 19, A20, A2I, A33 Self-portrait in a cap, with the mouth A22 open The artist in a cap and pleated shirt Indexes of comparative material and literary sources

Drawings and etchings by Ben. 1061 The conspiracy of Claudius Civilis, Munich 22,23 (or attributed to) Rem.brandt Ben. I 170 Young girl looking out of a window, Dresden 23 Ben. 1175 The anatomy lesson of Dr. Joan Deyman, Amsterdam 23

Names of cities refer to the main printroom there. ETCHINGS

DRAWINGS B.4 Self-portrait with a broad nose 648 (fig. 3) B. 7 Self-portrait in a soft hat and embroidered cloak 329 (fig. 6), 379 Ben. 6 verso Two figures seated in arm-chairs, Rotterdam 25, 186, B.9 Self-portrait, leaning forward, listening 632 187 (fig. 9), 189 B. 10 Self-portraitJrowning 632 Ben. 7 Old man with a book, seated, Berlin 149, 163, 165 (fig. 6), B. [3 Selfportrait open mouthed, as ifshouting 56, 343, 425, 632 16 7,281 B. 15 Self-portrait in a cloak with a falling collar 425 Ben. 8 Judas repentant, formerly Vienna, private collection 23, B. 17 Self-portrait in a cap and scarf [72, 388 185 (fig. 7), 186~190 B.24 Self-portrait in afur cap 56, 425 Ben. 9 recto Group of three priests or doctors in high caps at a table, B.25 (not by Rembrandt) Bust of Rembrandt with bushy hair 425 Amsterdam 22 (fig. 12), 186 (fig. 8), 187, 189, 193,255 B. 38 Joseph's coat brought to Jacob 379 Ben. 10 Oriental leaning on a stick, Berlin 335, 495 (fig. 6), 496 B·42 The blindness of Tobit 205, 476 Ben. II The supper at Emmaus, Cambridge, Mass. 201 B.44 The angel appearing to the shepherds 29 (fig. 20), 30 Ben. 15 S. Paul, Paris 167, 270 B. 51 Simeon in the Temple 56, 189, 335 Ben. 16 Bust of an apostle, Darmstadt 149, 281 B. 54 The flight into Egypt 48 I Ben. I7 The raising of Lazarus, London 5,25, 300 (fig. 6), 301, B.59 The rest on thejlight into Egypt 481 (fig. 4) 30 5 B. 62 The holy Jamify 486 Ben. I8 S. Jerome kneeling in prayer, Paris 38 B. 66 Christ disputing with the doctors 56, 552 Ben. I9 S. Jerome praying, Bremen 149, 28 I B. 69 Christ driving the mone.ychangers from the Temple 47, 92, 189, Ben. 20 Bearded old man seated in an arm-chair, Paris, colI. A. Delon I go (fig. [I) 149, 263, 28 I, 348, 543 B·73 The raising of Lazarus 35, 30 J, 302, 303 (fig. 8), 305, 306 Ben. 21 a (attributed to]. Lievens) A mounted trumpeter, Amster- B. 77 Ecce homo 30, 35, 200 dam 135,442,443,516 B.81 The descent from the cross 35,304,379 Ben. 30 recto Standing beggar, Amsterdam 54 B. go The good Samaritan 47 Ben. 31 Standing beggar with a leather bag, Amsterdam 54 B.93 (attributed to]. Lievens) The beheading of S.John the Ben. 32 Old beggar in a long cloak and high cap, Amsterdam 54 Baptist 442,444 (fig. 4) Ben. 37 Seated old man, Washington 149,281 B. 95 Peter and John at the gate of the Temple I go, 19 [, 495 Ben. 38 Seated old man, bowedforwards, Stockholm 149,281,587 B. 10 [ S. Jerome prrqing 379 Ben. 39 Bust of a bearded old man, Paris 149, 270, 281 B. J 04 S. Jerome reading in an Italian landscape 30 Ben. 40 Old man seated in an arm-chair, Haarlem, Teyler Museum B. 105 S. Jerome in a dark chamber 552 149, 26 3,281,348,543 B. [34 Old woman seated in a cottage with a string ofonions on the wall Ben. 41 Old man with clasped hands, seated in an arm-chair, Berlin 562 149, 26 3,281,348,543,579 B. 142 A Polander standing with his stick .'i6 Ben. 42 Bearded old man, Washington 149,281 B. 149 S. Paul in meditation 167,270 Ben. 44 An old Pole, formerly Lugano, private collection 379 B.152 The Persian 328 (fig. 5), 329, 379 Ben. 45 A Polish officer, standing, Leningrad 379 B. 153 The blindness of Tobit 476 Ben. 46 Scholar pondering beside his writing table, Paris 537 (fig. 4) B. 165 Beggar man and lfloman behind a hank 56 Ben. 51 (attributed to J. Lievens) Afoot operation, Florence 442, B. 190 A man making water 56 5 16,5 1 7 (fig. 5) B. Ig2 The artist drawing from the model 30 Ben. 53 Self-portrait, bust, London 2 I I, 2 I 6 B. 20 I Diana at the bath 54, 3 I 3, 371 Ben. 54 Self-portrait, bust, Amsterdam 216 B.260 Bust of an old bearded man looking downwards 149, 28 [,543, Ben. 56 Rembrandt'sfather, Oxford 149,270,580 546 (fig. 8), 579, 621, 664 Ben. 76 The centurion of Capernaum kneeling before Christ, Rotter- B. 262 Old man with beard,fur cap and lIelvet cloak 54, [49, 28 I, 60 I dam 25 B. 263 Bearded man in a JliTred oriental cap and robe 319, 422, 615 Ben. 82 Lot drunk, Frankfurt 25, 149, 28 I B. 286 The first oriental head 40 Ben. 90 Abraham's sacrifice, London 23 B.287 The second oriental head 40 Ben. 92 The rape of Ganymede, Dresden 23 B. 288 The third oriental head 40 Ben. 95 Jacob lamenting at the sight of Joseph's blood-stained coat, B. 29 I Bust of an old man withflowing beard and white sleelle 579 Berlin 87 B. 292 Bald-headed man in right profile 41, 56, 204 Ben. 106 A man infetters, lamenting, Munich 87 B.294 Bald-headed man in right profile: small bust 4 I, 604 Ben. 136 Solomon's idolatry, Paris 335 B.298 (not by Rembrandt) Bald man looking downwards 591 Ben. 317 Young woman in rich oriental costume and head-dress, Berlin B·304 },;[an wearing a dose cap 289, 436, 437 (fig. 4), 615 121 B.309 Old man with aJlowing beard 149, 281 Ben. 390 An artist in his studio, Portinscale, coli. F. Springell 21 I B. 3 [[ A1an in a broad-brimmed hat 56 Ben. 430 Self-portrait, bust, Marseilles 172 B. 3 I 2 Bust of an old man with afur cap 149, 281,60 I Ben. 442 Portrait of a lady holding afan, London 23 B. 315 Old man with ajlowing beard 149, 281, 579 Ben. 567 The holy family in the carpenter's workshop, Bayonne 23 B'316 S'elf-portrait in a cap, laughing 247, 632 3en. 58 I The circumcision, Munich 23 B.320 Self-portrait in a cap, with e.yes wide opened 632 3en. 757 Portrait of a lady, with an open book on her knees, Rotter• B. 32 [ Bust of a man wearing a high cap 56, 204, 289, 575 dam 23 B.325 Bust of an old man with aflowing beard 149, 281, 587 :en. 872 Tobit asleep, Rotterdam 206 B. 338 Self-portrait, roughly etched 8,56, 112, 172, 211, 216, 22g, ',en. 969 S. John the Baptist preaching, Paris 23 247,429,636 INDEXES OF COMPARATIVE MATERIAL AND LITERARY SOURCES

B. 343 The artist's mother seated at a table 54, '274, 3 I 9, 664 Buytewech, W. 458 B. 348 The artist's mother seated, in an oriental headdress '274, 664 - (etching by]. van de Velde) , Tobit and Anna with the kid 86 B. 35'2 The artist's mother: head only,Jullface 56,57, T56, '273, 3 T9, Caravaggio, Madonna di Loreto, Rome, S. Agostino 200 670 -, Madonna del Rosario, Vienna '200 B.353 (not by Rembrandt) Bust of an old woman 670 (fig. 3), Carracci, Annibale, Pieta, Parma 191 67'2 Collaert, A., see under M. de Vos B.354 The artist's mother: head and bust 56, 156, '273, 319,670 Coornhert, D. V., see under M. van Heemskerck B.374 Three studies if old men's heads 604 Cornelisz., C. - van Haarlem, Portrait if the foal Pieter van der Morsch, sale London 19'29633 Cort, C., see under M. Venusti Works by artists other than Rembrandt Coter, C. de, S. Luke painting the Virgin, Vieure, Allier '28 Crabeth II, W., SS. Peter and Paul, Lincoln, University of For engravers after Rembrandt paintings, see also: Nebraska Art Galleries 166, 167 (fig. 9) Index of paintings catalogued in volume I, Danckerts, C., see under F. Hals and]. Leyster Engravers. Dethier, H. (etching), Bust if an old man 44, 45 (fig. 19) Names of cities refer to the main museum or print• Dou,G·3,35,45,48,50, 112, 165,235,319,403,422,436,464, room there. 476,486,537,544,569,595,608,665 Tobit and Anna, Paris 465 Alberti, C., see under: Rosso Fiorentino An artist in his studio, Duisburg, private collection '26, '2 I '2 Anonymous, ft,lan with a watch, whereabouts unknown '2'23 (fig. 4) - An artist in his studio, London, L. Koetser 197'2 '2 I 2 (etching), Judas repentant 193 An artist in his studio, London, coiL Lord Northbrook '205 - (-), Bustifa man looking downwards 6'21 (fig. 3) - An artist in his studio, London, coil. Lord Samuel 2 I '2 (-), Bust if Rembrandt with bushy hair 4'25 An artist in his studio, N ew York, N ew York Historical Society (-), Bust if an old woman 670 (fig. 3),67'2 '212 - (miniature), see under: Stavelot Bible An artist in his studio, private collection 48 I, 48'2 (fig. 5) (woodcut), see under: Biblia pauperum, Speculum hum• - An astronomer, Leningrad 205, 476 anae salvationis, Vorsterman Bible The young mother, The Hague 336 Baburen, D. van (engraving by C. Bloemaert), Flute-player 403 Man smoking a pipe, formerly Vienna, coil. Czartoryski 465 Backer,]. A. 50 Old man smoking in his study, formerly Prague, Galerie Nostiz -, Hippocrates visiting Democritus, Milwaukee, coil. Dr. A. Bader 205 '281 -, Old woman eating, Schwerin 465 Bailliu, P. de 46-47,51 -, Old woman peeling apples, formerly Berlin, coil. Huldschinsky - (engraving), 'So Anastasius' 47 (fig. '23),55 1,55'2 (fig. 5),553 465 Berkheyde,]., Self-portrait, Florence '26 -, Bust oj a man in a plumed cap, Kassel '205 Beyeren, L. van 608 -, Head if a man, formerly Paris, art trade 3'20 (fig. 4) Biblia pauperum (woodcut), Balaam and the ass 80 - (attribution), Tobit and Anna (no. C 3), London 461-466 Bisschop, C. de 35 (-), A soldier, Budapest 500 Blockland t, A. (drawing), Andromeda, Brussels 3 I 3 (suggested attribution), Theflight into Egypt (no. C 5), Tours Bloemaert, A. 45 I 478-482 , 5 ID, 557 (engraving by C. Bloemaert), Avaritia T39, 14T (fig. 5) - (-), A biblical or historical nocturnal scene (no. C 10), Tokyo (-) , Two children singing 403 508-5 11 (-), Old woman with a rosary 273 (fig. 2), 274 (-), A man writing by candlelight (no. C 18), Milwaukee, coil. - (engraving by W. van Swanenburg), S. Paul 148, 270 (fig. 4) Dr. A. Bader 554-558 - (-), S. Peter repentant 348 (fig. 3), 349 (or]. Lievens), Eli instructing Samuel, on loan to Amsterdam, (-), The sinners of the Old and New Testaments: Judas 191 Rijksmuseum 563, 565 (fig. 5), 566 Bloemaert, C., see under: D. van Baburen, A. Bloemaert and (engraving by Reveil), Tobit and Anna at prayer 465 G. van Honthorst Droochsloot,]. C., An artist in his studio, Macon 26 Bol, F. 35, 247 Dufour, P. (engraving), Jacob recognizing Joseph's blood-stained -, Bust oj an old man, Basle '291 coat 87 -, (drawing), Holy Family, Darmstadt 486 Durer, A. (engraving), Melancholia 1362,363 Bosch, H., The Four Last Things and the Seven Deadly Sins, Madrid Dusart, C. (drawing), An artist in his studio, Amsterdam 26 206 Dyck, A. van 23, 395, 444 Bramer, L., Thejudgment of Solomon, several versions 189 -, The apostle Thomas, Essen, coil. Krupp von Bohlen und -, The queen of Sheba bifore Solomon, several versions 189 Halbach 128 Bray, S. de 457 - (engraving by P. de]ode), Portrait of Jan van Montfort 396 Bril, P. 544 Ecckhout, G. van den 35 Brouwer, A. 206, 628 - (copy after), S. Paul on the island of Malta, The Hague, Brugghen, H. ter 45 I, 458 Museum Bredius 5 10, 5 I I (fig. 2) , Samson and Delilah, mentioned in an Amsterdam inventory EIshcimer, A. 71, 73,371 of 1691 '255 -, The martyrdom if S. Lawrence, London 120 , Pilate washing his hands, Kassel 457 -, Il contento, Edinburgh 370 -, The deliverance if S. Peter, France, private collection '255 (engraving by H. Goudt), Philemon and Baucis 200 (fig. 5) -, The deliverance of s. Peter, Schwerin '255 - (etching by W. Hollar), Minerva 363 Bry, ]. Th. de (engraving from Emblemata saecularia 161 I), - (engraving by P. Soutman), The martyrdom ofS. Lawrence 120 Young woman fooling her old husband 4 15 Fabritius, B. (?; drawing), Seated oriental figure, Windsor Castle Bueckelaer,]., Merry company, Antwerp '205 (fig. 3), 206 306 Fabritius, C. 35, 536 -, Manoah's sacrifice, formerly Rotterdam, Museum Boymans -, The raising of Lazarus, Warsaw 306 453 Flinck, G. 35 -, Samson and Delilah, sale 1806 255 , The rest on the flight into Egypt, Bayeux 486 -, The ceremonial reception of David with the head oj Goliath, lost Galle, Ph., see under M. van Heemskerck and J. Stradanus since 1830 135 Gelder, A. de 20, 35 - David's letter to Uriah, Groningen 189, 263 , The blessing oj Tobias and his bride Sarah, whereabouts un• - The triumph of Mordecai, Amsterdam, Rembrandthuis 20 known 356 The raising oj Lazarus, The Hague 305, 306 -, Esther preparing to intercede with Ahasuerus, London, Edw. The baptism of the Eunuch, Berlin 101 Speelman Ltd 1956 121,122 , The baptism oj the Eunuch, Karlsruhe IO I (fig. 7) -, An artist in his studio, Frankfurt 26 The baptism of the Eunuch, Munich 101 Gherwen, R. van 35 The baptism oj the Eunuch, Paris, colI. F. Lugt (Fondation Gheyn II,J. de (engraving), A woman quarrelling with her husband Custodia) 101 87 - Coriolanus and the Roman women, Dublin, Trinity College 71, Gheyn III, J. de (by or copy after), The apostle Paul, London 112, 134, 135 (fig. 6) 562 -, Hermit reading, formerly Brussels, colI. Baron L. Janssen 544 - (etching), The apostle Paul 148 Leeuw, W. de 46-51 - (-), The philosopher Chilo 270 -, see also under J. Lievens Goudt, H., see under A. Elsheimer (etching), David playing the harp to Saul 48, 49 (fig. 25), 264 Goyen, J. van 200, 485 (fig. 5) Grebber, P. de, Belshazzar'sJeast, Kassel 452 (-), Tobit and Anna 48,49 (fig. 26),465 (flg. 4) -, The raising oj Lazarus, Turin 306 (-), Young woman 47, 48 (fig. 24) Guercino 456 (-; attributed), 'Mariana' 50, 51 (fig. 9) Hals, F. 452, 458, 459, 626 (-; -), Bust oj a young man with neckerchief and Jeathered cap 49, -, Young man holding a skull, London 223 50 (fig. 27) - (engraving by C. Danckerts) , Two children with a cat 5 I Lesire, P., The Cumaean si~yl, whereabouts unknown 356 (fig. Hecken, A. van der, Judas repentant, Leningrad 193 6), 597 Heem, J. D. de, Still-life with books, Amsterdam 120 -, Bust oj ayoung man, Hanover 235, 597 -, Still-life with books, The Hague 120 Leyden, L. van 3 1, 58 Heemskerck, M. van (engraving), The prodigal son 120 -, The Last Judgment, Lciden 148, 166 - (etching by D. V. Coornhert), Balaam and the ass 80 (engraving), The life oJJoseph series 405 (engraving by Ph. Galle), Samson and Delilah 255 (-), David playing the harp before Saul 263 (-), Acta Apostolorum series: S. Peter in prison 348 - (-), SS. Peter and Paul in a landscape 166 - (-), Acta Apostolorum series: Baptism oJthe Eunuch 102 (fig. 8) - (-), Young man with a skull 223 Hollar, W., see under A. Elsheimer (woodcut), TheJatal power oj women series oj 1514: Samson and Honthorst, G. van 122,451,459 Delilah 255 Granida and Daifilo, Utrecht 255 - (-), TheJatal power oJwomen series oj 1517: Samson and Delilah The dentist, Dresden 405 255 Merry company, Munich 405 Leyster, J. 452 - Old woman examining a coin by lantern light, whereabouts un• - (engraving by C. Danckerts) , Two children with a cat 5 I known 141, 142 (fig. 6) Lievens,j. 3, 7,3 I, 35,40,56, 135, 173, 204, 2 I 1,234,255, 3 I 9, (engraving by C. Bloemaert), Old woman holding a candle and a 362,370,380,442,443,452,453,476,527,563,575,672 purse 141, 142 (fig. 7) -, Samson betrayed by Delilah, Amsterdam 255, 442, 444, 455, (-), Old woman singing 403 456 (fig. 9) Hoogstraten, S. van (etching, attributed), Bust of an old woman , Job on the dungheap, Ottawa 459, 476, 563 670 (fig. 3) -, The raising oj Lazarus, Brighton 30 1, 305, 306 Jacobsz., L. 380, 544 -, The raising oJLazarus, mentioned in Rembrandt's inventory -, The apostle Paul, Leeuwarden 270 of 1656305 Jode, P. de, see under A. van Dyck -, Pilate washing his hands, Leiden 442, 457 J ouderville, I. de 380 -, Christ at the column, The Hague, S. Nystad 1979454,455 (fig. Saul and David, Warsaw 507 8),456,458 Bust of ayoung man, Dublin 247, 505, 507 (fig. 6) Christ on the cross, Nancy 343, 344 (fig. 6) Young man laughing, The Hague, Bredius Museum 247 - The apostle Paul, Bremen 270 Man in oriental costume, private collection 505, 506 (fig. 4) The Jour evangelists, Bamberg 455 Knee-lengthfigure oj a woman, private collection 505, 507 (fig. S. Jerome, Leiden 200, 444 5) - A hermit, mentioned in Rembrandt's inventory of 1656544 - (attribution), Minerva in her study (no. C 9), Denver 502-507 Vertumnus and Pomona, whereabouts unknown 165 Keihl, E. 35 - Homo bulla, Besan<;:on 453 Koedijck, I. 476 - Allego~y on the five senses, Chicago, colI. Taylor 457, 458 Koninck, Ph. 35 - Student reading at the jire, formerly colI. Charles I 562 Koninck, S. 35, 505, 565, 569 Young man blowing on a torch, Warsaw 453 -, Judas repentant, formerly Bonn, Provinzial-Museum 193 - Young man with a pipe blowing on a glowing coal, vVarsaw 453, Lastman, P. 3, 23, 72, 73,81, I I I, 13 0 , I4I, 190,452 454 (fig. 7) -, Abraham's sacrifice, Amsterdam, Rembrandthuis 444 - Man singing, New Yark, colI. J. Reder 403 -, Balaam and the ass, New York, coli. Richard L. Feigen 79 (fig. - An oriental, Sanssouci 46 5) Head oj a young man (self-portrait?), Copenhagen 4 I (fig. IO)

695 INDEXES OF COMPARATIVE MATERIAL AND LITERARY SOURCES

- Bust of an old man, Dublin 205, 632 Poorter, W. de 501, 505 - Bust ~f an old man, Leipzig 128 -, The circumcision, Kassel 335, 336 - Bust oj an old man, Schwerin 563,620 (fig. 2),62 I -, Christ and the woman taken in adultery, Dresden 335, 336, 495 - Old woman reading, Amsterdam 458 (fig. 7),496 - (attribution), Samson betrayed by Delilah (no. C I), Amster- -, The raising of Lazarus, Munich 306 dam 439-445 -, Woman weighing gold, Raleigh 496 - (-), Esther'sfeast (no. C 2), Raleigh 71, 120,446-460 - (attribution), Simeon in the Temple, Dresden 496 - (suggested attribution), TheJootoperation (no. C 1 I), Switzer- Pot, H. (attribution), Old woman making lace, England, private land, private collection 5 I 2-5 I 8 collection 420 (fig. 4) - (-), IIalf-length figure of a man in a turban (no. C 2 I ), Philadel• Pynas,jacob 73, 459, 476 phia 572-575 -, Paul and Barnabas at Lystra, Amsterdam 7 I - (or G. Dou), Eli instructing Samuel, on loan to Amsterdam, -, The stoning qf S. Stephen, formerly London, colI. Dr. E. Rijksmuseum 563, 565 (fig. 5), 566 Schapiro 72 - (wrongly attributed), Head of a b~v, Amsterdam 453 Pynas, jan 73, 459 - (drawing), Moses praying during the battle against the Amalekites, -, The raising of Lazarus, Aschaffenburg 306 Leipzig 442, 443 Quast, P., A man in a plumed cap, Rotterdam 420,42 I (fig. 5) - (-), Christ in Gethsemane, Dresden 442, 443 (fig. 3) Raimondi, M. A., see under Raphael - (-), A hermit, London 444 - (engraving), David cutting off the head rif Goliath 72 - (-), Mercury and Argus, Dresden 444 - (-), 'La Vierge au berceau' 156, 157 (fig. 9) - (-), Mucius Scaevola and Porsenna, Leiden 443 Raphael, S. Cecilia with Jour saints, Bologna 149 - ( ), Afoot operation, Florence 442,516,5 I7 (fig. 5) - (tapestry), S. Paul in prison, Rome, Vatican 148 - (-), A mounted trumpeter, Amsterdam 135,442,443,516 - (-), The blinding oj Elymas, Rome, Vatican 476 - (etching), Jacob anointing the stone at Beth-El T02 - (engraving by M. A. Raimondi), S. Paul preaching in Athens - (-), The raising of Lazarus 301 (fig. 7), 305 30 5 (fig. 9) - (-), The beheading ofS. John the Baptist 442,444 (fig. 4) - (-), ihe death of Ananias 305 (fig. 10),306 - (-), S. Jerome 200,444 - (engraving by A. Veneziano), The blinding of Elymas 476 - (-), A hermit 544 Rembrandt (anonymous draughtsman after), An old man read• - (-), A hermit 444, 544 ing, Weimar 542,545 (fig. 7),621 - (-), Mercury and Argus 444 - (imitation), Minerva, The Hague 362 - (-), Bust rif an oriental, in left profile 289 Rembrandt school, The parable rif the hidden treasure, Budapest - (-), Bust rif an old man 320 486 - (-), Bust rifa man in a turban 422 - (drawing), Samson and Delilah, Leiden 255 - (-), Variae effigies: Bust of ayoung man in right profile 40 - (-), Seated oriental figure, Windsor Castle 306 (-), Bust of an old oriental in l~ft profile 40 Reni, G., The assumption rif the Virgin, Genoa, S. Ambrogio 349 (-), Bust rif an oriental in right profile 40, 205, 289 -, S. Peter weeping, Florence, Palazzo Pitti 349 (-), Bust rif an old man in left profile 40 -, The apostles Peter and Paul, Milan 166, 28 I (-), Bust rif an oriental infront 40,205 Reveil, see under G. Dou (-), Bust q/ an old man in right profile 40 Roghman, R. 35 (-), Bust rif a young man in right profile 40 Roman relief, The abduction rif Proserpina, Louvre 370 - (-; attributed), Head rif a man 320 (fig. 5) - (engraving in Galleria Giustiniani 165 I ), Battle scene 80 (fig. 6), - (-; -), Bust oj a man looking downwards 320 92 - (etching by W. de Leeuw), S. Paul the Hermit 47,48 Romano, G., The stoning rif S. Stephen, Genoa, S. Stefano 72 - (etchingbyj.G.vanVliet),IsaacandEsau456,457 (fig. TO), Rosso Fiorentino (engraving by Ch. Alberti), The stoning rif S. 458 Stephen 73 Lorrain, C. 102 Rousseau(x),j. de(s) 49,420,584 Luther Bible, see Chr. Murrer Roymerswaele, M. van 141 Maes, N. 35 Rubens, P. P. 18,35,47,121,122,444 Mallery, K. de, see under M. de Vos - Samson and Delilah, London 255 Master of thej udgment of Solomon, SS. Peter and Paul, London, - The adoration oJthe Magi, Lyon 134,380 P. & D. Colnaghi & Co. Ltd 1976/77 167 (fig. 8) - The miracle of S. Francis Xavier, Vienna 305 Matham, j., see under P. P. Rubens - The miracle oj S. l,gnatius, Vienna 305 Metsu, G., Old woman reading, Amsterdam 355 - The abduction oj Proserpina, Madrid 371 Michelangelo, The fall rif man, Rome, Sistine Chapel 255 - Portrait rif Nicolas de Respaigne, Kassel 380 -, The Doni Madonna, Florence 255 - (engraving by j. Matham), Samson and Delilah 442 - (drawing), Christ on the cross, London 343 - (engraving by P. Pontius), Christ on the cross 343 (fig. 5), 344 MoerentorfBible, see C. van Sichem - (etching by P. Soutman), The abduction rif Proserpina 370, 37 I Moeyaert, C. C. (drawing), Judas repentant, New York, colI. (fig. 4) E. E. Wolf 193 - (engraving by L. Vorsterman), Christ on the cross 343 Molenaer,j. M. 17 - (anonymous engraving after L. Vorsterman), The adoration Mol~jn, P. de 485 rifthe Magi 120, 134, 136 (fig. 7),380 (fig. 6) Moreelse, P. 45 I Ruisdael, J. van, A ruined castle gateway, London 200 Murrer, Chr. (woodcut in the Luther Bible), Judas repentant 191 Ruysdael, S. 485 Muziano, G. 544 R~jckaert III, D., An artist in his studio, Paris 26 Ostade, A. van 495, 542, 544 (fig. 6) Sadeler, E., see under j. Tintoretto Patinir, j. 544 Sadeler IT, R., see under L. Sustris Pontius, P., see under P. P. Rubens

696 INDEXES OF COMPARATIVE MATERIAL AND LITERARY SOURCES

Saint-Aubin, G. de (after Rembrandt), Simeon in the Temple, - (-), An old man in aJur cap 40, 42 (fig. I 1),46,291 (fig. 6) Paris, Musee du Petit Palais 155, 156, 157 (fig. 8) - (-), An old woman reading 39, 40 (fig. 7),51,355,357 (fig. 7) Santvoort, D. van, The supper at Emmaus, Paris 201 (-; wrongly attributed), Bust oj an old man 46, 47 (fig. 22) Savery, S. 51 Vorsterman, L. see under: P. P. Rubens - (detail of engraved portrait frame), The clementia of king Vorsterman Bible (woodcut), Jeremiah lamenting 282, 283 (fig. Wladislaus IV I 12 (fig. 8) 6) (pu blisher), The driving-out of the money-changers Jrom the Vos, M. de 544 Temple 47 - (engraving by A. Collaert), Acta Apostolorum series: The bap• (-), Bust oj an old man 50,51 (fig. 30) tism oj the Eunuch 102 Schooten,]. van 40 - (engraving by K. de Mallery), leones Illustrium Feminarum -, The company oj Comelis van Kerchem, Leiden 458 Novi Testamenti series: The prophetess Anna 355, 356 (fig. 5) Sichem, C. van (woodcut in the Moerentoif Bible), The repentance Wet I,]. de, The raising of Lazarus, whereabouts unknown 306 oj S. Peter 87 -, Judas repentant, Copenhagen and London, art market 1952 Soutman, P. 47 193 -, see also under: A. Elsheimer, P. P. Rubens Willmann, M. L. L. (etching), Bearded man 422 (fig. 6) Speculum humanae salvationis (woodcut), Balaam and the ass - (-; attributed), Bust ~f an old woman 670 (fig. 3) 80 - (-), Saul throwing his spear at David 263 - (-), Jeremiah lamenting 282 Literary sources Spreeuwen,]. van, A philosopher in his study, Amsterdam 206 Stavelot Bible (initial), Jeremiah lamenting 282 Alciati, A., Emblematum liber, Augsburg 1531 102 Steen,]. 628 Anonymous, Die historie van den ouden Tobias ende synen sone den -, The miser, Copenhagen 139 jongen Tobias, Amsterdam 1617 87 Steenwyck II, H. van, S. Jerome in his study, Maastricht 552,553 Brussels Manuscript of 1635 2 I (fig. 6) Burton, R., The anatomy oj Melancholy, Oxford 1621 282 Stolker,]. (drawing), Fancy portrait of Rembrandt, London 155 Claudianus, De raptu Proserpinae 371 (fig. 6), 156 Commonplace-book of 1640/50 23, 24 - (-), Fancy portrait of , London 155, 156 (fig. 7), 157 Hoogstraeten, S. van, Inleiding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkonst, Stradanus,]. (engraving by Ph. Galle), Christ driving the money• Rotterdam 1678 22, 23, 2 I I changers Jrom the Temple 92 Huygens, C. 344, 363, 370, 371 Sustris, L. (engraving by R. Sadeler II), The abduction ojProser• -, Poemata (Ms.) 235 pina 371 -, Vita (Ms.) 7, 185, 191, 192 (fig. 13) Swanenburgh, 1. van, The making oj cloth (6, originally 7 Lairesse, G. de, 'tGroot schilder-boek, Amsterdam 1709 23, panels), Leiden 25 25,30,31 Swanenburgh, W. van, see under: A. Bloemaert Lebrun, P., see Brussels Manuscript of 1635 Tempesta, A. 481 Latombe, A. 19 - (title print after), The abduction of Proserpina 371 Mander, C. van, Den grondt der edel vry schilder-const, Haarlem Tintoretto,]., The abduction ojProserpina, in 1618 in the colI. Sir 1604 18, 23, 24, 25 Dudley Carlton, The Hague 371 -, Wtlegghingh op den Metamorphosis, Haarlem 1604 314 - (engraving by E. Sadeler), The last supper 200 -, Uytbeeldinge der figueren, Haarlem 1604 363 Veen, O. van, Claudius Civilis laying siege to Vetera, Amsterdam Marshall, Th., see Commonplace-book of 1640/50 510 Mauden, D. van, Speculum aureum vitae moralis seu Tobias ad vivum Velasquez, Los barrachos, Madrid 200 delineatus, Antwerp 1631 87 Velde, E. van de 102 Mayerne Manuscript, De 19, 26 Velde,]. van de, see under W. Buytewech Molanus, 1., De historia ss. imaginum et picturarum pro vero earum usu Vellert, D. (drawing), Balaam and the ass, Braunschweig 79 contra abusus libri IV, Louvain 1594 166 Veneziano, A., see under: Raphael Picinellus, Ph., Mundus symbolicus, Cologne 1695 80, 122 Venusti, M. (engraving by C. Cort), The stoning oJS. Stephen 72 Plantijn, C., Thesaurus theutonicae linguae, Antwerp 1573 Visscher, c.]. (publisher), The baptism oJthe Eunuch 38 (fig. 5), 206 102 Plemp, C. G., Epigrammatum libri IX, Amsterdam 1638 48, Vliet, ]. G. van 8, 35-46, 49, 5 I, 228, 428, 5 I 6, 543 49, 263,465 -, see also under:]. Lievens Plinius 2 I I - (drawing; attributed), Lot and his daughters, London 36 (fig. Revius, ]., Over-rsselsche sangen en dichten, Deventer 1630 2),42 102,122 (etching), Lot and his daughters 36 (fig. I), 5 I Ripa, C., Iconologia, Amsterdam 1644 570 (-), The resurrection 4 I Schabaelje, ]. Ph., Den grooten emblemata sacra, Amsterdam (-), The baptism oJthe Eunuch 36,37 (fig. 3), 5 I, 102,3 I 2,370, 1654 49, 50 379 Struys, ]., Ontschakingh van Proserpina, Amsterdam 1634 (-), S. Jerome kneeling in prayer 36, 38, 39 (fig. 6), 51 37 1 (-), An old oriental 40, 44, 45 (fig. 18) (-), Bust oj a laughing man in a gorget 40,43 (fig. 14),45,429 (fig. 2) (-), A man grieving 40,44 (fig. 16),45,580 (-), Bust oJayoung man 43 (fig. 13),45,173 (fig. 3) (-), Ayoung man in a gorget and cap 40,41 (fig. 9) (-), BustoJan oldman 43 (fig. 15),44,45,579 (fig. 3),604 Concordance

In the first column are the catalogue numbers in HdG Bredius Bauch Gerson Hofstede de Groot, Bredius, Br.-Gerson, Bauch and Gerson. The corresponding catalogue num- Br.-Gerson bers in the present work are listed under the names A9 C 19 34 ------of these authors. 35 A25 C42 36 B7 HdG Bredius Bauch Gerson 37 A32 Br.-Gerson 38 A20 A 14, A2 A6 40 C36 copy I 41 AI A33 AI C2 42 A4 A29 2 A 19 A3 AI 43 C5 C20 3 A22, A9 A9 44 C10 B5 copy I 45 C8 C37 A3 C43 46 A 12 A42 4 C35 A24 A3 47 A 15 B4 5 C34 A 13 A4 48 C7 6 C 13 A2 49 A28 A 16 C28 A6 C3 50 C 12 C26 7 C36 A25 C10 51 A30 8 A20 C5 52 A34 A4I 9 C37 A24 54 A35 10 C38 A 12 55 A3 I I I B5 A 13 56 A35 12 A33 A 15 57 A39 13 C39 A25 63 A27 14 C40 A 16 64 C42 15 C33 C7 64 a A3 16 A40 A30 65 C43 17 A34 66 C3 18 A7 67 C4I 19 A10 68 C 19 20 A 18 69 A37 21 C14 70 A32 22 All 73 C20 23 A26 74 C29 24 A28 76 A29 25 A36 77 B7 26 A2 C17 78 C30 27 A37 79 B4 A27 C33 80 A34 C28 28 A8 81 A 12 A42 29 C22 87 C6 30 A 14, 89 C 12 copy I 90 A38 31 C30 96 A6 32 A 19 97 A7 33 A24 C34 98 C I I 698 CONCORDANCE

HdG Bredius Bauch Gerson HdG Bredius Bauch Gerson Br.-Gerson Br.-Gerson 177 A 26 99 ._------101 179 All ------107 A 30, 186 C 17 --_.__ .- _. 19 2 C 16 copy 1 ... ____._ ------107 a A 30 195 A 31 109 A8 209 A38 .._------_._------_._------_. I 10 AIO 2 I I C 9 I I I All 21 3 A 39 ---- I 12 A 18 228 C 15 I 13 B6 240 C 18 ----_._-- ._---_... 114 C 29 249 C42 ------_._------115 C 31 A27 -- 116 B7 A32 ------II7 C7 C28 25 2 A37 ..__ ... _------.- _._--_. 118 C 18 253 A38 .. _----- I 19 C 14 254 A3 1 ----_._.. _- 120 A26 266 ----_._--- 121 A 17 282 A 10 .. ----_. ------122 A 36 28 A 14 -_.. _---- 7 123 AI5, C 20 288 A 14,

____c_oP ..... y __ I__ _ copy I ------124 A29 28 A22, ~----- 9 125 C 16 copy 1 126 C 8 290 A 19 -._------12 A28 29 1 C35 7 ------cc------._------128 C 26 29 2 A20 ---_. -- ---_._----_.- ._---- 12 293 C38 9 .. __._-- 13 0 C36 ._--_... 13 2 A8 C39 . ------._---- 133 C~n C21 297 A33 ------_.- 134 B6 A36 298 C34 ----_ .. --- _._------135 C 32 C I7 299 B5 ------_. _ .. 00 3 ._------C37 - 137 C3 1, 01 A40 ---3 --- copy 2 316 A37 138 C31, A41 320 C 19 .._._---- copy I 28 3._._._------138A C 31 333 C 10 ----.. ---.~-- --_._ ...... _._-_._------140 C 25 343 C 13 C22 --_._. 141 C 26 344 C25, 142 copy I ---- 143 A 41 345 C 2 I C27 147 A 16 C30 . __. 347 148 C 24 350 A40 ------_. --_. -- --_.------156 A 23 371 C26

699 CONCORDANCE

HdG Bredius Bauch Gerson HdG Bredius Bauch Gerson Br.-Gerson Br.-Gerson 372 C24 539 A 16 388 C27 A A 15 539 - -- 390 C25 542 A 19 393 AI7 543 B6 A34 1 A 18 A A35 ------4 9 ----- 543 420 AIO 549 A22, 421 B I, B2 copy I 422 C I I 55 2 C36 423 A 13 55 2A A33 424 C 13 556 C 12 425 C 18 557 A23 426 C 18, 564 C38 copy I 570 B5 427 CI4 57 2 C33 428 AI7 577 A41 429 C 15 59 1 C39 430 C 17 601 All 440 C6 602 A26 456 C31, 604 A28 copy 2 605 C 16 60 A6 60 A36 4 ------7 462 A31 63 1 C2 463 A39 63 2 A7 465 C9 633 C22 466 A38 636 C23 86 A3 67 2 C20 ------4 487 A2 673 B4 488 A9 674 C30 489 A24 675 A42 490 A25 676 B7 499 C44 677 A29 529 A20 678 C29, 530 C37 copy I 53 1 C34 681 C28 531 A AI 682 C29 53 2 A4 685 C42 53 2A C5 686 C41 533 A 14, CIO 68 7 A27 copy I 688 A32 534 C8 535 A 12 536 C7 537 A30, copy I 538 A30 700